20
Views
0
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

A court‐enforced bill of rights for South Africa?

Pages 81-110 | Published online: 21 Sep 2007

References

  • Kahn , E. 1983 . Fiat justitia: Essays in Memory of Oliver Deneys Schreiner , 1 Cape Town : Juta .
  • De Tocqueville , A. 1969 . Democracy in America , Volume I , 107 New York : Vintage Books .
  • Coetsee , H.J. 1984 . “Hoekom nie ‘n Verklaring van Menseregte nie?” . Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap , 9 ( 1 ) Mei : 11
  • Wiechers , Marinus and Themaat , J.P. VerLoren van . 1967 . (Staatsreg , 128 Durban : Butterworths .
  • The President's Council (Constitutional Committee of the President's Council . 1982 . Adaptation of Constitutional Structures in South Africa ‐ , Cape Town : Government Printer . Second Report (PC 4/1982),
  • Cowen , D.V. 1961 . The Foundations of Freedom , 52ff London : Oxford University Press .
  • Dugard , C.J.R. 1978 . Human Rights and the South African Legal Order , 53ff Princeton , New Jersey : Princeton University Press .
  • Jennings , Sir Ivor . 1956 . The Approach to Self‐Government , 20 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1982 . “Parliamentary Sovereignty, Fundamental Freedoms and a Bill of Rights” . South African Law Journal , 99 : 583
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1985 . “The Bill‐of‐Rights Issue” . Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap , 10 ( 1 ) Mei : 13
  • Nwabueze , B.O. 1973 . Constitutionalism in Emergent States , 41 London : C. Hurst and Co. .
  • Henkin , L. 1978 . The Rights of Man Today , 1 Boulder , Colorado : Westview Press .
  • Milne , Judge A. J. M. 1977 . “Should We Have a Bill of Rights?” . Modern Law Review , 40 : 391 – 392 .
  • Cappelletti , M. 1973 . “Fundamental Guarantees of Parties in Civil Proceedings (General Report)” . In Fundamental Guarantees of the Parties in Civil Litigation , Edited by: Cappelletti , M. and Tallon , D. 665 – 666 . New York : Ocean Publications .
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1979 . “The Concept of Human Rights: Its History, Contents and Meaning” . In Human Rights: The Cape Town Conference , Edited by: Forsyth , C.F. and Schiller , J.E. 10ff Cape Town : Juta .
  • Sieghart , P. 1982 . The International Law of Human Rights , 14ff Oxford : Clarendon Press .
  • Kotzé , J.G. 1949 . Memoirs and Reminiscences , xii – xiii . Cape Town : Maskew Miller .
  • Milne , Judge . 1977 . Modern Law Review , 40 : 389
  • 1976 . Modernz Law Review , 39 : 121
  • Beinart , B. 1962 . “The Rule of Law” . Acta juridica , : 137
  • Molteno , D.B. 1965–66 . “The Rules Behind the Rule of Law” . Acta Juridica , : 147 – 148 .
  • Molteno , D.B. 1972 . “Change and Methods of Change” . In Law, Justice and Society Edited by: Randall , P. 96 – 97 . Johannesburg (Report of the Sprocas Legal Commission,
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1976 . Die Beskeming can Menseregte in Suid‐Afrika , 76 – 77 . 102 Cape Town : Juta .
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1982 . “Parliamentary Sovereignty, Fundamental Freedoms and a Bill of Rights” . South African Law Journal , 99 : 582 – 583 .
  • Van Niekerk , B. 1973 . “The Dream of Liberty: Bills of Rights for the Bantustans” . South African Law Journal , 90 : 403
  • Hiemstra , V.G. 1971 . “Constitutions of Liberty” . South African Law Journal , 88 : 45ff
  • Corbett , M.M. 1979 . “Human Rights: The Road Ahead” . In Human Rights: The Cape Town Conference , Edited by: Forsyth , C.F. and Schiller , J.E. 196 Cape Town : Juta .
  • 1985 . Natal Mercury (Durban) , September 11
  • Leon , R.N. 1986 . “A Bill of Rights for South Africa” . South African Journal on Human Rights , 2 March : 60 Part 1,
  • Didcott , J.D. 1988 . “Practical Workings of a Bill of Rights” . In A Bill of Rights for South Africa , Edited by: Van der Westhuizen , J. V. and Viljoen , H.P. 52ff Durban : Butterworths .
  • Van Wyk , D.H. 1988 . “Menseregte‐Handves en Politieke Idioom” . In A Bill of Rights for South Africa , Edited by: Van der Westhuizen , J.V. and Viljoen , H.P. 87ff Durban : Butterworths .
  • Buthelezi Commission . 1982 . (The Requirements for Stability and Development in KwaZulu and Natal , Volumes I and II , Durban : H. & H. Publications .
