Quantitative Limits to Qualitative Engagements: GIS, Its Critics, and the Philosophical DivideFootnote∗

∗Many thanks to the suggestions of the three reviewers, whose probing questions have helped to produce an ultimately more thoughtful work. I am also grateful to Nadine Schuurman and Paul Kingsbury for their insights on the subject matter of critique, its role in geography, and GIScience.

Literature Cited

• Agarwal , P. 2005 . Ontological considerations in GIScience . International Journal of Geographical Information Science , 19 (5) : 501 – 36 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Agnew , J. 2006 . Open to surprise? . Progress in Human Geography , 30(1) : 1 – 4 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ahlqvist , O. 2004 . A parametrized representation of uncertain conceptual spaces . Transactions in GIS , 8 (4) : 493 – 514 .
   Google Scholar
• Ahlqvist , T. 2000 . A quest for polygon landscapes, or GIS and the condition of epistemology . Fennia , 178 (1) : 97 – 111 .
   Google Scholar
• Aitken , S. and Craine , J. 2006 . “ Guest editorial: Affective geovisualizations ” . In Directions Magazine 7 February. http://www.directionsmag.com/article.php?article_id=2097 (last accessed 20 June 2008)
   Google Scholar
• Antonious , G. and van Harmelen , F. 2004 . “ Web Ontology Language: OWL. ” . In Handbook on ontologies , Berlin : Springer-Verlag . S. Staab and R. Studer, 67–97
   Google Scholar
• Baader , F. , Horrocks , I. and Sattler , U. 2004 . “ Description logics ” . In Handbook on ontologies , Berlin : Springer-Verlag . S. Staab and R. Studer, 3–28
   Google Scholar
• Barnes , T. 2000 . “ Foundationalism ” . In The dictionary of human geography , Malden, MA : Blackwell . R. J. Johnston, D. Gregory, G. Pratt, and M. Watts, 278–79
   Google Scholar
• Bhaskar , R. 1978 . A realist theory of science. 2nd ed. , Atlantic Highlands, NJ : Humanities Press .
   Google Scholar
• Bhaskar , R. 1986 . Scientific realism and human emancipation. , London : Verso .
   Google Scholar
• Bhaskar , R. 2007 . “ Theorising ontology ” . In Contributions to social ontology , London and New York : Routledge . C. Lawson, J. Latsis, and N. Martins, 192–204
   Google Scholar
• Bhattarya , S. and Tripathi , N. 2004 . Integrating indigenous knowledge and GIS for participatory natural resource management: State-of-the-practice . Electronic Journal on Information Systems in Developing Countries , 17 (3) : 1 – 13 .
   Google Scholar
• Blomley , N. 2006 . Uncritical critical geography? . Progress in Human Geography , 30 : 87 – 94 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Brown , M. and Knopp , L. 2008 . Queering the map: The productive tensions of colliding epistemologies . Annals of the Association of American Geographers , 98 (1) : 40 – 58 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Callard , F. 2003 . The taming of psychoanalysis in geography . Social & Cultural Geography , 4 (3) : 295 – 312 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Callon , M. and Law , J. 2004 . Introduction: Absence-presence, circulation and encountering in complex space. Guest editorial . Environment and Planning D , 22 (1) : 3 – 11 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chambers , K. J. , Corbett , J. , Keller , C. P. and Wood , C. J. B. 2004 . Indigenous knowledge, mapping, and GIS: A diffusion of innovation perspective . Cartographica , 59 (3) : 19 – 33 .
   Google Scholar
• Chapin , M. , Lamb , Z. and Threlkeld , B. 2005 . Mapping indigenous lands . Annual Review of Anthropology , 34 : 619 – 39 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chase , R. S. , Benavides , M. , Pariona , M. and Tuesta , E. 2003 . Mapping the past and the future: Geomatics and indigenous territories in the Peruvian Amazon . Human Organization , 62 (4) : 357 – 69 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chrisman , N. 2005 . Full circle: More than just social implications of GIS . Cartographica , 40 (4) : 23 – 35 .
   Google Scholar
• Cloke , P. and Johnston , R. 2005 . “ Deconstructing human geography's binaries ” . In Spaces of geographical thought , London : Sage . P. Cloke and R. Johnston, 1–20
   Google Scholar
• Cloke , P. , Philo , C. and Sadler , D. 1991 . Approaching human geography: An introduction to contemporary theoretical debates. , London : Chapman .
   Google Scholar
• Crampton , J. W. and Krygier , J. 2006 . An introduction to critical cartography . ACME , 4 (1) : 11 – 33 .
   Google Scholar
• Curry , M. 1998 . Digital places: Living with geographic information technologies. , London and New York : Routledge .
   Google Scholar
• Derrida , J. 1970 . “ Structure, sign, and play in the discourse of human sciences ” . In The structuralist controversy , Baltimore : The John Hopkins University Press . R. Macksey and E. Donato, 247–42
   Google Scholar
• Dixon , D. P. and Jones , J. P. I. 1998 . My dinner with Derrida, or spatial analysis and poststructuralism do lunch . Environment and Planning A , 30 (2) : 247 – 60 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dixon , D. P. and Jones , J. P. I. 2004a . “ Poststructuralism ” . In A companion to cultural geography , Malden, MA : Blackwell . J. S. Duncan, N. C. Johnson, and R. H. Schein, 79–107
   Google Scholar
• Dixon , D. P. and Jones , J. P. I. 2004b . “ What next? ” . In Environment and Planning A Vol. 36(3) , 381 – 90 .
   Google Scholar
• Dodge , M. and Kitchen , R. 2004 . Flying through code/space: The real virtuality of air travel . Environment and Planning A , 36 (2) : 195 – 211 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Elwood , S. 2002 . GIS use in community planning: A multidimensional analysis of empowerment . Environment and Planning A , 34 (5) : 905 – 22 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Elwood , S. 2006a . Critical issues in participatory GIS: Deconstructions, reconstructions, and new research directions . Transactions in GIS , 10(5) : 693 – 708 .
   Google Scholar
• Elwood , S. 2006b . Negotiating knowledge production: The everyday inclusions, exclusions, and contradictions of participatory GIS research . The Professional Geographer , 58 : 197 – 208 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Elwood , S. 2006c . “ When you just say it, people don't see it: The politics of geovisualization in urban redevelopment. Paper presented at the University of British Columbia ” . 25 January
   Google Scholar
• Feuchtwanger , M. and Poiker , T. K. 1987 . “ Infological and datalogical spatial models ” . In Lecture notes in digital mapping and land information , Canada : Department of Surveying Engineering, University of Calgary . J. A. R. Blais, 146–67. Calgary, AB
   Google Scholar
• Ghose , R. 2001 . Use of information technology for community empowerment: Transforming geographic information systems into community information systems . Transactions in GIS , 5 (2) : 141 – 63 .
   Google Scholar
• Gold , C. M. 2006 . What is GIS and what is not? . Transactions in GIS , 10(4) : 505 – 19 .
   Google Scholar
• Gould , P. 1994 . Perspectives and sensitivities: Teaching as the creation of conditions of possibility for geographic thinking . Journal of Geography in Higher Education , 18 (3) : 277 – 89 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gould , P. 1999 . Becoming a geographer , Syracuse, NY : Syracuse University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Gregory , D. 2000 . “ Ontology ” . In The dictionary of human geography , Malden, MA : Blackwell . R. J. Johnston, D. Gregory, G. Pratt, and M. Watts, 561–64
   Google Scholar
• Gruber , T. R. 1993 . A translation approach to portable ontology specifications . Knowledge Acquisition , 5 (2) : 199 – 220 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hallisey , E. J. 2005 . Cartographic visualization: An assessment and epistemological review . The Professional Geographer , 57 (3) : 350 – 64 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hannah , M. G. and Strohmayer , U. 2001 . Anatomy of debate in human geography . Political Geography , 20 (3) : 381 – 404 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hansen , F. 1994 . Approaching human geography: Towards new approaches in human geography? . Geografiska Annaler , 76B(3) : 211 – 16 .
