274
Views
14
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review

A review of analgesic and emotive breathing: a multidisciplinary approach

, &
Pages 97-102 | Published online: 29 Feb 2016

Abstract

The diaphragm is the primary muscle involved in breathing and other non-primarily respiratory functions such as the maintenance of correct posture and lumbar and sacroiliac movement. It intervenes to facilitate cleaning of the upper airways through coughing, facilitates the evacuation of the intestines, and promotes the redistribution of the body’s blood. The diaphragm also has the ability to affect the perception of pain and the emotional state of the patient, functions that are the subject of this article. The aim of this article is to gather for the first time, within a single text, information on the nonrespiratory functions of the diaphragm muscle and its analgesic and emotional response functions. It also aims to highlight and reflect on the fact that when the diaphragm is treated manually, a daily occurrence for manual operators, it is not just an area of musculature that is treated but the entire body, including the psyche. This reflection allows for a multidisciplinary approach to the diaphragm and the collaboration of various medical and nonmedical practitioners, with the ultimate goal of regaining or improving the patient’s physical and mental well-being.

Introduction

The diaphragm is the main respiratory muscle that is able to influence, through its contractions, the act of breathing.Citation1 It provides good mechanical function of the spine and sacroiliac joint, as well as affecting the working of the pelvic and buccal floor muscles.Citation1,Citation2 The diaphragm also facilitates the venous and lymphatic return, works to maintain a balanced posture during several changes of the body positions, allowing the viscera above and below the diaphragm to work properly.Citation2Citation5 The diaphragm works together with various processes such as expectoration through coughing and the actions of vomiting, defecation, and swallowing.Citation2,Citation5 The diaphragm muscle plays a key role in health and in the many activities of the human body.

The respiratory diaphragm muscle is innervated by the phrenic nerve (C3–C5) and the vagus nerve (cranial nerve X); the first receives pulses from groups of medullary neurons of the pre-Bötzinger complex and neurons of the parafacial retrotrapezoid complex, which in turn receive orders over retroambiguus from the core of the bulb, although the mechanisms that underlie these links are not completely clear.Citation2 The vagus nerve is part of the parasympathetic autonomous system originating from the spinal oblongata, and terminates at the nucleus ambiguus.Citation6 The phrenic nerve and the vagus nerve anastomose at the neck level.Citation2

The areas of the brain involved in the control of breathing are different and their activation weight changes depending on the type of breathing, metabolic conditions, and interoceptive and exteroceptive information.Citation7Citation10

The aim of this article is to gather for the first time, within a single text, information on the nonrespiratory functions of the diaphragm muscle: its analgesic and emotional response functions. It also aims to highlight and reflect on the fact that when the diaphragm is treated manually, a daily occurrence for manual operators, it is not just an area of musculature that is treated but the entire body, including the psyche. This reflection allows for a multidisciplinary approach to the diaphragm and the collaboration of various medical and nonmedical practitioners, with the ultimate goal of regaining or improving the patient’s physical and mental well-being.

Analgesic respiration

The perception of pain is diminished if the breath is held after a deep breath, a condition in which the diaphragm is lowered.Citation11 This event appears to reflect the involvement of baroreceptors. With this action, the respiratory systolic pressure increases, with a decrease in the cardiac frequency.Citation11 We know that when the baroreceptors situated in the carotid body and the area of the aortic arch in the adventitia of the vessels are naturally stimulated by the cardiac cycle, in particular by the systole, the nociceptive stimulus is attenuated by the activation of the baroreceptors.Citation12

The intervention of the baroreceptors affects the muscle tone, as it decreases the activity of the sympathetic nervous system, reducing the contractile tone.Citation12 The reduction of pain perception is greater if the subject is aware of the pain itself.Citation12 Acute and chronic pain can alter the baroreceptor function and consequently damage the regulatory function of the cardiovascular system; this will lead, in the long run, to an increased risk of morbidity and mortality.Citation13