  • President's Council recommendation (Constitutional Committee of the President's Council . 1982 . Proposals for Constitutional Reform in the Republic of South Africa , Cape Town : Government Printer . ‐ First Report (PC 3/1982),
  • Boulle , L.J. 1982 . “The Buthelezi Commission Recommendations in the Light of Current Constitutional Trends” . Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa , XV ( 3 ) November : 269
  • Slabbert , F. van Zyl . 1985 . The Last White Parliament , 3 Johannesburg : Jonathan Ball .
  • Rautenbach , I.M. 1981 . “Die Juridiese Werking van Menseregte‐Aktes en die Nuwe Grondwetlike Bedeling” . In ’n Nuwe Grordwetlike Bedeling vir Suid‐Afrika: Enkele Regsaspekte , Edited by: Jacobs , S.C. 151ff Durban : Butterworths .
  • Hand , J. 1982 . “Aspects of Judicial Review in Southern Africa” . Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa , XV ( 3 ) November : 276ff
  • Robinson , J.A. 1984 . “Menseregte, Militêre Diensplig en Geloofsbeswaardes” . Tydskrif vir Hedendaagse Romeins‐Hollandse Reg , 47 : 210ff
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1984 . “Menseregte in Perspektief” . Woorden Daad , 24 ( 259 ) Maart : 13
  • Venter , F. 1981 . Die Staatsreg van Afsonderlike Ontwikkeling , 316ff Potchefstroom : Sentrale Publikasie‐Afdeling, Potchefstroomse Universiteit vir CHO .
  • Venter , F. 1984 . “Menseregte‐Perspektief” . Woord en Daad , 24 ( 262 ) Junie : 13ff
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1985 . “The Bill‐of‐Rights Issue” . Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap , 10 ( 1 ) Mei : 1ff
  • Mackinnon , V.S. 1985 . “Dicey and New Dispensations: The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms” . Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa , XVIII ( 3 ) November : 404ff
  • 1986 . Natal Mercury (Durban) , June 4
  • 1986 . Sunday Times (Johannesburg) , July 13
  • 1986 . Sunday Times (Johannesburg) , August 31
  • Sanders , A.J.G.M. 1986 . “A Bill of Rights for South Africa?” . SA Public Law , 1 ( 1 ) June : 1ff
  • Dicey , Lord . 1959 . (An Introduction to the Study of the Constitution , 91 London : Macmillan .
  • Milne , A.J.M. 1977 . “Should We Have a Bill of Rights?” . Modern Law Review , 40 : 389
  • Phillips , H.O. 1957 . “Self‐Limitation by the United Kingdom Parliament” . Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly , : 443ff
  • Phillips , H.O. and Jackson , P. 1978 . Constitutional and Administrative Law , 446 – 456 . London : Sweet and Maxwell .
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1976 . Die Beskerming van Menseregte in Suid‐Afrika , 42 – 51 . Cape Town : Juta .
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1982 . “Parliamentary Sovereignty, Fundamental Freedoms and a Bill of Rights” . South African Law Journal , 99 : 560ff
  • South Africa, Republic of. Department of Foreign Affairs . 1968 . South Africa and the Rule of Law , Pretoria : Government Printer .
  • Venter , F. 1973 . “The Withering of the ‘Rule of Law'” . Speculum Juris , 8 : 69 – 88 .
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1982 . “Parliamentary Sovereignty, Fundamental Freedoms and a Bill of Rights” . South African Law Journal , 99 : 571
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1985 . “The Bill‐of‐Rights Issue” . Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap , 10 ( 1 ) Mei : 9
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1984 . Die Grondwtt van die Republiek van Suid‐Afrika , 54 – 55 . Johannesburg : Lex Patria .
  • Naidu , A. 1986 . “The Development of the Protection of Human Rights in Canada” . Obiter , October : 22ff
  • La Forest , G.V. 1983 . “The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms: An Overview” . Canadian Bar Review , 61 : 19ff
  • Russell , P.H. 1983 . “The Political Purposes of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms” . Canadian Bar Review , 61 : 30ff
  • McWhinney , E. 1983 . “The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms: The Lessons of Comparative Jurisprudence” . Canadian Bar Review , 61 : 55ff
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1982 . “Parliamentary Sovereignty, Fundamental Freedoms and a Bill of Rights” . South African Law Journal , 99 : 569
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1985 . “The Bill‐of‐Rights Issue” . Tydskrij vir Regswetenskap , 10 ( 1 ) Mei : 8
  • Jaconelli , J. 1976 . “The European Convention on Human Rights: The Text of a British Bill of Rights” . Public Law , Autumn : 226
  • Brown , L.N. 1977 . “A Bill of Rights for the United Kingdom?” . Parliamentarian , 58 : 79
  • Silkin , S. 1977 . “The Rights of Man and the Rule of Law” . Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly , 28 ( 1 ) Spring : 3ff
  • Scarman , L. 1974 . English Law: The New Dimension , 10ff London : Stevens and Sons .
  • Sornarajah , M. 1976 . “Bill of Rights: The Commonwealth Debate” . Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa , IX ( 2 ) July : 163ff
  • Milne , A.J.M. 1977 . “Should We Have a Bill of Rights?” . Modern Law Review , 40 : 389ff
  • Nwabueze , B.O. 1977 . Judicialism in Commonwealth Africa , 22 New York : St. Martin's Press .
  • Thayer , J. 1982–83 . “The Origins and Scope of the American Doctrine of Constitutional Law” . Harvard Law Review , 96 : 129 131
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1985 . “The Bill‐of‐Rights Issue” . Tydskrij vir Regswetenskap , 10 ( 1 ) Mei : 3ff
  • Hand , L. 1959 . The Spirit of Liberty , 144 New York : Vintage Books .
  • Muir , W.K. 1967 . Law and Attitude Change , 135 – 136 . Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1985 . “The Bill‐of‐Rights Issue” . Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap , 10 ( 1 ) Mei : 14
  • Fagan , H. A. 1959 . Our Responsibility: A Discussion of South Africa's Racial Problems , 61 64 Stellenbosch : Stellenbosch University Publishers .
  • Hund , J. 1982 . “Aspects of Judicial Review in Southern Africa” . Comparative and International Law Journal of Southern Africa , XV ( 3 ) November : 276
  • Forsyth , C.F. 1980 . “Human Rights and Ideology: A First Examination” . South African Law Journal , 97 : 111
  • Davis , D.M. 1980 . “Human Rights: A Rebutter” . South African Law Journal , 97 : 616ff
  • Forsyth , C.F. 1980 . “Human Rights and Ideology: A First Examination” . South African Law Journal , 97 : 102ff
  • Forsyth , C.F. 1979 . “Human Rights and Ideology: Litis Contestatio” . In Human Rights: The Cape Town Conference , Edited by: Forsyth , C.F. and Schiller , J.E. 622ff Cape Town : Juta .
  • Forsyth , C.F. 1980 . “Human Rights and Ideology: A First Examination” . South African Law Journal , 97 : 111
  • Eze , O.C. 1984 . Human Rights in Africa: Some Selected Problems , 5 – 6 . Lagos : Macmillan Nigeria .
  • 1985 . Natal Mercury (Durban) , September 11
  • Davis , D.M. 1988 . “Legality and Struggle: Towards a View of a Bill of Rights for South Africa” . In A Bill of Rights for South Africa , Edited by: Van der Westhuizen , J.V. and Viljoen , H.P. 177 Durban : Butterworths .
  • 1985 . Natal Mercury (Durban) , September 11
  • Davis , D.M. “Legality and Struggle: Towards a View of a Bill of Rights for South Africa” . Edited by: Van der Westhuizen , J.V. and Viljoen , H.P. 178 op. cit.
  • Du Plessis , L.M. 1988 . “Filosofiese Perspektief op ‘n Menseregte‐Handves vir Suid‐Afrika” . In A Bill of Rights for South Africa , Edited by: Van der Westhuizen , J.V. and Viljoen , H.P. 26 Durban : Butterworths .
  • Basson , D.A. 1988 . “Die Regbank en ‘n Menseregte‐Handves” . In A Bill of Rights for South Africa , Edited by: Van der Westhuizen , J.V. and Viljoen , H.P. 63ff Durban : Butterworths .
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1985 . “The Bill‐of‐Rights Issue” . Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap , 10 ( 1 ) Mei : 10
  • Nwabueze , B.O. Constitutionalism in Emergent States 1 op. cit.
  • Van der Vyver , J.D. 1985 . “The Bill‐of‐Rights Issue” . Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap , 10 ( 1 ) Mei : 16
  • Cowen , D.V. 1985 . Is There a Role for a Court‐Enforced Charter of Rights in a New South African Constitution? 4 (Unpublished paper dated
  • Venter , F. 1977 . “Salus Reipublicae Suprema Lex” . Tydskrif vir HedeniaagseRomeins‐Hollandse Reg , 40 : 232ff
  • Du Plessis , L.M. 1985 . “Thoughts on Law, Order and State Security” . Journal for South African Law , December : 233ff
  • Denning , Lord Alfred . 1949 . Freedom under the Law , 5 London : Stevens .
  • Marasinghe , L. 1984 . “Traditional Conceptions of Human Rights in Africa” . In Human Rights and Development in Africa , Edited by: Welch , C.E. Jr. and Meltzer , R.I. 32ff Albany (New York) : State University of New York Press .
