Uncertainty, Teaching and Personal Autonomy: an inquiry into a pedagogic dualism

NOTES AND REFERENCES

• Dearden , R. F. 1972 . “ Autonomy and education ” . In Education and the Development of Reason , Edited by: Dearden , R. F. , Hirst , P. H. and Peters , R. S. 448 London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
   Google Scholar
• Mill , J. S. 1965 . “ Inaugural address ” . In Mill's Essays on Literature and Society , Edited by: Schneewind , J. B. 399 New York : Collier‐Macmillan .
   Google Scholar
• Hull , J. M. 1975 . “ Agreed syllabuses, past, present and future ” . In New Movements in Religious Education , Edited by: Smart , R. N. and Horder , D. London : Temple Smith . See, for example,
   Google Scholar
• Schools Council/Nuffield Foundation . 1970 . The Humanities Project: an introduction , 6 London : Heinemann .
   Google Scholar
• Stenhouse , L. 1983 . “ Towards a vernacular humanism ” . In Authority, Education and Emancipation , Edited by: Stenhouse , L. 168 London : Heinemann .
   Google Scholar
• Schools Council/Nuffield Foundation . 1970 . The Humanities Project: an introduction , 1 – 10 . London : Heinemann . See
   Google Scholar
• Smalley , B. 1957 . “ Prima clavis sapientiae: Augustine and Abelard ” . In Essays in Honour of Fritz Saxl , Edited by: Gordon , D. J. 95 – 96 . London : Thomas Nelson . K. W. Hoskin (1986) The professional in educational history, in: J. Wilkes The Professional Teacher, Proceedings of the 1985 Annual Conference of the History of Education Society, pp. 4‐5 (London, History of Education Society); and P. Abelard Sic et Non Prologue, in: J‐P. Migne Patrologia Latina (Paris, 1844‐64).
   Google Scholar
• Stenhouse , L. 1983 . “ Research as a basis for teaching ” . In Authority, Education and Emancipation , Edited by: Stenhouse , L. 179 London : Heinemann .
   Google Scholar
• Ibid.
   Google Scholar
• M , R. 1976 . Value education in a pluralist society . Proceedings of the Philosophy of Education Society of Great Britain , 10 : 12 – 13 . See
   Google Scholar
• Op. cit., p. 12.
   Google Scholar
• Stenhouse , L. 1983 . “ Towards a vernacular humanism ” . In Authority Education and Emancipation , Edited by: Stenhouse , L. 166 London : Heinemann .
   Google Scholar
• Flew , A. G. N. 1972 . “ Indoctrination and doctrines ” . In Concepts of Indoctrination , Edited by: Snook , I. A. London : Routledge & Kegan Paul . and J. Wilson (1964) Education and indoctrination, in: T. H. B. Hollins Aims in Education: the philosophical approach (Manchester, Manchester University Press).
   Google Scholar
• Strike , K. A. 1975 . “ Autonomy and control: toward a theory of legitimate influence ” . In The Philosophy of Open Education , Edited by: Nyberg , D. 187 London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
   Google Scholar
• Langford , G. 1968 . Philosophy and Education , 128 London : Macmillan .
   Google Scholar
• Freire , P. 1970 . Pedagogy of the Oppressed Ch. 2 , New York : Seabury . See, for example,
   Google Scholar
• A , K. 1975 . “ Autonomy and control: toward a theory of legitimate influence ” . In The Philosophy of Open Education , Edited by: Nyberg , D. 183 – 188 . London : Routledge & Kegan Paul . See
   Google Scholar
• Plato Republic 536d‐e.
   Google Scholar
• S , R. 1966 . Ethics and Education , 30 London : George Allen & Unwin . See
   Google Scholar
• Gardner , P. 1987 . The compulsory curriculum and beyond: a rejoinder to John White . Journal of Philosophy of Education , 21 (2) : 275 – 277 . For some considerations of the idea that we are the best judges of our own interests and are in a privileged position when it comes to making such judgements, see: P. Gardner (1984) The compulsory curriculum and beyond: a consideration of some aspects of the educational philosophy of J. P, Journal of Philosophy of Education 18(2), pp. 174‐176; and
   Google Scholar
• Mill , J. S. 1965 . “ Inaugural address ” . In Mill's Essays on Literature and Society , Edited by: Schneewind , J. B. 399 New York : Collier‐Macmillan .
   Google Scholar
• Aristotle, The Nicomachean Ethics Bk. 1, iii.
   Google Scholar
• Gardner , P. 1989 . “ Neutrality in education ” . In Liberal Neutrality , Edited by: Goodin , R. E. and Reeve , A. London : Routledge . Some may feel that the Humanities Curriculum Project's attitude towards the nature of the controversial and values may be difficult to reconcile with the wherewithal for viable inquiry. See, for instance, C. Bailey (1975) Neutrality and rationality in teaching, D. Bridges, P. Scrimshaw Values and Authority in Schools (London, Hodder & Stoughton). See also
   Google Scholar
• Hart , H. L. A. 1982 . Essays on Bentham Ch. 10 , Oxford : Oxford University Press . See also J. Raz (1986) The Morality of Freedom pp. 35‐37 (Oxford, Oxford University Press). Content‐dependent and content‐independent reasons are usually considered in the context of reasons for acting, not, as we have done, in the context of reasons for believing.
   Google Scholar
• Gardner , P. 1991 . Personal autonomy and religious upbringing: the ‘problem’ . Journal of Philosophy of Education , 25 (1) It has to be admitted that there has been a tendency to associate rationality, the ability to reason well, with autonomy, though, along with Dworkin and others, I would oppose this association. See G. Dworkin (1988) The Theory and Practice of Autonomy p. 17 (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). See also
   Google Scholar
• R. M. Hare would argue that in the realm of morality at least there is a logical requirement that we be prepared to eliminate any proper name or definite description that may appear in our reasons. See R. M. Hare (1963) Freedom and Reason pp. 35‐37 (Oxford, Oxford University Press); and R. M. Hare (1955) Universalisability, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society Vol. 55. If Hare is right, then moral reasoning involves a lack of content‐independent reasons.
   Google Scholar
• Rogers , C. 1969 . Freedom to Learn , New York : Merill . See K. A. Strike (1975) Autonomy and control: toward a theory of legitimate influence, D. Nyberg The Philosophy of Open Education pp. 183‐184 (London, Routledge & Kegan Paul). See also
   Google Scholar
• Baier , K. 1973 . “ Moral autonomy as an aim of moral education ” . In New Essays in the Philosophy of Education , Edited by: Langford , G. and O'Connor , D. J. 109 London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
   Google Scholar
• A , K. 1975 . “ Autonomy and control: toward a theory of legitimate influence ” . In The Philosophy of Open Education , Edited by: Nyberg , D. 184 – 187 . London : Routledge & Kegan Paul . See also K. Baier (1973) Moral autonomy as an aim of moral education, G. Langford & D. J. O'Connor (Eds) New Essays in the Philosophy of Education, p. 108 (London, Routledge & Kegan Paul).
   Google Scholar
• Strike , K. A. 1975 . “ Autonomy and control: toward a theory of legitimate influence ” . In The Philosophy of Open Education , Edited by: Nyberg , D. 186 London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
   Google Scholar
• Baier , K. 1973 . “ Moral autonomy as an aim of moral education ” . In New Essays in the Philosophy of Education , Edited by: Langford , G. and O'Connor , D. J. 108 London : Routledge & Kegan Paul) .
   Google Scholar
• Strike , K. A. 1975 . “ Autonomy and control: toward a theory of legitimate influence ” . In The Philosophy of Open Education Edited by: Nyberg , D. 188 – 189 . and K. Baier (1973) moral autonomy as an aim of moral education, in: G. Langford & D. J. O'Connor (Eds) New Essays in the Philosophy of Education pp. 106‐113 (London, Routledge & Kegan Paul). See also S. I. Benn (1988) A Theory of Freedom pp. 175‐183 (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press).
   Google Scholar
• Stephen , J. F. 1967 . Liberty, Equality, Fraternity , 81 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Dearden , R. F. 1972 . “ Autonomy and education ” . In Education and the Development of Reason , Edited by: Dearden , R. F. , Hirst , P. H. and Peters , R. S. 452 London : Routledge & Kegan Paul). Dearden's italics .
   Google Scholar
• Dearden , R. F. 1984 . Freedom and the development of autonomy: a reply to Victor Quinn . Journal of Philosophy of Education , 18 (2) : 272
   Google Scholar
• Perhaps this provides a case for teaching philosophy, that is, for teaching something about the philosophy of religion, moral philosophy, aesthetics, etc. This would not be an attempt to develop general thinking skills, whatever they might be if there are any, but to teach something about the problems and nature of certain areas of inquiry.
   Google Scholar
• Benn , S. I. 1988 . A Theory of Freedom , 182 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Mill , J. S. 1974 . On Liberty , 96 Harmondsworth : Penguin .
   Google Scholar
• Op. cit., pp. 95‐96.
   Google Scholar
• Benn , S. I. 1988 . A Theory of Freedom , 182 Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
   Google Scholar
• Op. cit., pp. 182‐183.
   Google Scholar
• Mill , J. S. 1974 . On Liberty , 95 Harmondsworth : Penguin .
   Google Scholar
• Bonnett , M. 1976 . Authenticity, autonomy and compulsory curriculum . Cambridge Journal of Education , 6 (3) : 111
   Google Scholar
• Dearden , R. F. 1972 . “ Autonomy and education ” . In Education and the Development of Reason , Edited by: Dearden , R. F. , Hirst , P. H. and Peters , R. S. 453 London : Routledge & Kegan Paul .
   Google Scholar