Publication Cover
Politikon
South African Journal of Political Studies
Volume 1, 1974 - Issue 2
17
Views
1
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

‘Freedom once conferred cannot be revoked’

Pages 27-50 | Published online: 24 Feb 2007

References

  • Georg , Jellinek . 1969 . Die Lehre von den Staatenverbindungen , 13 Aälen : herdruk van 1882 uitgawe Scientia .
  • Dicey , A.V. 1959 . Law of the Constitution 39 10de uitgawe
  • Dr G.N. Barrie , Die Soewereiniteit van die Parlement , ongepubliseerde proefskrif, Universiteit van Suid‐Afrika , 1968 .
  • Julian H. Franklin , Jean Bodin and Rise of Absolutist Theory , Cambridge 1973 ;
  • Horst Denzer (red.), Jean Bodin Verhandlungen der Internationalen Bodin Tagung in München , München 1973 .
  • Holdworth , W.S. 1937 . A History of English Law, 2de uitgawe vol. VI , 203 – 207 . en 258. Helmut Quaritsch a.w. p. 453.
  • Salmon , J.H.M. 1959 . The French Religious Wars in English Political Thought 69 Oxford
  • J.W. Gough , Fundamental Law in English Constitutional History , 1955 , p. 7 – 8 .
  • Ernst , Reibstein . 1972 . Volkssouveränität und Freiheitsrechte , Vol. 1 , 248 Band : bewerk deur C. Schott .
  • Jeremy Bentham , A Fragment on Government , herdruk 1931 met inleiding deur F.C. Montague, p. 209 .
  • Jeremy , Bentham . A Fragment on Government A Fragment on Government herdruk 1931 met inleiding deur F.C. Montague 209 XIII en XIV.
  • William , Blackstone . 1778 . Commentaries on the Laws of England , vol. 1 , 48 – 49 . 8ste uitgawe .
  • Ibid.,p. 216 XXII.
  • Ibid.,p. 218 XXVI.
  • Ibid.,I, p. 218 XXVI.
  • Ibid.,I, p. 218 XXVI, p. 220 XXXIV, p. 223 XXXVI.
  • Vergelyk die uiteensetting in sy werk wat nou gepubliseer is onder die titel: Of Laws in General,deur A.L.A. Hart 1970, pp. 64–67.
  • Fragment on Government, pp. 218–221.
  • Ibid., 2,pp. 149–150, XXX.
  • John , Austin . 1832 . The Provence of Jurisprudence Determined 193 – 194 . herdruk in 1954
  • Ibid.,p. 202. Vir hom is staat en soewereiniteit dus ook gelyk, vergelyk p. 226.
  • Ibid.,p. 194 en word weer gestel op p. 195.
  • Ibid.,p. 198.
  • Ibid.,p. 202 e.v.
  • Ibid.,p. 266 en p. 292.
  • Ibid.,p. 230.
  • Ibid.,pp. 194–195.
  • Ibid.,pp. 230–231.
  • Ibid.,p. 231.
  • a.w. pp. 39–40 en p. 50 e.v.
  • Ibid.,p. 40.
  • S.E. Finer , Comparative Government , 1970 , Pelman Books , 1974, 147 .
  • Dicey, a.w. p. 70 e.v.
  • Ibid.,p. 73 e.v.
  • Parliament,1939, p. 1. Vergelyk ook W.I. Jennings, The Law and the Constitution,p. 154.
  • Mitchell , J.D.B. 1968 . Constitutional Law 65 2de uitgawe
  • Smith , S.A. de . 1964 . The New Commonwealth and its Constitutions 4
  • Quaritsch , a.w. pp. 442–443.
  • H.J. van Eikema Homines , Hoofdlijnen van de geschiedenis der rechtsfilosofie , 1972 , pp. 63 – 64 .
  • Friedmann , W. 1951 . Law and Social Change in Contemporary Brittain 104
  • Maitland . 1936 . Selected Essays 113 W. Friedmann, a.w., pp. 177–178.
  • a.w., p. 383.
  • Laski , Harold J. 1947 . Parliamentary Government 8
  • 1932 . The Growth of Political Thought in the West 387
  • Bärtschi , Hans E. 1957 . Die Entwicklung vom imperialistischen Rechtsgedanken zur modernen Idee des Commonwealths im Lebenswerk Lord Balfours 137
  • Karl , Loewenstein . 1967 . Staatsrecht und Staatspraxis von Grossbritannien 77 Band I
  • Latham , R.E.T. 1937 . The Law and the Commonwealth 513
  • Byvoegsel and Hancock , W.K. 1918–1936 . Survey of British Commonwealth Affairs
  • Wheare , K.C. 1953 . The Statute of Westminster and Dominion Status 154 5de uitgawe
  • Keith , A.B. 1933 . Constitutional Law of the British Dominions 38
  • Wheare , K.C. 1953 . The Statute of Westminster and Dominion Status 5de uitgaws 153 – 157 .
