Publication Cover
Communicatio
South African Journal for Communication Theory and Research
Volume 22, 1996 - Issue 2
24
Views
4
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Research articles

Knowledge and power in the South African debate on pornography 1900s – 1990s: a discursive critique

Pages 33-50 | Published online: 04 Dec 2007

BIBLIOGRAPHY

  • Adam , H and Giliomee , H . 1979 . The rise and crisis of Afrikaner power. , Cape Town : David Philip .
  • Adlys , T . 1993 . Debating porn. . Agenda: a journal about women and gender , 16 : 56 – 61 .
  • Anderson , D M . 1987 . Porn & violence, fantasy & freedom: getting the facts straight first. . Christianity and Crisis , 47 ( 6 ) : 144 – 147 .
  • Ashforth , A . 1990 . Reckoning schemes of legitimation: on commissions of inquiry as power/knowledge forms. . Journal of Historical Sociology , 3 ( 1 ) : 1 – 22 .
  • Attorney General's Commission on Pornography . 1986 . Final Report of the Attorney General's Commission on Pornography. , Nashville : Rutledge Hill .
  • Barker , M , ed. 1984 . The video nasties: freedom and censorship in the media. , London : Pluto. .
  • Barlow , G and Hill , A , eds. 1985 . Video violence and children. , London : Hodder & Stoughton. .
  • Bosman , F C L . 1930a . Skakels van die ketting . Die Huisgenoot , 24 January : 57 – 52 .
  • Bosman , F C L . 1930b . Verdoeseling of waarheid? . Die Burger , 31 January : 6
  • Bosman , F C L . 1930c . Bang vir die waarheid? . Die Burger , 8 February : 5
  • Bourdieu , P . 1983 . The field of cultural production, or: the economic world reversed. . Poetics , 12 : 311 – 356 .
  • Bozzoli , B . 1981 . Challenging local orthodoxies. . Social Dynamics , 6 ( 2 ) : 53 – 73 .
  • Brannigan , A and Kapardis , A . 1986 . The controversy over pornography and sex crimes: the criminological evidence and beyond. . Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology , 19 ( 4 ) : 259 – 284 .
  • Brink , A . 1983 . Mapmakers: writing in a state of siege. , London : Faber & Faber. .
  • Brownmiller , S. 1986 . Against our will: men, women and rape. , Harmondsworth : Penguin. .
  • Bruwer , J . 1985 . Pornografie, erotiek en sensuur. . Communicatio , 11 ( 2 ) : 3 – 22 .
  • Cameron , E . 1987 . Nude monarchy: the case of South African judges. . South African Journal on Human Rights , 3 : 338 – 346 .
  • Chidester , D . 1992 . Shots in the streets: violence and religion in South Africa. , Cape Town : Oxford University Press. .
  • Christensen , F M . 1990a . Pornography: the other side. , New York : Praeger .
  • Christensen , F M . 1990b . Cultural and ideological bias in pornography research . Philosophy of the Social Sciences , 20 ( 3 ) : 351 – 375 .
  • Cline , V B . 1974 . Where do you draw the line?, an exploration into media violence, pornography, and censorship. Provo , Utah : Brigham Young University Press. .
  • Coetzee , J M . 1991 . The mind of apartheid: Geoffrey Cronjé (1907-). . Social Dynamics , 17 ( 1 ) : 1 – 35 .
  • Corrupt whom? . 1969 . South African Medical Journal , 43 September : 1178
  • Court , H J . 1980 . Pornography: a Christian critique. , Downers Grove, II. : Inter Varsity Press .
  • Cronjé Commission see South Africa. Commission of Enquiry in Regard to Undesirable Publications . 1957 .
  • Davis D 1985a . Introduction: criminology and South Africa . In D Davis M Slabbert (eds) Crime and power in South Africa. Cape Town : David Philip .
