1,393
Views
60
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

The Devil Is in the Definitions

Contrasting American and German Approaches to Zoning

Pages 436-450 | Published online: 22 Jun 2010

References

  • Alterman , R. 1997 . The challenge of farmland preservation: Lessons from a six-nation comparison . Journal of the American Planning Association , 63 ( 2 ) : 220 – 243 .
  • American Planning Association. 1998 . Planning Advisory Service report no. 479: The principles of smart development , Chicago : Author .
  • Angotti , T. and Hanhardt , E. 2001 . Problems and prospects for healthy mixed-use communities in New York City . Planning Practice and Research , 16 ( 2 ) : 145 – 154 .
  • Asabere , P. and Forrest , H. 1997 . Hierarchical zoning, incompatible uses and price discounts . Real Estate Economics , 25 ( 3 ) : 439 – 451 .
  • Beatley , T. 2000 . Green urbanism: Learning from European cities , Washington, DC : Island Press .
  • Booth , P. 2003 . Planning by consent: The origins and nature of British development control , London : Routledge .
  • Boyer , M. C. 1983 . Dreaming the rational city: The myth of American city planning , Cambridge, MA : MIT Press .
  • Burchell , R. and Mukherji , S. 2003 . Conventional development versus managed growth: The costs of sprawl . American Journal of Public Health , 93 ( 9 ) : 1534 – 1540 .
  • Calthorpe , P. 1993 . The next American metropolis: Ecology, community, and the American dream , Princeton, NJ : Princeton Architectural Press .
  • Congress for the New Urbanism. 2001a . New urbanism: Comprehensive report & best practices guide , Ithaca, NY : New Urban Publications .
  • Congress for the New Urbanism. (2001b). Model codes. Retrieved October 4, 2006, from www.cnu.org/www.cnu.org/pdf/code_catalog_ 8–1-01.pdf (www.cnu.org/www.cnu.org/pdf/code_catalog_ 8–1-01.pdf)
  • Cullingworth , J. 1993 . The political culture of planning: American land use planning in comparative perspective , London : Routledge .
  • Daniels , T. 2001 . Smart growth: A new American approach to regional planning . Planning Practice and Research , 16 ( 3/4 ) : 271 – 279 .
  • Department of Commerce. (1926). A Standard State Zoning Enabling Act. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office. Retrieved September 10, 2007, from http://www.planning.org/growingsmart/pdf/SZEnablingAct1926.pdf (http://www.planning.org/growingsmart/pdf/SZEnablingAct1926.pdf)
  • Dietrich , H. and Dransfeld , E. 1995 . “ Dusseldorf ” . In European cities, planning systems and property markets , Edited by: Berry , J. and McGreal , S. 84 – 101 . London : E & FN Spon .
  • Dowall , D. 1984 . The suburban squeeze , Berkeley : University of California Press .
  • Downs , A. 2001 . What does “smart growth” really mean? . Planning , 67 ( 4 ) : 20 – 25 .
  • Downs , A. 2005 . Smart growth: Why we discuss it more than we do it . Journal of “the American Planning Association” , 71 ( 4 ) : 367 – 380 .
  • Duany , A. and Talen , E. 2002a . Making the good easy: The Smart-Code alternative . The Fordham Law Journal , April : 1445 – 1468 .
  • Duany , A. and Talen , E. 2002b . Transect planning . Journal of the American Planning Association , 68 ( 3 ) : 245 – 267 .
  • Duany , A. , Wright , W. , Sorlinen , S. , Hall , L. , Watkins , M. , Slone , D. , Hugalde , G. and Merson , R. 2004 . SmartCode & manual , Ithaca, NY : New Urban Publications .
  • Egan, J. (2006, November 21). Survey indicates mixed-use trend on the rise. National Real Estate Investor. Retrieved September 10, 2007, from http://nreionline.com/news/Survey_Mixed_use_Trend_Rise/index.html. (http://nreionline.com/news/Survey_Mixed_use_Trend_Rise/index.html.)
  • European Commission. 1999 . The EU compendium of spatial planning systems and policies: Germany , Luxemburg : Official Publications of the European Communities . Euclid v. Ambler, 272 U.S. 365(1926)
  • Ewing , R. , Pendall , R. and Chen , D. 2002 . Measuring sprawl and its impacts , Washington, DC : Smart Growth America .
  • Federal Ministry for Transport, Building and Housing. 1990 . Federal land utilization ordinance [Baunutzungsverordnung] , Berlin : Author .
