Does empathy change during undergraduate medical education? – A meta-analysis*

References

• Bangash A, Ali N, Shehzad A, Haqqi S. 2013. Maintenance of empathy levels among first and final year medical students: a cross sectional study. F1000Res. 2:157.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Baron-Cohen S, Wheelwright S. 2004. The empathy quotient: an investigation of adults with asperger syndrome or high functioning autism, and normal sex differences. J Autism Dev Disord.Disord. 34:163–175.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Beckman HB, Frankel RM. 1984. The effect of physician behavior on the collection of data. Ann Intern Med. 101:692–696.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bellet PS, Maloney MJ. 1991. The importance of empathy as an interviewing skill in medicine. JAMA. 226:1831–1832.
   Google Scholar
• Berg K, Blatt B, Lopreiato J, Jung J, Schaeffer A, Heil D, Owens T, Carter-Nolan PL, Berg D, Veloski J, et al. 2015. Standardized patient assessment of medical student empathy: ethnicity and gender effects in a multi-institutional study. Acad Med. 90:105–111.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Berg K, Majdan JF, Berg D, Veloski J, Hojat M. 2011. Medical students’ self-reported empathy and simulated patients’ assessments of student empathy: an analysis by gender and ethnicity. Acad Med. 86:984–988.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Borenstein M, Hedges L, Higgins J, Rothstein H. 2005. Comprehensive meta-9 analysis (Version 3.3) Emglewood (NJ): Biostat.
   Google Scholar
• Canale SD, Louis DZ, Maio V, Wang X, Rossi G, Hojat M, Gonnella JS. 2012. The relationship between physician empathy and disease complications: an empirical study of primary care physicians and their diabetic patients in Parma, Italy. Acad Med. 87:1243–1249.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chen DC, Kirshenbaum DS, Yan J, Kirshenbaum E, Aseltine RH. 2012. Characterizing changes in student empathy throughout medical school. Med Teach. 34:305–311.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chen D, Lew R, Hershman W, Orlander J. 2007. A cross-sectional measurement of medical student empathy. J Gen Intern Med. 22:1434–1438.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Chen DCR, Pahilan ME, Orlander JD. 2010. Comparing a self-administered measure of empathy with observed behaviour among medical students. J Gen Intern Med. 25:200–202.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Cohen J. 1992. A power primer. Psychol Bull. 112:155–159.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Costa P, de Carvalho-Filho AM, Schweller M, Thiemann P, Salgueira A, Benson J, Costa MJ, Quince T. 2017. Measuring medical students’ empathy: exploring the underlying constructs of and associations between two widely used self-report instruments in five countries. Acad Med. 92:860–867.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Costa P, Magalhaes E, Costa MJ. 2013. A talent growth model suggests that empathy of medical students does not decline over time. Adv in Health Sci Educ. 18:509–522.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Cowley C. 2006. Polemic: five proposals for a medical school admission policy. J Med Ethics. 32:491–494.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Davis MH. 1983. Measuring individual differences in empathy: Evidence for a multidimensional approach. J Pers Soc Psychol. 44:113–126.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Davis DA, Mazmanian PE, Fordis M, Harrison RV, Thorpe KE, Perrier L. 2006. Accuracy of physician self-assessment compared with observed measures of competence: a systematic review. JAMA. 296:1094–1102.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Decety J, Yoder K. 2016. Empathy and motivation for justice: cognitive empathy and concern, but not emotional empathy, predict sensitivity to injustice for others. Soc Neurosci. 11:1–14.