Gaspirali v. Il'minskii: Two identity projects for the muslims of the Russian Empire

References

• Ostroumov , Nikolai . 1913 . "K istorii musul'manskogo obrazovatel'nogo dvizheniia v Rossii v XIX i XX stoletiiakh" . Mir Islama , 2 ( 5 ) : 316 – 326 . "Ismail Bei Gasprinskii" is the English transliteration of the Russianized form of Gaspirah's name
   Google Scholar
• Stamoolis , James J. 1986 . Eastern Orthodox Mission Theology Today , 28 Maryknoll , NY : Orbis Books .
   Google Scholar
• Smirnoff , Eugene . 1903 . A Short Account of the Historical Development and Present Position of Russian Orthodox Missions 16 – 23 . London For the missionary activities of Makarius and Veniaminov see
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. 1892 . "Pravoslavnoe bogosluzhenie na tatarskom iazyke" ” . In Nikolai Ivanovich Il'minskii: izbrannye mesta iz pedagogicheskikh sochinenii, nekotorye svedeniia o ego geiatel'nosti i o poslednykh dniakh ego zhizni , 1892 , 22 – 29 . Kazan' : Tipografiia imperatorskogo universiteta . For the relationship between Makarius and Il'minskii
   Google Scholar
• Hale , C. R. 1878 . "The Orthodox Missionary Society of Russia" . American Church Review , 30 : 344 – 360 . In 1870, Veniaminov founded the Orthodox Missionary Society in Moscow. See
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. 1895 . Pis'ma N. I. Il'minskogo k Ober-prokuroru Sviateishego Sinoda Konstantinu Petrovichu Pobe-donostsevu , 116 – 126 . 180 – 187 . Kazan' : Tipo-litografiia imperatorskogo universitete . This society supported Il'minskii's work from then on. For examples of how Il'minskii followed the Russian Orthodox missions and for the personal relationship between Il'minskii and Veniaminov, see
   Google Scholar
• Lemercier-Quelquejay , Chantal . 1967 . "Les missions orthodoxes en pays musulmans de moyenne-et basse-Volga, 1552-1865" . Cahiers du Monde Russe et Soviétique , 8 ( 3 ) : 387 – 391 .
   Google Scholar
• Khodarkovsky , Michael . 1996 . '"Not by Word Alone': Missionary Policies and Religious Conversion in Early Modern Russia" . Comparative Studies in Society and History , 38 ( 2 ) : 283 – 287 .
   Google Scholar
• Kefeli-Clay , Agnes . 1996 . "L'Islam populaire chez les Tatars chretiens orthodoxes au XIXe siecle" . Cahiers du Monde Russe , 37 ( 4 ) : 411
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. 1870 . "O perevode pravoslavnykh kristianskikh knig na tatarskii iazyk, pri khristiano-tatarskoi shkole v Kazani" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , November : 2 – 3 . Chapter 152; Il'minskii's student Nikolai Ostroumov has a similar argument in
   Google Scholar
• Ostroumov , Nikolai . 1872 . "Zametka ob otnoshenii Mokhammedanstva k obrazovaniiu kreshchenykh Tatar" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniias , 4 June : 94 – 95 . ch. 161, old.
   Google Scholar
• Lazzerini . IsmailBey Gasprinskii 2 – 3 .
   Google Scholar
• Kirimli , Hakan . 1996 . Kirim Tatarlartnda MiIli Kimlik ve MiIli Hareketler, 1905-1916 , 38 Ankara : Turk Tarih Kurumu Basimevi . This book is the Turkish edition of Kirimli, National Movements and National Identity
   Google Scholar
• Lazzerini . Is mail Bey Gasprinskii 4 – 11 .
   Google Scholar
• Fisher , Alan W. 1968 . "Enlightened Despotism and Islam under Catherine II" . Slavic Review , 27 ( 4 ) : 542 – 553 .
   Google Scholar
• Fisher , Alan W. 1987 . The Crimean Tatars , 78 88 92 – 93 . Stanford , CA : Hoover Institution Press . On the Russian colonization and emigrations, see
   Google Scholar
• Kirimli . Kirim Tatarlarinda MiIli Kimlik 11 – 17 .