   Google Scholar
• Harris , T. M. , Weiner , D. , Warner , T. A. and Levin , R. 1995 . “ Pursuing social goals through participatory geographic information systems: Redressing South Africa's historical political ecology ” . In Ground truth: The social implications of geographic information systems , New York : Guilford . J. Pickles, 196–222
   Google Scholar
• Johnson , J. T. , Paulini Louis , R. and Promono , A. H. 2006 . Facing the future: Encouraging critical cartographic literacies in indigenous communities . ACME , 4 (1) : 80 – 98 .
   Google Scholar
• Jones , J. P. I. 2003 . “ Introduction: Reading geography through binary oppositions ” . In Handbook of cultural geography , Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage . K. Anderson, M. Domosh, S. Pile, and N. Thrift, 511–19
   Google Scholar
• Katz , C. 2001 . On the grounds of globalization: A topography for feminist political engagement . Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society , 26 : 1213 – 34 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kitcher , P. 1998 . “ A plea for science studies ” . In A house built on sand: Exposing postmodernist myths about science , New York : Oxford University Press . N. Koertge, 32–56
   Google Scholar
• Kwan , M.-P. 2002a . Feminist visualization: Re-envisioning GIS as a method in feminist geographic research . Annals of the Association of American Geographers , 92(4) : 645 – 61 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kwan , M.-P. 2002b . Is GIS for women? Reflections on the critical discourse in the 1990s . Gender, Place and Culture , 9(3) : 271 – 79 .
   Google Scholar
• Kwan , M.-P. 2004 . Beyond difference: From canonical geography to hybrid geographies . Annals of the Association of American Geographers , 94 (4) : 756 – 63 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kwan , M.-P. 2007 . Affecting geospatial technologies: Toward a feminist politics of emotion . The Professional Geographer , 59 (1) : 22 – 34 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kyem , P. A. K. 2004 . Of intractable conflicts and participatory GIS applications: The search for consensus amidst competing claims and institutional demands . Annals of the Association of American Geographers , 94 (1) : 37 – 57 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lakoff , G. 1987 . Women, fire, and dangerous things. , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
   Google Scholar
• Latsis , J. , Lawson , C. and Martins , N. 2007 . “ Introduction: Ontology, philosophy and the social sciences ” . In Contributions to social ontology , London and New York : Routledge . C. Lawson, J. Latsis, and N. Martins, 1–14
   Google Scholar
• Leitner , H. and Sheppard , E. 2003 . Unbounding critical geographic research on cities: The 1990s and beyond . Urban Geography , 23 (6) : 510 – 28 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Mark , D. M. and Turk , A. G. 2003 . “ Landscape categories in Yindjibarndi: Ontology, environment, and language ” . In Spatial information theory: Foundations of geographic information science , Berlin : Springer . W. Kuhn, M. F. Worboys, and S. Timpf, 28–35
   Google Scholar
• McCall , M. K. and Minang , P. A. 2005 . Assessing participatory GIS for community-based natural resource management: Claiming community forests in Cameroon . Geographical Journal , 171 (4) : 340 – 58 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McLafferty , S. 2002 . Mapping women's worlds: Knowledge, power and the bounds of GIS . Gender, Place and Culture , 9 (3) : 263 – 69 .
   Google Scholar
• McLafferty , S. 2005 . Women and GIS: Geospatial technologies and feminist geographies . Cartographica , 40 (4) : 37 – 45 .
   Google Scholar
• Miller , H. J. and Wentz , E. A. 2003 . Representation and spatial analysis in geographic information systems . Annals of the Association of American Geographers , 93 (3) : 574 – 94 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pavlovskaya , M. 2002 . Mapping urban change and changing GIS: Other views of economic restructuring . Gender, Place and Culture , 9 (3) : 281 – 90 .
   Google Scholar
• Pavlovskaya , M. 2006 . Theorizing with GIS: A tool for critical geographies? . Environment and Planning A , 38(11) : 2003 – 20 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Peet , R. 1998 . Modern geographic thought. , Oxford, UK : Blackwell .
