345
Views
9
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Review

Toward an institutional theory of escalation of commitment within sport management: A review and future directions

, &
Pages 571-583 | Received 06 Sep 2018, Accepted 15 Jan 2019, Published online: 19 Jan 2019

References

  • M.HutchinsonC.T.HavardB.K.BergT.D.RyanLosing the core sport product: Marketing amidst uncertainty in college athleticsSport Marketing Quarterly252016185194
  • H.R.ArkesC.BlumerThe psychology of sunk costsOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes351985124140
  • M.HutchinsonD.A.RascherK.JenningsA smaller window to the university: The impact of athletic de-escalation on status and reputationJournal of Intercollegiate Sport920167389
  • A.BanduraSocial learning theory1977Prentice-HallEnglewood Cliffs, NJ
  • T.BatemanThe escalation of commitment in sequential decision-making: Situational and personal moderators and limiting conditionsDecision Sciences1719863349
  • M.H.BazermanNegotiator judgment: A critical look at the rationality assumptionThe American Behavioral Scientist271983211228
  • M.H.BazermanT.GiulianoA.AppelmanEscalation in individual and group decision makingOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance331984141152
  • H.S.BeckerNotes on the concept of commitmentThe American Journal of Sociology6619603240
  • H.S.BeckerPersonal change in adult lifeSociometry2819644053
  • J.BehrensE.HolgerWhat keeps managers away from a losing course of action? Go/Stop decisions in new product developmentThe Journal of Product Innovation Management312014361374
  • B.K.BergM.HutchinsonC.C.IrwinPrioritizing local sport activities: Determining organizational commitment to an innovative swimming programCase Studies in Sport Management520166979
  • B.K.BergK.WinsleyR.D.FullerM.HutchinsonFrom crisis to de-escalation: An examination of politics in a high school steroid testing programInternational Journal of Exercise Science102017890899
  • J.M.BeyerD.R.HannahThe cultural significance of athletics in US higher educationJournal of Sport Management1422000105132
  • A.BouchetM.HutchinsonOrganizational escalation to an uncertain course of action: A case study of institutional branding at Southern Methodist UniversityJournal of Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics32010272295
  • A.BouchetM.HutchinsonOrganizational escalation and retreat in university athletics: Brand insulation in Birmingham-Southern College’s transition to Division III athleticsJournal of Intercollegiate Sport42011261282
  • A.BouchetM.D.LairdM.TroiloM.HutchinsonG.FerrisEffects of increased commitment on reputation and status: Evidence from NCAA Division I universitiesSport Management Review202017395407
  • W.BouldingR.MorganR.StaelinPulling the plug to stop the new product drainJournal of Marketing Research341997164176
  • M.BowenThe escalation phenomenon reconsidered: Decision dilemmas or decision errorsThe Academy of Management Review1219875266
  • J.BrocknerS.NathansonA.FriendJ.HarbeckC.SamuelsonR.HouserThe role of modeling processes in the “knee deep in the Big Muddy” phenomenonOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance3319847799
  • J.BrocknerJ.Z.RubinE.LangFace-saving and entrapmentJournal of Experimental Social Psychology1719816879
  • J.BrocknerM.C.ShawJ.Z.RubinFactors affecting withdrawal from an escalating conflict: Quitting before it’s too lateJournal of Experimental Social Psychology151979492503
  • L.ChalipToward a distinctive sport management disciplineJournal of Sport Management2012006121
  • M.J.ChenK.H.SuW.P.TsaiCompetitive tension: The awareness-motivation-capability perspectiveThe Academy of Management Journal502007101118
  • A.CohenKroc Center challenges will continue after construction’s done (May). Retrieved from2013Athletic Businesshttp://https://www.athleticbusiness.com/kroc-center-challenges-will-continue-after-construction-s-done.html
  • E.J.ConlonJ.M.ParksInformation requests in the context of escalationThe Journal of Applied Psychology721987344350
  • M.A.DavisP.BobkoContextual effects on escalation processes in public sector decision makingOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes371986121138
  • D.L.DeephouseM.SuchmanLegitimacy in organizational institutionalismR.GreenwoodC.OliverK.SahlinR.SuddabyThe SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism2008SAGE.Thousand Oaks, CA4977
  • B.DennisTrump budget seeks 23 percent cut at EPA, eliminating dozens of programs February 12). Retrieved from2018The Washington Posthttp://https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2018/02/12/trump-budget-seeks-23-percent-cut-at-epa-would-eliminate-dozens-of-programs/?utm_term=.f6c58439579f
  • C.E.DeversG.M.McNamaraR.M.WisemanM.ArrfeltMoving closer to the action: Examining compensation design effects on firm riskOrganization Science192008548566
  • P.DiMaggioW.W.PowellThe iron cage revisited: Collective rationality and institutional isomorphism in organizational fieldsAmerican Sociological Review481983147160
  • S.EssexB.ChalkeyMega-sporting events in urban and regional policy: A history of the Winter OlympicsPlanning Perspectives192004201232
  • R.FiedlandR.R.AlfordBringing society back in: Symbols, practices, and institutional contradictionsW.W.PowellP.J.DiMaggioThe New institutionalism in organizational analysis1991University of Chicago PressChicago, IL232263
  • R.ForsythRangers in crisis: The final whistle sounds on Rangers 140 years of history Retrieved from:2012Telegraphhttp://https://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/teams/rangers/9327256/Rangers-in-crisis-the-final-whistle-sounds-on-Rangers-140-years-of-history.html
  • R.ForsythRangers chairman Dave King bullish on Rangers spending spree Retrieved from:2017Telegraphhttp://https://www.telegraph.co.uk/football/2017/06/22/rangers-chairman-dave-king-bullish-spending-spree-gathers-pace/
  • F.V.FoxB.M.StawThe trapped administrator: Effects of a job insecurity and policy resistance upon commitment to a course of actionAdministrative Science Quarterly241979449471
  • H.H.GarlandC.A.SandefurDe-escalation of commitment in oil exploration: When sunk costs and negative feedback coincideThe Journal of Applied Psychology751990721727
  • D.GhoshDe-escalation strategies: Some experimental evidenceBehavioral Research in Accounting9199788112
  • C.GomezJ.I.SanchezCultural boundaries of self-justification and prospect theories in escalation of commitment: A US-Mexico comparisonInternational Journal of Human Resource Management24201326462656
  • P.S.GoodmanM.BazermanE.ConlonInstitutionalization of planned organizational changeB.M.StawL.L.Cummings Research in organizational behavior Vol. 2 (1980) JAI Press. Greenwich, CT. 215–246.
  • R.GreenwoodC.OliverK.SahlinR.SuddabyThe SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism2008SAGE.Los Angeles, CA
  • R.GreenwoodM.RaynardF.KodeihE.R.MicelottaM.LounsburyInstitutional complexity and organizational responsesThe Academy of Management Annals512011317371
  • I.GulerThrowing good money after bad? Political and institutional influences on sequential decision making in the venture capital industryAdministrative Science Quarterly522007248285
  • C.HeathEscalation and de-escalation of commitment in response to sunk costs: The role of budgeting in mental accountingOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes6219953854
  • C.R.HiningsD.LogueC.ZietsmaFields, insitutional infrastructure and governanceR.GreenwoodC.OliverT.B.LawrenceR.E.MeyerThe SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism2nd ed.2018SAGEThousand Oaks, CA163189
  • M.HutchinsonInitiating institutional redirection: Factors for de-escalation of commitment in Division I athletic departmentsJournal of Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics62013114130
  • M.HutchinsonB.K.BergInstitutions of higher commitment: A case study of de-escalation and American football’s decisive role in intercollegiate athleticsSport Management Review182015464480
  • M.HutchinsonA.BouchetOrganizational redirection in highly bureaucratic environments: De-escalation of commitment among Division I athletic departmentsJournal of Sport Management282014143161
  • M.HutchinsonA.BouchetAchieving organizational de-escalation: Exit strategy implementation among United States collegiate athletic departmentsSport Management Review172014347361
  • M.HutchinsonB.K.BergT.B.KellisonPolitical activity in escalation of commitment: Sport facility funding and government decision making in the United StatesSport Management Review212018263278
  • M.HutchinsonC.NiteA.BouchetEscalation of commitment in United States collegiate athletic departments: An investigation of social and structural determinants of commitmentJournal of Sport Management2920155775