  • Seidman , R.B. 1974 . “Judicial Review and Fundamental Freedoms in Anglopihonic Independent Africa” . Ohio State Law Journal , 35 : 820
  • Read , J.S. 1973 . “Bills of Rights in ‘The Third World’: Some Commonwealth Experiences” . Verfassung und Recht in Übersee , 6 : 29
  • Seidman , R.B. 1973 . “Law and Stagnation in Africa” . Zambia Law Journal , 5 : 56
  • Seidman , R.B. 1974 . “Judicial Review and Fundamental Freedoms in Anglophonic Independent Africa” . Ohio State Law Journal , 35 : 820
  • Aihe , D.O. 1971–72 . “Neo‐Nigerian Human Rights in Zambia: A Comparative Study with Some Countries in Africa and the West Indies” . Zambia Law Journal , 3/4 ( 1/2 ) : 43ff
  • Welch , C.E. Jr. 1984 . “Human Rights as a Problem in Contemporary Africa” . In Human Rights and Development in Africa , Edited by: Welch , C.E. Jr. and Meltzer , R.I. 14 Albany (New York) : State University of New York Press .
  • Nwabueze , B.O. Constitutionalism in Emergent States 24ff op. cit.
  • Nwabueze , B.O. Constitutionalism in Emergent States 23ff op. cit.
  • Wiseberg , L.S. 1975 . Human Rights in Africa: Towards a Definition of the Problem of a Double Standard . Paper presented at the Eighteenth Annual Meeting of the African Studies Association . October 29 1975 , San Francisco . ‐November 1,
  • Weinstein , W. 1975 . Africa's Approach to Human Rights at the United Nations . Paper presented at the Eighteenth Annual Meeting of the African Studies Association . October 29 1975 , San Francisco . ‐November 1,
  • Bretton , H.L. 1977 . Human Rights in Africa: Further Thoughts and an Agenda for Action . Paper presented at the Joint Annual Meeting of the African Studies Association (Twentieth Meeting) and the Latin American Studies Association . November 2–5 1977 , Houston , Texas .
  • Berhane , C. 1984 . “Africa and Human Rights” . New African , March : 39
  • Jason , P. 1985 . “Human Rights and African Leaders’ Wrongs” . New African , September : 19
  • Wako , A. 1985 . “Human Rights: Little Cause for Joy” . The Weekly Review , January 11 : 11 – 12 .
  • Yahya , M. 1985 . “Aliens and Human Rights in Africa” . The Weekly Review , June 28 : 25 – 27 .
  • Sithole , N. 1986 . “Monitoring African Human Rights” . American Review , Autumn : 8 – 9 .
  • Mubako , S.V. 1973 . “Zambia's Single‐Party Constitution: A Search for Unity and Development” . Zambia Law Journal , 5 : 67ff
  • Welch , C.E. Jr. 1978 . “The Right of Association in Ghana and Tanzania” . Journal of Modern African Studies , 16 ( 4 ) December : 639
  • Nwabueze , B.O. Constitutionalism in Emergent States 159 op. cit.
  • Venter , D. 1981 . “Black Africa and the Apartheid Issue: A South African Response?” . Journal of Contemporary African Studies , 1 ( 1 ) October : 84ff
  • Welch , C.E. Jr. 1981 . “The OAU and Human Rights: Towards a New Definition” . Journal of Modern African Studies , 19 ( 3 ) September : 402ff
  • Weisfelder , R.F. 1984 . “Human Rights under Majority Rule in Southern Africa: The Mote in Thy Brother's Eye” . In Human Rights and Development in Africa , Edited by: Welch , C.E. Jr. and Meltzer , R.I. 117 Albany (New York) : State University of New York Press .
  • Welch , C.E. Jr. 1981 . “The OAU and Human Rights: Towards a New Definition” . Journal of Modern African Studies , 19 ( 3 ) September : 405 – 406 .
  • Welch , C.E. Jr. “Human Rights as a Problem in Contemporary Africa” . Edited by: Welch , C.E. Jr. and Meltzer , R.I. 11 – 14 . op. cit.,
  • Nwabueze , B.O. Constitutionalism in Emergent States 162 op. cit.,
  • Kannyo , E. 1984 . “The Banjul Charter on Human and People's Rights: Genesis and Political Background” . In Human Rights and Development in Africa , Edited by: Welch , C.E. Jr. and Meltzer , R.I. 128ff Albany (New York) : State University of New York Press .
  • Gittleman , R. 1984 . “The Banjul Charter of Human and People's Rights: A Legal Analysis” . In Human Rights and Development in Africa , Edited by: Welch , C.E. Jr. and Meltzer , R.I. 152ff Albany (New York) : State University of New York Press .
  • Greenberg , J. 1979 . “South Africa and the American Experience” . Acta Juridica , : 123

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.