Use of CHROMagar Candida for the presumptive identification of Candida species directly from clinical specimens in resource-limited settings

Abstract

Introduction: Identification of yeast isolated from clinical specimens to the species level has become increasingly important. Ever-increasing numbers of immuno-suppressed patients, a widening range of recognized pathogens, and the discovery of resistance to antifungal drugs are contributing factors to this necessity.

Material and methods: A total of 487 yeast strains were studied for the primary isolation and presumptive identification, directly from clinical specimen. Efficacy of CHROMagar Candida has been evaluated with conventional methods including morphology on Corn meal–tween 80 agar and biochemical methods by using API 20 C AUX.

Results: The result of this study shows that CHROMagar Candida can easily identify three species of Candida on the basis of colonial color and morphology, and accurately differentiate between them i.e. Candida albicans, Candida tropicalis, and Candida krusei. The specificity and sensitivity of CHROMagar Candida for C. albicans calculated as 99%, for C. tropicalis calculated as 98%, and C. krusei it is 100%.

Conclusion: The data presented supports the use of CHROMagar Candida for the rapid identification of Candida species directly from clinical specimens in resource-limited settings, which could be very helpful in developing appropriate therapeutic strategy and management of patients.

• CHROMagar Candida
• resource-limited settings
• presumptive identification

Introduction

Infections due to Candida species and other fungi have increased dramatically in recent years and are of particular importance because of the rising number of immuno-compromised patients 1. Although Candida albicans remains the most common cause of human Candidiasis, the frequency of infection attributed to other members of the genus is also increasing 2 3. This is primarily due to the increase in the number of at risk individuals, particularly those with impaired immunity, such as transplant recipients, cancer patients receiving chemotherapy, and human immunodeficiency virus-infected patients 4 5 6 7 8 . In the 1980s C. albicans accounted for more than 80% of all candidal isolates recovered from nosocomial yeast infection 9. Now, C. albicans accounts for more than 80% of all Candida blood isolates in a recent review 10. The emergence of Candida species other than C. albicans is a matter of concern in several major institutions 3 11 12 13 14 . These species are also shown to have reduced susceptibility to antifungal agents. The frequency of isolation of Candida krusei, Candida glabrata, Candida tropicalis, and Candida prapsilosis is steadily increasing globally 15 16. Fungal infections caused by Candida species are being detected more frequently in clinical laboratories 17. Changing Candida epidemiology and availability of newer antifungal drugs with different antifungal spectra means that physicians can no longer make therapeutic decisions based on broad identification of fungi as yeast and mold 18. The conventional methods of yeast identification, which mainly consist of assimilation and fermentation characteristics, are reported to be cumbersome and beyond the expertise range available in local laboratories. In non-specialized clinical laboratories 19, especially in resource-limited settings, identification of yeast and yeast-like organisms requires evaluation of microscopic morphology and biochemical studies. Some unusual yeasts may require unique morphological and biochemical studies for identification, occasionally requiring up to 21 days of incubation 20. Effective treatment requires both early diagnosis and prompt initiation of therapy against fungal infection 21. As the traditional methods are tedious and time consuming to perform in the routine laboratories, numerous isolation media are available in the market that can identify pathogens within 4–72 hours, depending upon the system 22 23 24 25 26 . Several brands of chromogenic media are available for rapid identification of yeast. These special media yield microbial colonies with varying pigmentation secondary substrates that react with enzymes secreted by micro organisms 27. These media are species-specific, allowing the organisms to be identified to the species level by their color and colonial characteristics. The manufacturer of CHROMagar Candida currently advertises its product as able to detect and differentiate three species, C. albicans by growth as light to medium green colonies, C. tropicalis by growth as steel blue colonies accompanied by purple pigmentation diffused into surrounding agar, and C. krusei by growth as large, fuzzy, rose colored colonies with white edges, after incubation for 48 hours at 37°C, as also reported in several studies 28 29 30 31 32 . Detection of Candida on CHROMagar Candida from poly fungal specimen also allows direct and more rapid and specific identification of C. albicans and other spp. 29 32 33 which could decrease the time required to obtain results. Use of chromogenic media in clinical microbiology laboratories for the isolation and presumptive identification of important Candida species is easy to perform, requires less time and is cost effective too. In this study our goal was to evaluate the usefulness of CHROMagar Candida for detection and identification of major Candida species with accuracy to reduce the time of identification, and its characterization from poly fungal specimens, especially in developing countries in resource-limited settings.