  • Davis D 1985b . Political trials in South Africa . In D Davis M Slabbert (eds) Crime and power in South Africa. Cape Town : David Philip .
  • De Klerk W A 1983 . The puritans in Africa: a story of Afrikanerdom. Harmondsworth : Penguin.
  • De Vleeschauwer , H J . 1959 . Censorship and libraries . Mousaion , 33 : 3 – 41 .
  • De Villiers , F M J . 1976 . Pornografie in perspektief . Woord en Daad , 16 ( 165 ) : 17 – 19 .
  • Devlin , P . 1979 . The enforcement of moral. , New York : Oxford University Press. .
  • Dirven , R . 1987 . Metaphors in politics: the case of apartheid. . Communication and Cognition , 22 ( 1 ) : 23 – 38 .
  • Donnerstein , E and Linz , D . 1986 . Mass media sexual violence and male viewers. . American Behavioral Scientist , 29 ( 5 ) : 601 – 618 .
  • Donnerstein , E , Linz , D and Pernod , S . 1987 . The question of pornography: research findings and policy implications. , New York : Free Press .
  • Dugard J 1980 . Political options for South Africa and implications for the West . In Rothberg R I Barratt J (eds) Conflict and compromise in South Africa. Cape Town : David Philip .
  • Du Plessis , L M . 1990 . Inleiding tot die reg. , Cape Town : Juta. .
  • Du Toit , A . 1981 . Facing up to the future: some personal reflections on the predicament of Afrikaner intellectuals in the legitimation crisis of Afrikaner nationalism and the apartheid state . Social Dynamics. , 7 ( 2 ) : 1 – 27 .
  • Du Toit A 1983 . The rationale of controlling political publications . In T Coggin , (ed) Censorship. Johannesburg : SA institute of race relations.
  • Dworkin , A . 1984 . Pornography: men possessing women. , London : The Women's Press. .
  • Exner , H F H H . 1975 . Jubilee congress: sex therapy workshop. . South African Medical Journal , 49 ( 40 ) : 1625
  • Foucault , M . 1980 . Power/knowledge: selected interviews and other writings. , 1972 – 1977 . London : Harvester. .
  • Foucault , M . 1981 . The history of sexuality, volume one: an introduction. , Harmondsworth : Penguin. .
  • Foucault , M . 1988a . Language, counter-memory, practice: selected essays and interviews. , Ithaca : Cornell University Press. .
  • Freed , L F . 1949 . The problem of the European prostitution in Johannesburg: a sociological survey. , Cape Town : Juta .
  • Furlong , P J . 1991 . Between crown and swastika: the impact of the radical right on the Afrikaner nationalist movement in the fascist era. , Johannesburg : Witwatersrand University Press. .
  • Geldenhuys , P B . 1977 . Pornografie, sensuur en reg. , Johannesburg : Lex Patria. .
  • Gifford , P . 1988 . The religious right in Southern Africa. , Harare : Baobab Books and University of Zimbabwe Publications. .
  • Gilfillan L A 1989 . Power/pain: the politics of pornography , in Vorster W S (ed) The morality of censorship. Pretoria : University of South Africa.
  • Giliomee , H . 1982 . The parting of ways: South African politics. , 1976 – 82 . Cape Town : David Philip. .
  • Gordon , R B . 1988 . Ethnological knowledge is of vital importance: the martialization of South African anthropology. . Dialectical Anthropology , 12 : 443 – 448 .
  • Griffin , S . 1988 . Pornography and silence: culture's revenge against nature. , London : The Women's Press. .
  • Gutsche , T . 1972 . The history and social significance of motion pictures in South Africa 1985–1940. , Cape Town : Timmins. .
  • Hansard . 1953 . Debates of the House of Assembly. , South Africa. Parliament : House of Assembly .
  • Hansson D 1990 . Changes in counter-revolutionary state strategy in the decade 1979 to 1989 . In D Hansson D van Zyl Smit (eds). Towards justice? Crime and state control in South Africa . Cape Town : Oxford University Press .
