292
Views
27
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Original Articles

Was there feudalism in Indian history?

Pages 273-310 | Published online: 05 Feb 2008

Notes

  • Manyon , L.A. , ed. 1964 . Feudal Society 446 Chicago
  • Strayer , Joseph R. and Coulborn , Rushton . 1956 . “ ‘Feudalism is primarily a method of government, not an economic or a social system, though it obviously modifies and is modified by the social and economic environment’, ‘The Idea of Feudalism’ ” . In Feudalism in History Edited by: Coulborn , R. 4 Princeton
  • Clegg , I.E. , ed. 1958 . Economic and Social History of Medieval Europe 7 – 12 . London (first published 1936)
  • Hilton , R.H. , ed. 1976 . The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism 33 – 56 . 102 – 08 . London
  • Dobb , Maurice . 1963 . Studies in the Development of Capitalism, , revised edition London equates it with serfdom
  • 1977 . Lineages of the Absolutist State 408 London (first published 1974)
  • 1965 . Indian Feudalism c. 300–1200 1 – 2 . 7 16 52 – 3 . 63 – 4 . 154 158 271 Calcutta
  • 1973 . Thoughts on Agrarian Relations in Mughal India 2 New Delhi
  • Marx , Karl and Engels , F. 1969 . Selected Works Vol. I , 160 – 62 . Moscow
  • Sawer , Marian . 1977 . Marxism and the Question of the Asiatic Mode of Production 208 The Hague
  • Capitalism, Development and Planning 2 – 3 . New York reprint 1970
  • Hilton , ed. 1976 . Peasants, Knights and Heretics 4 Cambridge
  • 1976 . ‘From Feudalism to Capitalism — Transition or Transitions?’ . Social Forces , 55 ( 2 ) December : 281
  • Marx , Karl . 1954 . Capital Vol. I , 718n Moscow
  • MarcBloch . Feudal Society 446 – 47 . 452
  • Anderson , Perry . Lineages 413 – 17 . 435 – 61 .
  • 1977 . Japan, China and the Modern World Economy: Towards a Reinterpretation of East Asian Development c. 1600 to 1918 25 71 – 90 . Cambridge
  • 1974 . ‘Problem of Transition from Ancient to Medieval in Indian History’ . The Indian Historical Review , I ( 1 ) March : 1 – 9 .
  • Yadava , B.N.S. 1973 . Society and Culture in Northern India in the Twelfth Century Allahbad
  • Jones . 1952 . ‘The Economic Basis of Athenian Democracy’ . Past and Present , Feb. : 13 – 31 .
  • Hilton . 1973 . Bond Men Made Free: Medieval Peasant Movements and the English Rebellion of 1381 10 London
  • 1959 . ‘Was Greek Civilisation Based on Slave Labour?’ . Historia , VIII : 58 – 59 .
  • Anderson , Perry . 1974 . Passages from Antiquity to Feudalism 22 – 23 . London
  • 1971 . Capital Vol. III , 804 807 Moscow
  • Marx . Capital , I 512
  • Finley , M.I. 1973 . The Ancient Economy 85 – 87 . London
  • Bloch , Marc . 1976 . French Rural History Edited by: Sondheimer , Janet . 68 London
  • Bloch . 1966 . “ ‘The Rise of Dependent Cultivation’ ” . In Cambridge Economic History of Europe, , 2nd edn. Edited by: Postan , M.M. Vol. I , 248 Cambridge
  • Duby , Georges . 1974 . Early Growth of European Economy: Warriors and Peasants from the Seventh to Twelfth Century Edited by: Clarke , Howard B. 40 New York
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 18 25 – 28 . 79 82
  • Bloch , Marc . Feudal Society 171 – 73 .
  • Bloch . “ ‘The Rise of Dependent Cultivation’ ” . 255 – 56 .
  • Bloch . French Rural History 72 – 74 . 76 – 77 . 85 – 90 .
  • Duby , Georges . 1968 . Rural Economy and Country Life in the Medieval West Edited by: Postan , Cynthia . 33 – 35 . London
  • Duby . Warriors and Peasants 88 – 89 .
  • Hilton , R.H. Bond Men Made Free 33 – 35 .
