Notes
- 1833 . “Logic. The Recent English Logical Treatises on that Science” . Edinburgh Review , April : 194 – 238 .
Works cited
- Aristotle . 1497–1498 . Eis organon Aristotelous , Venice : Aldus Manutius .
- _____ . 1791–1800 . Aristotelis opera omnia Graece , Edited by: Buhle , Theophilus . Zweibrücken : Bipont . Io.
- _____ . 1831 . Aristotelis Opera , Edited by: Bekker , I. Berlin : Georgius Reimerus .
- _____ . 1843 . Opera omnia , Edited by: Weise , C. H. Leipzig : Tauschnitz .
- _____ . 1848–1874 . Opera omnia , Paris : Didot .
- Arnold , Matthew . 1875 . God and the Bible , London : Smith, Elder, and Co. .
- Barthes , Roland . 1977 . “The Death of the Author” . In Image‐Music‐Text , Edited by: Heath , Stephen . New York : Hill & Wang .
- Barthélemy‐Saint‐Hilaire , J. , ed. 1870 . Rhétorique d'Aristote: traduite en français et accompagnée de notes perpétuelles avec La rhétorique à Alexandre (apocryphe) et un appendice sur l'enthymème , 2 vols , Paris : Librairie philosophique de Ladrange .
- Baur , Ferdinand Christian . 1876 . Paul: The Apostle of Jesus Christ, His Life, His Work His Epistles, His Doctrine , Edited by: Zeller , Eduard and Menzies , A . 2 vols , London : Williams and Norgate .
- Bensel‐Myers , Linda . 1992 . Rhetoric for Academic Reasoning , 124 – 128 . 167 – 173 . 210 New York : Harper Collins .
- Berlin , James . 1984 . Writing Instruction in Nineteenth Century American Colleges , Carbondale : Southern Illinois University Press .
- Bentham , George . 1827 . Outline of a New System of Logic, With a Critical Examination of Dr. Whately's “Elements of Logic” , London : Hunt and Clarke . (Rpt. Bristol: Thoemmes 1990)
- Blakesley , Joseph . 1839 . A Life of Aristotle , Cambridge : J. and J. Deighton .
- Brandt , William . 1969 . The Craft of Writing , Englewood Cliffs, NJ : Prentice‐Hall .
- Brink , Charles Oscar . 1986 . English Classical Scholarship: Historical Reflections on Bentley, Porson and Housman , Cambridge : Clarke .
- Burgess , Thomas . 1829 . A Letter to the Reverend Thomas Beynon, Archdeacon of Cardigan, in Reply to the Vindication of the Literary Character of Professor Porson by Crito Cantabrigiensis [Thomas Turton] and in further Proof of the Authenticity of 1 John v. 7 , Salisbury : Brodie and Dowding .
- Burgon , John William . 1896 . The Traditional Text of the Holy Gospels Vindicated and Established , Edited by: Miller , Edward . London : George Bell and Sons . [Cited as 1896a]
- _____ . 1896 . The Causes of Corruption of The Traditional Text of the Holy Gospels , Edited by: Miller , Edward . London : George Bell and Sons . [Cited as 1896b]
- Burnyeat , M. F. 1994 . “Enthymeme: Aristotle on the Logic of Persuasion” . In Aristotle's Rhetoric: Philosophical Essays , Edited by: Furley , David and Nehemas , Alexander . 3 – 55 . Princeton : Princeton University Press .
- Conley , Thomas M. 1984 . “The Enthymeme in Perspective” . Quarterly Journal of Speech , 70 : 168 – 187 .
- _____ . 1990 . Rhetoric in the European Tradition , New York : Longman .
- Cope , E. M. 1867 . An Introduction to Aristotle's Rhetoric , London : Macmillan .
