Single photon emission computed tomography: An alternative imaging modality in left ventricular evaluation

Abstract

Various diagnostic imaging modalities have been used for quantitative left ventricular (LV) parameters. Because of the suboptimal value of the most widely used technology, two-dimensional (2D) echocardiography, 3D ultrasonographic imaging has improved accuracy for LV volume and function. Single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) is another diagnostic method where LV volumetric and functional parameters can be accurately provided by gated myocardial perfusion tomographic slices. First pass radionuclide venticulography is another imaging modality which has some practical limitations. Despite lower ejection fraction (EF) values compared with invasive approach, noninvasive techniques are accurate in determination of normal and depressed EF. Noninvasive techniques with 3D approach including gated SPECT are beneficial for not only global but also regional LV evaluation. It has been mentioned that the slight difference between echocardiography and SPECT could be caused by the diverse population studied. The results of diagnostic stress tests support that SPECT is feasible to use in evaluation of LV volume and functional analysis. Magnetic resonance imaging is an expensive modality to use routinely, but it preserves its importance in selected patients for providing precise LV geometric data.

Keywords:

• geometry
• left ventricle
• single photon emission computed tomography
• volume

Introduction

Various diagnostic imaging modalities have been used for calculation of left ventricular (LV) volume. Two-dimensional (2D) echocardiography is most widely used technology, but it is suboptimal for detection of LV volume due to the complex LV cavity geometry. In ultrasonographic assessment of LV volumes, current 2D echo-cardiographic methods to quantitate ventricular performance require image acquisition from standardized scanning planes. LV volume is calculated from assumptions that the ventricular cavity can be represented by individual geometric figures or their combination. Both limitations of acoustic access and distortion of ventricular shape may invalidate these assumptions of standardized imaging planes and geometry, and lead to errors in calculating ventricular volume (Teichholz et al 1976).

Regional diversity of LV may be a difficulty of echocardiographic volume assessment in clinical practice. It has been shown that simplified echocardiographic reconstruction used in conjunction with tissue harmonic imaging and automated endocardial border extraction accurately calculates LV volume and function in patients with regional wall motion abnormalities or distorted LVs caused by ischemic heart disease (Mele et al 2004). 3D ultrasonographic imaging provides improved accuracy for LV volume and function compared with current 2D algorithms (Siu et al 1995; Nosir et al 1996). In 3D reconstruction, the technique required many cardiac cycles to reconstruct the heart, with considerable artifact due to respiratory and patient movement (Salustri et al 1996). An integrated system may provide better agreement between LV volumes calculated by 3D reconstruction and actual volumes (Handschumacher et al 1993).

Increased LV volumes are associated with high mortality, adverse cardiovascular events, and worse prognosis (Siu et al 1995). Although LV volumes have important prognostic implications, its evaluation is commonly underestimated in practice. If it is evaluated accurately, it provides additional incremental value to risk assessment and guides further therapy. Real-time 3D echocardiography has been compared with TI-201 single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and found to be accurate and reproducible for the measurement of LV volumes for risk assessment in ischemic heart disease and dilated cardiomyopathy (Chan et al 2006).

Determination of regional LV diversity is the main difficulty not only for ischemic heart disease and volume overload, but for hypertrophied hearts. The novel modality by application of real-time 3D imaging technology can improve understanding of the spatial relations of various cardiac structures and offers the potential for more accurate volumetric quantization (Gopal et al 1992). We previously have used real-time 3D imaging to evaluate total and segmental LV volume in patients with LV hypertrophy and have described the details in regional geometry and global LV morphology (Yalçin et al 2000). Using 3D volumetric data, it has become possible to evaluate regional and global LV geometries especially in patients with LV geometric distortion or complex LV morphology. However, 3D approach is not a widely used echocardiographic method in clinical practice.

SPECT is one of the diagnostic modalities to evaluate LV volumetric and functional parameters accurately provided by gated myocardial perfusion tomographic slices. Gated perfusion tomographic slices have been used for volume calculations which includes 2D geometric assumptions and 3D approaches. Geometric modeling has been used for manually 2D calculation of ejection fraction (EF) using gated myocardial perfusion SPECT which has provided acceptable correlation with equilibrium multigated blood-pool and with contrast ventriculography (DePuey et al 1993; Mochizuki et al 1997). In healthy young subjects, post-exercise cardiac changes affect systolic functions detected on gated thallium myocardial perfusion scintigraphy, resulting in a smaller heart size during stress. However, the absence of these findings in the elderly suggests a decrease in contractility with age (Aktaş et al 2005). In addition to aging, decreased contractility may be detected by gated myocardial perfusion SPECT in postischemic stunning due to stress-induced ischemic episode (Johnson et al 1997). Therefore, Johnson and colleagues (1997) suggested that the presence of post-ischemic reduction in the post-stress EF may be another marker of disease severity and reduced event-free survival.

