Faddism and quackery in cancer nutritionFootnote∗

This paper is based on a talk presented at a meeting entitled “Cancer 1981/Cancer 2001: An International Colloquium,”; sponsored by the MD Anderson Hospital and held in Houston, TX, November 12, 1981.

References and Notes

• Herbert , V . 1981 . Nutrition Cultism: Facts & Fictions, 3rd printing (revised) , Philadelphia : George F. Stickley Co. .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V and Barrett , S . 1981 . Vitamins and “Health” Foods: The Great American Hustle , Philadelphia : George F. Stickley Co. .
   Google Scholar
• The Editors of Consumer Reports Books . 1980 . Health Quackery , Orangeburg, NY : Consumers Union .
   Google Scholar
• Brody , JE and Holleb , AI . 1977 . You CanFight Cancer and Win , New York : Times Books, Quadrangle .
   Google Scholar
• Morra , M and Potts , E . 1980 . Choices: Realistic Alternatives in Cancer Treatment , New York : Avon Books .
   Google Scholar
• Levitt , PM , Guralnick , EDS , Kagan , AR and Gilbert , H . 1979 . The Cancer Reference Book , New York : Dell Publishing Co., Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• The Editors of Time‐Life Books . 1981 . Fighting Cancer , Alexandria, VA : Time‐Life Books, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• Hudnall , M . 1982 . “ACSH Survey: How Popular Magazines Rate on Nutrition” . ACSH News and Views , 3 (1) : 1 – 2 .
   Google Scholar
• van Eys , J , Seelig , MS and Nichols , BL , eds. 1979 . Nutrition and Cancer , New York : SP Medical & Scientific Books .
   Google Scholar
• Winick , M , ed. 1977 . Nutrition and Cancer , New York : John Wiley & Sons, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• Rosenbaum , EH , Stitt , CN , Drasin , H and Rosenbaum , I . 1980 . Nutrition for the Cancer Patient , Palo Alto, CA : Bull Publishing Co. .
   Google Scholar
• Aker , S and Lenssen , P . 1976 . A Guide to Good Nutrition: During and After Chemotherapy and Radiation, , 2nd ed , Seattle : Research Dietary Services of the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center .
   Google Scholar
• US Dept. of Health and Human Services . 1981 . Diet and Nutrition: A Resource for Parents of Children With Cancer , Washington, DC : US Government Printing Office . NIH Publication No. 81–2038
   Google Scholar
• US Dept. of Health and Human Services . 1981 . Eating Hints: Recipes and Tips for Better Nutrition During Cancer Treatment , Washington, DC : US Government Printing Office . NIH Publication No. 81–2079
   Google Scholar
• US Dept. of Health and Human Services . 1981 . Nutrition and the Cancer Patient: An Annotated Bibliography of Patient and Professional Information and Educational Materials, , 2nd ed. , Washington, DC : US Government Printing Office . NIH Publication No. 81–1511
   Google Scholar
• Darby , WJ . 1974 . “The Allure of Quackery: The Unicorn and Other Lessons From History” . Nutr Rev , 32 ( Suppl. 1 ) : 57
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Bruch , H . 1970 . “The Allure of Food Cults and Nutrition Quackery” . J Am Diet Assoc , 57 : 316
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McBean , L and Speckman , EW . 1974 . “Food Faddism: A Challenge to Nutritionists and Dietitians” . Am J Clin Nutr , 27 : 1071
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Schaefer , R and Yetley , EA . 1975 . “Social Psychology of Food Faddism” . J Am Diet Assoc , 66 : 129
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Barrett , S . 1981 . The Health Robbers, , 2nd ed. , 20a Philadelphia : George F. Stickley Co. . Complimentary copies of this report may be obtained from Congressman Pepper.
   Google Scholar
• 1981 . “Low Reading Comprehension Found” . The New York Times , 12 November : 13
   Google Scholar
• Morowitz , HJ . 1978 . “Drinking Hemlock and Other Nutritional Matters” . Hosp Pract , 13 : 155
   Google Scholar
• Koeffler , HP , Lowe , L and Golde , DW . 1980 . “Amygdalin (Laetrile): Effect on Clonogenic Cells From Human Myeloid Leukemia Cell Lines and Normal Human Marrow” . Cancer Treat Rep , 64 : 105 – 109 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• van Eys , J . 1981 . “Tumor‐Host Competition for Nutrients” . Paper presented at meeting entitled “Cancer 1981/Cancer 2001: An International Colloquium . November 13 1981 . Houston, TX : MD Anderson Hospital and Tumor Institute .
