Publication Cover
The Round Table
The Commonwealth Journal of International Affairs
Volume 91, 2002 - Issue 365
128
Views
3
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

'A formula may have to be found': Ireland, India, and the headship of the Commonwealth

Pages 391-413 | Published online: 25 Aug 2010

References

  • 1999 . The Round Table , 88 ( 350 ) April : vi Editorial
  • Marshall , P. “ 'Shaping the "New Commonwealth", 1949' ” . 185 – 197 .
  • The Commonwealth at the Summit: Communiqués of Commonwealth Heads of Government Meetings 1944-1985 . pp. 29 – 30 . London : Commonwealth Secretariat . Text in
  • Madden , F. and Darwin , J. , eds. 1993 . “ Articles of Agreement for a treaty between Great Britain and Ireland, 6 December 1921 ” . In Select Documents on the Constitutional History of the British Empire and Commonwealth, Volume VI, The Dominions and India since 1900 , Volume VI , 560 – 564 . Westport and London : Greenwood Press .
  • Macardle , D. 1937 . The Irish Republic , Gollancz : London . ; Irish Press, Dublin, 1951
  • Hancock , W. K. 1937 . Survey of British Commonwealth Affairs, Volume I, Problems of Nationality 1918-1936 , Volume I , Oxford University Press . Chapter III 'Saorsát Éireann'
  • Geyser , O. 1998 . 'Irish Independence: Jan Smuts and Eamon de Valera' . The Round Table , 87 ( 348 ) October : 473 – 484 .
  • Pakenham , F. 1935, 1972 . Peace by Ordeal , London : Sidgwick and Jackson . A dramatic account in, [Earl of Longford]
  • Mansergh , Diana , ed. 1997 . Nationalism and Independence: Selected Irish Papers by Nicholas Mansergh , 191 – 192 . Cork University Press . Conversation with President de Valera, 21 September 1965 in
  • Macardle . Irish Republic 937 Draft Treaty A in
  • Ibid, p 943 for Irish memo, 22 November 1921.
  • Ibid, p 960 for 'Document No. Two'.
  • Madden . Select Documents , VI 105 – 106 . 124 – 128 .
  • Wheare , K. C. 1960 . The Constitutional Structure of the Commonwealth , Oxford University Press .
  • de Vere White , T. 1948 . Kevin O'Higgins , 223 London : Methuen .
  • Harkness , D. W. 1969 . The Restless Dominion: The Irish Free State and the British Commonwealth of Nations , London : Macmillan . For a full account of the Free State rôle see
  • Amery , L. S. 1953 . My Political Life 2 vols , 390 – 395 . London II
  • Low , D. A. 1973 . “ 'Sequence and the demission of power' ” . Edited by: Rampant , Lion . 148 – 187 . Frank Cass : London . On the crucial debate about empire see
  • McMahon , D. 1984 . Republicans and Imperialists: AngloIrish Relations in the 1930s , New Haven : Yale University Press . The best account of the Irish debate is
  • Harkness , D. W. 1970 . 'Mr de Valera's dominion: Irish relations with Britain and the Commonwealth, 1932-1938' . Journal of Commonwealth Political Studies , 8 ( 3 ) : 206 – 228 .
  • Holland , R. F. 1981 . Britain and the Commonwealth Alliance 1918-1939 , 152 – 166 . London : Macmillan .
  • Coupland , R. , ed. 1935 . “ 'Reflections on a Visit to Dublin' ” . In The Empire in these Days: An interpretation , 75 – 78 . London : Macmillan . Notes by Coupland on visit to Dublin 26 June-3 July 1933. DO 35/398/3, file 11111/447. See also
  • McMahon . Republicans and Imperialists 214 – 218 .
  • Mansergh , N. 1952 . “ 'The twilight of dominion status' ” . In Survey of British Commonwealth Affairs: Problems of External Policy 1931-1939 , 270 – 333 . Oxford University Press .
  • Earl of Longford and O'Neill , T. P. 1970 . Eamon de Volera , 377 London : Hutchinson .
  • Moore , R. J. 1987 . Making the New Commonwealth , Oxford : Clarendon Press . The best account is, which is set against the background of Indo-Pakistan conflict over Kashmir
  • TOPI , XI 226 – 229 .
  • Tinker , H. , ed. 1984 . Burma: The Struggle for Independence 1944-48 , 2 vols , 389 London : HMSO . II
  • Mansergh . 1947 . “ 'The implications of Eire's relationship with the British Commonwealth of Nations' ” . RIIA .
  • Mansergh . 1948 . The Commonwealth of Nations , 193 – 224 . London : RIIA . Cyclostyled copy in PREM 8/735, which became CR(O)(48)3, 10 March 1948. Published in, and Selected Irish Papers, pp 148-168
  • Stent , P. J. H. “ 'The British Commonwealth and Asia' ” . 25 – 36 . PREM . 8/735
  • H. McNeill to P. Noel-Baker, 6 February 1948. DO 35/2187.
  • Laski , H. J. 1 February 1948 . “ 'Note on the possible association of an independent state with Great Britain' ” . 1 February , 52 PREM . 8/735
  • Hyam , R. , ed. 1992 . The Labour Government 1945-1951 , 4 vols , 153 – 155 . London : HMSO . Attlee to Nehru, 11 March 1948. British Documents on the End of Empire Project [BDEEP], Series A, VoI 2, IV
  • Moore . New Commonwealth 128 – 130 .
  • Mansergh , N. 1958 . Survey of British Commonwealth Affairs: Problems of Wartime Cooperation and Post-War Change, 1939-1952 , 265 – 273 . London : Oxford University Press .
  • 5 September 1948 . Sunday Independent 5 September , 1 Dublin
  • 1948 . Montreal Gazette , 8 September : 1 Winnipeg Free Press, 9 September 1948, p 17
  • 1948 . The Ottawa Journal , 7 September : 1 quoted Costello as saying 'Closer "association" with the Commonwealth would be with the British Commonwealth of Nations rather than with a "Commonwealth of British Nations'"
  • Mansergh . 1969 . “ 'Irish Foreign Policy, 1945-51' ” . In Ireland in the War Years and After 1939-51 , Edited by: Nowlan , K. B. and Williams , T. D. 140 – 141 . Dublin and London : Gill and Macmillan .
  • Mclnerney , M. 1967 . 'Mr John A. Costello Remembers-5' . The Irish Times , 8 September : 10 Costello's recollections are recorded by
  • Duff to Noel-Baker (85), 1 June 1948. DO 35/3931
  • McMahon , D. 1999 . “ 'Ireland and the Empire-Commonwealth, 1900-1948' ” . In Oxford History of the British Empire, VoI IV, The Twentieth Century , Edited by: Brown , Judith and Louis , Wm. Roger . Vol. VoI IV , 161 Oxford University Press .
  • O'Brien , J. B. 1988 . 'Ireland's departure from the British Commonwealth' . Round Table , 77 ( 306 ) April : 179 – 194 . Note of meeting in the British Embassy, Paris, 14 November 1948; note of meeting in Evatt's office, Palais de Chaillot, 16 November 1948. DO 35/3964. Evatt's rôle is somewhat overplayed in
  • Walker , Gordon . 31 December 1948 . “ 'The link with India' ” . 31 December , Ibid
  • Moore . New Commonwealth 161 – 162 .
  • Pearson , L. B. 1974 . Memoirs, Volume 2, 1948-55, The International Years , Volume 2 , 101 – 106 . London : Gollancz . Notes on Visit to London, April 19-30 1949, 3. Pearson Papers, MG 26, N1, Box 334, file India-Canada Relations 1947-57. See also

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.