119
Views
4
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Research

Women achieve peak freestyle swim speed at earlier ages than men

, &
Pages 189-199 | Published online: 12 Nov 2012

Abstract

Background

The age of peak swim performance has been investigated for freestyle swimmers for distances ranging from 50 m to 1500 m among swimmers aged 19 to 99 years. However, studies have yet to investigate the 10 to 19 year-old age group. The aims of the present study were (1) to investigate the age range of peak freestyle swim speed, and (2) to find differences in age range and peak freestyle swim speed between male and female freestyle swimmers from 50 m to 1500 m at a national level.

Methods

The changes in age range and peak freestyle swim speed among Swiss elite freestyle swimmers aged 0–9 years and 70–79 years who were ranked on the Swiss high score list between 2006 and 2010 were analyzed using linear regression analyses and analysis of variance.

Results

Men were fastest at ages 22–23 years for 100 m and 200 m; at ages 24–25 years for 400 m and 800 m; and at 26–27 years for 50 m and 1500 m. Women achieved peak freestyle swim speed at ages 20–21 years for all distances with the exception of 800 m. In the 800 m, women were fastest at ages 26–27 years. The difference in peak freestyle swim speed decreased with increasing swim distance from 50 m to 800 m (ie, 13.1% ± 1.3% in 50 m; 13.2% ± 0.9% in 100 m; 10.8% ± 0.9% in 200 m; 7.9% ± 1.3% in 400 m; and 4.2% ± 2.0% in 800 m). For 1500 m, however, the gender difference increased to 6.4% ± 2.3%.

Conclusion

These findings suggest that peak freestyle swim speed is achieved at lower age ranges in women when compared to men at 50 m to 1500 m, but not at 800 m. The gender difference in peak freestyle swim speed decreased with increasing swim distance from 50 m to 800 m, but not for 1500 m. These data should be confirmed with swimmers at an international level.

Introduction

It is well known that endurance performance decreases when age increases.Citation1Citation4 In endurance performances such as swimming, peak performance has been described between the ages of 35 and 40 years, with a linear decrease in performance until approximately 70 years of age.Citation2 Until the age of approximately 70 years, the decrease in endurance performance is parallel in both women and men.Citation1Citation3 After the age of 70 years, the decline in performance occurs exponentially.Citation1Citation3

For swimmers, the age-related performance decline shows differences regarding both the length of the swim distance as well as gender.Citation2,Citation3 In Donato et al, the age-related decline in freestyle swimming performance was greater in the 1500 m freestyle than in the 50 m freestyle, and was greater in women than in men in 50 m.Citation2 In women, the decline in swimming performance became progressively greater from the 50 m freestyle to the 800 m freestyle, as well as to the 1500 m freestyle. In men, however, no differences were observed in the age-related performance decline from the 100 m freestyle to the 1500 m freestyle.Citation3 Donato et al also reported that the rates of decline in swimming performance associated with age were greater in long duration events compared to short duration events, suggesting a relatively smaller loss of anaerobic muscular power with age compared with cardiovascular endurance.Citation2

For coaches and athletes, the knowledge of the age of peak performance in an endurance performance might be of higher interest than knowing the time course of the age-related decline in performance. When coaches and swimmers know the age of peak freestyle swim speed, the career of an elite swimmer can be better planned. The age of peak endurance performance seemed to remain relatively stable across the years when athletes who had competed in different disciplines and over different distances were investigated.Citation5 Schulz and CurnowCitation5 analyzed data from between 1896 and 1980 of Olympic track and field athletes as well as swimmers between. They presented the age and peak performance data of Olympic gold medal winners and showed that the age of peak performance remained relatively stable. For swimmers, the age at which the gold medal was won remained remarkably consistent between 1896 and 1980. Men won the gold medal in 100 m freestyle at the age of 21.4 ± 3.1 years, and women won the medal at 19.4 ± 2.9 years. For the 400 m freestyle, men won gold at the age of 19.9 ± 2.2 years and women at the age of 17.6 ± 1.9 years. For longer distances, men were more likely to win a gold medal at the age of 20.3 ± 3.5 years in the 1500 m freestyle, and women at the age of 16.0 ± 1.4 years in the 800 m freestyle.Citation5

However, there seem to be differences regarding the relationship between the age of peak performance and the length of endurance performance for different sports disciplines. For running, several studies investigated the age of peak performance for short-distance runners,Citation5 middle-distance runners,Citation5 half-marathoners,Citation6 marathoners,Citation5,Citation6 and ultra-marathoners.Citation7Citation9 In runners, the age of peak performance seemed to increase with increasing running distance.Citation5Citation9 Also, among triathletes, the age of peak performance is lower in shorter triathlon distances compared to longer distances.Citation10,Citation11 For swimmers, however, younger ages were associated with faster swim speeds in longer distances.Citation5 In freestyle swimmers, differences in the age of peak performance associated with swim length have been reported. The age of peak performance in the 1500 m freestyle was achieved at a younger age (~18 years) compared to the peak performance in the 50 m freestyle, which was achieved at a higher age (~23 years).Citation12

The age of peak swim performance seems to be dependent on gender. Schulz and CurnowCitation5 showed that women generally achieved peak swim performances at younger ages than men. In freestyle swimming, however, the association of increased age with increasing distance was reversed for female swimmers, where a younger age of peak performance was associated with a longer swimming distance. Tanaka and SealsCitation3 reported that men reached their fastest swim times for 1500 m freestyle between 25 and 40 years of age, whereas women achieved their fastest 1500 m freestyle times at the age of 30 to 35 years. In contrast, peak performance in 50 m freestyle was attained at the age of 20 to 30 years in both women and men. Schulz and CurnowCitation5 analyzed the data of Olympic swimmers who competed in 100 m freestyle, 400 m freestyle, and 1500 m freestyle for men, and 100 m freestyle, 400 m freestyle, and 800 m freestyle for women. From 1896 to 1980, the age of peak swim performance was between approximately 21 years for the 100 m freestyle and approximately 20 years for 1500 m freestyle in men, and between approximately 19 years for the 100 m freestyle, and approximately 16 years for 800 m freestyle for women.

The age of peak swim performance has been investigated for freestyle swimmers across distances from 50 m to 1500 m.Citation2,Citation3,Citation5,Citation13 These reports showed different results for the age of peak performance, and some of these reports were based on older data, from 1896–1980,Citation5 1988–1999,Citation2 1991–1995,Citation3 and 1993–2001.Citation13 In addition, these studies missed investigating the age group encompassing 10–19 years. Donato et alCitation2 investigated athletes aged 19 to 85 years, FairbrotherCitation13 examined athletes aged 19 to 96 years, and Tanaka and SealsCitation3 assessed athletes aged 19 to 99 years. Since Schulz and CurnowCitation5 showed that the age of peak performance in females was ~20 years or younger, the studies of Donato et al,Citation2 Fairbrother,Citation13 and Tanaka and SealsCitation3 likely failed to determine the correct age of peak swim performance since they excluded swimmers between the ages of 10 and 19 years old from their analyses. Furthermore, Schulz and CurnowCitation5 did not investigate all swim distances in their analysis, such as the 200 m freestyle among women and men, the 1500 m freestyle among women, and the 800 m freestyle among men.

Therefore, the aims of the present study were (1) to investigate the age range of peak freestyle swim speed, and (2) to find potential differences in both the age range and the speed of peak freestyle swim performance in male and female top freestyle swimmers for distances from 50 m to 1500 m. We hypothesized that (1) the age range of peak freestyle swim speed would be lower in women compared to men, and that (2) the age range of peak freestyle swim speed would decrease in women with increasing swim distance. To test these hypotheses, we investigated swimmers in the age groups of 0–9 years to 70–79 years who were ranked on the Swiss swimming high score list between 2006 and 2010.

Materials and methods

All male and female freestyle swimmers who were ranked on the Swiss swimming high score list between 2006 and 2010 were analyzed for their freestyle swim performance on 50 m, 100 m, 200 m, 400 m, 800 m, and 1500 m distances. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of St Gallen, Switzerland, while waiving the requirement for informed consent since the study involved the analysis of publicly available data. The data set from this study was obtained from the Swiss Swimming Federation’s website.Citation14 The high score list of the Swiss Swimming Federation registers the fastest swim time of each swimmer across all ages for each year.Citation14 No swimmer is listed more than twice on the annual high score list.

In total, data were available from 50,519 swimmers, including 24,656 women and 25,863 men who competed in races in 50 m swimming pools. In order to facilitate data analysis and to make the results more comparable, all swimming times were transformed to swim speed in meters per second by calculating [swim distance (m)]/[swim time (seconds)] prior to statistical analysis. Due to the high variability of performance over time, and given the low number of swimmers per age group in the years preceding 2006, we decided to analyze only swimmers in the five consecutive years between 2006 and 2010.

For the analysis of swim performance across age groups, all swimmers were separated by gender and were further categorized into the following age groups: 0–9 years, 10–19 years, 20–29 years, 30–39 years, 40–49 years, 50–59 years, 60–69 years, and 70–79 years. For each age group and gender, the top three performances (ie, the three fastest swim speeds) per swim distance and age were determined.

The change in age group and swim speed among the top three swimmers was investigated across the 5 years between 2006 and 2010. A one-way analysis of variance showed no significant difference in swim speed for the top three swimmers within the fastest age groups between 2006 and 2010; therefore, the data were pooled together (n = 3 subjects × 5 years = 15 for each age group). In case less than three swimmers were listed in a given age group, that age group was excluded from further data analysis. Data were then analyzed between age groups. The age groups showing the fastest swim speeds were 10–19 years and 20–29 years. In a second step, all swimmers aged 10–29 years were separately analyzed in 2-year age groups (ie, 10–11 years, 12–13 years, 14–15 years, and so on). For each of these age groups we determined the top three swimmers per gender and swim distance and compared swim speeds between age groups.

Statistical analysis

In order to increase the reliability of the data analyses, each set of data was tested for normal distribution as well as for homogeneity of variances in advance of the statistical analyses. Normal distribution was tested using the D’Agostino–Pearson omnibus normality test, and homogeneity of variances was tested using either Levene’s test in case of two groups, and with Bartlett’s test in case of more than two groups. To find the significant differences between groups, analysis of variance with subsequent Tukey–Kramer post hoc analysis was employed. Statistical analyses were performed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences statistics software ([SPSS] version 19; IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY) and GraphPad Prism (version 5; GraphPad Software, La Jolla, CA). Significance was accepted at P < 0.05 (two-sided for t-tests). Data in the text are given as mean ± standard deviation (SD).

Results

For men, peak freestyle swim speed was achieved in the age groups 10–19 years and 20–29 years for all distances (). For women, peak freestyle swim speed was achieved in the age groups 10–19 years, 20–29 years, and 30–39 years for the 50 m freestyle and 400 m freestyle (). For the 100 m freestyle, 200 m freestyle, 800 m freestyle, and 1500 m freestyle, peak freestyle swim speed was attained in the age groups 10–29 years and 20–29 years.

Figure 1 Swim speed of the three fastest male swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 in each 10-year age group based on distance. Swim speed of the three fastest male swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 in each 10-year age group based on distance for the 50 m freestyle (A), 100 m freestyle (B), 200 m freestyle (C), 400 m freestyle (D), 800 m freestyle (E), and 1500 m freestyle (F).

Note: Age groups with no significant difference in swim speed are indicated by a rectangle and marked with “NS.”
Figure 1 Swim speed of the three fastest male swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 in each 10-year age group based on distance. Swim speed of the three fastest male swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 in each 10-year age group based on distance for the 50 m freestyle (A), 100 m freestyle (B), 200 m freestyle (C), 400 m freestyle (D), 800 m freestyle (E), and 1500 m freestyle (F).

Figure 2 Swim speed of the three fastest male swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 2-year age group and distance. Swim speed of the three fastest male swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 2-year age group and distance for swimmers aged between 10 and 29 years for the 50 m freestyle (A), 100 m freestyle (B), 200 m freestyle (C), 400 m freestyle (D), 800 m freestyle (E), and 1500 m freestyle (F).

Note: Age groups with no significant difference in swim speed are indicated by a rectangle and marked with 1“NS.”
Figure 2 Swim speed of the three fastest male swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 2-year age group and distance. Swim speed of the three fastest male swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 2-year age group and distance for swimmers aged between 10 and 29 years for the 50 m freestyle (A), 100 m freestyle (B), 200 m freestyle (C), 400 m freestyle (D), 800 m freestyle (E), and 1500 m freestyle (F).

When the age groups 10–19 years and 20–29 years were analyzed in 2-years intervals, men were fastest between 22–23 years for the 100 m and 200 m freestyle, between 24–25 years for the 400 m and 800 m freestyle, and between 26–27 years for the 50 m and 1500 m freestyle (). Women achieved their peak freestyle swim speed at the age range of 20–21 years for all distances with the exception of the 800 m freestyle. In the 800 m freestyle, women were fastest at 26–27 years ().