  • Wheare , K.C. 1960 . The Constitutional Structure of the Commonwealth
  • (1935) A C 500 op 520.
  • pp. 4 – 5 . . S.A. de Smith, a.w.,
  • Wade , H.W.R. 1955 . The Basis of Legal Sovereignty . Cambridge Law Journal , : 196 – 197 .
  • Jennings , Sir W.I. 1957 . Constitutional Laws of the Commonwealth , 1 : 123
  • de Smith , S.A. 1971 . The Constitution and the Common Market . the Modern Law Review , 34 : 612
  • Wheare , K.C. 1960 . The Constitutional Structure of the Commonwealth 34
  • Wiechers , M. Staatsreg 218 2de uitgawe
  • Die Wet op die Status van die Unie,no. 69 van 1934.
  • a.w., p. 533.
  • H.W.R. Wade, a.w., p. 191.
  • Merle , Lipton . 1972 . International Affairs , 48 ( 1 ) : 19 “The action of South Africa in voluntarily fragmenting its territory and granting independance to some of the large and small fragments would be unprecedented.”
  • Riesenberg , Peter N. 1956 . Inalienability of Sovereignty in Medieval Political Thought 82 – 89 .
  • Ernst , Kantorowiz . 1968 . Kingship under the Impact of Jurisprudence, opgeneem in sy Selected Studies 164 – 165 .
  • 1952 . “ Vergelyk ook Friedrich August Freiherr von der Heydte ” . In Die Geburtsstunde des souveränen Staates 95
  • Schwarz , H.A. and Liebermann , von Wahlendorf . 1971 . Fondement et Principes d'un Ordre Juridique Naissant 189 190 192 en 193. Die skrywer steun hoofsaaklik op Ernst Kantorowiz se bekende werk The Kings Two Bodies,1957 (ongelukkig is die werk nie op die oomblik in enige Suid‐Afrikaanse biblioteek beskikbaar nie).
  • Ibid.,p. 195.
  • Salmond . 1957 . Jurisprudence , 373 11de uitgawe .
  • 1936 . Maitland‐Selected Essays 109
  • P.J.J. Olivier , Legal Fictions: An Analysis and Evaluation , 1973 , p. 184 .
  • Maitland . The Crown as Corporation in Selected Essays 104 – 127 .
  • a.w., p. 373. Vergelyk ook Von Wahlendorf, a.w., p. 190.
  • Blackstone, a.w. I., p. 160. Austin, a.w., p. 236, wys op die moontlike teenstrydighede in die standpunt van Blackstone.
  • Blackstone , a.w. I,p. 252.
  • Ibid.,I, p. 241 e.v.
  • Ibid.,I, p. 250.
  • Ibid.,I, p. 249.
  • Austin , a.w. p. 236 en p. 266.
  • Ibid.,p. 230.
  • Ibid.,p. 261 e.v.
  • Ibid.,p. 212.
  • Ibid.,p. 198.
  • Ibid.,p. 202 e.v.
  • Ibid.,p. 303.
  • Ibid.,pp. 229–230.
  • Ibid.,p. 230.
  • Dicey . Englands Case Against Home Rule 244 – 5 . aangehaal deur H.W.R. Wade, a.w., p. 196, sien ook Dicey, The Law and the Constitution,10de uitgawe, p. 68.
  • D.V. Cowen , The Foundation of Freedom , 1961 , p. 180 .
  • Tammelo , Vergelyk ook Iimar . 1958 . The Antinomy of Parliamentary Sovereignty
  • Loewenstein , a.w. p. 62.
  • Omar Tammelo, a.w., pp. 507–108 stel die moontlikheid, vergelyk ook E.C.S. Wade, a.w., p. 90.
  • Anson , W.R. 1886 . “The Government of Ireland Bill and the Sovereignty of Parliament” . The Law Quarterly Review , : 427 e.v.
  • Ibid.,p. 438.
  • Ibid.,p. 440.
  • pp. 194 – 196 . . H.W.R. Wade a.w.,
  • Cowen , D.V. 1961 . The Foundations of Freedom 183 – 184 .
  • 1953 . “Legislature and Judiciary” . Modern Law Review , 16 ( 3 ) : 292 – 293 .
  • The Foundations of Freedom 180 – 181 .
  • Dicey , vergelyk ook . The Law and the Constitution 18
  • Cowen , D.V. The Foundations of Freedom 184
  • Kahn , Prof E. 1963 . “Some Thoughts on the Competency of the Transkeian Legislative Assembly and the Sovereignty of the South African Parliament” . S A L J , : 473 480
  • Wiechers , M. Staatsreg 454 – 457 . 2de uitgawe
  • G.N. Barrie, a.w., p. 246.
  • de Smith , S.A. The Commonwealth and its constitutions 4 – 5 .
  • de Smith , S.A. 1971 . “The Constitution and the Common Market” . Modern Law Review , 34 : 612
  • Ibid.,p. 613.