  • Federal Ministry for Transport, Building and Housing. 1997a . Federal building code [Baugesetzbuch] , Berlin : Author .
  • Federal Ministry for Transport, Building and Housing. 1997b . Federal regional planning act [Raumordnungsgesetz] , Berlin : Author .
  • Federal Office of Regional Planning, Building and Urban Development. 1993 . Law and practice of urban development in the Federal Republic of Germany , Berlin : Author .
  • Fischel , W. 1999 . “ Does the American way of zoning cause the suburbs of metropolitan areas to be too spread out ” . In Governance and opportunity in metropolitan America , Edited by: Altshuler , A. , Morill , M. , Wolman , H. and Mitchell , F. 151 – 191 . Washington, DC : National Academy .
  • Fischler , R. 1998a . The metropolitan dimension of early zoning: Revisiting the 1916 New York ordinance . Journal of the American Planning Association , 64 ( 2 ) : 170 – 188 .
  • Fischler , R. 1998b . Toward a genealogy of planning: Zoning and the welfare state . Planning Perspectives , 13 ( 4 ) : 389 – 410 .
  • Fischler , R. and Kolnick , K. 2006 . American zoning: German import or home product. Paper presented at the Second World Planning Schools Congress . July 11–16 2006 , Mexico City. July
  • Fishman , R. 1987 . Bourgeois utopias: The rise and fall of suburbia , New York : BasicBooks .
  • Foucault , M. 1972 . The archeology of knowledge , New York : Pantheon Books .
  • Freund , E. 1926 . Planning problems of town, city and region , Philadelphia : W. Fell .
  • Gerckens , L. 2003 . Planning ABCs: An overview of 26 planning topics from automobile to zoning , Burlington, VT : Champlain Planning Press . Planning Commissioners Journal
  • Gerckens, L. (2005). American zoning & the physical isolation of uses. Retrieved March 24, 2005, from http://www.plannersweb.com/articles/ger065.html. (http://www.plannersweb.com/articles/ger065.html.)
  • Grant , J. 2002 . Mixed use in theory and practice: Canadian experience in implementing a planning principle . Journal of the American Planning Association , 68 ( 1 ) : 71 – 84 .
  • Hirt , S. 2005 . Toward post-modern urbanism: Evolution of planning in Cleveland, Ohio . Journal of Planning Education and Research , 25 ( 1 ) : 27 – 42 .
  • Hirt , S. 2007 . The mixed-use trend: Planning attitudes and practices in northeast Ohio . Journal of Architectural and Planning Research , 24 ( 3 ) : 224 – 244 .
  • Jacobs , A. and Appleyard , D. 1987 . Toward an urban design manifesto . Journal of the American Planning Association , 53 ( 1 ) : 112 – 120 .
  • Jacobs , J. 1961 . The death and life of great American cities , New York : Random House .
  • Kamba , W. 1974 . Comparative law: A theoretical framework . The International and Comparative Law Quarterly , 23 ( 3 ) : 485 – 519 .
  • Katz, P. (2004, November). Form first: The New Urbanist alternative to conventional zoning. Retrieved September 10, 2007, from http://www.nh.gov/oep/resourcelibrary/referencelibrary/f/formbasedzoning/ formfirst.htm. (http://www.nh.gov/oep/resourcelibrary/referencelibrary/f/formbasedzoning/ formfirst.htm.)
  • Kimminich , O. 1975 . “ Town and country planning law in the Federal Republic of Germany ” . In Planning law in Western Europe , Edited by: Garner , J. 155 – 176 . New York : Elsevier .
  • Krier , L. 1988 . Traditional ideas for today's towns . City Magazine , 10 ( 2 ) : 20 – 23 .
  • Kunstler , J. 1996 . Home from nowhere: Remaking our everyday world for the twenty-first century , New York : Simon & Schuster .
  • Langdon , P. 2006 . The not-so-secret code . Planning , 72 ( 1 ) January : 24 – 29 .
  • Lefcoe , G. 1979 . Land development in crowded places: Lessons from abroad , Washington, DC : Conservation Foundation .
  • Lepaulle , P. 1922 . Functions of comparative law . Harvard Law Review , 35 ( 7 ) : 838 – 858 .
  • Levine , J. 2006 . Zoned out: Regulation, markets and choices in transportation and metropolitan land use , Washington, DC : Resources for the Future .
  • Liebmann , G. 1996 . Modernization of zoning: A means to reform . Regulation , 19 ( 2 ) Retrieved September 10, 2007, from www.cato.org/pubs/regulation/reg19n2f.html
  • Light , M. 1999 . Different ideas of the city: Origins of metropolitan land-use regimes in the United States, Germany, and Switzerland . Yale Journal of International Law , 24 ( 2 ) : 577 – 612 .
  • Logan , T. 1976 . The Americanization of German zoning . Journal of the American Institute of Planners , 42 ( 4 ) : 377 – 385 .
  • Miller, J. (2004). Smart codes, smart places. Retrieved September 10, 2007, from http://www.realtor.org/smart_growth.nsf/docfiles/ summer04sm.pdf/$FILE/summer04sm.pdf. (http://www.realtor.org/smart_growth.nsf/docfiles/ summer04sm.pdf/$FILE/summer04sm.pdf.)
  • Montgomery , J. 1998 . Making a city: Urbanity, vitality and urban design . Journal of Urban Design , 3 ( 1 ) : 93 – 115 .
  • Nelson , R. 1977 . Zoning and property rights: An analysis of the American system of land-use regulation , Cambridge, MA : MIT Press .
  • Newman , P. and Thornley , A. 1996 . Urban planning in Europe: International competition, national systems and planning projects , London : Routledge .
  • Nivola , P. 1999 . Laws of the landscape: How policies shape cities in Europe and America , Washington, DC : Brookings Institution Press .
  • Pendall , R. 1999 . Do land use controls cause sprawl? . Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design , 26 ( 4 ) : 555 – 571 .
  • Pendall , R. , Puentes , R. and Martin , J. 2006 . From traditional to reformed: A review of the land use regulations in the nation's largest metropolitan areas , Washington, DC : Brookings Institution Press .
  • Perin , C. 1977 . Everything in its place: Social order and land use in America , Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
  • Platt , R. 2004 . Land use and society: Geography, law and public policy , Washington, DC : Island Press .
  • Pollard , W. 1931 . Outline of the law of zoning in the United States . Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science , 155 ( 2 ) : 15 – 33 .
  • Reitz , J. 1998 . How to do comparative law . American Journal of Comparative Law , 46 ( 4 ) : 617 – 636 .
  • Scott , M. 1971 . American city planning since 1890 , Berkeley : University of California .
  • Schmidt-Eichstaedt , G. 2001 . “ National-level planning institutions and decisions in the Federal Republic of Germany ” . In National-level planning in democratic countries: An international comparison of city and regional policy-making , Edited by: Alterman , R. 127 – 147 . Liverpool : Liverpool University Press .
  • Siy, E. (2004). Learning from abroad: The European approach to smarter growth and sustainable development. Retrieved September 10, 2007, from http://www.fundersnetwork.org/usr_doc/Learning_from_Abroad-FINAL.pdf. (http://www.fundersnetwork.org/usr_doc/Learning_from_Abroad-FINAL.pdf.)
  • Steigerwald, B. (2001, June). Urban studies legend Jane Jacobs on gentrification, the new urbanism, and her legacy. The Reason Magazine. Retrieved September 10, 2007, from http://www.reason.com/news/show/28053.html (http://www.reason.com/news/show/28053.html)
  • Strickland , R. 1993 . “ The 1961 zoning revision and the template of the Ideal City ” . In Planning and zoning New York City: Yesterday, today and tomorrow , Edited by: Bressi , T. 48 – 60 . New Brunswick, NJ : Center for Urban Policy Research .
  • Talen , E. 2005 . New urbanism and American planning , London : Routledge .
  • Talen , E. 2006 . Design that enables diversity: The complications of a planning ideal . Journal of Planning Literature , 20 ( 3 ) : 233 – 249 .
  • Talen , E. and Knaap , G. 2003 . Legalizing smart growth: An empirical study of land use regulation in Illinois . Journal of Planning Education and Research , 22 ( 4 ) : 345 – 359 .
  • Toll , S. 1969 . Zoned American , New York : Grossman Publishers .
  • Wickersham , J. 2001 . Jane Jacobs's critique of zoning: From Euclid to Portland and beyond . Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Review , 28 ( 4 ) : 547 – 563 .
  • Wiegandt , C. 2000 . Urban development and urban policy in Germany: An overview , Bonn : Federal Office for Regional Planning and Building .
  • Willis , C. 1993 . “ A 3D CBD ” . In Planning and zoning New York City: Yesterday, today and tomorrow , Edited by: Bressi , T. 3 – 26 . New Brunswick, NJ : Center for Urban Policy Research .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.