Comparative Swimming Performance of Juvenile Pond-Cultured and Wild-Caught Channel Catfish

Abstract

We compared the swimming performance of juvenile pond-cultured and wild-caught channel catfish Ictalurus punctatus using a fixed-velocity, time-to-fatigue protocol as a measure of overall fitness. Swimming performance of juvenile catfish from each source was determined at 10-cm/s intervals between speeds of 30 and 120 cm/s. The identified swimming performance categories included sustained speeds (swimming speeds without fatigue in times ≥200 min: aerobic metabolism); prolonged speeds (swimming speeds with fatigue in times ≥20 s but <200 min: mixed aerobic and anaerobic metabolism); and burst (swimming speeds with fatigue in times <20 s: anaerobic metabolism). The maximum sustained swimming speed (maximum speed without fatigue in times ≥200 min) was 40 cm/s for both pond-cultured and wild-caught juveniles. The maximum prolonged swimming speed (maximum speed with fatigue in times ≥200 min) was 90 and 100 cm/s for wild-caught and pond-cultured juvenile catfish, respectively. The swimming performance of pond-cultured and wild-caught juvenile catfish differed significantly only at 120 cm/s, which was a burst swimming speed for wild-caught juveniles and a prolonged swimming speed for pond-cultured juveniles. The burst swimming speed for pond-cultured juveniles was not determined but was estimated to be more than 120 cm/s. The total length, standard length, fork length, and condition factor of juvenile pond-cultured and wild-caught catfish were not significantly different. The reported swimming performance data provide important information on the overall fitness (e.g., ability to obtain prey and avoid predation) of juvenile pond-cultured and wild-caught catfish that will benefit fisheries managers considering the stocking of juvenile pond-cultured channel catfish in managed lakes and rivers as well as research scientists developing and evaluating improved strains of channel catfish for commercial production.