- Copleston , Edward and Whately , Richard . 1857 . Opinions of the late Dr. Copleston, Bishop of Llandaff, and Archbishop Whately in Favour of Legalizing Marriage with a Deceased Wife's Sister. Extracted from Remains of the late Edward Copleston and Whately's annotations on Bacon's Essays , London : T. Hatchard . [rpt. 1866]
- Crito Cantabrigiensis [Thomas Turton] . 1827 . A Vindication of the Literary Character of Professor Porson from the Animadversions of the Right Reverend Thomas Burgess, Lord Bishop of Salisbury, in Various Publications on 1 John v. 7 , Cambridge : J. Smith .
- Day , Angel . 1586 . The English secretorie. Wherein is contayned, a perfect method, for the inditing of all manner of epistles and familiar letters , London : R. Waldegrave . [rpt: Menston: Scolar Pr., 1967]
- Defoe , Daniel . 1727 . The compleat English tradesman, with supplement , London : for Charles Rivington . [Rpt.: 1732, 1738]
- Dilthey , Wilhelm . 1976 . Selected Writings , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
- Ellison , Robert H. 1998 . The Victorian Pulpit: Spoken and Written Sermons in Nineteenth‐Century Britain , Selinsgrove : Susquehanna University Press .
- Emmel , Barbara . 1994 . “Towards a Pedagogy of the Enthymeme: The Roles of Dialogue, Intention, and Function in Shaping Argument” . Rhetoric Review , 13 ( 1 ) : 132 – 150 .
- Foucault , Michel . 1977 . “What Is An Author” . In Language. Counter Memory. Practice , Ithaca : Cornell University Press . Selected Essays and Interviews by Michel Foucault
- Fox , Adam . 1954 . John Mill and Richard Bentley: A Study of the Textual Criticism of the New Testament, 1675–1729 , Oxford : Blackwell .
- Fulwood , William . 1568 . The enimie of idlenesse: teaching the manner and stile how to endite, compose and write all sorts of epistles and letters , London : H. Bynneman for L. Maylard . [Rpt: 1571, 1578, 1582, 1586, 1593, 1598, 1607, 1612, 1621]
- Funk , Robert W. 1993 . The Five Gospels: The Search for the Authentic Words of Jesus , New York : Scribner .
- Gadamer , Hans‐Georg . 1976 . Philosophical Hermeneutics , Berkeley : University of California Press .
- _____ . 1986 . The Idea of the Good in Platonic‐Aristotelian Philosophy , New Haven, CT : Yale University Press .
- _____ . 1975 . Truth and Method , New York : Seabury Press .
- _____ . 1991 . Gadamer and Hermeneutics , London : Routledge .
- Gage , John . 1983 . “Teaching the Enthymeme: Invention and Arrangement” . Rhetoric Review , 2 ( 1 ) : 38 – 50 .
- _____ . 1991 . The Shape of Reason: Argumentative Writing in College , 2nd ed. , New York : Macmillan .
- Gaines , Robert . 2000 . “Aristotle's Rhetoric and the Contemporary Arts of Practical Discourse” . In Rereading Aristotle's Rhetoric , Edited by: Gross , Alan G. and Walzer , Arthur E. 3 – 23 . Carbondale, IL : Southern Illinois University Press .
- Gillies , John . 1804 . Aristotle's Ethics and Politics , 2nd ed. , 2 vols , London : T. Cadell .
- Grant , Alexander . 1878 . Aristotle , Edinburgh : William Blackwood & Sons .
- Green , Lawrence . 1995 . “Aristotle's Enthymeme and the Imperfect Syllogism” . In Rhetoric and Pedagogy: Its History, Philosophy, and Practice , Edited by: Horner , Winifred Bryan and Leff , Michael . 19 – 42 . Mahwah, NJ : Lawrence Erlbaum Associates .
- Gross , Alan and Walzer , Arthur . 2000 . “Preface” . In Rereading Aristotle's Rhetoric , Edited by: Gross , Alan G. and Walzer , Arthur E. ix – xi . Carbondale, IL : Southern Illinois University Press .
