Adiposity and hyperglycaemia in pregnancy and related health outcomes in European ethnic minorities of Asian and African origin: a review

Abstract

Background : Ethnic minorities in Europe have high susceptibility to type 2 diabetes (T2DM) and, in some groups, also cardiovascular disease (CVD). Pregnancy can be considered a stress test that predicts future morbidity patterns in women and that affects future health of the child.

Objective : To review ethnic differences in: 1) adiposity, hyperglycaemia, and pre-eclampsia during pregnancy; 2) future risk in the mother of obesity, T2DM and CVD; and 3) prenatal development and possible influences of maternal obesity, hyperglycaemia, and pre-eclampsia on offspring's future disease risk, as relevant for ethnic minorities in Europe of Asian and African origin.

Design : Literature review.

Results : Maternal health among ethnic minorities is still sparsely documented. Higher pre-pregnant body mass index (BMI) is found in women of African and Middle Eastern descent, and lower BMI in women from East and South Asia compared with women from the majority population. Within study populations, risk of gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) is considerably higher in many minority groups, particularly South Asians, than in the majority population. This increased risk is apparent at lower BMI and younger ages. Women of African origin have higher risk of pre-eclampsia. A GDM pregnancy implies approximately seven-fold higher risk of T2DM than normal pregnancies, and both GDM and pre-eclampsia increase later risk of CVD. Asian neonates have lower birth weights, and mostly also African neonates. This may translate into increased risks of later obesity, T2DM, and CVD. Foetal overgrowth can promote the same conditions. Breastfeeding represents a possible strategy to reduce risk of T2DM in both the mother and the child.

Conclusions : Ethnic minority women in Europe with Asian and African origin and their offspring seem to be at increased risk of T2DM and CVD, both currently and in the future. Pregnancy is an important window of opportunity for short and long-term disease prevention.

• obesity
• gestational diabetes
• pre-eclampsia
• type 2 diabetes
• cardiovascular disease
• pregnancy
• prenatal development
• breastfeeding
• ethnicity
• immigrants

The rise in obesity prevalence, particularly childhood and early adulthood obesity, is estimated to substantially increase the costs for the health care systems in the EU 1. In 2010, between 35 and 80% of the adult population in European countries were overweight or obese 2. Together with sedentary behaviours, these conditions are the major drivers of the increased prevalence of type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM). Childhood obesity may also lead to a future epidemic of cardiovascular diseases (CVD) in early adulthood 3. These health problems are not evenly distributed, as most ethnic minority groups with origin from low- and middle-income countries, particularly from Asia and the Middle East, are disproportionally affected 4–6. Furthermore, T2DM is diagnosed up to 10–15 years earlier in the first generation of immigrants from Asia and the Middle East (including North Africa), compared with ethnic Europeans 5 7, and mortality rates from CVD 8 and T2DM 9 10 are higher. The pathophysiology of this increased risk is thought to be complex, involving a life history of gene and environment interactions, exacerbated by low physical activity and unfavourable diets 11. Migration may lead to a rapid ‘Westernization’ of dietary habits, typically an increase in intake of energy, fat, and refined carbohydrates and a shift favouring animal relative to vegetable food sources 12 13. Some studies point to socioeconomic deprivation to a large extent explaining the ethnic variations in CVD risk 14–17, but to a lesser extent the high prevalence of T2DM 18. However, as many immigrant populations in Europe are rather young 19, the morbidity and mortality patterns of the ethnic minority groups are still emerging.

Pregnancy can be considered a natural stress test for the mother 20. Complications like gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) and pre-eclampsia seem to be early markers of disturbances in glucose metabolism, endothelial dysfunction, and hypertension 21. In turn, presence of such factors predicts future risk of T2DM and CVD in the mother 20. A recent phenomenon is pregnancies complicated by pre-existing T2DM with numbers now exceeding that of type 1 diabetes in Europe 22. Also T2DM substantially increases the risks of several adverse pregnancy outcomes both for the mother and the child 23.

Research into the developmental origins of health and disease has established that a poor intrauterine environment may have significant consequences for both foetal growth and later risk of non-communicable diseases in the offspring 24 25. Also foetal overgrowth, which for a long while has been observed with maternal type 1 diabetes 23, is associated with several adverse outcomes for mothers and offspring also in milder hyperglycaemia and obesity 26. Thus, the higher prevalence of T2DM in ethnic minority women of reproductive age, and possibly also variations in obesity prevalence, milder forms of hyperglycaemia, and pre-eclampsia, may have major health consequences across generations.

The aim of this article is to review the literature about differences between ethnic groups of Asian and African origin and the majority population in European countries, respectively, regarding the following topics: 1) adiposity, hyperglycaemia, and pre-eclampsia in pregnancy; 2) future risk for the mothers of obesity, T2DM, and CVD; and 3) prenatal development and possible influences of maternal obesity, hyperglycaemia, and pre-eclampsia on the child's future risk of obesity, T2DM, and CVD. Ethnicity may be defined as the social group a person belongs to because of a shared culture, history, geographical origin, language, diet, physical, genetic, and other factors 27. In this review, the focus is on populations of Asian and African origin, as they are widely represented 19. In some countries, this will also include the second and higher generations after immigration.

Evidence acquisition

Literature was gathered through two different procedures. Systematic searches were performed in PubMed to identify European studies with a main aim to compare an outcome in ethnic groups of Asian and African descent compared with the general population/majority ethnic group. The selected outcomes were as follows:

• adiposity/weight status in pregnant women (Table 1);

• gestational weight gain (Table 2);

• GDM (Table 3);

• pre-eclampsia (Table 4);

• post-partum weight retention (Table 2); and

• birth weight (Table 5).

Table 1. Comparison of BMI in pregnant women between groups of Asian and African origin and the majority population in European countries

