Political incorporation versus political stability: The case of the Chilean agrarian reform, 1965–70Footnote∗

This is a revised version of a paper presented to a seminar in the Department of Anthropology at University College, London. The author wishes to thank Donal Cruise O'Brien, Alfred Lehmann, and Bernard Schaffer for their helpful comments which have much to do with what is correct and nothing to do with what is erroneous in the following pages. He also wishes to express his appreciation to those who took part in the discussion at University College for their contribution.

References

• Affonso , Almino and Klein , Emilio . 1970 . “ Sergio Gómez and Pablo Ramirez ” . In Movimiento Campesino Chileno , Santiago : I.C.I.R.A. .
   Google Scholar
• Barraclough , Solon and Schatan , Jacobo . 1970 . ‘Política Tecnológica y Desarrollo Agrícola’ . Cuadernos de la Realidad Nacional , September
   Google Scholar
• Bendix , Reinhard . 1964 . Nation‐Building and Citizenship , New York : Wiley .
   Google Scholar
• Bernstein , Henry . 1971 . ‘Modernization Theory and the Sociology of Development’ . Journal of Development Studies , VII : 1
   Google Scholar
• Blok , Anton . 1966 . ‘Land Reform in a Western Sicilian Latifondo Village’ . Anthropological Quarterly , XXXIX : 1
   Google Scholar
• Blok , Anton . 1969 . “ ‘Peasants, Patrons and Brokers in Western Sicily’ ” . Vol. XLII , 3 ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Boissevain , Jeremy . 1966 . ‘Patronage in Sicily’ . Man , I : 1
   Google Scholar
• Bourricaud , François . 1967 . Pouvoir et Société dans le Pérou Contemporain , Paris : Cahiers de la Fondation Nationale des Sciences Politiques .
   Google Scholar
• Chayanov , A. V. 1966 . Theory of Peasant Economy , Edited by: Thorner , Daniel , Kerblay , Basile and Smith , R. E. F. Homewood, Ill. : American Economie Association .
   Google Scholar
• C.O.R. A. (Corporación de la Reforma Agraria) . 1968 . Cuatro Años de Reforma Agraria Santiago
   Google Scholar
• Dahrendorf , Ralf . 1959 . Class and Class Conflict in an Industrial Society , London : Routledge .
   Google Scholar
• Davis , John . 1969 . ‘Honour and Politics in Pisticci’ . Proceedings of the Royal Anthropological Institute ,
   Google Scholar
• de Kadt , Emmanuel . 1967 . ‘Paternalism and Populism: the Catholic Church in Latin America’ . Journal of Contemporary History , II : 4
   Google Scholar
• Deutsch , Karl , Deutsch and Foltz . 1968 . “ ‘Nation‐Building and National Development’ ” . In Nation‐Building , New York : Atherton Press .
   Google Scholar
• Deutsch , Karl . 1969 . Nationalism and its Alternatives , New York : Alfred A. Knopf .
   Google Scholar
• Dirección de Estadística y Censos, 1965, Chile, Censo Agrícola.
   Google Scholar
• Dumont , Louis . 1960 . ‘Caste, Racisme et Stratification’ . Cahiers Internationaux de Sociologie , XXIX
   Google Scholar
• Dumont , Louis . 1966 . Homo Hierarchies , Paris : Gallimard .
   Google Scholar
• Echenique , Jorge . 1970 . “ ‘Las Expropriations y la Organización de Asentamientos, 1965–1970’ ” . In Reforma Agraria Chilena: Seis Ensayos de Interpretación , Santiago : I.C.I.R.A. .
   Google Scholar
• Echeverría , Roberto . 1969 . “ ‘The Effect of Agricultural Price Policies on Intersectoral Income Distribution’ ” . Dissertation Series, no. 13 Cornell University, Latin American Studies Program .
   Google Scholar
• Eisenstadt , S. N. 1966 . Modernization; Protest and Change , Englewood Cliffs, N.J. : Prentice‐Hall .
   Google Scholar
• Etzioni , Amitai . 1961 . A Comparative Analysis of Complex Organizations , Glencoe Free Press .
   Google Scholar
• Felstehausen , Herman . 1970 . ‘Agrarian Reform and Development in Colombia’ . A.I.D. Spring Review of Land Reform , V Washington, A.I.D.
