Contesting civil society: Reflections from El Salvador

References

• Chambers , R . 1997 . 'Editorial: responsible well-being--a personal agenda for development' . Worm Development , 25 (11) : 1743 – 1754 . In a discussion of the changing vocabulary and language of development lexicon, Robert Chambers identifies 'civil society' as a term which has 'come close to the mainstream of much development discourse during the past two decades' (p 1744). He also includes it in his table on 'Development vocabulary' as a 'domain' or 'dimension' (p 1745)
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• UNDP . 1997 . Human Development Report , 115 New York : Oxford University Press . The UNDP and World Bank also include civil society in their recent development reports. For example, the UNDP views national and international civil society as 'major players' in the quest for eradicating poverty. See
   Google Scholar
• World Bank . 1997 . World Development Report , 160 New York : Oxford University Press . In turn, the World Bank sees civil society as important in preventing anarchy and as major 'pillar' in the relationship between state and society
   Google Scholar
• McIlwaine , C . 1998 . 'Civil society and development geography' . Progress in Human Geography , 22 (3) : 415 – 424 . The conceptual section of this paper draws on an earlier review of the literature
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pearce , J . 1997 . 'Civil society, the market and democracy in Latin America' . Democratization , 4 : 57 – 83 . The aphorism 'All things to all people' was first used by Pearce to describe the variations inherent in the term civil society
   Google Scholar
• Cohen , J and Arato , A . 1992 . Civil Society and Political Theory , Cambridge , MA : Massachusetts Institute of Technology . For discussions on the history of the concept
   Google Scholar
• Keane , J . 1988 . Democracy and Civil Society , London : Verso .
   Google Scholar
• Tester , K . 1992 . Civil Society , London : Routledge .
   Google Scholar
• Shils , E . 1991 . 'The virtue of civil society' . Government and Opposition , 26 : 3 – 20 . Edward Shils points out that the term was originally used in ancient jurisprudence, and had a 'fluctuating presence' in mediaeval political philosophy. While also used in the 17th century to describe 'a condition in which men (sic) lived under government', not until the 18th century did the term civil society evolve into one close to its current usage, largely through the work of Adam Ferguson. In the 19th century civil society was widely debated by Hegel, then Marx, as well as Gramsci, whose interpretations still colour discussions of the term today
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Fine , R and Rai , S . 1997 . 'Understanding civil society: a preface' . Democratization , 4 : 1 – 6 .
   Google Scholar
• Pearce, 'Civil society, the market and democracy in Latin America'.
   Google Scholar
• Robinson , M . 1995 . 'strengthening civil society in Africa: the role of foreign political aid' . IDS Bulletin , 26 : 70 – 80 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Blaney , D L and Pasha , M K . 1993 . 'Civil society and democracy in the Third World: ambiguities and historical possibilities' . Studies in Comparative International Development , 28 : 3 – 24 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• White , G . 1994 . 'Civil society, democratization and development (1) Clearing the analytical ground' . Democratization , 1 : 375 – 90 .
   Google Scholar
• Pearce , J . “ 'Between co-option and irrelevance? Latin American NGOS in the 1990s' ” . In NGOS, States and Donors: Too Close For Comfort? , Edited by: Hulme , D and Edwards , M . Basingstoke : Macmillan . Pearce, 'Civil society, the market and democracy in Latin America'
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . Children Fund , : 257 – 274 .
   Google Scholar
• Ndegwa , S N . 1996 . The Two Faces of Civil Society: NGOs and Politics in Africa , West Hartford , CT : Kumarian Press .
   Google Scholar
• White , G , Howell , J and Xiaoyuan , S . 1996 . In Search of Civil Society: Institutional Change in Contemporary China , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Schwedler , J . 1995 . Toward Civil Society in the Middle East? A Primer , Boulder , CO : Lynne Rienner .
