Assessment of the accuracy of a three-dimensional imaging system for archiving dental study models

Abstract

Objective: The use of stone and plaster study models is an integral part of any dental practice and is required for research. Storage of study models is problematic in terms of space and cost. Ayoub et al. introduced a new technique based on the recent advances in stereophotogrammetry for archiving dental study models in a digital format. However, assessment of the accuracy of the generated three-dimensional (3D) models has not been carried out yet. It was the aim of this study to evaluate the accuracy of this technique.

Design: A comparative assessment between direct measurements of dental study models and measurements of computer generated 3D images of the same study models was performed.

Materials and methods: Twenty-two dental study models stored at Glasgow Dental Hospital and School for the purposes of research were used in the study. The models were captured in three dimensions using a photostereometric technique and stored in digital format.

Main Outcome Measures: Measurements were conducted directly on dental study models and on the computer generated 3D images using Euclidean Distance Matrix Analysis. The difference between the two sets of measurements was statistically analysed using a two-sample t-test.

Results: The average difference between measurements of dental casts and 3D images was 0.27 mm. This difference was within the range of operator errors (0.10–0.48 mm) and was not statistically significant (P < 0.05).

Conclusion: This study shows that it is possible to use 3D imaging to store dental study models for treatment monitoring and research with a satisfactory degree of accuracy.

Keywords:

• dental casts
• dimensional accuracy
• study models
• 3-D imaging

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank Svenja Hoff and Jean Christophe Nebill (Department of Computer Science, University of Glasgow) for their help with the production of images of the computer generated casts.