The baroreceptors are structures that are activated if the vessel is stretched by passing blood.Citation14 The passing afferents are collected by the nucleus of the solitary tract (NTS), which regulates efferential intervention of the vagal system and the inhibitory sympathetic efferent in the spinal cord near the nucleus ambiguus, the dorsal motor nucleus, and the rostral ventrolateral medulla oblongata area.Citation14 Baroceptor afferents affect different areas of the central nervous system, with a generalized inhibitory effect.Citation14 The NTS interconnects with the reticular formation, from which information is sent to the front, lateral, and medial prefrontal insula and the anterior cingulate cortex; even the thalamus, hypothalamus, and periaqueductal gray area receive signals from NTS baroreceptors.Citation14

There is a close relationship between emotion, respiration, and the intervention of baroreceptors.Citation14 Emotional experience influences the response to pain, because the pain response is not simply a neural process started by nociceptive afferents.Citation12 Emotional states, such as anxiety or depression, and psychiatric disorders are able to negatively alter the baroreceptor response.Citation15 Stress can lead to anxiety and/or depression, resulting in an alteration of the proper functioning of the diaphragm.Citation16 Modifications in the emotional state cause a perception of greater pain.Citation17 We can state that the diaphragm has an influence on baroreceptors and the perception of pain and vice versa.

Diaphragm movement changes the body pressure, as it facilitates the venous return and lymphatic flow upward.Citation2 This modulation of pressure influences the redistribution of blood.Citation18 It is this action that probably determines the baroreceptors response and the reduced perception of pain, but there are no scientific texts, as yet, to substantiate this claim.

Recent scientific evidence highlights the ability to carry pain afferents by the vagus nerve, especially for visceral pain. It is generally believed that pain arising from the viscera is mediated exclusively by spinal afferents, because vagal afferents primarily convey interoceptive information, but do not contribute to the perception of pain.Citation19 Studies have shown that vagal afferents respond to nociceptive mechanical and chemical stimulation from the visceral area and this leads to brain stem representation of nociceptive signals.Citation19 We know that the NTS stimulates the vagus nerve. We can assume that a physiological function of the diaphragm muscle can somehow reduce the afferent nociceptive stimulation from the vagus nerve, or through adequate visceral pressure and/or proper functions of the viscera at the lowering of the diaphragm.Citation20 There is no scientific evidence to confirm this reflection at this time.

An incorrect positioning of the diaphragm due to systemic or local pathological reasons, as in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, previous laparoscopic surgery, cerebral ischemia, and somatic problems related to somatic disorders of the lumbar and sacroiliac joint and cervical spine, can be the source problems of pain, both locally and in visceral articulated functions.Citation21Citation28 The causes of induced localized, somatic, or visceral or systemic pain may be varied. There are no studies that correlate these diseases and pain with exhaustive explanations directly related to the actions and functions of the diaphragm muscle. We can assume that the baroreceptors are not adequately stimulated due to an alteration of diaphragm mobility; this will lead to a greater feeling of pain. The same diaphragm can be a source of afferent pain probably because the phrenic nerve, a mixed nerve that carries motor and sensory information, shares information with the trigeminal nucleus spinae.Citation2,Citation29,Citation30 The latter has a connection with the NTS, and there is speculation that this connection is the cause of pain from the diaphragm.Citation31

The diaphragm has a phrenic center, consisting of a strong “V”-shaped connective component having a variable percentage of the amount of contractile tissue.Citation32 The fascial system is richly innervated by proprioceptors, which may become a source of afferent pain, transforming in turn into nociceptors.Citation33 The crural and connective area is populated by proprioceptors, and we can assume that alteration of the position and function of the respiratory muscle creates a condition of irritability of these proprioceptors and consequent occurrence of painful afferents.Citation2 The right phrenic nerve penetrates the diaphragm at the level of the connective tissue of the phrenic center, while the left phrenic nerve penetrates the muscle area of the muscle; the right nerve has a faster electro conductivity than the left.Citation32,Citation34 We might suppose that if the position of the diaphragm is not physiological, the phrenic nerve will be stretched or irritated in different ways, causing nociceptive afferents, in the same way as irritation of a peripheral nerve from the surrounding tissues.Citation35,Citation36

Emotional respiration

The diaphragm has many functions, including maintenance of the systemic biochemical and emotive equilibrium.Citation37 The most important stimulus for the generation of respiration is provided by chemoreceptors that manage the biochemical equilibrium of the organism.Citation37 Breathing is also affected by environmental conditions inside and outside the body, and it is thought to have other ways of neural stimulation in respect of chemoreceptor stimulation.Citation37 The action of the diaphragm is not controlled solely by metabolic demands, but also by emotional states, such as sadness, fear, anxiety, and anger.Citation37 The interaction between respiration and emotion involves a complex interaction between the brain stem and the brain centers such as the limbic area and cortex.Citation37,Citation38 The life of the person and his/her personality influence the behavior of the diaphram.Citation37 The amygdala, which is part of the limbic system, is reciprocally connected to each of the respiratory areas, just as the medulla oblongata, and is considered the most important area that manages emotive breathing.Citation37,Citation39 The amygdala is divided into three areas – the basolateral, cortical, and central areas; the basolateral amygdala sends efferents to the central area, which in direct and indirect mode sends signals to the hypothalamus and the brainstem trunk.Citation39 The amygdala is stimulated by dopamine production from tegmental area of the midbrain, and recent studies on animal models show that the dopamine that reaches the amygdala manages emotive respiration.Citation39 The amygdala efferents pass through the areas connected to respiration, such as the NTS and correlated structures.Citation39

The sensations of breathing are the result of two cortical and subcortical processes: a discriminative process that assesses spatial awareness, timing, and intensity of breath; and an affective process that assesses the emotional feelings of the respiratory components.Citation9

Breathing stimulates the mechanoreceptors of the diaphragm and the visceroceptors of the organs moved by inhalation–exhalation, which constitute the interception mechanism.Citation9,Citation40 The latter constitutes the awareness of the condition of the body based on the information derived directly from the body.Citation40 The ascent and descent of the diaphragm also stimulates the skin and organs of the mediastinum, and the complexity of afferent structures determines the different representations of central respiration.Citation2,Citation41

The afferent pathways of interoception project to the autonomous medulla centers and the brain stem, where they are split into the anterior cingulate cortex and the dorsal posterior insula, thanks to the extension of the thalamus cortical.Citation42 Interoception can modulate the representation of exteroceptive body, as well as the tolerance to pain; dysregulation of the pathways that manage or stimulate interoception could cause a distortion of body image, affecting emotion.Citation42,Citation43

The same anxious state alters afferent pathways related to breathing (receptors that adapt quickly and slowly, type C bronchial and lung receptors, high–threshold-type Aδ receptors, cough receptors, and neuroepithelial receptors), amplifying one or more receptor pathways related to respiration.Citation41 We can strongly assume that an altered function of the diaphragm can adversely affect the patient’s emotional state, probably because the interoceptive pathways stimulated by breathing are managed as motivational information, as these pathways of information are bidirectional.Citation41

The request for challenging breathing, as in a physical exercise, could cause a strong emotional reaction in anxious people, making them relive symptoms and psychological disorders, worsening the respiratory function.Citation41 We know that patients with respiratory ailments or chronic pain suffer from anxiety disorders, and this condition implies that the function of the diaphragm can worsen with physical exertion without taking into account also the emotional aspect of the patient.Citation44,Citation45

Interoception is also linked to the visceral movement caused by respiration, and we know that people more susceptible to visceral afferents show more intense emotions.Citation46 A probable cause could be related to the neurogenic neuroinflammation spreading inflammatory substances in the spinal cord, involving more areas and making them more likely to respond to a minimum of stimuli, making the afferential paths related to interception a further cause for anxiety and pain.Citation46 This event could lead to a pleiotropic effect of functional impairment of the connective tissue, further destabilizing the functioning of the diaphragm.Citation46 This neurogenic neuroinflammation is found in respiratory diseases, such as allergies of the upper airway and chronic diseases (such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease), as well as in conditions of chronic pain.Citation47Citation49 One could speak of “emotional allodynia breathing” when a breath that stimulates interoceptive afferent pathways causes symptoms linked to psychological aspects.

The innervation of the diaphragm muscle may be responsible, directly and indirectly, for the emotional state of the person. Afferent stimulation to the NTS by the phrenic nerve could affect the emotional response, because the NTS handles visceral afferents and has a close relationship with the same nerve.Citation50,Citation51 Confirmation of this assumption is expected. The phrenic nerve has subdiaphragmatic ganglia with a relationship with the adrenal gland.Citation52,Citation53 The significance of this relationship is unknown. But we know that the adrenal gland and the hypothalamus–pituitary axis (HPA) affects the feeling of pain and the intensity of emotional aspects.Citation54,Citation55 The possible existence of a cause–effect on the HPA axis and the direct intervention of the phrenic nerve with the emotional aspect and the intensity of the perceived pain threshold need more studies and research. Further research is expected. The vagus nerve affects the emotional spectrum and respiratory rate, probably always through the NTS. We do not have exhaustive knowledge of whether or not there is also a bidirectional response to emotional conditions by the diaphragm from the vagus nerve.Citation56Citation58

It is undeniable that a respiratory disorder can alter the emotional picture, similar to depression and anxiety, and it is equally true that an altered emotional state worsens the respiratory function.Citation59,Citation60 Considering also the emotional side during manual treatment, such as manual therapy or an osteopathic treatment, would probably be more helpful for the patient.

Conclusion

The diaphragm influences the intensity of the pain and there is an indisputable association with emotions and experience acknowledged by the patient. Every professional such as the doctor, the manual operator, and the psychologist ends their sphere of competence where the other professional’s competence begins. This reflection allows for a multidisciplinary approach to the diaphragm, and collaboration of various medical and nonmedical figures, with the ultimate goal to regain or improve patient’s physical and mental well-being.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

