Animal models of systemic sclerosis: their utility and limitations

Abstract

Without doubt, animal models have provided significant insights into our understanding of the rheumatological diseases; however, no model has accurately replicated all aspects of any autoimmune disease. Recent years have seen a plethora of knockouts and transgenics that have contributed to our knowledge of the initiating events of systemic sclerosis, an autoimmune disease. In this review, the focus is on models of systemic sclerosis and how they have progressed our understanding of fibrosis and vasculopathy, and whether they are relevant to the pathogenesis of systemic sclerosis.

Keywords:

• systemic sclerosis
• animal models
• vasculopathy
• fibrosis
• chicken
• mouse

Introduction

Systemic sclerosis is an autoimmune disease characterized by fibrosis of the skin and internal organs. It is a rare disease with orphan status in the USA. It has a prevalence of 240 cases per million adults, with an annual incidence of 20 cases per million adults.¹ The initiating events leading to systemic sclerosis are currently unknown, so understanding the factors driving this disease is difficult and animal models have therefore provided significant insights into its pathology. The hallmarks of systemic sclerosis are inflammation and autoimmunity, endothelial cell dysfunction leading to widespread vasculopathy, and progressive fibrosis.² Some of the earliest events in the pathology of systemic sclerosis result in microvascular abnormalities, such as endothelial injury leading to a perivascular infiltrate and neointimal thickening of the vessels. In addition, autoantibodies develop. Taken together, these factors culminate in progressive fibrosis that can affect the skin and internal organs, including the kidney, heart, lung, and gastrointestinal tract.

Systemic sclerosis is further divided into two subsets of disease that describe the pattern of skin fibrosis. Limited cutaneous systemic sclerosis includes a subset of patients with fibrosis limited to the distal extremities and with facial involvement, whereas diffuse cutaneous systemic sclerosis is characterized by fibrosis that is proximal to the knees and elbows. Internal organ involvement can occur in both subsets, and patients with diffuse cutaneous disease more frequently have organ involvement early on in their disease course and these patients have sooner morbidity and mortality than those with limited disease.

The autoantibody profile found in patients with systemic sclerosis defines the subset of disease (diffuse cutaneous or limited cutaneous) and can often predict internal organ involvement. Three dominant mutually exclusive autoantibody profiles are found to be associated with systemic sclerosis.³ These are the topoisomerase-1/Scl70 autoantibody associated with diffuse disease, the centromeric autoantibody associated with limited disease, and the autoantibodies against RNA polymerase I and III that are strongly associated with patients who have the diffuse subset and develop hypertensive renal disease.⁴

Animal models are important and have been used to study numerous aspects of disease that otherwise cannot be studied at length within the human population. They provide the opportunity to investigate genes or therapeutics without initial risk to humans. Rodents have a physiology and anatomy similar to that of man, and most models employ mice, given that over 95% of the mouse genome is similar to that in humans. Rodents have an accelerated lifespan, are small, require less space to house, and are cost-effective; as a result, a multitude of reagents have been developed for use. Rodent genes can be easily manipulated and genetically engineered for selective tissue expression to replicate human disease more accurately. However, animal models do not always replicate disease faithfully, and in many instances they are predictive such that they exhibit one or two features of a disease, rather than being homologous to the human illness by demonstrating all features of the disease.

Investigators researching systemic sclerosis have often borrowed models from other pathological diseases that exhibit features similar to those of fibrosis; for example, the models that were developed for the study of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis. However, while idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis may be more faithfully replicated in those models, it often falls short as a model for systemic sclerosis due to the systemic nature of the disease. The systemic nature of systemic sclerosis is probably the most profound difference between this and other fibrosing disorders where usually a specific organ is affected.

Not encompassing of all the models used to study the pathogenesis of systemic sclerosis, this review critically focuses on the benefits and disadvantages of some of the more commonly used models and a number of the recently developed animal models (Table 1). We also discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the avian model of systemic sclerosis.

Table 1 Prominent features of animal models of systemic sclerosis

	Fibrotic site	Vasculopathy	Inflammation	Autoantibody target
Spontaneous genetic models
Tsk1/+ mouse^Citation5,Citation8,Citation11	Dermis	Cardiomyopathy and abnormal vascular tone	Absent	Fibrillin-1
Tsk2/+ mouse^Citation29,Citation31,Citation32	Dermis	Absent	Modest inflammation	ANA, DNA topoisomerase I/Scl70
UCD-200 chicken^Citation35,Citation37	Skin and organs	Vascular occlusion	Perivascular infiltrate	ssDNA, histones, dsDNA
Inducible models
Bleomycin model^Citation51^–^Citation53	Skin and lung	Present	Peaks between days 3 and 5, then declines	Gastric mucosa
Hypochlorous model^Citation71,Citation73	Skin and lung	Vasculopathy of small renal arteries	Present in the dermis	Higher but not significant levels of DNA topoisomerase I/Scl70
Sclerodermatous GVHD^Citation78	Skin	Present	Inflammation and cytokine perturbations	DNA topoisomerase I/Scl70
Angiotensin II model^Citation79,Citation80	Present	Present, also has cardiovascular remodeling	Perivascular inflammation	Not reported
DNA topoisomerase I and CFA^Citation83	Skin and lung	Not reported	Cytokine perturbations and inflammation peaks at 8 weeks	DNA topoisomerase I/Scl70
Transgenic models
Endothelin-1^Citation87,Citation88	Kidney and lung	Reduced	Present	Not reported
FRA-2^Citation95,Citation96	Skin and lung	Present	Present	Not reported
Type I TGF-β receptor^Citation97	Dermis	Present	Absent	Not reported
Kinase-deficient type II TGF-β receptor^Citation102,Citation104	Dermis and lung	Absent but addition of a VEGFR inhibitor promoted vasculopathy	Not reported	Not reported
PDGFR-α^Citation107	Skin and organs	Not reported	Cytokine perturbations	DNA topoisomerase I/Scl70
Knockout models
Caveolin-1^Citation110,Citation111,Citation180	Dermis	Present	Increased inflammatory responses	Not reported
Egr-1^Citation119	Reduced fibrosis	Not reported	Reduced inflammation	Not reported
Fli1^Citation123	Skin	Present	Not reported	Not reported
MCP-1^Citation124	Reduced fibrosis	Not reported	Reduced inflammation	Not reported
mPGES-1^Citation128	Reduced fibrosis	Not reported	Reduced inflammation	Not reported
PPARγ^Citation131	Dermis	Not reported	Increased inflammation	Not reported
PTEN^Citation136	Dermis	Not reported	Not reported	Not reported
Relaxin^Citation139	Skin	Not reported	Not reported	Not reported

Abbreviations: ANA, antinuclear antibody; CFA, Freund’s complete adjuvant; MCP-1, macrophage chemoattractant protein-1; PPARγ, peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma; PTEN, phosphatase and tensin homolog; FRA-2, Fos-related antigen-2; Egr-1, early growth response gene; Fli1, Friend leukemia integration factor-1; TGF-β, transforming growth factor-beta; PDGFR, platelet-derived growth factor receptor; ssDNA, single-stranded DNA; dsDNA, double-stranded DNA; VEGFR, vascular endothelial growth factor receptor; GVHD, graft versus host disease; Tsk1/+, tight skin 1; Tsk2/+, tight skin 2; UCD-200, University of California at Davis line 200; mPGES-1, microsomal prostaglandin E2 synthase-1.

Genetic models of systemic sclerosis

There are three models of systemic sclerosis that have arisen by spontaneous mutations to the genome, resulting in increased extracellular matrix deposition. Two spontaneous mutations arose in mice and one in the chicken. All these models have proven to be useful in studying fibrosis and vasculopathy; however, the mutations present in these animals do not appear to be relevant to human disease from a genetic standpoint given that systemic sclerosis is not hereditary.

Tight skin 1 mouse model

This mouse was first reported in 1976 by Green et al,⁵ occurred as a result of spontaneous mutation in the B10.-D2(58N)/Sn strain, and was detected by a feeling of tethering in the skin in the interscapular region. The mutation is homozygous lethal and mice are bred as heterozygotes. These mice have thickened skin that is firmly bound to the subcutaneous tissue. There is loss of elasticity in the skin, although the mice have increased deposition of elastin.⁶ Due to the increased elastin, the mouse also displays an emphysema-like pathology in the lung tissue.⁷ The tight skin 1 (Tsk1/+) mouse has an enlarged heart and has been studied in the context of cardiomyopathy.⁸ It has also been reported to have an enlarged skeleton, with increased bone and cartilage growth.⁵ The mutation was found to be a partial duplication of the fibrillin-1 gene on chromosome 2.⁹ This mutation is thought to sequester increased levels of transforming growth factor (TGF)-β in the extracellular matrix, driving collagen synthesis.¹⁰ With identification of this mutation in the Tsk1/+ mouse and the presence of autoantibodies to fibrillin-1,¹¹ clinicians and researchers have tried to correlate this mouse better with systemic sclerosis. Autoantibodies found in patient serum were reported to be directed against fibrillin-1 in a study cohort of Choctaw Native American Indians.¹² A follow-up study failed to demonstrate fibrillin-1 autoantibodies in patients of other ethnicities with systemic sclerosis.¹³ Another study reported an association with a microsatellite marker near the fibrillin-1 gene in Choctaw Indians and Japanese patients with systemic sclerosis,^14,15 but this was not reproduced in other cohorts.^16,17 Further studies in systemic sclerosis have shown that the fibroblasts are able to assemble fibrillin-1 microfibrils but these fibrils are unstable, suggesting that there is an inherent defect in fibrillin-1 in systemic sclerosis.¹⁸

More recent analyses of fibrillin-1 have suggested that the mutations associated with this protein are correlated with stiff skin syndrome, which is an autosomal dominant congenital form of systemic sclerosis. Stiff skin syndrome is characterized by increased synthesis of fibrillin, elastin, and collagen. Microfibrillar assembly is increased but abnormal, and the microfibrils appear to be shorter. There is also increased activation of the TGF-β pathway, as indicated by the nuclear localization of Smad2 and expression of connective tissue growth factor.¹⁹ A mouse model employing the fibrillin-1 missense mutation identified in stiff skin syndrome was found to recapitulate fibrosis in the dermis, and this signaling was via α5β1 and αvβ3 integrins, which was driven by TGF-β.²⁰ Intriguingly, the stiff skin model had autoantibodies toward topoisomerase I.²⁰ Inflammation in the skin was also prominent and there was enrichment of plasmacytoid dendritic cells and Th2, Th17, and Th9 CD4 subpopulations.²⁰ The authors argued that the abnormal fibrillin-1 results in microfibrillar aggregates that fail to make adequate contact with cells but are able to retain the ability to sequester latent TGF-β, which becomes activated due to stiffness in the extracellular matrix resulting in a feed-forward signaling mechanism to drive fibrosis.²⁰ Integrins are known to sense the extracellular environment, and by that sensing are able to dictate the response of the fibroblast.^21–24 The stiff skin syndrome model hints at dysregulated signaling mechanisms driven by integrins that may be relevant for the pathology of systemic sclerosis; however, it does not address the etiology of systemic sclerosis because these fibrillin-1 mutations are not identified in the disease.

The Tsk1/+ mouse has been used to study the efficacy of various drugs for the treatment of fibrosis, and the model has proved valuable in this regard. Imatinib is a small-molecule tyrosine kinase inhibitor that is able to inhibit both TGF-β and platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) pathways. Imatinib prevents the development of inflammation-driven experimental fibrosis mediated by the drug bleomycin. Furthermore, imatinib reduced dermal thickening in the Tsk1/+ model,²⁵ suggesting the involvement of TGF-β and PDGF in the development of fibrosis in this model. Interferon-gamma therapy administered by nanoparticles also successfully reduced skin thickness in the Tsk1/+ mouse,²⁶ and edaravone, a free radical scavenger, decreased collagen synthesis,²⁷ as did rapamycin.²⁸

Tight skin 2 mouse model

The tight skin 2 (Tsk2/+) mouse was first described in 1986, and arose in the offspring of a 101/H mouse exposed to the mutagenic agent ethylnitrosourea. As with Tsk1/+, tight skin is found in the interscapular region.²⁹ The gene mutation is located on chromosome 1 between 42.5 and 52.5 Mb,³⁰ and to date the genetic defect has not been published. Like Tsk1/+, Tsk2/+ traits are highly penetrant and are homozygous embryonic lethal. Tsk2/+ mice replicate many features of systemic sclerosis, including tight skin, increased deposition of dermal extracellular matrix, and autoantibodies.^31,32 Tsk2/+ shows increased transcription rates of type I and III collagen in dermal fibroblasts,³³ suggesting that the increased collagen synthesis is cell autonomous rather than dependent on the integrity of the skin as a whole. Tsk2/+ mice were also reported to have increased autoimmunity, and a majority of the mice developed multiple autoantibodies specific for systemic sclerosis, including Scl70, centromere, and DNA.³² A restricted T-cell receptor bias was noted in skin infiltrates that encompasses specific T-cell receptor subtypes.³⁴ Until the genetic mutation has been identified, the value of this model cannot be fully realized. Another caveat to this model is that few laboratories choose to study it, possibly because the gene mutation is yet to be reported.

