Risk homeostasis theory and traffic accidents: propositions, deductions and discussion of dissension in recent reactions

References

• ADAMS , J. G. U. , 1985 a , Risk and freedom The record of road safety regulation . ( Transport Publishing Projects , London ).
   Google Scholar
• ADAMS , J. G. U. , 1985 b , Smeed's law, seat belts, and the emperor's.new clothes . In Human Behavior and Traffic Safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHWING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ), pp. 193 – 248 .
   Google Scholar
• ANDERSON , J. R. , 1982 , The acquisition of cognitive skill . Psychological Review , 89 , 369 – 406 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• ASCHENBRENNER , JC. M. , BIEHL , B. , and WURM , G. M. , 1986 , Antiblockiersystem und Verkehrssicherheit Ein Vergleich der Unfallbelastung von Taxen mit und ohne Antiblockiersystem ( Teilbericht und die Bundesanstalt fur Strassenwesen zum Forschungs-projekt 8323 Einfluss der Risikokompensation auf die Wirkung von Sicherheitsmass-nahmen , pt Mannheim , FR Germany , March ).
   Google Scholar
• BADIA , P. , HABER , A. , and RUNYON , R. P. , 1970 , Research problems in psychology ( Addison-Wesley , Reading , Mass .).
   Google Scholar
• BEN-DAVID , G. , LEWIN , I. , HALIVA , Y. , and TEL-NIR , L. , 1972 , The influence of personal communication on the driving behaviour of private motorists in Israel . Accident Analysis and Prevention , 4 , 269 – 301 .
   Google Scholar
• BERNARD , C. , 1859 , Legons sur les proprietes physiologiques et les alterations pathologiques des liquides de iorganisme ( J. B. Balliere , Paris ).
   Google Scholar
• BERTALANFFY , L. , 1968 , General system theory ( G. Braziller , New York ).
   Google Scholar
• BINDER , A. , 1970 , Further considerations on testing the null hypothesis and the strategy and tactics of investigating theoretical models . In Research problems in psychology ( Edited by P. BADIA, A., HABER and R. P. BUNYON ) ( Addison-Wesley , Reading , Mass .).
   Google Scholar
• BONNIE , R. J. , 1985 , The efficacy of law as a paternalistic instrument . Nebraska Symposium on Motivation , 29 , 131 – 211 .
   Google Scholar
• BOYLE , A. J. , WRIGHT , C. C. , 1984 , Accident ‘migration’ after remedial treatment at accident blackspots . Traffic Engineering and Control , 25 , 260 – 267 .
   Google Scholar
• BRINDLE , L. , 1986 , Some further evidence refuting risk homeostasis theory . Proceedings, ATEC 86, The lack of road safety ( Paris , June 9-13 ).
   Google Scholar
• BROWNING , J. J. , and WILDE , G. J. S. , 1977 , The effect of beverage alcohol on perceived risk under realistic and simulated traffic conditions . Proceedings, Seventh International Conference on Alcohol, Drugs and Traffic Safety ( Melbourne , Australia , 23-28 January ).
   Google Scholar
• CANNON , W. B. , 1929 , Organization for physiological homeostasis . Physiological Review , 9 , 399 – 431 .
   Google Scholar
• COLE , G. A. , and WITHEY , S. B. , 1982 , The risk of aggregation . Risk Analysis , 2 , 243 – 247 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• CONYBEARE , J. A. C. , 1980 , Evaluation of automobile safety regulations The case of compulsory seat belt legislation in Australia . Policy Sciences , 12 , 27 – 39 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• COWNIE , A. R. , and CALDERWOOD , J. H. , 1966 , Feedback in accident control . Operational Research Quarterly , 17 , 253 – 262 .
   Google Scholar
• DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT, Scottish Development Department, Welsh Office, 1984 , Road Accidents Great Britain 1983 ( HMSO , London ).
   Google Scholar
• DOEBELIN , E. O. , 1962 , Dynamic analysis and feedback control ( McGraw-Hill , New York ).
   Google Scholar
• EVANS , L. , 1985 , Human behavior feedback and traffic safety , Human Factors . 21 , 555 – 576 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• EVANS , L. , 1986 a , Risk homeostasis theory and traffic accident data . Risk Analysis , 6 , 81 – 94 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• EVANS , L. , 1986 b , Comments on Wilde's notes on ‘Risk homeostasis theory and traffic accident data ’. Risk Analysis , 6 , 103 – 107 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• FULLER , R. , 1984 , A conceptualisation of driving behaviour as threat avoidance . Ergonomics , 27 , 1139 – 1155 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• FULLER , R. G. C. , 1986 , Reflections on risk homeostasis theory . In New directions in research on decision making ( Edited by B. BREHMER, H. JUNGERMANN, P. LOURENS and G. SEVGN ) ( Elsevier , Amsterdam ).
   Google Scholar
• GRAHAM , J. D. , 1982 , On Wilde's theory of risk homeostasis . Risk Analysis . 2 , 235 – 237 .
