147
Views
4
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review

Animal models of contraception: utility and limitations

, &
Pages 27-35 | Published online: 17 Apr 2015

Abstract

Appropriate animal modeling is vital for the successful development of novel contraceptive devices. Advances in reproductive biology have identified novel pathways for contraceptive intervention. Here we review species-specific anatomic and physiologic considerations impacting preclinical contraceptive testing, including efficacy testing, mechanistic studies, device design, and modeling off-target effects. Emphasis is placed on the use of nonhuman primate models in contraceptive device development.

Introduction

There is an urgent need for investment in preclinical development of novel contraceptive methods. Despite an increase in the variety of available contraceptive products, nearly half of pregnancies in the USA are unplanned.Citation1 Unintended pregnancy is associated with significant public health consequences, including increased risk of low infant birth weight, preterm delivery, and maternal depression.Citation2 Contraceptive choice and effective use is associated with a wide range of variables, including but not limited to, socioeconomic characteristics,Citation3 childbearing goals,Citation4 and method-specific experiences or attitudes.Citation5 This variability suggests that increased contraceptive choice may improve usage and compliance; however, newly marketed contraceptive products are often variations in the dose and delivery method of well-established steroidogenic products.Citation6

Barriers to development of novel contraceptives have been multidimensional, including regulatory and corporate limitations.Citation7 One difficulty originates from the unique character of newer contraceptives, which combines aspects of pharmaceuticals, biologics, and devices in a single medical product. Therefore, development and optimization of these products includes not only evaluation of pharmacokinetics, toxicology, efficacy, and mechanisms of action, but must also consider device design and user acceptability. These aspects can be challenging to interrogate, but their successful preclinical modeling increases the likelihood of success in human clinical trials.

In this review, we draw on examples of contraceptive modeling in multiple species to illustrate how challenges to preclinical development have recently been addressed. We begin with a brief discussion of the utility of rodent and nonhuman primate species for discovery of novel contraceptive targets, as well as means by which contraceptive efficacy is evaluated in preclinical models. We move on to discuss species-specific anatomic and physiologic considerations impacting evaluation of contraceptive device design and mechanism of action. Finally, we review models used for characterization of extra-contraceptive effects. Emphasis is placed on nonhuman primate models for contraceptive device development. Normative reproductive values for species used in contraceptive modeling are summarized in .

Table 1 Comparison of normative reproductive values in species used for contraceptive modeling

Contraceptive discovery

Characterization of processes underlying folliculogenesis, ovulation, luteal maintenance, and implantation in animal models has facilitated identification of potential pathways for contraceptive intervention and assisted reproductive technologies.Citation8 In order to achieve a contraceptive effect with minimal side effects, the expression and function of these targets should be unique to the reproductive tract or pathway. Ideally, an event occurring near fertilization is targeted in order to avoid affecting early gametogenesis.Citation7

Rodent models are well suited for in vivo contraceptive target discovery. The availability of advanced genetic engineering technologies, such as CRISPR/Cas systems,Citation9 as well as resources for comprehensive phenotypic analysisCitation10 of genetically engineered mice facilitate discovery of fertility and contraceptive targets.Citation11 These targets fall across the hypothalamic–pituitary–gonadal axis and include a number of reproductive modulatory strategies, including vaccines, receptor antagonists, and hormonal analogs. Immunocontraceptive targets include zona pellucida glycoproteins,Citation12 spermatic antigens,Citation13 or hormones such as gonadotropin-releasing hormone or human chorionic gonadotropin.Citation14 Receptor-level modulation has been attempted at endometrial targets necessary for receptivity and decidualization, such as tissue-specific serine proteases,Citation15,Citation16 follicle-stimulating hormone,Citation17,Citation18 prostaglandin E2,Citation19 and progesterone receptors.Citation20

Due to similarities with human reproductive anatomy and physiology, contraceptive target discovery also occurs in nonhuman primate species. For example, mRNA expression of eight proteases was upregulated 12 hours post-ovulation in rhesus macaques subjected to an ovulatory stimulation protocol. Moreover, direct follicular injection of a metalloproteinase inhibitor prior to ovulation was associated with inhibition of follicular rupture.Citation21 Similarly, pre-ovulatory gonadotropin surges potentiate phosphodiesterase 3A-mediated oocyte maturation.Citation22 Treatment of female macaques with a phosphodiesterase inhibitor was associated with a reduced rate of pregnancy in one preclinical trial.Citation23 Antagonism of endometrial targets necessary for implantation, such as leukemia inhibitory factorCitation24 or vascular endothelial growth factor,Citation25 has also undergone proof of concept testing. Development of compounds with antagonistic or modulatory activity at the progesterone receptor (antiprogestins, progesterone receptor modulators) has been evaluated in nonhuman primates as well as rodents. Parenteral administration of an antiprogestin is associated with reversible suppression of menstruation in artificially cycled rhesus macaques.Citation26 Similarly, intrauterine delivery of two antiprogestins, ulipristal acetateCitation27 and Schering ZK 230 211,Citation28 has been evaluated in ovariectomized, artificially cycled rhesus and stump-tailed macaques, respectively. In both cases, endometrial atrophy and amenorrhea were associated with intrauterine administration of a range of doses.