   Google Scholar
• Haynes , J . 1996 . Democracy and Civil Society in the Third World: Politics and New Political Movements , Cambridge : Polity Press . who points out: 'The term "civil society" has crept quietly and largely unexamined into the literature on political economy in the Third World over the last decade' (p 16) See also Bebbington and Riddell who consider civil society 'a notoriously slippery concept' (p 108)
   Google Scholar
• Bebbington , A and Riddell . 1997 . “ 'Heavy hands, hidden hands, holding hands? Donors, intermediary NGOS and civil society organisations' ” . In NGOS, States and Donors Edited by: Hulme and Edwards . 107 – 127 .
   Google Scholar
• Hadenius , A and Uggla , F . 1996 . 'Making civil society work, promoting democratic development: what can states and donors do?' . Worm Development , 24 : 1621 – 1639 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Haynes . Democracy and Civil Society in the Third World 16
   Google Scholar
• Held , D . 1995 . Democracy and the Global Order , 181 Cambridge : Polity .
   Google Scholar
• Diamond , L . 1994 . 'Toward democratic consolidation: rethinking civil society' . Journal of Democracy , 5 : 4 – 17 .
   Google Scholar
• Foley , M W and Edwards , B . 1996 . 'The paradox of civil society' . Journal of Democracy , 7 : 38 – 52 . for discussions of these issues
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• UNDP . 1993 . Human Development Report 1993 , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Macdonald , L . 1997 . Supporting Civil Society: The Political Role of Non-Governmental Organizations in Central America , Basingstoke : Macmillan . who define the activities of civil society in this broad manner
   Google Scholar
• Hadenius and Uggla . “ 'Making civil society work' ” . 1621
   Google Scholar
• Pearce, 'Civil society, the market and democracy in Latin America'.
   Google Scholar
• Blair , H . “ Donors, democratisation and civil society: relating theory to practice' ” . In NGOs States and Donors Edited by: Hulme and Edwards . 23 – 42 .
   Google Scholar
• Clark , J . “ 'The state, popular participation and the voluntary sector' ” . In NGOS, States and Donors Edited by: Edwards . 43 – 58 .
   Google Scholar
• Lehmann , D . 1990 . Democracy and Development in Latin America , Cambridge : Polity Press . See Ndegwa, The Two Faces of Civil Society, on the African case; on Latin America
   Google Scholar
• Fine , R . 1997 . 'Civil society theory, Enlightenment and critique' . Democratization , 4 : 7 – 28 . See also Foley & Edwards, 'The paradox of civil society'
   Google Scholar
• The distinction between civil society as concept and as theory is made by both Pearce, 'Civil society, the market and democracy in Latin America' and Fine, 'Civil society theory, Enlightenment and critique'.
   Google Scholar
• Munslow , B and Ekoko , F E . 1995 . 'Is democracy necessary for sustainable development?' . Democratization , 2 : 158 – 178 .
   Google Scholar
• Whitehead , L . 1997 . '"Bowling in the Bronx": the uncivil interstices between civil and political society' . Democratization , 4 : 94 – 114 .
   Google Scholar
• Foley , M W and Edwards , B . 1997 . 'Escape from politics? Social theory and the social capital debate' . American Behavioural Scientist , 40 : 550 – 561 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Macdonald . Supporting Civil Society 16 – 20 .
   Google Scholar
• Nzimande , B and Sikhosana , M . 1995 . “ 'Civil society: a theoretical survey and critique of some South African conceptions' ” . In Democracy, Civil Society and the State: Social Movements in Southern Africa , Edited by: Sachikonye , L M . 20 – 46 . Harare : SAPES Books .
   Google Scholar
• Wilson , R . 1997 . The People's Conscience? Civil Groups, Peace and Justice in the South African and Guatemalan Transitions , London : Catholic Institute for International Relations . for discussions
   Google Scholar
• Moore , M . 1993 . 'Good government? Introduction' . IDS Bulletin , 24 : 1 – 6 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Simon , D . 1998 . 'Rethinking (post)modernism, postcolonialism and posttraditionalism: South-North perspectives' . Environment and Planning D: Society and Space , 16 : 219 – 245 . David Simon also makes the point that rolling back the state may provide greater opportunities for NGO and CBO initiatives by creating 'political and symbolic spaces' (pp 221-222)
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• World Bank . 1997 . Worm Development Report 1997 , Oxford : Oxford University Press . This idea is encompassed within the
   Google Scholar
• Simon , D . 1995 . “ 'Debt, democracy and development' ” . In Structurally Adjusted Africa: Poverty, Debt and Basic Needs , Edited by: Simon , D . 17 – 44 . London : Pluto .
