Robert Boyle's epistemology: The interaction between scientific and religious knowledgeFootnote¹

A version of this paper was given in March 1991, at the annual International Conference for Philosophy of Science in Dubrovnik; a later version was given at a joint session of the Canadian Society for the History and Philosophy of Science and the Canadian Society for the Study of European Ideas in May 1991. I am grateful to members of the audience on both occasions for helpful suggestions. I have also benefited from a number of conversations with Margaret Osier on Boyleana and related 17th century matters. All workers on the Boyle manuscripts know how helpful the Librarian and staff of the Royal Society Library are, and I should like to thank them once again for that help, as well as thanking the Royal Society for permission to quote from the Boyle Letters and the Boyle Papers.

References to the Royal Society's Boyle Papers (BP) are given by volume and page or folio as appropriate, with recto and verso indicated as necessary. In transcriptions from the Boyle Papers I have indicated Boyle's deletions by brackets ([,]), insertions by pointed brackets (<,>), conjectured readings and my insertion of obvious omissions by braces ({,}), and catch words by slashes (/). Since we do not yet have a definitive edition of Boyle: references to his works are given by chapter, section, etc, as appropriate, followed by the volume and page in Thomas Birch's 1772 edition of The Works (6 vols, London, 1772; reprinted Hildesheim: Georg Olms, 1966).