   Google Scholar
• Bezchinskii , A. 1903 . Putevoditel' po Krymu , 74 Moskva : Tipo-lit. T-va I. N. Kushnerev . Prince Menshikov had in fact ordered deportation of the Crimean Tatars to Central Russia in 1854, but this proved to be practically impossible under the war conditions
   Google Scholar
• Kirimli . Kirim Tatarlarinda MiIli Kimlik 15
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 15.
   Google Scholar
• Gaspirinski , Ismail . 1328 (1913) . "Muhâceret-i Muazzama" . Türk Yurdu , 2 : 707 In 1913, Gaspirali wrote: "I would not let even one Turk move from his place in Russia if I had the power to do so, because one emigrating Turk is influencing ten others; he is leaving them in ambivalence, and he himself cannot find salvation in emigration; a homeland is being ruined, but another one is not being founded; nobody gains anything, everybody loses something."
   Google Scholar
• Saydam , Abdullah . 1997 . Kirim ve Kafkas Göçleri (1856-1876) , 69 Ankara : Turk Tarih Kurumu Basimevi .
   Google Scholar
• Gasprinskii , Ismail . 1985 . Russkoe Musul'manstvo , 28 – 29 . Oxford : Society for Central Asian Studies . 1881; reprint
   Google Scholar
• Khalid , Adeeb . 1998 . The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform: Jadidism in Central Asia , 19 – 44 . Berkeley , CA : University of California Press . There were two types of traditional Muslim schools: mektebs, elementary schools, and medreses, higher schools that had an exclusively religious character in nineteenth-century Russia until the reform movement that came toward the end of the nineteenth century. On the function of traditional education in the traditional Muslim societies in Russia; Although Khalid's work is confined to Central Asia, the situation in other parts of Russia was not much different
   Google Scholar
• Lazzerini . Ismail Bey Gasprinskii xx School reforms of Sihabeddin MercanÎ and Abdülqayyum Nasirf are two outstanding examples of these attempts
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . "O perevode" ” . 3 For a case study about the impact of these everyday relations, see Kefeli-Clay, "L'Islam populaire."
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . Pis'ma 4
   Google Scholar
• 1908 . "ismail Bey Gaspirinskiy ile Miilâqat" . Tasvir-i Efkâr , 27 June
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. "O primenenii Russkogo alfavita k inorodcheskim iazykam" ” . In Nikolai Ivanovich Il'minskii 5 – 6 . Beginning from the late eighteenth century, the Holy Synod had engaged in the translation of Christian texts into the languages of the inorodtsy. In 1883, Il'minskii analyzed these translations in a long treatise. He contended that these translations were unsuccessful because they had not paid attention to the lexical, semantic, and syntactic rules of the vernaculars
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. 1883 . Opyty perelozheniia khristianskikh verouchitel'nykh knig na Tatarskii i drugie inorodcheskie iazyki v nachale tekushchogo stoleiia , Kazan' : Tipgrafiia Imperatorskogo Universiteta .
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . "O perevode" ” . 14
   Google Scholar
• Chicherina , Sophia . 1910 . O iazyke prepodavanyia v shkolakh dlia vostochnykh inorodtsev , 7 S-Petersburg : Tipografiia V. Ia. Mil'shteina .
   Google Scholar
• Iznoskov , I. "Pamiati Nikolaia Ivanovicha Il'minskogo" ” . In Nikolai Ivanovich Il'minskii 95
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . "Pravoslavnoe bogosluzhenie," and Nikolai I. Il'minskii, "O tserkovnom bogosluzhenii na inorodcheskikh iazykakh" ” . In Nikolai Ivanovich Il'minskii 30 – 40 .
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 63
   Google Scholar
• 1867 . "K voprosu ob ustroistve uchilishch dlia inorodcheskikh detei Kazanskogo uchebnogo okruga" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , April : 75 – 96 . ch. 134
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. 1867 . "Shkola dlia pervonachal'nogo obucheniia detei kreshchenykh Tatar, v Kazani" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , June : 293 – 328 . ch. 134
   Google Scholar
• Neverov , M. 1869 . "K voprosu ob obrazvanii inorodtsev" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , December : 127 M. Neverov uses the term "Il'minskii system." ), ch. 146
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler . Educational Policies 132 – 150 . For the details of the Il'minskii system, see
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 79 – 80 . 177 – 187 . Ibid., p. 84
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. "Ob obrazovanii inorodtsev" ” . In Nikolai Ivanovich Il'minskii 18 – 19 .
