1,543
Views
19
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
INVITED ARTICLE

Developmental biology enriches paleontology

, &
Pages 1223-1234 | Received 21 Oct 2011, Accepted 19 Jun 2012, Published online: 31 Oct 2012

LITERATURE CITED

  • Barton , N. H. , Briggs , D. E. G. , Eisen , J. A. , Goldstein , D. B. and Patel , N. H. 2007 . “ Evolution ” . 833 New York : Cold Spring Harbor Laboratories Press, Cold Spring Harbor .
  • Behringer , R. R. , Eakin , G. S. and Renfree , M. B. 2006 . Mammalian diversity: gametes, embryos, and reproduction . Reproduction, Fertility, and Development , 18 : 99 – 107 .
  • Bell , M. A. 1994 . “ Paleobiology and evolution of threespine stickleback ” . In The Evolutionary Biology of the Threespine Stickleback , Edited by: Bell , M. A. and Foster , S. A. 438 – 469 . Oxford , , U.K : Oxford University Press .
  • Bell , M. A. , Baumgartner , J. V. and Olson , E. C. 1985 . Patterns of temporal change in single morphological characteristics of a Miocene stickleback fish . Paleobiology , 11 : 258 – 271 .
  • Bell , M. A. , Travis , M. P. and Blouw , D. M. 2006 . Inferring natural selection in a fossil threespine stickleback . Paleobiology , 32 : 562 – 577 .
  • Bell , M. A. , Ortí , G. , Walker , J. A. and Koenings , J. P. 1993 . Evolution of pelvic reduction in threespine sticklebacks: a test of competing hypotheses . Evolution , 47 : 906 – 914 .
  • Bever , G. S. , Gauthier , J. A. and Wagner , G. P. 2011 . Finding the frame shift: digit loss, developmental variability, and the origin of the avian hand . Evolution and Development , 13 : 269 – 279 .
  • Bolker , J. A. 2002 . Modulatiry in development and why it matters to evo-devo . American Zoologist , 40 : 770 – 776 .
  • Buchholtz , E. A. 2007 . Modular evolution of the cetacean vertebral column . Evolution and Development , 9 : 278 – 289 .
  • Burke , A. C. and Feduccia , A. 1997 . Developmental patterns and the Identification of homologies in the avian hand . Science , 278 : 666 – 668 .
  • Burke , A. C. , Nelson , C. E. , Morgan , B. A. and Tabin , C. 1995 . Hox genes and the evolution of vertebrate axial morphology . Development , 121 : 333 – 346 .
  • Caldwell , M. W. 2000 . On the phylogenetic relationships of Pachyrhachis within snakes: a response to Zaher (1998) . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology , 20 : 187 – 190 .
  • Caldwell , M. W. and Lee , M. S. Y. 1997 . A snake with legs from the marine Cretaceous of the middle east . Nature , 386 : 705 – 709 .
  • Carroll , S. B. , Grenier , J. K. and Weatherbee , S. B. 2004 . From DNA to Diversity , 214 Malden , Massachusetts : Blackwell Science .
  • Chan , Y. F. , Marks , M. E. , Jones , F. C. , Villarreal , G. Jr. , Shapiro , M. D. , Brady , S. D. , Southwick , A. M. , Absher , D. M. , Grimwood , J. , Schmutz , J. , Myers , R. M. , Petrov , D. , Jónsson , B. , Schluter , D. , Bell , M. A. and Kingsley , D. M. 2010 . Adaptive evolution of pelvic reduction in sticklebacks by recurrent deletion of a Pitx1 enhancer . Science , 327 : 302 – 305 .
  • Charité , J. , McFadden , D. G. and Olson , E. N. 2000 . The bHLH transcription factor dHAND controls Sonic hedgehog expression and establishment of the zone of polarizing activity during limb development . Development , 127 : 2461 – 2470 .
  • Chuong , C.-M. 1998 . “ Morphogenesis of epithelial appendages: variations on top of a common theme and implications in regeneration ” . In Molecular Basis of Epithelial Appendage Morphogenesis , Edited by: Chuong , C.-M. 3 – 14 . Austin , Texas : R. G. Landes .
  • Cohn , M. I. and Tickle , C. 1999 . Developmental basis of limblessness and axial patterning in snakes . Nature , 399 : 474 – 479 .
  • Cresko , W. A. , Amores , A. , Wilson , C. , Murphy , J. , Currey , M. , Phillips , P. , Bell , M. A. , Kimmel , C. B. and Postlethwait , J. H. 2004 . Parallel genetic basis for repeated evolution of armor loss in Alaskan threespine stickleback populations . Trends in Genetics , 20 : 481 – 490 .