Figure 3 Swim speed of the three fastest female swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 10-year age group and distance. Swim speed of the three fastest female swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 10-year age group and distance for the 50 m freestyle (A), 100 m freestyle (B), 200 m freestyle (C), 400 m freestyle (D), 800 m freestyle (E), and 1500 m freestyle (F).

Note: Age groups with no significant difference in swim speed are indicated by a rectangle and marked with “NS.”
Figure 3 Swim speed of the three fastest female swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 10-year age group and distance. Swim speed of the three fastest female swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 10-year age group and distance for the 50 m freestyle (A), 100 m freestyle (B), 200 m freestyle (C), 400 m freestyle (D), 800 m freestyle (E), and 1500 m freestyle (F).

Figure 4 Swim speed of the three fastest female swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 2-year age group and distance. Swim speed of the three fastest female swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 2-year age group and distance for swimmers aged between 10 and 29 years for the 50 m freestyle (A), 100 m freestyle (B), 200 m freestyle (C), 400 m freestyle (D), 800 m freestyle (E), and 1500 m freestyle (F).

Note: Age groups with no significant difference in swim speed are indicated by a rectangle and marked with “NS.”
Figure 4 Swim speed of the three fastest female swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 2-year age group and distance. Swim speed of the three fastest female swimmers in freestyle swimming between 2006 and 2010 per 2-year age group and distance for swimmers aged between 10 and 29 years for the 50 m freestyle (A), 100 m freestyle (B), 200 m freestyle (C), 400 m freestyle (D), 800 m freestyle (E), and 1500 m freestyle (F).

The difference in peak freestyle swim speed decreased with increasing swim distance from the 50 m freestyle to the 800 m freestyle. The gender difference in performance was 13.1% ± 1.3% for the 50 m freestyle, 13.2% ± 0.9% for the 100 m freestyle, 10.8% ± 0.9% for the 200 m freestyle, 7.9% ± 1.3% for the 400 m freestyle, and 4.2% ± 2.0% for the 800 m freestyle. For the 1500 m freestyle, however, the difference in peak swim speed increased to 6.4% ± 2.3%.

Discussion

We intended, firstly, to investigate the age range of peak swim speed in both male and female top swimmers for freestyle distances ranging from 50 m to 1500 m. Secondly, we also wanted to find potential differences in both the age range and speed of peak freestyle swim performance. With respect to the existing literature investigating the age-related performance decline in freestyle swimming, we hypothesized that (1) the age range of peak freestyle swim speed would be lower in women compared to men, and (2) the age range of peak freestyle swim speed would decrease in women with increasing length of the swim distance. The main findings were that (1) women achieved their peak freestyle swim speed at lower age ranges compared to men, with the exception of the 800 m distance, and (2) the gender difference in peak freestyle swim speed decreased with increasing length of the swim distance from 50 m to 800 m, but not for 1500 m.

Women achieve peak freestyle swim speed at earlier ages than men

The most important finding was that the age range associated with peak freestyle swim speed was approximately 2 years lower in women compared to men. While Schulz and CurnowCitation5 reported that the age range of peak freestyle swim speed was approximately 21 years for men and approximately 19 years for women, we found a considerably higher age range of peak freestyle swim speed for both women and men. The present data differ from the findings of Schulz and Curnow,Citation5 who analyzed data of Olympic swimmers from between 1896 and 1980 by investigating the 100 m freestyle, 400 m freestyle, and 1500 m freestyle for men, and the 100 m freestyle, 400 m freestyle, and 800 m freestyle for women. From 1896 to 1980, the age of peak freestyle performance among men was between 21.4 years for the 100 m freestyle and 20.3 years for the 1500 m freestyle, while for women it was between 19.4 years for the 100 m freestyle and 16 years for the 800 m freestyle.Citation5

Schulz and CurnowCitation5 separated their data into two halves (ie, 1896–1936 and 1942–1980) using World War II as a dividing point. For men, the age of peak freestyle performance decreased in the 100 m freestyle from 22.0 years to 20.78 years, in the 400 m freestyle from 20.44 years to 19.44 years, and in the 1500 m freestyle from 21.09 years to 19.44 years between the two halves. For women, however, the age of peak freestyle performance increased in the 100 m freestyle from 18 years to 20.33 years, but the age of peak performance decreased in the 400 m freestyle from 18 years to 17.33 years. For the 800 m freestyle, there were no data available from 1986–1936 to compare with the second half after World War 2.

The different findings between the results of Schulz and CurnowCitation5 and the present data might be explained by the different time frames of the investigation period and the changes in anthropometric characteristics across the years. While Schulz and CurnowCitation5 analyzed data from 1896 to 1980, we analyzed data from 2006 to 2010. We assume that changes in anthropometric characteristics across the last century might have occurred, explaining these differences. In swimming, anthropometric characteristics such as body height have an influence on performance.Citation15Citation18 Geladas et alCitation16 examined the relationship between anthropometry, physical capacity, and sprint swimming performance in swimmers of both genders aged 12–14 years old. Upper extremity length, horizontal jump, and grip strength were significant predictors of 100 m freestyle performance in boys. In girls, however, body height, upper extremity and hand length, shoulder flexibility, and horizontal jump were all significantly related to 100 m freestyle time, but the degree of the association was markedly lower than in boys. Zampagni et alCitation18 determined in elite master swimmers of both genders anthropometric predictor variables using anthropometric measures and the hand-grip strength measure. Age, height, and hand grip strength were the best predictors in short-distance events, whereas only age and height were predictors in middle- and long-distance events. Differences between sexes were not found in the 50 m event, but were present in all other events.

In the last several years, anthropometry in adolescents has changed.Citation19Citation23 Kagawa et alCitation19 analyzed the changes in growth between 1900 and 2000 in Japanese children from the ages of 6 to 17 years. Over this 100-year period, boys showed increases in height and weight in increments of 1.0–2.0 cm per decade and 0.4–1.7 kg per decade, whereas girls demonstrated growth rates of 1.1–1.9 cm and 0.4–1.5 kg per decade. The rates of height growth were significantly different between pre-, during, and post-World War II periods. While Japanese children were considerably larger in 2000 compared to 1900, the growth increments noted between 1950 and 1960 reflected children’s “catch-up” growth to restore physical size, as seen in children prior to World War II. The increments in body size growth continued after 1960, with the greatest changes seen across the pubertal years. When changes in body dimensions were analyzed for recent decades, Simsek et alCitation20 reported a significant secular increase from 1993 to 2003 in terms of weight and height measurements among 7 to 15-year-old boys and girls in Ankara, Turkey. Also, Marmo et alCitation21 showed that boys and girls exhibited an increase in body height and body weight in São Paulo, Brazil between 1979/1980 and 1993/1994.

Another explanation for the different age ranges associated with peak freestyle swim speed between women and men could include anthropometry and body fat as an important predictor variables for swimming performance.Citation16,Citation24Citation28 Female swimmers have significantly more adipose tissue than male swimmers.Citation24,Citation26,Citation28 Siders et alCitation26 reported that measurements of body composition such as body fat and body mass may be predictors of swimming performance in women, but not in men. Tuuri et alCitation27 showed that greater fat mass in female swimmers was more strongly related to lower levels of exercise. While the swimmers achieved their peak freestyle swim speed at approximately 20 years of age, specific changes in body composition during that age period might be of importance. Therefore, the difference in the age of peak freestyle swim speed between genders might be explained by body fat and its changes during maturation.Citation29Citation31 Bitar et alCitation29 showed that, during the onset of puberty, boys and girls gained fat-free mass, whereas fat mass gain was higher in girls than in boys. Lean body mass, which primarily reflects muscle mass, begins to increase during early puberty in both boys and girls. Fat mass, however, increases during the late stages of puberty in girls.Citation30 Further increases in fat mass after puberty may impair swim performance in women. An important finding was reported by Stager et al.Citation31 These authors showed that the mean age at menarche in swimmers was significantly later than in controls (ie, 13.4 years and 13 years, respectively). A later menarche means that puberty, as well as its associated increase in fat mass, will also be delayed. Stager et alCitation31 assumed that the later menarche observed in swimmers appeared to be associated with factors that contribute to a superior performance. Zuniga et alCitation28 showed that male and female sprint swimmers at approximately 11 years of age exhibited different percentages of body fat (boys 9.4% ± 5.4% of body fat; girls 12.7% ± 6.2% of body fat, respectively), and suggested that swimming performance for girls may be improved through training programs designed to reduce body fat.

Furthermore, maturation occurs earlier in women than in men.Citation30,Citation32 This can be seen in bone growth during puberty in relation to physical growth.Citation33 Maximal increase of all bone variables, such as width, mineral content, and density, occurred earlier in girls than in boys, with the earliest increase occurring for bone width, mineral content, and density. By the age of 17 years, boys had attained 86% of the adult bone mineral content and volumetric density, while girls had attained 93% of the adult bone mineral content and 94% of volumetric density. A study on the growth of the metacarpal bones showed a difference of approximately 2 years in the growth patterns noted between boys and girls.Citation32

Decrease in gender difference with increasing length of swim distance from 50 m to 800 m

A second important finding was that the gender difference in peak freestyle swim speed decreased between 50 m and 800 m. This finding is in line with previous findings observed for the 100 m to the 400 m freestyle distances. The analysis of the 100 m, 200 m, and 400 m freestyle swimming world records from 1957 to 2006 showed that gender differences in performance remained stable between 8% and 11%.Citation34 Regarding the distance of freestyle swimming, the gender difference decreased with increasing swim distance. For the 100 m freestyle, the gender difference was at 11%; for the 200 m freestyle, the gender difference was at 10%; and for the 400 m freestyle, the gender difference was at 9%.Citation34 It seems likely that female swimmers seem to achieve the same performance in longer swim distances as male swimmers. Eichenberger et alCitation35 showed that male and female top swimmers reached the same swim distance in a 12-hour swim in a pool. In the English Channel Swim, the best annual performances did not differ between the sexes.Citation36 However, the sex differences in open-water ultra-swimming performance in the 26.4 km open-water ultra-swim (the Marathon Swim in Lake Zurich, Switzerland), remained unchanged at approximately 11.5% in the last 25 years.Citation37

Anthropometric differences between women and men might explain the differences in the age of the fastest swim speed. Women have proportionally more fatty tissue located caudally compared to men, and the center of buoyancy is different between men and women.Citation24 For the longer freestyle distances, the higher body fat in women might play an important role; the higher body fat and the more caudally located body fat may explain why women are able to compete faster over longer distances (ie, in 400 m freestyle to 1500 m freestyle) than shorter distances (ie, 50 m freestyle to 200 m freestyle). Women seem to have a higher mechanical efficiency compared to men, most probably due to a lower drag.Citation38 In addition, body height and the length of the extremities might also explain these differences. Geladas et alCitation16 showed in 2005 that anthropometric characteristics such as extremity length and grip strength were significant predictors of 100 m freestyle performance in boys. In girls, however, the anthropometric characteristics body height, upper extremity, and hand length were all significantly related to 100 m freestyle times. Furthermore, body height and arm span were smaller in female swimmers than male swimmers.Citation25 Apart from these anthropometric characteristics, differences in stroke frequency and stroke length in freestyle swimming might also explain the present findings. Seifert et alCitation25 analyzed kinematic changes during 100 m front crawl in both women and men. High-speed swimmers were characterized by a higher and more stable stroke length. In fact, the principal gender difference was the greater stroke length observed in men compared to women.

Greater gender difference in 1500 m compared to 800 m freestyle swimming

We found a decrease in gender difference in peak swim speed between the 50 m freestyle and 800 m freestyle; however, for the 1500 m freestyle, the gender difference increased when compared to performance on the 800 m freestyle. This finding is in contrast to previous findings. Tanaka and SealsCitation3 reported a decrease in gender difference from 50 m freestyle to 1500 m freestyle swimming. Also, the authors reported different values for this gender difference.Citation3 They showed a gender difference of approximately 20% for the 50 m freestyle, with a continuous decrease in the gender difference to approximately 10% for the 1500 m freestyle.

The most probable explanation for the disparate findings between previous research and the present results in terms of performance in the longer distances such as the 800 m freestyle and the 1500 m freestyle is the study population. While Tanaka and SealsCitation3 investigated participants between the ages of 19 and 99 years who competed in the US Masters Swimming Championships from 1991–1995, we investigated Swiss elite swimmers between the ages of 0 and 79 years competing between 2006 and 2010. Since the fastest race times were achieved across most distances by swimmers between the ages of 10 and 29 years, the inclusion of the 10–19 age group in the present study may explain the gender differences observed for the longer swim distances.

Limitations

This study is limited in that anthropometric,Citation26Citation28,Citation39 physiological,Citation40 and trainingCitation41 variables were not included. The athletes’ nutrition levels might have also had an influence on their performance.Citation42 Variables such as hand grip strength,Citation16,Citation18 horizontal jump,Citation16 and shoulder flexibilityCitation16 were not investigated. These variables have been reported to influence swim performance. The inclusion of swimmers aged between 10 and 19 years might have influenced the present findings. Swimmers between 10 and 19 years had undergone puberty; during this period, considerable changes in anthropometric characteristics might have occurred,Citation30 which may have affected swim performance. Change in stature has only been investigated with data from the general population, but not with data from athletes. The variability in gains in stature is due to secular trends, heredity, and effects of environmental conditions on the human phenotype, which may have affected swim performance.Citation43,Citation44 These aspects were, however, not included in this study. Finally, we compared our data from swimmers between the ages of 0 and 79 years with results from studies where athletes were aged between 19 and 99 years.Citation2,Citation3,Citation5,Citation13 The comparison of the data from different age groups with the present findings might also have had an influence on the interpretation of the present data.

Conclusion

These findings suggest that peak freestyle swim speed is achieved at lower age ranges in women compared to men from the 50 m freestyle to the 1500 m freestyle, but not for the 800 m freestyle. The gender difference in peak freestyle swim speed decreased with increasing length of the swim distance from 50 m to 800 m, but not for 1500 m. Future studies need to investigate differences in age range and peak freestyle swim speed in longer swim distances and in open-water swimming. The present findings should be confirmed with swimmers at an international level.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

References

  • BongardVMcDermottAYDallalGESchaeferEJEffects of age and gender on physical performanceAge (Dordr)2007292–3778519424833
  • DonatoAJTenchKGlueckDHSealsDREskurzaITanakaHDeclines in physiological functional capacity with age: a longitudinal study in peak swimming performanceJ Appl Physiol200394276476912391125
  • TanakaHSealsDRAge and gender interactions in physiological functional capacity: insight from swimming performanceJ Appl Physiol19978238468519074973
  • ZamparoPEffects of age and gender on the propelling efficiency of the arm strokeEur J Appl Physiol2006971525816468063
  • SchulzRCurnowCPeak performance and age among superathletes: track and field, swimming, baseball, tennis, and golfJ Gerontol1988435P113P1203418037
  • LeykDErleyORidderDAge-related changes in marathon and half-marathon performancesInt J Sports Med200728651351717600902
  • KnechtleBRüstCARosemannTLepersRAge-related changes in 100-km ultra-marathon running performanceAge (Dordr)20123441033104521796378
  • KnothCKnechtleBRüstCARosemannTLepersRParticipation and performance trends in multi-stage ultra-marathons – The ‘Marathon des Sables’ from 2003–2012Extreme Physiology and Medicine2012In press
  • EichenbergerEKnechtleBRüstCARosemannTLepersRAge and gender interactions in mountain ultramarathon running – the Swiss Alpine MarathonOpen Access Journal of Sports Medicine201237380
  • KnechtleBRüstCARosemannTLepersRAge and gender differences in half-Ironman triathlon performances – the Ironman 70.3 Switzerland from 2007 to 2010Open Access Journal of Sports Medicine201235966
  • KnechtleBRüstCAKnechtlePRosemannTLepersRAge-related changes in ultra-triathlon performancesExtreme Physiology and Medicine20121523849327
  • BerthelotGLenSHellardPExponential growth combined with exponential decline explains lifetime performance evolution in individual and human speciesAge (Dordr)20123441001100921695422
  • FairbrotherJTAge-related changes in top-ten men’s US. Masters 50-m freestyle swim times as a function of finishing placePercept Mot Skills20071053 Pt 21289129318380129
  • Highscore list [webpage on the Internet]BernSchweizerischer Schwimmverband Available from: http://rankings.fsn.ch3242012 German
  • AvlonitouESomatometric variables for preadolescent swimmersJ Sports Med Phys Fitness19943421851917967588
  • GeladasNDNassisGPPavlicevicSSomatic and physical traits affecting sprint swimming performance in young swimmersInt J Sports Med200526213914415726490
  • JagomägiGJürimäeTThe influence of anthropometrical and flexibility parameters on the results of breaststroke swimmingAnthropol Anz200563221321915962572
  • ZampagniMLCasinoDBenelliPVisaniAMarcacciMDe VitoGAnthropometric and strength variables to predict freestyle performance times in elite master swimmersJ Strength Cond Res20082241298130718545175
  • KagawaMTaharaYMojiKNakaoRAoyagiKHillsAPSecular changes in growth among Japanese children over 100 years (1900–2000)Asia Pac J Clin Nutr201120218018921669586
  • SimsekFUlukolBGulnarSBThe secular trends in height and weight of Turkish school children during 1993–2003Child Care Health Dev200531444144715948881
  • MarmoDBZambonMPMorcilloAMGuimareyLMSecular trends of growth of schoolchildren from Paulínia, São Paulo-Brazil (1979/80–1993/94)Rev Assoc Med Bras2004504386390 Portuguese15666018
  • KurokawaNNakaiKSuzukiKTrends in growth status among schoolchildren in Sendai, Japan, 1994–2003: leveling-off of mean body height and weightTohoku J Exp Med2008216437137519060452
  • KrawczynskiMWalkowiakJKrzyzaniakASecular changes in body height and weight in children and adolescents in Poznan, Poland, between 1880 and 2000Acta Paediatr200392327728212725540
  • McLeanSPHinrichsRNSex differences in the centre of buoyancy location of competitive swimmersJ Sports Sci19981643733839663961
  • SeifertLBoulesteixLCholletDEffect of gender on the adaptation of arm coordination in front crawlInt J Sports Med200425321722315088247
  • SidersWALukaskiHCBolonchukWWRelationships among swimming performance, body composition and somatotype in competitive collegiate swimmersJ Sports Med Phys Fitness19933321661718412052
  • TuuriGLoftinMOescherJAssociation of swim distance and age with body composition in adult female swimmersMed Sci Sports Exerc200234122110211412471324
  • ZunigaJHoushTJMielkeMGender comparisons of anthropometric characteristics of young sprint swimmersJ Strength Cond Res201125110310820093967
  • BitarAVernetJCoudertJVermorelMLongitudinal changes in body composition, physical capacities and energy expenditure in boys and girls during the onset of pubertyEur J Nutr200039415716311079735
  • WheelerMDPhysical changes of pubertyEndocrinol Metab Clin North Am19912011142029881
  • StagerJMRobertshawDMiescherEDelayed menarche in swimmers in relation to age at onset of training and athletic performanceMed Sci Sports Exerc19841665505556513771
  • MartinDDHeckmannCJenniOGRankeMBBinderGThodbergHHMetacarpal thickness, width, length and medullary diameter in children – reference curves from the First Zürich Longitudinal StudyOsteoporos Int20112251525153620949257
  • MagareyAMBoultonTJChattertonBESchultzCNordinBECockingtonRABone growth from 11 to 17 years: relationship to growth, gender and changes with pubertal status including timing of menarcheActa Paediatr199988213914610102144
  • NevillAMWhyteGPHolderRLPeyrebruneMAre there limits to swimming world records?Int J Sports Med200728121012101717534781
  • EichenbergerEKnechtleBKnechtlePRüstCARosemannTLepersRNo gender difference in peak performance in ultra-endurance swimming performance – Analysis of the ‘Zurich 12-h Swim’ from 1996 to 2010Chinese Journal of Physiology20125534635123282209
  • EichenbergerEKnechtleBKnechtlePRüstCARosemannTLepersRBest performances by men and women open-water swimmers during the ‘English Channel Swim’ from 1900 to 2010J Sports Sci201230121295130122830602
  • EichenbergerEKnechtleBKnechtlePSex difference in open-water ultra-swim performance in the longest freshwater lake swim in Europe: Sex difference in ultra-swimmingJ Strength Cond Res Epub6282012
  • PendergastDRDi PramperoPECraigABJrWilsonDRRennieDWQuantitative analysis of the front crawl in men and womenJ Appl Physiol1977433475479914719
  • GrimstonSKHayJGRelationships among anthropometric and stroking characteristics of college swimmersMed Sci Sports Exerc198618160683959866
  • Pessoa FilhoDMAlvesFBReisJFGrecoCCDenadaiBSVO2 kinetics during heavy and severe exercise in swimmingInt J Sports Med201233974474822592546
  • AspenesSTKarlsenTExercise-training intervention studies in competitive swimmingSports Med201242652754322587822
  • RodriguezNRDi MarcoNMLangleySAmerican Dietetic Association, Dietitians of Canada, American College of Sports MedicineAmerican College of Sports Medicine position stand. Nutrition and athletic performanceMed Sci Sports Exerc200941370973119225360
  • WellsJCStockJTRe-examining heritability: genetics, life history and plasticityTrends Endocrinol Metab2011221042142821757369
  • WellsJCMaternal capital and the metabolic ghetto: an evolutionary perspective on the transgenerational basis of health inequalitiesAm J Hum Biol201022111719844897