Romani Migrations and EU Enlargement: Reply to Critics and some Epistemological Considerations for Policy-making

References

• Braham , Mark and Braham , Matthew . 2000 . "Romani Migrations and EU Enlargement," . Cambridge Review of International Affairs , 13 ( 2 ) : 97 – 116 .
   Google Scholar
• Council of Europe . 1999 . Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities , Strasbourg : Council of Europe Publishing . Copenhagen Criteria of the 1993 Copenhagen European Council;
   Google Scholar
• Braham and Braham . "Romani Migrations and EU Enlargement," ” . 99 for a Czech example of the use of this strategy.
   Google Scholar
• Kovats , Martin . 2000 . "Romani Migrations: Strangers in Anybody's Land: Academic Introduction," . Cambridge Review of International Affairs , 13 ( 2 ) : 16
   Google Scholar
• Trehan , Nidhi . 2000 . "Romani Migrations: Addressing Continuing Debates," . Cambridge Review of International Affairs , 13 ( 2 ) : 117
   Google Scholar
• Boulding , Kenneth E. 1962 . Conflict and Defense , New York : Harper Torchbooks . For an analytically rigorous treatment of this problem see
   Google Scholar
• Wright , Erik Ohlin . 2000 . Class Counts , 206 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Kovats . "Romani Migrations," ” . 16
   Google Scholar
• Trehan , Nidhi . "Romani Migrations," ” . 117
   Google Scholar
• Frank , Robert H. , ed. 1997 . Microeconomics and Behavior, , 3rd edn , New York : McGraw-Hill . Note that "rationality" is being used here in a very specific sense of instrumental choice that is utility maximising by being "complete," "transitive" and "consistent." Readers unfamiliar with "rational choice" should refer to any basic text on microeconomics, e.g.
   Google Scholar
• Fraser , Sir Angus . 2000 . 'The Present and Future of the Gypsy Past," . Cambridge Review of International Affairs , 13 ( 2 ) : 17 – 31 . For a detailed discussion of the debate over Romani origins, see
   Google Scholar
• Mirga , Andrzej and Gheorghe , Nicolae . 1997 . The Roma in the Twenty-First Century: A Policy Paper , Princeton : Project on Ethnic Relations .
   Google Scholar
• Braham , Mark and Braham , Matthew . "Romani Migrations and EU Enlargement," ” . 101
   Google Scholar
• Braham , Mark . 1993 . The Untouchables: A Survey of the Roma People of Central and Eastern Europe , Geneva : UNHCR .
   Google Scholar
• European Roma Rights Centre . 2000 . Roma Rights , http://errc.org
   Google Scholar
• Rawls , John . 1971 . A Theory of Justice , Oxford : Oxford University Press . Note the term "generic instruments." These are, abstractly speaking, "social contracts" and in so being must have a high degree of generality if they are to achieve consensus. They therefore by definition exclude the particulars of one culture or another, although they are based on certain presumptions about cultures. Generic instruments are an expression of agreed principles from which policy programmes can be derived. See, for example,
   Google Scholar
• Harsanyi , John C. 1955 . "Cardinal Welfare, Individualistic Ethics, and Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility," . Journal of Political Economy , 63 : 309 – 321 . A similar idea is expressed by
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Harsanyi , John C. 1976 . Essays on Ethics, Social Behavior, and Scientific Explanation , 6 – 23 . Dordrecht : D. Reidel .
   Google Scholar
• Dasgupta , Partha . 2000 . "Valuing Objects and Evaluating Policies in Imperfect Economies," . Economic Journal , May : c1 – c29 . If one could conceive Romani populations to be economic systems, then we would, following Dasgupta, classify them as an "imperfect economies," which he calls a polite term for today's poor countries. These economies are, according to Dasgupta, imperfect in that their institutions and cultural modes are largely dysfunctional because they produce a significantly lower level of social welfare in comparison with the modern capitalist economies of the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) countries. See
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Young , H. Peyton . 1994 . Equity in Theory and Practice , Princeton : Princeton University Press . To avoid any misunderstanding, we are not denigrating people as mere economic agents. What we are saying here is an expression of the ethical principles of impartiality and equality that underpin human rights. In slightly more formal terms, we are implying that a society is fair and just if its institutions do not discriminate against the members of the society except insofar as they differ in type. If a society adheres to the fundamental principles of human rights, "type" is only ability and not race, religion, or creed. See, for example,
   Google Scholar
• Harsanyi , John C. 1969 . "Rational-Choice Models of Political Behavior vs. Functionalist and Conformist Theories," . World Politics , 21 : 513 – 538 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Harsanyi . Essays on Ethics 142
   Google Scholar
• Harsanyi . "Rational Choice Models," ” . 142
   Google Scholar