  • K.KadousL.M.SedorThe efficacy of third-party consultation in preventing managerial escalation of commitment: The role of mental representationsContemporary Accounting Research2120045582
  • M.KeilPulling the plug: Software project management and the problem of project escalationMIS Quarterly191995421447
  • M.KeilM.MähringIs your project turning into a black hole?California Management Review532010631
  • M.KeilD.RobeyTurning around troubled software projects: An exploratory study of the de-escalation of commitment to failing courses of actionJournal of Management Information Systems1519996387
  • M.KeilD.RobeyBlowing the whistle on troubled software projectsCommunications of the ACM4420018793
  • M.KeilG.DepledgeA.RaiEscalation: The role of problem recognition and cognitive biasDecision Sciences382007391421
  • T.B.KellisonS.TrendafilovaB.P.McCulloughSustainable stadium design as cause and effect of social changeInternational Journal of Event Management Research1020156383
  • D.KellyM.A.DixonBecoming a “real university:” the strategic benefits of adding football for NCAA Division I institutionsJournal of Intercollegiate Sport422011283303
  • M.C.KernanR.G.LordThe effects of explicit goals and specific feedback on escalation processesJournal of Applied Social Psychology19198911251143
  • S.KesenneThe economic impact, costs and benefits of the FIFA world cup and the olympic games: Who wins, who loses?W.MaennigA.ZimbalistInternational handbook on the economics of mega sporting events2012Edward Elgar PublishingNorthampton, MA270278
  • S.L.KirbyM.A.DavisA study of escalating commitment in principal-agent relationships: Effects of monitoring and personal responsibilityThe Journal of Applied Psychology831998206217
  • M.S.KraatzE.S.BlockOrganizational implications of institutional pluralismR.GreenwoodC.OliverK.SahlinR.SuddabyThe SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism2008SAGE.Thousand Oaks, CA243275
  • J.Y.Y.KwongK.F.E.WongReducing and exaggerating escalation of commitment by option partitioningThe Journal of Applied Psychology992014697712
  • D.LamB.OzorioThe effect of prior outcomes on gender risk-taking differencesJournal of Risk Research162013791802
  • A.LeviEscalating commitment and risk taking in dynamic decision behavior Unpublished doctoral dissertation1982Yale UniversityNew Haven, CT
  • M.D.MahlendorfC.M.WallenburgPublic justification and investment in failing projects: The moderating effect of optimistic outcome expectationsJournal of Applied Social Psychology43201322712286
  • M.MähringM.KeilInformation technology project escalation: A process modelDecision Sciences3922008239272
  • M.MähringM.KeilL.MathiassenJ.Pries-HejeMaking IT project de-escalation happen: An exploration into key rolesJournal of the Association for Information Systems92008462496
  • J.G.MarchBounded rationality, ambiguity, and the engineering of choiceThe Bell Journal of Economics91978587608
  • B.E.McCainContinuing investment under conditions of failure: A laboratory study of the limits of escalationThe Journal of Applied Psychology711986280284
  • B.P.McCulloughM.PfahlS.NguyenThe green waves of environmental sustainability in sportSport in Society: Cultures, Commerce, Media, Politics19201610401065
  • G.M.McNamaraJ.HaleblianB.J.DykesThe performance implications of participating in an acquisition wave: Early mover advantages, bandwagon effects, and the moderating influence of industry characteristics and acquirer tacticsThe Academy of Management Journal512008113130
  • G.M.McNamaraH.MoonP.BromileyBanking on commitment: Intended and unintended consequences of an organization’s attempt to attenuate escalation of commitmentThe Academy of Management Journal452002443452
  • W.G.MeyerThe effect of optimism bias on the decision to terminate failing projectsProject Management Journal452014720
  • J.W.MeyerB.RowanInstitutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremonyThe American Journal of Sociology831977340363
  • R.MontealegreM.KeilDe-escalating information technology projects: Lessons from the Denver International AirportManagement Information Systems Quarterly242000417447
  • H.MoonD.E.ConlonFrom acclaim to blame: Evidence of a person sensitivity decision biasThe Journal of Applied Psychology8720023342
  • C.NiteT.Bopp Conflicting prescriptions for ‘ethical’ leadership in complex institutions: Perspectives from U.S. Collegiate athletic administrators Vol. 13 (2017) Leadership. 368–387.
