94
Views
2
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Intention, capability and surprise: A comparative analysis

Pages 19-40 | Published online: 24 Jan 2008

Notes

  • Ben‐Zvi , Abraham . 1976 . ‘Hindsight and Foresight: A Conceptual Framework for the Analysis of Surprise Attacks’ . World Politics , XXVIII ( 3 ) April : 381
  • Wohlstetter , Roberta . 1962 . Pearl Harbor: Warning and Decision , Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press .
  • Ben‐Zvi , Abraham . 1987 . The Illusion of Deterrence: The Roosevelt Presidency and the Origins of the Pacific War , Boulder, CO and London : Westview Press: Studies in International Politics .
  • Wohlstetter . Pearl Harbor 397
  • Stein , Janice Gross . 1988 . ‘Building Politics into Psychology: The Misperception of Threat,’ . Political Psychology , 9 ( 2 ) June : 248 – 9 .
  • Kam , Ephraim . 1988 . Surprise Attack: The Victim's Perspective , 86 – 105 . Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .
  • Jervis , Robert . 1976 . Perception and Misperception in International Politics , 162 – 3 . Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
  • Holsti , Ole R. 1962 . ‘The Belief System and National Images: A Case Study’ . Journal of Conflict Resolution , 6 ( 2 ) Sept. : 245
  • Knorr , Klaus . 1976 . “ ‘Strategic Intelligence: Problems and Remedies’ ” . In Strategic Thought in the Nuclear Age , Edited by: Martin , Lawrence . 78 – 9 . London : Heinemann .
  • Hoist , Johan Jorgen . 1966 . ‘Surprise, Signals and Reaction: The Attack on Norway, April 9, 1940 ‐ Some Observations’ . Cooperation and Conflict , 1 ( 2 ) : 31 – 45 .
  • George , Alexander L. and Smoke , Richard . 1974 . Deterrence in American Foreign Policy: Theory and Practice , New York : Columbia University Press .
  • Wohlstetter , Roberta . 1965 . ‘Cuba and Pearl Harbor: Hindsight and Foresight’ . Foreign Affairs , 43 ( 4 ) July : 699
  • George and Smoke . Deterrence in American Foreign Policy 574
  • Ben‐Zvi , Abraham . 1976–77 . ‘Misperceiving the Role of Perception: A Critique’ . The Jerusalem Journal of International Relations , 2 ( 2 ) Winter : 79
  • Lebow , Richard Ned . 1981 . Between Peace and War: The Nature of International Crisis , Baltimore, MD : The Johns Hopkins University Press .
  • Jervis , Robert , Ned Lebow , Richard and Stein , Janice Gross . 1985 . Psychology and Deterrence , Baltimore, MD : The John Hopkins University Press .
  • Janis , Irving L. and Mann , Leon . 1977 . Decision Making: A Psychological Analysis of Conflict, Choice, and Commitment , New York : Free Press .
  • Jervis , Robert . 1982–83 . ‘Deterrence and Perception’ . International Security , 7 ( 3 ) Winter : 29 – 30 .
  • Stein . “ ‘The Misperception of Threat’ ” . 257 – 9 .
  • Knorr . “ ‘Strategic Intelligence’ ” . 78 – 9 .
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 57 – 97 .
  • idem . “ ’Miscalculation in the South Atlantic: The Origins of the Falklands War’ ” . In Psychology and Deterrence 82 – 124 .
  • idem . 1987 . ’Deterrence Failure Revisited’ . International Security , 12 ( 1 ) Summer : 197 – 8 .
  • Jervis , Robert . “ ‘Perceiving and Coping with Threat,’ ” . In Psychology and Deterrence 24 – 7 .
  • Pipes , Richard . 1981 . “ ‘American Perceptions and Misperceptions of Soviet Military Intentions and Capabilities’ ” . In Intelligence Policy and National Security , Edited by: Pfaltzgraff , Robert L. Jr. , Ra'anan , Uri and Milberg , Warren . 78 London : Macmillan .
  • Jervis . “ ‘Deterrence and Perception’ ” . 14
  • idem . 1979 . ’Deterrence Theory Revisited’ . World Politics , XXXI ( 2 ) Jan. : 296 – 9 .
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Misperceiving the Role of Perception’ ” . 90
  • Jervis . “ ‘Perceiving and Coping with Threat’ ” . 33
  • Betts , Richard K. 1982 . Surprise Attack: Lessons for Defense Planning , 114 – 18 . 145 – 9 . Washington, DC : The Brookings Institution .
  • Jervis , Robert . 1986 . ‘Representativeness in Foreign Judgements’ . Political Psychology , 7 ( 3 ) : 485 – 6 .
  • idem . “ ’Perceiving and Coping With Threat’ ” . 27 – 33 .
  • Levite , Ariel . 1989 . Intelligence and Strategic Surprises , New York : Columbia University Press .
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Misperceiving the Role of Perception’ ” . 89 – 96 .
  • Jervis , Robert . 1988 . ‘War and Misperception’ . Journal of Interdisciplinary History , XVIII ( 4 ) Spring : 676
  • Levite , Ariel . 1989 . ‘Intelligence and Strategic Surprises Revisited: A Response to Richard K. Betts’ “Surprise, Scholasticism, and Strategy'” . International Studies Quarterly , 33 ( 3 ) Sept. : 346 – 7 .
  • idem . Intelligence and Strategic Surprises 3 27 151
  • George , Alexander L. and Smoke , Richard . 1989 . ‘Deterrence and Foreign Policy’ . World Politics , XLI ( 2 ) Jan. : 171
  • George , Alexander L. 1979 . “ ‘Case Studies and Theory Development: The Method of Structured, Focused Comparison’ ” . In Diplomacy: New Approaches in History, Theory, and Policy , Edited by: Lauren , Paul Gordon . 44 – 5 . 50 – 51 . New York : Free Press .
  • Eckstein , Harry . 1975 . “ ‘Case Studies and Theory in Political Science’ ” . In Handbook of Political Science , Edited by: Greenstein , Fred I. and Polsby , Nelson W. Vol.7 , 99 Reading, MA : Addison‐Wesley .
  • George . “ ‘Case Studies and Theory Development’ ” . 45
  • Eckstein . “ ‘Case Studies and Theory’ ” . 99 – 104 .
  • Hoffmann , Steven A. 1972 . ‘Anticipation, Disaster and Victory: India 1962–72’ . Asian Survey , XII Nov. : 967 – 8 .
  • Mullik , B.N. 1971 . The Chinese Betrayal , 329 – 30 . Bombay : Allied Publishers .
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 166
  • Vertzberger , Yaacov V.I. 1984 . Misperceptions in Foreign Policymaking: The Sino‐Indian Conflict, 1959–1962 , 124 134 – 6 . 161 195 – 201 . Boulder, CO : Westview Press .
  • idem . 1982 . ’India's Strategic Posture and the Border War Defeat of 1962: a Case Study in Miscalculation’ . Journal of Strategic Studies , 5 ( 3 ) Sept. : 377
  • Orme , John . 1987 . ‘Deterrence Failures: A Second Look’ . International Security , 11 ( 4 ) Spring : 116 – 18 .
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Hindsight and Foresight’ ” . 386
  • Stein , Janice Gross . 1980 . ‘"Intelligence and Stupidity” Reconsidered: Estimation and Decision in Israel, 1973’ . The Journal of Strategic Studies , 3 ( 3 ) Sept. : 151
  • idem . “ ’Calculation, Miscalculation and Conventional Deterrence II: The View from Jerusalem’ ” . In Psychology and Deterrence 64
  • Knorr , Klaus . 1976 . “ ‘Threat Perception’ ” . In Historical Dimensions of National Security Problems , 97 – 8 . Lawrence, KS : University Press of Kansas . in idem
  • Mullik . The Chinese Betrayal 330
  • Orme . “ ‘Deterrence Failures’ ” . 116
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Hindsight and Foresight’ ” . 392
  • Vertzberger . Misperceptions in Foreign Policymaking 200
  • Kam . Surprise Attack 59 62
  • Handel , Michael I. 1984 . ‘Intelligence and the Problem of Strategic Surprise’ . Journal of Strategic Studies , 7 ( 3 ) Sept. : 239
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Hindsight and Foresight’ ” . 386
  • Levite . Intelligence and Strategic Surprises 27
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Hindsight and Foresight’ ” . 386
  • Handel . “ ‘Intelligence and the Problem of Strategic Surprise’ ” . 239
  • Patchen , Martin . 1988 . Resolving Disputes Between Nations: Coercion or Conciliation? , 64 – 6 . Durham, NC : Duke University Press . London
  • Jervis , Robert . 1986 . “ ‘Cognition and Political Behavior’ ” . In Political Cognition , Edited by: Lau , Richard and Sears , David . 331 – 2 . Potomak, MD : Earlbaum .
  • Vertzberger . Misperceptions in Foreign Policymaking 195
  • idem . “ ’India's Strategic Posture’ ” . 377
  • Idem . “ ’India's Strategic Posture’ ” . 377
  • Idem . Misperceptions in Foreign Policymaking 195
  • Mullik . The Chinese Betrayal 341
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Hindsight and Foresight’ ” . 384
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Jerusalem’ ” . 64 66 – 8 .
