Physical activity, muscle function, falls and fractures

Abstract

Study design: A thematic review.

Objectives: To evaluate if physical activity enhances muscle strength, improves balance, and reduces the fall frequency and the fracture incidence.

Background: One of the major medical problems of today is the increasing incidence of fragility fractures. Muscle strength and fall is one of the major determinants of a fracture. If physical activity could increase muscle strength, improve balance and reduce the fall frequency, then training could be recommended as prevention for fractures.

Methods: The review used Medline (Pub Med) and the search words exercise, physical activity, muscle strength, balance, falls, fractures. Randomized controlled trials (RCT) were predominantly included, although this not is a systematic review.

Results: The evidence that physical activity modifies the risk factors for fall is compelling, although RCT with fractures as end point are lacking. Physical activity is associated with improved muscle strength, co-ordination and balance. Physical training increases muscle strength also in octogenarians by up to 200%, i.e. a much more pronounced effect than the corresponding increase in muscle volume or bone mass. There is also evidence that physical activity decreases the actual number of falls. Observational cohort and case-control studies imply that physical activity is associated with reduced hip fracture risk. If exercise reduces the number of vertebral fractures and other fragility fractures are less evaluated.

Conclusions: Physical activity in older ages can be recommended to improve muscle strength and balance, to reduce the risk to fall and fractures, although the highest level of evidence – RCT with fracture as endpoint – is lacking.

• exercise
• muscle strength
• muscle mass
• fall
• fractures
• physical activity

Introduction

The increasing number of fragility fractures, usually defined as fractures of distal radius, proximal humerus, spine, pelvis, hip or tibial condyles due to a low energy trauma, has created an appreciable problem in the western world 123. Half of the female and one-third of the male population will, during their lifetime, suffer at least one fragility fracture, followed by increased morbidity and mortality 45. Fragility fractures are associated with very high cost if sick-leave, visits to doctors, examination and pain medication are included 6. With this knowledge, the health care service and other sectors of society should unify their work and efforts, to try to decrease the number of fractures. Efforts during the last decades, both clinically and within research, have mainly been focused on how to increase bone mass (BM) or bone mineral content (BMC) or bone mineral density (BMD) 789. These treatment strategies are logical, as BMD has been shown to be one of the best predictors of bone strength. An increase in BMD by 10% (one standard deviation, SD) has been estimated to reduce the fracture incidence by 50% 1011.

Several double-blinded, prospective, randomized, controlled trials (RCT) clearly indicate that drug treatment could increase BMD by up to 10% and halve the fracture risk in both men and women with osteoporosis 79, defined as BMD below 2.5 SD, corresponding to around 25% lower BMD value than in young individuals within the same gender 12. However, even if the relative risk to sustain a fracture is lower among individuals with osteopenia, i.e. a BMD reduced by 1–2.5 SD compared to young individuals of the same sex 12, the majority of fractures will occur in this larger group of individuals. At present, no data exist which imply that drug treatment in osteopenic individuals would reduce the number of fragility fractures 13, and lifelong treatment of everybody from e.g. 50 years of age is not demonstrated to be cost-effective 13.

A fracture seldom occurs without a trauma, usually a fall. Thus, strategies to reduce the number of falls would probably also reduce the number of fractures 14. Traits that are of importance for fall risk include muscle strength, muscle function and balance 15. This review evaluates existing data in the literature, to verify or oppose the hypothesis that physical exercise affects non-skeletal risk factors for fractures such as muscle mass, muscle strength, balance and fall frequency, and ultimately if physical activity is associated with reduced fracture incidence.

2 Method

Medline (Pub Med) was searched using the search words exercise, physical activity, muscle strength, balance, falls and fractures. Papers were scrutinized from 1966 and onwards and only papers in English were included. Randomized controlled trials (RCT) were used if available. From the relevant papers a continued search was undertaken by the link ‘related manuscripts’. If no RCT were found, the next level of evidence in the evidence-based hierarchy was scrutinized, i.e. non-randomized, controlled studies, then retrospective and prospective observation cohort studies and finally case-control studies. If a variety of papers were found within the same level of evidence, the authors tried to include the first published paper and the paper with the largest included cohorts and the longest follow-up.

