373
Views
34
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The contemporary American abortion controversy: Stages in the argument

Pages 410-424 | Published online: 05 Jun 2009

Notes

  • Lynch , Robert N. 6 March 1976 . “Abortion and 1976 Politics” . In America 6 March , 177
  • Fraker , Susan . 1978 . “Abortion Under Attack” . Reader's Digest , September : 42
  • McGee , Michael Calvin . 1980 . “The ‘Ideograph’: A Link Between Rhetoric and Ideology” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 66 : 1 – 17 .
  • Burke , Kenneth . 1969 . A Grammar of Motives , Berkeley : University of California Press . (1945; rpt.
  • Cathcart , Robert S. 1980 . “Defining Social Movements by Their Rhetorical Form” . Central Stales Speech Journal , 31 : 267
  • Andrews , James R. “History and Theory in the Study of the Rhetoric of Social Movements” . 274 – 81 .
  • Griffin , Leland . “On Studying Movements” . 226
  • Griffin , Leland . 1952 . “The Rhetoric of Historical Movements” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 38 : 184 – 88 .
  • Mohr , James C. 1978 . Abortion in America: The Origins and Evolution of National Policy, 1800–1900 , New York : Oxford Union Press .
  • Plant , Barbara . April 1971 . “Abortion as a Secondary Birth Control Measure: A Functional Approach” . April , University of Windsor . M.A. Thesis,
  • Noonan , John T. Jr. 1970 . The Morality of Abortion: Legal and Historical Perspectives , xi – xvii . Cambridge, Massachusetts : Harvard University Press .
  • Lader , Lawrence . 1973 . Abortion II: Making the Revolution , xi Boston : Beacon Press .
  • Sarvis , Betty and Rodman , Hyman . 1974 . The Abortion Controversy , New York : Columbia University Press .
  • Toulmin , Stephen . 1958 . The Uses of Argument , Cambridge : The University Press .
  • Gronbeck , Bruce E. . “Sociocultural Notions of Argument Fields: A Primer” . Dimensions of Argument: Proceedings of the Second Summer Conference on Argumentation . Edited by: Ziegelmueller , George and Rhodes , Jack . pp. 1 – 21 . Annandale, Va : Speech Communication Association .
  • Zarefsky , David . “ ‘Reasonableness’ Public Policy Argument: Fields as Institutions” . 88 – 100 .
  • Fisher , Walter R. “Good Reasons: Fields and Genre” . 114 – 26 .
  • Rosen , Harold , ed. 1964 . Therapeutic Abortion , New York : Julian Press .
  • Nathanson , Bernard and Ostling , Richard . 1979 . Aborting America , Garden City, New York : Doubleday and Company, Inc. .
  • Guttmacher , Alan . 1967 . The Case for Legalized Abortion Now , Berkeley : Diablo Press .
  • Lader , Lawrence . 1966 . Abortion , 24 – 41 . Boston : Beacon Press .
  • Clark , Marguerite . 1960 . “Abortion Racket, What Should Be Done?” . Newsweek , 15 August : 50 – 2 .
  • Davidson , Muriel . 1963 . “Deadly Favor” . Ladies Home Journal , November : 53 – 7 .
  • 1962 . “Abortion and the Law” . Time , 3 August : 30
  • Ridgeway , James . 1963 . “One Million Abortions” . New Republic , 9 February : 14 – 17 .
  • 1963 . “Why Did You Do It? France's Biggest Postwar Mass Abortion Trial” . Newsweek , 10 June : 54
  • Guttmacher , Allan F. 1960 . “Law that Doctors Often Break” . Reader's Digest , January : 51 – 4 .
  • Martin , John Bartlow . 1961 . “Abortion” . Saturday Evening Post , 20 May : 19 – 21 .
  • Marley , Faye . 1963 . “Legal Abortion Safer” . Science News Letter , 2 March : 134
  • Goodman , Walter . October 1965 . “Abortion and Sterilization: The Search for the Answers” . In Redbook October , 70 – 1 .
  • Starr , Jack . 1962 . “Growing Tragedy of Illegal Abortion” . Look , 19 October : 52 – 3 .