Contraceptive efficacy

Preclinical evaluation of contraceptive efficacy presents many challenges to the investigator. When selecting a model species, differences in reproductive physiology should be taken into consideration. Rodent ovarian follicular dynamics differ from those of monovulatory nonhuman primates in several important ways, including follicular size, number of follicles released, and hormonal control of ovulation and luteal maintenance.Citation29 A post-copulatory prolactin surge is required for luteal development in rodents, while a mid-cycle luteinizing hormone (LH) surge is sufficient amongst primates.Citation30 Old World monkey species, such as macaques and baboons, exhibit pituitary release of LH and gonadal LH receptor morphology that closely resembles that observed in humans. Conversely, New World monkey species, such as marmosets and squirrel monkeys, release chorionic gonadotropin from the pituitary and express a modified form of the gonadal LH receptor.Citation31

Prospective evaluation of contraceptive efficacy is difficult in women. In Phase I and Phase II clinical trials, markers of reduced fertility, such as ovulatory or spermatogenesis rates, are utilized in place of pregnancy.Citation7 The use of pregnancy as an endpoint is a significant advantage in animal modeling of contraceptives. For example, Peluffo et al evaluated a prostaglandin E2 receptor 2 antagonist in a contraceptive trial with cynomolgus macaques.Citation19 Following pretrial treatment, group-housed females were introduced to a single male. Pregnancy was detected via serum progesterone and macaque chorionic gonadotropin levels and viability was confirmed with abdominal ultrasound. Pregnancies were terminated prior to 32 days’ gestation with parenteral mifepristone or intrafetal methotrexate.Citation32 Thirty-eight percent of macaques receiving the prostaglandin E2 receptor 2 antagonist became pregnant in comparison with 80% in the vehicle-treated control group. In rodents, quantitative evaluation of contraceptive efficacy is easily determined by comparison of implantation rates in control and experimental uterine horns at necropsy. However, when evaluating preclinical contraceptive efficacy in rodents, investigators and regulatory bodies must define acceptable levels of reduction in gestational rates in these polyovulatory species.

In addition to use of pregnancy as an endpoint, animal modeling permits standardization of ovarian cyclicity. Ovarian cycle length can be synchronized through provision of exogenous hormone in ovariectomized macaques. This is typically performed in seasonally anovulatory species, such as rhesus macaques. In this protocol, animals are implanted with a subcutaneous capsule of estradiol for 14 days. A capsule containing progesterone is added from days 14–28, and then removed to stimulate menstruation. This protocol has been successfully used to synchronize and control ovarian cycle variability in a cohort of macaques prior to a contraceptive trial.Citation28 Disadvantages include potential impacts of exogenous progesterone, such as vaginal epithelial thinning and differences in background hormonal milieu, between ovariectomized and intact animals, as Old World primate species have a large circulating pool of adrenal-origin androgen.Citation29

Where collection of preovulatory follicles for in vitro analysis is of interest, a controlled ovarian stimulation protocol has been described for the rhesus and cynomolgus macaque.Citation19,Citation33 In these protocols, injection of human chorionic gonadotropin is followed by a course of recombinant human follicle-stimulating hormone, a gonadotropin-releasing hormone antagonist for prevention of endogenous gonadotropic surge, and finally a single preoperative dose of recombinant LH to promote follicular maturation without rupture. This protocol facilitates progressive development of a dominant follicle, but replaces endogenous LH with exogenous human chorionic gonadotropin in order to control the timing of ovulation.Citation30

Where exogenous control of ovarian cycle is not desired, cycle monitoring is often still critical to the study of contraceptive efficacy. In rodents, the ovarian cycle is noninvasively monitored through cyclical changes in vaginal cytology.Citation34 In Old World monkey species with menses, swabs of the vaginal anterior fornix can be examined for the presence of blood or sperm when animals are being bred. Alternatively, the external genitalia can be visually examined. In baboons, menses may be difficult to visualize. Rather, perineal skin tumescence is reliably used as a visual proxy for the ovarian cycle.Citation35 External observations may be complemented by fecal, urine, or serum hormonal assays in most nonhuman primate species.Citation36Citation38

Contraceptive device design

Due to their similarity to human reproductive anatomy and physiology, nonhuman primates are advantageous for late-stage preclinical evaluation of both contraceptive design and efficacy. Preclinical safety and feasibility is generally evaluated in rodents and rabbits. These species are advantageous due to the presence of dual uterine horns, a short ovarian cycle, and reduced cost relative to nonhuman primates, although challenges with device scale and differences in reproductive physiology may limit the translational value. Model characteristics are summarized for each contraceptive device in . For the purposes of this discussion, contraceptive devices will refer to both hormonal and nonhormonal intrauterine devices (IUDs), intravaginal rings, transdermal patches, and subcutaneous implants. Nonhormonal barrier methods such as condoms or diaphragms will not be discussed.