UCD-200 chicken

University of California at Davis line 200 (UCD-200) chickens develop a hereditary connective tissue disease that is similar in many ways to systemic sclerosis. It is characterized by a perivascular lymphocytic infiltration,³⁵ endothelial injury resulting in vascular occlusion,³⁶ speckled antinuclear antibodies,^37,38 and fibrosis of the skin and visceral organs.³⁷ During experiments to map the genetic mutation in UCD-200 chickens crossed with red jungle fowl chickens, it was noted that the F1 generation were disease-free, whereas 36% of the back-crossed population (F2 generation) had early onset avian systemic sclerosis and 61% had late onset avian systemic sclerosis. The incidence of avian systemic sclerosis was significantly higher in male chickens than in female chickens.³⁹ This suggests that the genetic defect in the UCD-200 line has an autosomal recessive mode of inheritance, or is comprised of multiple genetic loci or multiple loci interactions that are required to drive disease.³⁹ Five genes have been identified that confer a high association with the disease, and include TGFBR1, IGFBP3, EXOC2/IRF4, CCR8, and SOCS1. All of the genes are located on chromosome 2, with the exception of SOCS1, which is located on chromosome 14. All of these genes have been reported to have significance in the pathology of systemic sclerosis or to play a role in autoimmunity.^40–44 In addition, COL1A2 was found to be located in close proximity to the quantitative trait loci on chromosome 2, suggesting that this gene may play a role in avian systemic sclerosis. A shorter mRNA transcript has been identified in the early inflammatory stage in the comb and esophagus of diseased chickens.³⁹

Of the three known spontaneous genetic animal models, this model probably represents systemic sclerosis the closest in terms of its pathological features. Especially important to systemic sclerosis and the UCD-200 model is the perivascular infiltrate that precedes vasculopathy. Inflammation of the skin occurs early on in the disease, and this is predominantly found in the comb, which becomes swollen and erythematous. The vasculopathy appears to be driven by endothelial apoptosis.^36,38 Histology of the comb demonstrates that there is vessel occlusion with neointimal formation and a perivascular inflammatory infiltrate.³⁶ The model also has internal organ involvement. Autoantigens present in the sera include single-stranded DNA, double-stranded DNA, histones, poly(G), and cardiolipin; however, they did not reflect the antinuclear antibody spectrum that is observed in diffuse systemic sclerosis.⁴⁵ The caveats to this model are that few animal facilities are equipped to house these chickens, which require significantly more room than mice and have to be housed separately. Few laboratories have studied this model because most researchers prefer smaller animals with greater reagent resources.

Inducible models of fibrosis

Animal models predicated on inducing fibrosis in the mouse are of great value because they allow for study of the initiating events in fibrosis. These models have proven to be very useful. However, induction of fibrosis in animals is limited to a small number of chemicals, and sclerodermatous graft versus host disease (GVHD) is difficult to work with.

Bleomycin model of fibrosis

The bleomycin mouse model of fibrosis is commonly used to replicate systemic sclerosis, or dermal or pulmonary fibrosis. Bleomycin is a glycopeptide antibiotic produced by Streptomyces verticillus and has been used to treat Hodgkin’s lymphoma, squamous cell carcinoma, and testicular cancer, and is usually used in combination with other antineoplastic drugs.⁴⁶ It has also been used to treat plantar warts.⁴⁷ However, use of bleomycin is not without significant risks, and a systemic sclerosis-like syndrome can ensue in susceptible individuals.^48–50 This observation paved the way for development of the bleomycin mouse model of fibrosis by Yamamoto et al.⁵¹ Local dermal injections of bleomycin in mice induced collagen synthesis at the injection site over 4 weeks. The overall effects were found to be systemic because the lung also showed increased collagen synthesis.⁵¹ The sensitivity to bleomycin was found to be strain-specific, and skin thickening was greater in some strains than in others. Yamamoto et al⁵² found that fibrosis was induced by approximately two-fold in C3H/He, DBA/2, B10.D2, and B10.A strains, and that dermal thickness was increased by more than 2.5-fold in A/J, C3H/He, B10.A, and B10.D2 strains. One of the initiating events in bleomycin-induced fibrosis is mediated by inflammation. During the first 3–5 days of injections, there is a peak in the skin inflammatory infiltrate which then decreases with extended treatment. Bleomycin has been reported to induce vascular changes in the skin at the injection site.⁵³ Upon withdrawal of bleomycin, the fibrosis resolves over time. Investigators usually terminate the study prior to resolution, but this model could be utilized in study pathways involved in the resolution of fibrosis. In a similar manner, skin involved in systemic sclerosis appears to soften during the course of the disease.⁵⁴ The model replicates some of the most important biomarkers of systemic sclerosis but is by its very nature a model with limited uses.

There are several modes for administration of bleomycin that have been used to induce fibrosis depending on the organ to be investigated. As described above, bleomycin can be injected subdermally to induce synthesis of collagen; however, this is labor-intensive and has to be performed daily for 3–4 weeks for a robust fibrotic lesion to develop. In addition to the skin becoming fibrotic, this method also causes lung fibrosis.⁵⁵ A single administration of bleomycin via intratracheal instillation in weight-adjusted dosages is frequently used to study pulmonary fibrosis. The fibrotic stage exists until 3–4 weeks post-administration.⁵⁶ There can be a poorer survival rate depending on the strain of mouse used.⁵⁷ Finally, bleomycin can be administered via Alzet^® osmotic pumps (DURECT Corporation, Cupertino, CA, USA) that are embedded under the skin and deliver a constant amount of compound over a certain number of days, making this approach to administration convenient on many levels. When used with bleomycin, the mortality observed in mice is significantly less than with intratracheal instillation.⁵⁸ Further, this method induces a pattern of interstitial lung disease that replicates the lung pathology of systemic sclerosis and produces fibrosis in the skin and internal organs also in a pattern that is similar to systemic sclerosis.⁵⁸

Bleomycin activates the NLRP3 inflammasome, leading to downstream signaling events in fibroblasts and resulting in synthesis of collagen.⁵⁵ Many of the signals that result in activation of the NLRP3 inflammasome are still being elucidated. Reactive oxygen species, oxidative stress, and the mitochondria are integrally involved in activation of the NLRP3 inflammasome.^59,60 Bleomycin induces oxidative stress^61,62 by activating the mitochondria, and it is this induction of oxidative stress that activates the inflammasome. Further evidence in support of this finding is that cells depleted of mitochondria are resistant to bleomycin-induced activation.⁶³ To further underscore the importance of reactive oxygen species and oxidative stress in this model, fibrosis was found to be abrogated when N-acetylcysteine was administered.⁶⁴ The culmination of inflammasome assembly and activation results in cleavage of caspase-1, which is then able to cleave interleukin (IL)-1β and IL-18 for secretion, leading to fibrosis.⁵⁵ IL-1β and IL-18 were found to be elevated in systemic sclerosis serum^65,66 and it was not until our laboratory specifically studied the involvement of the inflammasome in the dermal fibrosis component of systemic sclerosis that the association between an activated inflammasome, fibrosis, and systemic sclerosis was found.⁵⁵ Further, we found that activated caspase-1 was driving the increased collagen synthesis and myofibroblast phenotype.⁵⁵

Although the bleomycin model replicates some of the earliest signaling patterns observed in systemic sclerosis, the model does not present with the profound autoantibody patterns typical of systemic sclerosis, but the mouse can establish an autoantibody that cross-reacts with the gastric mucosa.⁶⁷

Hypochlorous model of systemic sclerosis

Reactive oxygen species have been implicated in the pathogenesis of systemic sclerosis, and systemic sclerosis monocytes⁶⁸ and fibroblasts⁶⁹ release increased amounts of reactive oxygen species, which triggers synthesis of collagen. The endoplasmic reticulum itself can induce reactive oxygen species and can also induce mitochondrial-reactive oxygen species,⁷⁰ suggesting that increased reactive oxygen species may play a central role in the fibrosis component of systemic sclerosis.

The hypochlorous mouse model is a newly developed inducible animal model, and provides further important insights into the initiating signals derived from the reactive oxygen species that promote fibrosis. The hypochlorous mouse model is induced by repeated intradermal injections of hypochlorous acid, which causes generation of hydroxyl radicals leading to increased synthesis of collagen in the skin and lung tissues. In addition, this model mimics the pathological changes observed in the systemic sclerosis kidney and induces anti-topoisomerase antibodies.⁷¹ The downside of this model at the moment is that it is currently only used by two laboratories to study the initiating events of fibrosis,^72–74 and it is not fully understood how hypochlorous acid induces fibrosis. It has been shown that overproduction of reactive oxygen species in this model activates ADAM17, which is involved in NOTCH signaling.⁷³ However, this model, like the bleomycin model, has proved to be useful in the testing of various candidate molecules for the prevention of fibrosis.^73,74

Sclerodermatous GVHD model

This model has been used to understand further some of the initiating factors that lead to systemic sclerosis, and is derived from the initial observations of dermal fibrosis induced in patients with chronic GVHD. Thus, this mouse model was developed and then characterized. The model demonstrates increased collagen synthesis as in systemic sclerosis, and the fibrotic changes were found to be driven by TGF-β because inhibition of TGF-β abrogated the progression of fibrosis.⁷⁵ Unlike systemic sclerosis, mice with sclerodermatous GVHD have a significant inflammatory infiltrate consisting of T-cells and monocytes/macrophages, and the numbers of inflammatory cells in the lesions are directly dependent on TGF-β.⁷⁶ Patients with systemic sclerosis generally do not present with such an infiltrate, and the few T-cells found in the lesions tend to be perivascular.⁷⁷

A modified model of GVHD was then developed and found to exhibit all the major aspects of systemic sclerosis. GVHD was developed in the RAG-2 knockout mouse by the transfer of B10.D2 spleen cells.⁷⁸ GVHD develops over time, and the model shows progressive skin thickening with disease duration. The kidneys and large and small intestines were found to be fibrotic. Vasoconstriction was reported, increased α-smooth muscle actin and endothelin-1 were found in the vessels of the skin and kidney, and anti-Scl70 antibodies were found in the serum. This model characterizes many of the features of systemic sclerosis, and of note, renal crisis was one of the pathologies observed. TGF-β was found to be elevated, and neutralization of TGF-β with antibodies reduced skin thickness and the ensuing vasculopathy.⁷⁸

Angiotensin II-inducible model of fibrosis

This is a recently developed model that uses angiotensin II to induce vascular constriction, leading to inflammation and fibrosis.⁷⁹ Using Alzet osmotic pumps, angiotensin II was found to induce dermal fibrosis by activating the TGF-β pathway, and increases were found in TGF-β2 and TGF-β3 but not in TGF-β1 mRNA. Angiotensin II was also found to increase the numbers of myofibroblasts and fibrocytes in the skin.⁷⁹ Increased numbers of vascular endothelial (VE)-cadherin and fibroblast-specific protein-1-positive cells were observed around the small vessels in this mouse model, suggesting increased endothelial to mesenchymal transition. The model also includes cardiovascular remodeling.⁸⁰ However, it is unknown whether these mice develop autoantibodies specific for systemic sclerosis.⁷⁹

The hypochlorous mouse model was used to test the hypothesis that angiotensin II receptor blockade could ameliorate fibrosis. Irbesartan, an angiotensin II receptor inhibitor, was found to reduce dermal thickness and total collagen content, with less inflammation, and to reduce anti-topoisomerase I antibodies.⁸¹ This suggests that angiotensin levels can be regulated by oxidative stress and play a critical role in the fibrosis component of systemic sclerosis, and it has been found that a subset of patients have elevated angiotensin II signaling.⁸²

Model induced by DNA topoisomerase I and Freund’s complete adjuvant

Autoimmunity is a significant feature in systemic sclerosis, and yet few investigators have developed models that specifically investigate this specific aspect of its pathology. Yoshizaki et al⁸³ demonstrated that subcutaneous administration of DNA topoisomerase I and Freund’s complete adjuvant for 8 weeks promoted dermal and lung fibrosis. Adjuvant lacking mycobacterial components (Freund’s incomplete adjuvant) did not induce fibrosis. Cytokine perturbations included increased levels of IL-4, interferon-gamma, IL-10, TGF-β, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha.⁸³ Bronchoalveolar lavage fluid was analyzed and the investigators found that the T-cell profile was skewed toward Th2 and Th17 in mice receiving DNA topoisomerase I and Freund’s complete adjuvant, and in the mice receiving DNA topoisomerase I and Freund’s incomplete adjuvant, and in the IL-6 deficient mice it was skewed toward Th1 and regulatory T-cells. This study raises the provocative possibility that an antibody directed against topoisomerase I could promote fibrosis.

Transgenic models of fibrosis

These models are important for understanding the role of the specific genes that contribute to fibrosis. Many of these models have been utilized from investigators outside the field of systemic sclerosis who study other forms of fibrosis. However, this should not detract from the importance of these models and what they tell us about the role of a particular gene in regulating collagen synthesis.

Endothelin-1 mouse model

Damage to endothelial cells causes increased expression of endothelin-1. The effects of overexpression of endothelin-1 were found to be deleterious to the vasculature and to contribute to hypertrophy of the vessels and vascular permeability, leading to vasoconstriction.⁸⁴ Endothelin-1 also plays a role in increased cell proliferation, fibrosis, and inflammation.^85,86 The transgenic mouse develops glomerulosclerosis and interstitial fibrosis.^87,88 Patients with systemic sclerosis have increased tissue and circulatory endothelin-1 levels as well as increased vasculopathy, and these findings underscore the importance of this protein in the pathology of systemic sclerosis.^89,90

Bosentan is an endothelin-1 antagonist and has been used successfully to treat pulmonary hypertension in systemic sclerosis.^91,92 Tsk1/+ mice were found to have impaired aortic relaxation, suggesting a role for endothelin-1,⁹³ and this led to the study of bosentan in these mice.⁹⁴ With bosentan, there was partial restoration of the relaxation capability of the vessels in Tsk1/+ mice, suggesting that these mice have endothelial dysfunction.⁹⁴ More specifically, endothelin-1 promoted increased expression of endothelin receptor B, but not endothelin receptor A, in Tsk1/+ mice.

Fos-related antigen-2 mouse model

The transgenic mouse model overexpressing the Fos-related antigen-2 (FRA-2) gene demonstrates many of the important factors resulting in the vasculopathy of systemic sclerosis. The FRA-2 transgenic animal displays microangiopathy in addition to progressive skin fibrosis. Overall, it was found that this pathology was preceded by apoptosis of endothelial cells.⁹⁵ FRA-2 is a transcription factor activator protein and belongs to the activator protein-1 family. This family is induced by cellular stress, and as a result, controls many of the downstream responses in the cell, such as cell proliferation, apoptosis, inflammation, tumorigenesis, and wound healing. In light of this, it was found that expression of FRA-2 was independent of the expression of major cytokines such as TGF-β1 and PDGF, and both are important cytokines driving the pathology of systemic sclerosis. However, overexpression of FRA-2 is apparent in the skin lesions of systemic sclerosis, suggesting there may be a direct causal involvement in fibrosis⁹⁵ and that it may also play a role in vasculopathy.⁹⁶

Type I TGF-β receptor transgenic model

A model was developed to specifically upregulate the type I TGF-β receptor in fibroblasts on a Cre-ER transgenic background. In this model, with progressing age, there were increasing levels of collagen deposition in the skin of the mouse. In addition, the ultrastructure of collagen was found to be disorganized. Vascular changes similar to systemic sclerosis were apparent, with hypertrophy of smooth muscle cells and neointimal thickening of vessel walls. Mice had increased levels of von Willebrand factor, which is similar to what is observed in systemic sclerosis, leading to the hypothesis that sustained activation of TGF-β signaling in fibroblasts can lead to endothelial damage.⁹⁷ Vascular smooth muscle cells from this mouse demonstrate enhanced remodeling of collagen gel lattices with altered endothelin-1 and endothelin receptor signaling. This model further replicates other features of the pathology of systemic sclerosis in that it has myocardial fibrosis and altered aortic dynamics. As expected, activation of the TGF-β pathway caused increased phosphorylation of Smad2/3 in fibroblasts, leading to increased phosphorylation of ERK1/2 and p38.⁹⁷ This model suggests that chronic expression of TGF-β in fibroblasts could cause the pathology observed in systemic sclerosis; however, some investigators believe that damage to endothelial cells is one of the leading culprits in initiating and driving the disease.^98–100

Kinase-deficient type II TGF-β receptor transgenic model

This model was developed when a fibroblast-specific transcriptional enhancer was identified upstream of the COL1A2 collagen gene.¹⁰¹ The enhancer was used to specifically express a kinase-deficient mutant type II TGF-β receptor that can engage TGF-β but cannot lead to phosphorylation of TGF-β receptor 1 and its downstream signaling pathways.¹⁰² The directed expression of the kinase-deficient type II TGF-β receptor resulted in increased fibrosis in the lung and skin. The transgenic fibroblasts were found to have a TGF-β activated phenotype with sustained induced expression of connective tissue growth factor and increased phosphorylation of Smad2/3,¹⁰² and increased myofibroblast numbers.¹⁰³ Although this transgenic model allows for the study of TGF-β signaling, caveats are the lack of immune activation and the fact that autoantibodies are not present. In addition, the transgenic model does not have vasculopathy; however, when a vascular endothelial growth factor receptor inhibitor is administered to these mice, they develop pulmonary arterial hypertension pathology similar to that observed in systemic sclerosis.¹⁰⁴

PDGF receptor-α transgenic model of fibrosis

PDGF has been implicated in the development of the fibrosis and vasculopathy seen in systemic sclerosis.^105,106 Olson and Soriano investigated the role of the PDGF receptor-α in fibrosis.¹⁰⁷ They designed transgenic mice to carry conditionally expressed PDGF receptor-α activating mutations that promoted fibrosis in the skin and internal organs. The importance of PDGF signaling during fibrosis was further recapitulated utilizing sunitinib and sorafenib,¹⁰⁸ two tyrosine kinase inhibitors that act to block the bioactivity of PDGF receptors and the vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)/VEGF receptor pathway. This study demonstrated that inhibition of phosphorylation of PDGF receptor-β with sunitinib effectively reduced skin and lung fibrosis. Sorafenib was not as effective for reduction of fibrosis; however, it significantly reduced the DNA topoisomerase I autoantibodies, IL-6 and TGF-β.¹⁰⁸ As discussed previously, imatinib, a TGF-β and PDGF pathway inhibitor, effectively reduced Tsk1/+ dermal fibrosis,²⁵ adding further credence to the value of tyrosine kinase inhibitors.

Knockout models of fibrosis

These models study the specific contribution of a gene in fibrosis. In some instances, the gene is a negative regulator of collagen synthesis and its deletion promotes fibrosis, whereas other genes are required for induction of the fibrotic process.

Caveolin-1

Caveolin is found to be expressed within the lipid rafts of the caveolae in the cell membranes and functions to modulate the functioning of various signaling molecules.¹⁰⁹ It was noted that caveolin-1-deficient mice had increased alveolar septa and lung fibrosis. In addition, these mice were found to have altered vasculopathy due to endothelial proliferation.¹¹⁰ On closer examination of the systemic sclerosis phenotype and the phenotypic changes, these mice were observed to have increased collagen and fibronectin accumulation, in addition to increased numbers of myofibroblasts.¹¹¹ It is now known that caveolin-1 regulates TGF-β signaling by interacting with the type I TGF-β receptor and regulating Smad signaling pathways by suppression of phosphorylation of Smad2¹¹² and inhibiting ERK signaling.¹¹³ However, TGF-β decreases expression of caveolin-1.¹¹⁴ Further, it has been found that loss of caveolin-1 can lead to oxidative stress¹¹⁵ and this is a pathology that has been associated with systemic sclerosis.^116,117

Early growth response protein-1 knockout mouse

Early growth response protein-1 (Egr-1) is a transcription factor that is a zinc finger binding protein and is involved in cell growth, differentiation, and survival. It is induced by stress signals.¹¹⁸ Egr-1-deficient mice were injected with bleomycin and skin fibrosis was assessed. There were decreased numbers of infiltrating inflammatory cells in the skin in addition to decreased dermal thickness and collagen expression.¹¹⁹ The signaling events downstream from Egr-1 play a role in collagen fibril formation because mice deficient in this protein have disorganized collagen fibers. Furthermore, bleomycin-induced lung fibrosis was attenuated in the absence of Egr-1, as was the ability to induce wound healing, and the absence of Egr-1 inhibited wound closure in in vitro scratch wound assays.¹¹⁹ In confirmation of the importance of Egr-1 in wound healing, an Egr-1 transgenic mouse was tested and found to enhance wound healing. This further demonstrates the importance of this transcription factor in the synthesis of collagen, wound healing, and fibrosis.

Friend leukemia integration factor-1 conditional knockout mouse

This model recapitulates many of the features of systemic sclerosis in that it has abnormalities of the vasculature.¹²⁰ Friend leukemia integration factor-1 (Fli1) is constitutively expressed in fibroblasts and plays a pivotal role in inhibiting the expression of extracellular matrix proteins, such as connective tissue growth factor and type I collagen.¹²¹ However, more recently, Fli1 was demonstrated to modulate endothelial cell function and to be involved during vascular development. The Fli1 conditional knockout mouse has increased vascular permeability, and this closely mimics the permeability observed in patients with systemic sclerosis due to reduced expression of VE-cadherin.¹²² Collagen fiber formation is dependent on Fli1¹²³ and this model further mimics the abnormalities in collagen fibril formation in systemic sclerosis, further confirming the importance of Fli1 in the pathogenesis of systemic sclerosis. Phosphorylation of Fli1 and its interaction with p300 transcription factor is also dependent on TGF-β, thus underscoring further the importance of this cytokine in the pathology of systemic sclerosis.

Macrophage chemoattractant protein-1 mouse model

The involvement of basic fibroblast growth factor and connective tissue growth factor in conjunction with macrophage chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1) is required for tissue fibrosis.¹²⁴ MCP-1-deficient mice show abrogated fibrotic responses when basic fibroblast growth factor and connective tissue growth factor are injected into the skin. In addition, this model has reduced macrophage recruitment, fewer mast cells, and fewer CD4+ T-cell numbers.¹²⁴ Connective tissue growth factor alone does not induce fibrosis, but when administered with basic fibroblast growth factor, there is increased autocrine signaling along with persistent fibrosis. MCP-1, basic fibroblast growth factor, and connective tissue growth factor are proteins that are regulated by TGF-β.^125–127 The correlation and interaction between MCP-1, basic fibroblast growth factor, and connective tissue growth factor indicates the importance of the interplay between these three proteins in fibrosis.

Microsomal prostaglandin E2 synthase-1 knockout model

Microsomal prostaglandin E2 synthase-1 (mPGES-1) is an inducible enzymatic protein that acts downstream of cyclo oxygenase. It specifically causes the conversion of prostaglandin H₂ to prostaglandin E₂. mPGES-1 was found to be overexpressed in systemic sclerosis fibroblasts, suggesting that this pathway is dysregulated.¹²⁸ Mice deficient in mPGES-1 are resistant to bleomycin-induced fibrosis, have decreased levels of α-smooth muscle actin, and reduced numbers of macrophages,¹²⁸ further underscoring the importance of this gene in fibrosis.

Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma

Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma (PPARγ) has been associated with the pathology of numerous diseases, including obesity, diabetes, atherosclerosis, and cancer. More recently, decreased PPARγ has been shown to be associated with fibrosis.¹²⁹ PPARγ is a nuclear receptor ligand-activated transcription factor that is decreased by TGF-β1 signaling. PPARγ inhibits collagen synthesis,¹³⁰ whereas TGF-β inhibits PPARγ expression,¹³¹ and is thus involved in the fibrotic response in systemic sclerosis. Kapoor et al further explored the role of PPARγ in fibrosis and found that conditional PPARγ-deficient mice developed greater skin thickening with bleomycin when compared with wild-type mice.¹³² Skin thickening was assessed by analysis of total collagen content, increased α-smooth muscle actin expression, and increased inflammation.¹³² In confirmation of this finding, rosiglitazone, a PPARγ agonist, was found to decrease fibrosis in the bleomycin mouse model.¹²⁹ Further, rosiglitazone was also effective in reducing already established fibrosis.¹²⁹ Inhibition of PPARγ with rosiglitazone and the PPARγ knockout mouse have helped to define the role of this protein in collagen synthesis. It is unknown if this model sees increased vascular remodeling, as it was not reported, but PPARγ is known to play a role in this process.¹³³

PTEN conditional knockout mouse model

Phosphatase and tensin homolog (PTEN) is a protein lipid phosphatase that activates Akt via phosphorylation, and the phosphoinositide 3-kinase-Akt signaling axis has been implicated in the production of collagen.¹³⁴ Akt phosphorylation is elevated in systemic sclerosis fibroblasts¹³⁵ and PTEN levels are decreased.¹³⁶ Regulation of PTEN is dependent on TGF-β; however, PTEN knockout mice have increased collagen deposition and thickened skin, in addition to increased numbers of proliferating cell nuclear antigen-positive fibroblasts, increased numbers of α-smooth muscle actin-bearing fibroblasts, and increased numbers of connective tissue growth factor-positive fibroblasts.¹³⁶ The data from this mouse model suggest that PTEN normally suppresses fibrogenesis and its absence spontaneously promotes collagen synthesis.

Relaxin knockout mouse

Relaxin is a small dimeric peptide that is generally associated with the female reproductive tract, and is known to be a vasodilator but also has antifibrotic effects.^137,138 Mice deficient in relaxin were found to have increased collagen deposition in the skin over time. Administration of human recombinant relaxin via osmotic minipumps abrogated fibrosis in this model.¹³⁹ This knockout mouse has been used to study other fibrotic diseases, such as liver fibrosis due to administration of carbon tetrachloride,¹⁴⁰ and cardiac fibrosis,¹⁴¹ and silica-induced pulmonary fibrosis.¹⁴² In all cases, relaxin was found to ameliorate collagen synthesis. This suggests that relaxin regulates collagen synthesis and could be used as a therapy for fibrotic diseases.

Using mouse models for preclinical testing

There are no formal guidance documents from the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requiring the use of animal models of efficacy for preclinical studies of a particular drug candidate prior to human clinical testing. However, the FDA does require various toxicological and pharmacological safety studies to ensure that the drug candidate and the final formulated drug product is reasonably safe before proceeding to human clinical testing. These toxicological and pharmacological safety studies are usually performed in rodent and canine species, but may include other species (porcine for example) if physiologically relevant to the drug candidate being tested or therapeutic area being targeted. Certainly from this perspective, a model replicating all or some of the aspects of disease is not required. However, in light of this, the efficacy of a potential drug candidate in preclinical studies has usually been required by pharmaceutical companies prior to investment of significant financial resources in clinical trials and in bringing the product to market. In addition, animal models have been used in proof-of-concept studies to investigate the role of a particular protein or pathway, or to test inhibitors or reagents identified more often than not at the coal face by academic researchers. Even so, success in an animal model has not always translated into a successful treatment for the patient (Table 2). Due to the polymorphic nature of the disease, until the cause (or causes) of systemic sclerosis are identified, a drug that treats all symptoms of the disease may not be realistic. Indeed, it may be that multiple treatment regimens are required to manage symptoms.

Table 2 Preclinical testing of drugs in mice and their outcome in systemic sclerosis

Drug	Mode of action	Efficacy in mice	Efficacy in SSc
Anakinra	IL-1 receptor antagonist	Effectively blocked pulmonary fibrosis in the bleomycin model^Citation143	Currently undergoing clinical trial, but no data are available
Bosentan	Endothelin-1 receptor antagonist	Tested in the Tsk1/+ mouse and shown to effectively reduce moderate vasculopathy^Citation94 and shown to be effective against bleomycin- induced pulmonary fibrosis^Citation181	Drug well tolerated and the data suggest that bosentan may be effective at stabilizing or improving the microcirculation in SSc^Citation166,Citation167
Colchicine	Inhibits mitosis	This drug demonstrated moderate protection against pulmonary fibrosis^Citation153 but was not tested for skin fibrosis	One study reported clinical improvement^Citation182 whereas other studies report no improvement^Citation154,Citation155
Cyclophosphamide	Nitrogen mustard alkylating agent	Use of bleomycin and cyclophosphamide as chemotherapeutic drugs is associated with side effects including toxicity to the respiratory system^Citation176 Their coadministration may enhance lung toxicity which may subsequently progress to the lung fibrosis	One year of oral cyclophosphamide in patients with symptomatic scleroderma-related interstitial lung disease had a significant but modest beneficial effect on lung function, dyspnea, thickening of the skin, and health-related quality of life^Citation177
Cyclosporin A	Immunosuppressant	Studies show efficacy at ameliorating bleomycin induced lung fibrosis^Citation144,Citation145	Limited studies in SSc patients; however, patients on cyclosporine appear to do well^Citation146 but not without a significant risk of renal toxicity^Citation147
Etanercept	TNF inhibitor	Effective at reducing bleomycin-induced dermal fibrosis^Citation156	Shown to be useful at treating inflammatory joint diseases in SSc^Citation157 but may not be effective against fibrosis^Citation158 and could be fatal^Citation159
Halofuginone	Inhibits collagen synthesis and Th17 differentiation	Effectively reduced fibrosis in Tsk1/+ mice, and mice with chronic GVHD^Citation165	Five of 12 SSc patients demonstrated efficacy in a small pilot study^Citation165 A larger clinical trial has not been performed
Imatinib	Tyrosine kinase inhibitor	Reduced dermal and hypodermal thickening in the Tsk1/+ mouse and reduced overt fibrosis in the bleomycin mouse model^Citation25	Frequent adverse events with poor tolerability^Citation160
Iloprost	Prostacyclin agonist	Iloprost has a protective effect on bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis^Citation161	Heterogeneous results of small trials make the efficacy of iloprost hard to assess^Citation162,Citation163
Losartan	Angiotensin II receptor antagonist	Losartan had an inhibitory effect on bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis^Citation168,Citation169	Short-term study demonstrated efficacy for treating Raynaud’s phenomenon; however, no studies have been published to suggest it might be effective against fibrosis
Methotrexate	Inhibits folic acid metabolism	No efficacy against bleomycin^Citation175	A recent study suggested that methotrexate did not significantly alter the skin score^Citation173 but seems successful in treating juvenile localized SSc^Citation174
Minocycline	Antibiotic	Not tested	Failed open-label trial^Citation172
Mycophenolate mofetil	Immunosuppressant	Mycophenolate mofetil was able to prevent the development of bleomycin-induced dermal fibrosis^Citation149	In a small study, mycophenolate mofetil demonstrated efficacy^Citation150
Pirfenidone	Antifibrotic/anti-inflammatory	Pirfenidone effectively prevented bleomycin-induced^Citation183 or cyclophosphamide- induced pulmonary fibrosis^Citation184	The clinical trial is currently recruiting and may be useful to treat lung fibrosis^Citation185
Prednisone	Immunosuppressant	Not tested	Promotes renal complications in SSc patients^Citation148
Relaxin	Modulation of systemic and vascular tone	Relaxin abrogated bleomycin-induced lung fibrosis^Citation138	Initial studies demonstrated efficacy in SSc;^Citation186 however a larger comprehensive cohort failed to show efficacy^Citation170
Rilonacept	A fusion protein between IL-1 receptor and IL-1 accessory protein	Not tested	Currently recruiting SSc patients and no data are available for this drug (NCT01538719)
Rituximab	Targets B-cells	Not tested	A moderately large cohort showed reduced fibrosis and inhibition of worsening of disease when treated with rituximab^Citation187
Terguride	Serotonin inhibitor	Terguride effectively reduced skin fibrosis in the bleomycin model^Citation188	An ongoing clinical trial since 2010 in Europe, but no data have been published to date
Thalidomide	Not completely known, but thought to be an IL-6 inhibitor or a Th1/Th2 modulator	Thalidomide successfully reduced pulmonary fibrosis^Citation189 Pomalidomide, an analog of thalidomide, effectively reduced skin fibrosis^Citation190	Clinical trial for thalidomide was terminated due to difficulty in recruiting subjects A pomalidomide study is currently underway (NCT01559129)

Abbreviations: IL, interleukin; SSc, systemic sclerosis; Tsk1/+, tight skin 1; GVHD, graft versus host disease; TNF, tumor necrosis factor; Th, T helper.

Anakinra is an IL-1R antagonist and has shown efficacy in treating IL-1-related diseases that are driven by inflammasome activation. Anakinra was effective at blocking bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis,¹⁴³ and clinical trials are currently underway to determine whether it will be effective in systemic sclerosis. Systemic sclerosis was not originally thought of as an IL-1-mediated disease until recently;⁵⁵ however, IL-1 expression can drive TGF-β signaling, and inhibition of this innate immune signaling pathway may also lead to inhibition of fibrosis in systemic sclerosis. Rilonacept is another drug that interferes with IL-1 signaling. This drug was never studied in preclinical models; however, a clinical trial is currently underway in patients with systemic sclerosis although no results are available.

Several immunosuppressants have been tested in preclinical models and in systemic sclerosis clinical trials with mixed success. Cyclosporine demonstrated some efficacy in preventing bleomycin-induced lung fibrosis;^144,145 however, although some patients with systemic sclerosis tolerated the drug,¹⁴⁶ there is a significant risk of renal toxicity.¹⁴⁷ Likewise, prednisone can promote renal toxicity in patients and their renal function has to be closely monitored.¹⁴⁸

Mycophenolate mofetil is an immunosuppressant that prevents the purine biosynthesis necessary for development of T-cells and B-cells. It is currently used to treat other autoimmune diseases. This drug successfully prevented bleomycin-induced fibrosis¹⁴⁹ and was successful in a small study of patients with systemic sclerosis;¹⁵⁰ however, larger studies are currently underway and it is currently unknown as to whether this drug will hold up to close scrutiny.