It was also reported that gated myocardial perfusion SPECT with Tc-99m labeled radiopharmaceutical may provide more objective imaging data than Tl-201 because gated SPECT performed with Tc-99m labeled radiopharmaceutical gives better image quality than Tl-201 due to higher myo-cardial count rate. So when objective myocardial function monitoring is needed Tc-99m labeled radiopharmaceutical could be a reasonable method (Hyun et al 2001).

The number of gated frames per cardiac cycle in myo-cardial gated SPECT may influence the accuracy of both EF and wall thickening. It has been shown that an 8-frame study results in a mismall constant and predictable decrease of 0.04 in EF compared with a 16-frame study (Germano et al 1995). First pass radionuclide venticulography is another imaging modality for EF calculations in which 32 frames per cardiac cycle are used. Despite high frame numbers, first pass radionuclide venticulography has some practical limitations like giving functional data only at the time of injection (Yoshioka et al 1999). Gated myocardial perfusion SPECT has been used with automated technology and has given a satisfactory result (Nichols et al 1997). It has been shown that automated edge-detection algorithm is well correlated with contrast left ventriculogram and MRI (Mochizuki et al 1997; Yoshioka et al 1999).

Planar multigated acquisition is one of the most common used technologies for EF and volume calculation. However, it is difficult to calculate EF of the ventricules due to atrial overlap so SPECT studies are widely used (Lu et al 1994). On the other hand, SPECT studies are not successful in right ventricular EF calculation which is feasibly evaluated by first pass radionuclide ventriculography (Massardo et al 2007). Also in multigated SPECT ventriculography, we could not obtain an idea of the perfusion of the myocardium even if we can begin imaging a few hours later, which differs from first pass radionuclide ventriculography in which imaging must began as soon as possible after injection (Borges-Neto 1997). In the literature, it is stated that gated myocardial perfusion SPECT which gives perfusion in addition to EF and wall motion analysis is superior to gated blood pool SPECT (Meine et al 2004).

Especially in coronary artery disease (CAD) patients, gated myocardial perfusion SPECT gives us more information than other technologies used for EF and volume calculations. With the quantitative gated SPECT (QGS) method, even in normal perfusion, we can detect wall motion abnormalities which will influence the survival of CAD patients (Stegger et al 2007). It has been documented that despite small systematic differences, agreement between gated myocardial SPECT and MRI is good over a wide range of volumes and EF values using the QGS method (Schaefer et al 2005).

The variables provided by exercise radionuclide angiocardiography predicts cardiac death in patients with CAD (Jones et al 1991). However, noninvasive assessment of EF usually has been found to be lower than that detected by angiography (Nichols et al 1998; Vourvouri et al 2001; Habash-Bseiso et al 2005). Despite lower EF values by noninvasive assessment, noninvasive techniques are accurate in determination of normal and depressed EF (Habash-Bseiso et al 2005). The quantification of influence of filtering and pixel size parameters on measured LV volumes for gated blood pool SPECT may be beneficial in correction of overestimation (Debrun et al 2005). SPECT has shown a slightly lower EF than that measured by echocardiography (Vourvouri et al 2001; Habash-Bseiso et al 2005), this could be also caused by diverse population studied (Albrechtsson et al 1982).

SPECT with boundary detection method also has shown a good correlation with equilibrium multigated blood-pool and MRI volumes (Faber et al 1988, ¹⁹⁹¹). Detection of boundaries for volume calculations may be possible in patients who have defect extending more than 25% of the myocardium (Nichols et al 1997). Border detection becomes more complicated in apical defects, it has been forced the wall to be a smooth connection between noninfarcted portions of the wall (Faber et al 1999). Finally, positron emission tomography from nuclear studies has been used accurately for global and regional detection of LV function (Kanayama et al 2007). It has given an acceptable result for LV volumes and EF in comparison with MRI and angiography (Schae-fer et al 2003). Among the noninvasive modalities, MRI is considered the gold standard, because of high accuracy and reproducibility for volume measurements (Barkhausen et al 2001). It has been used for assessment of myocardial thickness and regional myocardial function quantitatively (Pflugfelder et al 1988).

In conclusion, gated myocardial perfusion SPECT is feasible for evaluation of LV volume and functional analysis in routine clinical practice. MRI preserves its importance in selected patients to determine more precise LV geometric data in patients with cardiac diseases, but it is unfortunately more expensive to use routinely.

Disclosure

The authors report no conflicts of interest in this work.