  • Di-Poï , N. , Montoya-Burgos , J. I. , Miller , H. , Pourquié , O. , Milinkovitch , M. C. and Duboule , D. 2010 . Changes in Hox genes’ structure and function during the evolution of the squamate body plan . Nature , 464 : 99 – 103 .
  • Eakin , G. S. and Behringer , R. R. 2004 . Diversity of germ layer and axis formation among mammals . Seminars in Cell and Developmental Biology , 15 : 619 – 629 .
  • Fliniaux , I. , Mikkola , M. L. , Lefebvre , S. and Thesleff , I. 2008 . Identification of dkk4 as a target of Eda-A1/Edar pathway reveals an unexpected role of ectodysplasin as inhibitor of Wnt . Developmental Biology , 320 : 60 – 71 .
  • Franzen , J.-L. 1981 . Das erste Skelett eines Dichobuniden (Mammalia, Artiodactyla) geborgen aus mitteleozänen Ölschiefer der ‘Grube Messel’ bei Darmstadt (Deutschland, S.-Hessen) . Senckenbergiania Lethaea , 61 : 299 – 353 .
  • Fromental-Ramain , C. , Warot , X. , Messadecq , N. , LeMeur , M. , Dolle , P. and Chambon , P. 1996 . Hoxa-13 and Hoxd-13 play a crucial role in the patterning of the limb autopod . Development , 122 : 2997 – 3011 .
  • Galis , F. 1999 . Why do almost all mammals have seven cervical vertebrae? Developmental constraints, Hox genes and cancer . Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution , 285 : 19 – 26 .
  • Gilbert , S. F. 2010 . Developmental Biology, , Ninth Edition , 711 Sunderland , Massachusetts : Sinauer .
  • Gingerich , P. D. , Smith , B. H. and Simons , E. L. 1990 . Hind limbs of Basilosaurus isis: evidence for feet in whales . Science , 229 : 154 – 157 .
  • Gingerich , P. D. , Haq , M. U. , Zalmout , I. S. , Khan , I. H. and Malkani , M. S. 2001 . Origin of whales from early artiodactyls: hands and feet of Eocene Protocetidae from Pakistan . Science , 293 : 235 – 267 .
  • Gingerich , P. D. , Raza , S. M. , Arif , M. , Anwar , M. and Zhou , X. 1994 . New whale from the Eocene of Pakistan and the origin of cetacean swimming . Nature , 368 : 844 – 847 .
  • Gould , S. J. 1977 . “ Ontogeny and Phylogeny ” . 477 Cambridge , Massachusetts : Belknap Press of Harvard Press .
  • Gridley , T. 2006 . The long and short of it: somite formation in mice . Developmental Dynamics , 235 : 2330 – 2336 .
  • Haldiman , J. T. and Tarpley , R. J. 1993 . “ Anatomy and physiology ” . Edited by: Burns , J. J. , Montague , J. J. and Cowles , C. J. 71 – 156 . The Bowhead Whale. Society for Marine Mammalogy, Special Publication 2 .
  • Hall , B. K. 1998 . Evolutionary Developmental Biology, , second edition , 491 London : Chapman and Hall .
  • Hansen , K. L. 2010 . A history of digit identification in the manus of theropods (including Aves) . Geological Society, London, Special Publications , 343 : 265 – 275 .
  • Harfe , B. D. , Scherz , P. J. , Nissim , S. , Tian , H. , McMahon , A. P. and Tabin , C. J. 2004 . Evidence for an expansion-based temporal Shh gradient in specifying vertebrate digit identities . Cell , 118 : 517 – 528 .
  • Hernández-Martínez , R. and Covarrubias , L. 2011 . Interdigital cell death function and regulation: new insights on an old programmed cell death model . Development, Growth & Differentiation , 53 : 245 – 258 .
  • Hockman , D. , Cretekos , C. J. , Mason , M. K. , Behringer , R. R. , Jacobs , D. S. and Illing , N. 2008 . A second wave of Sonic hedgehog expression during the development of the bat limb . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , 105 : 16982 – 16987 .
  • Holland , L. Z. 2008 . The Amphioxus genome illuminates vertebrate origins and cephalochordate biology . Genome Research , 18 : 1100 – 1111 . (64 authors).
  • Horan , G. S. B. , Ramirez-Solis , R. , Featherstone , M. S. , Wolgemuth , D. J. , Bradley , A. and Behringer , R. R. 1995 . Compound mutants for the paralogous hoxa-4, hoxb-4, and hoxd-4 genes show more complete homeotic transformations and a dose-dependent increase in the number of vertebrae transformed . Genes & Development , 9 : 1667 – 1677 .
  • Jeffery , J. E. , Bininda-Emonds , O. R. , Coates , M. I. and Richardson , M. K. 2005 . A new technique for identifying sequence heterochrony . Systematic Biology , 54 : 230 – 240 .
  • Kangas , A. T. , Evans , A. R. , Thesleff , I. and Jernvall , J. 2004 . Nonindependence of mammalian dental characters . Nature , 432 : 211 – 214 .
  • Laws , R. M. 1966 . Age criteria for the African elephant . East African Wildlife Journal , 4 : 1 – 37 .
  • Lee , M. S. Y. and Caldwell , M. W. 1998 . Anatomy and relationships of the primitive snake Pachyrhachis . Philosophical Transactions: Biological Sciences , 353 : 1521 – 1552 .
  • Lewis , J. and Özbudak , E. M. 2007 . Deciphering the somite segmentation clock: beyond mutants and morphants . Developmental Dynamics , 236 : 1410 – 1415 .
  • Mallo , E. A. 2009 . The road to the vertebral formula . Journal of Developmental Biology , 53 : 8 – 10 .
  • Markitantova , Y. V. , Avdonin , P. P. , Grigoryan , E. N. and Zinov’eva , R. D. 2010 . Identification of the Pitx1 embryogenesis regulatory gene in a regenerating newt retina . Doklady Biological Sciences , 435 : 421 – 424 .
  • McCollum , M. A. , Rosenman , B. A. , Suwa , G. , Meindl , R. S. and Lovejoy , C. O. 2010 . The vertebral formula of the last common ancestor of African apes and humans . Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution , 314 : 123 – 134 .
  • Merino , R. , Rodriguez-Leon , J. , Macias , D. , Ganan , Y. , Economides , A. N. and Hurle , J. M. 1999 . The BMP antagonist Gremlin regulates outgrowth, chondrogenesis and programmed cell death in the developing limb . Development , 126 : 5515 – 5522 .
  • Milinkovitch , M. C. and Tzika , A. 2007 . Escaping the mouse trap: the selection of new evo-devo model species . Journal of Experimental Zoology: Molecular and Developmental Evolution , 308B : 337 – 346 .
  • Montavon , T. , Le Garrec , J. -F. O. , Kerszberg , M. and Duboule , D. 2008 . Modeling Hox gene regulation in digits: reverse collinearity and the molecular origin of thumbness . Genes & Development , 22 : 346 – 359 .
  • Muller , G. B. 2007 . Evo-devo: extending the evolutionary synthesis . Nature Reviews, Genetics , 8 : 943 – 949 .
  • Müller , J. , Scheyer , T. M. , Head , J. J. , Barrett , P. M. , Werneburg , I. , Ericson , P. G. , Pol , D. and Sánchez-Villagra , M. R. 2010 . Homeotic effects, somitogenesis and the evolution of vertebral numbers in recent and fossil amniotes . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , 107 : 2118 – 2123 .
  • Narita , Y. and Kuratani , S. 2005 . Evolution of the vertebral formulae in mammals: a perspective on developmental constraints . Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution , 15 : 91 – 106 .
  • Pajni-Underwood , S. , Wilson , C. P. , Elder , C. , Mishina , Y. and Lewandoski , M. 2007 . BMP signals control limb bud interdigital programmed cell death by regulating FGF signaling . Development , 134 : 2359 – 2368 .
  • Panman , L. and Zeller , R. 2003 . Patterning the limb before and after SHH signalling . Journal of Anatomy , 202 : 3 – 12 .
  • Paus , R. 1998 . Principles of hair cycle control . Journal of Dermatology , 25 : 793 – 802 .
  • Polly , P. D. , Head , J. J. and Cohn , M. J. 2001 . “ Testing modularity and dissociation: the evolution of regional proportions in snakes ” . In Beyond Heterochrony: The Evolution of Development , Edited by: Zeldtich , M. L. 305 – 335 . New York : Wiley .
  • Proszkowiec-Weglarz , M. , Higgins , S. E. and Porter , T. E. 2011 . Changes in gene expression during pituitary morphogenesis and organogenesis in the chick embryo . Endocrinology , 152 : 989 – 1000 .
  • Raff , R. A. 2007 . Written in stone: fossils, genes and evo-devo . Nature Reviews Genetics , 8 : 911 – 920 .
  • Raff , R. A. and Sly , B. J. 2000 . Modularity and dissociation in the evolution of gene expression territories in development . Evolution & Development , 2 : 102 – 113 .
  • Raff , R. A. , Arthur , W. , Carroll , S. B. , Coates , M. I. and Wray , G.G. 1999 . Editorial: chronicling the birth of a discipline . Evolution & Development , 1 : 1 – 2 .
  • Reimchen , T. E. 1994 . “ Predators and morphological evolution in threespine stickleback ” . In The Evolutionary Biology of the Threespine Stickleback , Edited by: Bell , M. A. and Foster , S. A. 240 – 276 . Oxford , , U.K : Oxford University Press .
  • Reno , P. L. , McCollum , M. A. , Cohn , M. J. , Meindl , R. S. , Hamrick , M. and Lovejoy , C. O. 2008 . Patterns of correlation and covariation of anthropoid distal forelimb segments correspond to Hoxd expression territories . Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution , 310 : 240 – 258 .
  • Richardson , M. K. , Gobes , S. M. , van Leeuwen , A. C. , Polman , J. A. , Pieau , C. and Sánchez-Villagra , M. R. 2009 . Heterochrony in limb evolution: developmental mechanisms and natural selection . Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution , 312 : 639 – 646 .
  • Richman , J. M. and Handrigan , G. R. 2011 . Reptilian tooth development . Genesis , 49 : 247 – 260 .
  • Romer , A. S. 1956 . “ Osteology of the Reptiles ” . 772 Chicago , Illinois : University of Chicago Press .
  • Sanders , W. J. , Gheerbrandt , E. , Harris , J. M. , Saegusa , H. and Delmer , C. 2010 . “ Proboscidea ” . In Cenozoic Mammals of Africa , Edited by: Werdelin , L. and Sanders , W. J. 253 – 260 . Berkeley , California : University of California Press .
  • Shapiro , M. D. , Bell , M. A. and Kingsley , D. M. 2006 . Parallel genetic origins of pelvic reduction in vertebrates . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , : 13753 – 13758 . 103
  • Shapiro , M. D. , Hanken , J. and Rosenthal , N. 2003 . Developmental basis of evolutionary digit loss in the Australian lizard Hemiergis . Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution , : 48 – 56 . 297
  • Shapiro , M. D. , Marks , M. E. , Peichel , C. L. , Blackman , B. K. , Nereng , K. S. , Jónsson , B. , Schluter , D. and Kingsley , D. M. 2004 . Genetic and developmental basis of evolutionary pelvic reduction in threespine sticklebacks . Nature , 428 : 717 – 723 .
  • Shapiro , M. D. , Summers , B. R. , Balabhadra , S. , Aldenhoven , J. T. , Miller , A. L. , Cunningham , C. B. , Bell , M. A. and Kingsley , D. M. 2009 . The genetic architecture of skeletal convergence and sex determination in ninespine sticklebacks . Current Biology , 19 : 1140 – 1145 .
  • Slijper , E. J. 1936 . Die Cetaceen, vergleichend-anatomisch und systematisch . Capita Zoologica , 6/7 : 1 – 590 .
  • Smith , K. K. 2003 . Time's arrow: heterochrony and the development of evolution . International Journal of Developmental Biology , 47 : 613 – 621 .
  • Sommer , R. J. 2005 . Genomic platforms for “evo-devo.” . Current Genomics , 6 : 569 – 570 .
  • Tamura , K. , Nomura , N. , Seki , R. , Yonei-Tamura , S. and Yokoyama , H. 2011 . Embryological evidence identifies wing digits in birds as digits 1, 2, and 3 . Science , 331 : 753 – 757 .
  • Tanaka , M. , Hale , L. A. , Amores , A. , Yan , Y. L. , Cresko , W. A. , Suzuki , T. and Postlethwait , J. H. 2005 . Developmental genetic basis for the evolution of pelvic fin loss in the pufferfish Takifugu rubripes . Developmental Biology , 281 : 227 – 239 .
  • Tassy , P. 1996 . “ Who is who among the Proboscidea? ” . In The Proboscidea, Evolution and Palaeoecology of Elephants and Their Relatives , Edited by: Shoshani , J. and Tassy , P. 39 – 48 . Oxford , , U.K : Oxford University Press .
  • Thewissen , J. G. M. and Heyning , J. 2007 . “ Embryogenesis and development in Stenella attenuata and other Cetaceans ” . In Reproductive Biology and Phylogeny of Cetacea , Edited by: Miller , D. 307 – 329 . Enfield , New Hampshire : Science Publishers .
  • Thewissen , J. G. M. , Hussain , S. T. and Arif , M. 1994 . Fossil evidence for the origin of aquatic locomotion in archaeocete whales . Science , 263 : 210 – 212 .
  • Thewissen , J. G. M. , Cooper , L. N. , George , J. C. and Bajpai , S. 2009 . From land to water: the origin of whales, dolphins, and porpoises . Evolution: Education and Outreach , 2 : 272 – 288 .
  • Thewissen , J. G. M. , Cooper , L. N. , Clementz , M. T. , Bajpai , S. and Tiwari , B. N. 2007 . Whales originated from aquatic artiodactyls in the Eocene epoch of India . Nature , 450 : 1190 – 1195 .
  • Thewissen , J. G. M. , Cohn , M. J. , Stevens , L. S. , Bajpai , S. , Heyning , J. and Horton , W. E. Jr . 2006 . Developmental basis for hind limb loss in dolphins and the origin of the cetacean bodyplan . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , 103 : 8414 – 8418 .
  • Uhen , M. D. 2003 . Form, function, and anatomy of Dorudon atrox (Mammalia, Cetacea) . University of Michigan, Papers on Paleontology , 34 : 1 – 222 .
  • Wagner , G. P. and Gauthier , J. A. 1999 . 1,2,3 = 2,3,4: a solution to the problem of the homology of the digits in the avian hand . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , 96 : 5111 – 5116 .
  • Wagner , G. P. and Vargas , A. 2008 . On the nature of thumbs . Genome Biology , 9 : 213 – 213.3 .
  • Wang , Z. , Young , R. L. , Xue , H. and Wagner , G. P. 2011 . Transcriptomic analysis of avian digits reveals conserved and derived digit identities in birds . Nature , 477 : 583 – 586 .
  • Weatherbee , S. D. , Behringer , R. R. , Rasweiler , IV, J. J. I. and Niswander , L. A. 2006 . Interdigital webbing retention in bat wings illustrates genetic changes underlying amniote limb diversification . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , 103 : 15103 – 15107 .
  • Wellik , D. M. 2009 . Hox genes and vertebrate axial pattern . Current Topics in Developmental Biology , 88 : 257 – 278 .
  • Wellik , D. M. and Capecchi , M. R. 2003 . Hox10 and Hox11 genes are required to globally pattern the mammalian skeleton . Science , 301 : 363 – 367 .
  • Welten , M. , Pavlovska , G. , Chen , Y. , Teruoka , Y. , Fisher , M. , Bangs , F. , Towers , M. and Tickle , C. 2011 . 3D expression patterns of cell cycle genes in the developing chick wing and comparison with expression patterns with genes implicated with digit specification . Developmental Dynamics , 240 : 1278 – 1288 .
  • Woltering , J. M. , Vonk , F. J. , Müller , H. , Bardine , N. , Tuduce , I. L. , de Bakker , M. A. , Knöchel , W. , Sirbu , I. O. , Durston , A. J. and Richardson , M. K. 2009 . Axial patterning in snakes and caecilians: evidence for an alternative interpretation of the Hox code . Developmental Biology , 332 : 82 – 89 .
  • Young , R. L. and Wagner , G. P. 2011 . Why ontogenetic homology criteria can be misleading: lessons from digit identity transformations . Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution , 316 : 165 – 170 .
  • Young , R. L. , Bever , G. S. , Wang , Z. and Wagner , G. P. 2011 . Identity of the avian wing digits: problems resolved and unsolved . Developmental Dynamics , 240 : 1042 – 1053 .
  • Zaher , H. and Rieppel , O. 2002 . On the phylogenetic relationships of the Cretaceous snakes with legs, with special reference to Pachyrhachis problematicus (Squamata, Serpentes) . Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology , 22 : 104 – 109 .
  • Zaher , H. , Apesteuía , S. and Scanferla , C. A. 2009 . The anatomy of the upper Cretaceous snake Najash rionegrina Apesteguía and Zaher, 2006, and the evolution of limblessness in snakes . Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society , 156 : 801 – 826 .
  • Zakany , J. , Kmita , M. and Duboule , D. 2004 . A dual role for Hox genes in limb anterior-posterior asymmetry . Science , 304 : 1669 – 1672 .

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.