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 149
  • Bloch , Marc . Feudal Society 180
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 40 87 – 88 . 90 – 91 .
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 148
  • Hilton , R.H. Bond Men Made Free 42 – 44 .
  • Preswich , J.O. 1963 . ‘Anglo‐Norman Feudalism and the Problem of Continuity’ . Past and Present , Nov. : 39 – 57 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 33 – 35 . 40
  • 1952 . ‘An Interpretation of Chinese Economic History’ . Past and Present , Feb. : 1 – 13 .
  • Ganshof , F.L. and Verhurlst , A. ‘France, the Low Countries and Western Germany’ . Cambridge Economic History , 314 – 15 .
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 89 – 90 . 94 – 95 .
  • Parain , Charles . ‘The Evolution of Agricultural Technique’ . Cambridge Economic History , 133 – 34 . 145 – 46 .
  • Bloch , Marc . French Rural History 25
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 24 – 25 .
  • Duby . Warriors and Peasants 169
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 17 – 21 .
  • White , Lynn Jr. 1973 . Medieval Technology and Social Change 41 – 43 . 53 London (first published 1962)
  • Bloch , Marc . Feudal Society 60 – 61 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 6 14
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 18
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 6 – 7 . 14 – 15 .
  • Bloch , Marc . French Rural History 72 – 74 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 40 – 42 .
  • Hilton , R.H. Bond Men Made Free 61 85 – 86 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 12 – 15 .
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 78 – 83 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 38 – 39 . 48 – 49 .
  • Bloch . 1967 . “ ‘Mediaeval Inventions’ ” . In Land and Work in Mediaeval Europe Edited by: Anderson , J.E. 182 London
  • Duby . Warriors and Peasants 95 – 96 . 177 229 – 30 .
  • Mukhia , Harbans . “ ‘Maurice Dobb's Explanation’ ” . 20 – 25 .
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 183
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 25 – 27 .
  • Beveridge , Lord . 1966 . “ ‘The Yield and Price of Corn in the Middle Ages’ ” . In Essays in Economic History Edited by: Carus‐Wilson , E.M. Vol. I , 15 – 16 . London (first published 1954)
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 102
  • Hilton , R.H. Bond Men Made Free 28
  • Latouche , Roben . 1961 . The Birth of Western Economy Edited by: Wilkinson , E.M. 82 London
  • Gurevich , A. 1977 . ‘Representations of Property during the High Middle Ages’ . Economy and Society , VI ( 1 ) Feb. : 8
  • Fourquin , G. 1976 . Lordship and Feudalism in the Middle Ages Edited by: Iris and Sells , Lytton . 168 London
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 294 – 95 .
  • Lopez , R.S. 1967 . The Birth of Europe 398 London
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 190
  • 1955 . ‘The Evolution of Feudal Rent in England’ . Past and Present , April : 22
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 198 – 99 .
  • Russell , J.C. 1958 . Late Ancient and Medieval Populations 102 – 13 . Philadelphia
  • Russell . 1972 . “ ‘Population in Europe’ ” . In The Fontana Economic History of Europe Edited by: Cipolla , Carlo M. Vol. I , 39 – 40 . London
  • Postan , M.M. 1975 . The Medieval Economy and Society 35 – 36 . London (first published 1972)
  • Titow , J.Z. 1962 . ‘Some Differences Between Manors and their Effects on the Condition of the Peasant in the Thirteenth Century’ . Agricultural History Review , X ( 1 ) : 1 – 2 .
  • Dobb , Maurice . Studies 47
  • Bloch , Marc . French Rural History 16
  • Duby . Rural Economy 119 – 22 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 81 – 87 .
  • Duby . Warriors and Peasants 199 – 210 .
  • Aubin , Hermann . ‘The Land east of the Elbe and German colonization eastwards’ . Cambridge Economic History , 455 – 56 .
  • Miller , E. 1964 . ‘The English Economy in the Thirteenth Century: Implications of Recent Research’ . Past and Present , July : 33
  • Croot , Patricia and Parker , David . 1978 . ‘Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development’ . Past and Present , February : 39
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 201 208
  • Roberts , B.K. 1968 . ‘A Study of Medieval Colonisation in the Forest of Arden, Warwickshire’ . Agricultural History Review , XVI : 102
  • Genicot , Leopold . ‘Crisis: from the Middle Ages to Modern Times’ . Cambridge Economic History , 733 – 34 .
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 205
  • Bloch , Marc . Feudal Society 137 – 41 .
  • Thirsk , Joan . 1964 . ‘The Family’ . Past and Present , April : 117 – 22 .
  • Medick , Hans . 1976 . ‘The proto‐industrial family economy: the structural function of household and family during the transition from peasant society to industrial capitalism’ . Social History , I ( 3 ) October : 292 – 93 .
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 205 – 08 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 77
  • 1977 . ‘Harvest Customs and Labourers’ Perquisites in Southern England, 1150–1350; the Corn Harvest’ . Agricultural History Review , XXV : 14
  • Bloch , Marc . French Rural History 106 – 12 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 208
  • Duby . Warriors and Peasants 91 – 92 .
  • Postan , M.M. “ ‘The Rise of a Money Economy’ ” . Edited by: Carus‐Wilson . Vol. I , 7 op. cit.;
  • Hilton , R.H. “ ‘Freedom and Villeinage in England’ ” . In Peasants, Knights and Heretics Edited by: Hilton . 181
  • Harvey , P.D.A. “ ‘The English Inflation of 1180–1220’ ” . 74 – 75 . ibid.
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 222
  • Kosminsky , E.A. 1966 . “ ‘Services and Money Rents in the Thirteenth Century’ ” . In Essays in Economic History Edited by: Carus‐Wilson . Vol. 11 ,
  • Bloch , Marc . Feudal Society 251
  • Critchley , J.S. 1978 . Feudalism 67 London
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 174 – 77 .
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 211 – 13 . 227 249 – 51 .
  • Bloch , Marc . Land and Work in Mediaeval Europe 135 – 68 .
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 222 – 23 . 227 – 29 .
  • Kosminsky , E.A. “ ‘Services and Money Rent’ ” . 46 – 48 . op. cit.
  • Hilton , R.H. Bond Men Made Free 128 – 29 . 130 132 206 – 7 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 126 – 65 .
  • Bloch , Marc . “ ‘Natural economy or money economy: a pseudo dilemma’ ” . In Land and Work in Mediaeval Europe 230 – 44 .
  • Garner , Lawrence , ed. 1976 . An Economic Theory of the Feudal System 133 London
  • Lopez , R.S. 1956 . ‘The Evolution of Land Transport in the Middle Ages’ . Past and Present , April : 24
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 302 – 05 .
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 191
  • Harvey , P.D.A. ‘The English Inflation of 1180–1220’ . Peasants, Knights andHeretics , 57 – 58 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 263 – 64 .
  • Postan , M.M. “ ‘The Rise of a Money Economy’ ” . 7 op. cit.
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 140
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 46 – 47 . 229
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 228 – 31 .
  • Bloch , Marc . French Rural History 191 – 92 .
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 47
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 229
  • Duby . Rural Economy 219 245
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 244 – 45 .
  • Duby , G. Warriors and Peasants 257 – 58 .
  • Kosminsky , E.A. “ ‘Services and Money Rents’ ” . 46 – 48 . op. cit.
  • Kosminsky . “ ‘The Evolution of Feudal Rent’ ” . 35 op. cit.
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 247
  • Duby . Warriors and Peasants 176 – 177 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 129
  • Bloch , Marc . French Rural History 124
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 236
  • Kosminsky . “ ‘Services and Money Rents,’ ” . 46 – 47 . op. cit.
  • Hilton . “ ‘Freedom and Villeinage in England’ ” . 181 184 op. cit.
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 256 – 57 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 152 280 305
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 286
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 197 – 99 .
  • Bloch , Marc . French Rural History 17 112
  • Postan , M.M. The Medieval Economy and Society 63 – 79 .
  • Hilton , R.H. Bond Men Made Free 16
  • Miller , E. “ ‘The English Economy of the Thirteenth century’ ” . 38 op. cit.
  • 1979 . ‘The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism’ . presented to the Indo‐French Seminar on the same theme at the University of Delhi . Jan. 1979 . pp. 21 (mimeo)
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 294 – 95 .
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 198 – 99 .