   Google Scholar
• Gross , L . 1983 . Oncogenic Viruses, , 3rd ed. , New York : Pergamon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1983 . “The Inhibition of Some Cancers and the Promotion of Others by Folic Acid, Vitamin B12, and Their Antagonists” . In Nutritional Factors in the Induction and Maintenance of Malignancy , Edited by: Butterworth , CE Jr and Hutchinson , M . 273 – 287 . New York : Academic Press .
   Google Scholar
• Morrison , SD . 1982 . “Control of Food Intake in the Experimental Cancerous Host” . In Molecular Interrelations of Nutrition and Cancer , Edited by: Arnott , MS , van Eys , J and Wang , YM . 123 – 135 . New York : Raven Press .
   Google Scholar
• van Eys , J . 1982 . “Nutrition, Basic Science, and Past Mistakes” . In Molecular Interrelations of Nutrition and Cancer , Edited by: Arnott , MS , van Eys , J and Wang , YM . 449 – 456 . New York : Raven Press .
   Google Scholar
• Ames , BN . 1983 . “Dietary Carcinogens and Anticarcinogens” . Science , 221 : 1256 – 1263 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Committee on Food Protection of the Food and Nutrition Board . 1973 . Toxicants Occurring Naturally in Foods; , 2nd ed. , Washington DC : National Academy of Sciences .
   Google Scholar
• Johnson , GT and Goldfinger , SW , eds. 1981 . The Harvard Medical School Health Letter Book , Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1979 . “Laetrile: The Cult of Cyanide. Promoting Poison for Profit” . Am J Clin Nutr , 32 : 1121 – 1158 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• American Cancer Society . 1979 . “Unproven Methods of Cancer Management” . New York : The American Cancer Society .
   Google Scholar
• Young , JH . 1980 . “Laetrile in Historical Perspective” . In Science and Cancer , Edited by: Markle , GE and Petersen , JC . Boulder, CO : Westview Press, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1981 . “Nutrition Cultism” . West JMed , 135 : 252 – 256 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1979 . “Pangamic Acid ('Vitamin B15’)” . Am J Clin Nutr , 32 : 1534 – 1540 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Herbert , V and Herbert , R . 1981 . “Pangamate ('Vitamin B15’)” . In Controversies in Nutrition , Edited by: Ellenbogen , L . New York : Churchill Livingstone, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• McPherrin , EW , Herbert , V and Herbert , R . 1981 . “Vitamin B15 Anatomy of a Health Fraud” . New York : American Council on Science and Health .
   Google Scholar
• Moertel , CG , Fleming , TR , Rubin , J , Kvols , LK , Sarna , G , Koch , R , Currie , VE , Young , CW , Jones , SE and Davignon , JP . 1982 . “A Clinical Trial of Amygdalin (Laetrile) in the Treatment of Human Cancer” . NEngl J Med , 306 : 201 – 207 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1977 . “A Book Whose Time Has Not Yet Come” . Am Med News , 20 (37) : 22
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Committee on Diet, Nutrition, and Cancer, Assembly of Life Sciences, National Research Council . 1982 . Diet, Nutrition, and Cancer , Washington DC : National Academy of Sciences Press .
   Google Scholar
• Abelson , P . 1983 . “Dietary Carcinogens” . Science , 221 : 1249
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Black , CA , ed. 1982 . Diet, Nutrition and Cancer: A Critique , Ames, IA : Council for Agricultural Science and Technology . Special Publication No. 13.
   Google Scholar
• Young , VR . . “Diet as a Risk Factor for Cancer: A Brief Overview” . Proceedings of the 1982 Lillian Fountain Smith Conference for Nutrition Educators . Edited by: Jansen , GR and Anderson , J . Fort Collins, CO : Colorado State University .
   Google Scholar
• 1977 . Canada's Food Guide: Handbook , Ottawa : Ministry of National Health and Welfare, Bureau of Nutritional Sciences, Health Protection Branch . (Cat. No. H21–74/1977)
   Google Scholar
• US Department of Agriculture . Food , Home and Garden Bulletin No. 228 Washington, DC : Human Nutrition Center, US Department of Agriculture. (Order from: Superintendent of Documents, US Government Printing Of fice . Washington, DC 20402
   Google Scholar
• American Cancer Society . 1984 . Nutrition and Cancer: Cause and Prevention , American Cancer Society Special Report New York : American Cancer Society .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1979 . “The Nutritionally and Metabolically Destructive ‘Nutritional and Metabolic Antineoplastic Diet’ of Laetrile Proponents” . Am J Clin Nutr , 32 : 96 – 98 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1980 . “Reply to Letter by MF McCarty” . Am JClin Nutr , 33 : 9 – 12 .
   Google Scholar
• Young , VR and Richardson , DP . 1979 . “Nutrients, Vitamins and Minerals in Cancer Prevention: Facts and Fallacies” . Cancer , 43 : 2125 – 2136 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Bertino , JR . 1979 . “Nutrients, Vitamins and Minerals as Therapy” . Cancer , 43 : 2137 – 2142 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Bothwell , TH , Charlton , RW , Cook , JD and Finch , CA , eds. 1979 . Iron Metabolism in Man , Oxford : Blackwell Scientific Publications, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• Fairbanks , VF and Beutler , E . 1977 . “Iron Deficiency” . In Hematology, , 2nd ed. , Edited by: Williams , WJ , Beutler , E , Erslev , AJ and Rundles , RW . 365 – 386 . New York : McGraw‐Hill, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1975 . “Drugs Effective in Iron‐Deficiency and Other Hypochromic Anemias” . In The Pharmacological Basis of Therapeutics, , 5th ed. , Edited by: Goodman , LS and Gilman , A . 1309 – 1323 . New York : Macmillan, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• Robinson , CH and Lawler , MR . 1977 . Normaland Therapeutic Nutrition, , 15th ed. , New York : Macmillan, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• Committee on Dietary Allowances, Food and Nutrition Board, National Research Council . 1980 . Recommended Dietary Allowances, , 9th ed. , Washington DC : National Academy of Sciences Press .
   Google Scholar
• Avioli , LV . 1980 . “Calcium and Phosphorus” . In Modern Nutrition in Health and Disease, , 6th ed. , Edited by: Goodhart , RS and Shils , ME . 294 – 309 . Philadelphia : Lea & Febiger .
   Google Scholar
• Recker , RR . 1983 . “Osteoporosis” . Contemp Nutr , 8 (5) : 1 – 2 .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V , Colman , N and Jacob , E . 1980 . “Folic Acid and Vitamin B12” . In Modern Nutrition in Health and Disease, , 6th ed. , Edited by: Goodhart , RS and Shils , ME . 229 – 258 . Philadelphia : Lea & Febiger .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1982 . “Hematology and the Anemias” . In Nutritional Support of Medical Practice, , 2nd ed. , Edited by: Schneider , HA , Anderson , CE and Coursin , DG . New York : Harper & Row Publishers, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V and Drivas , G . 1982 . “Spirulina and Vitamin B12” . JAMA , 248 : 3096 – 3097 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Herbert , V , Drivas , G , Chu , M , Levitt , D and Cooper , B . 1983 . “Differential Radioassays Better Measure Cobalamin Content of Vitamins and ‘Health Foods’ Than Do Microbiologic Assays. Some Products Sold to Vegetarians as Rich Vitamin B12 Sources Are Not. The Official United States Pharmacopeia (U.S.P) Method (L. leichmannii ) and E. gracilis Assay as ‘Vitamin B12’ Noncobalamin Corrinoids” . Blood , 62 ( Suppl. 1 ) : 37A
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Bowman , BB , Kushner , RF , Dawson , SC and Levin , B . 1984 . “Macrobiotic Diets for Cancer Treatment and Prevention” . J Clin Oncol , 2 : 702 – 711 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Committee on Nutrition, American Academy of Pediatrics . 1977 . “Nutritional Aspects of Vegetarianism, Health Foods, and Fad Diets” . Pediatrics , 59 : 460
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Dwyer , JT , Dietz , WH Jr , Hass , G and Suskind , R . 1979 . “Risk of Nutritional Rickets Among Vegetarian Children” . Am J Dis Child , 133 : 134 – 140 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 1979 . “Vegetarian Diets” . Med Lett Drugs Ther , 21 : 62 – 63 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 1978 . “Laetrile: Not So Harmless” . Emerg Med , 10 : 55
   Google Scholar
• 1977 . “Toxicityof Laetrile” . FDA Drug Bull , 7 (5) : 25
   Google Scholar
• 1978 . “Case Against ‘Nontoxic’ Laetrile Grows” . Med World News , 19 : 16 21
   Google Scholar
• Conn , EE . 1973 . “Cyanogenetic Glycosides” . In Toxicants Occurring Naturally in Foods, , 2nd ed. , Edited by: Committee on Food Protection of the Food and Nutrition Board . 299 – 308 . Washington, DC : National Academy of Sciences Press .
