The absolute network theory of language and traditional epistemology: On the philosophical foundations of Paul Churchland's scientific realismFootnote¹

Several friends, students and colleagues generously read and commented upon drafts of this paper. I am especially indebted to Dr P. M. S. Hacker (St. John's College, Oxford), Dr M. Ayers (Wadham College, Oxford), Dr Th. C. Meijering, Drs J. J. M. Sleutels and Th. C. W. Oudemans (Leiden University), Prof. Dr G. Lock (University of Nijmegen), Dr B. Smith (University of Manchester and Lichtenstein), and to my former assistant, Dr. M. Lievers.

Notes

• 1985 . ‘Conceptual Progress and Word/World Relations: In Search of the Essence of Natural Kinds’ . Canadian Journal of Philosophy , 15 : 1 – 17 .
   Google Scholar
• 1986 . ‘The Continuity of Philosophy and the Sciences’ . Mind and Language , 1 : 5 – 14 .
   Google Scholar
• 1981 . ‘Eliminative Materialism and the Propositional Attitudes’ . The Journal of Philosophy , LXXVIII : 67 – 90 .
   Google Scholar
• 1981 . ‘Functionalism, Qualia and Intentionality’ . Philosophical Topics , 12 : 121 – 45 . (with Patricia Smith Churchland)
   Google Scholar
• 1987 . ‘How Parapsychology Could Become a Science’ . Inquiry , 30 : 227 – 39 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• 1970 . ‘The Logical Character of Action Explanations’ . Philosophical Review , LXXIX : 214 – 36 .
   Google Scholar
• 1984 . Matter and Consciousness. A Contemporary Introduction to the Philosophy of Mind , Cambridge, Mass : MIT Press .
   Google Scholar
• Churchland , Paul M. and Hooker , Clifford A. , eds. 1985 . “ ‘The Ontological Status of Observables: In Praise of the Superempirical Virtues’ ” . In Images of Science: Essays on Realism and Empiricism, with a Reply from Bas C. van Fraassen , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
   Google Scholar
• 1988 . ‘Perceptual Plasticity and Theoretical Neutrality: A Reply to Jerry Fodor’ . Philosophy of Science , 55 : 167 – 87 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fodor . ‘Reply’ . 188 – 98 . ibid.
   Google Scholar
• 1985 . ‘Reduction, Qualia, and the Direct Introspection of Brain States’ . The Journal of Philosophy , LXXXII : 8 – 28 .
   Google Scholar
• 1986 . ‘Some Reductive Strategies in Cognitive Neurobiology’ . Mind , XCV : 279 – 309 .
   Google Scholar
• 1979 . Scientific Realism and the Plasticity of Mind , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• 1983 . ‘Stalking the Wild Epistemic Engine’ . NoÛs , 17 : 5 – 18 . (with Patricia Smith Churchland)
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• 1975 . ‘Two Grades of Evidential Bias’ . Philosophy of Science , 42 : 250 – 9 .
   Google Scholar
• 1982 . ‘Is Thinker a Natural Kind’ . Dialogue , 21 : 223 – 38 .
   Google Scholar
• Churchland , Patricia Smith . 1986 . Neurophilosophy: Toward a Unified Science of the Mind‐Brain , Cambridge, Mass. : MIT Press .
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . 1965 . “ ‘Problems of Empiricism’ ” . In Beyond the Edge of Certainty , Edited by: Colodny , R. G. Englewood Cliffs, N.J. : Prentice‐Hall . (abbreviated: PE)
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . 1981 . Philosophical Papers , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press . (abbreviation: PP)
   Google Scholar
• Wittgenstein . 1958 . Philosophical Investigations , Vol. 1 , Oxford : Blackwell . §115
   Google Scholar
• Austin , J. L. 1970 . “ ‘The Meaning of a Word’ ” . In Philosophical Papers , 2nd ed. , Oxford : Clarendon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hacker , P. M. S. 1986 . Insight and Illusion , (rev. ed.) , Oxford : Clarendon Press . ch. VI
   Google Scholar
• Baker , G. P. and Hacker , P. M. S. 1983 . Wittgenstein, Meaning and Understanding , Oxford : Blackwell . ch. XIII
   Google Scholar
• 1953 . “ ‘Two Dogmas of Empiricism’ ” . In From a Logical Point of View , Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard University Press . §6
   Google Scholar
• 1969 . “ ‘Epistemology Naturalized’ ” . In Ontological Relativity and Other Essays , 85 – 90 . New York : Columbia University Press .
   Google Scholar
• 1974 . The Roots of Reference , La Salle, Illinois : Open Court . §§ 1, 9, 10 and 11
   Google Scholar
• Churchland . SRPM 1 – 2 .
   Google Scholar
• Churchland . SRPM 61 76
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . PE 180
   Google Scholar
• PP Vol. I , x
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . PP vol. I , x
   Google Scholar
• Churchland . SRPM 15
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . “ ‘Science without Experience’ ” . In PP vol. I , ch. 7
   Google Scholar
• Rorty . 1980 . Philosophy & the Mirror of Nature , 184 Oxford : Blackwell .