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 295
  • Kershaw , Ian . “ ‘The Great Famine and Agrarian Crisis in England 1315–22’ ” . In Peasants, Knights and Heretics Edited by: Hilton . 85 – 132 .
  • Ziegler , Philip . 1970 . The Black Death London
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 201
  • Russell , J.C. Late Ancient and Medieval Populations 131
  • Ordish , O. , ed. 1963 . Agrarian History of Western Europe, 500–1850 11 84 London
  • Hilton , R.H. Bond Men Made Free 154
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 307 – 08 . 320
  • Bois , Guy . “ ‘Note on the movement of prices in feudal economic systems’ ” . 2 (mimeo)
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 316
  • Kay , Cristobal . 1974 . ‘Comparative Development of the European Manorial System and the Latin American Hacienda System’ . Journal of Peasant Studies , II ( 1 ) October : 72
  • Bois , Guy . “ ‘Transition’ ” . 21 – 26 . op. cit.
  • Hilton , R.H. 1978 . ‘A Crisis of Feudalism’ . Past and Present , August : 11 – 18 .
  • Hilton , R.H. Bond Men Made Free 85 ff
  • Duby , G. Rural Economy 332 – 35 .
  • Blickle , Peter . 1979 . ‘Peasant revolts in the German empire in the late Middle Ages’ . Social History , IV ( 2 ) May : 223 – 39 .
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 199
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 293
  • Yadava , B.N.S. 1968 . “ ‘Some Aspects of Changing order in India, during the Saka‐Kusana Age’ ” . In Kusana Studies Edited by: Sharma , G.R. 80 Allahabad
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 1 – 76 . 210 – 62 .
  • B.N.S. Yadava, Society and Culture 172 – 73 .
  • Thorner , Daniel . “ ‘Feudalism in India’ ” . Edited by: Coulborn , R. 143 – 45 . op. cit.
  • Kosambi , D.D. 1975 . An Introduction to the Study of Indian History, , 2nd revised edn. 391 – 92 . Bombay (first published 1956)
  • Tod , Col. James . 1920 . Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan Edited by: Crooke , W. Vol. I , 155 – 56 . 182 – 83 . 190 London
  • Sircar , D.C. 1969 . Landlordism and Tenancy in Ancient and Medieval India as Revealed by Epigraphic Records 36 Lucknow
  • Kosambi , D.D. An Introduction & c 353 – 55 . 403
  • 1972 . The Culture and Civilization of Ancient India in Historical Outline 23 – 24 . New Delhi (first published in 1970)
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 1 – 2 . 16 34 63 – 64 . 84 154 208
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Culture 171 – 72 . 175 – 80 .
  • Chandra , Satish . 1974 . ‘Some Aspects of Indian Village Society in Northern India During the Eighteenth Century’ . Indian Historical Review , I ( 1 ) March : 51
  • Habib , Irfan . 1962 . ‘Marxist Interpretation’ . Seminar , 39 Nov. : 36 – 37 .
  • 1957–58 . ’Origins of Feudalism in India’ . Journal of the Economic and Social History of the Orient , 1 : 297 – 328 .
  • 1974 . ‘Indian Feudalism Retouched’ (review article) . Indian Historical Review , I ( 2 ) Sept. : 320 – 30 .
  • ‘Immobility and Subjection of Indian Peasantry in Early Medieval Complex’ . Indian Historical Review , I ( 1 ) 27
  • Moreland , W.H. 1929 . Agrarian System of Moslem India 204 Allahabad
  • Yadava . “ ‘Immobility and Subjection’ ” . 27
  • Indian Feudalism 53 – 59 . 118
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Culture 137 – 39 .
  • R.S. Sharma, Indian Feudalism 50 – 53 . 121 – 22 . 243 283
  • Sharma , R.S. 1966 . Light on Early Indian Society and Economy 73 Bombay
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Culture 163 – 73 .
  • Yadava . “ ‘Immobility and Subjection’ ” . 21 – 23 .
  • Sircar , D.C. 1966 . “ ‘Landlordism Confused with Feudalism’ ” . In Land System and Feudalism in Ancient India Edited by: Sircar . 58 – 61 . Calcutta
  • Chattopadhyaya . 1974 . ‘Trade and Urban Centres in Early Medieval North India’ . Indian Historical Review , I ( 2 ) Sept. : 203 – 19 .
  • Tarafdar , M.R. 1978 . ‘Trade and Society in Early Medieval Bengal’ . Indian Historical Review , IV ( 2 ) Jan. : 274 – 86 .
  • Anderson , Perry . Passages 128
  • Jain , P.C. 1971 . Labour in Ancient India 242 – 43 . New Delhi
  • Rai , G.K. 1976 . ‘Forced Labour in Ancient and Early Medieval India’ . Indian Historical Review , III ( 1 ) July : 26 37
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 48 – 53 . 121 – 22 . 242 – 43 .
  • Habib , Irfan . 1963 . Agrarian System of Mughal India 150 239 248 Bombay
  • Fukazawa , H. 1974 . “ ‘A Note on the Corvee System (Vethbegar) in Eighteenth Century Maratha Kingdom’ ” . In Science and Human Progress (Essays in Honour of the late Professor D.D. Kosambi) Bombay
  • Mukhia , Harbans . 1977 . ‘Illegal Extortions from Peasants, Artisans and Menials in Eighteenth Century Eastern Rajasthan’ . Indian Economic and Social History Review , XIV ( 2 ) April‐June : 231 – 45 .
  • Elliot , Henry . 1859 . Memoirs of the History, Folk‐lore and Distribution of the Races of the North‐Western Provinces of India Edited by: Beames , John . Vol. II , 232 London
  • Rai , G.K. “ ‘Forced Labour’ ” . 30 op. cit.
  • Shamasatry , R. , ed. 1967 . Kautilya's Arthasastra , 8th edn. Mysore
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 69 – 73 .
  • Bernier , F. 1916 . Travels in the Mogul Empire 1656–68 Edited by: Constable , A. 228 – 29 . London
  • Khan , Ali Muhammad . 1928 . Mirat‐Ahmadi Edited by: Ali , Nawab . Vol. I , 260 Baroda
  • Pelsaert , F. 1925 . Jahangir's India Edited by: Moreland , W.H. and Geyl , Peter . 60 Cambridge
  • Waqai‐Ajmer‐wa‐Ranthambor , 227 Hyderabad : Andhra State Archives .
  • Memoirs , II 341
  • 1867–77 . Ain‐i‐Akbari , Vol. I , 538 485 505 Calcutta : Blochmann .
  • Raychaudhuri , S.P. , Gopal , L. and Subbarayappa , B.V. 1971 . “ ‘Agriculture’ ” . In A Concise History of Science in India Edited by: Bose , D.M. , Sen , S.N. and Subbarayappa , B.V. 353 New Delhi
  • Jain , P.C. Labourin Ancient India 35 – 36 .
  • ‘Botany : Vedic and Post‐Vedic period’ . History of Science , 377 – 78 .
  • Niyogi , Puspa . 1962 . Contributions to the Economic History of Northern India 20 Calcutta
  • Kautilyas . Arthasastra 131 – 32 .
  • Ain , I 304 – 36 .
  • Ain , I 389
  • Ain , I 389
  • Niyogi , Puspa . Contributions 21
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 35
  • 1965 . The Kautilya Arthasastra, part III 174 Bombay
  • Niyogi . Contributions 69
  • Sircar . Landlordism and Tenancy 4
  • Niyogi , P. Contributions 1
  • Mazumdar , B.P. 1960 . The Socio‐Economic History of Northern India (1030–1194 A.D.) 175 Calcutta
  • Sircar , D.C. 1966 . Indian Epigraphical Glossary Delhi
  • Raychaudhuri , ed. 1964 . Agriculturein Ancient India 81 New Delhi
  • Majumdar , G.P. and Banerji , S.C. , eds. 1960 . Anhasastra the Krsi‐Parasara Calcutta
  • Sarngadhara . 1936 . Upavana‐Vinoda Edited by: Majumdar , G.P. Calcutta
  • Raychaudhuri , S.P. 1966 . ‘Land Classification in Ancient India’ . Indian Journal of the History of Science , I ( 2 ) Nov. : 107
  • Ghosh , A.K. and Sen , S.N. ‘Botany: Vedic and Post‐Vedic Period’ . History of Science , 379
  • Majumdar , G.P. ‘Introduction’ . Krsi‐Parasara , vi
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Cuture 256 – 62 .
  • Tennant , William . 1804 . Indian Recreations; consisting chiefly of strictures on the Domestic and Rural Economy of the Mahomedans and Hindoos Vol. II , 16 Edinburgh
  • Ain , I 297
  • Habib , Man . Agrarian System 23
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 53 – 54 . 55 – 56 . 116
  • 1971 . ‘Potentialities of Capitalistic Development in the Economy of Mughal India’ . Enquiry , III ( 3 ) Winter : 4 new series
  • ‘Botany: Vedic and Post‐Vedic Period’ . History of Science , 377 132
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Culture 257
  • Lai , B.B. 1970–71 . ‘Perhaps the Earliest Ploughed Field So Far Excavated Anywhere in the World’ . Purattatva , : 1 – 3 .
  • Raychaudhuri , S.P. ‘Agriculture’ . History of Science , 352
  • Sharma , R.S. Light & c 55 – 56 .
  • Sharma , R.S. Light etc 57
  • Gupta , Jaya Datta and Saraswati , B.N. 1961 . “ ‘Ploughs and Husking Implements’ ” . In Peasant L ife in India , Memoir No.8 25 – 29 . Calcutta : Anthropological Survey of India .
  • Mukherji , N.G. 1915 . Handbook of Indian Agriculture 93 99 Calcutta
  • Elliot . Memoirs , II 340 – 41 .
  • Royal Commission on Agriculture in India . 1928 . Report 110 – 12 . London
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 24
  • Elliot . Memoirs 340
  • Raychaudhuri , S.P. ‘Agriculture’ . History of Science , 352
  • Chanana , D.R. 1963 . ‘The Spread of Agriculture in the Ganges Valley’ . Contributions to Indian Economic History , : 115
  • Raychaudhuri , S.P. ‘Agriculture’ . History of Science , 360 150
  • Sharma , R.S. Light etc 57 60 – 61 .
  • Elliot . Memoirs , II 341 – 42 .
  • Grierson . 1926 . Bihar Peasant Life. , 2nd edn. 172 Patna
  • Chaudhuri , A.K. 1971 . Early Medieval Village in Northern‐Eastern India (A.D. 600–1200) 153 – 54 . Calcutta
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 26
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Culture 257
  • Raychaudhuri , S.P. “ ‘Agriculture’ ” . 353 – 54 . 131 op. cit.
  • Habib , Irfan . 1969 . ‘Presidential Address’ . Proceedings of Indian History Congress, 31st Session . 1969 , Varanasi. pp. 149 – 55 .
  • Ain , I 538
  • Barani , Zia‐ud‐din . 1862 . Tarikh‐i‐Firuz Shahi Edited by: Khan , Saiyad Ahmad . 367 – 71 . Calcutta
  • Afif , Shams‐i‐Siraj . 1888–91 . Tarikh‐i‐Firuz Shahi , Edited by: Wilayat , M. 127 Calcutta : Hussain .
  • Bhandari , Sujan Rai . 1918 . Khulasat‐ul‐Tawarikh Edited by: Hasan , Zafar . 29 – 30 . 36 – 37 . Delhi
  • Sharma , R.S. Light etc 62
  • Yadava , B.N.S. “ ‘Thus the Sudra peasants cannot be equated with the unfree serf of Medieval Europe’ ” . In Land System and Feudalism Edited by: Sircar , D.C. 94
  • Barani , Zia‐ud‐din . Tarikh‐i‐Firuz Shahi 313 – 14 .
  • Habib , Irfan . 1978 . ‘Economic History of the Delhi Sultanate — An Essay in Interpretation’ . Indian Historical Review , IV ( 2 ) Jan. : 292 – 94 . 297
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 56 118 – 24 .
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 115 – 16 . 118
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 149 – 50 .
  • Khan , Ali Muhammad . Mirat‐i‐Ahmadi 268 – 72 .
  • Shariat . Agrarian System 113
  • 1978 . ‘Aurangzeb's Farman on Land Tax — An analysis in the Light of the Fatawa‐i‐Alamgiri’ . Islamic Culture , 52 ( 2 ) April : 117 – 26 .