  • C.NiteM.HutchinsonThe pursuit of legitimacy: Expanding conceptions of escalation of commitment within sportInternational Journal of Sport Management2018
  • C.NiteM.HutchinsonE.N.MeltonA.BouchetLocating universities within the phases of escalation of commitment to intercollegiate athleticsJournal of Applied Sport Management7201583108
  • C.NiteJ.N.SingerG.B.CunninghamAddressing competing logics between the mission of a religious university and the demands of intercollegiate athleticsSport Management Review162013465476
  • G.B.NorthcraftG.WolfDollars, sense, and sunk costs: A life cycle model of resource allocation decisionsThe Academy of Management Review91984225234
  • G.B.NorthcraftW.GleesonG.WolfFactors affecting the strength of commitment to a course of action Unpublished manuscript1984University of Arizona, Department of Management and PolicyTucson, AZ
  • D.O’BrienT.SlackThe emergence of a professional logic in English rugby union: The role of isomorphic and diffusion processesJournal of Sport Management18120041339
  • W.OcasioP.H.ThortonM.LounsburyAdvances to the institutional logics perspectiveR.GreenwoodC.OliverT.B.LawrenceR.E.MeyerThe SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism2nd ed.2017SAGE.Thousand Oaks, CA509531
  • O.PalaD.J.VriensJ.A.M.VennixCausal loop diagrams as a de-escalation techniqueThe Journal of the Operational Research Society662015593601
  • G.PanS.L.PanTransition to IS project de-escalation: An exploration into management executives’ influence behaviorsIEEE Transactions on Engineering Management582011109123
  • G.PanS.L.PanM.NewmanManaging information technology project escalation and de-escalation: An approach-avoidance perspectiveIEEE Transactions on Engineering Management5620097694
  • G.PanS.L.PanM.NewmanD.FlynnEscalation and de-escalation of commitment: A commitment transformation analysis of an e-government projectInformation Systems Journal12006321
  • J.PfefferPower in organizations1981PitmanMarshfield, MA
  • J.RossB.M.StawExpo 86: An escalation prototypeAdministrative Science Quarterly311986274297
  • J.RossB.M.StawOrganizational escalation and exit: Lessons from the Shoreham Nuclear Power PlantThe Academy of Management Journal361993701732
  • D.P.RoyT.R.GraeffS.K.HarmonRepositioning a university through NCAA Division IA football membershipJournal of Sport Management2220081129
  • J.Z.RubinJ.BrocknerS.Small-WeilS.NathansonFactors affecting entry into psychological trapsThe Journal of Conflict Resolution241980405426
  • K.R.SarangeeJ.L.WoolleyJ.B.SchmidtE.LongDe‐escalation mechanisms in high‐technology product innovationJournal of Product Innovation Management315201410231038
  • R.L.SchaumbergS.S.WiltermuthDesire for a positive moral self-regard exacerbates escalation of commitment to initiatives with prosocial aimsOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes1232014110123
  • C.SchwenkEffects of devil’s advocacy on escalating commitmentHuman Relations411988769782
  • W.R.ScottOrganizations and institutions1995SAGE.Thousand Oaks, CA
  • P.SelznickLeadership in administration: A sociological perspective1957Row, Peterson.Evanston, IL
  • I.SimonsonB.M.StawDeescalation strategies: A comparison of techniques for reducing commitment to losing courses of actionThe Journal of Applied Psychology771992419426
  • N.SivanathanD.C.MoldenA.D.GalinskyG.KuThe promise and peril of self-affirmation in de-escalation of commitmentOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes1072008114
  • B.SkirstadP.ChelladuraiFor ‘love’ and money: A sports club’s innovative response to multiple logicsJournal of Sport Management252011339353
  • D.J.SleesmanD.E.ConlonG.M.McNamaraJ.E.MilesCleaning up the big muddy: A meta-analytic review of the determinants of escalation of commitmentThe Academy of Management Journal552012541562
  • D.J.SleesmanA.C.LennardG.McNamaraD.E.ConlonPutting escalation of commitment in context: A multilevel review and analysisAcademy of Management Annals1212018178207
  • A.P.SnowM.KeilL.WallaceThe effects of optimistic and pessimistic biasing on software project status reportingInformation & Management442007130141
  • R.M.SouthallM.S.NagelJ.M.AmisC.SouthallA method to March madness? Institutional logics and the 2006 National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I men’s basketball tournamentJournal of Sport Management222008677700
  • B.M.StawKnee-deep in the big muddy: A study of escalating commitment to a chosen course of actionOrganizational Behavior and Human Performance1619762744
  • B.M.StawF.FoxEscalation: Some determinants to a previously chosen course of actionHuman Relations301977431450
  • B.M.StawH.HoangSunk costs in the NBA: Why draft order affects playing time and survival in professional basketballAdministrative Science Quarterly401995474494
  • B.M.StawJ.RossCommitment to a policy decision: A multi-theoretical perspectiveAdministrative Science Quarterly2319784064
  • B.M.StawJ.RossCommitment in an experimenting society: An experiment on the attribution of leadership from administrative scenariosThe Journal of Applied Psychology651980249260
  • B.M.StawJ.RossBehavior in escalation situations: Antecedents, prototypes, and solutionsResearch in Organizational Behavior919873978
  • J.C.SteinInternal capital markets and the competition for corporate resourcesThe Journal of Finance521997111133
  • I.SternA.D.HendersonWithin-business diversification in technology-intensive industriesStrategic Management Journal252004487505
  • M.C.SuchmanManaging legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approachesThe Academy of Management Review201995571610
  • A.TegerToo much invested to quit1980Pergamon PressNew York, NY
  • P.H.ThorntonW.OcasioInstitutional logicsR.GreenwoodC.OliverK.SahlinR.SuddabyThe SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism2008SAGE.Thousand Oaks, CA99129
  • P.H.ThorntonW.OcasioM.LounsburyThe institutional logics perspective: A new approach to culture, structure, and process2012Oxford University Press on Demand
  • K.E.Van OorschotF.LangerakK.SenguptaEscalation, deescalation or reformulation: Effective interventions in delayed NPD projectsThe Journal of Product Innovation Management282011848867
  • L.WangM.KuncS.BaiRealizing value from project implementation under uncertainty: An exploratory study using system dynamicsInternational Journal of Project Management352017341352
  • M.WashingtonK.D.W.PattersonHostile takeover or joint venture: Connections between institutional theory and sport management researchSport Management Review142011112
  • M.WashingtonM.J.VentrescaInstitutional contradictions and struggles in the formation of US collegiate basketball, 1880–1938Journal of Sport Management2220083049
  • M.WashingtonE.J.ZajacStatus evolution and competition: Theory and evidenceThe Academy of Management Journal482005282296
  • R.A.WolfeK.E.WeickJ.M.UsherJ.R.TerborgL.PoppoA.J.MurrellSport and organizational studies: Exploring synergyJournal of Management Inquiry1422005182210
  • K.F.E.WongJ.Y.KwongThe role of anticipated regret in escalation of commitmentThe Journal of Applied Psychology922007545554
  • L.YuehWhy on earth buy a football club? (February 27) Retrieved from2014BBChttp://www.bbc.com/news/business-26365955

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.