Meta-Analysis of Meta-Analyses in Communication: Comparing Fixed Effects and Random Effects Analysis Models

References

• *Allen , M. , Berkowitz , S. , Hunt , S. , & Louden , A. ( 1999 ). A meta-analysis of the impact of forensics and communication education on critical thinking . Communication Education , 48 , 18 – 30 .
   Google Scholar
• *Allen , M. , Bourhis , J. , Emmers-Sommer , T. , & Sahlstein , E. ( 1998 ). Reducing dating anxiety: A meta-analysis . Communication Reports , 11 , 49 – 55 .
   Google Scholar
• *Allen , M. , D'Alessio , D. , & Emmers-Sommer , T. M. ( 1999 ). Reactions of criminal sexual offenders to pornography: A meta-analytic summary . Communication Yearbook , 22 , 139 – 169 .
   Google Scholar
• *Allen , M. , Emmers-Sommer , T. M. , D'Alessio , D. , Timmerman , L. , Hanzal , A. , & Korus , J. ( 2007 ). The connection between the physiological and psychological reactions to sexually explicit materials: A literature summary using meta-analysis . Communication Monographs , 74 , 541 – 560 .
   Google Scholar
• Allen , M. , Mabry , E. , Mattrey , M. , Bourhis , J. , Titsworth , S. , & Burrell , N. ( 2004 ). Evaluating the effectiveness of distance learning: A comparison using meta-analysis . Journal of Communication , 54 , 402 – 420 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Allen , M. , Witt , P. L. , & Wheeless , L. R. ( 2006 ). The role of teacher immediacy as a motivational factor in student learning: Using meta-analysis to test a causal model . Communication Education , 55 , 21 – 31 .
   Google Scholar
• *BarNir , A. ( 1998 ). Can group- and issue-related factors predict choice shift? A meta-analysis of group decisions on life dilemmas . Small Group Research , 29 , 308 – 338 .
   Google Scholar
• Beatty , M. J. , Heisel , A. D. , Hall , A. E. , Levine , T. R. , & La France , B. H. ( 2002 ). What can we learn from the study of twins about genetic and environmental influences on interpersonal affiliation, aggressiveness, and social anxiety? A meta-analytic study . Communication Monographs , 69 , 1 – 18 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Becker , B. J. ( 1996 ). The generalizability of empirical research results . In C. P. Benbow & D. Lubinski (Eds.), Intellectual talent: Psychological and social issues (pp. 363 – 383 ). Baltimore , MD : Johns Hopkins University Press .
   Google Scholar
• *Benoit , W. L. , Hansen , G. J. , & Verser , R. M. ( 2003 ). A meta-analysis of the effects of viewing U.S. presidential debates . Communication Monographs , 70 , 335 – 350 .
   Google Scholar
• Borenstein , M. , Hedges , L. , & Rothstein , H. ( 2007 ). Meta-analysis: Fixed effects vs. random effects [Online White Paper]. Retrieved May 22, 2008, from www.meta-analysis.com and http://www.sciencedownload.net/demodownload/Fixed%20effect%20vs.%20random%20effects.pdf
   Google Scholar
• Boster , F. J. ( 2002 ). On making progess in communication science . Human Communication Research , 28 , 473 – 490 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Bourhis , J. , & Allen , M. ( 1998 ). The role of videotaped feedback in the instruction of public speaking: A quantitative synthesis of published empirical research . Communication Research Reports , 15 , 256 – 261 .
   Google Scholar
• Bowers , C. A. , Pharmer , J. A. , & Salas , E. ( 2000 ). When member homogeneity is needed in work teams: A meta-analysis . Small Group Research , 31 , 305 – 327 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Buck , R. , & VanLear , A. ( 2002 ). Verbal and nonverbal communication: Distinguishing symbolic, spontaneous, and pseudo-spontaneous nonverbal behavior . Journal of Communication , 52 , 522 – 541 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Casey , M. K. , Allen , M. , Emmers-Sommer , T. , Sahlstein , E. , Degooyer , D. , et al.. (2003). When a celebrity contracts a disease: The example of Earvin “Magic” Johnson's announcement that was HIV positive. Journal of Health Communication , 8, 249–265.
   Google Scholar
• Chiaburu , D. S. , & Harrison , D. A. ( 2008 ). Do peers make the place? Conceptual synthesis and meta-analysis of coworker effects of perceptions, attitudes, OCBs, and performance . Journal of Applied Psychology , 93 , 1082 – 1103 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Cooper , E. , & Allen , M. ( 1998 ). A meta-analytic examination of the impact of student race on classroom interaction . Communication Research Reports , 15 , 151 – 161 .
   Google Scholar
• Cooper , H. ( 1989 ). Integrating research: A guide for literature reviews () , 2nd ed. . Newbury Park , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Cooper , H. ( 1997 ). Some finer points in meta-analysis . In M. Hunt (Ed.), How science takes stock: The story of meta-analysis (pp. 169 – 181 ). New York : Russell Sage Foundation .
   Google Scholar
• D'Alessio , D. , & Allen , M. ( 2000 ). Media bias in presidential elections: A meta-analysis . Journal of Communication , 50 , 133 – 156 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Devine , D. J. , & Philips , J. L. ( 2001 ). Do smarter teams do better? A meta-analysis of cognitive ability and team performance . Small Group Research , 32 , 507 – 532 .
   Google Scholar
• *Dillard , J. P. , Weber , K. M. , & Vail , R. G. ( 2007 ). The relationship between the perceived and actual effectiveness of persuasive messages: A meta-analysis with implications for formative campaign research . Journal of Communication , 57 , 613 – 631 .
   Google Scholar
• Emmers-Sommer , T. M. , & Allen , M. ( 1999a ). Surveying the effects of media effects: A meta-analytic summary of the media effects research in Human Communication Research . Human Communication Research , 25 , 478 – 497 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Emmers-Sommer , T. M. , & Allen , M. ( 1999b ). Variables related to sexual coercion: A path model . Journal of Social and Personal Relationships , 16 , 659 – 678 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Emmers-Sommer , T. M. , Allen , M. , Bourhis , J. , Sahlstein , E. , Laskowski , K. , et al. . ( 2004 ). A meta-analysis of the relationship between social skills and sexual offenders . Communication Reports , 17 , 1 – 7 .
   Google Scholar
• Feeley , T. H. ( 2008 ). A bibliometric analysis of communication journals from 2002 to 2005 . Human Communication Research , 34 , 505 – 520 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Field , A. P. ( 2001 ). Meta-analysis of correlation coefficients: A Monte Carlo comparison of fixed- and random-effects methods . Psychological Methods , 6 , 161 – 180 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Field , A. P. ( 2003 ). The problems in using fixed-effects models of meta-analysis on real-world data . Understanding Statistics , 2 , 105 – 124 .
   Google Scholar
• *Frank , M. G. , & Feeley , T. H. ( 2003 ). To catch a liar: Challenges for research in lie detection training . Journal of Applied Communication Research , 31 ( 3 ), 58 – 75 .
   Google Scholar
• Hall , S. M. , & Brannick , M. T. ( 2002 ). Comparison of two random-effects methods of meta-analysis . Journal of Applied Psychology , 87 , 377 – 389 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hansen , G. J. , & Benoit , W. L. ( 2007 ). Communication forms as predictors of issue knowledge in presidential campaigns: A meta-analytic assessment . Mass Communication & Society , 10 , 189 – 210 .
   Google Scholar
• Hedges , L. V. ( 1992 ). Meta-analysis . Journal of Educational Statistics , 17 , 279 – 296 .
   Google Scholar
• Hedges , L. V. , & Olkin , I. ( 1985 ). Statistical methods for meta-analysis . Orlando , FL : Academic .
   Google Scholar
• Hedges , L. V. , & Vevea , J. L. ( 1998 ). Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis . Psychological Methods , 3 , 486 – 504 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hetsroni , A. ( 2007a ). Four decades of violent content on prime-time network programming: A longitudinal meta-analytic review . Journal of Communication , 57 , 759 – 784 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hetsroni , A. ( 2007b ). Three decades of sexual content on prime-time network programming: A longitudinal meta-analytic review . Journal of Communication , 57 , 318 – 348 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Hoffner , C. A. , & Levine , K. J. ( 2005 ). Enjoyment of mediated fright and violence: A meta-analysis . Media Psychology , 7 , 207 – 237 .
   Google Scholar
• *Hogben , M. (1998). Factors moderating the effect of televised aggression on viewer behavior. Communication Research , 25, 220–247.
   Google Scholar
• *Holmstrom , A. J. ( 2004 ). The effects of the media on body image: A meta-analysis . Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media , 48 , 196 – 217 .
   Google Scholar
• *Hullett , C. R. ( 2005 ). The impact of mood on persuasion: A meta-analysis . Communication Research , 32 , 423 – 442 .
   Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. , & Schmidt , F. E. ( 1990 ). Methods of meta-analysis: Correcting error and bias in research findings . Newbury Park , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. , & Schmidt , F. E. ( 1994 ). Correcting for sources of artificial variation across studies . In H. Cooper & L. V. Hedges (Eds.), The handbook of research synthesis (pp. 323 – 338 ). New York : Russell Sage Foundation .
   Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. , & Schmidt , F. E. ( 1996 ). Cumulative research knowledge and social policy formulation: The critical role of meta-analysis . Psychology, Public Policy, and Law , 2 , 324 – 347 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. , & Schmidt , F. L. ( 2000 ). Fixed effects vs. random effects meta-analysis models: Implications for cumulative research knowledge . International Journal of Selection and Assessment , 8 , 275 – 292 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. , & Schmidt , F. L. ( 2004 ). Methods of meta-analysis: Correcting error and bias in research findings . Thousand Oaks , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Hunter , J. E. , Schmidt , F. L. , & Jackson , G. B. ( 1982 ). Meta-analysis: Cumulating research findings across studies . Beverly Hills , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Johnson , B. T. , Mullen , B. , & Salas , E. ( 1995 ). Comparison of three major meta-analytic approaches . Journal of Applied Psychology , 80 , 94 – 106 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *La France , B. H. , Heisel , A. D. , & Beatty , M. J. ( 2004 ). Is there empirical evidence for a nonverbal profile of extraversion?: A meta-analysis and critique of the literature . Communication Monographs , 71 , 28 – 48 .
   Google Scholar
• Latham , G. P. , Erez , M. , & Locke , E. A. ( 1988 ). Resolving scientific disputes by the joint design of crucial experiments by the antagonists: Application to the Erez–Latham dispute regarding participation in goal setting . Journal of Applied Psychology , 73 , 753 – 772 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Levine , T. R. , Anders , L. N. , Banas , J. , Baum , K. L. , Endo , K. , et al. . ( 2000 ). Norms, expectations, and deception: A norm violation model of veracity judgments . Communication Monographs , 67 , 123 – 137 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Levine , T. R. , Bresnahan , M. , Park , H. S. , Lapinski , M. K. , Wittenbaum , G. M. , et al. . ( 2003 ). Self-construal scales lack validity . Human Communication Research , 29 , 210 – 252 .
   Google Scholar
• Lipsey , M. W. , & Wilson , D. B. ( 2001 ). Practical meta-analysis . Newbury Park , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Machill , M. , Beiler , M. , & Fischer , C. ( 2006 ). Europe-topics in Europe's media: The debate about the European public sphere: A meta-analysis of media content analyses . European Journal of Communication , 21 , 57 – 88 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Mares , M. , & Woodard , E. ( 2005 ). Positive effects of television on children's social interactions: A meta-analysis . Media Psychology , 7 , 301 – 322 .
   Google Scholar
• *Mast , M. S. ( 2002 ). Dominance expressed and inferred through speaking time: A meta-analysis . Human Communication Research , 28 , 420 – 450 .
   Google Scholar
• *Mattson , M. , Allen , M. , Ryan , D. J. , & Miller , V. ( 2000 ). Considering organizations as a unique interpersonal context for deception detection: A meta-analytic review . Communication Research Reports , 17 , 148 – 160 .
   Google Scholar
• *Noar , S. M. , Carlyle , K. , & Cole , C. ( 2006 ). Why communication is crucial: Meta-analysis of the relationship between safer sexual communication and condom use . Journal of Health Communication , 11 , 365 – 390 .
   Google Scholar
• *Novak , J. M. , Markey , V. , & Allen , M. ( 2007 ). Evaluating cognitive outcomes of service learning in higher education: A meta-analysis . Communication Research Reports , 24 , 149 – 157 .
   Google Scholar
• *O'Keefe , D. J. (1999). How to handle opposing arguments in persuasive messages: A meta-analytic review of the effects of one-sided and two-sided messages. Communication Yearbook , 22, 209–249.
   Google Scholar
• *O'Keefe , D. J. ( 2000 ). Guilt and social influence . Communication Yearbook , 23 , 67 – 101 .
   Google Scholar
• *O'Keefe , D. J. , & Hale , S. L. ( 1998 ). The door-in-the-face influence strategy: A random-effects meta-analytic review . Communication Yearbook , 21 , 1 – 33 .
   Google Scholar
• O'Keefe , D. J. , & Hale , S. L. ( 2001 ). An odds-ratio based meta-analysis of research on the door-in-the-face influence strategy . Communication Reports , 14 , 31 – 38 .
   Google Scholar
• O'Keefe , D. J. , & Jensen , J. D. ( 2006 ). The advantages of compliance or the disadvantages of noncompliance? A meta-analytic review of the relative persuasive effectiveness of gain-framed and loss-framed messages . Communication Yearbook , 30 , 1 – 43 .
   Google Scholar
• *O'Keefe , D. J. , & Jensen , J. D. ( 2007 ). The relative persuasiveness of gain-framed loss-framed messages for encouraging disease prevention behaviors: A meta-analytic review . Journal of Health Communication , 12 , 623 – 644 .
   Google Scholar
• *Orlitzsky , M. , & Hirokawa , R. Y. ( 2001 ). To err is human, to correct for it divine: A meta-analysis of research testing the functional theory of group decision-making effectiveness . Small Group Research , 32 , 313 – 341 .
   Google Scholar
• Overton , R. C. ( 1998 ). A comparison of fixed effects and mixed (random effects) models for meta-analysis tests of moderator variable effects . Psychological Methods , 3 , 354 – 379 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Paul , B. , Salwen , M. B. , & Dupagne , M. ( 2000 ). The third-person effect: A meta-analysis of the perceptual hypothesis . Mass Communication & Society , 3 , 57 – 85 .
   Google Scholar
• *Rains , S. A. ( 2005 ). Leveling the organizational playing field—virtually: A meta-analysis of experimental research assessing the impact of group support system use on member influence behaviors . Communication Research , 32 , 193 – 234 .
   Google Scholar
• *Riggio , H. R. , & Riggio , R. E. ( 2002 ). Emotional expressiveness, extraversion, and neuroticism: A meta-analysis . Journal of Nonverbal Behavior , 26 , 195 – 218 .
   Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. ( 1991 ). Meta-analytic procedures for social research . Newbury Park , CA : Sage .
   Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. ( 1995 ). Writing meta-analytic reviews . Psychological Bulletin , 118 , 183 – 192 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. , Rosnow , R. L. , & Rubin , D. B. ( 2000 ). Contrasts and effect sizes in behavioral research . Cambridge , England : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Rosenthal , R. , & Rubin , D. ( 1978 ). Interpersonal expectancy effects: The first 345 studies . Behavior and Brain Sciences , 3 , 377 – 415 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sagie , A. , & Koslowsky , M. ( 1993 ). Detecting moderators with meta-analysis: An evaluation and comparison of techniques . Personnel Psychology , 46 , 629 – 640 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Salas , E. , Nichols , D. R. , & Driskell , J. E. ( 2007 ). Testing three team training strategies in intact teams: A meta-analysis . Small Group Research , 38 , 471 – 488 .
   Google Scholar
• Schmidt , F. L. ( 1992 ). What do data really mean? Research findings, meta-analysis, and cumulative knowledge in psychology . American Psychologist , 47 , 1173 – 1181 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schmidt , F. L. , Oh , I. S. , & Hayes , T. L. ( 2009 ). Fixed- versus random-effects models in meta-analysis: Model properties and an empirical comparison of differences in results . British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology , 62 , 97 – 128 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Sheehan , K. B. ( 2001 ). E-mail survey response rates: A review . Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication , 6 . Available at http://www.jcmc.indiana.edu/vol6/issue2/sheehan.html
   Google Scholar
• *Sherry , J. L. ( 2001 ). The effects of violent video games on aggression . Human Communication Research , 27 , 409 – 431 .
   Google Scholar
• *Snyder , L. B. , Hamilton , M. A. , Mitchell , E. W. , Kiwanuka-Tondo , J. , Fleming-Milici , F. , & Proctor , D. ( 2004 ). A meta-analysis of the effect of mediated health communication campaigns on behavior change in the United States . Journal of Health Communication , 9 , 71 – 96 .
   Google Scholar
• *Sopory , P. , & Dillard , J. P. ( 2002 ). The persuasive effects of metaphor: A meta-analysis . Human Communication Research , 28 , 382 – 419 .
   Google Scholar
• Stephen , T. , & Geel , R. ( 2007 ). Normative publication productivity of communication scholars at selected career milestones . Human Communication Research , 33 , 103 – 118 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Strom , R. E. , & Boster , F. J. (2007). Dropping out of high school: A meta-analysis assessing the effect of messages in the home and in school. Communication Education , 56, 433–452.
   Google Scholar
• Sun , Y. , Pan , Z. , & Shen , L. ( 2008 ). Understanding the third-person perception: Evidence from a meta-analysis . Journal of Communication , 58 , 280 – 300 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Timmerman , C. E. , & Kruepke , K. A. ( 2006 ). Computer-assisted instruction, media richness, and college student performance . Communication Education , 55 , 73 – 104 .
   Google Scholar
• Van den Hooff , B. , Groot , J. , & de Jonge , S. ( 2005 ). Situational influences on the use of communication technologies: A meta-analysis and exploratory study . Journal of Business Communication , 41 ( 2 ), 4 – 27 .
   Google Scholar
• Whitener , E. M. ( 1990 ). Confusion of confidence intervals and credibility intervals in meta-analysis . Journal of Applied Psychology , 75 , 315 – 321 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• *Witt , P. L. , Wheeless , L. R. , & Allen , M. ( 2004 ). A meta-analytical review of the relationship between teacher immediacy and student learning . Communication Monographs , 71 , 184 – 207 .
   Google Scholar