The Effects of Whirling Disease on Growth and Survival of Snake River Cutthroat and Colorado River Rainbow Trout Fingerlings

Abstract

Two sizes of fingerling Snake River cutthroat trout Oncorhynchus clarkii behnkei and Colorado River rainbow trout O. mykiss were raised at hatcheries testing negative for Myxobolus cerebralis and stocked into the Dolores and Cache la Poudre rivers from 1999 to 2001. Populations were resampled over a 2-year period to determine which species and size combination had the highest growth and survival rates. Fish were tested for M. cerebralis via polymerase chain reaction and pepsin−trypsin digest analyses. Growth and survival rates between the species and size groups were not significantly different in either river. In the Dolores River, annual survival for both species and sizes of fish combined ranged from 0.063 to 0.12. In the Cache la Poudre River, survival for both sizes of rainbow trout was 0.004; survival for cutthroat trout ranged from 0.182 to 0.53. Larger fish had higher growth rates than smaller fish, and cutthroat trout had higher rates than similar sizes of rainbow trout. In both rivers, a higher percentage of the rainbow trout sample was infected than in the cutthroat trout sample. Rainbow trout also had a higher mean number of spores per head than cutthroat trout, and small rainbow trout had higher spore counts than large rainbow trout. Survival rates for cutthroat trout in the Cache la Poudre River were the highest of any of the groups, suggesting a difference that is biologically significant. Raising fingerlings to sizes greater than 100 mm can improve poststocking survival. If rainbow trout are stocked into contaminated waters, raising fingerlings to a larger size does not appear to improve growth or survival rates. Stocking rainbow trout in the spring could maximize growth rates but will expose fish to greater triactinomyxon densities, resulting in higher intensities of infection.