948
Views
35
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review

Pharmacy student professional identity formation: a scoping review

, &
Pages 15-34 | Published online: 27 Mar 2019

Abstract

Purpose

Transitioning from being pharmacy students to pharmacists is challenging. Students need to reconcile their professional aspirations and what they have learnt with the realities of practice. A smooth transition can be hampered when they are unable to enact the role they have envisaged or if their expectations are not met. These challenges relate to professional identity. A key challenge for pharmacy educators is how best to support the professional identity formation (PIF) of pharmacy students. To assist with this challenge, we conducted a scoping review to identify factors influencing pharmacy students’ PIF and pedagogical strategies to support PIF.

Methods

In September 2018, we undertook a scoping review of all contemporary research investigating pharmacy student PIF including all relevant qualitative, quantitative, theoretical, and gray literature. We searched eight databases for the review: MEDLINE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Embase, Australian Education Index, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. Literature published between January 2008 and September 2018 was reviewed and screened using inclusion/exclusion criteria. The selected articles were charted and thematically analyzed.

Results

We included 22 articles in the review. Studies generally concurred about the importance of attending to PIF throughout the whole pharmacy curriculum. Yet, those studies reporting on pharmacy students’ professional identities found that students experienced challenges forming their identities. While several curriculum interventions supporting PIF have been implemented, these tended to be one-offs and there was an absence of interventions engaging key stakeholders including placement preceptors, other health professionals, and patients/consumers.

Conclusion

Supporting the formation of pharmacy students’ professional identity, while recognized as an important goal for pharmacy education, requires further empirical inquiry. Pedagogical practices focused on identity formation including adopting an integrative curricular approach are required.

Introduction

Pharmacy graduates need to be prepared for the realities of professional practice. However, transitioning from being a pharmacy student to a pharmacist is challenging. Students need to reconcile their curricular learnings and aspirations for professional practice with the realities of authentic practice.Citation1 These transitions can be complicated when students’ understandings of their professional selves do not align with their practice experience.Citation2,Citation3 These challenges relate to professional identity, that is, the sense of being a professional formed through interaction between self and context.Citation4,Citation5 Those with strong professional identities tend to be confident, motivated, and able to cope with complex and uncertain aspects of practice.Citation6Citation8 For pharmacy graduates, the formation of professional identity means they need to understand the pharmacist role and the context and cultures of different practice settings, and to have begun to socialize into the profession. Thus, a key goal for university curricula is supporting the professional identity formation (PIF) of its students.Citation9

There is considerable evidence within the health professions education literature confirming that participating in a vocational degree (eg, medicine, nursing) is “as much about the development of professional identity as it is about knowledge learning”.Citation10 Within medical education, supporting PIF is considered to be its highest purposeCitation11 because professional identity is a “key determinant of the scope and nature of professional work”, that is, how professionals enact their practice.Citation12 Conversely, curricular approaches that do not purposefully attend to PIF, but focus primarily on the development of knowledge and skills, can result in students lacking clarity about their future role and having fragmented understandings of their professional selves.Citation13 Within medical education, and in the absence of a pharmacy-specific definition, professional identity has been defined as

“a representation of self, achieved in stages over time during which the characteristics, values, and norms of the medical profession are internalized, resulting in an individual thinking, acting, and feeling like a physician”.Citation14

PIF, then, is an active, developmental process where individuals integrate the knowledge, skills, values, and behaviors of a competent professional.Citation15 Intentional support of PIF through curricular experiences, such as mentorship and self-reflection, has been shown to assist students to become the kind of professionals they want to be, in spite of the realities of practice.Citation7,Citation16 In other words, curricular experiences shape learning as well as PIF enabling students to become a “certain kind of person”.Citation17 Relating these ideas to pharmacy education means that curriculum experiences would result in individuals who will think, act, and do things in a way that shows they are truly patient-centered pharmacists.Citation18

However, facilitating PIF requires not only consideration about who individuals are becoming but also broader societal considerations about “the hallmarks of the pharmacist that society wants a student to become? What processes support and promote this transformation of identity?”Citation11 These questions relate to what is “known about the development of pharmacist identity in relation to features of social context”.Citation19 Yet, the pharmacy profession lacks agreement on what it means to be a pharmacist and how to best support PIF within higher education. For example, an opinion study examining community pharmacists’ and pharmacy academics’ views on pharmacy practice competencies found that academics emphasized the importance of research, pharmaceutical technology, and the regulatory aspects of quality, while community pharmacists concentrated more on patient care competences.Citation20

Theoretical perspectives of professional identity

Professional identities are formed through an evolutionary and iterative process whereby individuals make choices, in response to the professional context, about who they want to be.Citation8 Professional identities are neither fixed nor unitary but are better conceptualized as relational, in that individuals respond to various experiences, situations, and people through an evaluative and emotional process and from this they iteratively construct (or renegotiate and reconstruct) their professional identity.Citation21 For educators, it can be helpful to think about our students as having, but also experimenting with, their “provisional selves” which “serve as trials for possible but not yet fully elaborated professional identities”Citation22 This is “an adaptive developmental process that happens simultaneously at two levels: 1) at the level of the individual, which involves the psychological development of the person, and 2) at the collective level, which involves the socialization of the person into appropriate roles and forms of participation in the community’s work”.Citation5

In other words, the construction of identities takes place through the interplay of internal and external forces in the midst of social interaction. This process is known as identification which is a “two-way process that occurs during the simultaneous amalgamation of self-definition (who I think I am: internal) and the definitions of oneself as presented by others (who I think you think I am: external) through language and artefacts”.Citation10