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dehning S, Girma E, Gasperi S, Meyer S, Tesfaye M, Siebeck M. 2012. Comparative cross-sectional study of empathy amongfirst year and final year medical students in Jimma University, Ethiopia: steady state of the heart and opening eyes. BMC Med Educ. 12:34.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dixon DM, Sweeney KG, Gray D. 1999. The physician healer: ancient magic or modern science? Br J Gen Pract. 49:309–312.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Domes G, Heinrichs M, Michel A, Berger C, Herpertz SC. 2007. Oxytocin improves ‘mind-reading’; in humans. Biol Psychiatry. 61:731–733.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Eva KW, Regehr G. 2005. Self-assessment in the health professions: a reformulation and research agenda. Acad Med. 80:46–54.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Goobers L, Craig KD, Vervoort T, Morley S, Sullivan MJL, de C Williams AC, Cano A, Crombez G. 2005. Facing others in pain: the effects of empathy. Pain 118:285–288.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hallerback MU, Lugnegard T, Hjarthag F, Gillberg C. 2009. The reading the mind in the eyes test: test-retest reliability of a Swedish version. Cogn Neuropsychiatry. 14:127–143.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Harkness KL, Washburn D, Theriault JE, Lee L, Sabbagh MA. 2011. Maternal history of depression is associated with enhanced theory of mind in depressed and nondepressed adult women. Psychiatry Res. 189:91–96.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hemmerdinger JM, Stoddart SDR, Lilford R. 2007. A systematic review of tests of empathy in medicine. BMC Med Educ. 7:24.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Higgins J, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG. 2003. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. Bmj. 327:557–560.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hirsh P, Walters L, Poncelet AN. 2012. Better learning, better doctors, better delivery system: possibilities from a case study of longitudinal integrated clerkships. Med Teach. 34:548–554.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hojat M. 2007. Empathy in patient care: antecedents, development, measurement and outcomes. New York (NY): Springer–Verlag.
   Google Scholar
• Hojat M, Gonnella JS. 2017. What matters more about the Interpersonal Reactivity Index and the Jefferson Scale of Empathy? Their underlying constructs or their relationships with pertinent measures of clinical competence and patient outcomes. Acad Med. 92:743–745.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hojat M, Louis DZ, Markham FW, Wender R, Rabinowitz C, Gonnella JS. 2011. Physicians’ empathy and clinical outcomes for diabetic patients. Acad Med. 86:359–364.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hojat M, Mangione S, Nasca TJ, Cohen MJM, Gonnella JS, Erdmann JB, Veloski J, Magee M. 2001. The Jefferson Scale of Physician Empathy: development and preliminary psychometric data. Educ Psychol Meas. 61:349–365.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hojat M, Mangione S, Nasca TJ, Gonnella JS, Magee M. 2005. Empathy scores in medical school and ratings of empathetic behavior in residency training 3 years later. J Soc Psychol. 145:663–672.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hojat M, Mangione S, Nasca TJ, Rattner S, Erdmann JB, Gonnella JS, Magee M. 2004. An empirical study of decline in empathy in medical school. Med Educ. 38:934–941.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hojat M, Vergare M, Maxwell K, Brainard G, Herrine S, Isenberg G, Veloski J, Gonnella J. 2009. The devil is in the third year: a longitudinal study of erosion of empathy in medical school. Acad Med. 84:1182–1191.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Horvath AO. 1991. Relationship between working alliance and outcome in psychotherapy: a meta-analysis. J Consult Clin Psychol. 38:139–149.
