Abstract
The purpose of this study is to explore original studies which provide evidence about the effects of bilingualism on the delay of the onset of dementia, specifically Alzheimer’s disease (AD). A literature review was conducted in the world’s acknowledged databases: Web of Science, Scopus, and MEDLINE. Altogether, 14 original studies focusing on the research topic were detected. These included six prospective cohort studies and eight retrospective studies. Both types of studies suggest different conclusions. The findings from the prospective cohort studies state that there is no association between bilingualism and the delay of the onset of AD, while the retrospective studies claim the opposite. Despite the negative results of the prospective cohort studies, more research should be conducted on bilingualism and its impact on the delay of the onset of AD, since the brain studies have brought positive findings as far as the enhancement of cognitive reserve is concerned.
Introduction
Aging and dementia
According to the recent report of the United NationsCitation1 on the aging process of the world’s population, the number of older people aged 60+ years has risen considerably. Globally, the number of these elderly people is growing faster than the number of people in any other age group. This accelerating trend in the rise of older population groups inevitably results in serious economic and social changes accompanied with a number of aging diseases such as dementia.
Dementia, specifically Alzheimer’s disease (AD), together with heart diseases, cancer, and respiratory diseases, is one of the most common causes of death among older people.Citation2 Globally, dementia affects around 58 million people, and it is estimated that the number of older people with dementia would triple by 2050, since each year about 9.9 million new dementia cases are diagnosed worldwide.Citation3,Citation4
Dementia is a syndrome of deterioration of cognitive functions that interferes with a patient’s everyday life. This cognitive impairment has an enormous impact not only on the patient’s health and his/her self-care but also on the costs of care, either at home or in a residential establishment.Citation5–Citation7 Therefore, there is sustainable effort to prevent cognitive decline which is the foremost sign of this neurological disorder. However, currently, there is no effective pharmacological treatment for the cognitive decline.Citation8 Thus, there is an increasing interest in non-pharmacological alternative approaches which may maintain or even increase the so-called cognitive reserve and enable healthy older people to delay the deterioration of cognitive functions.
Cognitive reserve, its enhancement, and bilingualism
Cognitive reserve can be defined as the resilience to neuropathological damage of the brain.Citation9 It is assumed that this is the result of experience-based neural changes which are caused by a physically and mentally stimulating lifestyle.Citation10 ResearchCitation11 indicates that especially the differences in cognitive reserve are affected by environmental enrichment. This means that although some people have signs of brain atrophy and neuronal loss, thanks to their cognitive reserve, they do not have visible difficulties in cognitive functioning.
A research studyCitation12 revealed that 60% of general cognitive ability is of genetic origin, but there are some non-pharmacological activities such as performing physical and mental activities, which play an important role in its enhancement as well.Citation13 Antoniou et alCitation10 claim that some of these non-pharmacological activities which are aimed at the stimulation of the cognitive functions might delay the cognitive decline.
One of these mental activities, which may also contribute to the enhancement of cognitive reserve, is bilingualism, that is, the ability to speak more than one language. In fact, bilingualism enables constant shifting between languages, with their distinct sounds, words, concepts, and grammatical rules, and offers effective training of executive functions such as attention, switching, inhibition, and monitoring. All these contribute to a higher cognitive reserve.Citation14 Thus, bilingualism is considered to be connected with cognitive advantage,Citation15 since researchCitation16 has shown that language does not only reflect the mind but also modify the brain to certain degree even in older age. Bak et al,Citation17 Goral et al,Citation18 and Luk et alCitation19 report that bilingual people may enhance their cognitive reserve at later age, thanks to the use of two languages, and the so-called mental flexibility. Schweitzer et alCitation20 argue that bilingualism is a clear case of an environmental factor that helps produce cognitive reserve, although it might also affect the brain and its development and organization, and contribute to brain reserve. There are several brain studies which confirm that bilingual people usually have greater gray matter volume than monolingual individuals, which has a positive impact on the functional connectivity between gray matter regions.Citation21–Citation24 Therefore, bilingualism seems to protect against the cognitive decline that occurs during aging. This has also been confirmed by the most recent study by Estanga et al,Citation25 who conclude that bilingualism influences cognitive reserve, especially improving executive and visual-spatial functions.