   Google Scholar
• GRANT , B. A. , 1985 , Empirical investigations of the theory of risk homeostasis and the study of risk perceived by automobile drivers . Ph.D. Thesis , Queen's University , Kingston , Ontario , Department of Psychology .
   Google Scholar
• HEDLUND , J. H. , 1985 , Recent U.S. traffic fatality trends . In Human Behavior and Traffic Safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHWING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ), pp. 7 – 19 .
   Google Scholar
• HOYOS , C. Graf , 1984 , Stellungnahme zu einer Diskussion uber die Theorie der Risikokom-pensation . Zeitschrift fur Verkehrssicherheit , 30 , 61 – 62 .
   Google Scholar
• HUGUENIN , R. D. , 1982 , Zur Problematik von Risikohomoostastheorien in der Verkehrspsy-chologie , Zeitschrift fur Verkehrssicherheit , 28 , 180 – 187 .
   Google Scholar
• JAPAN STATISTICAL YEARBOOK , 1964-1983 ( Tokyo Statistical Bureau, Management and Coordination Agency ).
   Google Scholar
• JOLY , R. , and WILDE , G. J. S. , 1986 , The effect of BAC at 0.08% by volume upon skill and risk-taking in a response-timing task . Proceedings, Tenth International Conference on Alcohol. Drugs and Traffic Safety ( Amsterdam , September 9-12 ).
   Google Scholar
• JOUBERT , P. , 1985 , Comment . In Human Behavior and Traffic Safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHWING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ).
   Google Scholar
• KOSHI , M. , 1985 , Road safety measure in Japan . In Human Behavior and Traffic Safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHWING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ), pp. 27 – 41 .
   Google Scholar
• KUNREUTHER , H. , 1985 , Incentives for improving driving behaviour Ex ante/ex post considerations . In Human Behavior and Traffic Safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHWING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ), pp. 365 – 378 .
   Google Scholar
• LICHTENSTEIN , S. , and FISCHHOFF , B. , 1977 , Do those who know more also know more about how much they know ? Organizational Behavior and Human Performance , 20 , 159 – 183 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• LUND , A. K. , and O'NEILL , B. , 1986 , Perceived risks and driving behavior . Accident Analysis and Prevention , 18 , 367 – 370 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• LUND , A. K. , and ZADOR , P. , 1984 , Mandatory belt use and driver risk taking . Risk Analysis , 4 , 41 – 53 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• MACKAY , M. , 1985 , Comment . In Human Behavior and Traffic Safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHWING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ).
   Google Scholar
• MCKENNA , F. , 1982 , The human factor in driving accidents . Ergonomics , 25 , 867 – 877 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• MCKENNA , F. , 1985 a , Do safety measures really work? An examination of risk homoeostasis theory . Ergonomics , 28, 489 – 498 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• MCKENNA , F. , 1985 b , Evidence and assumptions relevant to risk homoeostasis . Ergonomics , 28 , 1539 – 1541 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• MCKENNA , F. , 1986 , Does risk homeostasis theory represent a threat to ergonomics ? In D. J. OSBORNE (ed.) Contemporary Ergonomics , ( Taylor & Francis , London ), pp 88 – 92 .
   Google Scholar
• MERCER , G. W. , 1986 , Influences on passenger casualty accidents unemployement driver gender, driver age, drinking driving and restraint device use . ( Ministry of the Attorney General , British C olumbia , Canada . February ).
   Google Scholar
• MICHON , J. A. , 1984 , Traffic and mobility . In Handbook of Work and Organizational Psychology, Vol. 2 ( Edited by P. J. D. DRENTH, H. THIERRY, P. J. WILLEMS and C. J. DEWOLFF ) ( Wiley , London ).
   Google Scholar
• MICHON , J. A. , 1985 , A critical view of driver behavior models What do we know, what should we do ? In Human Behavior and Traffic Safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHWING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ), pp. 485 – 520 .
   Google Scholar
• MOORE-EDE , M. C. , SULZMAN , F. M. , and FULLER , C. A. , 1982 , The clocks that time us ( Harvard University Press , Cambridge , Mass .).
   Google Scholar
• MUNDEN , M. , 1967 , The relation between a driver's speed and his accident rate . Road Research Laboratory , U.K. Report No. LR 88 .
   Google Scholar
• NAATANEN , R. , and SUMMALA , H. , 1976 , Road user behaviour and traffic accidents ( North-Holland/American Elsevier , Amsterdam and New York ).
   Google Scholar
• NATIONAL SAFETY COUNCIL , 1981 , Accident Facts ( Chicago ).
   Google Scholar
• OECD , 1971 , Road safety campaigns; Design and evaluation ( Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development , Paris ).
   Google Scholar
• OECD , 1978 , Chairman's report and report of Subgroup III Mass media communications for pedestrian safety ( Transport and Road Research Laboratory , U.K. , on behalf of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development ).
   Google Scholar
• OPPE , S. , 1985 , Contribution to evaluation of intermediate variables background paper . Proceedings, Evaluation 85, International Meeting on the Evaluation of local traffic safety measures ( Paris , May 20-23 ).
   Google Scholar
• ORR , L. , 1982 , Goals, risks and choices . Risk Analysis , 2 , 239 – 242 .
