The potential of inoculation in promoting resistance to the effectiveness of comparative advertising messages

References

• Allen , M. , Hale , J. , Mongeau , P. , Berkowitz‐Stafford , S. , Stafford , S. , Shanahan , W. , Agee , P. , Dillon , K. , Jackson , R. and Ray , C. 1990 . Testing a model of message sidedness: Three replications . Communication Monographs , 57 : 275 – 291 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Alwit , L. F. and Mitchell , A. A. 1985 . Psychological processes and advertising effects: Theory, research, and application , Hillsdale, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Anderson , L. R. and McCuire , W. J. 1965 . Prior reassurance of group consensus as a factor in producing resistance to persuasion . Sociometry , 28 : 44 – 56 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Atkin , C. K. 1984 . “ Consumer and social effects of advertising ” . In Progress in communication sciences , Edited by: Dervin , B. and Voigt , M. J. Vol. 4 , 205 – 248 . Norwood, NJ : Ablex Publishing Corporation .
   Google Scholar
• Becker , S. W. , Bavelas , A. and Braden , M. 1961 . An index to measure contingency of English sentences,”; . Language and Speech , 4 : 138 – 145 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Barry , T. E. and Tremblay , R. L. 1975 . Comparative advertising: Perspectives and issues . Journal of Advertising , 4 : 15 – 20 .
   Google Scholar
• Bither , S. W. , Dolich , I.J. and Nell , E. B. 1971 . The application of attitude immunization techniques in marketing . Journal of Marketing Research , 18 : 56 – 61 .
   Google Scholar
• Boddewyn , J. J. and Marton , K. 1978 . Comparison advertising: A worldwide study , NewYork : Hastings House .
   Google Scholar
• Britt , S. H. , Adams , S. C. and Miller , A. S. 1972 . How many advertising exposures per day . Journal of Advertising Research , 12 : 3 – 9 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Burgoon , M. , Burgoon , J. K. , Riess , M. , Butler , J. , Montgomery , C. L. , Stinnett , W. D. , Miller , M. , Long , M. , Vaughn , D. and Caine , B. 1976 . Propensity of persuasive attack and intensity of pretreatment messages as predictors of resistance to persuasion . Journal of Psychology , 92 : 123 – 129 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Burgoon , M. and Chase , L. J. 1973 . The effects of differential linguistic patterns in messages attempting to induce resistance to persuasion . Speech Monographs , 40 : 1 – 7 .
   Google Scholar
• Burgoon , M. , Cohen , M. , Miller , M. D. and Montgomery , C. L. 1978 . An empirical test of a model of resistance to persuasion . Human Communication Research , 5 : 27 – 39 .
   Google Scholar
• Burgoon , M. and King , L. B. 1974 . The mediation of resistance to persuasion strategies by language variables and active‐passive participation . Human Communication Research , 1 : 30 – 41 .
   Google Scholar
• Burnkrant , R. E. and Sawyer , A. C. 1983 . “ Effects of involvement and message content on information‐processing intensity ” . In Information processing research in advertising , Edited by: Harris , R. J. 43 – 64 . Hillsdale, NJ : Erlbaum .
   Google Scholar
• Chaiken , S. 1980 . Heuristic versus systematic message processing and the use of source versus message cues in persuasion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 39 : 752 – 766 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Clarke , K. and Belk , R. K. 1978 . “ The effects of product involvement and task definition on anticipated consumer effort ” . In Advances in Consumer Research , Edited by: Hunt , H. K. Vol. 5 , 313 – 318 . Ann Arbor, Ml : Association for Consumer Research .
   Google Scholar
• Cohen , J. B. and Goldberg , M. E. 1970 . The dissonance model in decision product evaluation . Journal of Marketing Research , 7 : 315 – 321 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dougherty , P. H. 1973 . Advertising: Comparison issue . New York Times , November 14
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Droge , C. 1989 . Shaping the route to attitude change: Central versus peripheral processing through comparative versus noncomparative advertising . Journal of Marketing Research , 26 : 193 – 204 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Etgar , M. and Goodwin , S. A. 1978 . “ Comparative advertising: Issues and problems,” . In Advances in consumer research , Edited by: Hunt , H. K. Vol. 5 , 63 – 71 . Chicago : Association for Consumer Research .
   Google Scholar
• Freedman , J. L. and Steinbruner , J. D. 1964 . Perceived choice and resistance to persuasion . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology , 68 : 678 – 681 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gardner , M. , Mitchell , A. and Staelin , R. 1977 . “ The effects of attacks and inoculations in a public policy context ” . In Contemporary marketing thought: 1977 educators’ proceedings , Edited by: Greenberg , B. A. and Bellenger , D. N. 292 – 297 . Chicago : American Marketing Association .
   Google Scholar
• Golden , L. L. 1974 . “ Consumer reactions to comparative advertising ” . In Advances in consumer research , Edited by: Anderson , B. B. Vol. 3 , 63 – 67 . Urbana, IL : Association for Consumer Research .
   Google Scholar
• Golden , L. L. 1979 . Consumer reactions to explicit brand comparisons in advertisements . Journal of Marketing Research , 16 : 517 – 532 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Goodwin , S. and Etgar , M. 1980 . An experimental investigation of comparative advertising: Impact of message appeal, information load, and utility of product class . Journal of Marketing Research , 17 : 187 – 202 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Greenwald , A. G. and Leavitt , C. 1984 . Audience involvement in advertising: Four levels . Journal of Consumer Research , 11 : 581 – 592 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hass , R. G. and Linder , D. E. 1972 . Counterargument availability and the effects of message structure on persuasion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 23 : 219 – 233 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Houston , M. J. , Childers , T. L. and Heckler , S. E. 1987 . Picture‐word consistency and the elaborative processing of advertisements . Journal of Marketing Research , 24 : 359 – 369 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Howard , J. A. and Sheth , J. N. 1969 . The theory of buying behavior , New York : John Wiley .
   Google Scholar
• Huberty , C. J. and Morris , J. D. 1989 . Multivariate analysis versus multiple univariate analyses . Psychological Bulletin , 105 : 302 – 308 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hunt , H. K. 1973 . Effects of corrective advertising . Journal of Advertising Research , 13 : 15 – 24 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Hupfer , N. and Gardner , D. 1971 . “ Differential involvement with products and issues ” . In Proceedings: Association for Consumer Research , Edited by: Gardner , D. 262 – 269 . College Park, MD : Association for Consumer Research .
   Google Scholar
• Infante , D. A. 1975 . Effects of opinionated language on communicator image and in conferring resistance to persuasion . Western Speech Communication , 39 : 112 – 119 .
   Google Scholar
• Jackson , S. and Allen , M. Meta‐analysis of the effectiveness of one‐sided and two‐sided argumentation . Paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Communication Association . Montreal, Canada. June .
   Google Scholar
• Jain , S. C. and Hackleman , E. C. 1978 . How effective is comparison advertising for stimulating brand recall? . Journal of Advertising , 7 : 20 – 25 .
   Google Scholar
• Johnson , B. T. and Eagly , A. H. 1989 . Effects of involvement in persuasion: A meta‐analysis . Psychological Bulletin , 106 : 290 – 314 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kamins , M. A. and Asseal , H. 1987 . Two‐sided versus one‐sided appeals: A cognitive perspective on argumentation, source derogation, and the effect of disconfirming trial on belief change . Journal of Marketing Research , 24 : 29 – 39 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Kassarjian , H. H. and Kassarjian , W. M. 1979 . “ Attitudes under low commitment conditions ” . In Attitude research plays for high stakes , Edited by: Maloney , J. C. and Silverman , B. 3 – 15 . Chicago : American Marketing Association .
   Google Scholar
• Krugman , H. E. 1965 . The impact of television advertising: learning without involvement . Public Opinion Quarterly , 29 : 349 – 356 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Lamb , C. W. , Pletcher , B. A. and Pride , W. M. 1979 . Print readers’ perceptions of various advertising formats . Journalism Quarterly , 56 : 328 – 335 .
   Google Scholar
• Lamb , C. W. , Pride , W. M. and Pletcher , B. A. 1978 . A taxonomy for comparative advertising research . Journal of Advertising , 7 : 43 – 47 .
   Google Scholar
• Lastovicka , J. L. and Gardner , D. M. 1979 . “ Components of involvement ” . In Attitude research plays for high stakes , Edited by: Maloney , J. C. and Silverman , B. 53 – 73 . Chicago : American Marketing Association .
   Google Scholar
• Levine , P. 1976 . Commercials that name competing brands . Journal of Advertising Research , 16 : 1 – 14 .
   Google Scholar
• Levy , R. 1987 . Big resurgence in comparative ads. Dun's . Business Month , 129 : 56 – 58 .
   Google Scholar
• Lumsdaine , A. A. and Janis , I. L. 1953 . Resistance to “counterpropaganda”; produced by one‐sided and two‐sided “propaganda”; presentations . Public Opinion Quarterly , 17 : 311 – 318 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Mazis , M. B. 1976 . A theoretical and empirical examination of comparative advertising , College of Business Administration Working Paper University of Florida .
   Google Scholar
• McCroskey , J. C. 1970 . The effects of evidence as an inhibitor of counter‐persuasion . Speech Monographs , 37 : 188 – 194 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McCroskey , J. C. , Young , T. J. and Scott , M. D. 1972 . The effects of message sidedness and evidence on inoculation against counterpersuasion in small group communication . Speech Monographs , 34 : 205 – 212 .
   Google Scholar
• McDougall , G. H. G. 1977 . “ Comparative advertising: Consumer issues and attitudes ” . In Contemporary marketing thought: 1977 educators‘ proceedings , Edited by: Greenberg , B.A. and Bellenger , D. N. 286 – 291 . Chicago : American Marketing Association .
   Google Scholar
• McGuire , W. J. 1961 . The effectiveness of supportive and refutational defenses in immunizing and restoring beliefs against persuasion . Sociometry , 24 : 184 – 197 .
   Google Scholar
• McGuire , W. J. 1962 . Persistence of the resistance to persuasion induced by various types of prior belief defenses . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology , 64 : 241 – 248 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McCuire , W. J. 1966 . “ Persistence of the resistance to persuasion induced by various types of prior belief defenses ” . In Problems in social psychology: Selected readings , Edited by: Backman , C. W. and Secord , P. F. 128 – 135 . New York : McGraw‐Hill .
   Google Scholar
• McGuire , W. J. 1970 . A vaccine for brainwash . Psychology Today , 3 February : 36 – 39 .
   Google Scholar
• McGuire , W. J. and Papageorgis , D. 1961 . The relative efficacy of various types of prior belief‐defense in producing immunity against persuasion . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology , 62 : 327 – 337 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McGuire , W. J. and Papageorgis , D. 1962 . Effectiveness of forewarning in developing resistance to persuasion . Public Opinion Quarterly , 26 : 24 – 34 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Miller , G. R. and Burgoon , M. 1973 . New techniques of persuasion , New York : Harper & Row Publishers .
   Google Scholar
• Miller , M. D. and Burgoon , M. 1979 . The relationship between violations of expectations and the induction of resistance to persuasion . Human Communication Research , 5 : 301 – 313 .
   Google Scholar
• Mitchell , A. A. Involvement: A potentially important mediator of consumer behavior . Advances in consumer research: Proceedings of the Association for Consumer Research ninth annual conference Miami Beach . October 1978 , Florida. Edited by: Wilkie , W. L. Vol. 6 , pp. 191 – 196 . Urbana, IL : Association for Consumer Research .
   Google Scholar
• Muehling , D. D. , Stem , D. E. Jr. and Raven , P. 1989 . Comparative advertising: Views from advertisers, agencies, media, and policy makers . Journal of Advertising Research , 29 : 38 – 48 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Murphy , J. H. II and Amundson , M. S. 1981 . The communications‐effectiveness of comparative advertising for a new brand on users of the dominant brand . Journal of Advertising , 10 : 14 – 48 .
   Google Scholar
• Papageorgis , D. and McGuire , W. J. 1961 . The generality of immunity to persuasion produced by pre‐exposure to weakened counterarguments . Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology , 62 : 475 – 481 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Petty , R. E. and Cacioppo , J. T. 1979 . Issue involvement can increase or decrease persuasion by enhancing message‐relevant cognitive responses . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 37 : 1915 – 1926 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Petty , R. E. and Cacioppo , J. T. 1984 . The effects of involvement in responses to argument quantity and quality: Central and peripheral routes to persuasion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 46 : 69 – 81 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Petty , R. E. , Cacioppo , J. T. and Goldman , R. 1981 . Personal involvement as a determinant of argument‐based persuasion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 41 : 847 – 855 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Petty , R. E. , Cacioppo , J. T. and Schumann , D. 1983 . Central and peripheral routes to advertising effectiveness: The moderating role of involvement . Journal of Consumer Research , 10 : 135 – 146 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pfau , M. Impact of product involvement, message format, and receiver gender on the efficacy of comparative advertising messages . Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Speech Communication Association . Atlanta, GA. November .