  • Hattingh , J P . 1987 . Pornografie en die Williams Committee: 'n oorsig van die poblematiek, agtergronde, resepsie en implikasie van die verslag. . South African Journal of Philosophy , 6 ( 3 ) : 88 – 101 .
  • Hawkins , G and Zimring , F E . 1988 . Pornography in a free society. , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press. .
  • Haysom , N and Marcus , G . 1985 . Undesirability and criminal liability under the Publications Act 42 of 1974. . South African Journal on Human Rights , 1 ( l ) : 31 – 45 .
  • Hofmeyr I 1987 . Building a nation from words: Afrikaans language, literature and ethnic identity In S Marks S Trapido (eds) The politics of race, class and nationalism in twentieth-century South Africa. London : Longman.
  • Hofstadter R 1972 . The paranoid style in American politics . In M L Medley J E Conyers (eds) Sociology for the seventies: a contemporary perspective. New York : John Wiley & Sons .
  • Howitt , D . 1982 . The mass media and social problems. , Oxford : Pergamon Press. .
  • Howitt D 1989 . Pornography: the recent debate . In G Cumberbatch D Howitt A measure of uncertainty: the effects of the mass media. London : Libbey.
  • Huer , J . 1987 . Art, beauty, and pornography: a journey through American culture. , Buffalo : Prometheus Books. .
  • Hugo P 1990 . The greatest evil of our time: white fear and sexual racism in South Africa . Paper read at the African Studies Forum, 30 August, University of South Africa , Pretoria .
  • Jarvie , I C . 1987 . The sociology of the pornography debate. . Philosophy of the Social Sciences , 17 ( 2 ) : 257 – 275 .
  • Joubert , D . 1974 . Met remand van 'n ander kleur. , Cape Town : Tafelberg. .
  • Kahn , E . 1966 . When the lion feeds – and the censor pounces: a disquisition on the banning of immoral publications in South Africa. . South African Law Journal , 83 : 278 – 336 .
  • Kappeler , S . 1986 . The pornography of representation. , Cambridge : Polity Press. .
  • Kruger Commission . See South Africa. Commission pf Inquiry into the Publications and Entertainments Amendment Bill . 1974 .
  • Langenhoven , C J . 1930a . Die smerige kultuur . Die Burger , 27 January
  • Langenhoven , C J . 1930b . Ons ‘geveinsde’ verdoeseling . Die Burger , 3 February
  • Langenhoven , C J . 1930c . Sal die staat ingryp? . Die Burger , 10 February
  • Langenhoven , C J . 1930d . Die realisme van wat? . Die Burger , 17 February
  • Lloyd , D . 1968 . The idea of law. , Harmondsworth : Penguin. .
  • Longford , Lord . 1972 . Pornography: the Longford report. , London : Coronet. .
  • MacCrone , I D . 1937 . Race attitudes in South Africa: historical, experimental and psychological studies. , London : University of the Witwatersrand/Oxford University Press. .
  • Marcus , G . 1987 . Judicial attitudes to the detention of children. . South African Journal on Human Rights , 3 ( 2 ) : 234 – 346 .
  • Marcus , G . 1988 . Fine distinction: scientific censorship, and the courts. . South African Journal on Human Rights , 4 ( 1 ) : 82 – 86 .
  • McCormack T 1987 . The end of communication and the beginning of ideology . In M Gurevitch M R Levy (eds) Mass communication review yearbook 6. Beverly Hills : Sage .
  • McCormack , T . 1988 . The censorship of pornography: catharsis or learning? . American Journal of Orthopsychiatry , 58 ( 4 ) : 492 – 504 .
  • McCormack T 1989 . Pornography . In E Barnow (ed) International encyclopedia of communications 3 : 331 – 334 . New York : Oxford University Press & The Annenberg School of Communication, University of Pennsylvania .