   Google Scholar
• PARTYKA , S. C. , 1984 , Simple models of fatality trends using employment and population data . Accident Analysis and Prevention , 16 , 211 – 222 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• PELTZMAN , S. , 1975 , The effects of automobile safety regulation , Journal of Political Economy , 83 , 677 – 725 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• RUMAR , K. , 1985 , The role of perceptual and cognitive filters in observed behavior . In Human behavior and traffic safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHWING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ), pp. 151 – 165 .
   Google Scholar
• SHANNON , H. S. , 1986 , Road accident data interpreting the British experience with particular reference to the risk homeostasis theory . Ergonomics , 29 , 1005 – 1015 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• SIVAK , M. , 1985 , Multiple ergonomic interventions and transportation safety . Ergonomics , 28 , 1143 – 1153 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• SLOVIC , P. , and FISCHHOFF , B. , 1982 , Targeting risks . Risk Analysis , 2 , 227 – 234 .
   Google Scholar
• STREFF , F. M. , and GELLER , E. S. , in press, An experimental test of risk compensation between-subject versus within-subject analyses . Accident Analysis and Prevention .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• SUMMALA , H. , 1986 , The deterministic man in a stochastic world risk management on the road . In New directions in research on decision making ( Edited by B. BREHMER, H. JUN-GERMANN, P., LOURENS and G. SEVGN ) ( Elsevier , Amsterdam ).
   Google Scholar
• SVENSON , O. , 1981 , Are we all less risky and more skillful than our fellow drivers ? Acta Psychologica , 47 , 143 – 148 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• TRANSPORT CANADA, 1986 , Road Safety and Motor Vehicle Regulation Directorate ( Ottawa ).
   Google Scholar
• TSCHERNITSCHECK , E. , 1978 , Verkehrssicherheitsprogramm eines Vertriebsunternehemens . Berufsgenossenschaft .
   Google Scholar
• VAUPEL , J. W. , and YASHIN , A. I. , 1985 , Heterogeneity's ruses some surprising effects of selection on population dynamics , The American Statistician , 39 , 176 – 185 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• WELFORD , A. O. , 1976 , Skilled performance perceptual and motor skills ( Scott , Foresman and Company , Glenview , Ill .).
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1982 a , The theory of risk homeostasis implications for safety and health . Risk Analysis . 2 , 209 – 258 .
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1982 b , Critical issues in risk homeostasis theory . Risk Analysis , 2 , 249 – 258 .
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1984 a , Evidence refuting risk homeostasis theory? A rejoinder to Frank P. McKenna . Ergonomics . 27 , 297 – 304 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1984 b , On the choice of denominator for the calculation of accident rates , In Transport Risk Assessment ( Edited by S. YAGAR ) ( University of Waterloo Press , Waterloo , Ontario ).
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1985 a , The use of incentives for the promotion of accident-free driving . Journal of Studies on Alcohol , Supplement No. 10 , 161 – 167 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1985 b , Assumptions necessary and unnecessary to risk homoeostasis . Ergonomics , 28 , 1531 – 1538 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1986 a , Notes on the interpretation of traffic accident data and of risk homeostasis A reply to L. Evans , Risk Analysis , 6 , 95 – 101 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1986 b , La theorie du risque homeostatique les debats actuels . Proceedings, ATEC 86, The Lack of Road Safety ( Paris , June 9-13 ).
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1986 c , Beyond the concept of risk homeostasis suggestions for research and application towards the prevention of accidents and lifestyle-related disease . Accident Analysis and Prevention , 18 , 377 – 401 ).
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , 1986 d , Road accident data and risk homeostasis theory a rejoinder to Harry S. Shannon. Submitted to Ergonomics .
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , and ACKERSVILLER , M. J. , 1981 , Accident journalism and traffic safety education . Ottawa Transport Canada, Traffic Safety , Report No. TP 3659 E, CR 8202 .
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , CLAXTON-OLDFIELD , S. P. , and PLATENIUS , P. H. , 1985 , Risk homeostasis in an experimental context . In Human behavior and traffic safety ( Edited by L. EVANS and R. C. SCHING ) ( Plenum Press , New York ), pp. 119 – 142 .
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , and KUNKEL , E. , 1984 , Die begriffliche und empirische Problematik der Risikokompensation . Zeitschrift fur Verkehrssicherheit , 30 , 52 – 61 .
   Google Scholar
• WILDE , G. J. S. , and MURDOCH , P. A. , 1982 , Incentive systems for accident-free and violation-free driving in the general population . Ergonomics . 25 , 879 – 890 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• WRIGHT , G. , 1984 , Behavioral decision theory an introduction ( Sage Publications , Beverley Hills , Calif. ).
   Google Scholar
• ZAHAVI , Y. , 1973 , The TT-relationship a unified approach to transportation planning . Traffic Engineering and Control , 14 , 205 – 212 .
   Google Scholar
• ZAHAVI , Y. , and RYAN , J. M. , 1980 , Stability of travel components over time . Transportation Research Record . 750 , 19 – 26 .
   Google Scholar