  • Lader . Abortion 65 – 6 .
  • Railsback , Celeste Condit . 1982 . “The Contemporary American Abortion Controversy: A Study of Public Argumentation” . University of Iowa . Diss.,
  • 1962 . “Is Abortion Ever Justified? Two Church Views” . U.S. News and World Report , 3 September : 89
  • 19 October 1963 . “Candle in a Dark World: West German Protestant Consultation Centers to Check Abortions” . In America 19 October , 445
  • McCormick , R.A. 19 June 1965 . “Abortion” . In America 19 June , 1241 – 44 .
  • 1968 . “Abortion and the Law” . Newsweek , 2 December
  • Lader , Lawrence . 1969 . “First Exclusive Survey of Non‐Hospital Abortions” . Look , 21 January : 63 – 65 .
  • Clark . “Abortion Racket: What Should Be Done?” . 51
  • Vaughn , Richard P. 16 October 1965 . “the immature side of her nature rebels against the prospect of being a mother” but at another level she craves “the experience of fulfillment and creativity that accompanies motherhood” in “Psychotherapeutic Abortion: Bill Under Consideration in California” . In America 16 October , 436 – 8 .
  • 1967 . “Abortion by Consent?” . Christian Century , 1 February : 132
  • Chrobot , L.F. , ed. 2 June 1962 . “Slaughter of the Innocent” . In America 2 June , 39
  • Goodman , Walter . 1965 . “Abortion Sought Abroad” . Science News Letter , 24 July : 63
  • 1965 . Health , April : 24 – 25 .
  • Hellegers , Andre E. 1967 . “Law and the Common Good” . Commonweal , 30 June : 418 ff
  • 1962 . “Doc Henrie's Farewell” . Newsweek , 30 June : 22 ff
  • Lader . Abortion 56 – 7 .
  • 1980 . “Most Important Problems During Election Campaigns” . Gallup Opinion Index , September : 11
  • Gallup , George H. 1972 . Public Opinion: 1935–1971 , 1572 – 73 . New York : Random House .
  • Kerby , P. 1967 . “Abortion: Laws and Attitudes” . Nation , 12 June : 754 – 56 .
  • 1968 . “Abortion and the Law” . Newsweek , 2 December : 82 – 83 .
  • 1968 . “Protecting Civil Liberties: The Right to Have an Abortion” . Current , May : 26 – 28 .
  • Hall , Robert E. 1968 . Saturday Review , 7 December : 78 – 9 .
  • 1967 . “Desperate Dilemma of Abortion” . Time , 13 October : 32 – 3 .
  • 1967 . “Coping with Abortion: Panel Discussion” . Mademoiselle , October : 211 – 212 .
  • Reiterman , Carl , ed. 1971 . Abortion and the Unwanted Child , New York : Springer Publishing Co. .
  • Blake , Judith . 1977 . “The Abortion Decisions: Judicial Review and Public Opinion” . In Abortion: New Directions for Policy Studies , Edited by: Manier , Edward , Liu , William and Solomon , David . 51 – 81 . Notre Dame, Indiana : University of Notre Dame Press .
  • Ulsaner , Eric M. and Weber , Ronald E. 1980 . “Public Support for Pro‐Choice Abortion Policies in the Nation and States: Changes and Stability After the Roe and Doe Decisions” . In The Law and Politics of Abortion , Edited by: Schneider , Carl E. and Vinovskis , Maris A. 206 – 23 . Lexington, Massachusetts : D.C. Heath and Company .
  • Lader . Abortion II 166 – 67 .
  • John‐Stevas , Norman St. 1968 . “Abortion, Catholics, and the Law” . Catholic World , January : 149 – 52 .
  • Shriver , Eunice Kennedy . 1968 . “When Pregnancy Means Heartbreak: Is Abortion the Answer?” . McCalls , April : 139
  • Brown , Brendon F. 1970 . “Criminal Abortion” . Vital Speeches of the Day , 1 July : 549 – 53 .
  • Kuhn , Harold B. 1971 . “Now Generation Churchmen and the Unborn” . Christianity Today , 29 January : 38
  • Blum , Virgil C. 1971 . “Public Policy Making: Why the Churches Strike Out” . America , 6 March : 224 – 28 .
