The rise and fall of lattice theories of the liquid state

References

• J.W. Gibbs , Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics, Developed with Especial Reference to the Rational Foundation of Thermodynamics (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT, 1902).
   Google Scholar
• See, for example, E.A. Guggenheim , J. Chem. Phys. 7 , 103 (1939).
   Google Scholar
• P. and T. Ehrenfest , Encyklopädie der mathematischen Wissenschaft (Teubner, Leipzig , 1912), Vol. 6. English translation by M.J. Moravcsik (Cornell University Press, 1959); M.J. Klein , Paul Ehrenfest, Vol. 1: The Making of a Theoretical Physicist ( North-Holland , Ithaca, NY, 1970), pp. 121, 136.
   Google Scholar
• R.H. Fowler , Statistical Mechanics: The Theory of the Properties of Matter at Equilibrium (Cambridge University Press, 1929), p. 7. The same sentences are repeated in the second edition of 1936. This book was revised and made more accessible to chemists by R.H. Fowler and E.A. Guggenheim , Statistical Thermodynamics (Cambridge University Press, 1939). The revision was largely the work of Guggenheim (1901–1970); see F.C. Tompkins and C.F. Goodeve , Biog. Mem. R. Soc. 17 , 303 (1971).
   Google Scholar
• J.C. Maxwell , Theory of Heat (Longmans Green, London , 1871). Four more editions appeared before his death in 1879 and the same doubt about the speed of molecules in liquids was expressed in later editions, Lord Rayleigh , editors, up to 1916; J.S. Rowlinson , Mol. Phys. 103 , 2821 (2005).
   Google Scholar
• L.S. Ornstein , Arch. Néerl. 4 , 203 (1918); F. Zernike , ibid . 4 , 74.
   Google Scholar
• L.S. Ornstein and F. Zernike , Proc. Sec. Sci. Acad. Amsterdam 17 , 793 (1914). The paper was read to the Academy in Dutch in September 1914 but was soon published in English. The paper was reprinted as Paper III-1 by H.L. Frisch and J.L. Lebowitz , editors, The Equilibrium Theory of Classical Fluids (Benjamin, New York , 1954).
   Google Scholar
• M. Smoluchowski , Bull. Int. Acad. Cracovie, Classe Sci. Math. Nat. 1057 (1907), and in a German translation in Ann. Phys. 25, 205 (1908); A. Einstein , Ann. Phys. 33 , 1275 (1910), English translation, Collected Papers, Vol. 3, Doc. 9.
   Google Scholar
• See eqn 539 of ref. 1.
   Google Scholar
• T. Andrews , Philos. Trans. R. Soc. 159 , 575 (1869); J.D. van der Waals , thesis in Dutch at Leiden, 1873, with translations into German (1881), English (1890) and French (1894). It is now most accessible through a revised English translation in 1988, Vol. 14 of the series Studies in Statistical Mechanics (North-Holland Publisher, Amsterdam ).
   Google Scholar
• The restrictions of symmetry on the form of phase transitions in solids was discussed by L.D. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz in Chapter 11 of their Statistics Physics, in the first English edition of 1938, and in later editions after the War.
   Google Scholar
• P. Debye and P. Scherrer , Nachrichten König. Ges. Wiss. Göttingen Math. Phys. Klasse 16 , 16 (1916). Benzene is the only liquid studied by Debye and Scherrer – their ‘random oriented particles’ were otherwise powdered solids; W.H. Keesom and J. de Smedt , Proc. Sec. Sci. Acad. Sci. Amsterdam 26 , 112 (1923); F. Zernike and J.A. Prins , Zeit. Phys. 41 , 184 (1927); P. Debye and H. Menke , Phys. Zeit. 31 , 797 (1930).
   Google Scholar
• J. Yvon , Actual. Sci. Ind. 203 (1935); ibid . 542 (1937); reprinted in his Oeuvre scientifique (Paris, 1986); J.G. Kirkwood , J. Chem. Phys. 3 , 300 (1935); ibid . 7 , 919 (1939); N.N. Bogoluibov , papers of 1946, printed in an expanded form in English in Problems of a Dynamical Theory in Statistical Physics, Studies in Statistical Mechanics, Vol. 1 ( Amsterdam , 1963), p. 1; M. Born and H.S. Green , papers in Proc. R. Soc. A from 1946, reprinted as a book in 1949 (Cambridge University Press). The fourth-order version of the integral was treated by Y.-T. Lee , F.H. Ree and T. Ree , J. Chem. Phys. 48 , 3506 (1968); ‘—II’, 55 , 234 (1971).