When we turn our gaze to pharmacy education, there is less clarity regarding strategies for supporting PIF. For example, the issue of supporting pharmacy students’ PIF was emphasized by the International Pharmaceutical Federation in 2000 and further illuminated by Taylor and Harding in 2007Citation23 who argued that pharmacy students’ experiences of undergraduate curriculum form the foundation of PIF. Since then, strategies addressing PIF have been integrated into some pharmacy education policies; for example, the Taskforce on Professional Identity Formation by the American Association of Colleges of Pharmacy aimed:

  1. to make recommendations for best practices in PIF;

  2. to create a tool kit for educational methods to support PIF within interprofessional contexts; and

  3. to generate recommendations to support faculty to develop students’ professional identities.Citation24

Yet in other countries, for example Australia, attending to pharmacy students’ professional identity has not been integrated into accreditation standards for pharmacy degrees.Citation25

No reviews currently exist that provide evidence for best supporting pharmacy student identity formation. The aim of this study is to appraise and summarize the literature, published in the past decade, related to pharmacy student PIF and to identify factors influencing pharmacy students’ perception of professional identity and its formation as well as pedagogical strategies to supporting PIF.

Methods

This study employed a scoping review methodology to map the available literature on the PIF of pharmacy students.Citation26,Citation27 Scoping reviews aim to summarize and disseminate research findings and identify gaps in the existing literature.Citation26 They differ from systematic reviews in that they take into account all relevant literature, regardless of methodology. For this review, we examined all contemporary research investigating pharmacy student PIF. To ensure the reliability and reproducibility of our methods, we followed the scoping review procedures outlined by Arksey and O’Malley:Citation26

  1. Identify the research question

  2. Identify relevant studies

  3. Select the (relevant) studies

  4. Chart the data

  5. Collate, summarize, and report the results

Identifying the research question

Our scoping review focused on answering the following research question: in the past decade, what is known about pharmacy student PIF and how can it best be supported through the pharmacy curriculum? This time point was selected based on previous researchCitation1 which noted a limited literature base prior to 2008. As a literature review examining PIF within higher education, including all degrees, was conducted in 2012,Citation9 we selected the time frame to ensure the integration of contemporary evidence.

Identifying relevant studies

Based on the research goals and our previous literature searchCitation1 and in consultation with our librarian, the following Boolean search strategy was used:

  1. Students, Pharmacy/(2540)

  2. ((pharmacy or pharmacist*) adj5 student*).tw. (2993) 3. Pharmacists/(14631)

  3. (pharmacy or pharmacist*).tw. (53908)

  4. Students/(50207)

  5. student*.tw. (244152)

  6. (or/3-4) and (or/5-6) (4362)

  7. 1 or 7 (5044)

  8. social identification/(8304)

  9. (professional adj3 identi*).tw. (2678)

  10. 9 or 10 (10732)

  11. 8 and 11 (22)

  12. limit 12 to yr=”2008 -Current” (19)

In earlier iterations of the search strategy, the term “curriculum” constrained the search too much. To ensure comprehensive investigation, the following databases were used: MEDLINE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Embase, Australian Education Index, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. The search was conducted on February 16, 2018, and the search was re-run on September 21, 2018. The search was limited to articles between 2008 and present.

Selecting the studies

All of the articles identified from the search were imported into EndNote® software, and duplicates were deleted. Using EndNote®, CN reviewed all of the article titles and applied the screening tool (inclusion criteria are explained below) to determine their eligibility for full-text review. Then, CN reviewed the articles selected for full-text review. The reference lists of the articles were also reviewed to identify any other relevant studies, particularly in the gray literature, not found in the initial search. To be included in the study, the following inclusion criteria were applied:

  1. Focus on explicitly addressing PIF

  2. Involve pharmacy curricula

  3. Focus on pharmacy students enrolled in pharmacy degree programs or their previous curricular experiences (and not on pharmacists)

The team reviewed all the selected articles, discussed the findings, and resolved disagreements on study selection and data extraction by consensus and through discussion.

Charting the data

We adopted a descriptive analytical approachCitation26 that applies a common analytical framework (ie, set of questions) to all the included articles. Based on these framework questions, the responses were charted into an Excel® spreadsheet. To answer our research question, we applied the following analytical questions to our data/literature set:

  • What is the rationale for supporting PIF in the pharmacy curriculum?

  • How do articles conceptualize pharmacy student’s professional identity?

  • How do pharmacy curriculum and pedagogical practices influence PIF?

  • What are the recommendations for future research?

Based on these analytical questions, the following information was extracted and included on the Excel® spreadsheet: demographic data (eg, year of publication, location of publication); methodology data (eg, research design, data collection); and thematic categories (eg, interventions, key findings, implications for PIF, conclusions).

Collating, summarizing, and reporting the results

Data were collated, summarized quantitatively, and analyzed thematically to identify recurrent patterns in the selected articles. First, we examined the studies quantitatively for the extent, nature, and distribution of the included articles. Separate Excel® spreadsheets and tables were produced: the geographical distribution of articles; study participants; and research methods adopted. Second, data were charted based on the key themes identified including: tools for measuring professional identity; need to examine PIF; current state of pharmacy students’ professional identities; curricular factors influencing PIF; and pedagogical practices supporting PIF (). To address our final research question, that is, recommendations for future research, we again followed the strategy described by Arksey and O’MalleyCitation26 by using the literature review to identify gaps by comparing the theoretical and methodological approaches across studies while consulting the broader health profession education and higher education literature to identify contemporary trends and issues emerging from these.