Bialystok et alCitation26 claim that thanks to better mental flexibility, bilingual people have the ability to adapt to constant changes and process information effectively and adaptively. Furthermore, Lee and TzengCitation27 indicate that effective connectivity, thanks to second language learning, improves the capacity for language processing and general executive control by reorganizing neural circuitries. This even concerns older learners whose age is considered to be far from the so-called critical period of language acquisition. These findings have also been confirmed by Schlegel et alCitation28 who have revealed that the brain maintains its plasticity in adult age. In their study on language learning with 11 English speakers studying Chinese for nine months, they have brought evidence that white matter in older individuals might still experience considerable changes which have a positive impact on foreign language learning in aging. BialystokCitation29 points out that the age in second language acquisition is not such a significant factor, but the length of exposure to the target language is important.
The purpose of this study is to explore original studies which provide evidence about the effects of bilingualism on the delay of the onset of AD.
Methods
The methodology of this study was based on Moher et al.Citation30 A literature review was conducted in Web of Science, Scopus, and MEDLINE databases with the goal of identifying research studies on the basis of the following key words: bilingualism AND cognitive decline, bilingualism AND dementia, and bilingualism AND AD. This review identified articles published during 2007 to May 2017.
Most of the studies on the research topic were identified in the Web of Science (146), followed by MEDLINE (129) and Scopus (104). Altogether, 379 publications were detected in the databases. The titles of all studies were checked in order to confirm whether they focused on the research topic and to eliminate duplicates. Ninety-eight studies were used for further analysis, in which the authors checked the content of the abstracts. Sixty studies were selected for the full-text analysis, out of which the findings of 14 studies were then used for the detailed analysis of the research topic ().
A study was included if it matched the corresponding period, that is, from 2007 up to May 2017. The selection period started with the year of 2007, since this is the year when the first findings on the efficacy of bilingualism on the delay of the onset of dementia appeared.Citation26 Furthermore, a study was included if it involved older people and focused on the topic of bilingualism, that is, the ability to speak and write more than one language, and its effect on the onset of AD. The studies which focused only on AD were included, while the studies concentrating on other, less frequent dementias, such as frontotemporal dementiaCitation31 or Parkinson’s diseases, were excluded.Citation32 The studiesCitation18,Citation33 that compared the performance of bilinguals to that of monolinguals on tasks such as nonverbal tasks, assumed to measure executive functioning, were excluded, as well as multilingual studies.Citation34,Citation35 The brain studiesCitation21–Citation25 were also excluded. Only studies written in English were included.
Findings
Altogether, 14 original studies focusing on the research topic were detected. These included six prospective cohort studies () and eight retrospective studies (). All studies except twoCitation38,Citation45 compared both monolingual and bilingual language groups. and provide an overview of the main findings on bilingualism and its effect on the delay of the onset of AD. The studies are presented in the alphabetical order of their first author.
Table 1 An overview of the prospective cohort studies on bilingualism and its effect on the delay of the onset of AD
Table 2 An overview of the retrospective and cross-sectional studies on bilingualism and its effect on the delay of the onset of AD
The research period of the prospective studies ranges between 5 and 50 years. Overall, the number of participants in these six studies was 8,233. All six studies in fact met the criteria for the evaluation of the quality of cohort studies set by the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale,Citation48 since they applied evidence-based measurement of their outcomes, such as a battery of cognitive performance tests, clinical examinations, or Cox regression. Furthermore, the followed-up period lasted 5 years at minimum, the clinical samples were derived from community samples and not referrals to specialist memory clinics, and most importantly, the age of the onset of AD was determined by standardized clinical examinations and not by subjective retrospective self-reports. In some studies, however, the self-reports were used for the assessment of language proficiency.Citation36,Citation39,Citation40 As Zahodne et alCitation40 indicate, this should not have any effect on the overall results. Apart from two studies,Citation17,Citation38 the findings suggest that there is no association between bilingualism and the delay of the onset of dementia, specifically AD.
On the contrary, the results of all retrospective studies with one exceptionCitation43 indicate that bilingualism might delay the onset of cognitive decline, specifically AD, by approximately 4.5 years. However, the number of subjects in these studies is lower than in the prospective studies. Altogether, 1,502 patients participated in the research, ranging from 44 to 648 patients. BakkerCitation49 points out that in order to attain desirable levels of power, at least 139 subjects should be involved in each language group. Criterion for bilingualism in these studies is that individuals should speak two or more languages fluently, approximately 50% of the time, ideally daily, at least since their early adulthood. In addition, the findings on the age of the onset of AD are based on questionnaires and interviews with these patients, their family members, or caregivers, which might also contribute to the misinterpretation of these results. Generally, retrospective studies usually have more potential sources of bias and confounding than prospective studies.Citation50
Discussion
As research on bilingualism reveals, there has been an increased interest in how and whether lifelong bilingualism protects the brain from cognitive decline, specifically from the symptoms of AD.Citation51 However, the results in favor of bilingual advantage differ as the findings from the selected research studies shown in and . Almost all retrospective studies in demonstrate the delay of the onset of dementia by 4.5 years and manifest that bilingualism contributes to the enhancement of cognitive reserve. This has also been confirmed by recent review studies.Citation51,Citation52 Bialystok et al,Citation52 by comparing monolingual and bilingual older individuals on measures of cognitive function and brain structure, emphasize that bilingualism is a protective factor against the symptoms of dementia. Nevertheless, their review leaves out some of the important prospective studies on this topic.Citation36,Citation37,Citation39 The same is true for the study by Alvarez and Rodriguez.Citation53
On the contrary, the findings from the prospective studies exert nonsignificant results as far as the bilingual advantage is concerned. The latest meta-analytic review study provides conclusive results about this.Citation54 Mukadam et alCitation54 on the basis of effect sizes (odds ratio of dementia of 0.96 [95% CI 0.74–1.23] in bilingual participants [n=5,527] compared to monolinguals) from the analyzed studies have concluded that there is no evidence that bilingualism protects from cognitive decline or dementia. The retrospective studies they detected could not be analyzed for effect sizes, since they incline to confounding by education or cultural differences in presentation to dementia services. This seems to be caused by shortcomings in the conception and assessment of bilinguals and confounding variables.Citation55 The most conflicting factors appear to be immigration status, education, group heterogeneity, or social factors.Citation56 In prospective studies, bilingualism is usually connected with a higher level of formal education. However, in retrospective studies, there is no consensus on this issue. In some studies,Citation26,Citation44,Citation45 monolingual groups have higher mean scores on education than bilingual groups. In addition, Fuller-Thomson and KuhCitation57 point out that immigrants usually have less morbidity and mortality. Therefore, more research should be performed on bilingualism in a nonimmigrant population and their cognitive decline. In addition, all the demographic data about the participants’ background, for example, education, occupation, or immigrant status, should be properly collected.
Thus, the authors of this mini-review agree with StraussCitation58 that although both types of the studies arrive at conflicting conclusions on bilingualism and its impact on the delay of the onset of dementia, one thing seems to be sure; speaking or learning another language cannot cause any harm. Furthermore, BakCitation14 adds that it has no side effects, and Bialystok et alCitation52 emphasize its important role in the reduction of potential costs, both for humans and national economy.
The limitations of this review study involve the use of insufficient and different methodologies, especially in the retrospective studies. This might result in the overestimated effects of the findings, which may have an adverse impact on the validity of these reviewed studies.Citation59,Citation60
Conclusion
Although the findings of this mini-review did not arrive at any revolutionary conclusions, they suggest that more research should be conducted on bilingualism and its impact on the delay of the onset of dementia, since the brain studies have brought positive findings as far as the enhancement of cognitive reserve is concerned.
In addition, Kurdziel et alCitation61 say, learning throughout aging is necessary because older individuals who keep mentally and physically active are less likely to be cognitively impaired and depressed.
Acknowledgments
This paper is supported by the project Excellence (2017) at the Faculty of Informatics and Management of the University of Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic, and by the research project PROGRES Q40 run at the Medical Faculty of Charles University.
Disclosure
The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.