   Google Scholar
• Pickles , J. 1997 . Tool or science? GIS, technoscience, and the theoretical turn . Annals of the Association of American Geographers , 87 (2) : 363 – 72 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pickles , J. 2004 . A history of spaces: Cartographic reason, mapping and the geo-coded world. , London and New York : Routledge .
   Google Scholar
• Popke , E. J. 2003 . Poststructuralist ethics: Subjectivity, responsibility and the space of community . Progress in Human Geography , 27 (3) : 298 – 316 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pratt , G. 2000 . “ Post-structuralism ” . In The dictionary of human geography , Malden, MA : Blackwell . R. J. Johnston, D. Gregory, G. Pratt, and M. Watts, 625–26
   Google Scholar
• Raper , J. F. 2005 . “ Spatial representation: The scientist's perspective ” . In Geographical information systems: Principles, techniques, management and applications , New York : Wiley . P. A. Longley, M. F. Goodchild, D. J. Maguire, and D. W. Rhind, 61–70
   Google Scholar
• Robbins , P. 2003 . Beyond ground truth: GIS and the environmental knowledge of herders, professional foresters, and other traditional communities . Human Ecology , 31 (2) : 233 – 53 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rorty , R. 1989 . Contingency, irony, and solidarity. , Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Rose , M. 2004 . Reembracing metaphysics . Environment and Planning A , 36 (3) : 461 – 68 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Saldanha , A. 2006 . Reontologising race: The machinic geography of phenotype . Environment and Planning D , 24 (1) : 9 – 24 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schuurman , N. 2000 . Trouble in the heartland: GIS and its critics in the 1990s . Progress in Human Geography , 24 (4) : 569 – 90 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schuurman , N. 2002 . Women and technology in geography: A cyborg manifesto for GIS . The Canadian Geographer , 46 (3) : 258 – 65 .
   Google Scholar
• Schuurman , N. 2005 . Social perspectives on semantic interoperability: Constraints on geographical knowledge from a data perspective . Cartographica , 40 (4) : 47 – 61 .
   Google Scholar
• Schuurman , N. 2006 . Why formalization matters: Critical GIS and ontology research . Annals of the Association of American Geographers , 96 (4) : 726 – 39 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schuurman , N. and Kwan , M.-P. 2004 . Guest editorial: Taking a walk on the social side of GIS . Cartographica , 39 (1) : 1 – 3 .
   Google Scholar
• Schuurman , N. and Leszczynski , A. 2006 . Ontology-based metadata . Transactions in GIS , 10 (5) : 709 – 26 .
   Google Scholar
• Sheppard , E. 2005 . Knowledge production through critical GIS: Genealogy and prospects . Cartographica , 40 (4) : 5 – 21 .
   Google Scholar
• Sieber , R. 2007 . Spatial data access by the grassroots . Cartography and Geographic Information Science , 34 (1) : 47 – 62 .
   Google Scholar
• Smith , B. 2003 . “ Ontology ” . In Blackwell guide to the philosophy of computing and information , Oxford : Blackwell . L. Floridi, 155–66
   Google Scholar
• Smith , N. 2005 . Neo-critical geography, or, the flat pluralist world of business class . Antipode , 37 (5) : 887 – 99 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sowa , J. F. 2000 . Knowledge representation: Logical, philosophical, and computational foundations. , Pacific Grove, CA : Brooks/Cole .
   Google Scholar
• Strohmayer , U. 2003 . “ The culture of epistemology ” . In Handbook of cultural geography , Thousand Oaks, CA : Sage . K. Anderson, M. Domosh, S. Pile, and N. Thrift, 520–31
   Google Scholar
• Thrift , N. and French , S. 2002 . The automatic production of space . Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers , 27 (3) : 309 – 35 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Wilshire , B. 1969 . Metaphysics: An introduction to philosophy, traditions in philosophy , New York : Pegasus .
   Google Scholar
• Wittgenstein , L. 2001 . Tractatus logico-philosophicus. , London and New York : Routledge . Trans. B. McGuiness and D. F. Pears. 2nd ed
   Google Scholar
• Yeung , H. W.-C. 1997 . Critical realism and realist research in human geography: A method or a philosophy in search of a method? . Progress in Human Geography , 21(1) : 51 – 74 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar