125
Views
8
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Research

Effect of anterior crowding or spacing on oral health-related quality of life: a cross-sectional study

, , , , &
Pages 461-465 | Published online: 27 Mar 2018

Abstract

Introduction

Oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL) involves many aspects such as chewing ability, sleeping, social interactions, self-esteem, and satisfaction with life and oral health. The increasing research interest in OHRQoL began only after the shortcomings of previous approaches of treating symptoms only and neglecting the patient’s self-perception were revealed.

Patients and methods

The current study design is a cross-sectional study of patients who attended King Abdulaziz University Dental Hospital (Jeddah, Saudi Arabia) and King Saud University Dental Hospital (Riyadh, Saudi Arabia). After obtaining their verbal consent, young adult and adult patients (mean age 25.19±7.29 years old) with anterior spacing or crowding were recruited to participate in the study. They filled the Arabic short version of the oral-health impact profile-14 questionnaire after a clinical evaluation of the severity of their spacing or crowding. Parameters of spacing/crowding severity assessment were as follows: <4, mild; 4–8, moderate; and >8, severe. Data were analyzed using the chi-square test in SPSS statistical package. The level of significance was set to <0.05.

Results

The sample size of this study was 308 subjects. Findings indicated a statistically significant (p=0.001) association between anterior spacing malocclusion (ASM) with Q5 “self-consciousness”, since 64.2% of patients with ASM reported being self-conscious. Results indicated a statistically significant association between educational level with anterior crowding malocclusion (ACM; p=0.02) and ASM (p=0.01) with Q3 “painful aching”. Moreover, findings indicated a statistically significant association (p=0.04) between income and ACM with Q5 “self-consciousness”. On the other hand, results showed no significant association between gender with either ACM or ASM.

Conclusion

This study sheds light on how anterior malocclusion (crowding or spacing) impacts OHRQoL negatively, especially heightening self-consciousness about their appearance. These effects should be addressed by the orthodontist during the course of treatment.

Introduction

Oral health-related quality of life (OHRQoL) is defined as “The subjective experience of symptoms related to oral conditions that have an impact on well-being.”Citation1 There are abundant articles discussing the effect of malocclusion generally or a specific type of malocclusion on the quality of life or self-esteem of patients. The increasing research interest in OHRQoL began only after the shortcomings of previous approaches of treating symptoms only and neglecting the patient’s self-perception were revealed.Citation2,Citation3 Some patients with mild malocclusion may report greater concerns than those with severe forms and a different self-perception. OHRQoL involves many aspects such as chewing ability, sleeping, social interactions, self-esteem, and satisfaction with life and oral health.Citation3,Citation4 Pelo et al conducted a study comparing two approaches for correcting skeletal discrepancies. One is the traditional approach of starting treatment with an orthodontic decompensation phase, followed by orthognathic surgery, and then orthodontic treatment again, and the other new approach is with surgery first and then orthodontic treatment. They used the oral-health impact profile-14 (OHIP-14) and the orthognathic quality of life questionnaires. They observed a significant and an immediate improvement in quality of life in the surgery-first group. One of the important factors that contributed to this improvement is the fact that the second approach corrects facial esthetics and concerns faster.Citation5 Choi et al assessed OHRQoL in 472 patients aged 21.1±8.6 years with OHIP-14 survey and food-intake ability (FIA) with the FIA questionnaire. They found no statistical difference between males and females in OHRQoL or masticatory ability. Moreover, most patients were seeking orthodontic treatment for esthetic purposes rather than to improve functional limitations. Participants >30 years old reported lower masticatory function and lower OHRQoL. Finally, they concluded that there is a linear relationship between malocclusion severity, OHRQoL score, and masticatory ability.Citation6 Barbosa et al conducted a cross-sectional study in Brazil that involved 167 school children aged between 8 and 14 years old to evaluate the impact of malocclusion on quality of life. They concluded that malocclusion affects a child’s quality of life negatively.Citation7 Hassan et al assessed OHRQoL using the oral health impact profile (OHIP) questionnaire in correlation with the index of orthodontic treatment needs (IOTN) in 120 children between the ages of 12 and 15 years seeking orthodontic treatment and their parents. They found that as the orthodontic treatment need increased, OHRQoL decreased.Citation8 Ramos-Jorge et al conducted a cross-sectional study in Brazil involving 451 children aged 3–5 years to assess the relationship between different types of malocclusion and quality of life. They found that anterior open bite was associated with a negative impact on the quality of life of preschool children and their families.Citation9 Hassan and Amin assessed OHRQoL using the OHIP-14 questionnaire and the IOTN in 366 young adults aged 21–25 years seeking orthodontic treatment. They concluded that malocclusion affects OHRQoL.Citation10 One important factor that affects quality of life is the patient’s perception. It is evident that some patients with severe malocclusion report a good quality of life. Hence, they do not seek orthodontic treatment. Thiruvenkadam et al compared the quality of life of children with a history of orthodontic treatment with patients who never had orthodontic treatment using a short version of the Child Oral Health Impact Profile (COHIP). They concluded that patients who had orthodontic treatment had a lower quality of life than those who never had orthodontic treatment.Citation3

