Barriers to Physician Reporting of Workers' Compensation Cases in France

Abstract

Studies suggest strong underreporting of occupational diseases in industrialized countries. We studied physician- related barriers to reporting of occupational sciatica (with herniated disk). We conducted a telephone survey of 391 general practitioners (CPs) and 96 rheumatologists in southeastern France with a standardized questionnaire and case-vignette of a patient with occupational sciatica. Our results show that 71% of CPs and 78% of rheumatologists would not recommend that the case-vignette patient file a workers' compensation claim, for the following reasons: possible role of nonwork-related activities (77%, 74%), should be reported as an occupational accident (67%, 42%), recommendation should be made by occupational physicians (60%, 60%), and risk of patient's losing his job (47%, 38%). Our results suggest that occupational sciatica is underreported in France. Physicians' lack of knowledge of reporting principles and procedures and their ethical dilemma regarding job loss may be barriers to reporting.

Keywords:

• Occupational diseases
• musculoskeletal diseases
• sciatica
• physicians
• attitude
• behaviour
• insurance claim review
• socioeconomic factors