   Google Scholar
• Volk , S . 1997 . '"Democracy" versus "democracy" ' . NACLA Report on the Americas , 30 : 6 – 12 .
   Google Scholar
• Synergos Institute . 1996 . 'How government and multilateral donors can form large scale partnership with civil society organisations' . Institutional Society (Innovations in Civil Society) , 3 : 16 – 30 . IDB; Blair, 'Donors, democratisation and civil society: relating theory to practice', on USAID
   Google Scholar
• Rodriguez , A and Winchester , L . 1996 . 'Cities, democracy and governance in Latin America' . International Social Science Journal , 48 : 73 – 83 . on decentralisation
   Google Scholar
• Stahl , K . 1996 . 'Anti-poverty programs: making structural adjustment more palatable' . NACLA Report on the Americas , 29 : 32 – 36 . on social investment funds
   Google Scholar
• Foley and Edwards . “ 'The paradox of civil society' ” . 39
   Google Scholar
• Fowler , A . 1993 . 'Non-governmental organisations as agents of democratization: an African perspective' . Journal of International Development , 5 : 325 – 339 .
   Google Scholar
• World Bank . Worm Development Report 1997 113
   Google Scholar
• Edwards , M . 1995 . Non-governmental Organisations--Performance and Accountability: Beyond the Magic Bullet , Edited by: Hulme , D . London : Earthscan with Save the Children Fund . and Hulme & Edwards, NGOS, States and Donors
   Google Scholar
• Gordenker , L and Weiss , T G . 1997 . 'Devolving responsibilities: a framework for analysing NGOs and services' . Third World Quarterly , 18 : 443 – 455 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Howes , M . 1997 . 'NGOS and the development of local institutions: a Ugandan case-study' . Journal of Modern African Studies , 35 : 17 – 35 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Uvin , P . 1995 . 'scaling up the grassroots and scaling down the summit: the relations between Third World nongovernmental organisations and the United Nations' . Third Worm Quarterly , 16 : 495 – 512 . for discussions
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bratton , M . 1990 . 'Non-governmental organisations in Africa: can they influence public policy?' . Development and Change , 21 : 87 – 118 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Smillie , I . 1997 . 'NGOs and development assistance: a change in mind-set?' . Third Worm Quarterly , 18 : 563 – 577 . for discussions
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Alexander , J . 1997 . 'The local state in post-war Mozambique: political practice and ideas about authority' . Africa , 7 : 1 – 26 . on Mozambique
   Google Scholar
• Oloka-Onyango , J and Barya , J J . 1997 . 'Civil society and the political economy of foreign aid in Uganda' . Democratization , 7 : 113 – 138 . on Uganda
   Google Scholar
• Pereira , A . 1993 . 'Economic underdevelopment, democracy and civil society: the North-East Brazil Case' . Third Worm Quarterly , 14 : 365 – 380 . on Brazil
   Google Scholar
• Amirahmadi , H and Gladstone , D . 1996 . 'Towards a dynamic theory of the state and civil society in the development process' . Journal of Planning, Education and Research , 16 : 15 – 25 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• and Hadenius & Uggla, 'Making civil society work'.
   Google Scholar
• Boagang , He . 1997 . The Democratic Implications of Civil Society in China , Basingstoke : Macmillan .
   Google Scholar
• Munslow & Ekoko, 'Is democracy necessary for sustainable development?'.
   Google Scholar
• This point is made by Edwards & Hulme, 'Too close for comfort?'