  • 1961 . ‘The Position of the Desai in the Pargana Administration of Subah Gujarat under the Mughals’ . Proceedings of Indian History Congress. twenty‐fourth session . 1961 , Delhi. pp. 152
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 120
  • Sircar , D.C. Land System and Feudalism 12
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 36 149
  • Grover , B.R. 1965 . ‘Nature of Dehat‐i‐Taalluqa (Zamindari villages) and the evolution of the Taaluqdari System During the Mughal Age’ . I.E.S.H.R. , II ( 2 and 3 ) April and July : 261
  • Sharma , R.S. “ ‘Indian Feudalism Retouched’ ” . 329
  • Kosambi , D.D. An Introduction 323
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 115
  • Hasan , S. Nurul . Thoughts 3
  • 1963 . ‘Nature of Land‐Rights in Mughal India’ . I.E.S.H.R. , I ( 1 ) : 2 – 5 .
  • 1970 . Land Revenue Administration under the Mughals 11 16 Bombay
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 61 – 63 .
  • Habib , Irfan . 1976 . “ ‘Jatts of Punjab and Sind’ ” . In Essays in Honour of Dr Ganda Singh Edited by: Singh , Harbans and Barrier , N.G. 92 – 103 . Patiala
  • Ain , I 199
  • Badauni , Abdul Qudir . Muntakhab‐ut‐Tawarikh , Vol. II , 189 Bib. Ind. .
  • Grover , B.R. “ ‘Dehat‐i‐Taalluqa’ ” . 262
  • Shakeb , Ziauddin Ahmed , ed. 1977 . “ ‘Yad‐dasht‐i‐izafa‐i‐dehat’ ” . In Mughal Archives Vol. I , 295 Hyderabad memorandum regarding newly settled villages) of Shah Jahan's time in
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 121 – 22 .
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 75
  • Sharma , R.S. Light etc 83
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society andCulture 171
  • Hasan , S. Nurul . Thoughts 18
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Culture 297 – 98 .
  • Niyogi , Puspa . Contributions 180
  • Kosambi , D.D. An Introduction etc 365
  • Sircar , D.C. Land System and Feudalism 21
  • Sircar . Landlordism and Tenancy 66 – 79 .
  • Yadava . Society and Culture 288 – 301 .
  • Habib , Irfan . “ ‘Potantialities etc’ ” . 11 – 12 . 27
  • Sharma , R.S. Light etc 56 58
  • Niyogi , P. Contributions 23 – 24 .
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Culture 258
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 257
  • Sarkar , Jadu Nath , ed. 1972 . Nuskha‐i‐Dilkusha 193 – 94 . Bombay
  • Yadava , B.N.S. 1976 . ‘Problem of Interaction between Socio‐economic Classes in the Early Medieval Complex’ . Indian Historical Review , III ( 1 ) July : 55
  • Sharma , R.S. Indian Feudalism 268
  • Habib , Irfan . Agrarian System 330 – 51 .
  • Yadava , B.N.S. Society and Culture 171
  • 1969 . ‘Problems of Marxist Historical Analysis’ . Enquiry , VIII ( 2 ) : 52 – 67 . Monsoon
  • 1976 . ‘The Analysis of Pre‐Colonial Social Formations in Asia in the Writings of Karl Marx’ . Indian Historical Review , 11 ( 2 ) Jan. : 365 – 88 .
  • Nicolaus , Martin , ed. 1973 . Grundrisse 472 – 73 . London
  • 1970 . A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy 33 Moscow
  • ‘primitive communal property... is still in existence in India'); . Capital , I 357 – 358 .
  • Centre for Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi. An earlier version of this paper was first read as the Presidential Address, to the Medieval India Section, Indian History Congress, Fortieth Session, at Waltair, in December 1979. It was later discussed at three seminars respectively organised by the School of Social Sciences, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi; Department of History, Erasmus University, Rotterdam; and Society for the Study of Feudalism, Sorbonne, Paris. I was fortunate enough to receive written and oral comments from Maurice Aymard, Guy Bois, Barun De, Irfan Habib, R.H. Hilton, Iqtidar Alam Khan, Frank Perlin, Burton Stein and immannuel Wallerstein; it isa privilege to acknowledge my debt of gratitude to them all.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.