   Google Scholar
• Foster , George . 1961 . ‘The Dyadic Contract: a Model for the Social Structure of a Mexican Village” . American Anthropologist , LXIII
   Google Scholar
• Foster , George . 1963 . “The Dyadic Contract in Tzintzuntzan’ ” . Vol. II , 1173 – 92 .
   Google Scholar
• “ ‘Patron‐Client Relationship’ ” . In ibid. Vol. LXV , 1280 – 94 .
   Google Scholar
• Foster , George . 1965 . “ ‘Peasant Society and the Image of the Limited Good’ ” . In ibid Vol. LXVII , 293 – 315 .
   Google Scholar
• Frank , André Gunder . 1969 . Latin America; Underdevelopment or Revolution? , New York and London : Monthly Review Press .
   Google Scholar
• Freyre , Gilberto . 1956 . The Masters and the Slaves New York
   Google Scholar
• Galjart , Benno . 1964 . ‘Class and following in rural Brazil’ . América Latina , VII : 2
   Google Scholar
• Gómez , Sergio . 1969 . Los Empresarios Agrícolas y la Reforma Agraria , Santiago : I.C.I.R.A. .
   Google Scholar
• Griffin , Keith . 1966 . ‘Reflections on Latin American Development’ . Oxford Economic Papers , XVIII : 1
   Google Scholar
• Gutelman , Michel . 1971 . Mexique: Réforme ou Mystification Agraire ? , Paris : Maspéro .
   Google Scholar
• Halévy , Eue . 1961 . The Triumph of Reform (1830–1841) , London : Benn .
   Google Scholar
• Hinton , William . 1968 . Fanshen: a Documentary of Revolution in a Chinese Village , New York : Monthly Review Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hobsbawm , Eric . 1959 . Primitive Rebels , Manchester U.P. .
   Google Scholar
• Hobsbawm , Eric . 1967 . “ ‘Problèmes Agraires à La Convención’ ” . In Problèmes Agraires en Amérique Latine. , Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique .
   Google Scholar
• Hobsbawm , Eric . 1969 . ‘La Convención: a case of nec‐feudalism’ . Journal of Latin American Studies , I : 1
   Google Scholar
• Homans , George . 1961 . Social Behaviour , London : Routledge .
   Google Scholar
• Huntington , Samuel P. 1968 . Political Order in Changing Societies , Yale U.P. .
   Google Scholar
• I.N.C.O.RA. (Instituto Colombiano de Reforma Agraria) . 1970 . ‘Agrarian Reform in Colombia’ . in A.I.D. Spring Review of Land Reform , V Washington, A.I.D.
   Google Scholar
• I.C.A.D. (Interamerican Committee for Agricultural Development) . 1966 . Chile: Tenencia de la Tierra y Desarrollo Socio‐Económico del Sector Agrícola Santiago
   Google Scholar
• I.C.A.D. 1966 . Perú: Tenencia de la Tierra y Desarrollo Socio‐Económico del Sector Agrícola Washington
   Google Scholar
• I.L.O. (International Labour Office) . 1970 . Towards Full Employment , Geneva : I.L.O. . a programme for Colombia prepared by an international mission for the I.L.O.
   Google Scholar
• Johnson , Dale . 1968–69 . ‘The National and Progressive Bourgeoisie in Chile’ . Studies in Comparative International Development , IV
   Google Scholar
• Labarca , Eduardo . 1969 . Chile Invadido , Santiago : Horizonte .
   Google Scholar
• Lehmann , David . 1970 . ‘Hacia un Análisis de la Conciencia de los Campesinos’ . Cuadernos de la Realidad Nacional , January
   Google Scholar
• Lenin . 1964 . The Development of Capitalism in Russia Moscow
   Google Scholar
• Marshall , T.H. 1950 . Citizenship and Social Class Cambridge
   Google Scholar
• Mauss , Marcel . 1968 . “ ‘Essai sur le Don’ ” . In Oeuvres , Paris : P.U.F. .
   Google Scholar
• Mensaje, 1969, nos. 178, 179 and 180, Santiago.
   Google Scholar
• El Mercurio, Santiago
   Google Scholar
• Moore , Barrington . 1966 . The Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy , Boston : Houghton Mifflin .
