Abstract
Objectives:
The purpose of this study was to investigate the physicians’ perceptions, and expectations of their experiences with the pharmacists at Hamad Medical Corporation (HMC) in Qatar.
Method:
A cross-sectional study was conducted at HMC between January and March 2006 using a validated questionnaire. The self-administered questionnaire was distributed to 500 physicians who were working at HMC comprising Hamad General Hospital, Women’s Hospital, Rumaila Hospital, Al-Amal Hospital, Al Khor Hospital, and primary health centers. The questionnaire was composed of four parts, investigating the physicians’ expectations, experiences, and perceptions of the pharmacists.
Results:
A total of 205 questionnaires were completed (response rate 41%). A total of 183 physicians (89%) expected the pharmacist to educate patients about safe and appropriate use of drugs, whereas 118 (57%) expected the pharmacist to be available for health-care team consultation during bedside rounds. The indices of physicians showing how comfortable they were with pharmacists, and their expectations of pharmacists, were 61% and 65%, respectively, whereas the index on experience of physicians with pharmacists was lower (15%).
Conclusions:
Physicians were comfortable with pharmacists and had high expectations of pharmacists in performing their duties. However, physicians reported a poor experience with pharmacists, who infrequently informed them about the effectiveness of alternative drugs, patients experiencing problems with prescribed medications, and who took personal responsibility to resolve any drug-related problem.
Introduction
Hepler and Strand defined pharmaceutical care as the responsible provision of drug therapy for the purpose of achieving definite outcomes that improve the patients’ quality of life by preventing and resolving drug-related problems.Citation1 Improving the quality of a patient’s life is the primary objective of every health organization in the world. Pharmacists play a vital role in achieving this goal. Diagnosis and prescribing medication to patients is the role of the physicians and compounding and dispensing medication was the pharmacist’s role.Citation2 The function of the pharmacist has now changed, and they play a direct role in patients’ care.Citation2,Citation3 A better interaction between physicians and pharmacists has led to safer, more effective, and less costly drug therapies.Citation4,Citation5 Several studies on pharmacist–physician collaborations have proven that direct patient care is still exclusively in the hands of the physician and that pharmacist input in managing drug therapy is dependent on the physician.Citation6–Citation12 Volume et alCitation3 have advocated pharmaceutical care to increase patients’ satisfaction with pharmacist’s activities, which may increase patients’ expectation that pharmacists will work on their behalf to assist them with their health care needs.
Aims and objectives
While much is known about physician–pharmacist interactions, little information has been published in the Middle East region, and there are no reports originating from Qatar. Accordingly, this study was conducted to determine physicians’ perceptions and expectations of their experience with hospital pharmacists, involvement in direct patient care. This study will evaluate physicians comfort, expectations, and experience with pharmacists in a Middle Eastern hospital setting.
Materials and methods
A cross-sectional study was conducted at Hamad Medical Corporation (HMC) in Qatar during January and March 2006. The questionnaire used was developed by Smith et al and validated in California.Citation13 The data collected using this questionnaire included respondent characteristics, perceptions, expectations, and experience of physicians with pharmacists at HMC. Demographic information including age, gender, nationality, place of work, current position, current area of practice, country where qualification was obtained, year of qualification obtained, and interaction with pharmacists, including the purpose, was collected.
HMC comprises five public hospitals (Hamad General Hospital [HGH], Women’s Hospital [WH], Rumaila Hospital [RH], Al-Amal Hospital [AAH], and Al Khor Hospital [AKH]) and 21 public primary health centers (PHCs). A total of 500 questionnaires were distributed to the physician offices of all public hospitals and PHCs in Qatar. Administrative assistants were requested to distribute the questionnaires to all the physicians who agreed to participate in the study during the week. The completed questionnaires were retrieved from the respective offices/centers by the administrative assistants.
