Abstract
Noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), such as obesity and type 2 diabetes mellitus, are a growing public health challenge in Australia, accounting for a significant and increasing cost to the health care system. Management of these chronic conditions is aided by interprofessional practice, but models of care require updating to incorporate the latest evidence-based practice. Increasing research evidence reports the benefits of physical activity and exercise on health status and the risk of inactivity to chronic disease development, yet physical activity advice is often the least comprehensive component of care. An essential but as yet underutilized player in NCD prevention and management is the “accredited exercise physiologist,” a specialist in the delivery of clinical exercise prescriptions for the prevention or management of chronic and complex conditions. In this article, the existing role of accredited exercise physiologists in interprofessional practice is examined, and an extension of their role proposed in primary health care settings.
Introduction
Noncommunicable chronic disease (NCD) is a global health crisis, with physical inactivity a leading behavioral risk factor common to obesity, type 2 diabetes mellitus, cardiovascular disease, and metabolic syndrome.Citation1–Citation4 Obesity has reached epidemic levels in Australia, with approximately 60% of the adult population overweight or obese.Citation5 Management of NCD is a growing public health challenge, with Australian primary health care systems designed to deliver acute, symptom-driven care, while chronic disease management is arguably more resource intensive. Australian primary health care involves four main types of services and providers: 1) general practice, 2) community health services, 3) private allied health providers, and 4) indigenous community-controlled health services. General practice is the predominant provider of primary health care, with general practitioners essentially the gatekeepers to a range of other health services. However, an effective framework for lifestyle modification and collaborative interdisciplinary care in primary health settings for chronic disease management is lacking.Citation6,Citation7
For example, a significant practice gap exists in the delivery, maintenance, and follow-up of patients for whom lifestyle modification has been prescribed.Citation8 General practitioners may provide excellent advice on physical activity and dietary changes, but are less likely to provide tailored exercise or ongoing support given a lack of time, understanding of the physiological and metabolic responses to exercise, or understanding of patients’ readiness to change behaviors.Citation9 Lifestyle intervention is underemphasized in the undergraduate training of general practitioners and other health professionals, as are interprofessional practice and collaboration.Citation9,Citation10 Increasingly, the demands placed on physicians’ time and a lack of training in the area may limit their ability to effectively counsel patients on the benefits of exercise and comprehensive lifestyle risk-factor modification.Citation3,Citation6
The burgeoning evidence base for both the benefits of physical activity for health and physical inactivity as a risk factor for NCDsCitation11–Citation13 underpins support for the revision of NCD models of care. Clinical programs should have a greater emphasis on lifestyle modification incorporating “Exercise is Medicine” principles,Citation14 as physical activity and exercise have traditionally been coupled with other public health agendas and often not fully recognized as a stand-alone, public health priority.Citation2 The introduction of “accredited exercise physiologists” (AEPs) – specialists in exercise interventions and physical activity education – into primary health care settings has the potential to greatly enhance existing health care delivery. This can be achieved through interprofessional practice, referring to a clinician whose role is exclusively in physical activity and exercise prescription to ensure tailored and appropriate advice, and creating a focus on behavior change as the core component of all clinical programs for both the prevention and management of NCD.Citation15
The value of the interdisciplinary team
Numerous benefits of interdisciplinary teams in primary health care settings have been cited, including increased learning and development of health care professions, better utilization of resources and improved cost-effectiveness, and improved self-management and health outcomes for patients.Citation10,Citation16 Interdisciplinary team care, which advocates lifestyle modification for chronic disease and supports high levels of self-efficacy and self-management in patient cohorts, has been associated with higher levels of treatment compliance and improved health outcomes.Citation7,Citation17,Citation18
To a certain extent, interdisciplinary teams are a result of increasing levels of specialization, although while individuals of the team may be specialists, the overall knowledge is broader and interprofessional collaboration is stronger.Citation16 Care provided by interdisciplinary teams is becoming increasingly complex and often challenging, necessarily requiring the application of a specialized body of knowledge.Citation8 Unfortunately, physical activity and exercise advice provided in standard care practice is often the least comprehensive component of care. Currently, no single clinician is dedicated to providing exercise, physical activity, and health education,Citation8 and recommendations made to patients are based on the National Physical Activity Guidelines for Australians,Citation19 which outline the minimum levels of physical activity required to gain a health benefit. Provision of these guidelines needs to be expanded to provide more comprehensive, tailored recommendations to individuals who may be suffering from complex conditions and/or injuries to support behavior change.Citation15
Although evidence for effective interventions is lacking in the literature, lifestyle modification programs, with individualized counseling and exercise prescription, have been successful in South Africa, Canada, and the UK.Citation9,Citation18,Citation20 Small-scale exercise referral schemes have also been successful in both the UK for sedentary individuals with chronic conditionsCitation20 and in Australia with the Healthy Eating Activity and Lifestyle (HEAL™) program.Citation21 Participants in the HEAL program have successfully achieved weight reduction, improvements in blood pressure and physical fitness parameters, and importantly, have maintained behavior change as measured by a 5-month post-program follow-up.Citation21
Exercise physiologists (AEPs)
AEPs are allied health professionals who specialize in the prescription of clinical exercise interventions for patients at high risk of developing, or with existing, chronic and complex medical conditions and/or injuries.Citation22 This emerging exercise physiology discipline has adopted the global initiative “Exercise is Medicine,” founded by the American College of Sports Medicine, and endorsed by professional bodies and practicing clinicians across many countries including Australia, South Africa, Canada, the USA, Germany, New Zealand, and the UK.Citation22,Citation23 The aims of AEP interventions are to prevent or manage chronic disease or injury, and assist in restoring optimal physical function, health, and wellness.Citation22 The scope of responsibilities for the AEP includes diagnostic and functional testing, exercise prescription, exercise supervision, patient counseling, education, and outcomes analysis. In addition, AEPs may address barriers to maintaining exercise compliance, including psychosocial factors, family or job responsibilities, orthopedic or musculoskeletal limitations, or other deterrents to regular exercise.Citation3
Exercise physiologists are currently widely employed in cardiac rehabilitation programs, but increasing opportunities exist in chronic disease management, including weight management, osteoporosis, pre-diabetes and type 2 diabetes mellitus management, and cancer rehabilitation.Citation8 Cardiac rehabilitation programs designed and facilitated by exercise physiologists have been highly successful in changing exercise and physical activity behaviors; preventing or delaying subsequent cardiac arrest; improving exercise tolerance, muscle atrophy, and circulation; improving quality of life; and significantly reducing risk factors for comorbidities in this patient population.Citation3,Citation12 This established model of care is transferrable to other areas of rehabilitative health and is hypothesized to produce the same health benefits.
The Exercise is Medicine initiative aims to raise the profile of exercise physiology and incorporate physical activity and exercise as standard components of a disease prevention and treatment paradigm in Australia, improving community health and reducing long-term health care costs.Citation23 More information about AEPs and Exercise is Medicine can be found at http://exerciseismedicine.org.au/ and http://www.essa.org.au (accessed November 27, 2013).
Conclusion
Extensive evidence exists with respect to growing levels of obesity and associated NCDs such as heart disease and diabetes and the positive effect of physical activity on the prevention and management of these conditions.Citation15,Citation24,Citation25 Equally, significant evidence is emerging with respect to the value of an interprofessional approach in the prevention and management of NCDs.Citation10 A small but growing body of evidence also exists indicating the positive impact of the addition of AEPs to interprofessional practice, which supports exercise physiology as an invaluable but currently underutilized discipline and essential resource in interventions designed to combat all chronic and noncommunicable diseases, not restricted to coronary heart disease.Citation3,Citation8,Citation26 Opportunity also exists for further research in this area of NCD prevention and management and Exercise is Medicine. The potential for exercise physiology to add measurable value in interventions designed to combat chronic and noncommunicable diseases is significant, and opportunities exists for AEPs to contribute to current chronic disease management in Australian primary health care settings.
Disclosure
The authors declare no conflicts of interest in this work.
References
- LeeIMShiromaEJLobeloFPuskaPBlairSNKatzmarzykPTLancet Physical Activity Series Working GroupEffect of physical inactivity on major non-communicable diseases worldwide: an analysis of burden of disease and life expectancyLancet2012380983821922922818936
- KohlHW3rdCraigCLLambertEVLancet Physical Activity Series Working GroupThe pandemic of physical inactivity: global action for public healthLancet2012380983829430522818941
- FranklinBFernAFowlerASpringTDejongAExercise physiologist’s role in clinical practiceBr J Sports Med2009432939819050005
- BoothFWRobertsCKLayeMJLack of exercise is a major cause of chronic diseasesCompr Physiol2012221143121123798298
- Australian Bureau of StatisticsAustralian Health Survey: First Results, 2011–12CanberraAustralian Government2012 Avaliable from http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/[email protected]/Latestproducts/4364.0.55.001Main%20Features12011-12?opendocument&tabname=Summary&prodno=4364.0.55.001&issue=2011-12&num=&view=Accessed November 12, 2013
- ABSAustralian health survey: first results, 2011–2012ABoStatisticsCanberra2012
- EggerGJBinnsAFRossnerSRThe emergence of “lifestyle medicine” as a structured approach for management of chronic diseaseMed J Aust2009190314314519203313
- WagnerEHAustinBTDavisCHindmarshMSchaeferJBonomiAImproving chronic illness care: translating evidence into actionHealth Aff (Millwood)2001206647811816692
- MathesonGOKlüglMDvorakJResponsibility of sport and exercise medicine in preventing and managing chronic disease: applying our knowledge and skill is overdueBr J Sports Med201145161272128221948123
- DermanEWPatelDNNosselCJSchwellnusMPHealthy lifestyle interventions in general practice: Part 1: An introduction to lifestyle and diseases of lifestyleS Afr Fam Pract2008504612
- DaviesGPPerkinsDMcDonaldJWilliamsAIntegrated primary health care in AustraliaInt J Integr Care20099e9519956377
- DixonJBThe effect of obesity on health outcomesMol Cell Endocrinol2010316210410819628019
- GiannuzziPMezzaniASanerHWorking Group on Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise PhysiologyEuropean Society of Cardiology. Physical activity for primary and secondary prevention. Position paper of the Working Group on Cardiac Rehabilitation and Exercise Physiology of the European Society of CardiologyEur J Cardiovasc Prev Rehabil200310531932714663293
- KatzmarzykPLearSAPhysical activity for obese individuals: a systematic review of effects on chronic disease risk factorsObes Rev20121329510521951422
- SallisREExercise is medicine and physicians need to prescribe it!Br J Sports Med20094313418971243
- MathesonGOKlüglMEngebretsenLPrevention and management of non-communicable disease: the IOC consensus statement, Lausanne 2013Br J Sports Med201347161003101124115479
- CashmanSBReidyPCodyKLemayCADeveloping and measuring progress toward collaborative, integrated, interdisciplinary health care teamsJ Interprof Care200418218319615203676
- JordanJEBriggsAMBrandCAOsborneRHEnhancing patient engagement in chronic disease self-management support initiatives in Australia: the need for an integrated approachMed J Aust2008189Suppl 10S9S1319143585
- FortierMSHoggWO’SullivanTLImpact of integrating a physical activity counsellor into the primary health care team: physical activity and health outcomes of the Physical Activity Counselling randomized controlled trialAppl Physiol Nutr Metab201136450351421848444
- Department of Health and Aged CareNational Physical Activity Guidelines for AdultsCanberraAustralian Government1999
- WilliamsNH“The wise, for cure, on exercise depend”: physical activity interventions in primary care in WalesBr J Sports Med200943210610818669546
- HetheringtonSBorodziczJHEAL™: Helping participants achieve significant health improvementsSydneySouth Western Sydney Medicare Local Ltd (SWSML) & Exercise and Sport Science Australia2013 Available from: http://www.essa.org.au/wp/wp-content/uploads/HEAL_research_article_June_2013.pdfAccessed January 15, 2014
- Exercise and Sports Science Australia (ESSA)AEP Scope of PracticeBrisbaneESSA2010 Available from: http://www.essa.org.au/wp/wp-content/uploads/AEP-Scope-of-Practice-v2-14.03.2011.pdfAccessed November 27, 2013
- American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM), ESSAExercise is Medicine® Australia Strategic Plan 2011–2013ACSM, ESSA2011 Available from: http://exerciseismedicine.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/Exercise-Is-Medicine-Aus-Strategic-Plan.pdfAccessed November 27, 2013
- WarburtonDENicolCWBredinSSHealth benefits of physical activity: the evidenceCMAJ2006174680180916534088
- MilesLPhysical activity and healthNutr Bull2007324314363
- EhrmanJKGordonPMVisichPSKeteyianSJClinical Exercise PhysiologyChampaign, ILHuman Kinetics2003