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . Pis'ma 223 During the imperial period "Tatar" basically denoted any Muslim living in the Russian empire, but it was more specifically used for the Lithuanian Tatars, Crimean Tatars, Kazan Tatars and the Caucasian Muslims. Russians called today's Kazakhs the "Kyrgyz" and today's Kirgiz "Kara-Kyrgyz." The most general term for the Muslims of sedentary Central Asia was "Sart." One should be careful about this terminology. In particular the word "Tatar" could have different meanings in different contexts. It could mean all the Muslims of the Russian empire in Gaspirah's usage, while it could mean the sedentary Muslims of European Russia in distinction from the nomadic Turkic tribes to their east in a text by Il'minskii
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. 1891 . Vospominaniia ob I. A. Altynsarine , 4 Kazan' : Tipo-Litografiia V. M. Kliuchnikova .
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler , Isabelle Teitz . 1983 . "Ibrahim Altynsarin, Nikolai Il'minskii and the Kazakhh National Awakening" . Central Asian Survey , 2 ( 3 ) : 99 – 116 . I should note that this article suffers from Kreindler's lack of knowledge about the Muslim reform movement that Gaspirah had initiated
   Google Scholar
• Alektorov , A. 1905 . "Iz istorii razvitiia obrazovaniia sredi Kirgizov Akmolinskoi i Semipalatinskoi Oblastei" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , December : 167 – 170 . ch. 342 In his letter to the Minister of Education, dated 17 March 1888, Il'minskii had also praised Altmsarin's schools for their success in bringing the Kazakh and Russian students close to each other. NART, f. 968, op. 1, d. 53
   Google Scholar
• Alektorov . "Iz istorii razvitiia" ” . 187 Jan Amos Komensky was the first known person to systematize and popularize the translative method. He arranged his books in columns with the same text in different languages. Thus the student would learn by comparing the foreign language with his native language. "Comenius, John Amos" Encyclopedia Britannica Online, (accessed 6 April 2001). Il'minskii knew, respected, and quoted Komensky.
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii , Nikolai I. "Besedy narodnoi shkole" ” . In Nikolai Ivanovich Il'minskii 76 – 77 .
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler . Educational Policies 57 – 58 .
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . Vospominaniia 192
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . Pis'ma 247 – 248 . 321 – 322 .
   Google Scholar
• Fisher, Enlightened Despotism.
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . "O primenenii" ” . 9
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler . Educational Policies 58
   Google Scholar
• Baldauf , Ingeborg . 1993 . Schriftreform und Schriftwechsel bei den Muslimischen Russland--und Sowjettürken (1850-1937): ein Symptom Ideengeschichtliher und Kulturpolitischer Entwicklungen , 688 Budapest : Akadémiai Kiado .
   Google Scholar
• Togan , Ahmet Zeki V. 1942-1947 . Bugünki Türkili (Türkistan) ve yakin tarihi , 490 – 491 . Istanbul : Ibrahim Horoz ve Güven Basimevleri .
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler . "Ibrahim Altynsarin" ” . 109
   Google Scholar
• Alektorov . "Iz istorii razvitiia" ” . 168
   Google Scholar
• Togan . Bugünki Türkili 501
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 143 – 145 .
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler . Educational Policies 172
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 173.
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskiiPis'ma, pp. 338-339. Unfortunately Smirnov's letters to Il'minskii (NART, f. 968, op. 1, d. 145) are lost.
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 45 – 46 .
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . Vospominaniia 192
   Google Scholar
• Chicherina . O iazyke prepodavanyia 8
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . Pis'ma 174 – 176 . 218 – 219 . 247 – 248 . 321 – 322 . 410 – 411 . See also: NART, f. 968, op. 1, d. 53
   Google Scholar
• Gasprinskii . Russkoe Musul'manstvo 63 67 – 68 . These articles were later published as a book and reprinted in 1985
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 26.
   Google Scholar
• Kinmli . Kirim Tatarlannda MiIli Kimlik 46 After 1905, he would more frequently use "Turk."
   Google Scholar
• Togan . Bugünki Türkili 555 ismail Bey Gaspirinskiy, Tunguç, 1881
   Google Scholar
• Gasprinskii . Russkoe Musul'manstvo 27 – 31 .
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 42-43, 46, 50, 61.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 59.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 72-73.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 64-65.
   Google Scholar
• Kirimli . Kirim Tatarlannda Millî Kimlik 40
   Google Scholar
• Usmanova , Dilara M. 1996 . "Die Tatarische Presse 1905-1918: Quellen, Entwicklungsetappen und Quantitative Analyse" ” . In Muslim Culture in Russian and Central Asia from the 18th to the Early 20th Centuries , Edited by: Kemper , Michael , von Kügelgen , Anke and Yermakov , Dmitriy . 239 – 278 . Berlin : Klaus Schwarz Verlag .
   Google Scholar
• Bennigsen , Alexandre and Quelquejay , Chantal Lemercier- . 1964 . La presse et le mouvement national chez les musulmans de Russie avant 1920 , Paris : Mouton . Turkistan Vilayeti'nin Gazeti was published in Tashkent for 47 years between 1870 and 1917, but it was an official publication edited by Ostroumov
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . "O primenenii" ” . 6
   Google Scholar
• Kirimli . Kirim Tatarlannda MiIlî Kimlik 48 – 49 .
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 40.
   Google Scholar
• Togan . Bugünki Türkili 556
   Google Scholar
• Ostroumov , Nikolai . 1906 . "Musul'manskie maktaby i russko-tuzemnye shkoly v Turkestanskom krae" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , February : 137 new series, ch. 1
   Google Scholar
• Khalid . The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform 24
   Google Scholar
• Ostroumov . "Musul'manskie maktaby" ” . 130 – 134 .
   Google Scholar
• Lykoshin , N. S. 1916 . Polzhizni v Turkestane 223 – 224 . Petrograd
   Google Scholar
• Ibrahimof , Abdürresid . Tercüme-i Halim , 1905 Kazan For a critique of medrese education from inside, see
   Google Scholar
• Kirimli . Kirim Tatarlarmda Millî Kimlik 53
   Google Scholar
• Lazzerini . Ismail Bey Gasprinskii 185 – 189 . Lazzerini also gives a sample curriculum and classroom plan
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . Pis'ma 396 – 397 . For examples of this usage, see
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii . "O perevode" ” . 2 – 4 .
   Google Scholar
• Il'minskii, Pis 'ma.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 53.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 62-63.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 321.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., p. 322.
   Google Scholar
• Pobedonostsev , Konstantin . "Iz vospominanii o N. I. Il'minskom" ” . In Nikolai Ivanovich Il'minskii 111
   Google Scholar
• Bobrovnikoff , Sophia . 1911 . "Moslems in Russia" . The Moslem World , 1 : 9
   Google Scholar
• Gasprinskii . Russkoe Musul'manstvo 65
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 62 – 84 . On the regulations of 1870
   Google Scholar
• Khalid . The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform 178 – 179 .
   Google Scholar
• Quoted in Ibid., p. 180.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid., pp. 179-180.
   Google Scholar
• Lazzerini , Edward J. 1984 . "From Bahchisarai to Bukhara in 1893: Ismail Bey Gasprinskii's Journey to Central Asia" . Central Asian Survey , 3 ( 4 ) : 77 – 88 . For the details of this trip see
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 174 – 187 . For more on this commission, see
   Google Scholar
• Ostroumov . "K istorii musul'manskogo" ” . 322 – 326 . Altmsarin's system, which used the Kazakh vernacular as the medium of instruction, had a limited usage by 1905. Russo-native schools generally used Russian as the language of instruction
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 178
   Google Scholar
• Miropiev , N. 1908 . "Russko inorodcheskie shkoly sistemy N. I. Il'minskogo" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , February : 183 – 210 . new series, ch. 13
   Google Scholar
• Khalid . The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform 180 See endnote 92. Quoted in
   Google Scholar
• Crews , R. D. 1999 . Allies in God's Command: Muslim Communities and the State in Imperial Russia , Princeton : Princeton University . For the government support to the traditionalists against the reformers; unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 187
   Google Scholar
• Gaspirali , Ismail Bey . 1905 . "Can Yaki DiI Meselesi" . Tercüman , 25 January
   Google Scholar
• Arsharuni , Arshalius and Gabidullin , Khaci . 1931 . Ocherki panislamizma i pantiurkizma v Rossii , 115 – 116 . Moscow : Bezbozhnik . The expression "literaturnyi rodnoi iazyk" in this Russian text is misleading. It is the translation of "edeb millî dil" in Turkish, which Gaspirali used to denote the common language he promoted for the entire Turkic world. Although "literary native language" is the literal translation of "literaturnyi rodnoi iazyk," the correct expression should be "literary national language" for this better gives the meaning of "edebî millî dil."
   Google Scholar
• 1907 . "Ma'arif Kamisiyasi" . Yulduz , 14 September
   Google Scholar
• 1906 . "Qafqaz Müslüman Mu'allimler Meclisiniñ Programi" . Beyan-ül Haq , 23 September
   Google Scholar
• 1906 . "Mu'allimler Cem'iyyetiniñ Vazîfeleri" . Beyan-ül Haq , 15 August
   Google Scholar
• 1906 . Mekârce Ciyunmda Mu'allim ve Skirdler" . Beyan-ül Haq , 24 September
   Google Scholar
• Deliorman , Allan . 1968 . "Ismail Gaspirali ve Tercüman Gazetesi" . Türk Kültürü , 6 ( 69 ) : 655
   Google Scholar
• Lazzerini . Ismail Bey Gasprinskii 51
   Google Scholar
• Zenkovsky , Serge A. 1960 . Pan-Turkism and Islam in Russia , 45 – 51 . Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press .
   Google Scholar
• 1913 . "Vopros o musul'manskoi fraktsii Gosudarstvennoi Dumy" . Mir Islama , 2 ( 2 ) : 101 – 109 .
   Google Scholar
• Ibrahimof , 'Alimcan . 1911 . "Biz Tatarmiz" . Sûrâ , 15 April : 236 – 238 .
   Google Scholar
• Türkoglu . 1911 . "Biz Türkmiz" . Sûrâ, 15 April , : 238 – 241 . Türkoglu would write three more articles under this title in 1912
   Google Scholar
• 1912 . Sûrâ , 1 January : 19 – 21 .
   Google Scholar
• 1912 . Sûrâ , 15 January : 55 – 56 .
   Google Scholar
• 1912 . Sûrâ , 1 February : 79 – 80 .
   Google Scholar
• Türkoglu . 1912 1 February . "Biz Türkmiz" ” . 1912 ,
   Google Scholar
• Türkoglu . 15 January 1912 . "Biz Türkmiz" ” . 15 January ,
   Google Scholar
• Türkoglu . 1 February 1912 . "Biz Türkmiz" ” . 1 February ,
   Google Scholar
• 1911 . "Til ve Imlâ Meselesi" . Sûrâ , 1 February : 79 – 82 .
   Google Scholar
• Cihandarof , Feyzurrahman . 1911 . "Qazaq Mekteblerine Dair" . Sûrâ , 15 February : 92 – 93 .