References

  • HarperCJShahgholiLCieslakKHellyerNJStrommenJABoonAJVariability in diaphragm motion during normal breathing, assessed with B-mode ultrasoundJ Orthop Sports Phys Ther2013431292793124175600
  • BordoniBZanierEAnatomic connections of the diaphragm: influence of respiration on the body systemJ Multidiscip Healthc2013628129123940419
  • HamaouiAHudsonALLavioletteLNieratMCDoMCSimilowskiTPostural disturbances resulting from unilateral and bilateral diaphragm contractions: a phrenic nerve stimulation studyJ Appl Physiol (1985)2014117882583225150226
  • BradleyHEsformesJBreathing pattern disorders and functional movementInt J Sports Phys Ther201491283924567853
  • ChaitowLGilbertCMorrisonDRecognizing and Treating Breathing Disorders. A Multidisciplinary ApproachOxford, EnglandChurchill Livingstone2013
  • ShenMJZipesDPRole of the autonomic nervous system in modulating cardiac arrhythmiasCirc Res201411461004102124625726
  • CritchleyHDNicotraAChiesaPASlow breathing and hypoxic challenge: cardiorespiratory consequences and their central neural substratesPLoS One2015105e012708225973923
  • EvansKCDoughertyDDSchmidAMModulation of spontaneous breathing via limbic/paralimbic-bulbar circuitry: an event-related fMRI studyNeuroimage200947396197119450692
  • DavenportPWVovkACortical and subcortical central neural pathways in respiratory sensationsRespir Physiol Neurobiol20091671728618977463
  • KuehnEMuellerKLohmannGSchuetz-BosbachSInteroceptive awareness changes the posterior insula functional connectivity profileBrain Struct Funct Epub 2015 Jan 23
  • Reyes Del PasoGALadrónMuñozde GuevaraCMontoroCIBreath-holding during exhalation as a simple manipulation to reduce pain perceptionPain Med Epub 2015 Apr 30
  • GrayMAMinatiLPaolettiGCritchleyHDBaroreceptor activation attenuates attentional effects on pain-evoked potentialsPain2010151385386120965656
  • NielsenRNikolajsenLKrønerKPre-operative baroreflex sensitivity and efferent cardiac parasympathetic activity are correlated with post-operative painActa Anaesthesiol Scand201559447548525532557
  • Reyes del PasoGAMontoroCMuñóz Ladrón de GuevaraCDuschekSJenningsJRThe effect of baroreceptor stimulation on pain perception depends on the elicitation of the reflex cardiovascular response: evidence of the interplay between the two branches of the baroreceptor systemBiol Psychol2014101829025038302
  • DuschekSWernerNSReyes Del PasoGAThe behavioral impact of baroreflex function: a reviewPsychophysiology201350121183119324033333
  • HagmanCJansonCEmtnerMBreathing retraining–a five-year follow-up of patients with dysfunctional breathingRespir Med201110581153115921454062
  • VietriJOtsuboTMontgomeryWTsujiTHaradaEThe incremental burden of pain in patients with depression: results of a Japanese surveyBMC Psychiatry20151510425947635
  • PetersenLGCarlsenJFNielsenMBDamgaardMSecherNHThe hydrostatic pressure indifference point underestimates orthostatic redistribution of blood in humansJ Appl Physiol (1985)2014116773073524481962
  • ChenSLWuXYCaoZJSubdiaphragmatic vagal afferent nerves modulate visceral painAm J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol20082946G1441G144918420825
  • MortonDCallisterRExercise-related transient abdominal pain (ETAP)Sports Med2015451233525178498
  • PrioriRAlivertiAAlbuquerqueALQuarantaMAlbertPCalverleyPMThe effect of posture on asynchronous chest wall movement in COPDJ Appl Physiol (1985)201311481066107523412901
  • HajGhanbariBGarlandSJRoadJDReidWDPain and physical performance in people with COPDRespir Med2013107111692169923845881
  • Di MassaAAvellaRGentiliCRespiratory dysfunction related to diaphragmatic shoulder pain after abdominal and pelvic laparoscopyMinerva Anestesiol19966251711768937041
  • ParkGYKimSRKimYWDecreased diaphragm excursion in stroke patients with dysphagia as assessed by M-mode sonographyArch Phys Med Rehabil201596111412125234476
  • OhHSeoWA comprehensive review of central post-stroke painPain Manag Nurs201516580481825962545
  • KolarPSulcJKynclMPostural function of the diaphragm in persons with and without chronic low back painJ Orthop Sports Phys Ther201242435236222236541
  • O’SullivanPBBealesDJChanges in pelvic floor and diaphragm kinematics and respiratory patterns in subjects with sacroiliac joint pain following a motor learning intervention: a case seriesMan Ther200712320921816919496
  • YeampattanapornOMekhoraKJalayondejaWWongsathikunJImmediate effects of breathing re-education on respiratory function and range of motion in chronic neck painJ Med Assoc Thai201497suppl 7S55S5925141528
  • BlowsWTDiaphragmatic cramp as a possible cause of noncardiac chest pain and referred mandibular painJ Neurosci Nurs199931318719010846650
  • WolfSGDiaphragmatic spasm: a neglected cause of dyspnoea and chest painIntegr Physiol Behav Sci199429174768018554
