Science Education for Citizens: Perspectives and Issues II. Science and Technology Policy and the Democratic Process

References

• Dorothy Nelkin Controversy: Politics of Technical Decisions SAGE Publications Beverly Hills 1979 For a review and analysis of these conflicts, see
   Google Scholar
• Mendelsohn , EVERETT and Weingart , PETER . 1978 . “ ‘The Social Assessment of Science: Issues and Perspectives’ ” . In The Social Assessment of Science , Edited by: Mendelsohn , E. , Nelkin , D. and Weingart , P. Conference Proceedings, University of Bielefeld .
   Google Scholar
• Opinion Research Corporation . September 1976 . “ Study III ” . In Attitudes of the U.S. Public Towards Science and Technology September , 51
   Google Scholar
• The above data on public attitudes are from the National Science Board, Science Indicators 1976. USGPO (1977), pp. 168-182. Similar ambivalence shows up in European surveys. See Commission of the European Communities, Science and European Public Opinion, Brussels, 1977. A more recent survey focusing specifically on medical research shows greater confidence in this field than others. Most respondents felt medical research has changed life for the better (very much better — 59%, somewhat for the better — 34%). But 49% agreed that in deciding what to do, scientists are more concerned with their own research interests than with public benefits; National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects. Special Study. DHEW Publication No. (OS) 78-0015, 1978.
   Google Scholar
• Nelson , RICHARD . 1977 . The Moon and the Ghetto , New York : W. W. Norton .
   Google Scholar
• Gianos , P. 1974 . ‘Scientists as Policy Advisors: The Context of Influence’ . Western Political Quarterly , September : 429 – 456 . BENVENISTE, G., The Politics of Expertise, Berkeley: Glendessary Press, 1972.
   Google Scholar
• Meynaud , JACQUES . 1968 . Technocracy , London : Faber and Faber . ELLUL, JACQUES, The Technological Society, New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1970.
   Google Scholar
• Noble , D. 1977 . America by Design , New York : Alfred A. Knopf . WINNER, L., Autonomous Technology, Cambridge: MIT Press, 1977: McCRAE, D., ‘Science and the Formation of Policy in a Democracy’, Minerva (April 1973), pp. 228-242.
   Google Scholar
• Primack , J. and Von HIPPEL , F. 1974 . Advice and Dissent: Scientists in the Political Arena , New York : Basic Books . BENVENISTE, G., op, cit.: LAKOFF, S., ‘Scientists, Technologists and Political Power’. In ROSING, I. S., and PRICE, D., Science, Technology and Society, Beverly Hill: SAGE Publications (1977), pp. 355-392.
   Google Scholar
• Klaw , SPENCER . 1969 . The New Brdhmans: Scientific Life in America , New York : Morrow . LAPP, R., The New Priesthood, New York: Harper and Row, 1965.
   Google Scholar
• Nelkin , Dorothy . 1971 . Nuclear Power and Its Critics , Ithaca : Cornell University Press . For example, see, NELKIN, DOROTHY, Jetport, New Brunswick: Transaction Books, 1975. For the propensity to protect when unable to avoid problems, see HIRSCHMAN, ALBERT, Exit, Voice and Loyalty, Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1970.
   Google Scholar
• Alford , R. 1975 . Health Care Politics , Chicago : University of Chicago Press .
   Google Scholar
• Mazur , A. 1973 . ‘Disputes Between Experts’ . Minerva , XI : 213 – 262 .
   Google Scholar
• 1977 . “ ‘Ann Arbor Science for the People Editorial Collective’ ” . In Biology as a Social Weapon , Minneapolis : Burgess . See for example
   Google Scholar
• Carpenter , RICHARD . 1970 . ‘Information for Decisions in Environmental Policy’ . Science , 168 12 June : 1316 – 22 . CASPER, BARRY M., ‘Scientists on the Hill’. Bulletin of the Atomic Scientist 33, November 1977, pp. 8-15, for discussion of scientific advice to Congress; FOX, HARRISON, Jr., and HAMMOND, SUSAN W., The Invisible Force in American Lawmaking, New York: The Free Press, 1977.