Author, year, (reference number)	Study design	Study population	Variable	Ethnic groups	n	Results		Comments
Djelantik et al. 2012 39	Community-based cohort study	Pregnant women living in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, January 2003–March 2004	Pre-pregnant BMI (pBMI)	N Dutch African Turkish Moroccan Other non-Western Other Western	7,871 4,900 495 328 585 904 659	pBMI 25–30 13.7% 30.9% 22.7% 33.4% 21.3% 11.1%	pBMI>30 4.1% 18.0% 11.0% 12.7% 7.9% 3.5%	Self-reported height and weight. pBMI>30 significantly more frequent among Turkish, Moroccan, and women of African descent
Jenum et al. 2012 41	Population-based cohort study	Healthy, pregnant women from three city district of Oslo, Norway, May 2008–2010	Pre-pregnant BMI (pBMI)	N Western Europe South Asia East Asia Middle East Somalia Sub-Saharan Africa/other non-Western	823^a 313 188 39 112 35 30	pBMI. Mean (SD) 24.6 (4.8) 23.7 (4.1) 22.3 (3.4) 25.9 (5.1) 26.8 (6.5) 26.3 (6.5)		Self-reported pre-pregnant weight, measured height at first visit. Heterogeneity between groups.
Hestlehurst et al. 2010 37	Database study	Women attending 37 maternity units in UK, 1989–2007	Early pregnant BMI	N White Asian/Asian British Black/Black British Mixed Chinese or other ethnic groups	619,323 447,423 50,738 22,525 5,962 11,394	BMI 25–29.9 24.7% 25.6% 32.3% 23.5% 20.5%	BMI>30 13.7% 10.4% 20.6% 12.7% 7.6%	Maternal height and weight at initial GP appointment, adjusted for gestational age. The study population was found to be nationally representative. Black/Black British had significantly higher ORs for overweight and obesity (Reference: White. Adjusted for age, parity, employment, and deprivation).
Ochsenbein-Kölble et al. 2007 48	Prospective cross-sectional study	Nulliparous women attending an obstetric prenatal outpatient clinic, Zürich, Switzerland, January 1996–February 2000	Pre-pregnant BMI (pBMI)	N Caucasians Asians Blacks	4,034 3,242 578 214	pBMI. Mean (SD) 23.6 (4.5) 22.5 (3.9) 24.1 (4.3)		Self-reported pre-pregnant weight. Mean pBMI sign different in Asians, but not in Blacks, compared to Caucasians.
Loetscher et al. 2007 40	Retrospective cohort study	Nulliparous women attending a prenatal outpatient clinic, Zürich, Switzerland, 1999–2003	Pre-pregnant BMI (pBMI)	N Switzerland Turkey Sri Lanka Middle East South Asia Far East Africa	1,432^a 262 95 173 24 36 36 118	pBMI>25 22.9% 42.1% 34.1% 41.7% 19.4% 2.8% 50.0%	pBMI>30 8.0% 16.8% 4.6% 8.3% 2.8% 0.0% 16.1%	Self-reported pre-pregnant weight, measured height at first visit. No analyses on differences in pre-pregnant BMI across ethnic groups were presented.
Hestlehurst et al. 2006 38	Database study	Women attending a maternity unit, Middlesbrough, UK, 1990–2004	Early pregnant BMI	N Caucasian Mixed race Asian/Asian British Black/Black British Chinese/other Ethnic group unknown	36,821 33,420 187 1,486 77 133 1,058	BMI 25–29.9 23.8% 18.2% 23.4% 28.6% 14.3% 24,1%	BMI>30 10.8% 11.2% 9.5% 10.4% 6.8% 11.2%	Maternal height and weight at initial GP appointment, adjusted for gestational age. Ethnicity was not significantly associated with obesity in models adjusted for age, parity, employment, deprivation, and marital status.

^aResults from women of other European and American nationalities not reported in this table.

For adiposity/weight status in pregnant women, studies reporting this measure in baseline data were also included. Weight data from the general female population were excluded as few studies report data for women of reproductive age separately. The search terms are presented in Appendix 1. The search was limited to papers in English and within the last 10 years with the final search 1 October 2012. Relevant studies from non-European countries were included when European studies were sparse or the studies highlighted specific aspects of relevance to the paper's aims.

Table 2. Comparison of gestational weight gain and post-partum weight retention between groups of Asian and African origin and the majority population in European countries

Author, year, (reference number)	Study design	Study population	Variable	Groups by ethnicity	n	Results	Comments
Ochsenbein-Kölble et al. 2007 48	Prospective cross-sectional study	Nulliparous women attending an obstetric prenatal outpatient clinic, Zürich, Switzerland, January 1996–February 2000	BMI and weight gain centile curves during the pregnancy	N Caucasians Asians Blacks	4,034 3,242 578 214	Asians and Blacks had significantly lower weight gain than Caucasians over the whole pregnancy period (p<0.001).	Self-reported pre-pregnant weight. Weight measured at each antenatal visit. Absolute weight change not presented.
Loetscher et al. 2007 40	Retrospective cohort study	Nulliparous women attending a prenatal outpatient clinic, Zürich, Switzerland, 1999–2003	Gestational weight gain	N Switzerland Turkey Sri Lanka Middle East South Asia Far East Africa	1,432^a 262 95 173 24 36 36 118	Mean (SD) net weight gain 10.9 (6,0) 11.6 (7,5) 8.4 (5,2) 11.3 (5.3) 10.3 (4.6) 11.6 (5.2) 9.0 (7.1)	Self-reported pre-pregnant weight. Weight at delivery (within 1 week prior to delivery) measured at the hospital No analyses on differences in weight gain across ethnic groups were presented.
van Poppel et al. 2012 82	Prospective cohort study	Pregnant women attending antenatal care in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, January 2003–March 2004	Weight retention 3–5 months post-partum	N Dutch Surinamese Turkish Moroccan Ghanaian	4,212^a 2,601 231 171 172 42	Weight retention>5 kg 26% 27% 52% 33% 26%	Self-reported pre-pregnant weight and weight 3–5 months post-partum. Turkish women had significantly higher crude OR for weight retention>5 kg (Reference: Dutch)

^aResults from women of other European and American nationalities not reported in this table.

For literature regarding mechanisms and theoretical models of relevance to highlight how the long-term health outcomes (part 2 and 3) may disproportionally affect ethnic minority groups of Asian and African origin, a hierarchical strategy was used. PubMed was searched using relevant search terms regarding a subtopic to identify: 1) review papers and theoretical reviews; 2) primary research papers of high quality (primarily cohort studies thought to be representative) if reviews did not provide specific information relevant for the ethnic minority populations in Europe; and 3) relevant reviews or primary research papers about ethnic differences from other continents, to be interpreted into a European context. Only the most recently published papers were used when relevant.

In the searches, papers on type 1 or type 2 diabetes and other specific diseases diagnosed prior to pregnancy, as well as papers about short time outcomes like stillbirth, caesarean section, malformations in the offspring, and about interventions, were excluded. However, as breastfeeding may benefit the mother and the baby in relation to several topics of interest in this review, this dimension of nutrition was included. As causal models rely on the available confounders and may make results from different papers less comparable, we primarily present crude or minimally adjusted results in the tables, to highlight the public health aspect. Although some risk factors for the clinical outcomes are mentioned, causal factors are not emphasised in this paper.