  • 1971 . National Review , 9 February : 116
  • 1972 . “Twisted Logic: Propositions to Legalize Abortion” . Christianity Today , 22 December : 24 – 5 .
  • Lader . Abortion II 182 – 84 .
  • Fischl , Irene . 1971 . “Why Are Nurses Shook Up Over Abortion?” . Look , 9 February : 66
  • Douglas , J.O. 1972 . “Abortion Problems in Britain” . Christianity Today , 17 March : 47
  • Marx , Paul . 1972 . “On Not Changing Womb Into Tomb” . Catholic World , January : 218
  • Kirk , Russell . 1972 . “The Sudden Death of Feticide” . National Review , 22 December : 1407
  • 1972 . “Twisted Logic: Propositions to Legalize Abortion” . Christianity Today , 22 December : 24 – 5 .
  • Rockefeller , John D. III . 1976 . “No Retreat on Abortion” . Newsweek , 21 June : 11
  • Baudry , Francis and Wiener , Alfred . 1974 . “Women's Choice: Pregnancy or Abortion” . Mademoiselle , April : 34
  • Byrn , Robert M. 2 June 1973 . “Goodbye to the Judeo‐Christian Era in Law” . In America 2 June , 511
  • Shriver , Eunice Kennedy . 1968 . “When Pregnancy Means Heartbreak: Is Abortion the Answer?” . McCalls , April : 139
  • Shaw , Russell . 1973 . “Alienation of American Catholics” . America , 8 September : 138 – 40 .
  • Miles , John A. Jr. 1973 . “Wife of Onan and the Sons of Cain” . National Review , 17 August : 891 – 94 .
  • O'Connell , Timothy . 2 June 1973 . “For American Catholics: End of an Illusion” . In America 2 June , 514
  • Noonan , John T. Jr. 1973 . “Right to Life: Raw Judicial Power” . National Review , 2 March : 16 – 64 .
  • Wedel , Mrs. Theodore . 15 December 1973 . “Maude Case: Pressure or Persuasion” . In America 15 December , 465
  • 1973 . “That's Entertainment” . Time , 27 August : 630
  • Beusse , Robert R. and Shaw , Russell . 3 November 1973 . “Maude's Abortion: Spontaneous or Induced?” . In America 3 November ,
  • 21 September 1974 . “When to Baptise . .. When to Dismiss” . In America 21 September , 123
  • Fuller , Tony . 1974 . “Baptism of Ire” . Newsweek , 2 September : 75
  • 1975 . “Fight Over Fetuses” . Time , 31 March : 82
  • Nelson , J. Robert . 1975 . “New Protection for the Unborn Child” . Christian Century , 20 August : 725
  • Alpern , David M. 1975 . “Abortion and the Law” . Newsweek , 3 March : 18 – 29 .
  • Berger , Carol Altekruse and Berger , Patrick F. 1975 . “The Edelin Decision” . Commonweal , 25 August : 77
  • 1975 . “Abortion: The Edelin Schock Wave” . Time , 3 March : 54
  • Keerdoja , Eileen and Wu , Ying Yilng . 1980 . “Dr. Wadill: Triple Jeopardy?” . Newsweek , 7 January : 10
  • 1978 . “The Scarlet A” . Time , 11 September : 22
  • 2 February 1980 . “Abortion and the Poor” . In America 2 February , 73
  • 8 March 1980 . “Hyde Amendment” . In America 8 March , 181
  • Steinfels , Peter . 1977 . “Politics of Abortion” . Commonweal , 22 July : 45
  • Lloyd . 13 June 1978 . Congressional Record , Vol. 124 , 13 June , 17261 Washington, D.C. : The U.S. Government Printing Office . pt 13,
  • Prentice , Thomas A. 1980 . “Letters from Readers” . Progressive , December : 37
  • Kilpatrick , James Jason . 1979 . “A Comment” . National Review , 25 May : 679
  • 1977 . “Fight Over Abortions” . US News and World Report , 19 December : 68
  • Neuhaus , Richard John . 1980 . “Hyde and Hysteria” . Christian Century , September 10–17 : 852
  • Fraker , Susan . 1978 . “Abortion Under Attack” . Newsweek , 5 June : 36 – 7 .
  • 1977 . “Unborn and the Born Again” . New Republic , 2 July : 5
  • Loesch , Juli . 9 December 1978 . “Pro‐Life, Pro‐ERA” . In America 9 December , 435
  • Uddo , Basile J. 7 July 1979 . “Inquiry on Abortion: View of J.Ts. Noonan” . In America 7 July , 14
  • Meehan , Mary . 1980 . “Abortion: the Left Has Betrayed the Sanctity of Life” . Progressive , September : 34
  • Loesch , Juli . 9 December 1978 . “Pro‐Life, Pro‐ERA” . In America 9 December , 435
  • Bernard , Anne . 26 March 1977 . “Born and the Unborn Alike” . In America 26 March , 272
  • Meehan , Francis X. 17 June 1978 . “Social Justice and Abortion” . In America 17 June , 478
  • Uddo , Basile J. 7 July 1979 . “Inquiry on Abortion: View of J. T. Noonan” . In America 7 July , 14
  • Vree , Dale . 1978 . “Bourgeois Abortions” . National Review , 27 October : 1351
  • Montgomery , John Warwick . 1980 . “Abortion: Courting Severe Judgment” . Christianity Today , 25 January : 54
  • Ashford , Thomas . 12 February 1977 . “Countdown to an Abortion” . In America 12 February , 128
  • Steinfels , Peter . 1977 . “Politics of Abortion” . Commonweal , 22 July : 45
  • Steinem , Gloria . 1977 . “Update: Abortion Alert” . Ms. , November : 118
  • Willis , Ellen . 1977 . “Abortion Backlash: Women Lose” . Rolling Stone , 3 November : 65
  • Fein , Elaine . 1980 . “The Facts About Abortion” . Harper's Bazaar , May : 76
  • Lake , Alice . 1980 . “Abortion Repeaters” . McCalls , September : 58
  • Welch , Mary Scott and Hermann , Dorothy . 1980 . “Why Miscarriage is so Misunderstood” . Ms. , February : 14
  • Steinem , Gloria . 1980 . “Nazi Connection” . Ms. , November : 14
  • Jagger , Alison . 1981 . “Political Philosophies of Women's Liberation” . In Feminism and Philosophy , Edited by: Vetterling‐Braggin , Mary , Elliston , Frederick A. and English , Jane . Totowa, NJ : Littlefield, Adams, and Company .
  • David , Henry P. , ed. 1974 . Abortion Research: International Experience , Lexington, Massachusetts : Lexington Books .
  • Callahan , Daniel . 1970 . Abortion: Law, Choice, and Morality , 219 – 66 . New York : The MacMillan Co. .
  • Lader . Abortion 116 – 131 .
  • Blumstock , Robert . 1981 . “Hungary” . In Attitudes in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union , Edited by: Welsh , William A. 330 – 31 . New York : Pergamon Press .
  • Kraditor , Aileen S. 1965 . Ideas of the Woman Suffrage Movement, 1890–1920 , 43 – 74 . New York : Columbia University Press .
  • Andrews , James R. 1967 . “Piety and Pragmatism: Rhetorical Aspects of the Early British Peace Movement” . Communication Monographs , 34 : 423 – 36 .
  • Simons , Herbert , Mechling , Elizabeth and Schrier , Howard N. 1984 . “Mobilizing for Collective Action from the Bottom Up: The Rhetoric of Social Movements” . In Handbook of Rhetoric and Communication Edited by: Bowers , John W. and Arnold , Carroll C. in press,
  • Griffin , Leland . 1969 . “A Dramatistic Theory of the Rhetoric of Movements” . In Critical Responses to Kenneth Burke , Edited by: Rueckert , William H. Minneapolis, Minnesota : University of Minnesota Press .
  • Turner , Ralph and Killian , Lewis . 1972 . Collective Behavior , Englewood Cliffs, NJ : Prentice‐Hall, Inc. .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.