Table 2 Comparison of animal models of contraceptive devices

Intrauterine devices

Intrauterine contraception currently available to consumers in the USA includes two levonorgestrel intrauterine systems (LNG-IUS) and a copper IUD, the T380A (Paragard®; Teva Pharmaceuticals, Petah Tivka, Israel). Available LNG-IUS systems include Mirena® (32×32 mm; 20 µg of LNG released per 24 hours; Bayer Healthcare Pharmaceuticals, Wayne, NJ, USA) and Skyla® (28×28 mm; 14 µg per 24 hours; Bayer Healthcare Pharmaceuticals).Citation39 Intrauterine contraception is associated with an excellent contraceptive efficacy rate, comparable with that of tubal ligation, and requires less reliance on user compliance than other contraceptive methods.Citation40 In some women, the LNG-IUS also confers noncontraceptive benefits such as amenorrhea.Citation41

Larger species of nonhuman primate such as the baboon have a uterine lumen size that can accommodate human-use IUDs. An LNG-IUS (Mirena®) can be transcervically deployed in the baboon uterus. In ex vivo and in vivo evaluation of LNG-IUS placement in three baboons, magnetic resonance imaging and transabdominal ultrasound indicated successful uterine fundic deployment of the IUS.Citation42 Successful implementation of a human-use copper IUD has been described in pigtail macaques. The GyneFix-200 mini® (Contrel Research, Ghent, Belgium) is a copper IUD consisting of four 5×2.2 mm cylinders on a suture. Devices were placed via hysterotomy and maintained for 3 months.Citation43

As suggested by the aforementioned studies, species differences in cervical anatomy affect whether devices can be deployed transcervically or require hysterotomy for placement. Unlike the baboon, which has a relatively straight cervical canal,Citation42 the cervix of most macaque species is sigmoidal, making transcervical deployment of IUDs impractical.Citation44 The necessity for IUD placement via hysterotomy and use of retention sutures may incite a local inflammatory response that can impact interpretation of data on toxicity and contraceptive efficacy. Interestingly, a recent study reports successful transcervical delivery of polidocanol foam in the rhesus macaque.Citation45 Atraumatic cervical cannulation was achieved with ultrasonographic or laparoscopic-guided placement of a series of cannulas used for gradual cervical dilation. This technique was not successful with all animals, however, and requires significant technical expertise. Similarly, nonsurgical transcervical cannulation in the rabbit has been reported,Citation46 although not in the context of intrauterine system placement. The ability to atraumatically cannulate the rabbit cervix may increase its utility as an animal model for IUD development.

Modification of the IUD shape and size is typically required for smaller species. A straight silicone elastomer (“silastic”) rod or a single silk, nylon, or copper filamentCitation47 has been utilized as an experimental alternative in smaller nonhuman primates and nonprimate animal models of intrauterine contraception. This type of device can be successfully implemented in many species, including rodents, with modifications easily made for individual variations in uterine size. Tubes can also be loaded with different pharmaceutical agents. For example, in one study that sought to evaluate the impact of an antiprogestin-releasing IUD in stump-tailed macaques, a 12 mm silastic tube was used to deliver one of three compounds with antiprogestin activity.Citation28 Tubes were placed in the uterine body lumen via hysterotomy and migration prevented with a myometrial stay suture. Successful deployment of similar rod-shaped devices of lengths ranging from 10 mm to 15 mm are reported in other nonhuman primate studies.Citation27 A filamentous IUD model has been well established in mice, rats, and guinea pigs.Citation48Citation50 In these models, a single length of silk or other monofilament suture is placed transcervically within a single uterine horn. The contralateral horn is used as a control. Other devices successfully deployed via hysterotomy in rodents include copper or silicone rodsCitation51Citation53 and metal or silicone coils.Citation54 Successful placement of IUDs from 5 mm to 35 mm in length are described in these studies. While the rod or filament IUDs offer flexibility with regard to scale and compound delivery, they do not necessarily mimic the biomechanical properties of larger IUDs.

This variability in size and type of device tested in preclinical studies has impacted our understanding of the contraceptive mechanism of action of the IUD. In both humans and animals, the mechanism of action is likely multimodal, occurring through alterations in the cervical mucous plug, endometrial receptivity, and germ cell or embryonic viability.Citation55 It is important to understand the contraceptive mechanism of action of the IUD, as it may impact user acceptability in light of patient preference for avoidance of post-fertilization effects.Citation56 In mice and rats, embryonic destruction within the uterine lumen is correlated with the presence of luminal polymorphonuclear leukocytes in the presence of a filamentous or copper IUD.Citation57,Citation58 In women, evidence suggests that pre-fertilization destruction of oocytes or sperm may be the more common contraceptive mechanism, particularly with the copper IUD.Citation55,Citation59,Citation60 However, study of pre-fertilization events is difficult to perform noninvasively in women, and conclusions have been drawn from relatively small sample sizes. Therefore, it would be advantageous to prospectively evaluate the mechanism of action of the IUD in an animal model. However differences in IUD size and placement, as well as species-specific differences in reproductive physiology, have been difficult to overcome.

Intravaginal rings

An intravaginal ring (IVR) releasing etonogestrel and ethinyl estradiol (NuvaRing®; Merck and Co, Whitehouse Station, NJ, USA) is currently approved for contraceptive use in the USA. IVRs offer an appealing means of drug delivery. Transmucosal vaginal drug delivery results in good bioavailability and comparable pharmacodynamic effects, without the side effects associated with oral administration.Citation61 Moreover, IVRs offer a coitally independent means of drug delivery that is associated with high levels of user acceptability.Citation61 Most preclinical studies of IVRs have been performed in macaque species and sheep.Citation62Citation66

Recently, significant efforts towards development of combined contraceptive and microbicide delivery via IVR have resulted in a renewed interest in preclinical testing of vaginal ring models.Citation62 Scaling of IVR size, stiffness, and surface area can present translational challenges. Promadej-Lanier et al tested three different IVR sizes in pigtail and rhesus macaques, and in both species, a 25 mm circumferential and 5 mm cross-sectional diameter silicone ring was associated with minimal induction of proinflammatory cytokines in the lower reproductive tract.Citation63 Additionally, no visual evidence of irritation or inflammation was noted on colposcopic evaluation, although the smaller ring was significantly stiffer than commercially available models. This model of ring has since been used in several studies evaluating IVR delivery of antiretroviral agents in both pigtailed and cynomolgus macaques.Citation64Citation66 These studies report acceptable levels of ring retention, although one noted that on necropsy 28 days post-placement, 25×5 mm rings were located mid-vagina in the smaller cynomolgus macaque.Citation66 Subsequent trials with a 20×4.5 mm ring were associated with successful pericervical retention.

Differences in scale and vaginal pH also present challenges to interpretation of pharmacokinetic data. For example, in vivo IVR delivery of the microbicide dapirivine was evaluated in the cynomolgus macaque.Citation66 Vaginal fluid concentrations of dapirivine were significantly lower than those reported from previous human clinical trials. The macaque vagina is more basic (pH 7) than that of the human (pH 4). The more basic vaginal environment may result in differences in drug protonation and consequent pharmacodynamic properties. Furthermore, the larger human IVR has a correspondingly greater surface area for drug delivery than the smaller macaque ring. It should also be noted that differences in vaginal epithelial morphology exist even between the different macaque species. For example, the vaginal epithelium of the rhesus macaque is more keratinized than that of humans or pigtail macaques.Citation67 Care should therefore be taken when extrapolating the pharmacokinetics of vaginally delivered topical drugs between species.

The sheep is a potential preclinical alternative to the nonhuman primate for evaluation of IVRs. Advantages of the sheep model include a body mass and cervicovaginal canal size similar to women. Visual and histologic evaluation of the reproductive tract may be performed with ease. The sheep vagina is lined by stratified squamous epithelium, and although the vaginal submucosa is thinner than in humans,Citation68 the vaginal epithelium of the sheep does not undergo pronounced histologic changes coincident with the estrous cycle, as is observed in the rodent.Citation69 Disadvantages of the sheep model include a seasonal estrous cycle and a paucity of data on reproductive tract mucosal immunology. As a result of the sheep’s larger size, human-sized IVRs can be tested without the scaling issues previously discussed. For example, the pharmacokinetic and toxicologic properties of a hydrophilic polyurethane IVR loaded with tenofovir were evaluated in sheep.Citation70 A 55×5.5 mm ring was used, which is comparable to the size of the NuvaRing (54×4 mm). These rings were maintained for 90 days, with only one case of expulsion.

Transdermal and subdermal delivery systems

Transdermal delivery systems include patches, gels, and sprays. A single transdermal patch is currently on the US market for sustained delivery of ethinyl estradiol and norelgestromin (Ortho Evra®; Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Beerse, Belgium). A 68 mg etonogestrel subdermal implant (Nexplanon®; Merck and Co) is also approved for use.

Transdermal drug absorption is affected by numerous variables, including species and drug characteristics. Amongst laboratory animal species, the pig, macaque, and rabbit are the most frequently utilized for study of topical drug applications.Citation71 Porcine ear skin is frequently used in vitro for early preclinical validation of percutaneous drug permeation.Citation72 Percutaneous absorption rates for testosterone and hydrocortisone as well nitroaromatic compounds is similar in vivo in rhesus macaques and humans.Citation71 In a study examining transdermal patch formulations of levonorgestrel and 17 beta-estradiol, good correlation was found between in vivo pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic data in rabbits and the results of Phase I clinical trials in women.Citation73 However, in percutaneous absorption studies of other hormonal compounds such as testosterone, data from rabbits is not predictive of human values.Citation71 Study of subdermal drug delivery is less impacted by heterogeneity of skin morphology than transdermal formulations; however, as with oral drug delivery, it is subject to species differences in drug distribution and metabolism. A comprehensive discussion of preclinical evaluation of injectable or oral contraceptives is beyond the scope of this review, so we direct the reader to an excellent review by Andersson et al for a more detailed analysis of assessment of circulating female reproductive hormones in animal models.Citation29

Extra-contraceptive effects

Drug or device extra-contraceptive effects may impact user health and safety as well as method acceptability. Animal models are useful for characterization of contraceptive off-target effects where human studies are unethical or otherwise not feasible. For example, it is difficult to evaluate the interaction between sexually transmitted infection (STI) rates and hormonal contraception in human populations due to significant confounds, such as condom use. Condoms prevent STIs but are used at significantly lower rates by individuals employing other contraceptive methods.Citation74 In particular, equivocal evidence on a causal relationship between human immunodeficiency virus acquisition and depot medroxyprogesterone acetate use in womenCitation75 has increased interest in modeling this interaction using macaques infected with unmodified or recombinant simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV or SHIV, respectively). These models were recently reviewed in a publication by McNicholl et al.Citation76 The same group has also developed a model of SHIV infection in copper IUD-implanted pigtail macaques.Citation43 In addition to SHIV, well characterized nonhuman primate models of Chlamydia trachomatis,Citation77 Mycoplasma genitalium,Citation78 Trichomonas vaginalis,Citation79 and genital papillomavirusCitation80 have been developed, and could be utilized for pathogen challenge studies of combined contraceptives.

Additionally, the vaginal microbiota of many species of nonhuman primate have been described both withCitation81 and without a contraceptive device.Citation82 As vaginal microbiota may contribute to host mucosal immune function, characterization of alterations in these bacterial communities is of particular importance for development of dual-action vaginal rings or IUDs that provide simultaneous contraception and microbicide-mediated STI protection. Several broad-spectrum microbicides have failed in clinical trials due to induction of mucosal damage with repeated use and increased risk of transmission of human immunodeficiency virus.Citation62 Use of more stringent preclinical product selection criteria, including description of the impact of a product on vaginal microbiota, may enhance understanding of microbicide epithelial toxicity and STI acquisition risk with contraceptive or dual-action products in a well characterized pathogen challenge model.

Associations between contraceptive use and obesity can also be explored in animal models. Although systematic review suggests no causal relationship between weight gain and combined oral contraception (COC), weight gain is a common complaint in COC users.Citation83 The impact of COC (ethinyl estradiol/LNG) on body weight, physical activity, caloric intake, percent body fat, and basal metabolic rate was compared in cohorts of healthy and obese female rhesus macaques over an 8-month treatment period. A 9% decrease in body weight was observed in the obese animals, with no significant difference observed in the normal animals. A significant increase from baseline in basal metabolic rate was observed with COC treatment in both groups.Citation84 A study using the same COC dosing protocol observed increases in both serum adiponectin and resistin from baseline in both obese and healthy weight macaques.Citation85

Conclusion

Validated animal models are crucial for preclinical prediction of drug safety and efficacy that cannot be determined in vitro. Due to similarities with humans in reproductive anatomy and physiology, nonhuman primates are attractive candidates for modeling of contraceptive devices, understanding of their contraceptive mechanism of action, and evaluation of contraceptive efficacy. Other species, such as rodents or rabbits, also serve important roles in preclinical dosing optimization, safety pharmacology, and contraceptive target discovery. Leverage of extensive genetic and phenotypic tools in murine models has enabled discovery of pathways in reproductive biology suitable for contraceptive intervention. However, interspecies differences in follicular, luteal, and endometrial dynamics may reduce the translatability of these discoveries. Nevertheless, with careful thought given to selection of animal models, preclinical modeling enhances contraceptive development and ultimately improves patient safety and contraceptive choice worldwide.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

References

  • AlkemaLKantorovaVMenozziCBiddlecomANational, regional, and global rates and trends in contraceptive prevalence and unmet need for family planning between 1990 and 2015: a systematic and comprehensive analysisLancet201338198781642165223489750
  • BrownSSEisenbergLThe Best Intentions: Unintended Pregnancy and the Well-Being of Children and FamiliesWashington, DC, USANational Academies1995
  • CraigADDehlendorfCBorreroSHarperCCRoccaCHExploring young adults’ contraceptive knowledge and attitudes: disparities by race/ethnicity and ageWomens Health Issues2014243e281e28924725755
  • BartzDShewMOfnerSFortenberryJDPregnancy intentions and contraceptive behaviors among adolescent women: a coital event level analysisJ Adolesc Health200741327127617707297
  • BrackenJGrahamCAYoung women’s attitudes towards, and experiences of, long-acting reversible contraceptivesEur J Contracept Reprod Health Care201419427628424882426
  • BahamondesLBahamondesMVNew and emerging contraceptives: a state-of-the-art reviewInt J Womens Health2014622123424570597
  • NassSJStraussJF3rdStrategies to facilitate the development of new contraceptivesNat Rev Drug Discov200431088589015459679
  • BavisterBDARTs in action in nonhuman primates: symposium summary – advances and remaining issuesReprod Biol Endocrinol200424315202938
  • JinekMChylinskiKFonfaraIHauerMDoudnaJACharpentierEA programmable dual-RNA-guided DNA endonuclease in adaptive bacterial immunityScience2012337609681682122745249
  • KimIYShinJHSeongJKMouse phenogenomics, toolbox for functional annotation of human genomeBMB Rep2010432799020193125
  • ArchambeaultDRMatzukMMDisrupting the male germ line to find infertility and contraception targetsAnn Endocrinol (Paris)201475210110824793995
  • GuptaNChakrabartiKPrakashKWadhwaNGuptaTGuptaSKImmunogenicity and contraceptive efficacy of Escherichia coli-expressed recombinant porcine zona pellucida proteinsAm J Reprod Immunol201370213915223444974
  • NazRKAntisperm contraceptive vaccines: where we are and where we are going?Am J Reprod Immunol201166151221481057
  • GuptaSKShresthaAMinhasVMilestones in contraceptive vaccines development and hurdles in their applicationHum Vaccin Immunother201410491192524262991
  • NieGFindlayJKSalamonsenLAIdentification of novel endometrial targets for contraceptionContraception200571427228115792646
  • LiuYXGaoFWeiPInvolvement of molecules related to angiogenesis, proteolysis and apoptosis in implantation in rhesus monkey and mouseContraception200571424926215792644
  • DiasJACampoBWeaverBAInhibition of follicle-stimulating hormone-induced preovulatory follicles in rats treated with a non-steroidal negative allosteric modulator of follicle-stimulating hormone receptorBiol Reprod20149011924285717
  • van de LagemaatRvan KoppenCJKrajnc-FrankenMAContraception by induction of luteinized unruptured follicles with short-acting low molecular weight FSH receptor agonists in female animal modelsReproduction2011142689390521930683
  • PeluffoMCStanleyJBraeuerNA prostaglandin E2 receptor antagonist prevents pregnancies during a preclinical contraceptive trial with female macaquesHum Reprod20142971400141224781425
  • NallasamySKimJSitruk-WareRBagchiMBagchiIUlipristal blocks ovulation by inhibiting progesterone receptor-dependent pathways intrinsic to the ovaryReprod Sci201320437138123012316
  • PeluffoMCMurphyMJBaughmanSTStoufferRLHenneboldJDSystematic analysis of protease gene expression in the rhesus macaque ovulatory follicle: metalloproteinase involvement in follicle ruptureEndocrinology2011152103963397421791558
  • ContiMAndersenCBRichardFJShitsukawaKTsafririARole of cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterases in resumption of meiosisMol Cell Endocrinol19981451–29149922093
  • JensenJTStoufferRLStanleyJEZelinskiMBEvaluation of the phosphodiesterase 3 inhibitor ORG 9935 as a contraceptive in female macaques: initial trialsContraception201081216517120103457
  • AschenbachLCHesterKEMcCannNCZhangJGDimitriadisEDuffyDMThe LIF receptor antagonist PEGLA is effectively delivered to the uterine endometrium and blocks LIF activity in cynomolgus monkeysContraception201387681382323121824
  • GhoshDSenguptaJTarget-oriented anti-implantation approaches for pregnancy interception: experiences in the rhesus monkey modelContraception200571429430115792648
  • SlaydenODChwaliszKBrennerRMReversible suppression of menstruation with progesterone antagonists in rhesus macaquesHum Reprod20011681562157411473944
  • BrennerRMSlaydenODNathATsongYYSitruk-WareRIntrauterine administration of CDB-2914 (ulipristal) suppresses the endometrium of rhesus macaquesContraception201081433634220227552
  • NayakNRSlaydenODMahKChwaliszKBrennerRMAntiprogestin-releasing intrauterine devices: a novel approach to endometrial contraceptionContraception2007756 SupplS104S11117531599