- Grote , George . 1883 . Aristotle , 3rd ed. , Edited by: Bain , Alexander and Robertson , G. Croom . London : John Murray .
- Hamilton , Sir William . 1860 . Lectures on Logic , Edited by: Mansel , H. L. and Veitch , John . 2 vols , Boston : Gould and Lincoln . [1852]
- _____ . 1856 . Discussions on Philosophy and Literature, Education and University Reform , New York : Harper and Brothers . [1852]
- Hampden , Renn Dickson . 1839 . A Lecture on Tradition. Read Before the University, in the Divinity School, Oxford, On Thursday, March 7th, 1839. With Additions , London : B Fellowes .
- _____ . 1848 . The Scholastic Philosophy Considered in its Relation to Christian Theology , 3rd ed. , Hereford : J. Head .
- _____ . 1862 . The Fathers of Greek Philosophy , Edinburgh : Adam and Charles Black .
- Heath , Malcolm , ed. 1995 . Hermogenes. On Issues , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
- Hessey , James Augustus . 1845 . Schemata Rhetorica, or Tables Explanatory of the Nature of the Enthymeme , Oxford : J. H. Parker .
- _____ . 1860 . Sunday: its origin, history, and present obligation, considered in the Bampton Lectures preached before the University of Oxford in the year 1860 , London : J. Murray . [rpt: Murray 1861, 1866; New York, Port, Young, 1880; London: Cassell, 1880 1889]
- _____ . 1850 . A scripture argument against permitting marriage with a wife's sister: a clergyman's letter to a friend , London : F. & J. Rivington . [rpt. 1851, 1856, 1859]
- _____ . 1883 . Six grand objections to marriage with a deceased wife's sister: set forth in a paper read (in part) at the Church Congress at Reading, October, 1883, with an introductory letter to the clergy, churchwardens and sidesmen of the Archdeaconry of Middlesex , London : Thomas Scott: and sold at the office of the Marriage Law Defence Union .
- Holland , Lady S. 1874 . A Memoir of the Reverend Sydney Smith , 2 vols , New York : Harper & Brothers .
- Horner , Winifred Bryan . 1990 . “Writing Instruction in Great Britain: 18th and 19th Centuries” . In A Short History of Writing Instruction , Edited by: Murphy , John J. Davis : Hermagoras Press .
- _____ . 1993 . Nineteenth Century Scottish Rhetoric: The American Connection , Carbondale : Southern Illinois University Press .
- Howell , W. S. 1956 . Logic and Rhetoric in England 1500–1700 , Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
- _____ . 1971 . Eighteenth Century British Logic and Rhetoric , Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
- Jacobi , Martin . 1986 . “Using Enthymemes to Teach Business Writing” . Bulletin of the Association for Business Communication , 49 ( 1 ) : 30 – 33 .
- Jarratt , Susan . 1991 . Rereading the Sophists: Classical Rhetoric Refigured , Carbondale : Southern Illinois University Press .
- Jauss , Hans Robert . 1982 . Towards an Aesthetics of Reception , Edited by: Bahti , Timothy . Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press .
- Jebb , Richard Claverhouse . 1909 . Bentley , London : Macmillan .
- Jevons , William Stanley . 1864 . Pure Logic or the Logic of Quality Apart from Quantity , London : E. Stanford .
- _____ . 1870 . Elementary Lessons in Logic: Deductive and Inductive , London : Macmillan .
- _____ . 1874 . The Principles of Science: A Treatise on Logic and Scientific Method , London : Macmillan .
- _____ . 1876 . Logic , London : Macmillan .
- Jordan , W. G. 1909 . Biblical Criticism and Modem Thought , Edinburgh : T. & T. Clarke .
- Kennedy , George . 1980 . Classical Rhetoric and Its Christian and Secular Tradition from Ancient to Modern Times , Chapel Hill, NC : University of North Carolina Press .
- _____ . 1983 . Greek Rhetoric Under the Christian Emperors , Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .
- Lampe , David Robert . 1982 . Bentley and the Wits: A Critical Introduction to the “Dialogues of the Dead” of William King , Unversity of Iowa . PhD thesis
- Mansel , H. L. , ed. 1856 . Arris Logicae Rudimento from the text of Aldrich , 3rd ed. , Oxford : Oxford University Press . [1849]
- Maynard , Michael . 1995 . A History of the Debate over 1 John 5,7–8. A Tracing of the Longevity of the Comma Johanneum With Evaluations of Arguments Against its Authenticity , Tempe, AZ : Comma Publications .
- McGann , Jerome . 1992 . A Critique of Modem Textual Criticism , Charlottesville : University of Virginia Press .
- Metzger , Bruce M. 1963 . Chapters in the History of the New Testament Textual Criticism , Leiden : E. J. Brill .
- _____ . 1964 . The Text of the New Testament: Its Transmission, Corruption, and Restoration , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
- Miller , Arthur and Bee , John D. 1972 . “Enthymemes: Body and Soul” . Philosophy and Rhetoric , 5 ( 4 ) : 201 – 214 .
- Monk , James Henry . 1833 . The life of Richard Bentley , 2nd ed. , London : J.G. & F. Rivington .
- Nash , Henry S. 1900 . The History of the Higher Criticism of the New Testament , New York : Macmfflan .
- Neel , Jasper . 1988 . Plato, Derrida, and Writing , Carbondale : Southern Illinois University Press .
- _____ . 1994 . Aristotle's Voice , Carbondale : Southern Illinois University Press .
- Nestle , Eberhard . 1901 . Introduction to the Textual Criticism of the Greek New Testament , Edited by: Edie , William and Menzies , Allan . London : Williams and Norgate .
- Newman , John Henry . 1967 . On the Inspiration of Scripture , Edited by: Holmes , J. Derek and Murray , Robert . Washington D. C. : Corpus Books .
- _____ . 1974 . An Essay on The Development of Christian Doctrine. The Edition of 1845 Edited by: Cameron , J. M. Harmondsworth, Middlesex, , England
- _____ . 1833 . The Arians of the Fourth Century: their doctrine, temper, and conduct, chiefly as exhibited in the councils of the church between A.D. 325 & A.D. 381 , London : J. G. & F. Rivington .
- _____ . 1840 . The Church of the Fathers , London : J.G.F. & J. Rivington .
- _____ . 1836 . Elucidations of Dr. Hampden ‘s theological statements , Oxford : J. H. Parker .
- Newman , John Henry . 1839–1840 . Tracts for the Times , London : Printed for J.G.F. & J. Rivington .
- Owen , Octavius Freire . 1853 . “ With the Introduction of Porphyry ” . In The Organon, or Logical Treatises of Aristotle , 2 vols , London : Henry G. Bohn .
- Pacius , Julius , ed. 1606 . Aristotelis . . . Organum: hoc est, libri omnes ad logicam pertinentes, Graecè, et Latinè Hanoviae [s.n]
- Peters , John P. 1901 . The Old Testament and the New Scholarship , London : Methuen & Co. .
- Pfeiffer , Rudolf . 1976 . History of Classical Scholarship from 1300 to 1850 , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
- Phillips , Arthur . 1923 . The Failure of the Higher Criticism of the New Testament , London : John Bale, Sons, & Danielsson Ltd. .
- Pattison , Mark . 1861 . “Tendencies of Religious Thought in England 1688–1750” . In Recent Inquiries in Theology , Edited by: Hedge , Frederic H. Boston : Walker, Waise, and Company .
- Pattison , Robert . 1991 . The Great Dissent: John Henry Newman and the Liberal Heresy , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
- Porson , Richard . 1790 . Letters to Mr Archdeacon Travis, in answer to his defense of the Three Heavenly Witnesses, 1 John V.7 London
- Poster , Carol . 1992 . “A Historicist Recontextualization of the Enthymeme” . Rhetoric Society Quarterly , 22 ( 2 ) : 1 – 24 .
