Abstract
Background
Atopic diseases, for example, eczema, asthma, and hay fever, are among the most common chronic diseases of childhood. Knowledge on health service use among children with atopic disease is limited. This study aimed to investigate the total use and costs of health services for children with and without eczema, asthma, and hay fever in a Danish general population.
Methods
We conducted a health survey with four complete birth cohorts from the City of Copenhagen. Individual questionnaire data on eczema, asthma, and hay fever for children aged 3, 6, 11, and 15 years were linked to register information on use and costs of health services and prescribed medication and parental education. In total 9,720 children participated (50.5%).
Results
We found increased health service use (number of additional consultations per year [95% confidence interval]) among children with current eczema symptoms (1.77 [1.29–2.26]), current asthma symptoms (2.53 [2.08–2.98]), and current hay fever symptoms (1.21 [0.74–1.67]), compared with children without these symptoms. We also found increased use of prescribed medication and most subtypes of health services. Current asthma symptoms and current eczema symptoms, but not current hay fever symptoms, increased the health service costs with at least €300 per year per child.
Conclusion
Children with eczema, asthma, and hay fever used health services and prescribed medication more than children without these diseases.
Introduction
Eczema, asthma, and hay fever are among the most common chronic diseases of childhood. As they are all associated with atopy, that is, the propensity to develop an IgE-mediated immune response to environmental allergens, they are often referred to as the atopic diseases. Several studies have examined asthma-related health service use among children with asthma, comparing, for example, ethnic minority children vs Caucasians,Citation1 children with suboptimal vs optimal medication regimens,Citation2 children with public vs private health insurances,Citation3 or children of single vs married parents.Citation4 However, total health service use among children with asthma or eczema compared with children without these diseases is scarcely described, and studies from countries with universal health care access are rare.
A French study found increased use of prescribed medication and higher costs of general practitioner consultations and prescribed medication among children with atopic eczema compared with healthy controls.Citation5 A Canadian and a German study found increased likelihood of consultations with the general practitioner and of hospitalization among children with asthma compared with children without.Citation6,Citation7 Finally, an American study of children with the same insurance found increased odds of using prescribed medication, outpatient hospital visits, emergency department visits, and hospitalization among children with asthma compared with children without.Citation8 We are not aware of any studies assessing health service use among children with hay fever or rhinitis compared with children without.
Due to high-quality, national registers providing access to administrative data for researchers, it is possible in Den-mark to examine health service use and costs in detail at the individual level.Citation9
The aim of this study was to examine use and costs of health services for children with and without eczema, asthma, and hay fever.
Methods
Study population and design
The study was based on a cross-sectional child health survey described in detail elsewhere,Citation10 including all children born in 1994, 1998, 2003, or 2006, who were resident in the City of Copenhagen in September 2009. Children aged 11 or 15 years answered questionnaires themselves, whereas the parents answered for children aged 3 or 6 years. We linked questionnaire data to administrative registers on demographics, health service use and costs, prescribed medication use and costs, and the primary carer’s education. Statistics Denmark provided register data linked by the unique personal identification number, the CPR number.Citation11 Register data were available for all the invited children.
In total, 9,720 out of 19,241 invited children participated (50.5%), with the lowest response rate among children aged 15 years (42.4%), followed by children aged 11 (50.9%), 6 (51.0%), and 3 years (55.2%). Most parents gave written, informed consent for participation when returning the questionnaires. For the 1,043 questionnaires returned without a signature, the Danish Data Protection Agency gave permission to consider having followed the written instructions and returned the questionnaire as informed consent. The study was approved by the Danish Data Protection Agency. According to Danish legislation, approval from the Danish Health Research Ethics Committee System is not required for studies based solely on questionnaires and registers.
Eczema, asthma, and hay fever
Outcome measures were eczema, asthma, and hay fever discerned as “known disease ever” and “current symptoms”. The measures were adapted from the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood,Citation12 and eczema symptoms were defined according to the United Kingdom Working Party’s diagnostic criteria.Citation13 Known disease ever was defined as “yes” to a single question for each disease, as were current asthma and hay fever symptoms. Current eczema symptoms were defined as “yes” to one major criterion and at least two of four minor criteria. The definitions are described in detail elsewhere.Citation10
Health service use
Denmark has a tax-funded health care system with health services free of charge for any person resident in Denmark and partial reimbursement for prescribed medication.Citation14
Total health service use in 1 year, 2009, was calculated as the sum of all consultations in the primary and secondary health care sector. In primary health care, this included any consultation with a general practitioner or medical specialist, and also approved email and telephone consultations and after-hours duty doctor services. In secondary (or tertiary) health care, this included all outpatient hospital visits, emergency department visits, and hospital admissions in the somatic and psychiatric system.
Subtypes of health services were dichotomized as whether or not the child had used the service during 2009: general practitioner, atopic disease-relevant medical specialist (ie, dermatologist; internal medicine specialist; ophthalmologist; ortho-, rhino-, and laryngologist; or pediatrician), and after-hours duty doctor. Outpatient hospital, emergency department, and hospital admissions were given with additional variables for atopic disease-related visits (ICD-10 codes: L20 [atopic eczema], J45, J46 [asthma], J30.0-4, H10.0 [allergic rhinitis]) and infection-related visits (A02–A09 [gastrointestinal infections], A30-49 [other bacterial infections], A80, A81, A85–A89 [viral infections in central nervous system], B00–B09, B25–B49, B95–B99 [other infectious diseases], H60, H65–H68, H70–H72, H75, H92 [ear infections], J00–J22, J32, J35.0, J36, J40–J42, J85, J86 [respiratory infections], L00–L08 [skin infections], N00, N01, N30, N39.0 [urinary tract infections], R50, R560 [fever of other and unknown causes]).
Total use of prescribed medication was calculated as total number of collected packages of prescribed medication for the child during 2009. Subtypes of prescribed medication were dichotomized as whether or not any medication of the following types was collected: skin medication (ACT codes: D01–D04, D05AA, D06–D08), respiratory or eye medication (R01, R03, R05, R06, S01G), systemic hormones (H02A), and anti-infective medication (J01–J05, D06, D08, S01A).
Total health service costs were calculated for 2009 as the total individual-level costs of all health services held by the tax-funded health care system including primary and secondary (tertiary) services and total costs of any prescribed medication. Subtypes of costs were additionally calculated as costs of prescribed medication and patient share of prescribed medication. Total and subtypes of costs of health services were derived from registers where exact prices of primary health care, prescribed medications, and diagnosis-related group tariffs are recorded.Citation15
Primary carer’s education
The primary carer’s highest attained educational level as of October 2009 was divided into four categories: 1) master’s degree or higher, 2) bachelor or academy degree, 3) vocational training, and 4) primary/secondary school including lower secondary school and general upper secondary education. The primary carer was defined as the mother, except in the cases where the father had full custody of the child.
Statistical analyses
We analyzed total health service use, prescribed medication use, and costs for children with each atopic disease or symptom group separately compared with children without, and adjusted for sex, age, and the primary carer’s educational level. We used linear regression analyses with maximum likelihood estimates, 95% confidence intervals (CIs), and test of significance.
We analyzed each subtype of health service and prescribed medication by logistic regression analyses with maximum likelihood estimation of odds ratios, 95% CIs, and test of significance, and with the same adjustments as mentioned.
Data were weighted for nonresponse based on register information on sex, age, ethnicity, health service use, parental civil status, parental educational level, household income, and type of residence in order to increase representativity.Citation16 The weights were computed by Statistics Denmark.Citation17 We also performed analyses without weighing for nonresponse, and the results were essentially the same. All analyses were performed in SAS statistical software version 9.3 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA), using their survey procedures. Statistical significance was defined as P<0.05.
Results
Descriptives of the population have been published previously.Citation10 In total, 9,720 children participated. 50.3% were female, and 35.3%, 25.8%, 21.3%, and 17.6% of the sample were 3, 6, 11, and 15 years old, respectively. The prevalence of current symptoms was 9.5% for eczema, 11.6% for asthma, and 10.9% for hay fever ().
Table 1 Characteristics of annual health service use, prescribed medication, and total costs in various subgroups of children
Total health service use and costs
Children in the study had, on average, six consultations with the health care system and used two packages of prescribed medication, and these services cost ~€600 per year (). These figures varied slightly in different subgroups of children. Children aged 3 years had two more annual consultations than the other age groups, while children aged 15 years used most prescribed medication and had the highest health service costs.
All atopic diseases and symptoms were associated with increased use of health services and prescribed medication, also when adjusted for sex, age, and primary carer’s educational level (). Children with current eczema symptoms had almost two more annual consultations of any kind, and children with asthma, either known disease ever or current symptoms, had almost three more annual consultations, compared with children without these diseases (). Known asthma ever, current asthma symptoms, and current eczema symptoms increased the total health service costs with >€300 per year, whereas children with known eczema ever, known hay fever ever, or current hay fever symptoms had the same costs as children without. However, children with any atopic disease or symptom had higher medication costs and higher patient shares of medication costs compared with children without (). Children with known asthma ever or current symptoms of two or more diseases had the highest medication costs of ~€100 more per year compared with children without and the highest patient share of ~€20 more per year ().
Table 2 Annual health service use and costs among children with eczema, asthma, and hay fever compared with children without
Subtypes of health service use
The use of different health service types among subgroups of children is shown in . With few exceptions, children with any atopic disease were more likely than children without to use any subtype of health services, also when adjusted for age, sex, and the primary carer’s educational level. The odds were highest for children with two or more diseases or symptoms (). Children with known asthma ever or current asthma symptoms were twice as likely as children without to consult a general practitioner or after-hours duty doctor or to be admitted to hospital. Infection-related hospital admissions accounted for about half of all hospital admissions (). Though all atopic diseases and symptoms increased the odds of consulting an atopic disease-relevant specialist, less than half of the children with eczema, asthma, and hay fever had seen a specialist the latest year (). For atopic disease-related consultations, we found too few cases to conduct reliable analyses. Only 80 children consulted an outpatient hospital, eight children visited an emergency department, and 45 children were admitted to the hospital due to an atopic disease.
Table 3 Subtypes of annual health service use among children with eczema, asthma, and hay fever compared with children without
Subtypes of prescribed medication
The use of prescribed medication subtypes among subgroups of children is shown in . One out of three children with known eczema ever or current eczema symptoms used prescribed skin medication, and almost half of the children with known asthma ever or current asthma symptoms used respiratory medication. Children with current symptoms of eczema, asthma, or hay fever, and children with known asthma ever used slightly more anti-infective medication compared with children without (), also when adjusted for age, sex, and the primary carer’s educational level (not shown).
Discussion
We found that children with atopic diseases used health services and prescribed medication more than children without atopic diseases, both in total and for most subtypes of health services.
This study is the first to examine health care use in children with hay fever and contributes new, detailed data on the increased health care use associated with eczema, asthma, and hay fever in a representative sample of Danish children with access to universal health care. Our findings support the hypothesis that childhood atopic disease increases the total health service use and health service costs, beyond the atopy-related services. Of note, there was an increased risk of hospital admission due to infections and increased use of anti-infective medication among children with atopic disease compared with other children, reflecting the burden of infectious disease comorbidity.
Our findings are in agreement with the French study of children with atopic eczemaCitation5 and the Canadian, German, and American studies of children with asthmaCitation6–Citation8 described in the “Introduction” section, and extend their findings by describing total health service use, but also more detailed subtypes of health services, medications, and costs. Furthermore, our results confirm other studies showing that far from all children with atopic disease get specialized treatment, even though it is recommended.Citation18–Citation20
The strengths of this study include complete data on detailed, individual-level register-based measures of all health services, costs, and educational level. Data from registries are generally considered reliable and without recall bias. Secondly, we used validated measures of atopic diseases, both known disease ever and current symptoms regardless of diagnosis, which is important when examining diseases expected to be underdiagnosed. Thirdly, we had a relatively homogenous study population in respect to accessibility of health services free of charge, and supply of facilities such as specialists and emergency departments, and with regular health examinations of children at different ages.
Limitations include lack of objective measures of atopic disease such as lung function or atopic disease tests and of severity measures. The variable “known disease ever” may include some children not currently affected, and a proportion of the children with “current symptoms of disease” may be undiagnosed. Our definitions may thus be a mixture of different phenotypes with different health care needs. This may in part explain the relatively low proportion of children receiving specialized treatment, and affect our estimates toward the null. Secondly, whereas register data are considered reliable concerning frequency, date, and duration of contacts, data from the primary health care sector are unspecific regarding the indication of health services. Therefore, we could not assess atopic disease-related primary health care consultations. Also, in analyses of cost of each specific disease, there may be a contribution of cost from other conditions. Moreover, the registers only contain prescribed medication, not over-the-counter medication such as many skin products and hay fever products, which are absent in our measures of medication use and costs. Every third prescription had no defined daily dose, so instead we used packages as unit, which is less precise. Thirdly, non-response bias is possible despite the detailed weighting for nonresponse. Even if a high degree of representativity is achieved, the results may only be applicable to children in the Danish health care system. Finally, we were limited by the cross-sectional design with no possibility to determine causality. We expect a circular relation, where atopic disease increases health service use, and at the same time, health service use increases the likelihood of known disease. We find the same tendencies when measuring known disease ever and current symptoms. We do, however, find a tendency toward lower use of health services among children with symptoms compared with children with known disease ever. This suggests a potential for improving early and sufficient detection of atopic diseases in children.
Conclusion
Eczema, asthma, and hay fever increased the use of most health services and prescribed medication in children. Children with two or more atopic diseases used most health services and medication and had the highest costs.
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank the children and their parents who participated, and the City of Copenhagen for conducting the child health survey. This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or nonprofit sectors.
Supplementary materials
Table S1 Annual medication costs and patient share of medication costs among children with eczema, asthma, or hay fever compared with children without
Table S2 Annual use of different types of health services among various subgroups of children
Table S3 Use of skin medication, respiratory medication, and anti-infective medication in 2009 among various subgroups of children
Disclosure
The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.
References
- MakHJohnstonPAbbeyHTalamoRCPrevalence of asthma and health service utilization of asthmatic children in an inner cityJ Allergy Clin Immunol19827053673727130552
- ZhangTSmithMACampPGCarletonBCHigh use of health services in patients with suboptimal asthma drug regimens: a population-based assessment in British Columbia, CanadaPharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf201322774475123559540
- ChangJFreedGLProsserLAComparisons of health care utilization outcomes in children with asthma enrolled in private insurance plans versus medicaidJ Pediatr Health Care2014281717923312366
- MoncriefTBeckAFSimmonsJMHuangBKahnRSSingle parent households and increased child asthma morbidityJ Asthma201451326026624320709
- MiseryLAnsolabehereXGrandfilsNGeorgescuVTaiebCNine-year follow-up of children with atopic dermatitis by general practitionersDermatology2014228434434924662194
- MaziakWvon MutiusEKeilUPredictors of health care utilization of children with asthma in the communityPediatr Allergy Immunol200415216617115059195
- ToTDellSTassoudjiMWangCHealth outcomes in low-income children with current asthma in CanadaChronic Dis Can2009292495519281690
- JinYSeiberEEFerketichAKSecondhand smoke and asthma: what are the effects on healthcare utilization among children?Prev Med201357212512823701846
- ThygesenLCDaasnesCThaulowIBronnum-HansenHIntroduction to Danish (nationwide) registers on health and social issues: structure, access, legislation, and archivingScand J Public Health2011397 Suppl121621898916
- Hammer-HelmichLLinnebergAThomsenSFGlumerCAssociation between parental socioeconomic position and prevalence of asthma, atopic eczema and hay fever in childrenScand J Public Health201442212012724089102
- PedersenCBThe Danish Civil Registration SystemScand J Public Health2011397 Suppl222521775345
- AsherMIKeilUAndersonHRInternational Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC): rationale and methodsEur Respir J1995834834917789502
- WilliamsHCBurneyPGPembrokeACHayRJThe U.K. Working Party’s Diagnostic Criteria for Atopic Dermatitis. III. Independent hospital validationBr J Dermatol199413134064167918017
- AndersenJSOlivarius NdeFKrasnikAThe Danish National Health Service RegisterScand J Public Health2011397 Suppl343721775348
- KruseMChristiansenTRegister-based studies of healthcare costsScand J Public Health2011397 Suppl20620921775385
- FangelSLindePCThorstedBLNye problemer med repræsentativitet i surveys, som opregning med registre kan reducere. [New problems with survey representativity, which enumeration with registers is able to reduce]Metode og Data2007931426 Danish
- SärndalC-ESwenssonBWretmanJModel Assisted Survey SamplingSpringer-VerlagNew York1992
- FloresGSnowden-BridonCTorresSUrban minority children with asthma: substantial morbidity, compromised quality and access to specialists, and the importance of poverty and specialty careJ Asthma200946439239819484676
- MothGSchiotzPOVedstedPA Danish population-based cohort study of newly diagnosed asthmatic children’s care pathway - adherence to guidelinesBMC Health Serv Res2008813018549494
- NolteHNepper-ChristensenSBackerVUnawareness and undertreatment of asthma and allergic rhinitis in a general populationRespir Med2006100235436216005621