Table 3. Comparison of the risk of gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) between groups of Asian and African origin and the majority population in European countries

Author, year, (reference number)	Study design	Study population	Variable	Ethnic groups	n	Results		Comments
Jenum et al. 2012 41	Population-based cohort study	Healthy, pregnant women, living in three city district of Oslo, Norway, 2008–2010	GDM with WHO criteria	N Western Europe (ref) South Asia Middle East Other minorities	759 313 188 112 146	Crude prevalence 13% 11% 15% 17% 12%	AOR p=0.026 – 2.24 (1.26–3.97) 2.13 (1.12–4.08) 1.45 (0.77–2.73)	AOR: adjusted OR, adjusted for age, pre-pregnant BMI, parity
			GDM with modified IADPSG criteria (no 1-h glucose values)	N Western Europe South Asia Middle East Other minorities	759 313 188 112 146	Crude prevalence 32% 24% 42% 37% 30%	AOR p<0.001 (ref) 2.94 (1.94–4.47) 1.79 (1.10–2.93) 1.44 (0.91–2.28)	AOR: adjusted OR, adjusted for age, pre-pregnant BMI, parity
Khalil et al. 2012 62	Cohort study	Pregnant women in 3 hospitals in South England, UK	Diagnosis with modified WHO criteria (fasting plasma glucose≥6.0 mmol/l)	N Caucasian Afro-Caribbean South Asian East Asian Mixed	76,158 57,564 11,395 3,645 1,793 1,761	1,355 cases (1.8%)^a,b	Crude OR (ref) 1.89 (1.66–2.16) 2.31 (1.90–2.80) 2.26 (1.72–2.96) 1.18 (0.81–1.70)	Data collected as part of routine antenatal care. GDM screening by 2-step approach
Makgoba et al. 2011 63	Retrospective study	Pregnant women in 15 maternity units in North West London, UK, 1988–2000	GDM criteria not specified. Reported by midwives at delivery. Inconsistency in methods and diagnosis	N White European, Black African, Black Caribbean South Asian Other minorities	174,320 131,201 4,927 4,698 20,086 13,408	Crude prevalence 1.0% 0.7% 1.8% 1.1% 2.0% 2.0%	Crude OR* (ref) 2.62 (1.83–3.74) 1.21 (0.72–2.02) 3.00 (2.51–3.57)	Advancing maternal age and BMI was associated with significantly higher risk for risk for GDM in South Asian and Black African women than in White European

^aFigures calculated based on number of cases reported in the paper.

^bFigures in subgroups not reported.

*For the BMI group: 18.5–24.9.

Part I: Variations in adiposity, hyperglycaemia, and pre-eclampsia in pregnancy between minority groups of Asian and African descent and ethnic Europeans

Pre-pregnant adiposity and gestational weight gain

The health risks associated with overweight and obesity are, among other factors, attributable to the adipose tissue being a potent endocrine and paracrine organ 28 29. Adipose tissue holds metabolic functions which lead to increased levels of inflammation. Cytokine secreting macrophages may affect the insulin signalling pathway and cause increased insulin resistance 26 30. The hormones and cytokines produced by adipose tissue are therefore important links between obesity and obesity-related complications, including the adverse outcomes seen in pregnancies 31. Obesity status is usually defined based on body mass index (BMI), with overweight at 25–29.9 kg/m² and obesity at BMI≥30 kg/m2 32, although this is a crude measure of adiposity, particularly in the mid-ranges of BMI 33.

Today, more women enter their pregnancies as overweight or obese. Data from the United Kingdom show that in 2007, 16% of the women entered their pregnancy as obese, and the rate of increase seems to be accelerating 14. Both pre-pregnant obesity and excessive weight gain during pregnancy are found to increase the risk for GDM and pre-eclampsia in the mother and are linked with higher post-partum weight retention 34 35. Pre-pregnant obesity has also been indicated as an independent risk factor for adverse pregnancy outcomes for the offspring 36.

Six European studies which compared weight status in pregnant women of Asian and African descent with the majority population were identified (Table 1). Just one study had a nationally representative sample of pregnant women with register data from more than 600,000 births in the United Kingdom between 1989 and 2007 37. Among women categorised as Black/Black British, more than 50% were either overweight or obese, and this was the only group with significantly higher odds ratio (OR) of obesity than White women in further analyses. A previous, smaller population-based study from the United Kingdom did not find the same, but had a very low number of Black women 38. The four remaining studies had maternal weight status included as baseline characteristics in cohort studies. Thus, the representativeness of the prevalence figures is likely to be variable. However, one consistent finding from these studies from the Netherlands 39, Switzerland 40, and Norway 41 was that women originating from African and Middle Eastern countries tended to enter their pregnancies with higher BMI levels than the majority population in each country.

Table 4. Comparison of the risk of pre-eclampsia for groups of Asian and African origin and the majority population in European countries

Author, year, (reference number)	Study design	Study population	Variable	Ethnic groups	n	Results		Comments
Khalil et al. 2012 62	Prospective cohort study	Pregnant women in 3 hospitals in South England, UK	Pre-eclampsia, defined affording to International Society for the Study of Hypertension in Pregnancy (ISSHP)	N Caucasian Afro-Caribbean South Asian East Asian Mixed	76,158 57,564 11,395 3,645 1,793 1,761	1,698 cases (2.3%)^a,b	Unadjusted OR (ref) 2.91 (2.62–3.24) 1.58 (1.28–1.95) 1.03 (0.72–1.47) 1.23 (0.89–1.72	Data collected as part of routine antenatal care. Number of cases in subgroups not reported. Significantly higher OR for pre-eclampsia in Afro-Caribbean and South Asian than Caucasian women
Bouthoorn et al. 2012 78	Population-based prospective cohort study	Pregnant women, The Generation R Study, Rotterdam, the Netherlands, 2002–2006	Pre-eclampsia, defined according to ISSHP	N Dutch Turkish Moroccan Cape Verde Surinamese-Creole^c Surinamese-Hindustan	6,215 3,886 718 534 331 232 250	120 cases (2.1%)^a 1.9% 1.6% 0.8% 4.2% 2.4% 3.8%	Unadjusted OR (ref) 0.83 (0.44–1.57) 0.40 (0.14–1.10) 2.22 (1.22–4.07) 1.24 (0.5–3.11) 2.04(1.00–4.13)	4–11% missing values for hypertensive pregnancy complications in ethnic groups

^aFigures calculated based on number of cases reported in the paper.

^bFigures in subgroups not reported.

^cResults for the Surinamese, who are reported to have at least partly African (the Creoles) and Indian (the Hindustanis) ancestral origin are given in this table, but not for women from the Antilles.

All six studies found, on the other hand, that pregnant women of South and East Asian descent overall were leaner than the European population. For instance, Asian/Asian British and Chinese/other had significantly higher OR for lean (BMI <18.5) vs. ideal weight compared with White British women 37. However, these figures need to be interpreted considering studies showing substantial differences in the amount of body fat relative to BMI across ethnic groups 42, especially in Asians 43 44, where the body fat percentage appears to be from 1–8% higher among Asians compared with Caucasians at a given BMI, sex, and age 45. The clinical relevance of the variations in body composition is supported by findings that South Asians appear to be more insulin resistant than Europeans for the same level of BMI 46. Thus, altered risks of chronic diseases may attend at different levels of BMI in different groups defined by ethnicity 44 47; therefore, it is difficult to conclude on the true variations in adiposity between Asian pregnant women and their European counterparts. A more widespread use of the suggested lower BMI cut-off values for defining overweight (BMI≥23 kg/m2) and obesity (BMI≥25 kg/m2) among South Asians and other Asian groups should be considered in further studies 47.