   Google Scholar
• G. Mie , Ann. Phys. 11 , 657 (1903); N.F. Mott , Proc. R. Soc. A 146 , 465 (1934). Mie's monatomic substances were also metals; little was then known about the properties of the liquid inert gases.
   Google Scholar
• A. Münster , Statistical Thermodynamics , Vol. 2 (Springer, Berlin , 1974), p. 330. This version is a revision and translation of the original book of 1956. See also Fowler and Guggenheim, ref. 4, §802.
   Google Scholar
• R.H. Fowler , ref. 4, opening sentence of chap. 13.
   Google Scholar
• John Jones (1894–1954) was born in Lancashire, studied mathematics at Manchester where he learnt about the properties of gases from Sydney Chapman. He learnt then about the theory of crystals at Bristol, and about quantum mechanics at Göttingen, before he moved in 1932 to the new Plummer chair of theoretical chemistry at Cambridge. He assumed the name by which he is now known on his marriage to Kathleen Lennard in 1925. He contributed the chapter on ‘Intermolecular Forces’ to the first edition of Fowler's book, ref. 4. A.F. Devonshire worked with Lennard-Jones in the 1930s and moved after the war to the Physics Department at Bristol where he studied the properties of ferroelectrics.
   Google Scholar
• E.A. Guggenheim , Proc. R. Soc. A 148 , 304 (1935); G.S. Rushbrooke , ibid . 166 , 296 (1938).
   Google Scholar
• J.E. Lennard-Jones and A.F. Devonshire , Proc. R. Soc. A 163 , 53 (1937); ibid. 165 , 1 (1938); Fowler and Guggenheim, ref. 4, §§ 808–814.
   Google Scholar
• H. Eyring and J.O. Hirschfelder , J. Phys. Chem. 41 , 249 (1937); J.F. Kincaid and H. Eyring , ibid . 43 , 37 (1939). Henry Eyring (1901–1981) had a somewhat eccentric understanding of statistical mechanics. His greatest achievement was his treatment of chemical reaction rates by means of what is usually called the ‘activated complex theory’. His involvement with the theory of liquids was less impressive, culminating in what he called the ‘significant structures’ theory which never attracted much support: H. Eyring and M.S. Jhon, Significant Liquid Structures (Wiley, New York, 1969). There was a revealing encounter at a Gordon Conference on liquids in New Hampshire in, I believe, the late1970s, when Eyring was giving a paper on his idiosyncratic views on liquids to an audience that contained Joseph Mayer (1904–1983), a man who was a careful mathematician who had done much to develop the theory of compressed gases and to derive some precise results for the properties of molecular canonical distribution functions in fluids. We were all seated at school desks and when Eyring embarked on one of his more obscure flights of fancy about the structure of a fluid surrounding a lattice site, Mayer had had enough. He stood up, banged down the lid of his desk, exclaimed ‘What the devil is a ring of degeneracies?’, and stalked out. Eyring continued unabashed. His student, Joseph Hirschfelder (1911–1990) was a more orthodox character who, after the War, made his career at the University of Wisconsin, which soon ranked with Cambridge and Princeton as one of the leading centres in which lattice theories of liquids flourished.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• T.L. Hill , J. Phys. Chem. 51 , 1219 (1947); I. Prigogine and G. Garikian , J. Chem. Phys. 45 , 273 (1948).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• R.H. Wentorf , R.J. Buehler , J.O. Hirschfelder and C.F. Curtiss , J. Chem. Phys. 18 , 1484 (1950); W.F. Fickett and W.W. Wood , ibid . 20 , 1624 (1952). Bill Wood was at Los Alamos and so required a theory that he hoped could be useful in discussing explosions.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• J.A. Barker , Lattice Theories of the Liquid State (Pergamon Press, Oxford , 1963), p. 63. John Barker (1925–1995) wrote this short monograph at a time when it was still hoped that a sound theoretical basis could be found for lattice theories but he himself was already becoming more sceptical and was soon to find a better theory; J.S. Rowlinson , Biog. Mem. R. Soc. 42 , 13 (1996). E.G.D. Cohen's Amsterdam thesis of 1957 ‘On the theory of the liquid state’, written under de Boer's supervision, was also a work confined to lattice theories.