   Google Scholar
• Sen , G . 1996 . 'Gender, markets and states: a selective review and research agenda' . World Development , 24 : 821 – 829 . on the importance of gender
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pearce . “ 'Between co-option and irrelevance? Latin American NGOS in the 1990s' ” . 72 For example, civil society is often referred to as 'a space which reflects the social divisions of society as a whole'
   Google Scholar
• Von Doepp , P . 1996 . 'Political transition and civil society: the cases of Kenya and Zambia' . Studies in Comparative International Development , 31 : 24 – 47 . Or it is seen as 'a potential location of power outside the state'. See
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lipschutz , R . 1992 . 'Reconstructing world politics: the emergence of global civil society' . Millenium: Journal of International Studies , 21 : 389 – 421 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pasha , M P . 1996 . 'Globalisation and poverty in South Asia' . Millenium: Journal of International Studies , 25 : 635 – 656 . for a discussion of the concept
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schearer , S B . 1996 . 'The emerging role of civil society in international development challenges to foreign aid programs' . Institutional Society (Innovations in Civil Society) , 3 : 12 – 27 . Many civil society groups, and particularly NGOs, have embraced the discourses surrounding the term 'global civil society' and organised themselves in a range of alliances. See for example on CIVICUS, the World Alliance for Citizen Participation
   Google Scholar
• Oloka-Onyango and Barya . “ 'Civil society and the political economy of foreign aid in Uganda' ” . 115 criticise the wholesale import of the notion of civil society on the grounds that it is 'suspiciously like other alien imports of convoluted pedigree and questionable validity'
   Google Scholar
• Putnam , R D . 1995 . 'Bowling alone: America's declining social capital' . Journal of Democracy , 6 : 65 – 78 . These ideas are strongly influenced by the work of
   Google Scholar
• Coleman , J . 1990 . Foundations of Social Theory , Cambridge , MA : Belknap .
   Google Scholar
• Wilson , P . 1997 . 'Building social capital: a learning agenda for the twenty-first century' . Urban Studies , 34 (5-6) : 745 – 760 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Foley and Edwards . “ 'Escape from politics?' ” . 550
   Google Scholar
• Bebbington , A . 1997 . 'social capital and rural intensification: local organistions and islands of sustainability in the rural Andes' . The Geographical Journal , 163 : 189 – 197 . on the role of social capital in building-up civil society in the context of the rural Andes
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Morris , M . 1998 . Social Capital and Poverty in India , IDS Working Paper 61 Brighton : Institute of Development Studies .
   Google Scholar
• Pearce . “ 'Civil society, the market and democracy in Latin America' ” . 59 – 69 . Pearce points out that civil society first received considerable attention in the mid 1980s among Latin American scholars at the same time as it enjoyed a revival in Eastern Europe; while academic interest subsided in the early 1990s, it was replaced by the embrace of the concept by the international development agencies, and in particular, the Inter-American Development Bank. By the mid-1990s, civil society was firmly on both donor, as well as academic and NGO agendas
   Google Scholar
• Foley , M W . 1996 . 'Laying the groundwork: the struggle for civil society in El Salvador' . Journal of Interamerican Studies and Worm Affairs , 38 (1) : 67 – 104 .
   Google Scholar
• O'Brien , D and Catenacci , L . 1997 . 'Towards a framework for local democracy in a war-torn society: the lessons of selected foreign assistance programmes in El Salvador'' . Democratization , 3 (4) : 435 – 458 . Ibid, and
   Google Scholar
• Lungo , M . 1996 . Ucles, El Salvador in the Eighties: Counterinsurgency and Revolution , Philadelphia , PA : Temple University Press . For an excellent account of this period
   Google Scholar
• Brockett , C D . 'El Salvador: the long journey from violence to reconciliation' . Latin American Research Review , 29 (3) 174 – 187 . For a review of the literature
   Google Scholar
• Dunkerley , J . 1994 . The Pacification of Central America , London : Verso . for an excellent discussion of the political developments in this period
   Google Scholar
• Pearce , J . 1998 . 'From civil war to "civil society": has the end of the Cold War brought peace to Central America?' . International Affairs , 74 (3) : 587 – 615 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sollis , P . 1992 . 'Displaced persons and human rights: the crisis in El Salvador' . Bulletin of Latin American Research , 11 (1) : 49 – 67 .
   Google Scholar
• Crosby , B L . 1997 . Democracy Sector Assessment: El Salvador , Washington, DC : Management Systems International/Office of Democratic Initiatives, USAID . Examples of business-orientated groups included the Camara de Comercio, or the Asociacion Salvadorena de Industriales (ASI). In the agricultural and labour sectors, coalitions of civil society organisations flourished such as the Bloque Popular Revolucionario, and the Union Comunal Salvadoreno
   Google Scholar
• Murray , K and Barry , T . 1995 . Inside El Salvador , 169 London : Latin America Bureau . M Lungo Uclos, cited in
   Google Scholar
• Stephen , L . 1995 . 'Women's rights are human rights: the merging of feminine and feminist interests among El Salvador's mothers of the disappeared (CO-MADRES)' . American Ethnologist , 22 (4) : 807 – 827 . One of the most well documented examples of a human rights organisation is that of CO-MADRES (Committee of Mothers and Relatives of Political Prisoners, Disappeared and Assassinated of El Salvador 'Monsenor Romero') discussed by
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pearce , J . 1986 . Promised Land: Peasant Rebellion in Chalatenango, El Salvador , London : Latin America Bureau .
   Google Scholar
• Sinclair , M , ed. 1995 . The New Politics of Survival: Grassroots Movements in Central America , New York : Monthly Review Press . on the variety of organisations which proliferated during this period
   Google Scholar
• Uclos , Lungo . El Salvador in the Eighties 156
   Google Scholar
• Sinclair . The New Politics of Survival 11
   Google Scholar
• Murray and Barry . Inside El Salvador 153
   Google Scholar
• Foley . “ 'Laying the Groundwork' ” . 74 – 75 .
   Google Scholar
• Pearce . “ 'From civil war to "civil society" ' ” . 597 – 599 .
   Google Scholar
• O'Brien and Catenacci . “ 'Local democracy in a war-torn society' ” . 439
   Google Scholar
• FORTAS itself is made-up of 40 small foundations. See Foley, 'Laying the groundwork', for a detailed discussion of FUSADES.
   Google Scholar
• Sollis , P . 1993 . Reluctant Reforms: The Cristiani Government and the International Community in the Process of the Salvadoran Post-War Reconstruction , Washington, DC : Washington Office on Latin America . for a detailed discussion of the role of NC, OS within the reconstruction phase. Pearce, 'From civil war to "civil society"' (p 601) also discusses the tensions inherent in the pursuit of peace at the same time as following structural adjustment policies. See both Pearce and Sollis on similar difficulties found elsewhere in Central America; and
   Google Scholar
• Sollis , P . 1995 . 'Panners in development? The state, nongovernmental organisations and the UN in Central America' . Third Worm Quarterly , 16 (3) : 525 – 542 .
   Google Scholar
• Vakil , A C . 1997 . 'Confronting the classification problem: toward a taxonomy of NGOS' . Worm Development , 25 (12) : 2057 – 2070 . The formulation of typologies has been explored in depth elsewhere. For a recent attempt see
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Desai , V and Preston , I . 1997 . A Typology of Urban Grassroots NGOS: The Case of Bombay , CEDAR Research Paper, No 21 Egham , Surrey : Department of Geography, Royal Holloway, University of London . In the context of Bombay, India, Desai and Preston discuss a typology based on 4 'clusters' which group NGOS according to: small-service delivery, large-service delivery, officially funded service delivery and policy advocacy
   Google Scholar
• Enriquez , A . 1997 . 'Desarrollo y ONGS en El Salvador: retos y perspectivas,' . Alternativas para el Desarrollo , 44 : 1 – 11 . This point is made by; It was also mentioned in a number of the interviews conducted
   Google Scholar
• Macias , R Cordova . 1997 . “ 'Analysis of the enabling framework for civil society' ” . San Salvador : USAID . In a UNDP study of 186 NGOS in 1992, 146 organisations were based in San Salvador, with 85 in nearby La Libertad
   Google Scholar
• PRISMA . 1997 . 'Hacia una estrategia ambiental para la Region Metropolitana de San Salvador' . RISMA Boletin , 22 : 2 – 3 . The San Salvador Metropolitan Area has grown territorially by 64 since 1980, with deleterious social, economic and environmental consequences in terms of employment, basic urban services and water supply
   Google Scholar
• Boyce , J K . 1995 . 'Adjustment towards peace: an introduction' . World Development , 23 (12) : 2067 – 2077 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Uclos , M Lungo . 1997 . 'Centroamerica: migracion internacional y politicas migratorias' . Alternativas para el Desarrollo , 47 : 13 – 19 . It has also been estimated that all Salvadoreans have at least one family member living in the United States, and that remittances represent 47 of their income
   Google Scholar
• Wood , E and Segovia , A . 1995 . 'Macroeconomic policy and the Salvadoran Peace Accords' . World Development , 23 (12) : 2079 – 2099 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ucles , M Lungo , Eekhof , K and Baires , S . 1997 . Migracion Internacional y Desarrollo Local en El Salvador, Avances 8 , San Salvador : FUNDE .
   Google Scholar
• Crosby . Democracy Sector Assessment 5 – 6 . In the context of an estimated 8000 murders every year, it is hardly surprising that in a national survey carried out in June/July 1996, 79 of the respondents identified crime as the number one problem. In turn, this was related to the deteriorating economic situation and widespread unemployment
   Google Scholar
• Pearce . “ 'From civil war to "civil society"' ” . 580
   Google Scholar
• Carr , M . 1994 . 'El Salvador: two cheers for democracy?' . Race and Class , 36 (1) : 1 – 22 . In rural areas, President Calderon Sol has developed the Plan Guardian at the behest of landowners, involving joint patrols of the police and army. However, this has met with resistance from the Left on the grounds that it violates the Peace Accords and serves as an excuse to reverse demilitarisation efforts
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Cordova Mac/as . “ 'Analysis of the enabling framework for civil society' ” . 10 – 15 .
   Google Scholar
• Foley . “ 'Laying the groundwork' ” . 80 – 81 .
   Google Scholar
• Castillo , L . 1995 . 'Editorial' . Autogestion (Boletin Informativo de la Fundacion Salvadorena de Apoyo Integral--(FUSAI) , 11 : 1 – 3 .
   Google Scholar
• de Hernandez , A M . 'Proceso de debate y creacion de la Icy que regula el trabajo de las ONGS en El Salvador' . Pobreza Urbana y Desarrollo , 7 (14) 24 – 31 . Interview with Luis Castillo, director of FUSAI, July 1997. See also
   Google Scholar
• Mitchell , T . 1995 . “ 'The object of development: America's Egypt' ” . In Power of Development , Edited by: Crush , J . 129 – 157 . London : Routledge . Timothy Mitchell makes similar observations about the role of USAID in Egypt. He notes that a major goal of USAID is to develop the private sector, although in reality the effect of these programmes is to strengthen the power of the state
   Google Scholar
• Escobar , A . 1995 . Encountering Development: The Making and Unmaking of the Third World , Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Foley . “ 'Laying the groundwork' ” . 79 This was reinforced through a visit to one of FORTAS'S foundations, Fundacion Coatepeque, in July 1997 with the director, Jose Mario Vasquez. In an interview with a community group receiving assistance from the foundation, it emerged that, while the projects themselves were technically sound, a top-down approach to organising was employed; little attempt was made by the foundation at promoting active and sustained participation on the part of the community. Indeed, this was in stark contrast to the activities of other NGOS such as FUNDAMUNI and FUSAI
   Google Scholar
• Sollis , P . 1993 . 'Poverty alleviation in El Salvador: an appraisal of the Cristiani government's social pro gramme' . Journal of International Development , 5 (5) : 437 – 458 . for a detailed discussion of the VIS
   Google Scholar
• FISDL . 1997 . Plan de Accion de la Nueva Forma de Trabajo del FISDL de El Salvador , San Salvador : FISDL . Interviews were also conducted with all the divisional heads of FISDL in July 1997
   Google Scholar
• Simon, 'Rethinking (post)modernism, postcolonialism, and posttraditionalism.'. See also Pearce, 'From civil war to "civil society"'.
   Google Scholar