The Importance of Phosphorus and Copper Carryover in Pond Sediments for Juvenile Percid Survival, Growth, and Yield

Abstract

Over-fertilization with phosphorus and carryover copper residual in the sediment from copper sulfate treatment in double-cropped ponds were suspected as the primary causes of low larval percid survival in coolwater aquaculture ponds. Consequently, in this study, we compared saugeye (male sauger Sander canadensis × female walleye S. vitreus) survival, growth, and yield among ponds that were single-cropped with only saugeyes in the spring during the previous two consecutive years (SS ponds) and ponds that were double-cropped (with saugeye culture in the spring and channel catfish Ictalurus punctatus culture in the summer) during the previous two consecutive years (DD ponds). We also compared sediment phosphorus (soluble reactive phosphorus [SRP] and total phosphorus [TP]), sediment copper concentrations, phytoplankton biomass, and zooplankton biomass. Fish survival (number harvested) and fish yield (mass harvested) were significantly lower in DD ponds than in SS ponds in 2001 but were similar in 2002 (a year of wide temperature fluctuation early in the production season). Sediment analyses revealed that DD ponds had significantly lower SRP and TP but higher copper concentrations than did SS ponds. A detailed study done in 2002 revealed that individual length and wet weight of percids were significantly higher in the SS ponds than in DD ponds; phytoplankton biomass was similar in both sets of ponds, while zooplankton biomass was significantly lower in DD ponds. These results suggest that residual materials used in double-cropped channel catfish ponds may negatively affect subsequent years' percid culture.