Levels of comfort were self-reported as uncomfortable, moderately comfortable, and comfortable for each item and were numerically coded as −1, 1, and 2, respectively, for calculating the comfort index by adding all items for each individual. Items on expectation and experience were self-reported on a five-point Likert scale (strongly disagree, disagree, neutral, agree, and strongly agree) and numerically coded as −2, −1, 0, 1, and 2, respectively, to calculate the index on the expectations and experience of physicians with pharmacists to show the overall impact of all the items on their expectations and experiences.
Descriptive statistics were calculated for all the variables included in the study. The SPSS statistical package (version 14.0; SPSS, Chicago, IL) was used to analyze the results. Student’s t-test was applied to obtain the significant difference in mean level of indices between gender and nationality. A P value <0.05 (two-tailed) was considered as statistically significant.
Results
Out of the 500 questionnaires distributed, 205 (41.0%) were reported by the end of the study. The mean age of the physicians was 43 years (range 36–50 years). The ratio of male to female was 3:1 and 82.0% were non-Qatari. Details of their current position, area of work, and year of qualification are given in . Generally, physicians interacted once a day with pharmacists to discuss drug availability.
Table 1 Description of physicians’ demographic information and interaction with pharmacists
Physicians’ comfort with pharmacists is shown in . They were very comfortable with pharmacists providing patient education (89%), suggesting use of nonprescribed medications (75%), designing and monitoring pharmacotherapeutic regimens (81%), and monitoring outcomes of pharmacotherapeutic regimens and plans, whereas pharmacists were comfortable suggesting use of prescription medication to physicians (62%) and detecting and preventing prescription errors (67%). Physicians’ comfort was found to be below average when pharmacists suggested use of certain prescription medications to patients (44%) and treated any minor illnesses (49%).
Table 2 Physicians’ comfort with pharmacists
Physician expectations of pharmacists are explained in . In general, physicians had high expectations of pharmacists as being the drug-therapy experts, providing education on safe and appropriate use of medications (89%), and knowing the specific indication of each drug even if the drug has more than one approved or recognized indication (66%). Lower expectations were reported on personal responsibility for resolving drug-related problems (48%) and monitoring drug therapy given to patients (50%), whereas moderately good expectations were reported on availability of pharmacists during consultation with patients (57%). Physicians reported the lowest agreement on pharmacists designing drug therapy (44%) and assisting patients in selecting appropriate nonprescription medications (36%).
Table 3 Physicians’ expectations of pharmacists
reveals experience of physicians with pharmacists. Physicians believed that pharmacists were a reliable source of general drug information (68%) and for routinely informing physicians if they discovered clinical problems with prescriptions (67%). Physicians reported the lowest agreement for pharmacists informing patients about cost-effective alternatives of the prescribed drug (32%) and providing clarification about the drug therapy (ie, pharmacists frequently let physicians know about patients if a patient has some problem with the given medication) (27%). Physicians also did not agree on pharmacists being responsible for resolving any drug-related problem (22%). Physicians were neutral toward pharmacists counseling patients on safe and appropriate use of their medications (35%).
Table 4 Experience of physicians with pharmacists
Indices on comfort, expectations, and experience of physicians with pharmacists are described in . It also shows that comfort and expectations of physicians were higher than average in carrying out their duties and felt that pharmacists should play a role in patients’ education, suggesting nonprescribed medications, detecting and preventing prescription error, as well as designing and monitoring pharmacotherapeutic plans, but physician expectations were not the same as their experience. There was no statistical difference in all the indices according to gender (P > 0.05) and nationality (P > 0.05).
Table 5 Description of comfort, expectation, and experience indices of physicians with pharmacists
Discussion
In the past few years, efforts worldwide have increasingly turned into extending the role of the pharmacists beyond the dispensary and into a more active role of dealing with patients’ drug-related problems.Citation14 This study described physicians’ comfort with pharmacists being involved in patient education, the use of nonprescribed medications, detecting and preventing prescription errors, and designing and monitoring pharmacotherapeutic plans, which have been similarly explored in a study done in Kuwait in 2005.Citation15
More than half of the physicians’ in our sample (55%) were uncomfortable with pharmacists prescribing and almost half of the participants (48%) were uncomfortable with pharmacists treating minor illnesses in our study. Similar results on treating minor illness were shown in other studies.Citation15–Citation17 A possible explanation for this finding is that general practitioners mostly believe that pharmacists do not have sufficient medical training to be able to correctly interpret a diagnosis or to participate in the clinical decision process.Citation18–Citation21 Fewer physicians in Jordan were reluctant to allow pharmacists to treat minor illnesses (34%),Citation22 which shows an increase in this trend in our study.
Most physicians in the study expected pharmacists to be an expert in drug therapy and act as an educator for the safe and appropriate use of medications. This is promising in the light of the evolving ‘extended roles’ of the pharmacist and the emergence of concepts like pharmaceutical care and good pharmacy practice. These include educating, monitoring, and caring for patients in collaboration with other health care professionals. Accordingly, pharmacists will be required to provide high-quality drug information, which leads to an increase for the need for reliable, accurate, trustworthy, and up-to-date information.Citation23
More physicians were comfortable or moderately comfortable with pharmacists designing drug therapy and assisting patients in selecting appropriate nonprescription medications than those who were not. This is reassuring, considering the increasing number of medicines that have been and are being deregulated to over-the-counter status worldwide, which would help in reducing costs as well as physicians’ time.Citation24–Citation26 Moreover, this deregulation is also believed to be a step forward to strengthen the advisory role of the community pharmacist.
Physicians’ experience with pharmacists providing more clinical services, such as informing physicians about more cost-effective alternatives, problems their patients are experiencing with their medications, or providing clarification of drug-therapy objectives, was poor, which indicates that pharmacists need to be trained differently to be able to provide such services. The curricula in universities from which Qatar pharmacists graduate need to be reviewed and modified toward pharmaceutical care in order to graduate more patient-oriented pharmacists. We share this study with the College of Pharmacy, Qatar University, and with the Pharmacy Technician Program, College of the North Atlantic-Qatar. There is a need for Qatar pharmacists to work more closely with physicians, thereby providing the physician with an opportunity to observe pharmacists performing clinical responsibility, which builds the physicians’ confidence in the pharmacists.
Conclusion
Physicians working with pharmacists have developed a collaborative approach to health care, but a lot of improvement is still required. Physicians show good comfort and expectations of pharmacists in performing their duties, but this expectation was not met by their experiences. However, greater effort needs to be directed toward increasing the awareness of physicians about the importance of collaboration among health care professionals and what benefits can be reflected from this on patient quality of life and health care.
Limitations
Less than one-half of potential respondents were included in the data, which therefore does not reflect the actual experiences of physicians and pharmacists in the hospitals. Private hospitals were not included in the study. A large study is warranted to extrapolate and generalize the results. We also need to investigate pharmacists’ experiences and expectations of physicians to cover both parts of the relationship.
Acknowledgements
This study was conducted under the guidance of Medical Research Centre (MRC). We thank MRC for providing funds, clearing ethical issues, and valuable guidance in working out this project. The authors acknowledge Dr Saad Al Kaabi, Medical Director, HMC, Dr Abd Al Latif Al Khal, Director of Medical Education, HMC, Dr Mariam Abd Al Malik, Chief of Staff, Primary Health Care for their kind support, Dr Peter Jewesson, Dean, College of Pharmacy, Qatar University for reviewing this manuscript, Ms Banan Al Arab, Secretary, Internal Medicine and Ms Sanaa Al Fadel, Secretary, Pharmacy Department, Al Amal Hospital for distributing and collecting the surveys. The authors would also like to acknowledge and appreciate all physicians who participated in this study.
Disclosure
The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.
References
- HeplerCDStrandLMOpportunities and responsibilities in pharmaceutical careAm J Hosp Pharm19904735335432316538
- JonesEJMackinnonNJTsuyukiRTPharmaceutical care in community pharmacies: practice and research in CanadaAnn Pharmacother20053991527153316014374
- VolumeCIFarrisKBKassamRCoxCECaveAPharmaceutical care research and education project: patient outcomesJ Am Pharm Assoc (Wash)200141341142011372906
- MartinSIn the physician’s office: an interview with W. Ray BurnsAm Pharm.1989NS291217192596392
- FortnerCBuilding cooperation with physicians: an interview with Charles Fortner. Interview by Joyce Leinberger MitchellAm Pharm.1990NS30224262305670
- MorelyAJepsonMHEdwardsCStillmanPWhat do doctors think of pharmacists treating minor ailments?Pharm J1983231387388
- GrussingPGGoffDAKrausDMMuellerCEDevelopment and validation of an instrument to measure physicians’ attitudes toward the clinical pharmacist’s roleDrug Intell Clin Pharm1984187–86356406745093
- GriffinJFMore physician–pharmacist cooperation neededN Engl J Med19863151710973762626
- NesbitFChaplinDCEdwardsJAJrCounseling of patients by pharmacists. Blessing or curse?N C Med J19955621151187898587
- BradshawSJDoucetteWRCommunity pharmacists as patient advocates: physician attitudesJ Am Pharm Assoc (Wash)19983855986029782693
- RanelliPLBissJPhysicians’ perceptions of communication with and responsibilities of pharmacistsJ Am Pharm Assoc (Wash)200040562563011029843
- CowenDLChanging relationship between pharmacists and physiciansAm J Hosp Pharm19924911271527211471635
- SmithWERayMDShannonDMPhysicians’ expectations of pharmacistsAm J Health Syst Pharm20025915557
- FarrisKBFernandez-LlimosFBenrimojSIPharmaceutical care in community pharmacies: practice and research from around the worldAnn Pharmacother20053991539154116014373
- MatoweLAbahussainEAAl-SaffarNBihzadSMAl-ForaihAAl-KanderyAAPhysicians’ perceptions and expectations of pharmacists’ professional duties in government hospitals in KuwaitMed Princ Pract200615318518916651833
- SpencerJAEdwardsCPharmacy beyond the dispensary: general practitioners’ viewBMJ19923046843167016721633521
- RitcheyFJRaneyMREffect of exposure on physicians’ attitudes toward clinical pharmacistsAm J Hosp Pharm19813810145914637294036
- HardingGTaylorKMProfessional relationships between general practitioners and pharmacists in health centresBr J Gen Pract1990403404644662271280
- EllisBCDoveySMCollinsDMTilyardMWClarkDWGeneral practitioners’ views on the role of the community pharmacistN Z Med J19921059434034051461595
- EdmundsJCalnanMWThe reprofessionalisation of community pharmacy? An exploration of attitudes to extended roles for community pharmacists amongst pharmacists and general practioners in the United KingdomSoc Sci Med200153794395511522139
- MuijrersPEKnottnerusJASijbrandijJJanknegtRGrolRPChanging relationships: attitudes and opinions of general practitioners and pharmacists regarding the role of the community pharmacistPharm World Sci200325523524114584231
- TahainehLMWazaifyMAlbsoul-YounesAKhaderYZaidanMPerceptions, experiences, and expectations of physicians in hospital settings in Jordan regarding the role of the pharmacistRes Social Adm Pharm200951637019285290
- WiedenmayerKSummersRSMackleCAGousAGSEverardMTrompDDeveloping Pharmacy Practice: A Focus on Patient CareGeneva (Switzerland)World Health Organization2006
- BatesIThe supply and consumption of over-the-counter medicinesTaylorKHardingGPharmacy PracticeLondon, UKTaylor & Francis2001139145
- BondCPOM to P – implications for practice pharmacistsPrim Care Pharm2001257
- British Medical AssociationThe Misuse of DrugsAmsterdam, The NetherlandsHarwood Academic Publishers1997