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . PE 198
   Google Scholar
• PP vol. I , 17 – 36 . 50 – 54 . 93 125
   Google Scholar
• Brown , J. R. 1983 . International Philosophical Quarterly , 23 : 226
   Google Scholar
• 1970 . The Structure of Scientific Revolutions , 2nd ed. , 193 Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
   Google Scholar
• Fodor . ‘Reply’ . 195 – 6 .
   Google Scholar
• Sellars , Wilfrid . 1963 . “ ‘Philosophy and the Scientific Image of Man’ ” . In Science, Perception, and Reality , London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
   Google Scholar
• Cohen , R. and Wartowski , M. , eds. 1965 . “ ‘Scientific Realism or Irenic Instrumentalism’ ” . In Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science vol. II ,
   Google Scholar
• 1971 . ‘Science, Sense Impressions, and Sensa: a Reply to Cornman’ . Review of Metaphysics , XXIV : 391 – 447 .
   Google Scholar
• Descartes . Regulae , XII
   Google Scholar
• “ ‘Philosophy and the Scientific Image of Man’ ” . In Science, Perception, and Reality 26 – 27 . 34 – 35 . op. cit.
   Google Scholar
• Hatfield , Gary C. and Epstein , William . 1979 . ‘The Sensory Core and the Foundations of Early Modern Perceptual Theory’ . Isis , 70 : 363 – 84 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Russell , Bertrand . 1962 . An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth , 13 Harmondsworth : Penguin Books .
   Google Scholar
• Margolis , Joseph . 1980 . Persons and Minds, Dialogue , 19 : 467 – 9 .
   Google Scholar
• Churchland , Patricia Smith . 1986 . ‘Replies to Comments’ . Inquiry , 29 : 254
   Google Scholar
• Goldman , Alan H. 1982 . ‘Epistemic Foundationalism and the Replaceability of Observation Language’ . Journal of Philosophy , 79 : 145 – 52 .
   Google Scholar
• Gibson , Eleanor . 1969 . Principles of Perceptual Learning and Development , 64 – 73 . 154 – 60 . New York : Meredith .
   Google Scholar
• Fodor , J. 1984 . ‘Observation Reconsidered’ . Philosophy of Science , 51 : 23 – 43 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kay , P. 1969 . Basic Colour Terms: Their Universality and Evolution , Berkeley : University of California Press .
   Google Scholar
• Heider , E. R. 1972 . ‘Universals in Colour Naming and Memory’ . Journal of Experimental Psychology , 93 : 10 – 20 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Lenneberg , E. H. 1967 . Biological Foundations of Language New York
   Google Scholar
• Rosch , E. 1973 . “ ‘On the Internal Structure of Perceptual and Semantic Categories’ ” . In Cognitive Development and the Acquisition of Language Edited by: Moore , T. New York
   Google Scholar
• De Valois , R. L. and Jacobs , G. H. 1968 . ‘Primate Colour Vision’ . Science , 162 : 533 – 40 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Rosch , E. 1977 . “ ‘Linguistic Relativity’ ” . In Thinking: Readings in Cognitive Science , Edited by: Johnson‐Laird , P. N. and Wason , P. C. 509 – 19 . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Rock , I. 1985 . ‘Perception and Knowledge’ . Acta Psychologica , 59 : 3 – 22 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Van Fraassen . 1981 . review of SRPM . Canadian Journal of Philosophy , 11 : 556 – 60 .
   Google Scholar
• Snow , C. P. 1969 . The Two Cultures and A Second Look , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Philipse , H. 1986 . Wijsbegeerte tussen twee culturen , Leiden : Brill .
   Google Scholar
• Passmore , John . 1978 . Science and its Critics , London : Duckworth .
   Google Scholar
• Madell , Geoffrey . 1985 . ‘Neurophilosophy: A Principled Sceptic's Response’ . Inquiry , 29 : 164 – 8 .
   Google Scholar
• Robinson , William S. 1985 . ‘Towards Eliminating Churchland's Eliminationism’ . Philosophical Topics , 13 : 61 – 68 .
   Google Scholar
• Wilkes , K. V. 1984 . ‘Pragmatics in Science and Theory in Common Sense’ . Inquiry , 27 : 339 – 61 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wilkes , K. V. 1985 . ‘Nemo Psychologus nisi Physiologus’ . Inquiry , 29 : 169 – 72 .
   Google Scholar
• van Fraassen , Bas C. 1980 . The Scientific Image , 13 – 19 . Oxford : Clarendon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Austin , J. L. 1962 . Sense and Sensibilia , 5 Oxford : Clarendon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Putnam , Hilary . 1982 . ‘Three Kinds of Scientific Realism’ . Philosophical Quarterly , 32 : 197 – 8 .
   Google Scholar
• Husserl , E. 1900 . Logische Untersuchungen , Vol. I , Halle : Niemeyer . §32
   Google Scholar
• Cooper , E. W. 1980 . ‘Four Anti‐Materialist Propositions’ . The Philosophical Forum , XI : 104
   Google Scholar
• Everitt , N. 1981 . ‘A Problem for the Eliminative Materialist’ . Mind , XC : 428 – 34 .
   Google Scholar
• Madell , G. 1987 . ‘Neurophilosophy: A Principled Sceptic's Response’ . Inquiry , 29 : 167 – 8 .
   Google Scholar
• Sharpe , R. A. 1980 . review of SRPM . Philosophical Quarterly , 30 : 268 – 9 .
   Google Scholar
• Swinburne , R. G. 1980 . review of SRPM . Philosophy , 55 : 273 – 5 .
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . PE 198 – 9 . 212 – 13 . 258 (note 158)
   Google Scholar
• Goldman , Alan H. 1982 . ‘Epistemie Foundationalism and the Replaceability of Observation Language’ . Journal of Philosophy , 79 : 143 – 54 .
   Google Scholar
• “ ‘Explanation, Reduction and Empiricism’ ” . In PP vol. I , 93 ch. 4
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . PE 212 – 15 .
   Google Scholar
• Shapere , Dudley . 1966 . “ ‘Meaning and Scientific Change’ ” . In Mind and Cosmos: Essays in Contemporary Science and Philosophy , Edited by: Colodny , R. G. 41 – 85 . Pittsburgh : University of Pittsburgh Press .
   Google Scholar
• Apel . 1973 . Transformation der Philosophie , vol. I , 313 Frankfurt am Main : Suhrkamp .
   Google Scholar
• Wittgenstein . Philosophical Investigations Vol. I , op. cit.
   Google Scholar
• Hacker , P. M. S. 1987 . Appearance and Reality: A Philosophical Investigation into Perception and Perceptual Qualities , Oxford : Blackwell .
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . PE 202 – 10 .
   Google Scholar
• “ ‘An attempt at a realistic interpretation of experience’ ” . In PP vol. I , 20 – 21 . ch. 2
   Google Scholar
• “ ‘Reply to Criticism; Comments on Smart, Sellars and Putnam’ ” . In PP vol. I , 125 ch. 6
   Google Scholar
• “ ‘Reply to Criticism’ ” . In PP vol. I , 125
   Google Scholar
• Lakatos , I. 1978 . Philosophical Papers , vol. I , 23 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Baker , G. P. and Hacker , P. M. S. 1985 . Wittgenstein: Rules, Grammar and Necessity , 229 – 30 . Oxford : Blackwell .
   Google Scholar
• Putnam , Hilary . 1975 . “ ‘How Not to Talk about Meaning; Comments on J. J. C. Smart’ ” . In Mind, Language and Reality, Philosophical Papers , vol. 2 , 122 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press . (ch. 6 of
   Google Scholar
• Churchland . 1986 . ‘The Continuity of Philosophy and the Sciences’ . Mind and Language , 1 : 9
   Google Scholar
• Churchland , Patricia Smith . 1986 . ‘Replies to Comments’ . Inquiry , 29 : 254
   Google Scholar
• Wittgenstein . Philosophical Investigations , I §242
   Google Scholar
• Baker , G. P. and Hacker , P. M. S. 1985 . Wittgenstein: Rules, Grammar and Necessity , 258 – 60 . 229 – 51 . Oxford : Blackwell .
   Google Scholar
• Jacobi , Friedrich Heinrich . 1812–1825 . “ ‘Uber den transcendentalen Idealismus’ ” . In Werke 6 vols , 304 Leipzig (1743–1819), II
   Google Scholar
• Windelband , W. 1976 . Lehrbuch der Geschichte der Philosophie , 16th ed. , 494 Tubingen : Niemeyer .
   Google Scholar
• Kenny , A. 1984 . The Legacy of Wittgenstein , Oxford : Blackwell .
   Google Scholar
• 1980 . ‘A Perspective on Mind‐Brain Research’ . Journal of Philosophy , LXXVII : 190
   Google Scholar
• Feyerabend . 1981 . “ ‘Historical Background: Some Observations on the Decay of the Philosophy of Science’ ” . In ch. 1 of Problems of Empiricism, Philosophical Papers vol. 2 , op. cit.
   Google Scholar
• 1975 . Against Method: Outline of an Anarchistic Theory of Knowledge , London : Verso .
   Google Scholar
• 1978 . Science in a Free Society , London : NLB .
   Google Scholar
• Several friends, students and colleagues generously read and commented upon drafts of this paper. I am especially indebted to Dr P. M. S. Hacker (St. John's College, Oxford), Dr M. Ayers (Wadham College, Oxford), Dr Th. C. Meijering, Drs J. J. M. Sleutels and Th. C. W. Oudemans (Leiden University), Prof. Dr G. Lock (University of Nijmegen), Dr B. Smith (University of Manchester and Lichtenstein), and to my former assistant, Dr. M. Lievers.
   Google Scholar