   Google Scholar
• Backer , RC and Herbert , V . 1979 . “Cyanide Production From Laetrile in the Presence of Megadoses of Ascorbic Acid” . JAMA , 241 : 1891 – 1892 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Swartz , RD , Wesley , JR , Somermeyer , MG and Lau , K . 1984 . “Hyperoxaluria and Renal Insufficiency Due to Ascorbic Acid Administration During Total Parenteral Nutrition” . Ann Int Med , 100 : 530 – 531 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . . “The Rationale of Massive‐Dose Vitamin Therapy. (Megavitamin Therapy: Hot Fiction vs. Cold Facts)” . Proceedings, Western Hemisphere Nutrition Congress IV . Acton, MA. Edited by: White , PL and Selvey , N . pp. 84 – 91 . Publishing Sciences Group .
   Google Scholar
• Hodges , RE . 1980 . “Food Fads and ‘Megavitamins’“ ” . In Nutrition in Medical Practice , Edited by: Hodges , RE . Philadelphia : W.B. Saunders Co. .
   Google Scholar
• Marshall , CW . 1983 . Vitamins and Minerals: Help or Harm? , Philadelphia : George F. Stickley Co. .
   Google Scholar
• Creagan , ET , Moertel , CG , O'Fallon , JR , Schutt , AJ , O'Connell , MJ , Rubin , J and Frytak , S . 1979 . “Failure of High‐Dose Vitamin C to Benefit Patients With Advanced Cancer” . N Engl J Med , 301 : 687
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• DiPalma , JR and McMichael , R . 1979 . “The Interaction of Vitamins With Cancer Chemotherapy” . CA , 29 : 280 – 286 .
   Google Scholar
• 1984 . “Selenium Intoxication—New York” . Morbidity Mortality Weekly Rpt , 33 (12) : 157 – 158 .
   Google Scholar
• Rechcigl , M Jr , ed. 1978 . “Effect of Nutrient Excesses and Toxicities in Animals and Man” . In CRC Handbook Series in Nutrition and Food, Section E, Nutritional Disorders , Vol. 1 , Boca Raton, FL : CRC Press, Inc. .
   Google Scholar
• 1977 . Physicians Desk Reference , 1656 Oradell, NJ : Medical Economics Books .
   Google Scholar
• Albanese , AA and Orto , LA . 1975 . “The Proteins and Amino Acids” . In Modern Nutrition in Health and Disease , Edited by: Goodhart , RS and Shils , ME . 28 – 88 . Philadelphia : Lea & Febiger .
   Google Scholar
• Colman , N , Herbert , V , Gardner , A and Gelernt , M . 1980 . “Mutagenicity of Dimethylglycine When Mixed With Nitrite: Possible Significance in Human Use of Pangamates” . Proc Soc Exp Biol Med , 164 : 9 – 12 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Gelernt , MD and Herbert , V . 1982 . “Mutagenicity of Diisopropylamine Dichloroacetate, the ‘Active Constituent’ of Vitamin B15 (Pangamic Acid)” . Nutr Cancer , 3 : 129 – 133 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Windholz , M , Budavari , S , Stroumtsos , LY and Fertig , MN , eds. 1976 . The Merck Index, , 9th ed. , Rahway, NJ : Merck and Company .
   Google Scholar
• Osuntokun , BO . . Toxicology in the Tropics . Proceedings of an International Symposium held at the University of Ibadan . February 1979 , London, Nigeria. “A Degenerative Neuropathy With Blindness and Chronic Cyanide Intoxication of Dietary Origin: The Evidence in the Nigerians” , Edited by: Bababunmi , EA and Smith , RL . Taylor & Francis Ltd. .
   Google Scholar
• Osuntokun , BO . 1981 . “Cassava Diet, Chronic Cyanide Intoxication, and Neuropathy in the Nigerian Africans” . In World Review of Nutrition and Dietetics , Edited by: Bourne , GH . 141 – 173 . Basel : S. Karger AG .
   Google Scholar
• 1983 . “Laetrile Promoter Goes to Jail” . CCAHF Newsletter , 6 (3) : 2
   Google Scholar
• 1983 . San Francisco Chronicle , 13 May
   Google Scholar
• 16 September 1982 . “ Report of the Regents Review Committee of the University of the State of New York: “In the matter of proceedings by the State Board for Professional Medical Conduct to determine the action to be taken with respect to the revocation or suspension of the license heretofore granted to Donald Robert Cole, M.D., to practice medicine in the State of New York..., “ ” . 16 September , No. 2476
   Google Scholar
• 1983 . “Cancer Issue Costs Doctor State License” . The New York Times , 30 September : B9
   Google Scholar
• 1983 . “New York State's Discipline of Physicians Covers a Range of Misconduct” . The New York Times , 3 April : 30
   Google Scholar
• Brian E. Briggs, M.D., vs. Minnesota Board of Medical Examiners. State of Minnesota, County of Hennepin, District Court, Fourth Judicial District, Court File No. AP804847, Order and Memorandum of Judge Pamela G. Alexander upholding revocation of the medical license of Dr. Briggs, in part because “Petitioner's medical philosophy, including his use of metabolic therapy and laetrile for treating cancer sufferers, is not recognized as proper treatment in Minnesota.... It should be noted that, while each of the drugs or therapies noted in the facts identifies a breach of the standard, and in some cases potential harm to a patient, their combination in treatment could mean even greater harm to a patient...”
   Google Scholar
• Vogel , SN and Sultan , TR . 1981 . “Cyanide Poisoning” . Clin Toxicol , 18 : 367 – 383 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Ortega , JA and Creek , J . 1979 . “Acute Cyanide Poisoning Following Administration of Laetrile Enemas” . J Pediatr , 93 : 1059
   Google Scholar
• Eisele , JW and Reay , DT . 1980 . “Deaths Related to Coffee Enemas” . JAMA , 244 : 1608 – 1609 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Miner , JW . 1964 . “The Phillips Case: A New Dimension in Murder” . J Forensic Sci , 9 : 1
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Magnusson , WG and Carper , J . 1968 . The Dark Side of the Marketplace: The Plight of the American Consumer , 156 – 184 . Englewood Cliffs, NJ : Prentice‐Hall .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V , Jarvis , WT and Monaco , GP . 1983 . “Commentary. Obstacles to Nutrition Education” . Health Values , 7 (2) : 38 – 41 .
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1981 . “Will Questionable Nutrition Overwhelm Nutrition Science?” . Am J Clin Nutr , 34 : 2848 – 2853 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• Herbert , V . . “Food Fads and Quackery” . Proceedings of the Lillian Fountain Smith Conference for Nutrition Educators . Fort Collins. Edited by: Jansen , GR and Anderson , J . CO : Colorado State University .
   Google Scholar
• US Office of Education . 1974 . Pollution in Higher Education , Washington DC : US Office of Education .
   Google Scholar
• McGrath , E. 1984 . “Sending Degrees to the Dogs” . Time , 2 April : 90
   Google Scholar
• Herbert , V . 1982 . “Legal Aspects of Specious Dietary Claims” . Bull NY Acad Med , 58 : 242 – 253 .
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• In the Matter of Tugender, 451 A. 2d 1328 (NJ Superior Court, Appellate Division, 28 September 1982).
   Google Scholar
• Special Committee on Aging . April 1983 . Consumer Frauds and Elderly Persons: A Growing Problem , April , Washington DC : The United States Senate .
   Google Scholar
• 19 March 1981 . “Nobel Laureate Says Scientists Must Forcefully Reject Cult Attacks” . In Peninsula Times Tribune 19 March , 13 – 15 . Oakland, CA
   Google Scholar
• 1981 . “New Chairman of Trade Panel Asks Rule Shift: Says Buyers Don't Need US Shield on Defects” . The New York Times , 27 October : 1
   Google Scholar
• This work was supported in part by the Research Service of the Veterans Administration and USPHS Grant No. AM20526.
   Google Scholar
• This paper is based on a talk presented at a meeting entitled “Cancer 1981/Cancer 2001: An International Colloquium,”; sponsored by the MD Anderson Hospital and held in Houston, TX, November 12, 1981.
   Google Scholar