3 Results and discussion

3.1 Physical activity and muscle function

Physical activity improves balance, co-ordination, muscle strength and reaction time. All these traits increase the possibility to break a tendency to fall or to protect from the full impact of an actual fall by the arms 1617181920. There are reports that muscle strength increases by up to 200% even in octogenarians, a much larger increase than the 2–20% increases in muscle volume or the 1–2% increases in BM with a similar training program 1617182021. Lord et al. reported that women above age 60 who exercised physically by aerobics twice per week improved balance, co-ordination and muscle strength 22. The muscle strength in the quadriceps muscle improved by 29% and the sway of the body was reduced by 6%, while the BM was unchanged during the intervention year. Heislein et al. reported that one hour of physical training twice a week increased the muscle strength in the quadriceps muscle by 21% and the grip strength by 14% with not more than eight weeks of physical training 23. Similarly, low to moderate physical activity during 16 weeks of physical training was associated with a 30–100% increase in muscle strength in both men and women while the BM at best increased by 3% 24. Adversely, a reduced level of physical training was followed by a fast decline in the muscle strength. Kontulainen et al. reported that muscle mass, expressed as a difference between dominant and non-dominant arm in tennis players, was reduced from 6 to 3% during 1–2 years of reduced level of physical activity 25 and Fiatarone et al. reported the muscle strength to decrease by 32% after only four weeks of reduced physical training 17.

3.2 Physical activity and the fall risk

Several observational studies have reported that the risk to fall decreases with increased physical activity 1526. One of the first RCT that supported this notion was the ‘The Frail and Injuries: Cooperative Studies of Intervention Techniques (FICSIT)’ study 20 (Fig. 1). The FICSIT actually included several separate studies with different training modalities, but was pre-planned as a multi-center study. The study included 60–75-year old individuals subjected to an intervention program with 10–36 weeks training; endurance training, balance training and Tai Chi. The falls were reduced by 17% in the training group compared to the controls 20. The Tai Chi training showed the best results, with a 47% reduction in multiple falls during a four-month period 2728 (Fig. 1).

Figure 1.  The relative risk to sustain a fall. Published study, number of individuals (N), the gender (m = male, f = female), mean age of the cohort (years), duration of the prospective studies (months). The figure presents 95% confidence interval (95% CI) for odds ratio in active compared to inactive individuals.

One of the most cited prospective studies included a multiple-risk-factor intervention including a physical exercise program during one year, a strategy that actually reduced the fall frequency 29. A Swedish study also advocated a multiple-risk-factor intervention including a physical exercise program, a study that during the 34 weeks follow-up registered both a reduced fall frequency and a reduced hip fracture incidence 30. Another report infers that a home-based balance and strength training program reduced the fall frequency by 32% and reduced the number of fracture-induced falls by 38% 31. One of the more hopeful findings in this study was that the positive effect was retained one year after the physical training intervention 31. However, physical training was continued after the follow-up period in this study, probably influencing the inferences. There are, in contrast, other studies that oppose the notion of a fall-preventing effect, showing that any physical training-induced reduction in falls disappears within two years after cessation of the physical training 32. Furthermore, the prevention programs for fractures predominantly prevent falls in those with impairment or old age 202829. Correspondingly, the effectiveness of physical exercise in fall prevention in middle-aged people is not good and therefore its benefit in fracture prevention may be as limited as that in bone preservation measures. There exists also a controversy if a physical exercise program in institutionalized, very frail individuals are of any benefit regarding fall reduction 33.

During the last years several RCT have been published that infer physical training to reduce the number of falls, sometimes with a significant outcome, sometimes only showing a trend 343536. Gregg et al. reported in a meta-analysis including six studies that isolated physical training really reduced the number of individuals who fell 34. When thoroughly scrutinizing these intervention studies, it seems that fall reduction is most probable in individuals living by their own. In contrast, among elderly living in institutions, it seems questionable if an intervention program with physical activity can reduce the number of falls 30313537. Maybe these individuals are too sick to be able to follow the physical training program or possibly, the physical training is too risky, leading to falls during the exercise sessions. In fact, there are studies supporting this hypothesis, reporting that individuals who sustain the most falls are those who are either most physically inactive or most physical active 363839.

3.3 Physical activity and fracture risk in women

Several studies have reported that individuals with low physical activity, presently or previously, have an increased risk of sustaining a hip fracture 40 (Fig. 2). Other studies conclude that daily physical activity is associated with a reduced hip fracture risk 41. In one of the largest, prospective observational studies of osteoporotic fragility fractures, the Study of osteoporotic fractures (SOF) –study with a cohort of 9,704 women above age 65, the quintile with the highest physical activity had a 42% lower hip fracture risk compared to the women in the lowest quintile 40. Moderate physical activity was associated with a 30% reduction in hip fracture risk compared to physically inactive women in the Leisure World Study, a study including 8,600 middle aged and elderly women 42 (Fig. 2).

Figure 2.  Relative risk of sustaining a hip fracture with a higher level of exercise. Original study, numbers (N), age (years), duration of observation (years) and compared activity levels with 95% confidence interval (95% CI) for the odds ratio presented. A 95% CI below 1.0 indicate that exercise reduces the number of fractures.

There are considerably less studies regarding physical activity and the risk to sustain a vertebral fracture. The previously mentioned SOF study shows that physical activity was associated with a 33% reduction in the number of vertebral fractures in active compared to inactive women 3440 (Fig. 3). This conclusion is supported by the European Vertebral Osteoporosis Study (EVOS), a study including 6,646 women, age 50–79 years. The study reported that physical activity 30 minutes or more every day was associated with a 30% reduction in the risk of sustaining a vertebral fracture, compared to inactive women 43 (Fig. 3).

Figure 3.  Relative risk of sustaining other fragility fractures with higher level of exercise. Original study, numbers (N), age (years), duration of observation (years) and compared activity levels with 95% confidence interval (95% CI) for the odds ratio presented. A 95% CI below 1.0 indicate that exercise reduce the number of fractures.

3.4 Physical activity and fracture risk in men

It is much more difficult to draw any conclusion as regards physical activity and the fracture incidence in men. Most studies in men are short-term studies with small cohorts, making a risk of type II error obvious (Fig. 2). One Finnish study including 3,262 Finnish men from age 50 onwards for two decades reported that a high physical activity at the time for the study start, reduced the risk to sustain a hip fracture by 38% 44. The Leisure World Study including 5,049 elderly men reported that increased training reduced the risk to sustain a hip fracture, as in women 42. There are now at least four large studies that follow well-defined groups, and all are in accordance when they report that regularly physical activity in men reduces the risk to sustain a hip fracture 424546. Existing data thus support that physical activity reduces the risk of hip fractures also in men (Fig. 2).

The evidence regarding physical activity and vertebral fractures and other fragility fractures is even less clear in men than in women (Fig. 3). The previously described EVOS study including 5,922 men shows that physical activity did not reduce the number of vertebral fractures. Actually, men with the highest activity level had the highest prevalence of vertebral fractures 43 (Fig. 3). Other studies, on the other hand, show a trend of reduction in the number of vertebral fractures with increased physical activity 4748. In conclusion, there are too few studies and partly contradictory data to make conclusions regarding physical activity and the number of vertebral fractures or other fragility fractures in men.

3.5 Fracture risk with detraining

There are a few short-term prospective studies that evaluate changes in BMD with detraining, most indicating a higher age related loss in BMD associated with reduced training 4950. But fracture risk has not prospectively been evaluated in these studies. Studies that evaluate long-term effects of detraining are cross-sectional or observational studies but no RCT. These studies indicate that all benefits in BMD are lost with decades of detraining 5152, even if there possibly remains benefits in skeletal structure 52. These studies also infer that there is a lower fracture risk in individuals with a former (or current) high physical activity 4952. There is one study with a RCT-like design 53, a study that investigated 27 postmenopausal women aged 58–75 subjected to a two-year back strengthening program, compared with 23 controls. The intervention period resulted in increased back strength in the exercising women. After eight years, the intervention group still had a higher back strength but also a higher BMD and fewer spine fractures (14 fractures in 322 vertebral bodies examined, 4.3%, in the control group and six fractures in 378 vertebral bodies examined, 1.6%, in the intervention group). The relative risk for compression fracture was 2.7 times greater in the control group than in the intervention group. To our knowledge, this is the first and only prospective study reported in the literature demonstrating a possible long-term effect of strong back muscles on the reduction of vertebral fractures 53.

4 Conclusions

Existing data indicate that exercise, in both men and women and independently of age, improves muscle strength even when conducted during a short period. The muscle strength improves far more and much faster than the increase in muscle mass. Physical activity in elderly individuals living by their own seems to reduce the number of falls. It is more questionable if similar physical training programs could reduce the number of falls among institutionalized elderly. A physically activity lifestyle is associated with lower number of hip fractures in women and probably also in men. Effect on other fragility-related fractures is less evaluated.

5 Recommendations

The existing data would support to recommend physical activity to improve muscle strength, improve balance reduce the risk to fall and with probable effect also on the risk to sustain fractures.

6 Conflict of interest and funding

Financial support was obtained from the University Hospital Foundations, Centrum for Sports Medical Research (CIF), the Swedish Society of Medicine, and the Swedish Society of Medical Research.