Indian Inflow: The interplay of foreign investment and intellectual property

References

• Nicholson , M . 1996 . 'Faltering steps on the upward path' . Financial Times , 19 November
   Google Scholar
• World Bank . 1996 . Social Indicators of Development , Washington, DC : World Bank . Survey III. See also
   Google Scholar
• Briskman , Louis J . 8 October 1996 . Senior Vice President and General Counsel of Westinghouse Electric Corporation 8 October , Washington, DC Conversation with
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'Emerging market indicators' . The Economist , 7-13 June : 110
   Google Scholar
• Metha , D . 1996 . 'India: the software paradise' . Cyber India Online , (internet edition)
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'India: India Press Digest--Indian Newspapers--May 2' . Reuter News Service , 2 May
   Google Scholar
• Authur , WB . 1996 . 'Increasing returns and the new world of business' . Harvard Business Review , 74 (4) : 108
   Google Scholar
• Alford , WP . 1994 . 'Intellectual property in East Asia: how theory does--and does not--matter: American approaches to intellectual property law in East Asia . UCLA Pacific Basin Law Journal , 13 : 12 The Honorable Bruce A Lehman, Assistant Secretary of Commerce and Commissioner of Patents and Trademarks, address to the Comparative Intellectual Property Inn of Court Meeting, 16 October 1996
   Google Scholar
• Bronckers , MCEJ . 1994 . 'The impact of Trips: intellectual property protection in developing countries . Common Market Law Review , 31 (4) : 1249
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'UNCTAD says developing nations need help in implementing TRIPs' . World Intellectual Property Report , 11 ( 4 ) : 136 (stating developing nations need assistance in implementing TRIPs because in most cases they simply do not have the resources available to carry it out. 'UNCTAD's major conclusion is that most developing nations require substantial aid to improve the protection and enforcement of intellectual property rights.')
   Google Scholar
• Braga , C Primo . 1990 . “ 'Sector issues I' ” . In Strengthening Protection of Intellectual Property in Developing Countries: A Survey of Literature , Edited by: Siebeck , WE . 51 Washington, DC : World Bank .
   Google Scholar
• Shankar , V . October-December 1996 . TN Seshan, Citi-India October-December , 29 (stating the complex nature of the polity includes different religions, languages, cultures, the disparities and the problems of illiteracy')
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . See US urges India to open wider economically' . Xinhua News Agency (New Delhi) , 9 October
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'India: India says it regrets US move on property rights' . Reuter News Service , 2 May
   Google Scholar
• Fernandez , C . 1996 . 'India: Lehman official urges India to speed disinvestment' . Reuter News Service , 25 September
   Google Scholar
• 1994 . Agreement On Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights . International Legal Materials , 33 15 April : 83 – 111 . (hereafter TRIPS)
   Google Scholar
• Kitch , EW . 1994 . 'Policy consideration: the patent policy of developing countries' . UCLA Pacific Basin Law Journal , 13 : 167
   Google Scholar
• Oddi , AS . 1987 . 'The international patent system and Third World development: reality or myth? . Duke Law Journal , November : 831
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Feinrider , M . 1981 . 'UNCTAD transfer of technology code negotiations' . Buffalo Law Review , 30 : 753
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gana , RL . 1996 . 'Has creativity died in the Third World? Some implications of the internationalization of intellectual property . Denver Journal of International Law & Policy , 24 : 112 138
   Google Scholar
• Tamanaha , BZ . 1995 . 'The lesson of law and development studies . American Journal International Law , 89 : 478
   Google Scholar
• Narayanan , P . 1985 . Patent Law , 6 Calcutta : Eastern Law House .
   Google Scholar
• Adelman , M and Baldia , S . 1996 . 'Prospects and limits of the patent provision in the Trips Agreement: the case of India' . Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law , 29 : 518
   Google Scholar
• Ganesan , AV . 1989 . 'International forum on the role of industrial property in economic corporation arraignments' . World Intellectual Property Organization , 45
   Google Scholar
• Patel , SJ . 'Transfer of technology and third UNCTAD' . Journal of World Trade Law , 228
   Google Scholar
• Mody , A . 1990 . “ 'New international environment for intellectual property rights' ” . In Intellectual Property Rights in Science, Technology, and Economic Performance, Boulder , Edited by: Rushing , FW . 203 – 206 . CO : Westview Press .
   Google Scholar
• Sen , F . “ 'Intellectual property rights and management of R&D in India' ” . In Intellectual Property Rights Edited by: Rushing . 134
   Google Scholar
• McLeland , L and O'Toole , JH . 1987 . 'Patent systems in less developed countries: the cases of India and the Andean Pact countries,''' . Journal of Law & Technology , 2 : 238
   Google Scholar
• Keayla , BK . 1994 . 'Patent protection and the pharmaceutical industry' . Intellectual Property Rights , : 151 Adelman & Baldia, 'Prospects and limits of the patent provision in the Trips Agreement', citing; (Note: 'working' relates to the manufacture and use of a patented article in the country that grants the patent. It is intended to preclude abuse of the monopoly grant through mere importation of the patented article.)
   Google Scholar
• Ahmed , M . 1997 . 'India: finding the right cure' . Business Standard , 19 February
   Google Scholar
• Mitra , S . 1996 . 'India and US sign agriculture agreement' . Reuter News Service , 27 January
   Google Scholar
• Shankar , V . 1996 . 'Indian expatriate skills back to the native air' . Citi-India , October-December : 26 Each year India produces 80 000 engineers, 50 000 medical doctors and 600 PhDs in engineering
   Google Scholar
• Jussawalla , M . 1983 . “ 'Trade, technology transfer, and development' ” . In The Trouble with Technology: Trade, Technology Transfer, and Development , Edited by: MacDonald , S . 136 New York : St Martin's Press . Survey of Impediments to Trade and Investment in the APEC Region, p. 97; The author states that should information-based technology transfer borm part of trade flows, the probability of narrowing the income gap between the developed and developing countries will be greater
   Google Scholar
• Rapp , RT and Rozek , RP . 1990 . 'Benefits and costs of intellectual property protection in developing countries,' . Journal of World Trade , 24 : 75 Kitch, 'Policy consideration'; ('Regression analysis shows that countries with higher rates of economic growth protect intellectual property rights. However, the regression analysis results do not show which is cause and which is effect')
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Braga , C Primo . 1990 . “ 'The developing country case for and against intellectual property protection ” . In Strengthening Protection of Intellectual Property in Developing Countries , Edited by: Siebeck . 80 – 81 . Washington DC : World Bank .
   Google Scholar
• McManis , CR . 1994 . 'Intellectual property in East Asia: introduction,' . UCLA Pacific Basin Law Journal , 13 : 1 Alford, 'Intellectual property in East Asia'; and Ganesan, 'International forum on the role of industrial property'
   Google Scholar
• Gana . “ 'Has creativity died in the Third World,' ” . 120 'The agreement promotes national economic interests and social values in the legitimizing form of treaty law'
   Google Scholar
• Scalise , DG and Nugent , D . 1995 . 'International intellectual property protections for living matter: biotechnology, multinational conventions and the exception for agriculture''' . Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law , 27 : 107
   Google Scholar
• Gorlin , JJ . 1993 . “ 'Update on international negotiations on intellectual property rights' ” . In Global Dimensions of Intellectual Property in Science and Technology , Edited by: Wallerstein , MB . 176 Washington, DC : National Academy Press .
   Google Scholar
• Nayyar , D . “ 'National and international approaches to intellectual property rights: India' ” . In Global Dimensions of Intellectual Property in Science and Technology Edited by: Wallerstein . 168
   Google Scholar
• Bronckers . “ 'The Impact of Trips' ” . 1246
   Google Scholar
• Reynolds , T and Flores , A . 1994 . Foreign Law: Current Sources of Codes and Basic Legislation in Jurisdictions of the World , Vol 3A , 6 Littleton , CO : Rothman .
   Google Scholar
• Gadbaw , RM and Kenny , LA . 1988 . “ 'India' ” . In Intellectual Property Rights: Global Consensus, Global Conflict? , Edited by: Gadbaw . 186 – 231 . Boulder , CO : Westview Press .
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• 1998 . 'WTO tells India to amend patent laws,' . The Hindu , 18 January
   Google Scholar
• Bronckers , MCEJ . 1996 . speech made to UNCTAD Workshop . March 5-7 1996 , Cairo . (transcript on file with author)
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'India: IPRS to conform to global standards,' . Business Standard , 7 December
   Google Scholar
• Narayanan . Patent Law 79 – 80 . Where the period for filing notice of opposition has expired, and the judgement, if any, has been finally decided in favour of the applicant, and there is no grounds for refusing the application, upon application the patent will be sealed and entered in the register. The sealing date is material for calculating the term of patents related to food and drugs, as well as for compulsory licences and licences of right endorsements.)