   Google Scholar
• Pfau , M. and Burgoon , M. 1988 . Inoculation in political campaign communication . Human Communication Research , 15 : 91 – 111 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pfau , M. , Kenski , H.C. , Nitz , M. and Sorenson , J. 1990 . Efficacy of inoculation strategies in promoting resistance to political attack messages: Application to direct mail . Communication Monographs , 57 : 25 – 43 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Prasad , V. K. 1976 . Communications‐effectiveness of comparative advertising: A laboratory analysis . Journal of Marketing Research , 13 : 128 – 137 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Pride , W. M. , Lamb , C. W. Jr. and Pletcher , B. A. 1977 . “ Are comparative advertisements more informative for owners of the mentioned competing brand than for nonowners ” . In Contemporary marketing thought: 1977 educators‘ proceedings , Series 41 Edited by: Greenberg , B. A. and Bellenger , D. N. 298 – 301 . Chicago : American Marketing Association .
   Google Scholar
• Pride , W. M. , Lamb , C. W. and Pletcher , B. A. 1979 . The informativeness of comparative advertisements: An empirical investigation . Journal of Advertising , 8 : 29 – 48 .
   Google Scholar
• Pryor , B. and Steinfatt , T. M. 1978 . The effects of initial belief level on inoculation theory and its proposed mechanisms . Human Communication Research , 4 : 217 – 230 .
   Google Scholar
• Ray , M. L. 1976 . “ Attitude as communication response ” . In Attitude research at bay Edited by: Johnson , D. and Wells , W. D.
   Google Scholar
• Rosser , C. 1990 . Involvement, attention, and perceptions of message relevance in the response to persuasive appeals . Communication Research , 17 : 571 – 600 .
   Google Scholar
• Rothschild , M. L. and Ray , M. L. 1974 . Involvement and political advertising effect: An exploratory experiment . Communication Research , 1 : 291 – 308 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Salmon , C. T. 1986 . “ Perspectives in involvement in consumer and communication research ” . In Progress in communication sciences , Edited by: Dervin , B. and Voigt , M. J. Vol. 7 , 243 – 268 . Norwood, NJ : Ablex Publishing Corporation .
   Google Scholar
• Sheluga , D. A. and Jacoby , J. 1978 . “ Do comparative claims encourage comparative shopping? The impact of comparative claims on consumers’ acquisition of product information ” . In Current issues and research in advertising , Edited by: Leigh , J. and Martin , C. R. Division of Research, Graduate School of Business Administration, the University of Michigan .
   Google Scholar
• Shimp , T. A. and Dyer , D. C. 1978 . The effects of comparative advertising mediated by market position of sponsoring brand . Journal of Advertising , 7 : 13 – 19 .
   Google Scholar
• Sujan , M. and Dekleva , C. 1987 . Product categorization and influence making: Some implications for comparative advertising . Journal of Consumer Research , 14 : 372 – 378 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Swinyard , W. R. 1981 . The interaction between comparative advertising and copy claim variation . Journal of Marketing Research , 28 : 175 – 186 .
   Google Scholar
• Szybillo , C. J. and Heslin , R. 1973 . Resistance to persuasion: Inoculation theory in a marketing context . Journal of Marketing Research , 20 : 396 – 403 .
   Google Scholar
• Tannenbaum , P. H. , Macaulay , J. R. and Norris , E. L. 1966 . Principle of congruity and reduction of persuasion . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 2 : 233 – 238 .
   Google Scholar
• Tannenbaum , P. H. and Norris , E. L. 1965 . Effects of curbing congruity principle strategies for the reduction of persuasion . Sociometry , 28 : 145 – 157 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Tyebjee , T. T. 1979 . Response time, conflict, and involvement in brand choice . Journal of Consumer Research , 6 : 259 – 304 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ulanoff , S. M. February 1975 . Comparison advertising: An historical retrospective , Marketing Science Institute Working Paper February , 9 – 46 .
   Google Scholar
• Ullman , W. R. and Bodaken , E. M. 1975 . Inducing resistance to persuasive attack: A test of two strategies of communication . Western Speech Communication , 39 : 240 – 248 .
   Google Scholar
• Wilson , R. D. 1976 . “ An empirical evaluation of comparative advertising messages: Subjects’ responses on perceptual dimensions ” . In Advances in consumer research , Edited by: Anderson , B. B. Vol. 3 , 53 – 57 . Association for Consumer Research .
   Google Scholar
• Wilson , R. D. and Mudderisoglu , A. August 1979 . An analysis of cognitive responses to comparative advertising , Working series in marketing number 84 August , Pennsylvania State University .
   Google Scholar
• Wright , P. L. 1974 . Analyzing media effects on advertising responses . Public Opinion Quarterly , 38 : 192 – 205 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Zaichkowsky , J. L. 1985 . Measuring the involvement construct . Journal of Consumer Research , 12 : 341 – 352 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar