211
Views
10
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Demonstration versus Small Group Practical Work in Science Education. A critical review of studies since 1900

&
Pages 109-146 | Published online: 14 Mar 2008

References

  • Atkinson , P. A. 1980 . Instruction — Memory — Performance. The Influence of Practical Work in Science on Memory and Performance , Monash University . Unpub. Ph.D. thesis
  • Anibel , F. G. 1926 . Comparative effectiveness of the lecture-demonstration and individual laboratory method . J. Educ. Res. , 13 ( 5 ) : 355 – 365 .
  • Balcziak , L. W. 1953 . The role of the laboratory and demonstration in college physical science in achieving the objectivity of general education , Univ. of Minnesota . Unpub. Ph.D. thesis
  • Ben-ZVI , R. , Hofstein , A. , Samuel , D. and Kempa , R. F. 1976 . The educational effectiveness of filmed experiments in high school chemical education . J. Chem. Educ. , 53
  • Bernard , J. D. 1941 . The lecture demonstration v the problem solving method of teaching college science course , White : University of New York . Dissertation, 1943
  • Bernstein , B. 1971 . “ On the classification and framing of educational knowledge ” . In Knowledge and Control , Edited by: Young , M. F. D. London : Collier-Macmillan .
  • Boenig , R. W. 1969 . Research in Science Education 1938 through 1947 , New York : Teachers College Press, University of Columbia .
  • Boretz , N. 1930 . Individual experimental versus pupil demonstration methods in High School General Science , Cunningham : University of New York . Unpublished M.A. thesis, 1946
  • Bowers , W. G. 1924 . The importance of laboratory work as compared with text-book work, etc. in the study of chemistry . School Science & Maths , 24 : 606 – 613 .
  • Brasure , R. E. 1929 . An experimental study of the teacher demonstration and the individual laboratory methods in the teaching of physics , University of Wisconsin . Unpublished M.Phil, thesis
  • Caldwell , O. W. 1921 . Science Teaching , The Gary Public School General Education Board . (Quoted in Carpinter 1926)
  • Carpinter , W. W. 1926 . A study of the comparison of different methods of laboratory practical on the basis of the results obtained on tests of certain classes in High School chemistry . J. Chem. Educ. , 3 ( 7 ) : 789 – 805 .
  • Connell , L. 1971 . Demonstration and individual practical work in science teaching; a review of opinions . The School Science Review , 52 ( 180 ) : 692 – 703 .
  • Cooprider , J. L. 1922 . Oral versus written instructions and demonstration versus individual work in high school science . School Science & Maths , 22 : 838 – 844 .
  • Cooprider , J. L. 1923 . Laboratory methods in High School science . School Science & Maths , 23 : 526 – 530 .
  • Coulter , J. C. 1966 . The effectiveness of inductive laboratory, inductive demonstration and deductive laboratory in biology . J. Res. in Set Teaching , 4 : 185 – 186 .
  • Cronbach , L. J. 1966 . “ The logic of experiments on discovery ” . In Learning by Discovery. a critical appraisal. , Edited by: Shulman , L. S. and Keislar , E. R. Chicago : Rand McNally .
  • Cunningham , H. A. 1920a . Under what conditions, in High Sdiool Science, is Individual Laboratory Work Preferable and when does the Lecture Demonstration Give Better Results? , Dept. of Education, University of Chicago . Unpub. Masters thesis
  • Cunningham , H. A. 1920b . Individual laboratory work versus lecture demonstration in high school science . University of Illinois Bull , 18 : 105 – 107 .
  • Cunningham , H. A. 1924a . Laboratory methods in natural science teaching . Schools Science & Maths , 24 : 709 – 715 .
  • Cunningham , H. A. 1924b . Laboratory methods in natural science teaching . School Science & Maths , 24 : 848 – 851 .
  • Cunningham , H. A. 1946 . Lecture demonstration versus individual laboratory method in science education — a summary . Science Educ , 30 : 70 – 82 .