- _____ . 1998 . “(Re)positioning Pedagogy: A Feminist Historiography of Aristotle's ” . In Rhetorical’ Feminist Interpretations of Aristotle , Edited by: Freeland , Cynthia . 327 – 350 . University Park, PA : Pennsylvania State University Press .
- _____ . 2000 . “The Enthymeme: An Interdisciplinary Bibliography” . Journal for the Study of the Rhetoric of the New Testament , Oct. http://rhetjoumal.uor.edu/?35,17. [Cited as 2000a]
- _____ . 2000 . “Being, Time, and Definition: Towards a Semiotics of Figurai Rhetoric” . Philosophy and Rhetoric , 33 ( 2 ) : 116 – 136 . [Cited as 2000b]
- _____ . 2001 . “Pedagogy and Bibliography: Aristotle's Rhetoric in Nineteenth Century England” . Rhetoric Society Quarterly , 31 ( 2 ) Spring : 5 – 35 .
- _____ . 2002 . “Review of Alan Gross and Arthur Walzer, eds. Rereading Aristotle's Rhetoric” . Ancient Philosophy , : 502 – 509 .
- Reeve , Anne , ed. 1986 . Erasmus’ Annotations of the New Testament , London : Duckworth .
- Reich , Emil . 1905 . The Failure of the ‘Higher Criticism’ of the Bible , London : James Nisbet & Co. .
- Reid , Thomas . 1806 . Analysis of Aristotle's Logic with Remarks , 2nd ed. , Edinburgh : William Creech .
- Reimarus , Hermann Samuel . 1970 . Reimarus: Fragments , Edited by: Talbert , Charles . Philadelphia, PA : Fortress Press .
- Renan , Ernest . 1864 . The Life of Jesus , Edited by: Wilbour , Charles Edwin . New York : Carleton . [1863]
- Reynolds , L. D. and Wilson , N. G. 1991 . Scribes and Scholars: A Guide to the Transmission of Greek and Latin Literature , 3rd ed. , Oxford : Clarendon Press .
- Richardson , Samuel . 1741 . Letters written to and for particular friends, on the Most important occasions , London : C. Rivington . [Rpt.: 1746, 1750, 1752. Dublin 1741 and Folcroft: Folcroft Library Editions 1974]
- Ricoeur , Paul . 1983 . “On Interpretation” . In Philosophy in France Today , Edited by: Montefiore , A. 139 – 155 . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
- _____ . 1977 . The Rule of Metaphor , Edited by: Czerny . Toronto : University of Toronto Press .
- _____ . 1976 . Interpretation Theory , Fort Worth : Texas Christian University Press .
- _____ . 1981 . Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
- Russell , Donald A. 1983 . Greek Declamation , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
- _____ . 1988 . “The Ass in the Lion's Skin: Thoughts on the Letters of Phalaris” . Journal of Hellenic Studies , 107 : 94 – 106 .
- Salmon , George . 1897 . Some Thoughts on the Textual Criticism of the New Testament , London : John Murray .
- Sandys , John Edwin . 1967 . A History of Classical Scholarship , 3 vols , New York and London : Hafner .
- Schaff , P. 1892 . Companion to the Greek Testament and the English Version , 4th ed. , New York : Harper .
- Schleiermacher , Friedrich . 1975 . The Life of Jesus , Edited by: Verheyden , Jack C. Philadelphia, PA : Fortress Press .
- _____ . 1998 . Hermeneutics and Criticism and Other Writings , Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
- Schweitzer , Albert . 1954 . The Quest of the Historical Jesus: A Critical Study of its Progress from Reimarus to Wrede , London : Adam & Charles Black .
- Scrivener , F. H. A. 1894 . A Plain Introduction to Criticism of the New Testament Edited by: Miller , E. 2 vols , London
- Smith , Sidney . 1810 . Response to A Reply to the Calumnies of the Edinburgh Review against Oxford . Edinburgh Review , 31 April : 158 – 187 .
- Spengel , Leonhard von , ed. 1847 . Ars rhetorica, quae vulgo fertur Aristotelis Ad Alexandrum , Leipzig : Wigand .
- Stewart , Donald . 1990 . “The Nineteenth Century” . In The Present State of Scholarship in Historical and Contemporary Rhetoric , Edited by: Homer , W. B. Columbia : University of Missouri Press .
- Stirewalt , Martin Luther . 1993 . Studies in Ancient Greek Epistolography , Atlanta, GA : Scholars Press .
- Strauss , David Friedrich . 1972 . The Life of Jesus Critically Examined , Edited by: Hodgson , Peter C. and Eliot , George . Philadelphia, PA : Fortress Press .
- _____ . 1977 . The Christ of Faith and the Jesus of History: A Critique of Schleiermacher's The Life of Jesus , Edited by: Keck , Leander E. Philadelphia, PA : Fortress Press .
- Taylor , Thomas , ed. 1812 . The Works of Aristotle Translated from the Greek with Copious Elucidations from the Best of his Greek Commentators , London : Robert Wilks .
- Trollope , Anthony . 1994 . Barchester Towers , Edited by: Herts , Ware . Wordsworth Classics .
- Tuckwell , William . 1909 . Pre‐Tractarian Oxford , London : Smith, Elder, & Co. .
- Utz , Richard . 2002 . Chaucer and the Discourse of German Philology , Tumhout : Brepols .
- Veyne , Paul . 1988 . Did the Greeks Believe in Their Myths? , Edited by: Wissing , Paula . Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
- Vincent , Marvin R. 1899 . A History of the Textual Criticism of the New Testament , New York : Macmillan Company .
- Vitanza , Victor . 1997 . Negation, Subjectivity, and the History of Rhetoric , Albany : State University of New York Press .
- Whately , Richard . 1975 . Elements of Logic , Edited by: McKerrow , Ray E. Delmar, NY : Scholars’ Facsimiles & Reprints . [1826]
- White , Reginald James . 1968 . Dr. Bentley: A Study in Academic Scarlet , East Lansing, MI : Michigan State University Press .
- Wimsatt , William and Beardsley , Munroe C. 1972 . “The Intentional Fallacy” . In 20th Century Literary Criticism , Edited by: Lodge , David . London : Longman .
- Wolf , Friedrich August . 1784 . Animadversiones ad Aristotelis Librum Primum Rhetoricum cum Notitia et Censura Graeci Scholasticae , Halae Saxonum .
- _____ . 1986 . Prolegomena ad Homerum , Edited by: Grafton , A. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press . [1795]
- Zeller , Eduard . 1844–1852 . Die Philosophie der Griechen, eine Untersuchung uber Character, Gang, und Hauptmommente ihrer Entwicklung , 5 eds. Tübingen by Zeller, 6th ed. rev. W. Nestle, Leipzig, 1920]
- Research for this study has been supported by many sources, including a fellowship at the Tanner Humanities Center of the University of Utah, a Rocky Mountain MLA Huntington fellowship, and a First Year Assistant Professor grant from Florida State University. An NEH Summer 2002 Seminar, “The Reform of Reason,”; which I co‐directed with Jan Swearingen, provided an opportunity to revise this essay, and I owe thanks to both the NEH and the fifteen seminar participants. I also owe thanks to several libraries, including the Bodleian Library, the British Library, Cambridge University Library, Folger Shakespeare Library, Huntington Library, Rylands Library, St. Deiniol's Library, and the ILL staffs of Montana State University and Florida State University libraries. I also would like to thank Marilyn Faulkenburg, Thomas Miller, Christopher Stray, Jan Swearingen, and Karen Whedbee for many useful comments.