Table 1 Summary of articles included in this scoping review on pharmacy student professional identity formation

Results

Our results are presented as follows. Firstly, an overview and descriptive summary is presented. Secondly, the themes identified are presented, including: 1) PIF as a curriculum priority; 2) conceptualization of pharmacy students’ professional identities; 3) curricular factors and pedagogical practices influencing pharmacy students’ PIF; and 4) recommendations for further research.

Overview and descriptive summary

As shown in , our initial search retrieved 137 articles of which 52 were duplicates. After applying the screening tool to the remaining 85 titles, 22 articles were identified and included in our final review (). Most of the articles were qualitative studies (n=8; 36%) or descriptions of curriculum development programs to promote PIF (n=7; 32%). The remaining articles were survey studies (n=4; 18%), opinion (n=2; 9%), and methodological studies (n=1; 5%). The majority of the studies were Australian (n=10; 45%) with the remainder from the USA (n=4; 18%), the UK (n=4; 18%), South Africa (n=2; 9%), Canada (n=1; 5%), and Lebanon (n=1; 5%).

Figure 1 Flow diagram of the search and selection process used for a 2018 literature search for articles on pharmacy students’ identity formation for a scoping review.

Figure 1 Flow diagram of the search and selection process used for a 2018 literature search for articles on pharmacy students’ identity formation for a scoping review.

The majority of studies (n=13; 60%)Citation28Citation40 were theoretically informed; however, there was considerable variation in theories chosen. In total, six different theories were used (). One group of authors noted that an agreed theoretical approach is required to inform curricular strategies in order to meaningfully address PIF.Citation45

Table 2 Theories informing pharmacy student professional identity formation research

PIF as a curriculum priority

Three articlesCitation38,Citation39,Citation49 including a curriculum mapping study,Citation37 a survey of pharmacy academics,Citation38 and an opinion paperCitation46 provided arguments for the importance of supporting pharmacy students’ PIF through their curricular experiences (). Firstly, the pharmacy curriculum influences how students see themselves and their work-readiness, particularly their ability to adapt to emerging roles, for example, advanced practice and changing pharmacist roles in complex health care environments.Citation46 When PIF is not foregrounded in the curriculum, pharmacy curriculums tend to focus on the provision of knowledge and skills, as observed in one pharmacy curriculum concept mapping exercise.Citation39 The authors noted that this focus may result in limited opportunities for students to develop strong professional identities.Citation39

Table 3 Professional identity formation as a curriculum priority

Curricular programs of teaching, learning, and assessment have been found to contribute to PIF through student engagement with authentic learning activities, curricular alignment with work practices, and interactions with practicing pharmacists;Citation49 however, the current curricular focus of academe tends to be on the provision of knowledge with limited purposeful intentions to support PIF.Citation38 Without careful consideration of curricular and pedagogical practice contributions to PIF, there is a risk that students’ professional identities will align to drug-centered understandings rather than patient-centered identities as was observed in a curriculum mapping study from one School of Pharmacy.Citation39 The study authors noted that these concerns aligned with the broader higher education and health professions’ education research and emphasized that strategies and research should inform curriculum development and enactment to foster students’ PIF as pharmacists.

Current state of pharmacy students’ professional identities

Five articles (23%) examined the ways in which pharmacy students understood themselves as becoming pharmacists, and these related to both individualist and collective experiences of identities (). Two studies focused on final-year students,Citation28,Citation50 and the remaining studies explored all pharmacy year groupsCitation30,Citation35 or graduates transitioning to practice.Citation37

Table 4 Current state of pharmacy students’ professional identities

Individualist perspectives of identities

Two studies examined how pharmacy students saw themselves and despite using different methodologies, that is, surveyCitation28 and focus groups,Citation37 came to similar conclusions. That is, pharmacy students’ understandings of their professional selves lacked a comprehensive understanding of what it means to be a pharmacist. Findings from the survey studyCitation28 found that students tended to focus on traditional pharmacist roles, for example, dispensing and counseling, and this understanding was influenced by experiential and part-time work experiences. While findings from the focus group study showed that pharmacy students’ aspirations were to be pharmacists who contribute to patient care, yet, based on their curricular experience, the students concluded that their futures selves were likely to be constrained and limited. The authors surmised that pharmacy students’ professional identities seem to lack coherence; that is, it is challenging to integrate the knowledge, skills, and behaviors promoted by the curriculum with their own values (eg, being patient centered by integrating curriculum studies into their practice experience).Citation37

Collective experience of identities

Four studiesCitation30,Citation35,Citation37,Citation50 examined how pharmacy student professional identities were constructed in relation to social context. The two key themes identified from these studies were: 1) identities lacking social recognition; and 2) identities remaining unresolved.

Identities lacking social recognition

One study noted that pharmacy students’ professional identities were contingent on their interactions with others (including patients, health care professionals, and pharmacy staff) and the tasks in which they were expected to engage. These experiences commonly occurred while on experiential placements.Citation37

Interactions with others

Two studies found that pharmacy students mostly reported lacking social recognition when experimenting with their professional selves during placement. For example, students found it challenging to relate their pharmacist selves to other health care professionalsCitation50 and this was particularly challenging when their advice was not accepted as this was something they had not experienced in the university setting.Citation35 Similarly, when engaging with patients/clients, students found it challenging when their attempts to enact their pharmacist selves were met with disinterest or, in some instances, anger. In both studies,Citation35,Citation50 these experiences were unexpected, and students were not equipped to navigate these challenges.

Engaging in pharmacy tasks

Another factor, identified by two studies,Citation30,Citation37 influencing students’ collective experience of identity formation was the tasks students were expected to engage in while on placements. For example, in one study,Citation37 students reported that they did not believe that engaging in tasks, such as unpacking medications, or observing pharmacy assistants engaging in tasks they believed were pharmacist unique (eg, counseling) contributed to their professional selves.Citation30 These conundrums were noted to be important considerations,Citation30 in terms of student PIF, because students lack power (eg, just a student and being directed by pharmacist and/or assistants), knowledge, and confidence to influence the outcome of these experiences and at the same time these types of experiences invariably lead to crushed ideals of what it means to be a pharmacist.Citation30

Unresolved identity dissonance

Two studies found that the experiences of the pharmacy curriculum often contributed to unresolved identity dissonance in that the pharmacist role tended to be presented as idealized, yet students’ practice experiences often did not align with these ideals.Citation35,Citation37 The authors emphasized that a lack of opportunities to resolve this dissonance made it challenging for students to form cohesive professional identities.Citation35,Citation37 Creating opportunities for students to share their placement experiences in the classroom with pharmacist tutors, the authors suggested, would help students to make sense of these identity dissonances in a supported environment.Citation35,Citation37 While Monrouxe et alCitation30 suggested that pedagogical practices, such as role-play activities, should be undertaken to encourage students to share experiences through narratives and then act out idealized actions, that is, how students wish they had acted, they argued that this approach could facilitate synergy between personal moral values and moral action enabling students to commit and recommit to their professional identities.Citation30

Curricular factors influencing PIF

Six studies (27%) found that pharmacy curricular experiences influence PIF and described the key curriculum factors influencing PIF ().Citation36,Citation37,Citation39,Citation43,Citation51Citation53 The key factors identified from curriculum mapping,Citation39 qualitative focus groups,Citation37 ethnographic research,Citation36 interviews,Citation35 and qualitative mixed methodsCitation52 studies are as follows. Firstly, a curriculum mapping study examining the intentions of a pharmacy curriculum found it was structured in content silos.Citation39 The authors noted a strong emphasis on the acquisition of drug-centered knowledge and less emphasis on patient-centered ways of being a pharmacist.Citation39 The authors also found that the assessment processes were dominated by theory examinations using multiple-choice and short-answer questions and suggested that these assessment practices promoted content siloing and a focus on knowledge acquisition. These processes made it challenging for students to construct patient-centered professional identities.Citation39

Table 5 Curricular factors influencing professional identity formation

Secondly, two studies found that student engagement with pharmacist role models who enact their pharmacist selves contributes to PIF.Citation37,Citation52 However, both studies noted that this engagement needs to be meaningful whereby students can integrate observed behaviors, feedback, and reflective accounts into their becoming pharmacist selves.Citation37,Citation52 An ethnographic study found that, while pharmacists are often employed by universities to teach pharmacy students, they often enact their educator selves, for example, deliver lectures, and often do not role model their pharmacy capabilities, for example, thinking out loud or role model counseling.Citation36

Opportunities to enact their professional selves through experiences such as practical classes and/or tutorial were valued by pharmacy students, in terms of contributing to their professional identities.Citation52 However, the authors noted there was variation in the extent of student engagement in these experiences with some students reporting that they had limited engagementCitation35 or the experiences lacked authenticity, for example, absence of patients and other health care professionals or pedagogical activities that promoted information provision-focused counseling/knowledge provision rather than collaborative dialog.Citation36 One study found that there were few opportunities for students to engage in feedback on their performance during these tutorial classes.Citation36

Finally, several studies noted that experiential learning through placements was highly valued by pharmacy students as an opportunity to try out their professional identities,Citation36,Citation37 and indeed, early work experiences, that is, before commencing a pharmacy degree, can contribute to improved pharmacist PIF, especially for students in the early years (first and second years) of their degree.Citation53 It has been noted that because there is considerable variation in how pharmacy practice is enacted, students often reported that the realities of practice were not aligned to how they imagined themselves as pharmacists.Citation37 For example, students would practice counseling while on placement, yet they reported that clients did not respond in the way they expected; in other instances, the usual counseling practices of the pharmacy did not align with taught practice models. The authors found that these experiences created a sense of dissonance for students as their identities were often unresolved as they moved from placements back to the university.Citation37 With the current trend toward university expansion of work-integrated learning and experiential placements, further research is needed to address this dissonance when students return to their campus classes.

Pedagogical practices supporting PIF

Several studies (n=9; 40%) focused on implementing and/or evaluating pedagogical strategies to support pharmacy student PIF. There was some homogeneity in the goals and objectives of the programs, and two main themes were identified: 1) developing professional identities; and 2) understanding how pedagogical practices contributed to identity. First, some programs focused on developing students’ pharmacist identitiesCitation34,Citation54 with some having a specific focus on supporting interprofessional understandings of identity formation.Citation55,Citation56 These programs used a range of learning activities, including workshops, reflective writing, interactions with practicing pharmacists, attending professional meetings, and so on,Citation34,Citation54 to support identity formation. The effectiveness of these programs was evaluated in heterogeneous ways. For example, some used assessment data as a measure of student engagementCitation54 or surveys were used to measure students’ satisfactionCitation34 and professional identities using a validated tool informed by self-determination theory.Citation34 On the other hand, the interprofessional programsCitation55,Citation56 used the Readiness for Interprofessional Learning Scale to evaluate their programs and included factors on sense of professional identity.Citation57

Second, several programs sought to understand how particular pedagogical practices contributed to PIF, for example, reflective essays,Citation29 coaching,Citation58 socialization activities including placements,Citation47 and facilitated discussions with academics.Citation59 The contributions of these programs to the students’ formation of professional identities were examined through questionnaires,Citation58 evaluation of reflective essays,Citation29 or interviews (group and individual).Citation59 Some of these evaluations were informed by professional identity theory, for example, social identity theoryCitation47 and Baxter-Magolda’s self-authorship theory.Citation29 All studies reported that the programs positively contributed to the students’ PIF. However, most programs were one-offs (seven out of nine studies), that is, a single course or module added to the curriculum.Citation55 It was not clear how the students’ identities changed over time or whether their identities were sustained. Most studies focused on early years, that is, first/second (n=4; 44%),Citation47 with a few involving final-year students (33%).Citation55 Only two studies adopted a longitudinal approach to supporting PIF; that is, pedagogical strategies were integrated across the curriculum (n=2; 22%), but the outcomes tended to be evaluated based on student impressions and assessment results rather than validated measures of professional identities.Citation54,Citation56

Recommendations for further research

Most studies reviewed suggested further research to investigate in depth the construction of pharmacy students’ professional identities with suggestions tending to be study replication in other Schools of Pharmacy or countries to address the lack of generalizability. This was because, with the exception of Schafheutle et al,Citation52 most studies were conducted in single site. Of the 22 articles, 6 did not offer future research recommendations. The recommendations from the remaining articles related to longitudinal exploration of students’ PIF,Citation29,Citation47,Citation53 implementation and evaluation of increasingly diverse placement experiences to support PIF,Citation55,Citation60 in-depth exploration of pharmacy academics’ understandings of supporting PIF,Citation38,Citation52 and in-depth exploration of pharmacy students’ experience of curriculum;Citation36 however, this was addressed in subsequent work.Citation35,Citation37

Few articles fully integrated identity theory into their enquiries, and this was noted by Mylrea et alCitation32 who argued for the application of self-determination theoryCitation44 to assist with understanding how student identities are formed and to inform curriculum reform. The same authors also generated a validated tool to understand links between motivation and professional identity (requires further testing).Citation61

Given the strong influence of the social experience on professional identity and the challenges experienced by pharmacy students (explained above), curiously, there were no research recommendations related to exploring the placement preceptors’, other health care professionals’ or consumers’ perspectives of and/or contributions to pharmacy students’ PIF. Thus, further research is required to address these gaps.

Discussion

Our scoping review identified 22 articles, published in the past decade, examining pharmacy student PIF and focused on factors influencing pharmacy students’ perception of professional identity and its formation and explored pedagogical strategies to supporting PIF. Our findings suggest that supporting pharmacy students’ PIF is an important goal for pharmacy education yet there is a paucity of research examining students’ PIF and the differing theoretical perspectives suggest this is an underdeveloped field of research and offers opportunities for synthesizing these differing perspectives.Citation9 Without curricular interventions supporting PIF, we found that pharmacy students can form professional identities that lack cohesion with their values and experiences of practice. There were few examples of integrative curriculum programs supporting PIF. Rather, we found curriculum interventions which tended to be one-off programs and the evaluations of outcomes were limited to existing assessment processes and lacked validated measures for PIF, and thus only partly contributed to understanding the outcomes of professional identity programs. Overall, our findings suggest that further opportunities exist to comprehensively support the successful formation of pharmacy students’ identities.

Pharmacy curriculum considerations

Pharmacy students find it challenging to integrate the knowledge, skills, and behaviors promoted by the curriculum with their own values (eg, being patient centered). Strong professional identities form when there is alignment between how students see themselves and how others see them.Citation10 While our findings agree with findings from other professions, in that both the formal curriculum and informal curriculum experiences were influencing how they saw themselves as they moved through these different contexts, for example, university to placement,Citation62 pharmacy students often lacked opportunities to resolve any discrepancies. These findings provide insights into the kinds of curricular programs and pedagogical program that can support the formation of strong professional identities. When considering how to best support pharmacy students’ progressive formation of strong professional identities, this review has identified two key curriculum considerations: 1) establishing the curriculum intention; and 2) fostering a longitudinal and integrative approach to PIF.

First, our findings indicate that it was generally agreed that supporting pharmacy students’ PIF is an important intention for pharmacy curriculum. Yet, the evidence suggests that without purposeful support of PIF pharmacy students struggled to develop strong professional identities especially as they moved between different contexts. These findings intimate that the ordering of learning experiences was not directly supporting or enabling access to experiences where students can reconcile and make sense of differing ways of being a pharmacist. To address this, curricular programs need to enable pharmacy students to “recognize, explore, articulate, prioritize, and share their authentic values and values conflicts within a supportive professional community”Citation62 Pharmacy educators will play a pivotal role in fostering these intentions through curriculum program development, yet our findings suggest that PIF may not yet be a core goal for pharmacy academics.Citation38 To best support pharmacy academics in this goal, there would be value in offering professional development in educational theory and pedagogical practice, as this has been noted by Blouin et alCitation63 to be lacking. Ensuring pharmacy academics recognize and understand the importance of PIF is important as students view them as key role models.Citation37,Citation52 Thus, consideration should be given to how to best sequence learning especially during transition (eg, from placement back to university) so that experiences of identity dissonance are discussed and resolved.

Second, no studies reported on PIF programs comprehensively integrated across the curriculum with alignment between learning outcomes, pedagogies, and assessment practices; rather, one-off approaches tend to be adopted. It is known that professional identities are formed through an evolutionary and iterative process where individuals make choices in response to the professional context about who they want to be.Citation8 Given this dynamic nature of PIF, supporting PIF in longitudinal and integrative curricular design is likely required.Citation64 To address this shortfall, strategies described by Holden et al,Citation64 who developed a longitudinal curriculum framework to help medical students develop their professional identities, could be applied. For example, this team of academics established a task force including academics, practitioners, and other professionals who generated agreement on the definition of PIF, explicated its key aspects, and identified strategies for promotion and assessment through the curriculum. Moreover, using this task force approach also aligns to broader pharmacy curriculum reform recommendations for collaboration between pharmacy practitioners and universities.Citation65Citation67 For example, in the UK, the General Pharmaceutical Council recommended that entry-to-practice pharmacy education should be jointly owned, planned, and delivered by the practice community and universities.Citation67 Yet, implementing curricular changes and innovation takes time and money and the profession has been slow to implement these changes.Citation63 Indeed, Blouin et alCitation63 note that within pharmacy education “innovation, in education or other venues, rarely waits on evidence of worth, and demonstrating worth does not guarantee adoption of the innovation”. Thus, a productive way forward may be to acknowledge the evidence, find ways to overcome resistance to curricular reform, and embrace innovation.Citation68

The value in this type of approach is that curriculum intentions are revised through collaborative engagement between pharmacy academics, professionals, and practitioners. Also, given our review found that the patient/consumer voice was missing there would be value including consumers in this task force. Finally, the process of longitudinal curriculum framework development will offer opportunities to consider meaningful PIF assessment process.Citation11,Citation69

Practice pedagogies for PIF

This review identified several learning activities and interactions contributing to PIF, for example, reflective essays,Citation29,Citation40,Citation47 group discussions,Citation59 and coaching,Citation58 yet further opportunities to augment PIF exist. For example, Rabow et alCitation62 in their review of medical PIF identified key pedagogical practices to support learners’ PIF through exploration and integration of student values with curricular learnings. Our review found that the following strategies could provide further opportunities for pharmacy student PIF: personal narratives, positive role modeling, and evaluation and feedback about values.Citation62

Firstly, because the formation of professional identity is both an internal and external process, both cognitive and social pedagogical opportunities are required for students to make sense of their experiences. Using personal narratives or storytelling pedagogies brings together these opportunities and is a key way to effectively support PIF.Citation10,Citation11 However, our review suggests there is an absence of storytelling pedagogies within pharmacy curricula and consideration should be given to integrating narratives pedagogies. Narrative approaches support students to derive personal meaning, learn from their experiences, and make PIF explicit. One approach is to use parallel charts, where students not only write up clinical case reports but also write narratives about their personal experiences with patients in separate charts.Citation70Citation72 Through this process, students learn to generate their own meaning from experiences and this meaning shapes their identity.Citation71

Secondly, positive role modeling is essential for the development of strong professional identities.Citation62 Yet, only two studies examined the perspectives of pharmacy academicsCitation52 and no studies explored the pharmacy preceptors’ perspectives of their role in supporting PIF of pharmacy students. This points to an important gap in the literature and suggests that, as noted by Rabow et al,Citation62 development programs to support faculty and preceptors in mentoring and serving as a positive role model are likely to make important contributions to student PIF.

Thirdly, an important finding from this review was students often reported lacking social recognition (eg, from patients, other health care professionals) when attempting to enact their pharmacist roles. These experiences made it challenging for them to develop strong professional identities. Moreover, the feedback and assessment processes were not providing students with guidance on how to best engage in their pharmacist roles. These types of experiences and reactions shape identity in two ways: 1) validates (or fails to validate) new behaviors; and 2) provides feedback about how to improve.Citation22 Experiences of lacking validation from others contribute to identity dissonance.Citation22 Curiously, there were few examples, except for socialization activities,Citation73 where students were encouraged to explore and make sense of how others (eg, patients and other health care professionals) saw them as becoming professionals. As GoldieCitation74 argues, these interactions need to foster meaningful student participation so that the students can find ways to appreciate and synthesize multiple perspectives. However, there can be few opportunities for students to engage in feedback processes.Citation36 A key driver of PIF is feedback,Citation69 while the absence of regular feedback with guidance on how to improve hampers PIF.Citation22,Citation75 Thus, further efforts are required to enhance feedback practices in the curriculum and will likely include faculty development for pharmacy educators and preceptors to engage in feedback practices. Also, strategies, such as feedback literacy programs, to support student feedback engagement could be incorporated into curriculum,Citation76 while consideration should be given to how the patient/consumer voice can be enabled to contribute to students’ feedback and subsequent PIF.

The limitation of this study, as with all scoping reviews, is that the research outcomes were not examined. Also, despite systematically following the methodological guidance of Arksey and O’Malley, the articles were not quality appraised. We used a comprehensive search strategy generated in collaboration with librarians; however, we may have missed some relevant studies. For example, there may have been value in purposefully searching for pedagogical practices such as experiential learning. Nonetheless, our review presents the extent, range, and nature of research activities which has not been conducted before and identified research gaps and noted where no research has been conducted.

Conclusion

Our scoping review found that supporting the formation of pharmacy students’ professional identity, while recognized as an important goal for pharmacy education, would benefit from further research (eg, multisite studies and careful investigation with all stakeholders) and additional pedagogical practices focused on identity formation including adopting an integrative curricular approach. These suggestions are likely to contribute to strong professional identities as graduates transition to professional practice.

Acknowledgments

The authors wish to thank Dr Ian Coombes for his helpful review and feedback on a draft of this manuscript, and Sarah Thorning and Susan Day, the librarians who assisted with the literature search.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

References

  • NobleCBecoming Pharmacists: How the Pharmacy Curriculum Influences Professional Identity FormationSt. Lucia, QLDThe University of Queensland2014
  • EdenMSchafheutleEIHassellKWorkload pressure among recently qualified pharmacists: an exploratory study of intentions to leave the professionInt J Pharm Pract200917318118720218250
  • PerroneLVickersMHLife after graduation as a “very uncomfortable world”: an Australian case studyEducation + Training20034526978
  • SteinertYEducational theory and strategies to support professionalism and professional identity formationCruessRLCruessSRSteinertYTeaching Medical Professionalism: Supporting the Development of a Professional Identity2nd edCambridgeCambridge University Press20166883
  • Jarvis-SelingerSPrattDDRegehrGCompetency is not enough: integrating identity formation into the medical education discourseAcad Med201287916
  • BleakleyABlighJBrowneJMedical Education for the Future: Identity, Power and LocationDordrechtSpringer2011
  • RonfeldtMGrossmanPBecoming a professional: experimenting with possible selvesTeach Educ Q20083534160
  • ScanlonL“Becoming” a professionalScanlonL“Becoming” a ProfessionalDordrechtSpringer2011
  • TredeFMacklinRBridgesDProfessional identity development: a review of the higher education literatureStud High Educ2012373365384
  • MonrouxeLVIdentity, identification and medical education: why should we care?Med Educ2010441404920078755
  • CookeMIrbyDMO’BrienBCEducating Physicians: A Call for Reform of Medical School and ResidencyStanfordJossey-Bass2010
  • HollandDLachicotteWJrVygotsky, Mead, and the new sociocultural studies of identityThe Cambridge Companion to Vygotsky2007101135
  • Dall’AlbaGLearning professional ways of being: ambiguities of becomingEduc Philos Theor20094113445
  • CruessRLCruessSRBoudreauJDSnellLSteinertYReframing medical education to support professional identity formationAcad Med201489111446145125054423
  • HoldenMBuckEClarkMSzauterKTrumbleJProfessional identity formation in medical education: the convergence of multiple domainsHEC Forum201224424525523104548
  • DanielewiczJIdentity Teaching Selves: Pedagogy, and Teacher EducationAlbanyState University of New York Press2001
  • GeeJPChapter 3: identity as an analytic lens for research in educationRev Res Educ200025199125
  • NobleCShawPNNissenLCoombesIO’BrienM. Curriculum for uncertainty: certainty may not be the answerAm J Pharm Educ201175113a
  • CantillonPDornanTDe GraveWBecoming a clinical teacher: identity formation in contextAcad Med Epub2018814
  • AtkinsonJde PaepeKSánchez PozoAWhat is a pharmacist: opinions of pharmacy department academics and community pharmacists on competences required for pharmacy practicePharmacy20164112
  • BeijaardDMeijerPCVerloopNReconsidering research on teachers’ professional identityTeach Teach Educ2004202107128
  • IbarraHProvisional selves: experimenting with image and identity in professional adaptationAdmin Sci Q1999444764791
  • TaylorKHardingGThe pharmacy degree: the student experience of professional trainingPharm Educ2007718388
  • American Association of Colleges of PharmacyTaskforce on professional identity formation – final report2014 Available from: https://www.aacp.org/sites/default/files/2017-11/COD%20Taskforce%20on%20Professional%20Identity%20Formation%20Final%20Report%20July%202014.pdfAccessed July 29, 2018
  • Australian Pharmacy CouncilAccreditation Standards for Pharmacy Programs in Australia and New ZealandCanberraAustralian Pharmacy Council Ltd2014
  • ArkseyHO’MalleyLScoping studies: towards a methodological frameworkInt J Soc Res Meth2005811932
  • TriccoACLillieEZarinWRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): checklist and explanationAnn Intern Med2018169746747330178033
  • BurrowsJdall’albaGCazeALBecoming pharmacists: Students’ understanding of pharmacy practice at graduation from an Australian UniversityCurr Pharm Teach Learn201686729741
  • JohnsonJLChauvinSProfessional identity formation in an advanced pharmacy practice experience emphasizing self-authorshipAm J Pharm Educ2016801017228179721
  • MonrouxeLVReesCEEndacottRTernanE“Even now it makes me angry”: health care students’ professionalism dilemma narrativesMed Educ201448550251724712935
  • MylreaMFSen GuptaTGlassBDValidation of a motivation survey tool for pharmacy students: exploring a link to professional identity developmentCurr Pharm Teach Learn20179576376929233302
  • MylreaMFSen GuptaTGlassBDDeveloping professional identity in undergraduate pharmacy students: a role for self-determination theoryPharmacy201752
  • MylreaMFGuptaTSGlassBDProfessionalization in pharmacy education as a matter of identityAm J Pharm Educ201579914226839431
  • MylreaMFSen GuptaTGlassBDDesign and evaluation of a novel professional identity development program for pharmacy studentsAm J Pharm Educ2018ajpe6842
  • NobleCCoombesINissenLShawPNClavarinoAMaking the transition from pharmacy student to pharmacist: Australian interns’ perceptions of professional identity formationInt J Pharm Pract201523429230425363500
  • NobleCCoombesIShawPNNissenLMClavarinoABecoming a pharmacist: the role of curriculum in professional identity formationPharm Pract201412100
  • NobleCO’BrienMCoombesIBecoming a pharmacist: Students’ perceptions of their curricular experience and professional identity formationCurr Pharm Teach Learn201463327339
  • NobleCCoombesINissenLPharmacy educators’ intention for the curriculum: an Australian pilot studyPharm Educ20141414856
  • NobleCO’BrienMCoombesIShawPNNissenLConcept mapping to evaluate an undergraduate pharmacy curriculumAm J Pharm Educ20117535521655409
  • van HuyssteenMBheekieAThe hidden curriculum of work-based learning for pharmacy students in public sector pharmacies in South AfricaPharm Educ2017171190198
  • Baxter MagoldaMBCreating Contexts for Learning and Self-AuthorshipNashvilleVanderbilt University Press1999
  • HeideggerMBeing and TimeNew YorkHarper and Row1962
  • NobleCCoombesIShawPNNissenLMClavarinoABecoming a pharmacist: the role of curriculum in professional identity formationPharm Pract201412100
  • DeciELRyanRMMotivationISelf-Determination in Human BehaviourNew YorkPlenum1985
  • MylreaMSen GuptaTGlassBDeveloping professional identity in undergraduate pharmacy students: a role for self-determination theoryPharmacy20175416
  • TajfelHTurnerJAn integrative theory of inter-group conflictAustinWWorchelSThe Social Psychology of Intergroup RelationsMontereyBrooks-Cole19793334
  • van HuyssteenMBheekieAThe meaning of being a pharmacist: considering the professional identity development of first-year pharmacy studentsAfr J Health Prof Educ201572208211
  • WengerECommunities of Practice: Learning, Meaning and IdentityCambridgeCambridge University Press1998
  • MylreaMFGuptaTSGlassBDProfessionalization in pharmacy education as a matter of identityAm J Pharm Educ201579914226839431
  • McCartneyJBoschmansSASouth African pharmacy student perspectives of a hospital-based experiential learning programmePharm Educ20181812940
  • NobleCCoombesINissenLShawPNClavarinoAMaking the transition from pharmacy student to pharmacist: Australian interns’ perceptions of professional identity formationInt J Pharm Pract201523429230425363500
  • SchafheutleEIHassellKAshcroftDMHallJHarrisonSHow do pharmacy students learn professionalism?Int J Pharm Pract201220211812822416936
  • BloomTJSmithJDRichWImpact of pre-pharmacy work experience on development of professional identity in student pharmacistsAm J Pharm Educ20178110614129367777
  • WelchBSpoonerJJTanzerKDintznerMRDesign and implementation of a professional development course seriesAm J Pharm Educ20178110639429367778
  • ZaudkeJKPaoloAKleoppelJPhillipsCShraderSThe impact of an interprofessional practice experience on readiness for interprofessional learningFam Med201648537137627159096
  • ZeeniNZeennyRHasbini-DanawiTStudent perceptions towards interprofessional education: findings from a longitudinal study based in a middle Eastern universityJ Interprof Care201630216517427026188
  • ReidRBruceDAllstaffKMcLernonDValidating the readiness for interprofessional learning scale (RIPLS) in the postgraduate context: are health care professionals ready for IPL?Med Educ200640541542216635120
  • ArmstrongLWaiteNRosenthalMSupporting student development through a cooperative education coaching programAsia-Pac J Coop Educ2015164255265
  • BridgesSJProfessional identity development: learning and journeying togetherRes Social Adm Pharm201814329029428363381
  • MantzouraniEHughesMLRole-emerging placements in pharmacy undergraduate education: perceptions of studentsPharm Educ20161618891
  • MylreaMFSen GuptaTGlassBDValidation of a motivation survey tool for pharmacy students: exploring a link to professional identity developmentCurr Pharm Teach Learn20179576376929233302
  • RabowMWRemenRNParmeleeDXInuiTSProfessional formation: extending medicine’s lineage of service into the next centuryAcad Med201085231031720107361
  • BlouinRARiffeeWHRobinsonETRoles of innovation in education deliveryAm J Pharm Educ200973815420221347
  • HoldenMDBuckELukJProfessional identity formationAcad Med201590676176725853688
  • TurnerCShared responsibility for the education of pharmacy studentsAm J Health Syst Pharm201875422322929436468
  • SpeedieMKBaldwinJNCarterRACultivating ‘habits of mind’ in the scholarly pharmacy clinician: report of the 2011-12 Argus CommissionAm J Pharm Educ2012766S3S322919095
  • General Pharmaceutical CouncilFuture pharmacists: standards for the initial education and training of pharmacistsLondon2011 Available from: https://www.pharmacyregulation.org/sites/default/files/document/gphc_future_pharmacists_may_2011.pdfAccessed January 25, 2019
  • WebbTLChangBPIBennY“The Ostrich Problem”: motivated avoidance or rejection of information about goal progressSocial and Personality Compass2013711794807
  • WaldHSProfessional identity (trans)formation in medical education: reflection, relationship, resilienceAcad Med201590670170625881651
  • CharonRNarrative medicine: a model for empathy, reflection, profession, and trustJAMA2001286151897190211597295
  • ClandininDJCaveMTCreating pedagogical spaces for developing doctor professional identityMed Educ200842876577018564095
  • ClandininJCaveMTCaveANarrative reflective practice in medical education for residents: composing shifting identitiesAdv Med Educ Pract201121723745070
  • van HuyssteenMBheekieAThe meaning of being a pharmacist: considering the professional identity development of first-year pharmacy studentsAfr J Health Prof Educ201572208211
  • GoldieJThe formation of professional identity in medical students: considerations for educatorsMed Teach2012349e641e64822905665
  • MgPRockmannKWKaufmannJBConstructing professional identity: the role of work and identity learning cycles in the customization of identity among medical residentsAcad Manag J2006492235262
  • NobleCSlyCCollierLEnhancing feedback literacy in the workplace: a learner-centred approachBillettSNewtonJMRogersGAugmenting Health and Social Care Students’ Clinical Learning Experiences: Outcomes and ProcessesDordrechtSpringer2019