  • AnderssonHRehmSStanislausDWoodCEScientific and regulatory policy committee (SRPC) paper: assessment of circulating hormones in nonclinical toxicity studies III. Female reproductive hormonesToxicol Pathol201341692193423334695
  • StoufferRLBishopCVBoganRLXuFHenneboldJDEndocrine and local control of the primate corpus luteumReprod Biol201313425927124287034
  • TardifSCarvilleAElmoreDWilliamsLERiceKReproduction and breeding of nonhuman primatesAbeeCRMansfieldKTardifSMorrisTNonhuman Primates in Biomedical Research2nd edBoston, MA, USAAcademic Press2012
  • MicksEShekellTStanleyJMedical termination of pregnancy in cynomolgus macaquesJ Med Primatol201241639440223078537
  • ChaffinCLDissenGAStoufferRLHormonal regulation of steroidogenic enzyme expression in granulosa cells during the peri-ovulatory interval in monkeysMol Hum Reprod200061111810611255
  • WestwoodFRThe female rat reproductive cycle: a practical histological guide to stagingToxicol Pathol200836337538418441260
  • GuyAJSchuerchFSHeffernanSThomsonPCO’BrienJKMcGreevyPDThe effect of medroxyprogesterone acetate on behavioural responses of captive female hamadryas baboons (Papio hamadryas)Anim Reprod Sci20081083–441242417980521
  • Zelinski-WootenMBSlaydenODChwaliszKHessDLBrennerRMStoufferRLChronic treatment of female rhesus monkeys with low doses of the antiprogestin ZK 137 316: establishment of a regimen that permits normal menstrual cyclicityHum Reprod19981322592679557820
  • HotchkissJAtkinsonLEKnobilETime course of serum estrogen and luteinizing hormone (LH) concentrations during the menstrual cycle of the rhesus monkeyEndocrinology19718911771834995997
  • BehboodiEKatzDFSamuelsSJTellLHendrickxAGLasleyBLThe use of a urinary estrone conjugates assay for detection of optimal mating time in the cynomolgus macaque (Macaca fascicularis)J Med Primatol19912052292341920378
  • HardemanJWeissBDIntrauterine devices: an updateAm Fam Physician201489644545024695563
  • WinnerBPeipertJFZhaoQEffectiveness of long-acting reversible contraceptionN Engl J Med2012366211998200722621627
  • Gemzell-DanielssonKSchellschmidtIApterDA randomized, phase II study describing the efficacy, bleeding profile, and safety of two low-dose levonorgestrel-releasing intrauterine contraceptive systems and MirenaFertil Steril201297361662222222193
  • BellJDBerginILNatavioMFFeasibility of LNG-IUS in a baboon modelContraception201387338038423114737
  • EngelRMMorrisMHenningTEvaluation of pigtail macaques as a model for the effects of copper intrauterine devices on HIV infectionJ Med Primatol201443534935924372425
  • HafezESEJaszczakSComparative anatomy and histology of the cervix uteri in non-human primatesPrimates1972133297316
  • JensenJTHannaCYaoSBlockade of tubal patency following transcervical administration of polidocanol foam: initial studies in rhesus macaquesContraception201489654054924560476
  • PostJHCardellaJFWilsonRPExperimental nonsurgical transcervical sterilization with a custom-designed platinum microcoilJ Vasc Interv Radiol199781 Pt 11131189025049
  • DoyleLLMargolisAJIntrauterine foreign body. I. Effect on reproductive processes in the ratFertil Steril19641559760614236835
  • BilbruckJHanlonGWGardPRMartinGPThe effects of transcervical monofilament insertion on the microbial status of the uterus in guinea-pigsJ Pharm Pharmacol19944632132168027930
  • OzalpSTanirHMCakmakBHassaHImpact of piroxicam beta-cyclodextrin on the efficacy of the intrauterine device in a rat modelEur J Contracept Reprod Health Care200712210711017559007
  • GardPRReynoldsJPHanlonGWUse of chlorhexidine-releasing nylon fibres to reduce device-related uterine infectionsGynecol Obstet Invest200049426126510828710
  • CelikOUgrasMHascalikSAydinNEAbbasovTEnhanced endometrial response to a magnetic intrauterine device: a preliminary studyEur J Contracept Reprod Health Care200914643744319929647
  • ZhangXYuanHDengLHuFMaJLinJEvaluation of the efficacy of a danazol-loaded intrauterine contraceptive device on adenomyosis in an ICR mouse modelHum Reprod20082392024203018552364
  • PengXHuSMengTSuoJXiongCThe antifertility effectiveness of a novel copper-containing composite used in intrauterine contraceptive devices and the releasing behavior of cupric ions contained in the composite in ratsContraception201286441341822445435
  • QiuYWangLGZhangMHZhangYPZhangADYangDTA new experimental three-dimensional, reticular intrauterine device (3-DRIUD) composed of nitinol and silicone rubberContraception2013881313623218860
  • OrtizMECroxattoHBCopper-T intrauterine device and levonorgestrel intrauterine system: biological bases of their mechanism of actionContraception2007756 SupplS16S3017531610
  • LarimoreWLStanfordJBPostfertilization effects of oral contraceptives and their relationship to informed consentArch Fam Med20009212613310693729
  • BattaSKChaudhuryRRThe anti-implantation property of intraluminal fluid in rats with an intra-uterine silk thread sutureJ Reprod Fertil19681611451465666995
  • HurstPRJefferiesKEcksteinPWheelerAGIntrauterine degeneration of embryos in IUD-bearing miceJ Reprod Fertil1977501187189864646
  • StanfordJBMikolajczykRTMechanisms of action of intrauterine devices: update and estimation of postfertilization effectsAm J Obstet Gynecol200218761699170812501086
  • AlvarezFBracheVFernandezENew insights on the mode of action of intrauterine contraceptive devices in womenFertil Steril19884957687733360166
  • RoumenFJMishellDRJrThe contraceptive vaginal ring, NuvaRing®, a decade after its introductionEur J Contracept Reprod Health Care201217641542723113828
  • VeazeyRSMicrobicide safety/efficacy studies in animals: macaques and small animal modelsCurr Opin HIV AIDS20083556757319373023
  • Promadej-LanierNSmithJMSrinivasanPDevelopment and evaluation of a vaginal ring device for sustained delivery of HIV microbicides to non-human primatesJ Med Primatol200938426327119476564
  • MossJAMaloneAMSmithTJSafety and pharmacokinetics of intravaginal rings delivering tenofovir in pig-tailed macaquesAntimicrob Agents Chemother201256115952596022964245
  • GunawardanaMMossJASmithTJMicrobial biofilms on the surface of intravaginal rings worn in non-human primatesJ Med Microbiol201160Pt 682883721393449
  • MurphyDJDesjardinsDDereuddre-BosquetNPre-clinical development of a combination microbicide vaginal ring containing dapivirine and darunavirJ Antimicrob Chemother20146992477248824862093
  • HadzicSVWangXDufourJComparison of the vaginal environment of Macaca mulatta and Macaca nemestrina throughout the menstrual cycleAm J Reprod Immunol201471432232924521395
  • VincentKLBourneNBellBAHigh resolution imaging of epithelial injury in the sheep cervicovaginal tract: a promising model for testing safety of candidate microbicidesSex Transm Dis200936531231819295469
  • TouitouEBarryBWEnhancement in Drug DeliveryBoca Raton, FL, USACRC Press2007
  • JohnsonTJClarkMRAlbrightTHA 90-day tenofovir reservoir intravaginal ring for mucosal HIV prophylaxisAntimicrob Agents Chemother201256126272628323006751
  • GodinBTouitouETransdermal skin delivery: predictions for humans from in vivo, ex vivo and animal modelsAdv Drug Deliv Rev200759111152116117889400
  • JacobiUKaiserMTollRPorcine ear skin: an in vitro model for human skinSkin Res Technol2007131192417250528
  • ChienYWChienTYBagdonREHuangYCBiermanRHTransdermal dual-controlled delivery of contraceptive drugs: formulation development, in vitro and in vivo evaluations, and clinical performancePharm Res1989612100010102516312
  • ESHRI Capri Workshop GroupSimultaneous prevention of unintended pregnancy and STIs: a challenging compromiseHum Reprod Update201420695296324935861
  • PolisCBCurtisKMUse of hormonal contraceptives and HIV acquisition in women: a systematic review of the epidemiological evidenceLancet Infect Dis201313979780823871397
  • McNichollJMHenningTCVishwanathanSAKershENNon-human primate models of hormonal contraception and HIVAm J Reprod Immunol201471651352224716832
  • BellJDBerginILHarrisLHThe effects of a single cervical inoculation of Chlamydia trachomatis on the female reproductive tract of the baboon (Papio anubis)J Infect Dis201120491305131221921205
  • WoodGEIverson-CabralSLPattonDLCummingsPKCosgrove SweeneyYTTottenPAPersistence, immune response, and antigenic variation of Mycoplasma genitalium in an experimentally infected pig-tailed macaque (Macaca nemestrina)Infect Immun20138182938295123732170
  • HenningTRButlerKHansonDIncreased susceptibility to vaginal simian/human immunodeficiency virus transmission in pig-tailed macaques coinfected with Chlamydia trachomatis and Trichomonas vaginalisJ Infect Dis201421081239124724755433
  • WoodCEChenZClineJMMillerBEBurkRDCharacterization and experimental transmission of an oncogenic papillomavirus in female macaquesJ Virol200781126339634517428865
  • HashwaySABerginILBassisCMImpact of a hormone-releasing intrauterine system on the vaginal microbiome: a prospective baboon modelJ Med Primatol2014432899924266633
  • YildirimSYeomanCJJangaSCPrimate vaginal microbiomes exhibit species specificity without universal Lactobacillus dominanceISME J20148122431244425036926
  • ModySKHanMObesity and contraceptionClin Obstet Gynecol201457350150725029338
  • EdelmanAJensenJTBulechowskyMCameronJCombined oral contraceptives and body weight: do oral contraceptives cause weight gain? A primate modelHum Reprod201126233033621126966
  • ShawKAHenneboldJDEdelmanABEffect of a combined estrogen and progesterone oral contraceptive on circulating adipocytokines adiponectin, resistin and DLK-1 in normal and obese female rhesus monkeysContraception201388117718223218850