References

• Adam , Ch. and Tannery , P. , eds. 1964 . Oeuvres de Descartes , revised edn , Paris : Vrin/C.N.R.S. . 1964–76
   Google Scholar
• Aristotle . 1984 . (The Complete Works of Aristotle , Edited by: Barnes , J. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Arnold , K. 1989a . Pascal's theory of scientific knowledge . Journal of the History of Philosophy , 27 : 531 – 544 .
   Google Scholar
• Arnold , K. 1989b . Pascal's great experiment . Dialogue , 28 : 401 – 415 .
   Google Scholar
• Ashworth , E.J. 1974 . Language and Logic in the Post‐medieval Period , Dordrecht : D. Reidel .
   Google Scholar
• Aubrey , J. 1957 . Brief Lives , Edited by: Dick , O.L. Ann Arbor : University of Michigan Press .
   Google Scholar
• Bacon , F. 1860 . The Works of Francis Bacon , Edited by: Spedding , J. , Ellis , R.L. and Heath , D.D. 14 vols , London, Stuttgart : Friedrich Frommann . 1962).
   Google Scholar
• Beck , D. 1986 . Miracle and the mechanical philosophy: the teleology of Robert Boyle in its historical context , Notre Dame : University Microfilms International 8702205 . Unpublished PhD thesis,
   Google Scholar
• Bennett , J. 1984 . A Study of Spinoza's Ethics , Hackett : Indianapolis .
   Google Scholar
• Blundeville , T. 1599 . The Art of Logike , London : The Scolar Press . 1599; reprinted Menston,
   Google Scholar
• Boas , M. 1958 . Robert Boyle and Seventeenth Century Chemistry , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Boyle , R. 1685 . An historical account of a strangely self‐moving liquor . Philosophical Transactions ,
   Google Scholar
• Boyle , R. 1772 . The Works of the Honourable Robert Boyle Edited by: Birch , T. 6 vols , London reprinted Hildesheim, Georg Olms, 1966).
   Google Scholar
• Burthogge , R. 1694 . An Essay upon Reason and the Nature of Spirits , London : Garland Publishing . reprinted New York,
   Google Scholar
• Crane , T. 1991 . All God has to do . Analysis , 51.4 : 235 – 244 .
   Google Scholar
• Cudworth , R. 1678 . The True Intellectual System of the Universe: The First Part; wherein, All the Reason and Philosophy of Atheism is Confuted; and Its Impossibility Demonstrated London 1678 reprinted Stuttgart‐Bad Cannstatt, Friedrich Frommann, 1964).
   Google Scholar
• Dean , W. 1959 . Handel's Dramatic Oratorios and Masques , London : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Dear , P. 1990 . Miracles, experiments and the ordinary course of nature . Isis , 81 : 663 – 683 .
   Google Scholar
• Descartes , R. 1983 . Principles of Philosophy , Edited by: Miller , V.R. and Miller , R.P. Dordrecht : D. Reidel .
   Google Scholar
• Foxcroft , H.C. 1902 . A Supplement to Burnet's History of My Own Time Oxford
   Google Scholar
• Garber , D. 1978 . “ Science and certainty in Descartes ” . In Descartes: Critical and Interpretative Essays , Edited by: Hooker , M. Baltimore : Johns Hopkins University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Gerhardt , C.I. , ed. 1875–90 . Leibniz: Philosophische Schriften 7 vols , Berlin 1875–90, reprinted Hildesheim, Olds, 1960–61).
   Google Scholar
• Grotius , H. 1624 . The Truth of the Christian Religion Paris
   Google Scholar
• Hacking , I. 1975 . The Emergence of Probability , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hacking , I. 1983 . Representing and Intervening , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Hall , A.R. and Hall , M.B. , eds. 1966 . The Correspondence of Henry Oldenburg, Volume II, 1663–1665 , Madison : University of Wisconsin Press .
   Google Scholar
• Harré , R. 1989 . “ Realism, reference and theory ” . In Key Themes in Philosophy , Edited by: Phillips Griffiths , A. 53 – 68 . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Huygens , C. 1899 . Œuvres Complètes de Christiaan Huygens , 22 vols , The Hague : Martinus Nijhoff . 1888–1950; vol. 8, 1899).
   Google Scholar
• Leibniz , G. 1977 . Discourse on the Natural Theology of the Chinese , Edited by: Rosemont , H. Jr and Cook , D.J. Honolulu : University Press of Hawaii .
   Google Scholar
• Leslie , J. 1989 . Universes , London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
   Google Scholar
• Locke , J. 1823 . The Works of John Locke 10 vols , London 1823 reprinted Aalen, Scientia, 1963).
   Google Scholar
• Locke , J. 1975 . An Essay Concerning Human Understanding , Edited by: Nidditch , P.H. Oxford : Clarendon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Loemker , L.R. , ed. 1956 . Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Philosophical Papers and Letters , 2 vols , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
   Google Scholar
• Mackie , J.L. 1976 . Problems from Locke , Oxford : Clarendon Press .
   Google Scholar
• Macintosh , J.J. 1991 . “ Robert Boyle on epicurean atomism and atheism ” . In Atoms, Pneuma, and Tranquility : Epicurean and Stoic Themes in European Thought , Edited by: Osler , M. J. 197 – 219 . New York : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Macintosh , J.J. 1983 . Perception and imagination in Descartes, Boyle and Hooke . Canadian Journal of Philosophy , 13 : 327 – 352 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• McRae , R. 1985 . “ Miracles and laws ” . In The Natural Philosophy of Leibniz , Edited by: Okruhlik , K. and Brown , J.R. 171 – 181 . Dordrecht : D. Reidel .
   Google Scholar
• Maddison , R.E.W. 1969 . The Life of the Honourable Robert Boyle, F.R.S , London : Taylor & Francis .
   Google Scholar
• Malebranche , N. 1980 . Dialogue between a Christian Philosopher and a Chinese Philosopher on the Nature and Existence of God , Edited by: Iorio , D.A. Washington : University Press of America .
   Google Scholar
• Mason , H.T. , ed. 1967 . The Leibniz‐Arnauld Correspondence , Manchester : Manchester University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Migne , J.‐P. 1844 . Patrologia Latina , Paris : Unayet .
   Google Scholar
• More , L.T. 1944 . The Life and Works of the Honourable Robert Boyle , London : Oxford University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Morrison , M. 1989 . “ Hypotheses and certainty in cartesian science ” . In An Intimate Relation , Edited by: Brown , J.R. and Mittelstrass , J. 43 – 64 . Dordrecht : Kluwer .
   Google Scholar
• Mungello , D.E. 1977 . Leibniz and Confucianism: The Search for Accord , Honolulu : University Press of Hawaii .
   Google Scholar
• Newton , I. 1959 . Correspondence , Edited by: Turnbull , H.W. 7 vols , Cambridge : published for the Royal Society at the University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Okruhlik , K. 1985 . “ The status of scientific laws in the Leibnizian system ” . In The Natural Philosophy of Leibniz , Edited by: Okruhlik , K. and Brown , J.R. 183 – 206 . Dordrecht : D. Reidel .
   Google Scholar
• Osler , M.J. 1985 . Eternal truths and the laws of nature: the theological foundations of Descartes’ philosophy of nature . Journal of the History of Ideas , 46 : 349 – 362 .
   Google Scholar
• Rogers , G.A.J. 1966 . Boyle, Locke, and Reason . Journal of the History of Ideas , 27 : 205 – 216 .
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Roy , O. 1972 . Leibniz et la Chine , Paris : Librairie Philosophique J. Vrin .
   Google Scholar
• Salmon , W. 1671 . Synopsis Medicinæ, or a Compendium of ... Physick , London : J. Dawks .
   Google Scholar
• Savitt , S. Selective scientific realism, constructive empiricism, and the unification of theories . Western Canadian Philosophical Association Meetings .
   Google Scholar
• Schneider , I. 1980 . “ Why do we find the origin of a calculus of probabilities in the seventeenth century? ” . In Probabilistic Thinking, Thermodynamics and the Interaction of the History and Philosophy of Science , Edited by: Hintikka , J. , Gruender , D. and Agazzi , E. Vol. 2 , 3 – 24 . Dordrecht : D. Reidel .
   Google Scholar
• Shapin , S. and Schaffer , S. 1985 . Leviathan and the Air Pump , Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Shapin , S. 1988 . Robert Boyle and mathematics: reality, representation, and experimental practice . Science in Context , 2 : 23 – 58 .
   Google Scholar
• van Leeuwen , H. 1970 . The Problem of Certainty in English Thought 1630–1690 , The Hague : Martinus Nijhoff .
   Google Scholar
• A version of this paper was given in March 1991, at the annual International Conference for Philosophy of Science in Dubrovnik; a later version was given at a joint session of the Canadian Society for the History and Philosophy of Science and the Canadian Society for the Study of European Ideas in May 1991. I am grateful to members of the audience on both occasions for helpful suggestions. I have also benefited from a number of conversations with Margaret Osier on Boyleana and related 17th century matters. All workers on the Boyle manuscripts know how helpful the Librarian and staff of the Royal Society Library are, and I should like to thank them once again for that help, as well as thanking the Royal Society for permission to quote from the Boyle Letters and the Boyle Papers. References to the Royal Society's Boyle Papers (BP) are given by volume and page or folio as appropriate, with recto and verso indicated as necessary. In transcriptions from the Boyle Papers I have indicated Boyle's deletions by brackets ([,]), insertions by pointed brackets (<,>), conjectured readings and my insertion of obvious omissions by braces ({,}), and catch words by slashes (/). Since we do not yet have a definitive edition of Boyle: references to his works are given by chapter, section, etc, as appropriate, followed by the volume and page in Thomas Birch's 1772 edition of The Works (6 vols, London, 1772; reprinted Hildesheim: Georg Olms, 1966).
   Google Scholar