Thalidomide has emerged as an immunomodulating therapeutic and is thought to modulate the Th1/Th2 profile by inhibiting tumor necrosis factor-alpha, IL-6, IL-10, and IL-12, and by enhancing the production of IL-2, IL-4, and IL-5 by immune cells.¹⁵¹ It has also been reported to increase the lymphocyte count, induce costimulation of T-cells, and alter the cytotoxicity of natural killer cells.¹⁵¹ Thalidomide and its analogs could abrogate fibrosis in mouse models, paving the way for this drug to be trialed in patients. In a small pilot study of patients with systemic sclerosis, thalidomide was found to enhance the healing of digital ulcers.¹⁵² However, to date, there has been some difficulty in recruiting patients for a long-term clinical trial and the study was terminated.

Colchicine, a drug that inhibits mitosis, was demonstrated to afford some protection against bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis.¹⁵³ However, when used to treat systemic sclerosis, there was mixed success in the clinical trials.^154,155 Inhibition of tumor necrosis factor-alpha by etanercept was effective in treating bleomycin-induced dermal fibrosis;¹⁵⁶ however, when trialed in systemic sclerosis, the drug appeared to effectively reduce the inflammatory joint disease seen in these patients¹⁵⁷ but did not appear to be efficacious against fibrosis,¹⁵⁸ and is not without risk for fatal fibrosing alveolitis.¹⁵⁹

Imatinib, a tyrosine kinase inhibitor, was initially promising as a therapeutic and was found to reduce the fibrosis in the Tsk1/+ mouse and the inducible bleomycin model;²⁵ however, when used in patients, adverse events were frequently observed and tolerability was poor.¹⁶⁰ Iloprost, a prostacyclin agonist, also effectively reduced bleomycin-induced fibrosis;¹⁶¹ however, there were heterogeneous responses in small patient cohorts and this has made the efficacy of iloprost hard to assess.^162,163

Halofuginone has been shown to interfere with collagen synthesis. It does so by inhibiting TGF-β signaling through a process that prevents phosphorylation of Smad3.¹⁶⁴ The drug has been used in Tsk1/+ mice and in mice with chronic GVHD, and both models demonstrated a significant reduction in fibrosis.¹⁶⁵ However, when halofuginone was used topically in a small pilot study on 12 patients with systemic sclerosis, five patients responded by demonstrating a significant reduction in skin score whereas seven did not respond.¹⁶⁵ A larger follow-up clinical trial has not been performed.

Bosentan was found to effectively reduce moderate vasculopathy in the Tsk1/+ mouse⁹⁴ and was effective in preventing bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis.^166,167 Bosentan has been used to ameliorate the microcirculation, helping to reduce Raynaud’s phenomenon. Losartan, an angiotensin II receptor inhibitor, was also effective for the treatment of Raynaud’s phenomenon, but to date the studies have not been formally published. However, losartan was found to reduce bleomycin-induced pulmonary fibrosis.^168,169 Both drugs lend credence to targeting abnormalities in the vasculature as valid therapeutics for systemic sclerosis. Relaxin is a small dimeric peptide that regulates vascular tone and also has an antifibrotic mode of action. The relaxin-deficient mouse suggested that this molecule could be used to treat fibrosis and this was confirmed with bleomycin studies; however, when trialed in systemic sclerosis, there were mixed results and overall relaxin was not effective at reducing fibrosis.¹⁷⁰

Much controversy is centered on the antibiotic minocycline as to whether it is effective in treating systemic sclerosis. One small clinical study demonstrated that four of eleven patients had complete remission of disease,¹⁷¹ which sparked huge interest in minocycline as a treatment for patients with systemic sclerosis. However, minocycline failed a larger open-label clinical trial.¹⁷² Like many other drugs, minocycline may be of value to a small number of patients, and that perhaps may be determined by the etiology of their disease. Because systemic sclerosis is very polymorphic in nature, its mode of onset may have many different origins.

Methotrexate failed as a drug for the treatment of adult-onset systemic sclerosis and did not significantly alter the overall skin score;¹⁷³ however, it was successful in treating juvenile localized systemic sclerosis.¹⁷⁴ Methotrexate was not shown to be effective in the bleomycin-induced mouse model of fibrosis.¹⁷⁵ Cyclophosphamide was found to have enhanced toxicity in the lung, especially when used in conjunction with bleomycin, where mice were found to have enhanced progression of lung fibrosis,¹⁷⁶ whereas cyclophosphamide appeared to protect against interstitial lung disease in patients with systemic sclerosis, with improvement of lung function and quality of life.¹⁷⁷

Future directions for animal models replicating systemic sclerosis pathology

In recent years, animal models have been developed that replicate more faithfully many of the important aspects of systemic sclerosis.^35,45,78,120 However, until the cause of systemic sclerosis is identified, an accurate model is not possible. Even so, once the cause has been identified, the use of animals may still preclude accurate development of the disease in an animal model, for the simple reason that animals are not humans. Recent research suggests that infection of fibroblasts by Epstein-Barr virus might drive the pathology of systemic sclerosis¹⁷⁸ and if this proves to be true, the development of an animal model will be very difficult. The natural host for the virus is man, but under specific experimental conditions, a small number of new world monkey species can be infected. In light of this, a humanized Epstein-Barr virus mouse has already been developed, but the mouse has not been reported to display fibrosis,¹⁷⁹ and the model may only be possible if mouse fibroblasts are specifically designed to allow infection with virus.

Due to the polymorphic and systemic nature of systemic sclerosis and the poor replicability of many of the models utilized in studies published to date, the issue arises as to whether more than one model should be used to study drug efficacy. This would be best from an idealistic point of view; however, it may not always be practical, due to the inherent expense of breeding and housing of animals for research. If more than one model is to be used, then the models should be carefully chosen. For example, in studying the efficacy of a drug on the TGF-β pathway, investigators might select animal models that target TGF-β but from different angles, such as receptor signaling using the kinase-deficient type II TGF-β receptor model and the type I TGF-β receptor transgenic model. The hope is that both models will together recapitulate and confirm present findings. However, disparate study findings can preclude a drug from entering clinical trials, and this drug may have been a successful therapeutic that is never realized, because animals are not humans.

Conclusion

Animal models are very useful in studying the initiating events, genes, and various factors required to establish fibrosis as often these events or features cannot be studied in the patient. With the exception of stiff skin syndrome, which is an inheritable variant of systemic sclerosis, all other systemic sclerosis variants are inducible, given that onset of the disease is usually later in life. Animal models, by their very nature, do not replicate all aspects of systemic sclerosis. Many of the recently developed animal models replicating various features of systemic sclerosis have provided insights into the vasculopathy, the role of proteins regulating fibrosis, and the role of the innate immune system in initiating fibrotic events. All these models have proved useful in increasing our understanding of the pathogenesis of systemic sclerosis that one day may lead to new paradigm shifts in the etiology of the disease. The animal models have led to the development of various drugs; however, many of these drugs have not translated well into therapeutics to treat systemic sclerosis, due in part to the fact that mice are not humans.

Disclosure

The author reports no conflicts of interest in this work.