   Google Scholar
• Myrdal , Gunnar . 1963 . Economic Theory and Underdeveloped Regions , London : Methuen .
   Google Scholar
• Neira , Hugo . 1963 . Cuzco, Tierra y Muerte Lima
   Google Scholar
• Parsons , Talcott . 1951 . The Social System , Glencoe : The Free Press .
   Google Scholar
• Petras , James . 1969 . Political Forces in Chilean Development , Berkeley : California U.P. .
   Google Scholar
• Petras , James . 1970a . Peru: a New Model for Latin America? , Pennsylvania State University, Institute of Public Administration .
   Google Scholar
• Petras , James and Zeitlin , Maurice . 1970b . ‘Agrarian Radicalism in Chile’ . British Journal of Sociology , XXI : 1
   Google Scholar
• Petras , James and LaPorte , Robert Jr. 1970c . ‘Modernization from above versus Reform from below; US policy towards Latin American agricultural development’ . Journal of Development Studies , VI : 3
   Google Scholar
• Quijano , Aníbal . 1965 . ‘El movimiento campesino peruano y sus líderes’ . América Latina , VIII : 4
   Google Scholar
• Ringlien , Wayne . 1970 . Efectos Económicos de la Politica Nacional de Expropiación en el Sector Privado Santiago
   Google Scholar
• Schejtman , Alejandro . 1968 . Ellnquilino del Valle Central , Santiago : I.C.I.R.A. .
   Google Scholar
• El Siglo, Santiago.
   Google Scholar
• Silverman , Sydel . 1965 . ‘Patronage and Community‐Nation Relationships in Central Italy’ . Ethnology , IV : 172 – 89 .
   Google Scholar
• Smelser , Neil . 1963 . The Sociology of Economic Life , Englewood Cliffs : Prentice‐Hall .
   Google Scholar
• Stavenhagen , Rodolfo . 1969 . ‘Marginalidad y Participación en la Reforma Agraria Mexicana’ . Revista Latinoamericana de Sociología , 1969 : 2
   Google Scholar
• Stavenhagen , Rodolfo . 1970 . “ ‘Social Aspects of Agrarian Structure in Mexico’ ” . In Agrarian Problems and Peasant Movements in Latin America , Edited by: Stavenhagen . New York : Doubleday .
   Google Scholar
• Stycos , J. Mayone . 1955 . Family and Fertility in Puerto Rico , New York : Columbia U.P. .
   Google Scholar
• Tarrow , Sydney . 1967 . Peasant Communism in Southern Italy , Yale U.P. .
   Google Scholar
• Thiesenhusen , William . 1970 . “ ‘Agrarian Reform in Chile’ ” . In A.I.D. Spring Review of Land Reform , vol. V , Washington : A.I.D. .
   Google Scholar
• Urzúa , Raúl . 1969 . La Demanda Campesina , Santiago : Catholic University of Chile .
   Google Scholar
• Vekemans , Roger S.J. 1967 . ‘Marginalidad, Incorporación e Integración’ . Boletín de D.E.S.A.L. , 37
   Google Scholar
• Weingrod , Alex . 1968 . ‘Patrons, Patronage, and Political Parties’ . Comparative Studies in Society and History , X : 4
   Google Scholar
• Wolf , Eric . 1967 . Peasants , Englewood Cliffs : Prentice‐Hall .
   Google Scholar
• Wolf , Eric and Sydney , Mintz . 1957 . ‘Hacienda and Plantation Systems in Middle America and the Antilles’ . Social and Economic Studies , VI : 3
   Google Scholar
• Womack , John Jr. 1969 . Zapata and the Mexican Revolution , London : Thames and Hudson .
   Google Scholar
• This is a revised version of a paper presented to a seminar in the Department of Anthropology at University College, London. The author wishes to thank Donal Cruise O'Brien, Alfred Lehmann, and Bernard Schaffer for their helpful comments which have much to do with what is correct and nothing to do with what is erroneous in the following pages. He also wishes to express his appreciation to those who took part in the discussion at University College for their contribution.
   Google Scholar
• Fellow of the Institute of Development Studies at the University of Sussex. Field research in Chile was financed by the Social Science Research Council and the Goldsmiths' Company.
   Google Scholar