   Google Scholar
• Humayun A, Herbert M. 2011. Towards behavioural sciences in undergraduate training: a core curriculum. J Pak Med Assoc. 61:800–807.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Igde FA, Sahin MK. 2017. Changes in empathy during medical education: an example from Turkey. Pak J Med Sci. 33:1177–1181.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Imran N, Aftab MA, Haider II, Farhat A. 2013. Educating tomorrow’s doctors: a cross sectional survey of emotional intelligence and empathy in medical students of Lahore. Pak J Med Sci. 29:710–714.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Khademalhosseini M, Khademalhosseini Z, Mahmoodian F. 2014. Comparison of empathy score among medical students in both basic and clinical levels. J Adv Med Educ Prof. 2:88–91.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Krupat E, Pelletier S, Alexander EK, Hirsh P, Ogur B, Schwartzstein R. 2009. Can changes in the principal clinical year prevent the erosion of students patient-centered beliefs? Acad Med. 84:582–586.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Krupnick JL, Sotsky SM, Simmens S, Moyer J, Elkin I, Watkins J, Pilkonis PA. 1996. The role of the therapeutic alliance in psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy outcome: findings in the National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research programme. J Consult Clin Psychol. 64:532–539.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lawrence EJ, Shaw P, Baker D, Baron-Cohen S, David AS. 2004. Empathy: reliability and validity of the Empathy Quotient. Psychol Med. 34:911–919.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lewis JR. 1994. Patient views on quality care in general practice: literature review. Soc Sci Med. 39:655–671.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lipsey MW, Wilson DB. 2001. Practical meta-analysis. Thousand Oaks (CA): Sage.
   Google Scholar
• Magalhães E, Salgueira A, Costa P, Costa M. 2011. Empathy in senior year and first year medical students: a cross-sectional study. BMC Med Educ. 11:52.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Maurage P, Grynberg D, Noël X, Joassin F, Hanak C, Verbanck P, Luminet O, de Timary P, Campanella S, Philippot P. 2011. The “Reading the Mind in the Eyes” test as a new way to explore complex emotions decoding in alcohol dependence. Psychiatry Res. 190:375–378.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McMillan LR, Shannon DM. 2011. Psychometric analysis of the JSPE nursing student version R: comparison of senior BSN students and medical students attitudes toward empathy in patient care. Int Sch REs Netw Nurs. 2011:1–7.
   Google Scholar
• Mehrabian A. 2000. Manual for the balanced emotional empathy scale (BEES). Monterey (CA): Albert Mehrabian.
   Google Scholar
• Mercer SW, Watt GCM, Reilly D. 2001. Empathy is important for enablement. BMJ. 322:865.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Mitchell A, Cormack M. 1998. The therapeutic relationship in complementary healthcare. London, UK: Churchill Livingstone.
   Google Scholar
• Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. 2009. the PRISMA group preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 6:e1000097.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Morling B, Lamoreaux M. 2008. Measuring culture outside the head: a meta-analysis of individualism-collectivism in cultural products. Pers Soc Psychol Rev. 12:199–221.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Muncer SJ, Ling J. 2006. Psychometric analysis of the empathy quotient (EQ) scale. Pers Individ Differ. 40:1111–1119.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• National Institutes of Health. 2001. Quality assessment tool for observational cohort and cross-sectional studies. [accessed 2001 Feb 01]. https://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health-pro/guidelines/in-develop/cardiovascular-risk-reduction/tools/cohort
   Google Scholar
• Neumann M, Edelhäuser F, Tauschel D, Fischer MR, Wirtz M, Woopen C, Haramati A, Scheffer C. 2011. Empathy decline and its reasons: a systematic review of studies with medical students and residents. Acad Med. 86:996–1009.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Newton BW, Barber L, Clardy J, Cleveland E, O’Sullivan P. 2008. Is there hardening of the heart during medical school? Acad Med. 83:244–249.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Paro HB, Silveira PS, Perotta B, Gannam S, Enns SC, Giaxa RR. 2014. Empathy among medical students: is there a relation with quality of life and burnout? PLoS One. 9:94133.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Platt FW. 1992. Empathy: can it be taught? Ann Intern Med. 117:700.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Quince T, Parker R, Wood D, Benson J. 2011. Stability of empathy among undergraduate medical students: a longitudinal study at one UK medical school. BMC Med Educ. 11:90.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ragsdale G, Foley RA. 2011. A maternal influence on Reading the mind in the Eyes mediated by executive function: differential parental influences on full and half-siblings. PLoS One. 6:e23236.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rees-Lewis JC. 1994. Patients viwes on quality care in general practice: literature review Soc Sci Med. 39:655–671.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Reynolds WJ. 2000. The measurement and development of empathy in nursing, 1st ed. Burlington (MA): Ashgate Pub Ltd.
