83
Views
22
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Research

Increasing dependency of older people in nursing homes is associated with need for dental treatments

, , &
Pages 2285-2290 | Published online: 02 Dec 2014

Abstract

To determine relationships between the need for dental treatments of institutionalized elderly people and cognitive impairment and the general level of care needed. Two hundred and sixty-eight residents of long-term care facilities in Germany were included in this study. Age, sex, diseases, number of frequently taken drugs, and location of the long-term care facility of the participants were recorded. For each participant, the need for care was assessed by use of the Barthel index (BI). Cognitive impairment was evaluated by use of the mini-mental state examination (MMSE). To assess dental treatment needs, the revised oral assessment guide (ROAG) was applied for different oral health conditions, which were rated “healthy” or “treatment needed”. Spearman correlations were performed to evaluate associations between BI and MMSE and dental treatment needs. Statistical analysis revealed significant associations of BI (P<0.001) and MMSE (P=0.015) with the ROAG score. Increasing dependency and decreasing cognitive ability worsen oral health and increase the need for dental treatment.

Introduction

The proportion of people 65 years and older among the German population has increased from 14.9% in 1990 to ~21% in recent years, and aging of the population is a long-term trend.Citation1 Consequently, these demographic changes have led to a larger number of elderly people in need of care. Today, of the 2.5 million Germans needing care, 743,000 are living in long-term care facilities.Citation2 Research has often revealed poor oral hygiene and oral health among elderly people in long-term care. In particular, high prevalence of periodontal diseases, ill-fitting dentures, and root caries have been reported by several authors.Citation3Citation6 The evidence suggests not only that oral health has a substantial effect on chewing function and therefore, nutrition,Citation7,Citation8 but also that it can affect general health. Multiple associations have been found between poor oral health and systemic diseases.Citation9Citation11 It has been reported that periodontal diseases are associated with a greater risk of cardiac infarction and strokeCitation9Citation11 and diminished oral hygiene is linked to pneumonia.Citation12 Little has been reported in the literature about the circumstances leading to worsening of the oral health of elderly people, however. In general, elderly people are a very heterogeneous group with a variety of cognitive and functional impairments.Citation8,Citation13Citation15 It has been pointed out that the decline in oral health is associated with increasing cognitive impairment caused by the onset of dementia.Citation8,Citation13Citation15 It has been stated that the likelihood of deterioration of oral health is also linked to caregivers’ lack of knowledge of very complex dental treatment (eg, implant-supported dentures).Citation16,Citation17 Moreover, estimation of the specific and changing needs of elderly people challenges caregivers who have to deal with many different tasks, for example washing, dressing, toileting, feeding, documenting care, and coordinating physicians’ visits.Citation17 Another reason for the many oral problems of aged people is the limited use of dental care services by residents of long-term care facilities,Citation18Citation20 which is associated with such general barriers as cost, education, family members’ lack of awareness of the need for dental services, transportation difficulties, and self-perceived need for oral care.Citation18Citation20 Apart from these considerations, however, few investigations of community-dwelling elderly people found associations between dependency and oral health and/or dental treatment needs.Citation8,Citation15 It has been shown that senior citizens who require a high level of care and who cannot function completely independently have fewer of their own teeth, no dentures, and suffer more frequently from dysphagia.Citation8 One study of an institutionalized elderly community affirmed this relationship. Worse oral hygiene and more caries have been reported among those in need of care.Citation21 Nevertheless, as far as the authors are aware, there has been no systematic investigation of associations between the level of care needed and/or cognitive ability and the overall dental treatment needs of elderly people in long-term care facilities. The purpose of this study was, therefore, to evaluate relationships between demographic variables, cognitive ability, and the general level of care needed, as measured by use of the Barthel index (BI), with the dental treatment needs and/or oral health of institutionalized elderly people.

Materials and methods

Study population

This study was approved by the local review board of the University of Heidelberg (approval number S-002/2012). It was performed in 13 long-term care facilities in southwestern Germany, in seven urban and six rural locations selected as representative of the state of Baden-Württemberg by the Ministry of Social Affairs (see Acknowledgments). All residents received written study information by mail. An event was also held to inform all residents and their caregivers about the study. No specific exclusion criteria were formulated, it was only required that participants signed a consent form. If the residents did not have the capacity to give consent, their legal guardians decided on their behalf. Two hundred and sixty-eight individuals agreed to participate and were included in the study.

Assessment tools

Age, sex, number of diseases, and frequently used drugs were obtained from the medical records of each participant.

Dental treatment needs

All dental examinations were conducted by two dentists experienced in epidemiologic surveys. Dental treatment needs were assessed by use of the revised oral assessment guide (ROAG),Citation22,Citation23 a standardized tool for evaluation of oral health that includes assessment of voice, lips, mucous membranes, gums, cleanliness of teeth and/or dentures, saliva, swallowing, caries, and the fitting, retention, and condition of dentures (12 items). The ROAG is also validated for use by physicians and caregivers.Citation22,Citation23 Each aspect of the oral health conditions is rated as healthy, to be monitored, or needs treatment. In previous studies, this three-point scale was used to monitor oral health to enable timely detection and treatment of oral shortcomings as they arose.Citation23Citation25 In this study, ROAG scores were divided into healthy and to be monitored (0) and dental treatment required (1). The total ROAG score could therefore range from 0 to 12. Prior to the beginning of the study the two examiners (see above) were calibrated in the use of ROAG by applying it to elderly patients attending the Department of Prosthodontics. To determine reliability, inter-examiner agreement between the two examiners was evaluated. Thirty of the participants were randomly selected and independently examined by use of the ROAG. Cronbach’s alpha was calculated for the raters and found to be 0.945.

Level of care needed

To assess the level of care needed, the BI was used.Citation26 This instrument, which was created for evaluation of the functional capacity of elderly communities,Citation27 is widely used in studies of epidemiology.Citation8,Citation15 The BI rates dependence in the activities of daily life from 0 to 100, where 0 is indicative of total dependence and 100 of total independence. In this study, the BI was determined on the basis of the usual categorization in accordance with cut-offs described in a previous study.Citation28 The BI was determined by the participants’ caregivers, as suggested in a previous study.Citation29

Cognitive impairment

For evaluation of participants’ cognitive impairment, the mini-mental state examination (MMSE) was conducted by four psychologists (see Acknowledgments). Before and during the study, the psychologists were trained by investigating psychiatric patients attending the memory clinic of the University of Heidelberg. Further assessment of reliability was not performed. The MMSE has, however, proved valid for the detection of cognitive impairment and is also widely used clinically as part of routine dementia screening.Citation30 In previous studies investigating correlations with oral health,Citation14,Citation15 the continuous or categorized MMSE was primarily used, even though other methods are available for screening of cognitive state, eg, the Global Deterioration Scale.Citation31 We also, therefore, decided to use the MMSE to enable comparison of data. The MMSE is conducted by asking participants to solve 30 tasks within the categories: orientation, registration, attention, calculation, recall, and language. Correctly performed exercises are rated with 1 point, whereas the score for failure is 0. Participants can therefore obtain scores ranging from 0 to 30, with high scores being indicative of healthy subjects.Citation30

Statistical evaluation

Data from case record forms were entered in two databases by two operators and checked for agreement. For descriptive purposes, frequencies, means (standard deviation [SD]), or medians (25%/75% quartiles) were plotted for age, sex, diseases, number of frequently taken drugs, location of the long-term care facility, and ROAG, MMSE, and BI scores, where appropriate. Because the ROAG score was found to violate the assumption of normal distribution (Kolmogorov–Smirnov test; P=0.001), nonparametric statistics were used (Spearman correlation, U-test, and Kruskal–Wallis test). The number of dental treatments required for different cut-off values was also studied: BI: 0–50 (severe dependency), 51–75 (moderate dependency), and 76–100 (mild or no impairment).Citation28 The level for local statistical significance was set at P<0.05. Because of the explorative nature of the study, no correction of alpha was performed. All statistical analysis was performed by use of SPSS (v19.0; IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY, USA).

Results

None of the included participants missed the investigations and was lost to statistical analysis. Thus, complete data for 268 participants (70.5% female) were available for statistical analysis. The mean age of the participants was 83.1 years (SD 9.1; range 51–102). The mean number of own teeth was 6.8 (SD 8.3) and 60.1% of the participants had their own teeth. Members of the study population had a mean of 3.4 diseases (SD 2.3) and were taking a mean of 6.6 (SD 3.5) permanent medications. Of the participants, 60.8% lived in urban long-term care facilities and 92.9% had at least one oral health condition in need of treatment. The median number of dental conditions requiring treatment, as measured by use of the ROAG, was 2.0 (25%/75% quartile 2.0/3.0). The median ROAG score for female participants was 2.0 (25%/75% quartile 2.0/3.0); for males it was 2.0 (2.0/4.0). For participants living in urban long-term care homes, the median ROAG was 2.0 (25%/75% quartile 2.0/3.0); for those living in rural long-term care homes, it was 3.0 (2.0/4.0). The mean MMSE (SD) among the participants was 17.3 (8.1); the mean BI (SD) was 46.9 (30.3). More details are given in .

Table 1 Characteristics of the sample and statistical correlation with ROAG score (n=268)

Age (P=0.673), sex (P=0.617), diseases (P=0.650), medications (P=0.944), and location of the long-term care facility (P=0.421) had no significant effect on ROAG score. Statistical analysis revealed significant associations of BI (Spearman correlation −0.241; P<0.001) and MMSE (Spearman correlation −0.178; P=0.015) with ROAG score ().

In the different BI categories, median (25%/75% quartile) ROAG scores were 3.0 (2.0/4.0) for participants with severe dependency (BI <50), 2.0 (2.0/3.0) for those with moderate dependency (BI 51–70), and 2.0 (1.0/3.0) for those with no to mild dependency (BI >70). ROAG scores were significantly different in the three categories (P=0.001). Detailed results are presented in .

Table 2 Median ROAG scores (25%/75% quartile) in the different BI categories (n=268)

Comparison of the BI scores for single items of the ROAG for participants who required dental treatment showed that median BI was significantly lower for participants in need of treatment for the voice, lips, tongue, gums, saliva, and caries (P<0.05; ).

Table 3 Median (25%/75% quartile) BI for the single items of ROAG (n=268)

Discussion

The results of this study suggest that participants’ greater need of care and decreasing cognitive ability are significantly associated with increased dental treatment needs. This is in accordance with previous findings among noninstitutionalized elderly people.Citation8,Citation13Citation15 Intercorrelation of care dependency and cognitive state were also revealed by a study of institutionalized elderly people.Citation21 However, to the knowledge of the authors, this is the first study that systematically evaluated a wide spectrum of oral issues by use of a screening instrument also applicable for nondental professionals. The study found worse oral hygiene and more caries among participants with diminished functional and cognitive capacity than among healthy subjects. Nevertheless, in this recent study, specific oral problems associated with mucous membranes, fitting, retention, and condition of dentures, and oral and/or denture hygiene occurred irrespective of the level of dependency. This might be because of general barriers to oral health provision among institutionalized elderly people, for example cost, education, lack of awareness of family members of the need to use dental services, and transport difficulties.Citation18Citation20 Another reason could be reduced self-perceived need for oral care.Citation18Citation20 Deterioration can, moreover, also occur as a result of caregivers’ inadequate knowledge about specific dental needs. Oral problems might also deteriorate as a result of caregivers’ lack of time, because they must deal with many other tasks, and oral conditions frequently have no priority.Citation17 In this context, it should be pointed out that these participants had a median of two oral health conditions that required treatment, and perfect oral health was observed for 7.1% only. This is in agreement with results from other studies that reported a variety of oral shortcomings among institutionalized elderly people.Citation3Citation6 Nevertheless, this study identified functional capacity as a variable predicting additional oral problems, and therefore, treatment needs. Severe dependency (BI <50), especially, seemed to be linked to several oral problems. Old people with their own teeth also suffer from higher prevalence of caries and such gum diseases as gingivitis and periodontitis. This is relevant because many aged people now have more of their own teeth remaining than in previous decades.Citation32 One might also expect systemic diseases to have a substantial effect on dental treatment needs. It has been stressed that elderly people suffering from multiple comorbidities accept their declining oral health as a part of aging, and therefore, as an unrecoverable condition.Citation18,Citation33 Further, some more or less asymptomatic oral problems (ie, periodontitis) seem, subjectively, to be irrelevant, or elderly people cope with them,Citation34,Citation35 whereas others substantially affect quality of life.Citation36 It should, however, be emphasised that ~90% of the participants in this study had at least one disease. Nonetheless, the levels of care needed identified for the single dental treatment needs as measured by ROAG allow a prediction of seniors’ dependency levels at which they are especially prone to specific oral diseases.

Furthermore, no difference was detected between participants’ dental treatment needs in rural and urban long-term care homes. In one study that investigated the association of living in a rural or urban long-term care home with oral health, the authors showed that urban location of the long-term care home is a predictor of use of dentures by edentulous elderly people.Citation20 This might be related to uneven distribution of dentists throughout urban and rural areas of Germany, although this was not confirmed by our study.

Another point worth discussing is use of the ROAG for oral examinations. The ROAG has three relevant advantages over other instruments. First, it covers a wide range of important aspects of oral health; second, it is validated for use by non-dentists, which gives physicians and caregivers – who often have more frequent contact with old people than dentists – the opportunity to estimate dental treatment needs; and, third, applying the ROAG is very quick (~10 minutes).Citation22,Citation23 Nevertheless, although the ROAG is an instrument recommended for screening oral conditions in elderly people, it has its limitations. The ROAG covers some shortcomings of oral health (ie, pathologies concerning lips, voice, saliva) that were fortunately not highly prevalent in this specific study community. Subsequently, these items show a rather unbalanced ratio of “treatment needed” and “no treatment needed” groups, which could have led to statistical bias. Nevertheless, participants with pathologic findings in these categories consistently showed high levels of care dependency. This is as expected,Citation8 and underlines the accuracy of the instrument. Nonetheless, a more specific instrument may have resulted in a more specific outcome, but might have also yielded an underestimation of relevant but less frequent pathologies. To this end, to the knowledge of the authors, currently no other standardized assessment tool exists that would be more specific for the community evaluated in this study.

Study limitations

It should be borne in mind that participants were not preselected, and therefore, 16 participants were younger than 65 years and should, strictly speaking, not be classified as old persons. Because they lived in a long-term care home and needed care, it seemed valuable to include results for these participants in this paper, as also discussed by Dolan and Atchison.Citation18

Conclusion

Within its limitations, this study found the need for oral treatment was very common among institutionalized old people. Increasing dependency and decreasing cognitive ability lead to diminished oral health and many dental treatment needs. Intensive monitoring of oral health among the most dependent elderly population is therefore recommended to enable recognition and treatment of oral problems at an early stage.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank all the participants in this study for their patience. We are grateful to the participating nursing homes for their kind support, to the Ministry of Social Affairs of Baden-Württemberg (Sozialministerium Baden-Württemberg) for funding the study, and to Ian Davies, copy editor, for English language revision.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