Anterior spacing and crowding are prevalent types of malocclusions in Saudi population.Citation11,Citation12 Hence, we were interested to explore the effects of these specific types of malocclusion on OHRQoL. This knowledge can help orthodontists to prioritize solving problems that are significantly affecting patient’s OHRQoL as early as possible in the treatment course. In addition, no study has assessed the effect of anterior spacing or crowding specifically on the quality of life. Therefore, the current study was aimed to evaluate the OHRQoL in subjects with anterior spacing or crowding.

Patients and methods

The current study design is a cross-sectional study of patients who attended King Abdulaziz University Dental Hospital (Jeddah, Saudi Arabia) and King Saud University Dental Hospital (Riyadh, Saudi Arabia). Ethical approval (number #0010117) was obtained from King Abdulaziz University Dental Hospital. After obtaining their verbal consent, young adult and adult patients (mean age 25.19±7.29 years old) with anterior spacing or crowding were recruited to participate in the study. Verbal consent was obtained from the parent or legal guardian of any participants who were under the age of 18. Verbal consent was approved by ethical approval committee of King Abdulaziz University Dental Hospital. The patients filled the Arabic short version of the OHIP-14 questionnaire after a clinical evaluation of the severity of their spacing or crowding.Citation13 Parameters of spacing/crowding severity assessment were as follows: <4, mild; 4–8, moderate; and >8, severe.Citation14

Exclusion criteria included the following:

  • Patients <15 years old

  • Current or history of orthodontic treatmentCitation3

  • Severe dentofacial anomalies, including cleft lip and palate or obvious malocclusions, such as severe unilateral or bilateral crossbite

  • Patients with extraction spaces

  • Patients with or in need of extensive dental treatment

  • Patients with extensive anterior dental treatment

  • Patients with systemic diseases

Statistical analysis

Data were analyzed using the chi-square test in SPSS statistical package (version 21; SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA). The level of significance was set to <0.05. The scores of OHIP-14 were dichotomized to absence (if the answer is “never” or “hardly ever”) and presence (if the answer is “occasionally,” “fairly often,” and “very often”) of impact on OHRQoL.

Results

The sample size of this study was 308 subjects. Descriptive analysis illustrated the sample characteristics with 53.2% males with the mean age of 25.2 years. In terms of educational level, almost 58% of the studied population held bachelor’s degrees. An income of <3,000 SR represents the majority of the studied population (40%) followed by those with >9,000 SR (23%; ). The distribution of anterior crowding malocclusion (ACM) and anterior spacing malocclusion (ASM) were divided into mild, moderate, and severe based on the severity of the cases. A trend was observed for both ACM and ASM where those with a mild form of malocclusion were more prevalent followed by moderate and severe forms. Upon comparison between crowding and spacing malocclusions, it was found that crowding was a more prevalent malocclusion with 56.5% than spacing, which represents 43.5%.