  • Curtis , F. D. 1926 . A Digest of Investigations in the Teaching of Science in Elementary and Secondary Schools , New York : Teachers College Press, Teachers College University of Columbia . (1971 Reprint)
  • Curtis , F. D. 1931 . A Second Digest of Investigations in the Teaching of Science ( 1971) , 2nd Ed. , New York : Teachers College Press, Teachers College University of Columbia .
  • Curtis , F. D. 1936 . A Third Digest of Investigations in the Teaching of Science ( 1971) , 2nd, ed. , New York : Teachers College Press, Teachers College University of Columbia .
  • De JARNETT , W. W. 1929 . A study of the lecture demonstration and individual laboratory methods of teaching biology in a small high school , University of Kansas . Unpublished M.A. thesis
  • Downing , E. R. 1925 . A comparison of the lecture-demonstration and the laboratory methods of instructions in science . School Review , 33 : 688 – 697 .
  • Dubin , R. and Taveggia , T. C. 1968 . The teaching-learning paradox: a comparative analysis of college teaching method , Eugen : Centre for the Advanced Study of Educational Administration. University of Oregon .
  • Duel , H. W. 1928 . The even-front system versus the rotation system in laboratory physics . School Review , 36 : 447 – 454 .
  • Duel , H. W. 1937 . Measurable outcomes of laboratory work in science; a review of experimental investigations . School Science & Maths , 37 : 795 – 810 .
  • Dyer , J. H. 1927 . An Analysis of Certain Outcomes on the Teaching of Physics in Public Schools with an Investigation of the Efficiency of a Laboratory Method in Establishing such Outcomes , Philadelphia : Westbrook Publishing Co. .
  • DYKES, C. (No title cited by Fountain 1934). Thesis for Master's Degree, George Peabody College for Teachers
  • Eells , W. C. 1926 . A plea for a standard definition of the standard deviation . J. Educ. Res. , 13 ( 1 ) : 45 – 52 .
  • Elder , A. L. 1939 . The lecture-demonstration method versus individual laboratory work in chemistry . Science Education , 23 : 209 – 215 . (in Cunningham 1946)
  • Erikson , H. A. 1929 . Laboratory experiments versus demonstration: Experiments in high school chemistry , New York University . Unpub. M.A. thesis (in Cunningham 1946)
  • Ewing , E. 1926 . Individual laboratory versus Teacher Demonstration Method of Teaching High School Chemistry , New York : Temple University Philadelphia . Unpub. Master's thesis, (Keiser 1933)
  • Fountain , C. R. 1934 . Laboratory investigation versus laboratory verification . The Physics Teacher (Am. J. Physic) , 2 : 177 – 178 .
  • Gage , N. L. 1978 . The Scientific Basis of the Art of Teaching , New York : Teachers College Press, Columbia University .
  • Galperin , P. Ya. 1953 . “ An experimental study in the formation of mental actions ” . In Psychology in the Soviet Union , Edited by: Simon , B. London : Routledge & Keegan Paul .
  • Galton , M. 1979 . Strategies and tactics in Junior School Classrooms . Brit. Educ. Res. J. , 5 ( 2 ) : 197 – 210 .
  • Garrett , R. M. 1978 . Pupil experimentation versus teacher demonstration in lower secondary science teaching: a comparative study of the development of simple cognitive skills , University of Keele . Unpub. M.A. thesis
  • Garrett , R. M. and Roberts , I. F. 1979 . “ Pupil experimentation. Has the pendulum swung too far? ” . In Research in Assessment II , 100 – 112 . Chemical Society Assessment Group Annual General Meeting, University of Warwick .
  • Gerberich , J. R. and Roberds , W. M. 1934 . Individualized instruction for superior students in introductory college physics . Science Education , 18 ( 1 ) : 28 – 32 .
  • Gilbert , J. P. 1910 . An experiment on methods of teaching zoology . J. of Educ. Psychol. , 1 : 321 – 332 .
  • Glass , G. V. 1976 . “ Review of research ” . In Primary, secondary and meta-analysis of research Edited by: Shulman , L. S.
  • Goldstein , P. 1937 . Student laboratory work versus teacher demonstration as a means of developing laboratory resourcefulness . Science Education , 21 : 185 – 193 . (Cunningham 1946)
  • Good , C. V. 1930 . Research in secondary school methods . J. Educ. Res. , 22 ( 1 ) : 9 – 30 .
  • Harwell , H. I. 1933 . Practical outcomes of the laboratory method and the lecture demonstration method in teaching high school chemistry by the use of concepts , University of Kansas . Unpub. M.A. thesis, (De Jarnett 1929)
  • Heafford , P. E. 1965 . “ The Teaching of Science ” . In Technology of Teaching Vol.2 Secondary Education , Edited by: Peterson , A. D. C. 81 – 105 . London : Pergamon Press .
  • Heaney , S. 1971 . The effects of three teaching methods and the ability of young pupils to solve problems in Biology: an experimental and quantitative investigation , University of Keele . Unpub. M.A. thesis
  • Heaney , S. 1971 . The effects of three teaching methods and the ability of young pupils to solve problems in biology: an experimental and quantitative investigation . J. Biol. Educ. , 5 : 219 – 228 .
  • Hedges , L. V. 1978 . A meta-analysis of studies of four teaching behaviour variables , Stanford, California : School of Education .
  • Heyer , C. and Rannow , W. 1969 . Auswikungen quantitativer Schulerexperimente auf die politisch-moralische Bildung und Erziehung . Chemie in der Schuler , 16 : 418 – 424 .
  • Hix , E. L. 1933 . The value of laboratory work in High School Physics , State College of Washington . Unpub. M.A. (Education) thesis
  • Horton , R. E. 1928 . Measurable Outcomes of Individual Laboratory Work in High School Chemistry , Teacher's College, Columbia University . Contributions to Education 303
  • Hunter , G. W. 1922 . An experiment in the use of three different methods of teaching in the classroom . School Science & Math. , 21 : 875 – 890 .
  • Hunter , G. W. 1923 . An experiment in the use of three different methods of teaching in the classroom . School Science & Maths , 22 : 20 – 32 .
  • Hurd , A. W. 1928 . Present inadequacies and suggested remedies in the teaching of High School Science . School Science & Maths , 28 : 637 – 639 .
  • Johnson , P. O. 1928 . A comparison of the lecture-demonstration, group laboratory experimentation,and the individual laboratory experimentation methods of teaching high school biology . J. Educ. Res. , 18 ( 2 ) : 103 – 111 .
  • Kahn , P. A. 1942 . An experimental study to compare the laboratory method of instruction with individual demonstration in elementary college biology , Cunningham : The College of the City of New York . Unpub. Master's thesis 1946
  • Keiser , L. B. 1933 . The present status of the lecture-demonstration versus the individual laboratory method of teaching science in the high school , College of the City of New York . Unpub. M.A. thesis
  • Kelley , T. L. 1923 . Statistical Method , 116 New York : MacMillan Co. .
  • Kempa , R. F. and Palmer , C. R. 1974 . The effectiveness of video-tape recorded demonstration in the learning of manipulative skills in practical chemistry . J. Educ. Technology , 5 ( 1 ) : 62 – 71 .
  • Kiebler , E. W. and Woody , C. 1923 . The individual laboratory method versus the demonstration method of teaching physics . J. of Educ. Res. , 7 ( 1 ) : 50 – 58 .
  • Knox , W. W. 1927 . The demonstration method versus the laboratory method of teaching High School chemistry . School Review , 25 : 376 – 386 .
  • Kruglak , H. 1952a . A comparison of the conventional and demonstration methods in the elementary college physics laboratory . J. Exptl. Educ. , 20 : 293 – 300 .
  • Kruglak , H. 1952b . Experimental outcomes of laboratory instruction in elementary college physics . Am. J. of Physics , 20 : 136 – 141 .
  • Kruglak , H. 1953 . Achievement of Physics students with and without laboratory work . Am. J. of Physics , 21 : 14 – 16 .
  • Kruglak , H. and Carlson , C. R. 1953 . Performance tests in physics at the University of Minnesota . Science Educ. , 37 : 108 – 121 .
  • Kruglak , H. and Goodwin , R. A. 1953 . Laboratory achievement in relation to the number of partners . Am. J. of Physics , 23 : 257 – 264 .