  • ManiyarFHSprengerTSchankinCGoadsbyPJThe origin of nausea in migraine-a PET studyJ Headache Pain2014158425471540
  • du PlessisMRamaiDShahSHollandJDTubbsRSLoukasMThe clinical anatomy of the musculotendinous part of the diaphragmSurg Radiol Anat20153791013102025935593
  • BordoniBZanierEClinical and symptomatological reflections: the fascial systemJ Multidiscip Healthc2014740141125258540
  • LuoYMMoxhamJPolkeyMIDiaphragm electromyography using an oesophageal catheter: current conceptsClin Sci (Lond)2008115823324418782085
  • RowePCFontaineKRViolandRLNeuromuscular strain as a contributor to cognitive and other symptoms in chronic fatigue syndrome: hypothesis and conceptual modelFront Physiol2013411523720638
  • RickettTConnellSBastijanicJHegdeSShiRFunctional and mechanical evaluation of nerve stretch injuryJ Med Syst201135578779320703726
  • HommaIMasaokaYBreathing rhythms and emotionsExp Physiol20089391011102118487316
  • MasaokaYIzumizakiMHommaIWhere is the rhythm generator for emotional breathing?Prog Brain Res201420936737724746058
  • SugitaTKanamaruMIizukaMBreathing is affected by dopamine D2-like receptors in the basolateral amygdalaRespir Physiol Neurobiol2015209232725281921
  • DomschkeKStevensSPfleidererBGerlachALInteroceptive sensitivity in anxiety and anxiety disorders: an overview and integration of neurobiological findingsClin Psychol Rev201030111119751958
  • PaulusMPThe breathing conundrum-interoceptive sensitivity and anxietyDepress Anxiety201330431532023468141
  • TsayAAllenTJProskeUGiummarraMJSensing the body in chronic pain: a review of psychophysical studies implicating altered body representationNeurosci Biobehav Rev20155222123225783221
  • GarfinkelSNCritchleyHDInteroception, emotion and brain: new insights link internal physiology to social behaviour. Commentary on: “Anterior insular cortex mediates bodily sensibility and social anxiety” by Terasawa et al. (2012)Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci20138323123423482658
  • ParreiraVFKirkwoodRNTownsMIs there an association between symptoms of anxiety and depression and quality of life in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease?Can Respir J2015221374125379656
  • BairMJWuJDamushTMSutherlandJMKroenkeKAssociation of depression and anxiety alone and in combination with chronic musculoskeletal pain in primary care patientsPsychosom Med200870889089718799425
  • SinibaldiLUrsiniGCastoriMPsychopathological manifestations of joint hypermobility and joint hypermobility syndrome/Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, hypermobility type: the link between connective tissue and psychological distress revisedAm J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet2015169C19710625821094
  • PisiGOlivieriDChettaAThe airway neurogenic inflammation: clinical and pharmacological implicationsInflamm Allergy Drug Targets20098317618119601877
  • ShahJPThakerNHeimurJAredoJVSikdarSGerberLMyofascial trigger points then and now: a historical and scientific perspectivePM R20157774676125724849
  • VermaVSheikhZAhmedASNociception and role of immune system in painActa Neurol Belg2014115321322025547878
  • ZoccalDBFuruyaWIBassiMColombariDSColombariEThe nucleus of the solitary tract and the coordination of respiratory and sympathetic activitiesFront Physiol2014523825009507
  • LiuSXWeiSJZhouDBFanYLEffects of microinjection of sodium glutamate and glycine into ventrolateral nucleus of tractus solitarius on the discharges of phrenic nerve in rabbitsSheng Li Xue Bao19974922272299812862
  • RusuMCConsiderations on the phrenic gangliaAnn Anat20061881859216447917
  • TubbsRSStetlerWKellyDRImmunohistochemical study of the phrenic ganglionAnat Sci Int200883315916118956788
  • HoyerJBurmannIKieselerMLMenstrual cycle phase modulates emotional conflict processing in women with and without premenstrual syndrome (PMS)–a pilot studyPLoS One201384e5978023637739
  • LacourtTEHoutveenJHDoornenLJBiological and psychological predictors of visceral pain sensitivity in healthy premenopausal womenEur J Pain201418456757424027228
  • WangZLüWQinRRespiratory sinus arrhythmia is associated with trait positive affect and positive emotional expressivityBiol Psychol201393119019623274836
  • KlarerMArnoldMGüntherLWinterCLanghansWMeyerUGut vagal afferents differentially modulate innate anxiety and learned fearJ Neurosci201434217067707624849343
  • FrazierTWStraussMESteinhauerSRRespiratory sinus arrhythmia as an index of emotional response in young adultsPsychophysiology2004411758314693002
  • von LeupoldtAChanPYEsserRWDavenportPWEmotions and neural processing of respiratory sensations investigated with respiratory-related evoked potentialsPsychosom Med201375324425223460722
  • GoodwinRDSchecknerBPenaLFeldmanJMTahaFLipsitzJDA 10-year prospective study of respiratory disease and depression and anxiety in adulthoodAnn Allergy Asthma Immunol2014113556557025216970