Table 1 Sample characteristics and demographic distribution

Bivariate analyses (chi-square test) were performed to test potential association between ACM and ASM with each of the OHIP-14 questions. Findings indicated a statistically significant (p=0.001) association between ASM with Q5 “self-consciousness,” since 64.2% of patients with ASM reported being self-conscious (). The potential associations between ACM and ASM with descriptive data (gender, educational level, and income) were tested using the chi-square test. Results indicated a statistically significant association between educational level with ACM (p=0.02) and ASM (p=0.01) with Q3 “painful aching”. Moreover, findings indicated a statistically significant association (p=0.04) between income and ACM with Q5 “self-consciousness”. On the other hand, results showed no significant association between gender with either ACM or ASM.

Table 2 The potential association between anterior malocclusion and OHIP-14

Discussion

This study used the Arabic version of OHIP-14, which was validated in a convenient sample of the Saudi population.Citation10,Citation13,Citation15Citation18 This questionnaire was used in several cross-sectional and longitudinal studies to assess the impact of several oral-health diseases and disorders, including malocclusion.Citation19,Citation20

Individuals seeking dental treatment with either ACM or ASM were recruited from King Abdulaziz University Dental Hospital in Jeddah and King Saud University Dental Hospital in Riyadh. The sample size consisted of 308 subjects, 53.2% males and 46.8% females with the mean age of 25.2 years. In terms of educational level, almost 58% of the studied population held a bachelor’s degree. An income of <3,000 SR represented the majority of the studied population (40%). Patients with ACM constituted 56.5% of the sample compared to 43.5% of patients with ASM.

In the current study, “painful aching”, “chewing efficiency”, “diet choices”, and “meal interruption” were not significant, supporting Daniels and Richmond findings stating that functional aspects have minimal effect on the OHRQoL among adolescents.Citation21 On the other hand, de Oliveira and Sheiham, and Hassan and Amin reported that functional parameters were significantly affected.Citation10,Citation22 This may be attributed to the fact that this study assessed anterior malocclusion (crowding and spacing), which may have no or minimal impact on functional abilities. Moreover, in the present study, “self-consciousness” was significantly affected by ASM. This finding supports the results of de Oliveira, who reported that self-consciousness increased for patients with malocclusion.Citation22

This study assessed the association between anterior malocclusion with descriptive data (gender, educational level, and income), and we found no statistically significant association with gender. This finding agrees with Hassan and Amin and disagrees with de Oliveria and Sheiham, Cicciu et al, and Ulinski et al who found that gender affected OHRQoL perception significantly; under similar conditions, females reported more discontent with their appearance than males.Citation10,Citation23Citation25 Furthermore, Tsakos et al reported that educational level affected OHRQoL negatively in elderly people.Citation26 The current study found educational level to be a significant factor for patients with ACM and ASM only regarding one question, which was Q5 “self-consciousness”.

The present study’s findings agree with those of other studies that use OHIP-14, which concluded that malocclusion affects OHRQoL negatively.Citation1,Citation6,Citation27,Citation28 A limitation of the current study must be considered. Subjects were recruited from hospitals; thus, this sample might not represent the characteristics of the rest of the population who did not seek dental treatment, thereby causing an unequal distribution of malocclusion severity and age.

Conclusion

This study shed light on how anterior malocclusion (crowding or spacing) impacts OHRQoL negatively, especially heightening self-consciousness about their appearance. These effects should be addressed by the orthodontist during the course of treatment.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.