   Google Scholar
• SARKAR , JS . 1992 . Trade Marks Law and Practice , 15 Calcutta : Kamal Law House . Ibid, Ch 16 section83(a). 'Patent rights are not granted merely to enable patentees to enjoy a monopoly for the importation of the patented article'. See also; (stating that the object of a patent grant is to encourage industrial progress. An implied condition of the exclusive right to make use of the invention is the exploitation of the invention for the benefit of the community. Failure to do so is an abuse of the granted patent rights
   Google Scholar
• Ganesan . “ 'International forum on the role of industrial property' ” . 47 (only one compulsory license has been granted under the law up to March 1989)
   Google Scholar
• McLeland and O'Toole . “ 'Patent systems in less developed countries' ” . 238
   Google Scholar
• Koshy , S . 1995 . 'The effect of trips on Indian patent law: a pharmaceutical industry perspective,' . Boston University Journal of Science & Technology Law , 1 : 18 Ibid, Ch 17 section100 (3). See also
   Google Scholar
• Ganesan . “ 'International forum on the role of industrial property' ” . 47 The total number of patents 'worked' in India by utilisation of the licence of right by any person other than the patent owner does not exceed 25 up to 1989
   Google Scholar
• The National Trade Data Bank . 21 March 1995 . Market Reports , 21 March , Washington, DC : US Department of Commerce .
   Google Scholar
• Narayanan , P . 1995 . Copyright and Industrial Designs , 4 Calcutta : Eastern Law House .
   Google Scholar
• Srivastava , AS . 1995 . Lal's the Copyright Act , 30 Allahabad : Law Publishers .
   Google Scholar
• Madhavan , N . 1994 . 'India to broaden copyright protection' . Reuter News Service , 8 November
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'Emerging powers: India' . The Wall Street Journal (US) Public Broadcasting Service (PBS) Video Series ,
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'software piracy raids in Chennai' . Business Line on Indiaserver , 29 April (internet edition)
   Google Scholar
• US Embassy . 1995 . 'India: new copyright laws' . Market Reports (New Delhi) , 21 March
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'Patent tribunal urgent, says CSIR chief' . Business Line on Indiaserver , 8 February (internet edition)
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'India: press digest--Indian newspapers' . Reuter News Service , 30 May (stating the government has launched a project aimed at modernising the patent information services in cooperation with WIPO and UNDP)
   Google Scholar
• Koshy . “ 'The effect of Trips on Indian Patent Law' ” . 33
   Google Scholar
• Koshy . “ 'The effect of Trips on Indian patent law' ” . 14 See also Oddi, 'The international patent system and Third World development'
   Google Scholar
• Koshy . “ 'The effect of Trips on Indian patent law' ” . 14
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'Pfizer to end pact with India's Torrent' . Reuter News Service , 6 March However
   Google Scholar
• Ahmed , M . 1997 . India: Pfizer seeks government nod for R&D subsidiary' . Business Standard , 9 January
   Google Scholar
• Ahmed . 1997 . 'India: back to the law' . Business Standard , 19 February Despite what it cited as a lack of meaningful patent protection, the potential for profits proved too tempting for Pfizer, which quickly thereafter sought approval from the Indian government for a subsidiary to conduct research work, and sought out Indian companies to do some of its development work
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'India to amend copyright law' . Xinhua News Agency , 7 October
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'India says it regrets US move on property rights' . Reuter News Service , 2 May
   Google Scholar
• Donaldson , T . 1996 . 'Values in tension: ethics away from home' . Harvard Business Review , 74 (5) : 52 See also 'UNCTAD says developing nations need help in implementing TRIPS', p. 136
   Google Scholar
• Graves , N . 1995 . 'India: US mission descends on India's "Silicon Valley"' . Reuter News Service , 18 January
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'Trade and foreign direct investment' . Press Release, World Trade Organization , 9 October : 25
   Google Scholar
• Braga , CA Primo . 1996 . “ 'Trade-related intellectual property issues: The Uruguay round agreement and its economic implications' ” . In The Uruguay Round and the Developing Economies , World Bank Discussion Paper No 307 Edited by: Martin and Winters , LA . 401 Washington, DC : World Bank .
   Google Scholar
• Kuflik , A . 1989 . Owning Scientific and Technical Information: Value and Ethical Issues , Edited by: Weil , V . 219 New Brunswick : Rutgers University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Mansfield , E . “ 'Unauthorized use of intellectual property: effects on investment, technology transfer, and innovation' ” . In Global Dimensions of Intellectual Property in Science and Technology Edited by: Wallerstein . 129 139 – 140 . Mansfield's approach was based on whether the intellectual property protection in certain nations was perceived by corporations to be too weak for them to engage in either joint venture investment, transfer of technology or licensing arrangements
   Google Scholar
• Gregg , DI . 1995 . 'Intellectual property, World Bank affiliate looks at link between IPR and foreign investment''' . Daily Report for Executives , 7 November
   Google Scholar
• Braga , Primo . “ 'Trade-related intellectual property issues' ” . 401
   Google Scholar
• Nations , United . 1993 . Intellectual Property Rights and Foreign Direct Investment , New York : United Nations . UN Doc. ST/CTC,/SER.A/24
   Google Scholar
• Ibid, p. 21.
   Google Scholar
• Brags , Primo . “ 'Trade-related intellectual properly issues' ” . 399
   Google Scholar
• Pearl , D . 1996 . 'No quick cure' . The Wall Street Journal , 13 December
   Google Scholar
• Mansfield . “ 'Unauthorized use of intellectual property' ” . 123
   Google Scholar
• United Nations . Intellectual Property Rights and Foreign Investment 4
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'Compulsory licensing and the developing world' . Marketletter , 9 December
   Google Scholar
• United Nations . “ 'Intellectual Property Rights and Foreign Investment,' ” . 26
   Google Scholar
• Ibid, pp 26-27.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid, p. 27.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid, pp 27-28.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid, p. 28.
   Google Scholar
• Reichman , JH . 1996 . 'Compliance with the Trips Agreement: introduction to a scholarly debate' . Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law , 29 : 380 Reichman cites a study by FM Scherer, which finds 'the legitimization of drug product patents in Italy did not induce a market shift in Italian pharmaceuticals manufacturers' strategic emphasis from emulating drags developed elsewhere to developing innovative drugs … research and development expenditure growth … did not accelerate after the patent regime transition and the number and character of new product launches did not change significantly'
   Google Scholar
• Adelman and Baldia . “ 'Prospects and limits of the patent provision in the Trips Agreement' ” . 525
   Google Scholar
• Prime Minister PV Narasimha Rao . 1995 . 'An Indian resurgence: economic reform in a democratic society' . Harvard International Review , 17 : 39
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• Ibid, p. 41.
   Google Scholar
• Shankar . “ 'Indian expatriate skills back to the native air' ” . 27
   Google Scholar
• Varma , A . 1996 . 'Fast forward' . India Today , 15 October : 69
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'Post-reform FDI inflow nears Rs20 000 crore' . Times of India , 17 April (internet edition)
   Google Scholar
• Nicoll , A . 1996 . 'Nehru legacy lives on' . The Financial Times , 19 November Survey IV
   Google Scholar
• Javalagi , RG and Talluri , VS . 1996 . 'The emerging role of India in international business' . Business Horizons , 19 September
   Google Scholar
• Varma . “ 'Fast forward' ” . 69
   Google Scholar
• Anand , P . 1994 . “ 'India' ” . In Legal Aspects of Doing Business in Asia and the Pacific , 11 – 12 . Deventer , , The Netherlands : Kluwer Law and Taxation .
   Google Scholar
• Javalagi & Talluri, 'The emerging role of India in international business'.
   Google Scholar
• Roa , SS . 1995 . 'Yankee, be good' . Financial World , 7 November
   Google Scholar
• Taylor , P . 1996 . 'Close to breakthrough' . The Financial Times , 19 November Survey VI
   Google Scholar
• 1996 . 'Indian software sales soared 61 in 1995/96' . Reuter News Service , 27 June
   Google Scholar
• Aggarwal , N . 1997 . 'Investor's guide: in a tearing hurry' . Economic Times , 3-6 April (internet edition)
   Google Scholar
• 1997 . 'satyam in consulting pact with US firm' . Business Line on Indiaserver , 24 April (internet edition)
   Google Scholar
• Ahmed , M . 1997 . 'India: back to the lab' . Business Standard , 9 January
   Google Scholar
• Das , G . 1996 . 'A million reformers now' . Citi-India , October-December : 8
   Google Scholar
• de Jonquieres , G . 1996 . 'Multinationals spur surge in investment,' . The Financial Times , 25 September Lehman, address to the Comparative Intellectual Property Inn of Court meeting. Lehman stated that 80 of the technology existing in Silicon Valley's computer industry today was not in existence just four years ago
   Google Scholar
• Gonzalez , M . 1997 . 'Harvard meets a real Taipan' . The Wall Street Journal , 10 April : A14
   Google Scholar
• Mitra , S . 1996 . 'Follow the changing rules' . Global Finance , September : 139
   Google Scholar
• Shankar . “ 'Indian expatriate skills back to the native air' ” . 26
   Google Scholar
• Mulugu , Somasekhar . 1998 . 'India: techscapes,' . Business Line , 2 January
   Google Scholar
• Ibid, p. 28.
   Google Scholar