2 Material and methods

2.1 Period of study

From April 2006 to September 2009.

2.2 Clinical isolates

A total of 487 yeast strains, including C. albicans (n=201), C. tropicalis (n=140), C. prapsilosis (n=32), C. krusei (n=30), C. glabrata (n=21), Candida lusitaniae (n=21), Candida guilliermondii (n=21), and Candida famata (n=21), were isolated from various clinical specimens (n=435) after direct plating on CHROMagar Candida (109 urine, 11 blood, 81 sputum, 22 wound, 91 vaginal secretion, and 21 peritoneal fluid).

2.3 Strains and media

Quality control strains of C. albicans (ATCC90029), C. prapsilosis (ATCC 2201), and C. krusei (ATCC6258) were taken from ATCC (American type culture collection) and IIDRL Laboratory, Department of Microbiology, University of Karachi, Pakistan. These control strains were first confirmed by using conventional methods, including germ tube formation test, and morphological characterization, which includes macroscopic features (morphology, color, size, and texture) on Sabouraud dextrose agar (SDA), Corn meal agar with tween 80 and CHROMagar Candida (CHROMagar Candida, France).

CHROMagar Candida medium comprised per liter peptone (10 g), glucose (20 g), agar (15 g), chloramphenicol (0.5 g), and Chromogenic ix. (2 g), pH 6.1. This medium was prepared according to the manufacturer's instructions, does not require autoclaving and is dispensed into Petri plates after cooling. Culture was inoculated and incubation was done at 37°C. The appearance of colonies, including color, size, and textures on CHROMagar Candida was analyzed.

2.4 Identification methods

All samples were first plated on SDA and CHROMagar for 48 hours at 37°C. The production of color and morphology as described by the manufacturer were recorded and the photographs recorded. For C. albicans the germ tube test was also performed to differentiate between C. albicans and non albicans Candida (NAC). The colonies from CHROMagar and SDA were plated on corn meal agar with Tween 80 for morphological examination of the production of chlamydospores, blastospores, true hyphae, and branched pseudohyphae. The results were again compared with the colonies that were grown on CHROMagar. These colonies from SDA were subjected to biochemical analysis by API 20C Aux (Biomuriex). Finally the results were again compared with the culture results and speciation was done. The data suggested that species which were identified by CHROMagar and Corn meal–Tween 80 agar were the same as were confirmed by API 20C Aux. It means that in the presence of CHROMagar it is not necessary to perform germ tube test for C. albicans to confirm, as was also reported by Odds and Bernaerts 31.

3 Results

We evaluated 487 yeast isolates from 435 clinical specimens during April 2006 to September 2009 (Table 1). These samples were directly plated on CHROMagar Candida (CHROMagar Candida, France), SDA (Oxoid), Corn meal agar (Oxoid) with Tween 80, and on CHROMagar Candida and SDA. Colony growth was observed after 24 and 48 hours of incubation. The development of the colony color was noted on CHROMagar Candida, and we observed that the medium better differentiated the color of colonies after 48 hours of incubation, while after 72 hours of incubation a distinct deep color of the colonies was observed. It was also noted that colony colors of isolated strains were deepened with the passage of time and persistence of pigment was also observed on CHROMagar plates after more than 15 days, as also reported by Pfaller, Houston and Coffmann 32.

Table 1. Growth and colonial characteristics of 487 yeast isolates incubated for 2 days on CHROMagar Candida and Corn meal–tween 80 agar at 37°C and identification of clinical yeast isolates by API 20C Aux Candida kits (Biomerieux)

Species	Total number. of isolates	Colony characteristics on CHROMagar Candida	Morphologic features on Corn meal–tween 80 agar	Identification by API 20C AUX
Candida albicans	201	Apple green colonies; consistent	Chlamydospores present; abundant pseudohyphae, and true hyphae, clusters of blastospores are present	Identified as C. albicans
Candida tropicalis	140	Dull blue, to purple color that diffused into surrounding agar with pale pink edges	Abundant pseudohyphae with blastoconidia	Identified as C. tropicalis
Candida parapsilosis	32	White to pale pink colonies	Clusters of blastospores were seen occasionally giant cells	Identified as C. parapsilosis
Candida krusei	30	Large, flat, spreading, pale pink colonies with matt surfaces	Branched pseudo mycelium with clusters and chains of blastospores	Identified as C. krusei
Candida glabrata	21	White large glossy pale pink to violet colonies	Pseudohyphae not present	Three isolates were not C. glabrata
Candida guilliermondii	21	Small pink to purple colonies	Pseudohyphae with clusters of blastospores	Identified as C. guilliermondii
Candida lusitaniae	21	Pink gray purple	Branched pseudohyphae present	Identified as C. lusitaniae
Candida famata	21	White to light pink colonies	Pseudohyphae not present	Identified as C. famata

The yeast cells were identified according to morphology and color of colonies on CHROMagar Candida. Germ tube formation for C. albicans was done with microscopic morphology on Corn meal–Tween 80 agar and confirmed by API 20C Aux yeast identification panel (Biomuriex, France), based on assimilation of carbohydrates.

The color of colonies on CHROMagar Candida was similar as given by the manufacturer, i.e. green colonies of C. albicans as indicated in Fig. 1C and D, steel blue colonies of C. tropicalis (Fig. 1A and B) accompanied by purple pigmentation which diffuses into surrounding agar by growth, and large, fuzzy, rose colored colonies with white edges of C. krusei, slightly white pale pink edges and small pink to purple colonies of C. guilliermondii, can easily be differentiated from Candida norvegensis which also produces purple color colonies. The edges of all colored colonies were paler and dark centered and the colony size was between 1 and 5 µm in diameter, also described by Odds and Bernaerts 31. The smooth white to light pink colonies of C. glabrata which later became pink (Fig. 1) and others spp. of Candida appear off-white including C. lusitaniae, C. famata, C. prapsilosis, and Candida rugosa.

Figure 1.  (A) Candida tropicalis bluish purple colonies. (B) The appearance of C. tropicalis after 72 hours of incubation on CHROMagar at 37°C. (C) Apple green color colonies of Candida albicans grown for 48 hours on CHROMagar Candida at 37°C. (D) Isolated green color colonies of C. albicans grown for 48 hours on CHROMagar Candida at 37°C. (E) Direct plating of sample on CHROMagar Candida for 48 hours at 37°C. Mix colonies of different species can also seen on this plate. (F) Smooth pink colonies of Candida glabrata grown for 48 hours on CHROMagar Candida at 37°C.

Comparative specificity and sensitivity of CHROMagar Candida (CHROMagar Candida, France) in terms of colony growth showed maximum sensitivity and specificity with 95% confidence level in the range of 95.3–100% (Table 2).

Table 2. Comparative specificity and sensitivity of three different cultural media for Candida spp.

Name of media	Specificity (N=487)	Sensitivity (N=487)	95% Confidence level	P-value
SDA	464 (95.3%)	467 (95.9%)	94.5–100%	<0.05
CHROMagar Candida	479 (98.4%)	478 (98.2%)	95.3–100%	<0.05
Corn meal agar with tween 80	470 (96.5%)	463 (95.0%)	92–99.4%	<0.05

CHROMagar Candida correctly identified 99% of C. albicans, 98% C. tropicalis, 100% C. krusei, 94% of C. glabrata but for other Candida species other tools of identification, for example, API 20C Aux along with CHROMagar Candida (CHROMagar Candida, France) should be used for the correct identification. For example, conventional methods, which includes macroscopic/microscopic characteristic, and biochemical profile by API system of identification (gold standard) to facilitate the diagnosis with efficiency and accuracy, should be possible simultaneously, so that the identification should be accomplished.

4 Discussion

In resource-limited countries, lack of training and of proper reagents, supplies and equipment makes detection and rapid presumptive identification of yeast species quite difficult. In order to reduce the financial burden of the poor patients, these laboratories do not go beyond the germ tube test and limit their diagnosis to C. albicans or NAC. The biochemical assimilation and fermentation tests are not used in these laboratories due to lack of resources, expertise, and the time required for these tests which increases the cost of mycology cultures 32. As a result, direct selection of appropriate agents for antifungal therapy or prophylaxis becomes almost impossible.

In resource-limited countries, clinicians have little confidence in the accuracy and quality of laboratory test results. They continue to prescribe costly antifungals without knowing the exact antifungal profile of the infectious agent; thereby they increase the economic burden of the society, which also contributes to the emergence of resistant Candida spp.

Without diagnostic tools, safe and effective drug treatment, prevention of resistance to antimicrobial therapy, and monitoring of resistance are not possible. In this setting there is always a need of a medium which helps not only in the isolation but also in the identification of the agent at the species level. The CHROMagar Candida medium was selected as a primary culture medium along with SDA, and we found it an appropriate and affordable diagnostics medium in resource-limiting setting. The reason is that an approximate cost per culture for complete identification of Candida using SDA, Corn meal agar, and API 20C Aux in Pakistan is around US$ 15 (Pak Rs. 1,200), while CHROMagar Candida costs around US$ 3 (Pak Rs. 250) per specimen culture, and thus it is more economical.

We also found that CHROMagar Candida, France easily identifies several species of Candida on the basis of colony color and morphology and accurately differentiates between the three most common species of Candida ,i.e. C. albicans, C. tropicalis, and C. krusei, which has also been reported by Murray et al. 20. This medium easily facilitates the detection of more than two species in a single specimen by giving different colored colonies on a plate at the same time, and it was also observed that if the specimen was heavily inoculated, it was difficult to differentiate between mixtures of yeast species on a single agar plate because of the different color reactions (Fig. 1).

The specificity and sensitivity of CHROMagar Candida for green color colony of C. albicans was calculated as 99%, for blue colonies with dark center surrounded by gray halo of C. tropicalis calculated as 98%, and for pink rough and spreading colonies with broad white edges of C. krusei as 100%. The CHROMagar Candida (CHROMagar Candida, France) can be used as culture medium for the primary isolation and presumptive identification of organisms in cases where early diagnosis of infections is needed without doing PCR 31. CHROMagar Candida (CHROMagar Candida, France) can also support the growth of fungi, in some cases where the causative agent might be a mold, as reported by Beck-Sague and Jarvis 9. This has also been observed in our study. Sometimes we found a mixture of yeast and mold in a single specimen, so this ability of the medium to support the growth of mold can easily be utilized in the laboratory setting.

5 Conclusion

On the whole it was observed that as the CHROMagar Candida (CHROMagar Candida, France) gives a presumptive identification within 48 hours, preliminary antifungal treatment can be administered with confidence while the confirmed identification is being obtained. In resource-limited settings, availability of this type of media not only facilitates the provision of rapid patient care, but may also assist to control the rise in antifungal agent resistance by reducing the time taken for presumptive identification of the organism at species level to start the therapeutic regime.

We can conclude that use of fast and accurate diagnostic methods can help in rapid treatment of patients.

6 Conflict of interest and funding

The authors have not received any funding or benefits from industry to conduct this study.

Acknowledgements

We are grateful to CHROMagar Candida, France and Biomerieux international for the generous donation of CHROMagar Candida and API 20C AUX used in this study, Dr. Uzair ul Ghani for his guidance, Prof. Dr. Riaz Ahmed Hashmi and administration of Jinnah University for Women, Karachi, Pakistan, for their financial support, and Ms. Fasiha Saeed, Lecturer, Department of Microbiology, Jinnah University for Women, Karachi for her technical support throughout the study.