  • Kruglak , H. and Wall , C. N. 1959 . Laboratory Performance Tests for General Physics , Kalamazoo, Michigan : Western Michigan University . For the National Science Foundation
  • Lawler , E. P. 1970 . Research in Science Education 1953 through 1957 , New York : Teachers College Press, University of Columbia .
  • Mallinson , G. G. 1947 . The individual laboratory method compared with the lecturedemonstration method in teaching general biology . Science Education , 31 : 175 – 79 .
  • Mayman , J. E. 1912 . An experimented investigation of the book method, lecture method and experimental method of teaching science in the elementary schools , New York City, Bureau of Educational Research . Unpublished PhD thesis
  • McCall , W. A. 1923 . How to Experiment in Education , 187 – 207 . MacMillan Co. .
  • McKeachie , W. J. and Kulik , J. A. 1978 . “ Effective College Teaching ” . In Review of research in education , Edited by: Kerlinger , N. F. Vol. 3 , 165 – 209 . Itasca, Illinois : Peacock, F.E. .
  • Mukerji , N. P. 1940 . An investigation of ability in work in groups and in isolation . Brit. J. Psychology , 30 : 352 – 356 .
  • Nash , H. B. and Phillips , M. J. W. 1927 . A study of the relative value of three methods of teaching high school chemistry . J. Educ. Res. , 15 ( 5 ) : 371 – 379 .
  • Newbury , N. F. 1965 . The Teaching of Chemistry , 3rd Ed. , London : Heinemann .
  • Newman , E. N. 1967 . A comparison of the effectiveness of three teaching methods in high school biology , Ann Arbor, Michigan : University microfilms . (In Ramsey & Howe, 1969)
  • Nisbet , J. 1974 . Fifty years of research in science education . Studies in Science Educ. , 1 : 103 – 112 .
  • Noll , V. H. 1930a . Laboratory instruction in the Field of Inorganic Chemistry , University of Minnesota . Unpub. Doctor's Dissertation
  • Noll , V. H. 1930b . Optimum laboratory emphasis in College Chemistry . School and Society , 32 : 300 – 303 .
  • Novak , J. D. 1958 . An experimental comparison of a conventional and project centred method of teaching a college general botany course . J. Experimental Educ. , 26 : 217 – 230 .
  • Oliver , M. 1965 . The efficiency of three methods of teaching high school biology . J. Exptl. Educ. , 33 : 289 – 295 . (In Ramsey & Howe 1969)
  • Palmer , C. R. 1971 . The Use of Recorded Demonstration in the Teaching of Manipulative Skills in Chemistry , School of Chemical Science, University of East Anglia . Unpub. M.Sc. thesis
  • Parlett , M. and Hamilton , D. 1978 . Evaluation as Illumination: a new approach to the study of innovatory programmes , Centre for Research in the Educational Sciences, University of Edinburgh . Occasional paper 9
  • Payne , V. G. 1932 . The lecture demonstration and individual laboratory methods compared . J. of Chem. Educ. , 9 ( 5 ) : 932 – 939 . 1097-1102,1277-1294
  • Pearson , K. 1894 . Contributions to the mathematical theory of evolution . Philosophical Transaction of the Royal Society , CLXXXV : 71 – 110 . Series A, Paper read Nov.16 1893
  • Perrussel , R. C. 1930 . A critical study of the value of the laboratory method versus the general class method in the teaching of physics , University of Kansas . Unpub. M.A.
  • Phillips , T. C. 1925 . A study of notebook and laboratory work as an effective aid in science teaching . School Review , 20 : 451 – 453 .
  • Pruitt , C. M. 1925 . An experiment of the Relative Efficiency of Methods of Conducting Chemistry Laboratory Work , University of Indiana . Unpub. Masters thesis
  • Pugh , D. B. 1927 . A comparison of the lecture-demonstration and individual laboratory methods of performing chemistry experiments, as measured by non-standard objective tests . High School Teacher , 3 : 184 – 187 .
