Development and Use of a Simple DNA Test to Distinguish Larval Redhorse Species in the Oconee River, Georgia

Abstract

The robust redhorse Moxostoma robustum is a rare catostomid species that was recently “rediscovered” in three Atlantic slope drainages in the southeastern United States, including the Oconee River, Georgia. Adult population size in the Oconee River is declining, and the population may be senescent due to recruitment failure. Evaluation of the environmental factors affecting the success of young life stages requires the ability to distinguish robust redhorse larvae from those of other redhorse species in the Oconee River. The use of morphological approaches, including size at collection date, have proven to be problematic in distinguishing larval robust redhorse from notchlip redhorse M. collapsum from the Oconee River. We developed a mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) assay to distinguish between reference adults of these two redhorse species from the Oconee, Savannah, and Pee Dee rivers. This mtDNA assay was then applied to unknown larval redhorse collections from the Oconee River. In one collection, discordance was revealed in 40% of the individual larvae identified by both size at collection date and mtDNA. Of these, 75% of the fish thought to be notchlip redhorses based on size at date of collection exhibited robust redhorse mtDNA haplotypes. These results illustrate the utility of DNA techniques in characterizing the young life stages of fish and suggest that earlier surveys underestimated the abundance of larval robust redhorses in the Oconee River.