   Google Scholar
• Ahmed . 1911 . "Her Kimniñ Ana TiIi Özine Qiymetli" . Sûrâ , 15 April : 232 – 233 . Although the period between 1905 and 1917 is the time when the Muslims of Russia most vocally discussed nationalism, territorial or extraterritorial, the precedents of their ideas were present earlier in the mid-nineteenth century in the works of people like Çokan Velixanov, Sihabuddin Mercanî and, as I try to explain in this article, Ismail Bey Gaspirali
   Google Scholar
• 1906 . "'Tercüman' Babamiza Bir Iki Söz" . Beyan-ül Haq , 29 May
   Google Scholar
• 1906 . "Ittifaq ve Islah" . Beyan-ül Haq , 20 September
   Google Scholar
• Velidof , Cemaleddin . 1912 . "Vine Til Meselesi" . Yulduz ,
   Google Scholar
• Gaspirali , Ismail Bey . 1912 . "Lisan Gerek Lisan" . Sûrâ , 1 January : 18 – 19 . Tercüman
   Google Scholar
• Geraci , Robert . 1997 . "Russian Orientalism at an Impasse: Tsarist Education Policy and the 1910 Conference on Islam" ” . In Russia's Orient: Imperial Borderlands and Peoples, 1700-1917 , Edited by: Brower , Daniel R. and Lazzerini , Edward J. 140 Indiana : Indiana University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Znamenskii , Petr . 1910 . Kazanskie Tatary 35 Kazan
   Google Scholar
• McCarthy , Frank T. 1973 . "The Kazan Missionary Congress" . Cahiers du monde russe et sovietique , 14 : 308 – 332 . For the details of this congress, see Geraci, "Russian Orientalism at an Impasse"
   Google Scholar
• 1913 . "K voprosu o panislamizme" . Mir Is lama , : 1 – 12 . and "Pantiurkizm v Rossii," Mir Islama, pp. 13-30
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler . Educational Policies 80
   Google Scholar
• Shatalov , I. 1870 . "Russkii iazyk v inorodcheskoi shkole" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , November : 1 – 21 . ch. 310
   Google Scholar
• Dowler , Wayne . 1995 . "The Politics of Language in Non-Russian Elementary Schools in the Eastern Empire, 1865-1914" . The Russian Review , 54 ( 3 ) : 516 – 538 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Arsharuni , A. "Iz istorii natsional'noi politiki tsarizma" . Krasnyi arkhiv , 4 ( 35 ) 107 – 127 . "Zhurnal osobogo soveshchaniia po vyrabotke mer dlia protivodeistviia tatarsko-musul'manskomu vliianiiu v Privolzhskom krae."
   Google Scholar
• Turdiev , Sherali . "La surette Russe, les maîtres d'école Tatars et le mouvement djadid au Turkestan" . Cahiers du Monde Russe , 37 ( 1-2 ) 211 – 215 .
   Google Scholar
• Khalid . The Politics of Muslim Cultural Reform 182
   Google Scholar
• Dowler . Classroom and Empire 225 – 227 . This was a blow to the Il'minskii system as applied to the baptized inorodtsy too, but it was in harmony with the ideas of the followers of Il'minskii about the Muslims of the empire
   Google Scholar
• Bobrovnikov , Nikolai . 1917 . "Sovremennoe polozhenie uchebnogo dela u inorodcheskikh piemen vostochnoi Rossii" . Zhurnal Ministerstva Narodnogo Prosveshcheniia , May : 51 – 84 . new series, ch. 135
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler . Educational Policies 211 – 213 .
   Google Scholar
• Kreindler , Isabelle Teitz . "A Neglected Source of Lenin's Nationality Policy" . Slavic Review , 36 ( 1 ) 86 – 100 . In this article, Kreindler traces Il'minskii's influence on Lenin's ideas to the personal relationship between a loyal disciple of Il'minskii, I. Ia. lakovlev and Lenin's father. Archival documents reveal that Lenin's father and mother had personally communicated with Il'minskii too. In a letter, dated 28 September 1889, Lenin's mother asks for Il'minskii's help for Lenin's readmission to the Kazan State University. NART, f. 968, op. 1, d. 157
   Google Scholar
• Gellner , Ernest . 1983 . Nations and Nationalism , 53 Oxford : Basil Blackwell Publisher .
   Google Scholar
• Usmanov , Mirkasim A. 1993 . "O triumphe i tragedii idei Gasprinskogo" ” . In Ismail Bei Gasprinskii--Rossiia i vostok , 3 – 15 . Kazan' : Tatarskoe knizhnoe izdatel'stvo .
   Google Scholar
• Chervonnaia , Svetlana M. 2001 . Ismail Gasprinskii--prosvetitel'naraodov Vostoka, k 150-letiiu co dnia rozhdeniia, Materialy Mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii , Moscow : N.I.I, teorii i istorii izobrazitel'nykh iskusstv Rossiiskoi Akademii khudozhestv . For a collection of the summaries of the works presented in this conference, see
   Google Scholar