References

  • EurostatDemography report 2010. Older, more numerous and diverse EuropeansLuxembourgPublications Office of the European Union2011 Available from: http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/cache/ITY_OFFPUB/KE-ET-10-001/EN/KE-ET-10-001-EN.PDFAccessed September 24, 2014
  • Statistisches BundesamtPflegestatistik. Pflege im Rahmen der Pflegeversicherung: DeutschlandergebnisseWiesbadenStatistisches Bundesamt2011 German
  • McMillanASWongMCLoECAllenPFThe impact of oral disease among the institutionalized and non-institutionalized elderly in Hong KongJ Oral Rehabil2003301465412485383
  • MontalSTraminiPTriayJAValcarcelJOral hygiene and the need for treatment of the dependent institutionalized elderlyGerodontology2006232677216677178
  • ChalmersJMCarterKDSpencerAJCaries incidence and increments in Adelaide nursing home residentsSpec Care Dentist20052529610515856916
  • OffenbacherSBarrosSPSingerREMossKWilliamsRCBeckJDPeriodontal disease at the biofilm-gingival interfaceJ Periodontol200778101911192518062113
  • BradburyJThomasonJMJepsonNJPerceived chewing ability and intake of fruit and vegetablesJ Dent Res200887872072518650541
  • FurutaMKomiya-NonakaMAkifusaSInterrelationship of oral health status, swallowing function, nutritional status, and cognitive ability with activities of daily living in Japanese elderly people receiving home care services due to physical disabilitiesCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol201341217318122934613
  • BeckJGarciaRHeissGVokonasPSOffenbacherSPeriodontal disease and cardiovascular diseaseJ Periodontol199667Suppl 10112312378910831
  • PussinenPJAlfthanGRissanenHReunanenAAsikainenSKnektPAntibodies to periodontal pathogens and stroke riskStroke20043592020202315232116
  • DörferCEBecherHZieglerCMThe association of gingivitis and periodontitis with ischemic strokeJ Clin Periodontol200431539640115086623
  • TerpenningMSTaylorGWLopatinDEKerrCKDominguezBLLoescheWJAspiration pneumonia: dental and oral risk factors in an older veteran populationJ Am Geriatr Soc200149555756311380747
  • ShipJAPuckettSALongitudinal study on oral health in subjects with Alzheimer’s diseaseJ Am Geriatr Soc199442157638277117
  • ChalmersJMCarterKDSpencerAJCaries incidence and increments in community-living older adults with and without dementiaGerodontology2002192809412542217
  • PurandareNWoodsEButlerSDental health of community-living older people attending secondary healthcare: a cross-sectional comparison between those with and without diagnosed mental illnessInt Psychogeriatr201022341742520003632
  • SaundersRHJrImplant or bridge for older adults: some additional thoughtsSpec Care Dentist2007271517388222
  • AdamsRQualified nurses lack adequate knowledge related to oral health, resulting in inadequate oral care of patients on medical wardsJ Adv Nurs19992435525608876416
  • DolanTAAtchisonKAImplications of access, utilization, and need for oral health care by the non-institutionalized and institutionalized elderly on the dental delivery systemJ Dent Educ199357128768878263235
  • DolanTAAtchisonKHuynhTNAccess to dental care among older adults in the United StatesJ Dent Educ200569996197416141082
  • MatthewsDCClovisJBBrillantMGOral health status of long-term care residents-a vulnerable populationJ Can Dent Assoc201278c322364866
  • ZuluagaDJFerreiraJMontoyaJAWillumsenTOral health in institutionalised elderly people in Oslo, Norway and its relationship with dependence and cognitive impairmentGerodontology2012292e420e42621564272
  • AnderssonPHallbergIRRenvertSInter-rater reliability of an oral assessment guide for elderly patients residing in a rehabilitation wardSpec Care Dentist200222518118612580356
  • HasselAJLeisenJRolkoCRexrothWOhlmannBRammelsbergPClinical assessment of oral health between physician and dentist – a pilot study on inter-examiner reliabilityZ Gerontol Geriatr2008412132138 German18327698
  • HanneKIngeliseTLindaCUlrichPPOral status and the need for oral health care among patients hospitalised with acute medical conditionsJ Clin Nurs20122119–202851285922905928
  • RibeiroMTFerreiraRCVargasAMe FerreiraEFValidity and reproducibility of the revised oral assessment guide applied by community health workersGerodontology201431210111023294324
  • MahoneyFIBarthelDWFunctional evaluation: the Barthel indexMd State Med J1965141616514258950
  • WadeDTCollinCThe Barthel ADL Index: a standard measure of physical disability?Int Disabil Stud198810264673042746
  • SupervíaAArandaDMárquezMAAguirreASkafEGutiérrezJPredicting length of hospitalisation of elderly patients, using the Barthel IndexAge Ageing200837333934218339617
  • CollinCWadeDTDaviesSHorneVThe Barthel ADL Index: a reliability studyInt Disabil Stud198810261633403500
  • FolsteinMFFolsteinSEMcHughPR“Mini-mental state”. A practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinicianJ Psychiatr Res19751231891981202204
  • ReisbergBFerrisSHde LeonMJCrookTThe Global Deterioration Scale for assessment of primary degenerative dementiaAm J Psychiatry19821399113611397114305
  • MichaelisWSchiffnerUVierte Deutsche Mundgesundheitsstudie IV, Institut der deutschen ZahnärzteCologneDeutscher Ärzte-Verlag2006 German
  • Castrejón-PérezRCBorges-YáñezSAGutiérrez-RobledoLMAvila-FunesJAOral health conditions and frailty in Mexican community-dwelling elderly: a cross sectional analysisBMC Public Health20121277322971075
  • LockerDGibsonBDiscrepancies between self-ratings of and satisfaction with oral health in two older adult populationsCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol200533428028816008635
  • PiuvezamGde LimaKCSelf-perceived oral health status in institutionalized elderly in BrazilArch Gerontol Geriatr201255151121621283
  • JohnMTKoepsellTDHujoelPMigliorettiDLLeRescheLMicheelisWDemographic factors, denture status and oral health-related quality of lifeCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol200432212513215061861