Data are very limited on ethnic variations in gestational weight gain in Europe, with only two relevant studies from Switzerland identified (Table 2). Neither of the studies had ethnic variations in gestational weight gain as a main study aim. In the largest of these, both Asians and Blacks had lower weight gain than Caucasians over the whole pregnancy period 48. The other study reported somewhat higher mean net weight gains among women from Turkey, the Middle East, and Far East compared to Swiss women, and lower among women from Sri Lanka, South Asia, and Africa, but many of the subgroups had very few participants 40. A review concerning variations in and health risks of gestational weight gains 35 concludes that also American data on determinants of gestational weight gain are sparse. In one North American study, White women tended to gain excessively, while more Black women had inadequate gestational weight gain adjusted for pre-pregnant BMI and other factors 49.

Table 5. Comparison of differences in birth weight for groups of Asian and African origin and the majority population in European countries

Author, year, (reference number)	Study design	Study population	Variable	Ethnic groups	n	Results	Comments
Goedhart, 2008 122	Population-based cohort study	Singleton, live births born in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, Jan 2003–March 2004.	Birth weight	N Dutch Turkish Moroccan Ghanaian (African) Other minorities	7,118^a 3,859 361 629 137 2,123	Mean birth weight 3,548 g 1st gen: 3,469 g 2nd gen:3,429 1st gen: 3,527 g 2nd gen:3,419 g 3,366 g	All ethnic groups had lower mean birth weight for gestational age compared with the native Dutch.
Kelly et al. 2008 123	Population-based cohort study	A random sample of all births in England and Wales, 2000–2001.	Birth weight	N British White India Pakistan Bangladesh Black African Other minorities	17,769^a 14,068 433 687 215 327 2,339	Mean birth weight 3,416 g 3,072 g 3,110 g 3,089 g 3,343 g	Bangladeshi neonates were on average 327 g lighter than British whites. Indians 344 g, Pakistanis 306 g, and Black African 73 g lighter.
Moser et al. 2008 124	Population-based register study	All live births in England and Wales, UK, 2005	Birth weight	N British White India Pakistani Bangladesh Black African Other minorities	649,371^a 418,052 16,053 24,290 8,241 3,535 179,200	Mean birth weight 3,393 g 3,082 g 3,130 g 3,075 g 3,288 g
Harding, 2006 127	Population-based register study	Hospital records from two municipalities in Lisbon, Portugal, July 2001–June 2002	Birth weight	N Native Portuguese Foreign-born African Portugal-born African	3,918 2,744 750 424	Mean birth weight 3,252 g 3,307 g 3,232 g	Term neonates of foreign-born African mothers were slightly heavier than White Portuguese neonates, but this difference disappeared after basic adjustments.
Drooger, 2005 128	Population -based cohort study	‘The Generation R study’ (low-risk pregnancies), Rotterdam, the Netherlands (data collection from 2002).	Estimated foetal weight (by ultrasound at GW 40)	N Native Dutch Moroccan Turkish Cape Verdean Other minorities	1,494 741 53 66 30 604	Mean birth weight 3,519 g 3,447 g 3,389 g 3,210 g	Differences not significant in Moroccan neonates or in Turkish neonates after adjustments for maternal height/weight, parity, and gender.
Harding, 2005 125	Population-based register study	National birth data from Portugal 1995–2002, for two ethnic groups.	Birth weight	N Portuguese African	872,463 849,595 22,463	Mean birth weight 3,303 g 3,297 g	No difference in mean birth weight in the two groups.
Vahratian, 2004 129	Population-based register study	Births at three public hospital prenatal clinics in Belgium, May 1994–April 1995.	Birth weight	N Native Belgians North African	1,162 808 354	Mean birth weight 3,184 g 3,338 g	Neonates born by North African immigrants were 154 g heavier than native Belgians, but this difference disappeared when adjusting for gestational age.
Harding, 2004 126	Population-based register study	One percent of all births in England and Wales, 1983–2000.	Birth weight	N British White UK-born Indian Foreign-born Indian UK-born Pakistani Foreign-born Pakistanis UK-born Bangladeshi Foreign-born Bangladeshi UK-born Black African Foreign-born Black African Other minorities	57,674^a 52,554 491 1,297 417 1,121 99 896 75 224 300	Mean birth weight 3,400 g 3,033 g 3,066 g 3,110 g 3,123 g 3,026 g 3,110 g 3,167 g 3,302 g	All groups had significantly lower mean birth weight, compared with British White neonates. After adjustments for maternal factors, mean birth weights were similar in neonates born by UK-born and foreign-born mothers within these ethnic groups.
Vangen, 2002 130	Population-based register study	All births in Norway from 1980–1995 for four ethnic groups	Birth weight	N Norwegian Pakistani Vietnamese North African Other minorities	820,256 808,658 6,854 3,283 1,461	3,530 g 3,244 g 3,202 g 3,559 g	Neonates born by Pakistani mothers were 286 g lighter, Vietnamese 328 g lighter, and North African 29 g heavier than neonates born by Norwegian mothers.

^aResults from women of other European and American nationalities not reported in this table.

Gestational diabetes mellitus

In normal pregnancies, maternal immune responses occur to prevent rejection of the foetus and placenta. Maternal and placental hormones alter the carbohydrate and lipid metabolism to ensure shunting of nutrients to the foetus 26. Pregnancy can be considered as a diabetogenic and inflammatory state due to the higher levels of maternal insulin resistance, hyperlipidaemia, and fat deposition. These normal alterations are aggravated by maternal adiposity. The insulin resistance in pregnancy increases about 50–60% during pregnancy, irrespective of the pre-pregnant level 26. Thus, overweight and obese women start their pregnancy more insulin resistant compared with normal weight women and become highly insulin resistant in the second half of their pregnancy 26. This is also the case for pregnant women from East and South Asia, as they are found to be more insulin resistant compared with Western Europeans for the same level of BMI 46 50 51.

Pancreatic β-cells must compensate for the pregnancy-induced insulin resistance with increased insulin secretion. If not, hyperglycaemia may occur 52. South Asian women are reported to be less able to increase their β-cell function mutual to the pregnancy-induced insulin resistance compared with Western Europeans 50. Reduced β-cell insulin response, in the setting of insulin resistance, is also seen among Asians outside pregnancy 51.

GDM is defined as any degree of glucose intolerance with onset or first recognition during pregnancy 53 54. The initial GDM criteria, which are in use today with only minor modifications 55, were primarily set to identify women predisposed to develop T2DM later in life 56. The WHO criteria, most commonly used in Europe, include the definition of diabetes and impaired glucose intolerance outside pregnancy 57. The International Association of Diabetes in Pregnancy Study Groups (IADPSG) recommend universal screening, and has proposed new criteria, set to identify women with increased risk of adverse foetal outcomes 54. Until now, a two-step screening procedure has mostly been used in clinical practice and research, implying that only women with definite risk factors have had an oral glucose tolerance test, which is the gold standard for a definite diagnosis of GDM.

The different methodologies, diagnostic criteria, and screening practises make comparison of prevalence figures between populations a challenge 58. GDM prevalence figures reported from Europe range from 1 to 22% 58 and will increase substantially if the IADPSG criteria are adopted 54. The HAPO study found an overall GDM prevalence of 18%, ranging from 9.3 to 26% at the different study sites, with the IADPSG criteria 59. In line with the trends for obesity and T2DM, increasing rates of GDM and undiagnosed T2DM in pregnant women attending antenatal care are observed in most parts of the world 60 61.

In the searches, only three European studies, two from the United Kingdom and one from Norway, were identified with a main outcome to compare the risk of GDM in ethnic minority groups with the majority population (Table 3). The prevalence of GDM differs substantially in the three studies, reflecting the different screening practises and diagnostic criteria and sampling methods.

Nevertheless, within the study population, all the studies found a 2–3 higher OR for GDM in women of South Asian origin 41 62 63. The grouping of the ethnic minority population varies between the studies, but also Black African 63, East Asian and Afro-Caribbean 62, and Middle Eastern 41 women had significantly higher OR for GDM in the three studies. The study based on the large population in London also points to that women of Black African and South Asian origin had higher risk of GDM at a younger age compared with White British women 63. Similar ethnic differences and interactions with age have been found in Australia 64, United States 65, and Canada 66. Furthermore, women with South Asian origin developed GDM at a lower BMI compared with other ethnic groups 63, as also confirmed elsewhere 67–69. All studies conclude that a BMI cut-off of ≥25 kg/m² might not identify Asian women at risk for GDM. In addition to adiposity and age, family history and low socioeconomic status partly explain the increased risk for GDM in ethnic minority groups 41 61 70.

Another important aspect relevant for ethnic differences is that a two- to three-fold higher prevalence of GDM is reported when applying the new IADPSG criteria rather than the WHO criteria, mainly due to a lower cut-off value for fasting plasma glucose 41 71 72. The study from Oslo also showed that compared with the WHO criteria, the GDM prevalence increased 2.8 times in the South Asians, compared with 2.2 times in Western Europeans when applying the IADPSG criteria 41. In other studies, women with Arab and South Asian origin have more abnormal fasting plasma glucose values 71. However, the increase in the GDM prevalence when applying the IADPSG criteria differed in women from East and South Asia, as a pattern with relatively lower fasting values and higher 2-h glucose values was more prevalent in the East Asian women 41. This is in line with findings from the HAPO study where women from East Asia were less likely to be diagnosed with GDM with the fasting glucose value compared with women from other study sites 59. Dissimilarities in how the IADPSG criteria apply to different ethnic groups may shed light on the possible underlying etiologic variations in glucose metabolism.

Pre-eclampsia

Pre-eclampsia, defined by the International Society for the Study of Hypertension in Pregnancy as blood pressure ≥140/90 mmHg and 24-h proteinuria ≥0.3 g, is a multisystem disorder characterised by abnormal vascular response to placentation 73. Pre-eclampsia is the leading cause of maternal mortality globally 74 and may seriously affect foetal growth. Delivery is the only curative treatment. The incidence ranges from 3 to 7% for nulliparous and 1 to 3% for multiparas 73, with slightly increasing rates in recent years 74. Early pre-eclampsia (<37 weeks of gestation) is most serious for the mother and the foetus, and is more likely to recur in later pregnancies 74. The risk factors for pre-eclampsia may be divided in two subgroups: those related to immunogenetic factors and those related to maternal disease 75. Women with pre-existing hypertension, diabetes, obesity, GDM or a close relative with pre-eclampsia or early CVD are at increased risk 76 77.

Only two European studies exploring ethnic differences in pre-eclampsia were found (Table 4). In the largest study from United Kingdom, women of Afro-Caribbean origin had a three-fold higher OR compared with the Caucasians, and South Asians had an OR of 1.6 62. In a study from the Netherlands, women from Cape Verde and Creoles from Suriname (with at least partly African origin) had increased risk 78. Studies from the United States have consistently found that women of African ancestral origin have the highest risk for pre-eclampsia 75 79. However, East Asian women may have lower risk than White women 75.

Part II: Health consequences of excessive weight gain, gestational diabetes, and pre-eclampsia for the mother after pregnancy – are ethnic differences observed in Europe?

Risk of future obesity

Pregnancy has been considered a critical period for development of overweight and obesity. A significant proportion of the gestational weight gain is lost at delivery, and the natural course is to lose most of the remaining weight within 12 months post-partum 80. However, women with excessive gestational weight gains have increased risk of post-partum weight retention 34 81. Only one European study reporting post-partum weight retention across ethnic groups was found (Table 2). In this Dutch study, 52% of the Turkish mothers had retained more than 5 kg, 3–5 months post-partum, compared with 26% of the Dutch, and this difference was significant in further analyses 82. Parity, that is, the number of times a woman has given birth, has been suggested as a risk factor for development of obesity, indicating progressive weight gains in mothers with many children. Such mechanism would be of importance to groups with high fertility rates. However, recent systematic reviews contest whether parity is an independent risk factor for obesity development in general 80. North American studies have also explored the role of parity with specific relevance to ethnic differences in post-partum weight retention and find inconsistent relationships 83–87. Thus, weight retention patterns in ethnic minority groups in Europe and their determinants still need to be explored.

Breastfeeding has been considered to have a beneficial effect on post-partum weight loss. Two large studies, one from Denmark 88 and one among racially diverse women in the United States 89, show a positive effect of breastfeeding on long-term post-partum weight loss compared with formula feeding, with stronger effects with more intensive and longer duration of breastfeeding. However, the WHO Multicentre Growth Reference Study found that although breastfeeding mothers in Norway, USA, Brazil, and India followed the expected trend (sustained loss the first year, plateaus or slight upward shifts the second), breastfeeding mothers in Oman lost little weight and in Ghana they tended to gain weight 90. This study points to that ethno-cultural practices related to the mothers’ food-intake and physical activity pattern seem to attenuate the effect of breastfeeding on weight retention. Although the overall rates of breastfeeding differ between European countries, most studies find that ethnic minority women breastfeed longer than the majority population 91 with some exceptions 92. However, the United Kingdom Infant Feeding Survey showed that for every additional 5 years spent in the United Kingdom, immigrant mothers were 5% less likely to breastfeed for at least 4 months 93 and the prevalence of breastfeeding is lower than in their countries of origin 94.

A systematic review points to obese mothers being less likely to breastfeed compared with normal weight mothers 95, which may reinforce a tendency to gain weight, although one study from the United States indicated that this association could vary between ethnic groups 96. Little is known about possible associations between maternal weight status, breastfeeding problems and ethnic variations in Europe.

Development of type 2 diabetes in women with previous gestational diabetes

The increasing trend for GDM globally, and the relatively higher susceptibility of many ethnic minority women in Europe today, is worrisome. GDM may reflect either a pre-existing, undiagnosed T2DM or a pregnancy-induced glucose-intolerant state with a high risk of future T2DM 97. Therefore, most clinical guidelines recommend a sustained screening program after a pregnancy complicated by GDM 98, as T2DM may be prevented or postponed in these women 99. The gradual fall in β-cell function and progression into T2DM is influenced by when in the pregnancy GDM developed, insulin needs, obesity, and ethnicity; though the relation with ethnicity is complex and seems to differ between studies 98 100. Recurrence rates of GDM in subsequent pregnancies have been found to vary between 30 and 84%, with higher rates in minority groups compared with White populations 97. However, those who did not develop GDM in a subsequent pregnancy had a reduced risk of T2DM 101.

We found only one small European study exploring ethnic differences in conversion rates 102. A recent review, covering the early post-partum period, found overt T2DM in 1.2–4.5% of the women, but impaired glucose tolerance or impaired fasting glucose in as many as 12–36% 98. South Asians had higher rates of both screening and abnormal results. Generally, differences in reported incidence rates of T2DM may reflect differences in screening procedures and attendance 98, and the rates of abnormalities are probably underestimates, as several studies only used fasting glucose 103. The first review also covering a longer follow-up, included 28 studies, five were from White populations in Europe; the majority were from the United States 100. The cumulative incidence of T2DM after the index pregnancy with GDM was found to range as much as from 2.6 to 70%, dependant on length of follow-up, and with the highest incidence found in ethnic minorities 100. The incidence increased rapidly the five first years to about 50% overall, and then more slowly after 10 years.

A later systematic review of 20 studies including GDM women and a control group, found that women with previous GDM had a seven-fold increased relative risk of developing T2DM, with a slight increase in risk in recent years 104. When it comes to conversion rates in recent studies, a large Canadian register study found that women who had GDM reached an incidence of T2DM of 16% after 5 years 105. The meta-analysis revealed that the relative risk was generally consistent for subgroups (age, BMI, diagnostic criteria, study size), including ethnicity 104. Eight studies were from Europe; the only one exploring ethnic differences in conversion to T2DM found that women of North African origin had higher conversion rates than the majority population 102. Most of the other studies did not provide comparisons of ethnic groups relevant for Europe. Some recently published studies indicate that women of Asian 106 107 or African origin 108 may be at an even higher risk of progression to T2DM than White women. Nevertheless, clinicians in Europe today need to be aware of the high prevalence of GDM and the substantially increased risk of T2DM regardless of ethnicity for women with pregnancies complicated by GDM.

CVD in women with previous gestational diabetes and pre-eclampsia

In recent years, associations between GDM or pre-eclampsia and later CVD are increasingly recognised 20 21. Women with previous GDM may display early signs of increased CVD risk through higher values for endothelial dysfunction, inflammatory markers, and metabolic abnormalities than controls 109. Furthermore, T2DM negates the protective effect of being a female on the risk of CVD 110. Little is known about ethnic differences in the risk of future CVD in women with previous GDM, as this is a rather new issue which has to be studied in multi-ethnic cohorts with long-term follow-up. In a large Canadian population-based cohort, not stratified for ethnicity, previous GDM gave a 70% increased risk of developing CVD after 12 years of follow-up 111. After adjusting for T2DM, the risk was attenuated, indicating that much of the excess CVD risk was mediated by the development of T2DM. Therefore, prevention of T2DM in women with GDM seems indicated also with respect to CVD 99 111.

Furthermore, women who develop pre-eclampsia seem to be at increased risk for CVD later in life 20. Obesity and concomitant hyperlipidaemia, hypertension, and other disorders associated with pre-existing endothelial dysfunction, such as the metabolic syndrome and T2DM, are factors shared by women at risk of both pre-eclampsia and CVD 112. Endothelial dysfunction has been observed at 23 weeks of gestation in women who later developed pre-eclampsia, during pre-eclampsia, and 3 months after pre-eclampsia has resolved 113 114. Little is known about ethnic differences in susceptibility for CVD in women with pre-eclampsia. In a meta-analysis, women with a history of pre-eclampsia had a four-fold increased risk for hypertension, a two-fold increased risk for ischemic heart disease, stroke, and deep venous thrombosis, and 1.5-times higher all-cause mortality 115. The doubled risk of later CVD seemed to persist more than 20 years after the index pregnancy 115. Associations between pre-eclampsia and future CVD seem independent of other known risk factors. Early onset pre-eclampsia gave the greatest risk of future CVD with a seven-fold increase 115. For the outcome ischemic heart disease, five of eight studies were European, and only one study from the United Kingdom included a population of mixed ethnicity 116, but results were not analysed according to ethnic origin. The excess risk of pre-eclampsia in women of African ancestral origin is likely contributing to their excess risk of hypertension and CVD 115.

Part III: Ethnic differences in prenatal development and possible effects on future risk of obesity, diabetes, and CVD

Developmental origin of health and disease

There is now strong evidence supporting that early development plays a central role in determining an individual's risk of later adult disease 117. In short, this involves mechanisms of developmental plasticity, including epigenetic processes enabling the development of a phenotype appropriate for the environment in which the offspring is predicted to live 118. The phenotypic characteristics may relate to metabolic control, skeletal muscle fibre, cardiomyocyte, and nephron numbers and control systems such as appetite, stress responses, and timing of puberty. It is thought that mechanisms exist, mediated through placental function, by which the mother modulates foetal growth to be appropriate to her stature, pre-pregnant condition, and nutritional status 119. A poor intrauterine environment may predispose the offspring to favour brain growth while restricting growth of internal organs, bone and muscle, and fat deposition in the third trimester in anticipation of a poor post-natal environment 119.

Although the adaptations seem advantageous favouring short time survival, fitness, and reproduction, they may turn out to be inappropriate in the actual environment the offspring is born into – a term called developmental mismatch 117. This mismatch may result in long-term increased susceptibility to non-communicable diseases, such as obesity, T2DM, and CVD 120, as observed in ethnic minorities in Europe. The mismatch may arise through unbalanced diet or body composition of the mother or a change in environment and lifestyle factors between generations. This may particularly be the case when there are rapid rural to urban transitions, as in developing countries, and for immigrants from low- and middle-income countries to Europe, where the mother developed in a very different environment from that where she is pregnant 119.

A rather new developmental pathway to obesity is hyper-nutrition during foetal life, also called the foetal overnutrition pathway 120. This may create a ‘vicious cycle’ where the increasing prevalence of obesity and T2DM in the mothers endorses obesity in later generations 121. The foetal overnutrition pathway may be particularly important in Europe and other Western societies today, irrespective of ethnic background. These early life developmental factors are not thought to cause later non-communicable diseases, but may influence such risks through different non-mutually exclusive pathways, especially in a later obesogenic environment 117.

Neonatal size and body composition

Birth weight is the most accessible and described measure reflecting foetal growth. We identified nine European studies comparing birth weight in different ethnic groups (Table 5). Generally, birth weight was lower for most groups with maternal origin from low-income countries than for the majority population, with babies of Asian descent, particularly South Asian, being the smallest 122–130. A few studies found that neonates of North African and Sub-Sahara African descent had similar or even slightly higher birth weight than the majority population 125 129 130. Ethnic differences in intrauterine growth seem to become more pronounced towards term 128 and seem to persist also for neonates of the second generation of mothers 126 127. In some studies, parental 131 and socioeconomic factors 123 may partly explain ethnic differences in birth weight.

Assessment of neonatal body composition, that is, the description of lean and fat mass, gives a better indication of growth relative to the in utero environment than birth weight alone 26. No studies from Europe were identified, but large differences in neonatal body composition were found when comparing neonates born in the United Kingdom, India, Congo, Finland, Sri Lanka, China, Nigeria, and Jamaica 132. Indian neonates from a poor rural district had small abdominal circumference and low muscle mass, but relatively preserved body fat, compared with babies born in Southampton, United Kingdom 133 134, also called ‘the thin-fat-phenotype’. This is proposed to represent a predisposition to T2DM present at birth 133 134. Differences in neonatal body composition between groups with European and African ancestry have been found in the United States 135, mostly due to a relative reduction in lean mass. The patterns and timing of tissue growth also seem to differ between these groups 136.

Infants of mothers with obesity or hyperglycaemia are heavier at birth than those of normal weight or normoglycaemic mothers, mostly related to an increase in fat mass 137. In offspring of women with obesity and GDM, increased maternal pre-pregnant insulin resistance is the strongest predictor for neonatal fat mass 138. In line with this, the large HAPO study, covering several ethnic groups, showed an independent continuous and graded relationship between maternal glycaemia and maternal BMI, and foetal outcomes such as birth weight above the 90th percentile and neonatal adiposity 139. When assessed together, both maternal hyperglycaemia and obesity were independently associated with increased adiposity in the newborn 140, and their combination had a greater impact than either one alone. However, recent studies have found that the influence of maternal obesity and GDM seemed to be stronger in ethnic minority groups than in groups with European ancestral origin 141 142 and that the combined effects were particularly strong in these groups.

Pre-eclampsia is, on the other hand, associated with an increased risk of intrauterine growth restriction 143, often characterised by a relative sparing of head and skeletal growth, and relatively more reduced abdominal size and subcutaneous fat mass. In line with the observed susceptibility for pre-eclampsia in women of African-Caribbean origin, their offspring seem to be at increased risk of growth restriction and other adverse outcomes related to pre-eclampsia 62.

Early origins of childhood and adult obesity

Although many factors will contribute to obesity development over the life course, both a restricted and an excessive in utero environment appear to have an independent effect on later risk of obesity and related chronic diseases 144. In a large systematic review, maternal BMI, early rapid growth, early adiposity rebound, childhood obesity, and low paternal employment status were the factors most consistently associated with adult obesity 145. However, studies exploring the associations between low and high birth weight and subsequent adult obesity showed mixed results. This may partly be related to the fact that birth weight is a crude indicator of the uterine environment. Prenatal influences on the development of the liver, pancreas, and endothelial cells, and an altered body composition may be more important in explaining differences in obesity and metabolic risk than birth weight 146. We found no longitudinal studies in ethnic minorities regarding early origin of adiposity.

Also early feeding practices influence infant growth and subsequent risk of adult obesity. After the first 2–3 months, breastfed infants grow at a slower rate than those who are formula fed 147. In the Dutch ABCD-study, the growth rate from 1 to 6 months was higher in infants of African, Turkish, and Moroccan descent than in the native Dutch. Breastfeeding duration and exclusive breastfeeding at 4 months were associated with slower growth in all ethnic groups. Lower rates of breastfeeding partly explained the increased growth rate in infants of African descent 148. Additionally, weight gain during the first 6 months of life explained a large proportion of the increased prevalence of overweight in Turkish and Moroccan 2-year olds 149.

Present evidence suggests that breastfeeding 150–155, particularly prolonged breastfeeding 156–159, may exert a modest protective effect on childhood and adolescent obesity, although some of the evidence is contradictory 150. On the other hand, recent studies including siblings suggest that breastfeeding selectively protects against extremes of childhood size 152 153. Most studies have included only mothers and children of European descent. Suggested mechanisms are hormones in breast milk, such as leptin and adiponectin, which may determine appetite signalling 160. The higher protein concentration in infant formula compared with human milk 161 and the ability of breastfed infants to self-regulate their energy intake are other possible mechanisms 162.

Early origins of type 2 diabetes

Many studies have replicated the first report showing a graded inverse association between birth weight and risk of T2DM 163, particularly if followed by high childhood or adult weight gains 146. A systematic review and meta-analysis based on 31 populations, including six from Asia 164 found that the pooled age- and sex-adjusted OR for T2DM was reduced by 25% per kilogram increased birth weight, after exclusion of two studies from native North Americans, demonstrating a U-shaped association. Adjustment for current BMI slightly strengthened the association, but socioeconomic status did not materially affect the estimate 164.

Although middle-aged and older populations studied in the later 20th century have strong inverse associations between birth weight and T2DM, it remains uncertain whether this pattern will persist 164. The U-shaped curve observed in Native Americans, as well as younger cohorts, indicates that high birth weights may also confer a risk. This pattern may be more common as maternal obesity and hyperglycaemia become more prevalent 140. Breastfed infants seem to have a modest reduction in risk of T2DM in later life compared with formula fed infants, as well as marginally lower insulin levels 165. Similar effects have been observed across different population groups.

A recent phenomenon is that T2DM is now diagnosed even in children and adolescents, strongly related to obesity, parental T2DM, and ethnicity 166. In the United States, T2DM constitutes nearly half of new cases of diabetes diagnosed in adolescence, compared with only 1–2% of all diabetes cases in youth in Europe 167. Few European studies about T2DM in children and adolescents have been published, but several report T2DM precursors. A systematic review of British studies found no consistent differences in obesity prevalence among children of different ethnic backgrounds 168. However, a large cross-sectional study of British school children found higher levels of adiposity in several ethnic minority groups, especially those of South Asian origin, compared with White children 169. Furthermore, the metabolic profiles of South Asian children were more insulinogenic and atherogenic compared with White British children, and some T2DM precursors were also elevated in children of Black African-Caribbean descent 170. Milder dysglycaemia and impaired glucose tolerance have been found in 25% of children with a severe degree of obesity, irrespective of ethnicity 171. Factors associated with more rapid progression are marked weight gain and profound insulin resistance. Thus, possible rapid conversion to T2DM in high risk individuals from the most susceptible ethnic minority groups should not be ignored.

Early origins of CVD

Associations between birth weight and later CVD have been found in numerous studies 24 25. A recent review and meta-analyses of 22 studies, mostly from Europe, found that 1 kg higher birth weight was associated with a 12% lower risk of CVD mortality, and a 6% reduced risk of all-cause mortality 172.

A higher incidence of CVD, appearing at a younger age, has been seen in several ethnic minority groups compared with ethnic Europeans 173. We can only speculate if the lower birth weight and the higher proportion of neonates in the lowest birth weight categories observed in many ethnic groups may be a potential explanatory factor for the observed differences in CVD risk. The higher prevalence of pre-eclampsia in women of African origin 62 could also possibly contribute to a higher incidence of CVD through restricted foetal growth.

Conclusions

The health profiles of ethnic minority women of Asian and African origin in Europe are still relatively poorly documented. Summed up, pre-pregnant BMI appears to be heterogeneous between groups, but the studies point to higher levels of obesity in women of African, possibly also Middle Eastern descent, while women from South and East Asia tend to have lower BMI than the majority populations. Differences in gestational weight gain and post-partum weight retention are hardly documented in European immigrant populations, but variations are likely. However, ethnic variations in adiposity at the same level of BMI may be of importance to interpret the true health risks in these women. This is shown especially in the significantly higher risk of GDM in many groups, particularly those of South Asian ancestry, even at lower BMI levels.

A GDM pregnancy implies a substantially increased risk of future T2DM, although ethnic differences in conversion rates may exist. GDM may also imply a slight predisposition to later CVD. African origin is associated with increased risk of pre-eclampsia compared with women of European descent, and pre-eclampsia may influence later development of CVD.

Regarding the neonates of women descending from Asian and African countries, the birth weights are generally lower than in the majority population, a tendency that seems to persist, at least over some generations. A few studies find higher birth weights in babies of mothers of African descent. The small neonatal size in ethnic minority groups is most likely, at least in part, due to persistent maternal constraints on foetal growth and can probably be regarded as mismatched when exposed to the current obesogenic environment. Evidence is mounting that low birth weight increases the risk of later obesity, T2DM, and CVD. Furthermore, neonates exposed to maternal obesity and GDM may carry an increased risk of the same conditions linked to foetal overgrowth.

This review draws upon the awareness that pregnancy can be considered a natural stress test that can reveal the future risk of T2DM and CVD in women 20. The increasing trend in the prevalence of GDM and the higher risk found in many ethnic minority groups are of great concern, and further application of the new IADPSG criteria for diagnosis may lead to further unfolding of the problem. As maternal obesity also carries independent risks of adverse outcomes both in the mother and the offspring, this condition also deserves more attention.

Although genes obviously play a role for individual susceptibility, research at the forefront is now addressing the ‘soft inheritance’ and epigenetic mechanisms, which are highly relevant for the observed ethnic variations in health and disease 117. The combined effects of early and later life exposures, against a genetic predisposition, are needed to understand the ethnic differences in prevalence of T2DM and its underlying metabolic disturbances 174 175.

Implications

The pregnancy and post-partum period is an important, but presently underused, window of opportunity for prevention of future non-communicable diseases both in the women herself and for the next generation 118. New public health initiatives need to focus more on early life interventions as interventions in adulthood have shown limited results 118. The widespread coverage of antenatal care in Europe has considerable potential to promote awareness about healthy diets, physical activity, and appropriate weight gains in pregnant women. Pregnant ethnic minority women, and probably most women today, should be screened for GDM. However, the current WHO manual for the antenatal care has little focus on the long-term prevention of non-communicable diseases in the mother and her offspring 176.

In the post-partum period, women with pregnancies complicated by GDM should be screened by an oral glucose tolerance test to identify overt T2DM as well as milder forms of dysglycaemia, where development of T2DM may be prevented or delayed by lifestyle interventions 99. Other high risk women, such as those with pre-eclampsia, and with excessive weight gain in the previous pregnancy, should be offered individual counselling related to their future risk of obesity, T2DM, and CVD. As breastfeeding may be associated with a decreased risk of obesity and adult disease both for the mother and baby 88 89 154 165, current efforts to promote breastfeeding should be strengthened, not least for ethnic minority groups.

However, there is still no uniform strategy for how excessive weight gain during pregnancy and adverse pregnancy outcomes best can be prevented on a population level 177–182, but it is clear that interventions targeting ethnic minority groups need to be culturally sensitive and tailored to their specific needs 178. Both research into development of culturally sensitive and evidence-based interventions targeting the most susceptible ethnic groups during pregnancy and post-partum and efforts to implement such strategies at a larger scale are highly needed. This review also revealed that only few studies address ethnic differences in maternal and perinatal health in Europe. This should be a prioritised area for research in the future, recognising the importance of early life for later health and disease.

Authors’ contributions

AKJ provided overall leadership and guidance on the development of the review, in close collaboration with AM. All authors took part in the evidence acquisition, but had special responsibility for parts I (KM, CS, AM), II (AKJ, AM), and III (AKJ, LS). AB reviewed the literature and wrote the sections considering breastfeeding. All authors have read and approved the final version.

Conflict of interest and funding

The authors have not received any funding or benefits from industry or elsewhere to conduct this study.

Appendix 1

Search terms with regard to ethnic differences in the pre-pregnant BMI, gestational weight gain, post-partum weight retention, prevalence of gestational diabetes mellitus, prevalence of pre-eclampsia, and birth weight and body composition of neonates.

	Search terms
Table No, outcome	Main area	Demarcations		Joint search string
1: pre-pregnant weight	Body constitution	(Pregnant OR pregnancy)	Europe	(Human migration OR Africa OR Asia OR ethnic OR ethnicity OR race OR racial OR immigrant OR immigrants OR minority OR minorities OR ethnology)
2: gestational weight gain	Weight gain	(Pregnant OR pregnancy)	Europe
2: post-partum weight retention	Postpartum weight retention	(Pregnant OR pregnancy)	Europe
3: gestational diabetes mellitus	Diabetes, gestational	(Pregnant OR pregnancy)	Europe
4: pre-eclampsia	Pre-eclampsia	(Pregnant OR pregnancy)	Europe
5: birth weight	(Birth weight OR birth weight OR body composition OR fat OR lean OR thin)	(Newborn OR infant OR neonatal)	Europe	(Ethnology OR ethnic OR ethnicity OR race OR racial OR minorities OR groups, minority)

Filters: 10 years, English.