References

  • Yamane-TakeuchiMEkuniDMizutaniSAssociations among oral health-related quality of life, subjective symptoms, clinical status, and self-rated oral health in Japanese university students: a cross-sectional studyBMC Oral Health201616112727903265
  • AllenPFAssessment of oral health related quality of lifeHealth Qual Life Outcomes2003114014514355
  • AsokanSJohnJBGeetha PriyaPRPrathibaJThiruvenkadamGOral health-related quality of life of children seeking orthodontic treatment based on child oral health impact profile: a cross-sectional studyContemp Clin Dent20156339640026321842
  • SettineriSRizzoALiottaMMentoCItalian validation of the psychosocial impact of dental aesthetics questionnaire (PIDAQ)Health201461621002108
  • PeloSGaspariniGGaragiolaUSurgery-first orthognathic approach vs traditional orthognathic approach: oral health-related quality of life assessed with 2 questionnairesAm J Orthod Dentofac Orthop20171522250254
  • ChoiSHKimJSChaJYHwangCJEffect of malocclusion severity on oral health–related quality of life and food intake ability in a Korean populationAm J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop2016149338439026926026
  • BarbosaTSGaviãoMBLemeMSCasteloPMOral health-related quality of life in children and preadolescents with caries, malocclusions or temporomandibular disordersOral Health Prev Dent201614538927175445
  • HassanAHHassanMHLinjawiAIAssociation of orthodontic treatment needs and oral health-related quality of life in Saudi children seeking orthodontic treatmentPatient Prefer Adherence201481571157925419119
  • Ramos-JorgeJMottaTMarquesLSPaivaSMRamos-JorgeMLAssociation between anterior open bite and impact on quality of life of preschool childrenBraz Oral Res20152914625741623
  • HassanAHAminHEAssociation of orthodontic treatment needs and oral health-related quality of life in young adultsAm J Orthod Dentofac Orthop201013714247
  • AlQarniMABanihuwaizAHAlshehriFDAlqarniASAlasmariDSEvaluate the malocclusion in subjects reporting for orthodontic treatment among Saudi population in Asser RegionJ Int oral Heal2014644246
  • AsiryMAOcclusal Status among 12–16 year-old school children in Riyadh, Saudi ArabiaJ Int oral Heal2015752023
  • Al-JundiMASzentpéteryAJohnMTAn Arabic version of the oral health impact profile: translation and psychometric propertiesInt Dent J2007572849217506467
  • MitchellLAn Introduction to Orthodontics4th editionOxford University Press2013
  • KhalifaNAllenPFAbu-bakrNHAbdel-RahmanMEPsychometric properties and performance of the oral health impact profile (OHIP-14s-ar) among Sudanese adultsJ Oral Sci201355212313223748451
  • Al HabashnehRKhaderYSSalamehSUse of the Arabic version of oral health impact profile-14 to evaluate the impact of periodontal disease on oral health-related quality of life among Jordanian adultsJ Oral Sci201254111312022466895
  • AllenPFLockerDDo item weights matter? An assessment using the oral health impact profileCommunity Dent Health19971431331389332036
  • AlghamdiMAFarsiNJHassanAHComparison of oral health-related quality of life of patients treated by palatal expanders with patients treated by fixed orthodontic appliancesPatient Prefer Adherence20171169970528408807
  • SladeGDAssessing change in quality of life using the oral health impact profileCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol199826152619511843
  • SladeGDDerivation and validation of a short-form oral health impact profileCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol19972542842909332805
  • DanielsCRichmondSThe Development of the Index of Complexity, Outcome and Need (ICON)J Orthod200027214916210867071
  • OliveiraDCFerreiraFMMorosini IdeATorres-PereiraCCMartins PaivaSFraizFCImpact of oral health status on the oral health-related quality of life of Brazilian male incarcerated adolescentsOral Health Prev Dent201513541742525789358
  • de OliveiraCMSheihamAOrthodontic treatment and its impact on oral health-related quality of life in Brazilian adolescentsJ Orthod2004311202715071148
  • CicciùMMatacenaGSignorinoFBrugalettaACicciùABramantiERelationship between oral health and its impact on the quality life of Alzheimer’s disease patients: a supportive care trialInt J Clin Exp Med20136976677224179569
  • UlinskiKGdo NascimentoMALimaAMFactors related to oral health-related quality of life of independent Brazilian elderlyInt J Dent2013201370504723533414
  • TsakosGSheihamAIliffeSThe impact of educational level on oral health-related quality of life in older people in LondonEur J Oral Sci2009117328629219583757
  • SilvaLFThomazEBFreitasHVPereiraALRibeiroCCAlvesCMImpact of malocclusion on the quality of life of Brazilian adolescents: a Population-Based StudyPLoS One2016119e016271527690356
  • ChoiSHKimBIChaJYHwangCJImpact of malocclusion and common oral diseases on oral health–related quality of life in young adultsAm J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop2015147558759525919104