  • Modise , T . 1993 . Apartheid erotica? . Playboy , 1 ( 2 ) : 53
  • Molitor , F and Sapolsky , B S . 1993 . Sex, violence, and victimization in slasher films. . Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media , 37 ( 2 ) : 233 – 242 .
  • Mulder C P 1976 . The rational for separate development . In N J Rhoodie (ed) South African dialogue: contrasts in South African thinking on basic race issues. Johannesburg : McGraw-Hill.
  • Mureinik , E . 1988 . Law and morality in South Africa. . South African Law Journal , 105 ( 3 ) : 457 – 469 .
  • Native crimes caused by bad literature . November 1953 . The Cape Argus Vol. 18 , November , 9
  • Nietzsche , F . 1978 . Twilight of the idols and the Anti-Christ. , Harmondsworth : Penguin. .
  • Nietzsche , F . 1965 . The birth of tragedy and the genealogy of morals. , New York : Doubleday. .
  • Paden , R . 1984 . On the discourse of pornography. . Philosophy and Social Criticism. , 10 : 17 – 38 .
  • Playboy . 1993 . Playboy forum , 1 ( 1 ) : 32 – 36 .
  • Preller , A C N . 1975 . Jubileumkongres: lesing oor seksterapie. . South African Medical Journal , 49 ( 40 ) : 1626
  • Prince , S . 1988 . The pornographic image and the practice of film theory. . Cinema Journal , 27 ( 20 ) : 27 – 39 .
  • Randall , R S . 1989 . Freedom and taboo: pornography and the politics of a self divided. , Berkeley : University of California Press. .
  • Rees , M and Day , C . 1980 . Muldergate: the story of the info scandal. , Johannesburg : Macmillan. .
  • Reiss , I L . 1986 . Journey into sexuality: an exploratory voyage. , Englewood Cliffs : Prentice Hall .
  • Richard D 1976 . Petty apartheid – the tip of the iceberg? In N J Rhoodie (ed) South African dialogue: contrasts in South African thinking on basic race issues. Johannesburg : McGraw-Hill.
  • Roos , S G . 1979 . Geestelike weerbaarheid teen ideologiese terrorisme. , Pretoria : NG Kerkboekhandel. .
  • Rushdoony , R J . 1975 . The politics of pornography. , Sandton : Valiant Publishers. .
  • Segal L 1992 . Introduction . In L Segal M McIntosh (eds) Sex exposed: sexuality and the pornography debate. London : Virago.
  • Silver , L . 1981 . Who are the censors? A closer look at publications control. . South African Law Journal , 98 : 105 – 111 .
  • Simons , G L . 1972 . Pornography without prejudice: a reply to objectors. , London : Abelard-Schuman. .
  • Slabbert M 1985 . Problems facing criminological researchers in South Africa . In D Davis M Slabbert (eds) Crime and power in South Africa. Cape Town : David Philip .
  • Smit J H 1989 . Morality and decency: a case in question . In W S Vorster (ed) The morality of censorship. Pretoria : University of South Africa.
  • Smith , T W . 1987 . The use of public opinion data by the Attorney General's Commission on Pornography. . Public Opinion Quarterly , 51 : 249 – 267 .
  • Soble , A . 1986 . Pornography: Marxism, feminism, and the futire of sexuality. , New Haven : Yale University Press. .
  • Sonderling , S . 1989 . The function of pornography in society: a survey ‘of some alternative intellectual views. . Communicatio: Journal of the Department of Communication, Unisa , 15 ( 2 ) : 57 – 69 .
  • Sonderling , S . 1990 . New and old voices from the ship of fools: the South African pornography debate. . Communicatio: Journal of the Department of Communication, Unisa , 16 ( 2 ) : 40 – 47 .
  • Sonderling , S . 1993 . Power of discourse and the discourse of power in making an issue of sexual abuse in South Africa: the rise and fall of social problems. . Critical Arts: A Journal for Cultural Studies , 6 ( 2 ) : 1 – 26 .
  • Sonderling , S . 1994a . An exploration of poststructuralist discursive critique and its implication for the study of communication . Communicatio: South African Journal for Communication Theory and Research , 20 ( 2 ) : 9 – 24 .
  • Sonderling , S . 1994b . An exploration of poststructuralist discursive critique and its implication for a critical analysis of the discourse on pornography (MA dissertation) , Department of Communication, University of South Africa .
  • Sonderling , S . 1994c . Pornography: why the nincompoop definitions? . Dialogus: Newsletter of the Department of Communication, Unisa , 1 ( 1 ) : 14 – 15 .
  • Sonderling , S . 1994d . Pornography and nincompoops . Hustler , November : 89 – 90 .
  • Sonderling , S . 1995 . Clear and present danger: old reactionaries and the police are tinkering with censorship. . Dialogus: Newsletter of the Department of Communication, Unisa. , 2 ( 1 ) : 16 – 17 .
  • South Africa. Commission Appointed to Enquire into Assaults on Women . 1913 . Report of the Commission Appointed to Enquire into Assaults on Women. , Cape Town : Cape Times/Government Printer (UG 39-13) .
  • South Africa. Commission of Inquiry into the Publications and Entertainments Amendment Bill (Kruger Commission) . 1974 . Report of the Commission of Inquiry into the Publications and Entertainment Bill. , Pretoria : Government Printer. Chairman: J T Kruger. .
  • South Africa. Commission of Enquiry in Regard to Undesirable Publications (Cronje Commission) . 1957 . Report of the Commission of Enquiry in regard to Undesirable Publication. , Pretoria : Government Printer . Chairman: G Cronjé
  • South Africa. Senaat . 1926 & 1927 . Debatte van die Senaat. , Government Printer : Cape Town .
  • South Africa. Parliament: House of Assembly . 1953 . Debates of the House of Assembly. , Pretoria : Government Printer .
  • Steenkamp , A . 1989 . Cry Freedom, en Gilfillan bedank uit Appèlraad . Vrye Weekblad , 1 September : 7
  • Steenkamp W F J 1965 . Samewerking met Langenhoven . In J P Scannell (ed) Keeromstraat 30: Gedenkbundel vir die vyftigste verjaardag van Die Burger. Cape Town : Nasionale Boekhandel .
  • Stewart , S . 1988 . The Marquis de Meese. . Critical inquiry , 15 ( 1 ) : 162 – 192 .
  • Steyn J C 1987 . Afrikanernasionalisme en Afrikaans . In H Du Plessis T Du Plessis (eds) Afrikaans en taalpolitiek: 15 opstelle. Pretoria : Haum.
  • Steyn , J C . 1990 . Die betekenis van ‘Die Burger’ vir die Afrikaanse letterkunde . Acta Academica , 2 : 1 – 167 .
  • Steytler N 1990 . Policing politcal opponents: death squads and cop culture . In D Hansson D Van Zyl Smit (eds) Towards justice? Crime and state control in South Africa. Cape Town : Oxford University Press
  • Suzman , A . 1988 . Censorship and the courts: the suggested abolition of the right of appeal to the Supreme Court from decisions of the publications control boards. . South African Law Journal , 89 : 191 – 206 .
  • Taitz , J . 1987 . Administrative law in South Africa: the theories do not always match the facts. . Journal for Juridical Science , 12 ( 1 ) : 31 – 42 .
  • 1993 . The Pretoria News. , 15 December : 2
  • Theron , A . 1988 . Pornografie as moontlike bydraende faktor tot geweldpleging teenoor die vrou. . South African Journal of Sociology , 19 ( 4 ) : 168 – 174 .
  • Theron A 1989 . Child pornography: towards an understanding of its dynamics and its effects on the child victim . In W S Vorster (ed) The morality of censorship. Pretoria : University of South Africa.
  • Theron , A . 1992 . Child pornography: exploration of the child, effects on the victim, and indication for therapy. . Acta Criminologica , 5 ( 1 ) : 49 – 54 .
  • Troup , F . 1975 . South Africa: an historical introduction. , Harmondsworth : Penguin. .
  • Van der Westhuizen , J B . 1976 . Pornografie en die reg . De Jure , 9 : 57 – 64 .
  • Van Deventer , A . 1989 . Veranderlikes in die subjektiewe ervaring van oudiovisuele erotika . Communicatio , 15 ( 1 ) : 62 – 66 .
  • Van Niekerk , M . 1991 . Die Christen en die beeldende kunste: enkele historiese en prinsipiële perspektiewe . Tydskrif vir Christelike Wetenskap , 27 ( 4 ) : 46 – 68 .
  • Van Rensburg , F I J . 1984 . Sensuur: het die owerheid moed opgegee? . Woord en Daad , 24 ( 261 ) : 18 – 19 .
  • Van Rensburg , F I J . 1985 . Pornografie. , Durban : Butterworth. .
  • Van Rensburg , F I J . 1986a . Vertrekpunte vir die ontwikkeling van 'n model en definisie van pornografie . Ecquid Novi , 7 ( 1 ) : 17 – 32 .
  • Van Rensburg , F I J . 1986b . Pornografie en beïnvloeding . Communicatio , 12 ( 2 ) : 47 – 57 .
  • Van Rensburg , F I J . 1989 . Discretions overstepping the limits of the Publications Act? . Ecquid Novi , 10 ( 1 & 2 ) : 21 – 32 .
  • Van Rensburg , F I J . 1990 . Sensuur: die stryd om 'n vrye, verantwoordelike letterkunde. , Johannesburg : Perskor. .
  • Van Rooyen , J C W . 1978 . Publikasiebeheer in Suid-Afrika. , Cape Town : Juta .
  • Van Rooyen , J C W . 1987 . Censorship in South Africa: being a commentary on the application of the Publications Act. , Cape Town : Juta .
  • Van Rooyen , J C W . 1988 . Die rol van die Wet op Publikasies in die handhawing van morele standaarde . SA Publiekreg/Public Law , 3 ( 2 ) : 131 – 141 .
  • Van Rooyen , J C W . 1989a . The limits of authority and censorship in South African publications control . Ecquid Novi , 10 ( 1&2 ) : 4 – 20 .
  • Van Rooyen J C W 1989b . Morality and the control of the arts and entertainment in South Africa . In W S Vorster (ed) The morality of censorship. Pretoria : University of South Africa.
  • Van Wyk Louw , N P . 1947 . Sensuur of pornografie? . Standpunte , 4 ( 8 ) : 10 – 21 .
  • Van Zyl Smit D 1990 . Introduction: contextualising criminology in contemporary South Africa . In D Hansson D Van Zyl Smit (eds) Towards justice? Crime and state control in South Africa. Cape Town : Oxford University Press .
  • Verhage J A 1972 . Langenhoven . In Standard encyclopaedia of Southern Africa Vol 6 . Cape Town : Nasou .
  • Wagner , P . 1990 . Eros revived: erotica of the enlightenment in England and America. , London : Paladin Grafton. .
  • Weeks , J . 1982 . Sex, politics and society: the regulation of sexuality since 1800. , 2nd Edition , London : Longman. .
  • Wilkins , I and Strydom , H . 1980 . The super-Afrikaners. , Johannesburg : Jonathan Ball. .
  • Williams , B , ed. 1981 . Obscenity and film censorship: an abridgement of the Williams Report. , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press. .
  • Williams , L . 1990 . Hard core: power, pleasure, and the ‘frenzy of the visible'. , London : Pandora. .
  • Wilson , J Q . 1971 . Violence, pornography, and social science. . Public Interest , 22 : 45 – 61 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.