   Google Scholar
• J.E. Lennard-Jones and A.F. Devonshire , Proc. R. Soc. A 169 , 317 (1939); ibid. 170 , 464 (1939); ibid. 174 , 102 (1940).
   Google Scholar
• J.E. Mayer and M.G. Mayer , Statistical Mechanics (Wiley, New York , 1940), p. 319.
   Google Scholar
• J.G. Kirkwood , J. Chem. Phys. 18 , 380 (1950); Barker, ref. 23, chap. 5.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• J. Hirschfelder , D. Stevenson and H. Eyring , J. Chem. Phys. 5 , 596 (1937); O.K. Rice , ibid . 6 , 476 (1938).
   Google Scholar
• F. Cernuschi and H. Eyring , J. Chem. Phys. 7 , 547 (1939); H.M. Peek and T.L. Hill , ibid ., 18 , 1252 (1950); J.S. Rowlinson and C.F. Curtiss , ibid . 19 , 1519 (1951).
   Google Scholar
• J.O. Hirschfelder , C.F. Curtiss and R.B. Bird , Molecular Theory of Gases and Liquids (Wiley, New York , 1954).
   Google Scholar
• E.G.D. Cohen . Thesis, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands , 1957.
   Google Scholar
• J.A. Barker , Aust. J. Chem. , 13 , 187 (1960); Proc. R. Soc. A 259 , 442 (1961); Barker, ref. 23, chap. 9.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fowler and Guggenheim, ref. 4, §814; A. Münster , ref. 15, p. 642. Guggenheim later endorsed this guess in Mixtures (Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 1952), p. 24.
   Google Scholar
• [ No author], L.S. Ornstein, A Survey of His Work from 1908 to 1933 ( Utrecht , 1933).
   Google Scholar
• A. Münster , ref. 15, p.153; R.H. Fowler , Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 34 , 382 (1938).
   Google Scholar
• R.C. Tolman , The Principles of Statistical Mechanics (Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 1938).
   Google Scholar
• H. Kramers , Proc. R. Acad. Sci. Amsterdam. 41 , 10 (1938).
   Google Scholar
• J. de Boer , Thesis, Amsterdam , 1940; ibid., Rep. Prog. Phys. 12 , 305 (1948–1949).
   Google Scholar
• G.S. Rushbrooke and H.I. Scoins , Proc. R. Soc. A 216 , 203 (1953); see also L. Rosenfeld , Theory of Electrons ( North-Holland, Amsterdam , 1951), p. 80; G.S. Rushbrooke , Introduction to Statistical Mechanics (Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 1949).
   Google Scholar
• The Royal Society of Chemistry has a medal which can be awarded only for advances in experimental chemistry. When in the 1970s candidates came forward who had made their contributions by means of computer simulation it was decided, after some discussion, that this field was experimental, not theoretical.
   Google Scholar
• J.K. Percus and G.J. Yevick , Phys. Rev., 110 , 1 (1958).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• G. Stell , Physica 29 , 517 (1963).
   Google Scholar
• E. Thiele , J. Chem. Phys. 39 , 474 (1963); M.S. Wertheim , Phys. Rev. Lett. 10 , 321 (1963).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• J.A. Barker and D. Henderson , J. Chem. Phys. 47 , 4714 (1967); J.D. Weeks , D. Chandler and H.C. Anderson , ibid . 54 , 5237 (1971).
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• H.N.V. Temperley , J.S. Rowlinson and G.S. Rushbrooke , editors, Physics of Simple Liquids ( North-Holland, Amsterdam , 1968).
   Google Scholar
• J.P. Hansen and I.R. McDonald , The Theory of Simple Liquids (Academic Press, New York , 1976).
   Google Scholar
• J.H. Hildebrand , The Solubility of Nonelectrolytes (Reinhold, New York , 1923); R.L. Scott , ibid. 3rd ed. (1950); J.H. Hildebrand , J.M. Prausnitz and R.L. Scott , Regular and Related Solutions (Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York , 1970).
   Google Scholar
• S. Sugden , The Parachor and Valency (Routledge, London , 1930).
   Google Scholar