   PubMedGoogle Scholar
• 1972 . ‘Four Systems of Policy, Politics and Choice’ . Public Administration Review , July/August : 298 – 309 . LA PORTE, TODD, ‘The Study of Public Organizations’, In MARINI, FRANK, Towards a New Public Administration, Scranton: Chandler, 1971, p.20.
   Google Scholar
• Scott , WILLIAM . 1969 . ‘Organizational Government: The Prospects for a Truly Participatory System’ . Public Administration Review , January/February : 43 – 53 . CRAMTON, ROGER, ‘The Why, Where, and How of Broadening Public Participation in the Administrative Process’, Georgetown Law Journal 60:3 (February 1972), p. 529. See also GELLHORN, ERNEST, ‘Public Participation in Administrative Proceedings’, The Yale Law Journal 81:3 (January 1972), p. 367.
   Google Scholar
• Wade , Nicholas . 1972 . ‘Freedom of Information’ . Science , 175 4 February : 493 – 502 . A review of these problems appears in, KOLATA, G., ‘Freedom of Information Act: Problems at the FDA’, Science 189 (4 July 1975), pp. 32-33.
   Google Scholar
• Sullivan , J. 1977 . “ ‘Implications of NSF Assistance to Non-Profit Organizations’ ” . In Report to NSF 64 Washington, D.C. An unpublished report
   Google Scholar
• Gray , Bradford , Cooke , Robert , A. , Tannenbaum and Arnold , S. 1978 . ‘Research Involving Human Subjects’ . Science , 201 ( 22 ) September : 1094 – 1104 .
   PubMed Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• Dimento , J. 1977 . ‘Citizen Environmental Litigation and Administrative Process’ . Duke Law Journal , 22 : 409 – 452 . For a review and bibliography on citizen litigation, see, For the difficulty of finding conceptual correspondence between scientific developments and legal concepts, see CARROLL, JAMES, ‘Participatory Technology’, Science 171 (19 February 1971), pp. 647-653.
   Google Scholar
• Clark , Roger , Stankey and George . 1976 . ‘Analyzing Public Input to Resource Decisions: Criteria, Principles, and Case Examples of the Codeinvolve System’ . Natural Resources Journal , 16 January : 220 – 222 .
   Google Scholar
• Murray , B. 1976 . ‘Peaking Plant Environment Report (EAC, September 1973)’ , 16 January : 197 – 212 . ‘Peaking Plant Environment Report (EAC, September 1973)’, reported in HEBERLEIN, THOMAS
   Web of Science ®Google Scholar
• For reviews of environmental mediation efforts, see the EIA Review published at MIT.
   Google Scholar
• Cambridge Experimentation Review Board . 1976 . ‘Guidelines for the Use of Recombinant DNA Molecule Technology in the City of Cambridge’ , December 21
   Google Scholar
• Nelkin , Dorothy . 1978 . Technological Decisions and Democracy , Beverly Hills : SAGE Publications .
   Google Scholar
• U.S. Congress, Senate, Committee on Government Operations . 1976 . Public Participation in Government Proceedings Act of 1976, Hearings , Washington, D.C. : GPO . See discussion in
   Google Scholar
• Bazelon and David , L. 1979 . ‘Risk and Responsibility’ . Science , 205 July 20 : 278
   Google Scholar
• 1978 . Daedalus , 44 ( March ) See devoted to the theme of Limits of Scientific Inquiry, and the Nobel Symposium, Volume 44, Ethics for Science Policy, Pergamon Press, 1979.
   Google Scholar
• A study of IRBs found that, although accepting the legitimacy of the IRBs, 25% of the 940 biomedical scientists and 38% of the 395 behavioural and social scientists interviewed felt the review procedures are an unwarranted intrusion on the investigator's autonomy; 43% of the biomedical scientists and 54% of the behavioural scientists felt the procedure had impeded the progress of research. National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects, Report and Recommendations on Institutional Review Boards, DHEW Publication (OS) 78-0008 (September 1978), p. 75.
   Google Scholar