  • Rainey , R. G. 1965 . The effects of directed versus non-directed laboratory work on high school chemistry achievement . J. Res. in Science Teaching , 3 : 286 – 292 .
  • Ramsey , G. A. and Howe , R. N. 1969a . An analysis of Research and Instructional procedures in secondary school science, Part I: Outcomes of instruction . The Science Teacher , 36 ( 3 ) : 62 – 70 .
  • Ramsey , G. A. and Howe , R. W. 1969b . An analysis of Research and Instructional Procedures in secondary school science. Part II: Instructional Procedures . The Science Teacher , 36 ( 4 ) : 72 – 81 .
  • Robertson , M. L. 1932 . A study of the relative effectiveness of two methods of teaching elementary science . Science Educ. , 16 : 182 – 187 . (White 1943)
  • Rossa , E. 1963 . Referat: Das Experiment im Unterricht . Chemie in der Schule , 10 : 439 – 455 .
  • Rowntree , D. 1974 . Educational Technology in Curriculum Development , London : Harper & Row .
  • Ruja , H. 1954 . Outcomes of lecture and discussion procedures in three college courses . J. of Experimental Edu. , 22 : 385 – 394 .
  • Scott , V. G. 1929 . An experiment in the effect of the individual laboratory versus demonstration method on the pupils final grade in general science , University of Washington . Unpub. M.A. thesis
  • Shore , D. P. 1929 . Demonstration laboratory versus individual laboratory in teaching high school physics , George Peabody College for Teachers . Unpub. M.A. thesis
  • Shulman , L. S. 1970 . Reconstruction of educational research . Rev. of Educ. Res. , 40 : 371 – 396 .
  • Shulman , L. S. and Tamir , P. 1973 . “ Research on teaching in the Natural Sciences ” . In Second Handbook on Res. of Teaching , Edited by: Travers , R. M. W. 1098 Chicago : Rand McNally .
  • Spear , E. B. 1915 . Problems in the experimental pedagogy of chemistry . J. of Educ. Psychology , 6 : 231 – 241 .
  • Stuit , D. B. and Englehart , M. D. 1932 . A critical summary of the research on the lecturedemonstration versus the individual laboratory method of teaching high school chemistry . Science Education , 16 : 380 – 391 . (In Cunningham 1946)
  • Swift , J. N. 1969 . Research in Science Education 1948 through 1952 , New York : Teachers College Press, University of Columbia .
  • Thorndyke , E. L. 1904 . An Introduction to the Theory of Mental and Social Measurement , New York : Teachers College Press, Columbia University .
  • Van Horne , D. 1929 . An experimental comparison of demonstration and individual laboratory methods in high school chemistry , Los Angeles : University of Southern California . Unpub. Master's thesis
  • Walter , C. H. 1926 . A comparative study of the teacher demonstration and the individual laboratory methods in physics when the time saved by the former method is given to drill work , University of Chicago . Unpub. Master's thesis, (Keiser 1933)
  • Walter , C. H. 1930 . The individual laboratory method of teaching physics when no printed directions are used . School Science & Maths , 30 : 429 – 432 .
  • Ward , J. 1956 . Group-study versus lecture demonstration method in physical science instruction for general education college students . J. Experimental Educ. , 24 : 197 – 210 .
  • White , J. R. 1943 . A comparison of the group-laboratory and the lecture-demonstration method in Engineering instruction , School of Education, University of New York . Unpub. doctoral thesis
  • Wiley , W. H. 1918 . An experimental study of methods in teaching high school chemistry . J. Educ. Psychol. , 9 ( 4 ) : 181 – 198 .
  • Wilkinson , G. H. 1928 . A comparison of four methods of laboratory procedure in high school physics , Los Angeles : University of Southern California . Unpub. Master's thesis, (Keiser 1933)
  • Yager , R. E. , Englen , H. B. and Snider , B. C. 1969 . Effects of laboratory and demonstration methods upon the outcomes of instruction in secondary biology . J. Res. in Science Teaching , 6 : 76 – 86 .
  • Young , J. E. 1949 . The Ability to Draw Inferences from Science Experiments , University of Glasgow . Unpub. D. Ed. thesis

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.