  • 1953 . Legislature and Judiciary , 297 M L R .
  • Loc. sit.
  • 1971 . Blackburn v. Attorney‐General , Vol. 2 , 1380 All E R .
  • Ibid.,p. 1381.
  • 1971 . The Constitution and the Common Market . M L R , 34 : 607
  • Tindale , F.A. 1972 . Parliamentary Sovereignty and the Primacy of European Community Law , vol. 35 , 375 – 402 . M L R . wys op die probleme indien daar vasgeklou word aan die tradisionele leerstuk maar aangesien hy voel dat die howe nie daarvan sal afsien nie bespreek hy verskillende tegniese middele sodat voorkom kan word dat die leerstuk van parlementêre soewereniteit die samewerking van Britanje in die Europese Gemeenskappe kan skaad.
  • Gilmour , D.R. 1968 . The Sovereignty of Parliament and the European Commission of Human Rights . Public Law , Spring : 72 – 73 .
  • Kaiser , Joseph H. 1972 . Souverän, Souveraner, Parlamentarische Souveränität , 102 Europarecht .
  • Art. 15 van Wet 46 van 1959.
  • Art. 2(1) (c) Wet op Bantoeowerhede, no. 65 van 1951.
  • Art. 7 van Wet 65 van 1951.
  • By Prok. R173 van 1973word so ‘n hof vir die Transkei ingestel met ingang vanaf 1 Augustus 1973.
  • Wet no. 54 van 1968.
  • Art. 2 Wet 54 van 1968. (Later gewysig deur Art. 8 Wet 23 van 1972 en nou vervang deur Art. 2 van Wet 20 van 1973).
  • Art. 1 van Wet 48 van 1963.
  • Kragtens Art. 26(1) van die Grondwet van Bantoetuislande no. 21 van 1971 is die volgende gebiede tot selfregerende gebiede verhef by wyse van proklamasie deur die Staats‐president.
  • Bophuthatswana Prok R131 van 1972
  • Ciskei Prok R187 van 1972
  • Lebowa Prok R225 van 1972
  • Venda Prok R12 van 1973
  • Gazankulu Prok R15 van 1973
  • Quaqua Prok R203 van 1974
  • Vergelyk skrywers genoem in voetnoot 110.
  • McWhinney , E. Federal Constitutional Making for a Multi‐National World 106 – 107 . stel dit soos volg t.a.v. die Britse ryksontbinding: “The extraordinary devolution of British political authority and ultimately also surrender of British sovereignty involved in the transition from Colonial Empire to Commonwealth is, in the end, simply a timely recognition by the British government at Westminster of the effective limits to the assertion of a juridical power that rests on the historical accidents of past military conquest or settlement in an era when claims of nationalism, independence and political self‐determination are paramount”.
  • 1937, A D, p. 229. of.Vergelyk ook Lord Denning in Blackburn v. Attorney‐General(1971). 2, All E R, p. 1380 of 1382. “Freedom once given cannot be taken away”.
  • Felix , Ermacora . 1970 . Allgemeine Staatslehre Vol. 2 , 900 Band
  • Art. 73 van die Handves van die Verenigde Volke.
  • Felix Ermacora, a.w., Band 2, p. 900.
  • Ibid.,p. 908. Bryce, Studies in History and Jurisprudence,vol. I, p. 290, gebruik ook hierdie terminologie by die tipering van federate stelsels.
  • vergelyk , Theodor Veiter . 1970 . Das Recht der Volksgruppen und Sprach‐minderheiten in Österreich 22 So ‘n gemeenskap sou volgens die tradisionele siening in die Duitse en Slawiese state as “nasie” aangedui kan word, “nasie” verwys daar na ‘n etniese gemeenskap met die tendens tot staatwording —
  • Rhoodie , Dr N.J. 1969 . Apartheid and Racial Partnership in Southern Africa 70 85 88 127
  • Friedrich August Freiherr von der Heydte , Völkerrecht ,Band I, 1958 , p. 296 .
  • Dr George Dahm , Völkerrecht , Band I, 1958 , p. 84 .
  • Hans , Kelsen . 1960 . Das Problem der Souveränität 54 herdruk van 2de uitgawe, 1928
  • 1958 . Strukturprobleme der modernen Demokratie 267 – 269 .
  • Smith , S.A. de . 1971 . “The Constitution and the Common Market” . M L R , 34 : 613

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.