References
- United NationsWorld population aging [report]2015 Available from: http://www.un.org/en/development/desa/population/publications/pdf/ageing/WPA2015_Report.pdfAccessed May 2, 2017
- VannMRBassPFThe 15 most common health concerns for seniors2016 Available from: http://www.everydayhealth.com/news/most-common-health-concerns-seniors/Accessed May 2, 2017
- LangaKMIs the risk of Alzheimer’s disease and dementia declining?Alzheimers Res Ther2015713425815064
- World Health Organization10 facts on dementia2016 Available from: http://www.who.int/features/factfiles/dementia/en/Accessed May 2, 2017
- KirshnerHSFrontotemporal dementia and progressive aphasia, a reviewNeuropsychiatr Dis Treat2014101045105524966676
- KlimovaBMaresovaPValisMHortJKucaKAlzheimer’s disease and language impairments: social intervention and medical treatmentClin Interv Aging2015101401140826346123
- MaresovaPKlimovaBKucaKAlzheimer’s disease: cost cuts call for novel drugs development and national strategyCeska Slov Farm201564253026084646
- KarakayaTFußerFSchröderJPantelJPharmacological treatment of mild cognitive impairment as a prodromal syndrome of Alzheimer’s diseaseCurr Neuropharmacol201311110210823814542
- SternYCognitive reserve: implications for assessment and interventionFolia Phoniatr Logop2013652495423941972
- AntoniouMGunasekeraGMWongPCForeign language training as cognitive therapy for age-related cognitive decline: a hypothesis for future researchNeurosci Biobehav Rev20133710 Pt 22689269824051310
- FischerASananbenesiFWangXDobbinMTsaiLHRecovery of learning and memory is associated with chromatin remodellingNature2007447714117818217468743
- McClearnGEJohanssonBBergSSubstantial genetic influence on cognitive abilities in twins 80 or more years oldScience19972765318156015639171059
- KlimovaBKucaKAlzheimer’s disease: potential preventive, noninvasive, intervention strategies in lowering the risk of cognitive decline – a review studyJ Appl Biomed2015134257261
- BakTLanguage lessons to help protect against dementiaBMJ2016354i503927645164
- ChengKWDengYHLiMYanHMThe impact of L2 learning on cognitive agingADMET DMPK201533260273
- KaiwenCYanhuiDDezhongYBilingualism (multilingualism) helps resist Alzheimer’s disease?Adv Psychol Sci2014221117231732
- BakTHNissanJJAllerhandMMDearyIJDoes bilingualism influence cognitive aging?Ann Neurol201475695996324890334
- GoralMCampanelliLSpiroA3rdLanguage dominance and inhibition abilities in bilingual older adultsBiling (Camb Engl)2015181798927531968
- LukGBialystokECraikFIGradyCLLifelong bilingualism maintains white matter integrity in older adultsJ Neurosci20113146168081681322090506
- SchweitzerTAWareJFischerCECraikFIBialystokEBilingualism as a contributor to cognitive reserve: evidence from brain atrophy in Alzheimer’s diseaseCortex201248899199621596373
- GrundyJGAndersonJAEBialystokENeural correlates of cognitive processing in monolinguals and bilingualsAnn N Y Acad Sci20171396118320128415142
- AbutalebiJCaniniMDella RosaPAGreenDWWeekesBSThe neuroprotective effects of bilingualism upon the inferior parietal lobule: a structural neuroimaging study in aging Chinese bilingualsJ Neurolinguistics201533313
- OlsenRKPangelinanMMBogulskiCThe effect of lifelong bilingualism on regional grey and white matter volumeBrain Res2015161212813925725380
- PeraniDFarsadMBallariniTThe impact of bilingualism on brain reserve and metabolic connectivity in Alzheimer’s diseaseProc Natl Acad Sci U S A201711471690169528137833
- EstangaAEcay-TorresMIbañezABeneficial effect of bilingualism on Alzheimer’s disease CSF biomarkers and cognitionNeurobiol Aging20175014415127916386
- BialystokECraikFIFreedmanMBilingualism as a protection against the onset of symptoms of dementiaNeuropsychologia200745245946417125807
- LeeRRTzengOJNeural bilingualism: a new look at an old problemLang Linguist2016172147193
- SchlegelAARudelsonJJTsePUWhite matter structure changes as adults learn a second languageJ Cogn Neurosci20122481664167022571459
- BialystokEThe structure of age: in search of barriers to second language acquisitionSecond Lang Res1997132116137
- MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJAltmanDGThe PRISMA GroupPreferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis: the PRISMA statementPLoS Med200966e100009719621072
- AlladiSBakTHShailajaMBilingualism delays the onset of behavioural but not aphasic forms of frontotemporal dementiaNeuropsychogia201799207212
- HindleJVMartin-ForbesPABastableAJCognitive reserve in Parkinson’s disease: the effects of Welsh-English bilingualism on executive functionParkinsons Dis2015201594357225922786
- CalabriaMBranziFMarnePHernandezMCostaAAge-related effects over bilingual language control and executive controlBiling Lang Cogn20151816578
- ChertkowHWhiteheadVPhillipsNWolfsonCAthertonJBergmanHMultilingualism (but not always bilingualism) delays the onset of Alzheimer disease: evidence from a bilingual communityAlzheimer Dis Assoc Disord201024211812520505429
- LiuYCLiuYYYipPKMeguroMMeguroKSpeaking one more language in early life has only minor effects on cognition in Taiwanese with low education level: the Taishan ProjectPsychogeriatrics201717425626128133849
- LawtonDMGasquoinePGWeimerAAAge of dementia diagnosis in community dwelling bilingual and monolingual Hispanic AmericansCortex20156614114525598395
- SandersAEHallCBKatzMJLiptonRBNon-native language use and risk of incident dementia in the elderlyJ Alzheimers Dis20122919910822232011
- WilsonRSBoylePAYangJJamesBDBennettDAEarly life instruction in foreign language and music and incidence of mild cognitive impairmentNeuropsychology201529229230225110933
- YeungCMJohnPDStMenecVTyasSLIs bilingualism associated with a lower risk of dementia in community-living old adults? Cross-sectional and prospective analysesAlzheimer Dis Assoc Disord201428432633224614266
- ZahodneLBSchofieldPWFarrellMTSternYManlyJJBilingualism does not alter cognitive decline or dementia risk among Spanish speaking immigrantsNeuropsychology201428223824624188113
- AlladiSBakTHDuggiralaVBilingualism delays age at onset of dementia, independent of education and immigration statusNeurology201381221938194424198291
- BialystokECraikFIBinnsMAOssherLFreedmanMEffects of bilingualism on the age of onset and progression of MCI and AD: evidence from executive function testsNeuropsychology201428229030424245925
- ClareLWhitakerCJCraikFIBilingualism, executive control, and age at diagnosis among people with early-stage Alzheimer’s disease in WalesJ Neuropsychol201410216318525420578
- CraikFIBialystokEFreedmanMDelaying the onset of Alzheimer disease: bilingualism as a form of cognitive reserveNeurology201075191726172921060095
- GollanTHSalmonDPMontoyaRIGalaskoDRDegree of bilingualism predicts age of diagnosis of Alzheimer’s disease in low-education but not in highly educated HispanicsNeuropsychologia201149143826383022001315
- OssherLBialystokECraikFIMurphyKJTroyerAKThe effect of bilingualism on amnestic mild cognitive impairmentJ Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci201368181222454387
- WoumansESantensPSiebenAVersijptJStevensMDuyckWBilingualism delays clinical manifestation of Alzheimer’s diseaseBiling Lang Cogn2015183568574
- WellsGASheaBO’ConnellDThe Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomized studies in meta-analyses Available from: http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical_epidemiology/oxford.aspAccessed July 25, 2017
- BakkerMPower problems: n>138Cortex20157336736826345269
- Cohort StudiesProspective versus retrospective cohort studies2016 Available from: http://sphweb.bumc.bu.edu/otlt/MPH-Modules/EP/EP713_CohortStudies/EP713_CohortStudies2.htmlAccessed May 8, 2017
- AbutalebiJClahsenHBilingualism, cognition, and agingBiling Lang Cogn201518112
- BialystokEAbutalebiJBakTHBurkeDMKrollJAging in two languages: implications for public healthAgeing Res Rev201627566026993154
- AlvarezARodriguezMThe effects of bilingualism on cognitive decline in mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and Alzheimer’s disease (AD)Arch Clin Neuropsychol2016316594
- MukadamNSommerlandALivingstonGThe relationship of bilingualism compared to monolingualism to the risk of cognitive decline or dementia: a systematic review and meta-analysisJ Alzheimers Dis2017581455428387680
- PaapKRJohnsonHASawiOShould the search for bilingual advantages in executive functioning continue?Cortex20167430531426586100
- CalvoVGarcíaAMManoiloffLIbáñezABilingualism and cognitive reserve: a critical overview and a plea for methodological innovationsFront Aging Neurosci2016724926793100
- Fuller-ThomsonEKuhDThe healthy migrant effect may confound the link between bilingualism and delayed onset of Alzheimer’s diseaseCortex20145212813024074458
- StraussSDoes bilingualism delay dementia?CMAJ20151877E209E21025802310
- Melby-LervågMHulmeCThere is no convincing evidence that working memory training is effective: a reply to Au et al (2014) and Karbach and Verhaeghen (2014)Psychon Bull Rev201623132433026082279
- Melby-LervågMHulmeCIs working memory training effective? A meta-analytic reviewDev Psychol201349227029122612437
- KurdzielLBMantuaJSpencerRMNovel word learning in older adults: a role for sleep?Brain Lang201716710611327291336