The Enthusiast's Eye: The Value of Unsanctioned Knowledge in Design Historical Scholarship

ABSTRACT

If design history research relies solely on institutionalized documentation and academic scholarship—that is, sanctioned knowledge—not only will its purview be limited to a very narrow segment of design culture, it will also lose out on a vast array of sources to valuable knowledge about our material environment produced by amateurs, collectors, and enthusiasts—what we in this article define as “unsanctioned knowledge.” Because of its dissociation with professional institutions and academic protocols and their—albeit admittedly utopian, but nonetheless upheld—ideals of objectivity, this type of knowledge is typically considered fundamentally subjective in nature and therefore of little or no relevance and value to academic scholarship. In this article, we argue that, to the contrary, design historical scholarship has much to gain from engaging more seriously with the unsanctioned knowledge represented by the enthusiast's eye.

KEYWORDS:

• enthusiasts
• amateurs
• collecting
• knowledge
• historiography