  • Kam . Surprise Attack 79
  • Handel , Michael I. 1976 . Perception, Deception and Surprise: The Case of the Yom Kippur War , Jerusalem Papers on Peace Problems, No.19 20 – 27 .
  • 10 Aug. 1973 . Ma'ariv 10 Aug. , Tel Aviv
  • Kam . Surprise Attack 79
  • Vertzberger . “ ‘India's Strategic Posture,’ ” . 389
  • Knorr . “ ‘Threat Perception’ ” . 98 – 9 .
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Misperceiving the Role of Perception,’ ” . 88
  • Handel . Perception, Deception and Surprise 38 51 – 2 .
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Jerusalem,’ ” . 77
  • Patchen . Resolving Disputes Between Nations 67
  • Knorr , Klaus . 1964 . ‘Failures in National Intelligence Estimates: The Case of the Cuban Missiles,’ . World Politics , XVI ( 3 ) April : 462
  • Jervis , Robert . 1986–87 . ‘Intelligence and Foreign Policy’ . International Security , 11 ( 3 ) Winter : 158
  • George and Smoke . Deterrence in American Foreign Policy 581
  • Levite . Intelligence and Strategic Surprises 27
  • Handel . “ ‘Intelligence and the Problem of Strategic Surprise’ ” . 239
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Hindsight and Foresight’ ” . 387
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 165 – 6 .
  • Hoffmann . “ ‘Anticipation, Disaster, and Victory’ ” . 962 – 3 .
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 189
  • Gupta , Karunakar . 1969 . India in World Politics: A Period of Transition , 164 – 5 . Calcutta : Scientific Books .
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 190
  • Mullik . The Chinese Betrayal 300
  • Hoffmann . “ ‘Anticipation, Disaster, and Victory’ ” . 967
  • Mullik . The Chinese Betrayal 329 – 30 .
  • Hoffmann . “ ‘Anticipation, Disaster, and Victory’ ” . 968
  • Vertzberger . Misperceptions in Foreign Policymaking 201
  • Mullik . The Chinese Betrayal 349
  • Jervis , Robert . 1970 . The Logic of Images in International Relations , 18 – 40 . Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 221
  • Vertzberger . Misperceptions in Foreign Policymaking 149
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Hindsight and Foresight’ ” . 386
  • Hoffmann . “ ‘Anticipation, Disaster and Victory’ ” . 963
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 165
  • Whiting , Alan S. 1975 . The Chinese Calculus of Deterrence: India and Indochina , 55 – 136 . Ann Arbor, MI : University of Michigan Press .
  • Segal , Gerald . 1985 . Defending China , 143 London : Oxford University Press .
  • Whiting . The Chinese Calculus of Deterrence 58 – 9 .
  • Vertzberger . Misperceptions in Foreign Policy making 200
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 190
  • Maxwell , Neville . 1972 . India's China War , 247 – 50 . Garden City, NY : Doubleday .
  • Vertzberger . Misperceptions in Foreign Policy making 200 – 201 .
  • Whiting . The Chinese Calculus of Deterrence 104
  • Vertzberger . Misperceptions in Foreign Policymaking 280
  • Whiting . The Chinese Calculus of Deterrence 20
  • Orme . “ ‘Deterrence Failures’ ” . 117
  • Whiting . The Chinese Calculus of Deterrence 23
  • Orme . “ ‘Deterrence Failures’ ” . 117
  • Whiting . The Chinese Calculus of Deterrence 48
  • Maxwell . India's China War 240 – 42 .
  • Vetzberger . Misperceptions in Foreign Policymaking 133
  • Lebow . Between Peace and War 191
  • Hoffmann . “ ‘Anticipation, Disaster, and Victory’ ” . 965
  • Hoffmann . “ ‘Anticipation, Disaster, and Victory’ ” . 966
  • Handel , Michael I. 1983 . “ ‘Crisis and Surprise in Three Arab‐Israeli Wars’ ” . In Strategic Military Surprise: Incentives and Opportunities , Edited by: Knorr , Klaus and Morgan , Patrick . 138 – 9 . New Brunswick, NJ : Transaction Books .
  • Levite . Intelligence and Strategic Surprises 27
  • Jervis . “ ‘Cognition and Political Behavior’ ” . 331 – 2 .
  • Handel . “ ‘Crisis and Surprise’ ” . 138 – 9 .
  • Perlmutter , Amos . 1975 . ‘Israel's Fourth War October 1973: Political and Military Misperceptions’ . Orbis , XIX ( 2 ) Summer : 452 – 3 .
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Hindsight and Foresight’ ” . 393 – 4 .
  • Shlaim , Avi . 1976 . ‘Failures in National Intelligence Estimates: The Case of the Yom Kippur War’ . World Politics , 28 ( 3 ) April : 353 – 354 .
  • Gilboa , Amos . 1989 . ‘Conceptual Rigidity’ . Ma'ariv , 17 Nov.
  • Schiff , Zeev . 17 Nov. 1989 . “ ‘A Different Conception’ ” . In Ha'aretz 17 Nov. , Tel‐Aviv
  • Morgan , Patrick . “ ‘The opportunity for Strategic Surprise’ ” . In Strategic Military Surprise 208 – 9 .
  • Bartov , Hanoch . 1978 . Dado ‐ 48 years and 20 days , Vol.1 , 243 Tel Aviv : Ma'ariv Book Guild . 2 Vols. (in Hebrew)
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Misperceiving the Role of Perception’ ” . 86 – 7 .
  • Betts . Surprise 74 – 5 .
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Jerusalem’ ” . 73
  • idem . “ ‘The 1973 Intelligence Failure’ ” . 47
  • Zamir , Zvi . 24 Nov. 1989 . “ ‘The Chief of Staff did not perceive the Warning’ ” . In Yedioth Ahronoth 24 Nov. , Tel‐Aviv
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Jerusalem’ ” . 74
  • Betts . Surprise 75
  • Handel . Perception, Deception and Surprise 35 – 6 .
  • Kam . Surprise Attack 103
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Jerusalem’ ” . 74
  • Handel . Perception, Deception and Surprise 35
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Jerusalem’ ” . 74
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Misperceiving the Role of Perception’ ” . 87
  • Herzog , Chaim . 1975 . The War of Atonement , 62 Tel‐Aviv : Steimatzky .
  • Handel . Perception, Deception and Surprise 35 – 6 .
  • Kam . Surprise Attack 33 – 4 .
  • Handel . Perception, Deception and Surprise 37
  • Nakdimon , Shlomo . 1989 . ‘Had Golda Meir Been Informed’ . Yedioth Ahronoth , 19 Nov.
  • Nakdimon , Shlomo . 1989 . ‘Intelligence Which Prime Minister Meir Received Before Yom Kippur’ . Yedioth Ahronoth , 8 Oct.
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Jerusalem’ ” . 77
  • April 1974 . The Agranat Report: A Partial Report by the Commission of Inquiry to the Government of Israel , April , 24 Jerusalem : Government Press Office .
  • Perlmutter . “ ‘Israel's Fourth War” . 455 – 7 . 460
  • Herzog . The War of Atonement 53
  • Ben‐Zvi . “ ‘Misperceiving the Role of Perception’ ” . 88
  • Kam . Surprise Attack 28 – 36 .
  • Morgan . “ ‘The Opportunity for Strategic Surprise’ ” . 199
  • Kam . Surprise Attack 33
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Jerusalem’ ” . 80 86
  • idem . ’Calculation, Miscalculation, and Conventional Deterrence: The View from Cairo’ . Psychology and Deterrence , 46
  • Kam . Surprise Attack 77 – 82 .
  • Stein . “ ‘The View from Cairo’ ” . 46 – 7 .
  • idem . 1982 . ‘The 1973 Intelligence Failure: A Reconsideration’ . The Jerusalem Quarterly , Summer : 47
  • Bartov , Hanoch . 1989 . ‘The Gamble Behind the Debacle’ . Ma'ariv , 10 Nov.
  • Whaley , Barton . 1973 . Codeword Barbarossa , 216 Cambridge, MA : MIT Press .
  • Chan , Steve . 1979 . ‘The Intelligence of Stupidity: Understanding Failures in Strategic Warning’ . American Political Science Review , 73 ( 1 ) March : 178 – 180 .
  • Levite . Intelligence and Strategic Surprises 153 158
  • Meir , Golda . 1975 . My Life , 426 – 7 . New York : Putnam .
  • Perlmutter . “ ‘Israel's Fourth War, October 1973’ ” . 452 – 3 . 458
  • Dayan , Moshe . 1976 . The Story of My Life , 575 – 8 . Tel‐Aviv : Dvir . Hebrew
  • May , Ernest R. 1984 . Knowing One's Enemies: Intelligence Assessment Before the Two World Wars , 505 – 41 . Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
  • Morgan . “ ‘The opportunity for Strategic Surprise’ ” . 236
  • Levite . “ ‘Intelligence and Strategic Surprises Revisited’ ” . 135 – 68 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.