   Google Scholar
• Roff S. 2015. Reconsidering the “decline” of medical student empathy as reported in studies using Jefferson scale of Physician Empathy. Med Teach. 37:783–786.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosenthal R. 1979. The “file drawer problem” and tolerance for null results. 10 Psychol Bull. 86:638–641.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rothschild B, Rand ML. 2006. Help for the helper: the psychophysiology of compassion fatigue and vicarious trauma. New York (NY): W. W. Norton Company.
   Google Scholar
• Rothstein H, Sutton AJ, Borenstein M. 2005. Publication bias in meta-analysis: prevention, assessment and adjustments. Chichester, England; Hoboken (NJ): Wiley.
   Google Scholar
• Scargle J. 2000. Publication bias: the "file-drawer" problem in scientific inference. J Sci Explor. 14:91–106.
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt FL, Oh IS, Hayes TL. 2009. Fixed-versus random effects models in 18 meta-analysis: model properties and an empirical comparison of differences in results. Brit J Math Stat Psychol. 62:97–128.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sedgwick P. 2013. Meta-analyses: how to read a funnel plot. BMJ. 346:f1342.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Shamay-Tsoory S. 2009. Empathic processing: Its cognitive and affective dimensions and neuroanatomical basis. In: Decety J, Ickes W, editors. The social neuroscience of empathy. Cambridge (MA): MIT Press; p. 215–232.
   Google Scholar
• Shashikumar R, Chaudhary R, Ryali V, Bhat C, Srivastava K, Prakash J, Basannar D. 2014. Cross sectional assessment of empathy among undergraduates from medical college. Med J Armed Forces Ind. 70:179–185.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Singer T, Lamm C. 2009. The social neuroscience of empathy. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 1156:81–96.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Smith KE, Norman GJ, Decety J. 2017. The complexity of empathy during medical school training: evidence for positive changes. Med Educ. 51:1146–1159.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Spector PE. 2006. Method variance in organizational research: truth or urban legend? Org Res Meth.9:221–232.
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Stansfield RB, Schwartz A, O’Brien CL, Dekhtyar M, Dunham L, Quirk M. 2016. Development of a metacognitive effort construct of empathy during clinical training: a longitudinal study of the factor structure of the Jefferson Scale of Empathy. Adv in Health Sci Educ. 21:5–17.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sterne JAC, Sutton AJ, Ioannidis JPA, Terrin N, Jones DR, Lau J, Carpenter J, Rucker G, Harbord RM, Schmid CH, et al. 2011. Recommendations for examining and interpreting funnel plot asymmetry in meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials. BMJ. 343:d4002. DOI:10.1136/bmj.d4002
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Usherwood T. 1999. Understanding the consultation: evidence, theory and practice. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
   Google Scholar
• Walker KM, Alligood MR. 2001. Empathy from a nursing perspective: moving beyond borrowed theory. Arch Psychiatr Nurs. 15:140–147.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ward M, Gruppen L, Regehr G. 2002. Measuring self-assessment: current state of the art. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. 7:63–80.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Williams B, Sadasivan S, Kadirvelu A. Malaysian 2015. Medical students’ self-reported empathy: a cross-sectional comparative study. Med J Malay. 70:76–80.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Yu J, Kirk M. 2009. Evaluation of empathy measurement tools in nursing: systematic review. J Adv Nurs. 65:1790–1806.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Zeighami R, Rafiie F, Parvizi S. 2012 Concept analysis of empathy in nursing. J Qual Res Health Sci. 1:27–33.
   Google Scholar
• Zeldow PB, Daugherty SR. 1987. The stability and attitudinal correlates of warmth and caring in medical students. Med Educ. 21:353–357.
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar